-i ,f'(;.. !i-.. - atujournals.atu.ac.ir/article_3159_76e9671f0b327cfbce... · 4 ~..".....

17
I, ~ IP1..cWi11LD1J.duD9,P. ~ (: .c .. ~ r. " .c- t c.. '<- S:- " v' ? ~. ~ .1: Ii- ~ , ~ \ ( ' (: r ' .c v, ~ oF \. " '~, ~, t '<- L " c... ~ ~ 'C " -: ~ t f (;, , ,,'\ I> i.. t.. t ~ II ,;-' > t v [. L t ~ v ,. (;, '{' -: ~ t 't. ~ : ~ C' , .~ t r~ " v!A t 1: ~ l '<- II " ;.... ::.. f- ~'l ,~ ~ fr' 'I, e., v I> . v -< I I f -p ~ ,i, ~ Vi. ~ ~ "- Vi. k v-~I- C LX \1, ~ C- t t ,'~' ~ c:.:., r c' ~ I" c" <., l- e 1 , r - t. 1- ~: I c;~. ,~ t ~ ~~t--- ~. <iA~ ~ 1 , 1- 0 [; C. & ' ~ b .t ~ t. <t- ~ C 'S t, J' .~. ~ 1',. ~ C' I- (I) .- ~ -t V\\ ) C; .., "<> . Ir:' (I Ii- > ~ I ~, t C, .J> ~: , -, - 1 , , r " c ,c t. " I- I- I~ ,. :t ~ L t <iA <;; c. c ~. [,: ~ b ~~ c"': ~ (.. c' 'f <p 1:" : (.. 'E (> [,. ~' . e --<<;;- ,; [ ' f ~ h ~. 1-' b > .e ;"L e , (.. -, t (I)' ~ 1 Y- ~ 1 l 'f c. f . --< r I C. "Ii- ~ ~ ~ : l ' I ,el t -:- ,~ E C' l- I:" 1-"'" ~ f" ~: *, . 1: ".. .t () '(01 (0 <rt;. - (,. 1Sf - \ (,.. (,. :. - -.. !i l (: L (0 (;.. ,f' IE k . . -I (, b <t <., - Archive of SID www.SID.ir

Upload: others

Post on 14-Apr-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: -I ,f'(;.. !i-.. - ATUjournals.atu.ac.ir/article_3159_76e9671f0b327cfbce... · 4 ~..".. ~~ ~ ~]!!) ~ ~ ~ ~

I,~

IP1.

.cW

i11L

D1J

.duD

9,P

.

~ (: .c..

~r.

".c

-

tc.

.'<

-S

:-"

v'

?~

.~

.1:

Ii-~

,~

\('

(:r

'.c

v,~

oF\.

"'~

,~

,t

'<-

L"

c...

~~

'C"

-:~

tf

(;,

,,,'

\I>

i..t..

t~

II,;-

'

>t

v[.

Lt

~v

,.(;

,

'{'-:

~t

't.~

:~

C'

,

.~t

r~

"v!

A

t1:

~l

'<-

II"

;....

::..

f-~

'l,~

~fr

''I,

e.,

vI>

.v

-<I

If

-p~

,i,

~V

i.~

~"-

Vi.

kv-

~I-

CLX

\1,

~C

-t

t,'~

'~

c:.:.

,r

c'~

I"c"

<.,

l-e

1,r

-t.

1-~

:I

c;~

.,~

t~

~~

t---

~.

<iA

~~

1,1-

0[;

C.

&'

~b

.t~

t.<

t-~

C'S

t,J'

.~.

~1'

,.~

C'

I-(I

).-

~-t

V\\

)C

;..,

"<>

.Ir

:'

(IIi-

>~

I~

,t

C,

.J>

~:

,-,

-

1

,, r

"c

,ct.

"I-

I-I~

,.:t

~L

t<

iA<

;;c.

c~

.[,:

~b

~~

c"':

~(.

.c'

'f<

p1:

":

(..

'E(>

[,.~

'.

e--

<<

;;-,;

['f

~h

~.

1-'

b>

.e;"

L e,(.

.-,

t(I

)'~ 1Y

-~

1

l'fc.

f.

--<

rI

C.

"Ii-

~~

~:

l'

I,e

lt

-:-

,~E

C'

l-I:

"1-

"'"

~

f" ~:

*, .

1: "..

.t()

'(01

(0 <rt;

.-

(,.

1Sf

- \(,

..(,

.

:.-

-.. !i l

(:L

(0(;

.. ,f'

IEk

.. -I (,

b<

t<

., -

Arc

hive

of S

ID

ww

w.S

ID.ir

Page 2: -I ,f'(;.. !i-.. - ATUjournals.atu.ac.ir/article_3159_76e9671f0b327cfbce... · 4 ~..".. ~~ ~ ~]!!) ~ ~ ~ ~

..

...I;!I ~ <l: ~Lu, (\ )J;.J~ ->:,wl:JL,..:AIJ->:ijl >:.fi l.:

0Lj -JJ J ~ ~fi ~..I;!J\':'";l:JL, >:.fi <l:.b.J7y>w~ ,JL:...~ -JJ L,1

J;.J-J <l:~ J;.J-J 0:1 <D,~b~ J-JJ1->:-J~ 0:1 ~JJ~I J;.j) ->:wl:JL, J~I

)~ ";l:JL ~ J >:.fi l;>~j-J~ (51->: I-J~I-JJ J)J->: -JJ (5~ wI~ ~

.J j L u-"

0I J;.jy>I ~~ J ~ 0:':,1 ~JU:i I-JJ \.:;~bJfi ~ ..:JJJ ~

0-:1J~I ~ -JJ ...u,J)~ ~\.:; J-Jy>I-J01 ..;l:JL,)~ ~ ~~J 'J~.)J

J~ J JjL ~1~ I.)L5"'""->:~ (5~ .b.;. ,..Glyu-"L>'"":y.)~\j ~ <l:J;.J.)

oJjL )y>A I.)<J7~ (5~~ I .)J ";l:JL, (5~J') hJ ~J

J ~J ~~ (51->:I.)Soj ,I~I 0w :,I ~JJ~1 J;.j) ->:wl:JL, 0YLs

J ~ :,I (5~~ ~.)J '-:-'"-"~ (51~~ \.:;...:AL ~I~ ..:JJJ 4..jlb~ wL,\J]1

t~ 0-:1 ..:AIJ~ Soj .)J <tJL '\ w\.:.:~ ~ 0=1->:L:.:.JJfi jL.;..:;1';;l:JL, >:.fi

(5~l:L> J ";l:JL >:.~ ~ ..>:-:IJ:; l..:I <D ~I~~ J'-7-:1JIj 0=1 .wl:JL,

..GI-y-:>.";l:JL, J;.J.) 0:1 jL.;..:;1<D..G1~J.J7~lS: ~jl..G10 I <l: ';;l:JL, wW;..:; ~..G)Jjl;>

~JjL ~J')J 1->: I.) ..:JJJ ~I -..91..u,1:,1(51~~ ~

OJj,)9\u-tj),J7 ~~l.o JJ ~ '7 ~ti4 ~~lS ~j\J-O

OJj)S1~jJI J7 ~l:JlA (,)~

~ l;><L...:\.i..,.)J ~JJ~I J;.j) ->: wl:JL, ~ j.)l;> (5u.~j.o :,I ~

~j...:J 0-:' J.J-7-J o~ 1(5~ J.>-?-J .J;. J~ J -..9~ ->: wl:JL, (5khy> ~ .:J;

i~

]n!!)

V'f

c ~ (.$lA':!l5'01~~ I) 01 J J.:.:...((.$)1...1-:.';>':!L( J.:.jIYif ~I) y,L..: 'r.Y-J} r, uL,JL.~)~-,

'~~}if ~y-:"'-' uL,JL.jl j-:.}(.$'r,~) ~J <f.1.J:,~,~ 01..;L,JL.~L jI J J.::.J.r'-:iJ~

Archive of SID

www.SID.ir

Page 3: -I ,f'(;.. !i-.. - ATUjournals.atu.ac.ir/article_3159_76e9671f0b327cfbce... · 4 ~..".. ~~ ~ ~]!!) ~ ~ ~ ~

6lP

I..=

w;I

eu>l

..i&

mg

.k

Cl..

.

1

.(C

1C

'-t

G\

c,~.

(,r

c-G

\.L

"t,

C.

L..

"t,

.t

-C

:t.r-

(:-

.'E

i:"'

'.(i

\'E

\I<

yr

L.

rL

.b

'."

[.(:

.

r'1,.

G\'

b~

','~

~~'

~~;

v.l'

'~t

rc

,f;'"

t.~

[t..

(,.t

.C

IL

.'I,

r:b.

(,!:

:..'tr

.l~

~~\

~oE

.r-

~.'E

"~

t.1

~.

r;r.

c.L

("e,

'L

.~"

c;b

(F>

t,.(,

\t.

1::.

<r

'LG

\t.

~'-I

,c.

~~

,,-'I,

C:

lA'E

.~.L

b(.

&("

t;--

~.

G\

C,

~L

.I,

v-~

}b

'I,~

'E~

~..~

~:

~v:

't~

fi:"

'~.

fA'c

.S.

("-<

ib

.~'

cc,

'-c.

~r:

:.L

c,~

~.-:

~,L

.' E

~1-

,L

.-

L.

I>'"

'CI-

.L't

.~

~G

\r'

Cb

.t~

CI

~r.

(;t,.

.I,

("G

\,:

~CI

~[.

;'( E'

t'[

:'c-

:(,

't

-.:.

(,,'

,rc:

tA,f

',.C

("L

.~

~-

)~

to

['(,

to

~-,

'.~'

.b

-;;

.~

f,.

I,L

..

t.."[

.L

.L

."'

.~!

~~

:~i:"

'~'

..t.

~f;

-ft

.b-

r~

e,'.

{'i.

,("

~~.

xi:"

'[~

CI

~~

.tA

.t,("

LL

t.n

'EV

t,:~

~.~

.tA

<;.

1~

c-<

1-t

\~

~\C

.(i

\1.

bc.

("}

,.r

-t

~.

C'-

C.~

c;~

t..c

~('

-("

G\

-~

.'~

t"1,

("t

;-c-

~"

<t-

,r'-f

..("

c.~

G\

.L~.

(",.

'to,

r;;r

.t

T:(

c,.

.LI

[c.

1)f'

~r;

;7"

(;~

~("

~.'t,

l...

C2.

.'

G:

~1

1/\

c;&

l',f

~f~

.t';

,r,r

cL

.~

<e

'~

['(>

.rc

b.'L

~~

(,to

'ti\

c~.

~.~

("r.

c;'

~L

.<

.C

I("

E\0

.r;

;7"t

.L

cl,

,-

"[..

".~

c("

("f

("~

r;;7

I>t"

.,'L

.tC

.(,

.~.

~t

b1:

-..r

.-.

t~'.

~.(i

\~

'i..

L.

("-!

E~

t,ID

.L

.C

f,.

(.

s.y~

fAll,

.oE

.Lt'~

t'.

1','b

~.("

,.f

.~.

<e'

..1

0~-

~,<

;.("

,.~.

,1;"

\\~

~,b

c-.~

.Ec.

\.:~.

-t

r;;r

C.

C.[

~.L

to.~

.vt-

Ii\

c.S:

..,c

('it

C"

t"c'

L.

\0.

r;;7

(.1/

\\',-

Cf

tAE.

'.(,

~("

L.'

Cc.

G\

r.("

."[.

.L

C.

oEr.

tAc'

:c

',.-

~E

;.~.

t<

;.cr

\-!

,f~

\;tA

r;;r

~,-I

b''L

~"t

.b

K~:

'I:-

.J;

b,~

~,.t'

-G

\~'

li\~

~~

~~

["fr

:€

t:~

E1,

~\C

f,.

'~:

~I~.

1..

Lr.

.t("

c.1

(e(,

'E,

c;-

("(;

t,..

:,~r;

;7C

!.-

t..~

t,.f'

f['

!v-;

'.

(:.

'E. f

~\~

ti\.,

€L

.~I

("L

.("

.v'

-'I;

(,,-

b~

(1\

r;;7

.-:.,

tA~~

..~

~.<

e.f

Arc

hive

of S

ID

ww

w.S

ID.ir

Page 4: -I ,f'(;.. !i-.. - ATUjournals.atu.ac.ir/article_3159_76e9671f0b327cfbce... · 4 ~..".. ~~ ~ ~]!!) ~ ~ ~ ~

$\£

~'.~

t£.

~''f:

it

T't

~~'

.~~.

,t'-

'"G

.}<

.,~

<".

c-:

.~:r

;.r

.eC

~I~.

r~

re:

° tf

1

~\[.

:~

-Ik

r<

.,f.

"I.

-.;[

-r:

~

1:""

".,,'

.I.

-~

C,

1:.

-c~!

C«>

G\

1'"

tr.

~~"

.LG

:c'

:~

ft

t~-

<;-

tl.-.

5-c-

t~'

:,0

:-(,

..<

7\<

.,I,

c~.

.f

L.

b(;

;"'-

G.,

J:"

i-«>

I.-

t-:

~.

!,.

<.,

<r'

(,.

,I;

.L:

~1

L.

,"(;

II-

,.~

~.L

t~

l\-

~.

t~~

.e,

,rc

n~c

1

~'r""

"e E'

C

{''-

'::..

~<

.,'I.

E-

I.-

~J;

::1/

\.

'1

'~\~

',r

Tt.

's;-

r\'1

.e,

,:,:~

:.~

G\

rt

..:-

c.i:'

r.f-

11

.,E

-~

.r.

.tC

'~

C-

<;.

~.t'

'"v\

~'it

t-

j;.

~-:-

~~

I.-

,'

~,,'

t.,'

c-. J'

-b

~(.

.<

;,-(,

.."c

.~

.(;

;L

.1/

\\

fc.

,1

~-

-;L

r.r.

:b<

.,-

,,-

'"~'

o",

,-,.

it;L

C.

.(.

.".

y-

.-

I.-

c-.

r,

,'f

'h:f

~"t;

~.~

~it.

1~

t<

.1,.

t.f

",.

'tC

f'~(;

;G

\c

rc.

c.I.

-~,

..'

c~

~t:

<;,:

\-tp

,b,f

Ii.

~,<

..:-:

-I~\

(;;

i..t

tI.

-<

7\-

'1;,

~

~.L

<.

,e-

't.S;

-b~

c1/

\\

ft

,0:-

,\0

."(;

'-,

~,1/

\\(:

\,<

\'-

G\

'-Ir;

;I~

~..

<E

!..

~~

(;j

~~

.~

C(.

.('!

;,

G\

c-'2

~It,.

~,c;

'I.b

rC

.cr.

:<

...f\

c-'

n!;

v.e

-<

.,v

c-l.-

e:~:

f.ic

e~.

rI.

-c,

~c'

~1,

:~

c.f:

~~

r-'

fLc.

,c-

':1-:

-,,'

'y.

e,'E

I.-

I.-

bl'

~c-

I.-

~c.

b~\

I:""

"':1

.\

""\

1"r,

S;-,

...c'

,e,

1

c'"

"~

~

1

(,..

-<

.,~

r:e:

.'L

b1;

,.-,

b't.

,'V,I

.l

.c1:

~,~.

[.~.

('t.

~\f

,:e,

~~,

~,.

cL

t..,e

-<

tA\

~I:

"""<

7\E

"~'t,

'r..

.\:.

.v.

~,e-

e,s;

-Ii

~t

5-c

~<

;.~

\.(

~:{

f~

~t

e:c.

Ii.

f<

.,L

.I.

-Ii

-.'E

:(,

.;;-

f\0

.f

':1.l:

\\.~

t

r~\

c[,

~«>

~.tp

1

,-.L

f-~.

~.'v

.':1

."

'f'C

.t.

,1.

-'e,

~to

.[

be,

[,.

-I)

Co'

::,C c

\ff\

\'(:

~f\\

j.,~

c.~.

t,.1-

I.-

.e-

!:I

.G

\' E

(I,

~<

i"

1,.

f»0

<.,

<.,

-,-

c.C

L.

r.C

C~

~ri

.'-

0.

f.1

:~.

",

,.:-C

~,.

cr

~''L

~C

,r,

L1

I:""

"c.-

\-c:

l.C

tIi

.'b

r;:

f.f-

1.:-

c.t

~~

L.

,0:-

Il'

~I

Y,

I.-

tp'E

LC

'V

~'L

.f

'"-(

,t'\.

-'~

~.[I

's;

-l"

'I:.

Ii-.

~,v\

~\5-

c

~lS

"Lo:

..laI

G.D

li.W

..m9~

\

Arc

hive

of S

ID

ww

w.S

ID.ir

Page 5: -I ,f'(;.. !i-.. - ATUjournals.atu.ac.ir/article_3159_76e9671f0b327cfbce... · 4 ~..".. ~~ ~ ~]!!) ~ ~ ~ ~

,

~WG .)~I ~y d.$ ..GI/>.)fij~1 (5-.>:-:L.1:i,~L.." ~ ~ -.>.)'ulS:~J~.

-.>yLc uloj ~1 -.>.)...\..t.)t..>"~~ 1-.>-.>~ ~l:Jlo ~1~ J .)~t..>" ~G:; i"~ J

~ -.>.) '-.>d..:J-'-""-" ->=-:>I-L; J />.)fi u=WAI-.> '-.>~ uTt:;~t..>" ~ ~l:Jlo

ul.J.=.o~~ l: t:;.)~t..>" -.>~ ~~ l: J ~Lo:,J~I ~WG ~I.)I (5~~

->=-:>I-L;~I ...GI.)~ .;L=> (Y J~ l: J ...J~ 1-.>')~ u T'/>.)J~I utj) >! ul:Jlo

'-:><tl:t:L ~ -.>.)j~ />.)J~I utj) >! ul:Jlo ~yl] d..:~ d.$ ..\..t.)t..>"uw.:,

.u b.)l..Gu-.>~ t..>"L.~1~WG

~~ J ...gu...oli.S~1 ~ vb.;l.~

~ ~ d.$).J..:~ l: J (5~.)I.) ~J ~lo u~. ~.:.~. .)~ ~ d.$~loj

uT~y d..:d.$ ~ j~1 ~lol~1 ,~.).? u-ob (51<tJ~ (5~1 J~ ~

~J! />Y:-J ~ l: J ul:Jlo u:;..;..1..G10=~ d..:l: J >:.~ ~ -.>.).).? J$y d..:

'(~l:/>.).J7 u TJ~ ~ d.$~.)~ -.>.))~Lo:,u~L />.)J~1utj) >! ul:Jlo

.~.)t..>" ut)fi <t.b.J7Y'u~ "-71-.>J.<..c.~I-.>~ ~l:Ju uloLL

~.)IJJ7 u~1.4 vb~~ ~~

~-.>>-'"" />.)1.)~ ul:JLc u.Sl:-.>.)~ -.>.),:-,j~ (5l41~.)1.)I (5~~ (51J!

J.J-'-""J (51~ .L.ly~ .))y <G~~I ,.)~ u~1 d.$~I~ -.>.)~ J />~

,1.4..:' ulo-A .)I />.)Jj..J1 utj) ~ ul:Jlo Uyl] ,~l: .J?:.I>! ~ .l.<>T.).) >! d~lo

<~

J~

]n~

VV

~ ~I <G.:J1.u b.)fi ...J~ />.)1.)>! ul:Jlo u,;.1.)->;.)1 I.)ulo~ J l..t')~ ~

u,;.L..~ -.>.)ulo~ J l4I,)~~1.)1d.$~IS:~J~ .)fik >!~ ~b ..Glyu-"

.~ l: .c;..;.1.),~t..>" />.)\£ ,1u l:Jlo J~ (5l41')~

-"

Archive of SID

www.SID.ir

Page 6: -I ,f'(;.. !i-.. - ATUjournals.atu.ac.ir/article_3159_76e9671f0b327cfbce... · 4 ~..".. ~~ ~ ~]!!) ~ ~ ~ ~

1

t~

Ii,

~r

tt.

t.:

t.1>

Ii,

(.,

~(;

j~

S'v

l~,

.'r/

\\,

'"(.

-C

-1;

.t..

~

"'f

r~

.t''Ii

\..r

,tr~~

'E<

e~.

~.Ii

.\

c-

["L

'C

~{/

\'b

~-

(.,

. f.

0'"

1?'.,

,,v

1

-t

r'~

'::-

\..V

'.(-

rv

1[.

.c.

1.(.

\.-

"v(.

;-r,

.-

'/\\

'f,.

'.,;;

l"W

',:..

.~

rC

.L

f(,

..1

."'

"1.

'"'G

\f'

",.

1\.~

,,-:-

(,~

1.'\"

t'"

.~.

J;L

<Po

fi:"

1v

.~C

vr.

-.C

o(r

f.l

.1;

b..

'":

",'

.~r;

;f

f--

'to,

'.r.

f;~

.-

(,,(

.G

r't,

Ii\"

~<

,.G

\-

CG

:[

t(1

.t

,~,.

\c

~r

If;

:t~

.r<

-

'"v

vi7

,I:-

v-,;

I;(

-::t

y/\

(.,

<-

1.

t.~

~;f

=-

:;;'t

\\c

-~

~~~

~o~

;.E'

t1.

.c'

T-L

",.

l/';.

,f-t

tf

~()

'C-

1/\

;:,I

:-\c

-f:

,.'~

:'.,

v..:

.'j

1/\

t.:-

,.,["

(.<

-~

.,~

J'\. ,

'.y.

[(-

,1:..

.1:

-.G

,~.

~~

-.r

~(

.0')A

,L

-(

I:-

\".'

(,'f

-L1:

-.;-

~1

-,l-

~{>

:.~

(,'v

,-..:

(1,

i.,,r

:-'I.

.~.

"\'Ii

\:,, tV

Q,

<-

f>t

.rC

cb

'",f

;,~;

.,':

y.G

,f

'C'

~G

..

':\'

~.

f1;

.:-<

-J.

.r.

,,:...

,r:-

\;-'.,

.',.P

t.I\

~.c.

(.,

~<

-~.

£,II

'E

l.(

,'.~

~(

:-~.

'~

t;

c:.

r.:

s.C r

~.l'

~' 1

(.,

'",C

-.~

~I:

.\"

,,,'y

,

t1

~1I

:f~

!;'"

G,

.'t,

G,

f""

..'.

'L.

~t.

~'.

'~

f\'G

.r

'tL

~."

.1,

~(I

.V

\\,

r.,f

t'\"

'{.

G\

{:-

<-

(,

~,~

.l-

,-Q

~~,

:;t

t1-

rs.

;.f

£}-

~:'E

1..

~~

\.,~

c.t

\;t-

,'\"

,c-

.r1:

-.f

f--

<f"

~,1,

I'-t;;

ib

~

{,

~r.

1/\\

c,'

rC

l~"

(,~.

c.".

L~b

I~

,r.'

.':",

;-L

'""'

Ir,\

V~

<-

<-

.-I

..

t,

(.t,

c.r

-Lr.

\c-

,.',,

-t;.

1,(.

,C

rC

~...

c::-

,,i.

'.r;

;~'

v;i.

",-

f--

~<

eL

.-

I',f

,,:-

\../\

\.t'"

-:-

[:'

Vr,

~~

.-I

'!~

~t

c,~

J.,r

:-\-

{'y

.tt

I\:t,

!ir

<f,

.~

~..

~j(.

,~(.

,t-,

'"r

-L{:

,v

'cr-

\1\

C.

}.-.

t.(.

,-<

vv

.~~

:'1/

\)

'~v

-.(,

,\T

:t

~c

G\

:LC

i"~

'E\:,

)\:,.

-C

.f

CL

'"~,

,\[

'1"'

,'~

<- t

(-:-

Cb

~1,

1,b

G.

t-,

.~£

V.~

}>-

[...1

;' f

"C

~t"

,.\.

"-,I

:"'

7",

.V

\\'

C/';

f--

rt

,.C

~'-L

"1;

!~"

~~.

(..

cf

yt

'1l

t"f

v,.

Ie1

~!,

r(.

Ec

(;j

-t

~f

'~,

1/\

i:r:-

~",

.G

,,r

's.

r:.

c.' E'

' {'b

<-

P\t.

c.~:

s::,

i.::-

.~-L

;:~

~'"

r,'

(.~

.-..

c.(.

.'t.

(.,

r-,

\1/

\v

\c-

~~

-,-

~b

't.[

.-r

G-"

-v'

,..

~l

!"I

.t'I

-.

b~L

c..

t[

4'"

Co

-0(

.,("

t--

'(.

,'1

;,..

~.r

~lp

L-i

D1tl

.D1.

.uW

D9.

H

Arc

hive

of S

ID

ww

w.S

ID.ir

Page 7: -I ,f'(;.. !i-.. - ATUjournals.atu.ac.ir/article_3159_76e9671f0b327cfbce... · 4 ~..".. ~~ ~ ~]!!) ~ ~ ~ ~

~lp

L.:

.:i:

D1

G.D

l.lili

JDg.

H

~:t.

l't

lR

~~

Ii-.

~~.

.~,~

.b

[~~

~~.

f".

-(.

.[.

(c

\tli\

c'~

r}..

,-~

-"C

t~

-lI

\'t.

&.

c:.r

:(.

.c.

.xG

)t:"

5-c

~'I,

ct.

""n

~.c

~t.

-,~

&"

.rT

li\r.

r.r

(.~

li\r

~.~

.-:

.R

ft(.

..~.

.:1-

~:-

1'r

~...~

!j.

Cf.

.[:

.. f

l.~5-

c.&

-(I

(.f:

'I,t.

-.:

~~.

'I,~"

'.(.

~~

.'E

EL

.("

-.t.

I.-

C 1-c.

<p

'I,~I.

-'E

C.

t.b

r,.

""(,

..(,

...r.

-,(,

,''-

c.,-

I.""

~.l

"".~

""~

b-,

[.\,

~.'-

""b

C.

G\

~~

c;r

.(;

}'i

-C

.~

'v-.

,~.

G\

(I

},

~.c.

.~,-

bbI~

~~G

\e.

Ii-.

r'~

<\

t,.~

'E,'V

[i\i

&G

\~

.'"

G\

~'.:

.'.

C,

"r

I.

,cfr

~,-

cI-

E.,

ci

"<

'i:'~

I.-

b.r

I.-

.'V

\&

(..

[,.

i{;

0<.,.

"-c.

.~'

C'

Cc.

C.

}.-

r..

.L

Ec-

.r"1

.-0

E.

li\G

eL-

'lA,

-<

t>-

CIL

-t.

c..

'r-.1

.c.

li\,

'I,~

~[.

.I.

-C

c~.

C2.

G\

C2.

~.

r't

c..

(,-,

(;-.

.C

f'i

5-c

<r,.

.r<

t>'"

'e[,

l.~

~1

'EC

2.t,.

(I.r

:c'

:t,

e(,

~L

C~'

F>'

Ec;

''-

.c-

-~'

b~.

~c

c.~

t.'E

G)

I.-

~,t

~'C

bC

.<

\,~

L.

0~

l~'

'ec-

c--

b.,-

,-<

v.,

":,'

c;c.

~.1

;'1

:.L

.b

-'1:..

.1>

-b

&"I

.-,

Ii.

~t

~'f

~~.

[;c

t(.

.~

f~~,

'~

'I,f

~~

'r.

Cf

~"

'.:.

t-'-

t!.'=

'L.

V.

.r:

~

'c

t:L

. f(,

..t

~.

r.

-~

r-

f:c

.L

li\lI

\t>

I.-

1-

1

,.

-:\

-'-Ii

-..

-.:

\t..1

..r

:-\.

::l.

§-' ~t:

I.-

c..

~c-

I.-

c-[

E()

lf

(,~

5-c

.c.

'-L

.[

1>C

-G

\"~

b,.

t/>

-

...:,

'1.;.

'.:.

C'

c.""

:..(.

.~

I.-

[.~"

.,

I.-

(.V

\

0't~

~.c

~.E

EC

J:-

~~

~'.

;r-

:'~

~.(

'G

\'1

0 [.~"

~12

,L

.r.

r-I.

-:'t

~~

(,..

fl'

li\-

t"c;

~10

.~

r-L

.,.,.

bV

I.-

C'b

'~

\I)

.r~-

~..c

-~

\t\::

..

cr

~.:

(.~.

[li\

~-;

.£;

~c:

~,~

~~

Cf,

.~

.r:

5-c

f:~

~'E

5-c

~~~

.5-

cc.

G\~

);t

,Cc'

~(.

I.-

C.

1.c.

(..I:

~b

(.1

li\-

(t:

cC

.L

;:-,C

10.

~L fi

~b

t~''E

[j.

rc.(

,~.

'E~

l.r

'E~,

r.:

:r-"

V\

r-~

C.

L-

r-1.

' E-

,--

.t'.

=;.

~C

-L:

["i

-:;

-':'1

..

".b

C;;

-.:.

Lb

C"

.b

'I,-"

c""

.'"G

\.~

C.

(,.b

~~

-L~

b

1

cc.

.bc.

(.::

L.'1

:..1

::~.

<-

'E,r

~.

c-r.

~"

.r1-;

,r~-;

5-c

oEt.

II

I1:

.c;

-.t..

./>

-'c;

IC

-1-1

:--

-bi

'hI

.~

[..G

o.V

\bI.-

h

l-

Arc

hive

of S

ID

ww

w.S

ID.ir

Page 8: -I ,f'(;.. !i-.. - ATUjournals.atu.ac.ir/article_3159_76e9671f0b327cfbce... · 4 ~..".. ~~ ~ ~]!!) ~ ~ ~ ~

-,~

I:-

(,f~

~~

.£"

~(,

(,t

G\

.cf~

\(,

1,.

.r-

b~.

.~

~r-

~t;

t.

~~

(pb

c.(p

f-'

~,...

.C

~.

IAb,

&f

~~

::n

["~.

?~

[.(p

S..r

-1:

c.t

c~~

~t

.f;r"

f.c

;~

(p~:

-IG

\G

\.1

ts.

,c.

c.<

i,.'

~(,

.,G

\r-

~

-~

(;<

,.-(.

CrE

1-;-

r-:-

c;;~

,r:

Cf

T.

.(~

~O

'.L

'E~

.t.tr

~.-I

.it.

~r

~b'

.-

c,r

-t'

C7

..r-

C~

(,(,

-1f

t.~(p

~C

~~

1~.

~~

'Eb f

<:.r

1:t

s:'t.

~."

,~1.

\:c.

C(,

t,:

b~

~c

1:~

-<

,.1>

f,<

;-~

'EC

;;"

c.("

~C

~B

,f;.t

v.~

t.f,

'~'

b~

~

ft.

~t

~.{;

0).

~,i

;Lf

~~f:

~cr

~.t

C;;

0.1:

.:

~C

;;

iE

'~

~,.r

-c.

E:

~[';

(pO

't

~-

r:

}l:.

,,

O'

-IC

.C

C--

-t'"

c-'

~.C

7-

.f;

f;.

::;::

t.~

~::::

t',(,

~f

t.'-

f;.

t.(p

~~..r

>t.

t0"

-1-.

r-""

:L

~[,

..t

~r

r-

(;;.

-1

f--

(,c

~I;

1.,

F>'

~~b

c....

.

~{.

'~r

,('

~c:

~t

~E

',.

'~,

&,~

r.

'

E'

-G

;1-

~~

,t~.

~:~

~f

E-

1.).

~G

\.r-

~.f

~b

~~

L.~

~~

~'~

~s.

,r'

s.,

f~

f,.

c-:-

to'.

['f;

.<

;;,~,

.~'

.~t,

<,.

~~,

'E.t.

'E.~

.tr:

-IIt

~I:

..'..

~~

1-.

'LII

[1

blA

b.~

.

r-l

,c.

(p"

'-I~

1:.

.11"

[..

Ii\

:-~.

~(C

~.f

:;

'E~~

.1

C(,

'l.\

Ff;

;'-

~[

~G

\c-

,t'!.

b.r

rIr

b'.,t

~c

-~

r("

[.r

-(~

.(~

,~c-

tf

~:~

1,.~

1"

1cr

.f'

F~

.(t

c.1

.r:

C(p

1

.r

C~.

~If

=("

V:-

ef.

(,-l

,~

C.

b.

c--

-F

c.(,

~,f;

.c"

"7~

-I'

~C

.',

~f;

.~

,t~~

G\

L.1

)t

s..

{>.

s..

V\

~~

).[

~. t

f'o'

~}.

-~

<e

(:-

~b'

b'L

~..

<.p

L~

C.

(,.~

..!

A,

r:L

r.1

.~,

C.

~1-

C.£

"~"

~~.

t-:

-,~

~C

.ilC

.

tc

(,.,.

{>.

r:~,

<;;

f;C

-Is.

,

~~

<i,

..E~

c-'

h~

't.t"

Co

~,f

;I:

..'..

~.1.

.~

'E("

.

~~.

.,E'

~~

£t

[1:

.).

1:.

~\

Cb

~'.

~

~lS

"blii

la.

Dli.

W.m

gH

Arc

hive

of S

ID

ww

w.S

ID.ir

Page 9: -I ,f'(;.. !i-.. - ATUjournals.atu.ac.ir/article_3159_76e9671f0b327cfbce... · 4 ~..".. ~~ ~ ~]!!) ~ ~ ~ ~

::lp

L-l

D1

a..D

~g.H

CIA

1~

t.C

r'~

~'.

~~'

.G

t'1

.~

C~

<E

'"1A

\~j;;

j-}

.--

f;r.

,EC

t,G

\P

~,

'c.

~t!

!-.t

!-~~

.f,'

<e.

c,'E

~~

1>,L

~.-

xf

.k(,

.-

~t

b!-

.~~

~~,

~\

~'.~

;!.~

V\\

f:b-

:"[

(,1-

~<

E.

:r(,

1,.

.tIA

t,~

~1

.rV

\~

~~

1,.f

'.:f

1,!-

,t.

<r.

-.,~

'~

!;,

~f

J~

1~

1,.

1'r.

c,'

,r~\

fL:'

t~

'-1;

"G

\(.

,1,

.L.

tt.

~f-

n.t

(~,

\,G

\;<

>r.

Cb

C-

Irf

.~,t"

it."

G\

~~

~'~

~f'

F:l'

~.'

IA.~

\-t.

.~c-

.~c,

["~

11\

[..

'I:~

'L(.

,.

'I,~.

~~'

:;:'

1..

<E

~C

t,C

r'f

~G

\ ff"

~~

L'

<:-

(..

C~

(.,

r;L

C~,

(..

C

["c,

~(.

.

-[

'\1.T

.G

\C

!-;

tb

C~

,~~

1;-

(,~

~{;

~\-

".-

t:""

?~

:'i

fL'E

~(.

.IA

\~

fL'~

t~~

(,

f),

'~

~~,

.r

,t~,

.~

1,:~

fe:

E::

t.t

T,:

~-;~

'-

~.t:"

"b

C~

t;jr

r"(,

(..

1't

't.1,

IA(.

. f.k

~t,

f..

~!;

'.

~,r

'~

!tG

\'. E

1:-

1..l-

~.

1:.

t1;

G\

ff;

.C

~~

(.,

C.

,-

(..

-,

.11

\C

(.,

.~~:

f~

~\f:

.1.

'.

~C

t,~

f'F.

~\(.

.r-

1-t~

Ct

cC

Cr

~t.

~C

X-

CG

\t

~f

'~r

fL'E

~r.

t:""~

:~

~'r~

'~

e,~

~,f

IA~

...~

bC

.~,

~.

r.

~~t..

~C

~'(,

'E[

.,r~

fL~

~c.

t~

t(.

.-

c-t

(.l

(..

~JE

b[

r',f

;IA

f;.L

b.c

:h

(..

t.C ["

~1,

.t

c!(.

~b

(,)

).

f;.

i:"~

~.C

I<

E..

C(.

.(.

.(.

.'E

c-b

'e'

IrI)

.

(7f-

'.f

):~'

\-~

.k 1'~

bff

~.f

CI:

r.(~

'()

L[.

.-

(II~

J;.

[..

['<>

-11

\t.

1;-.

f;.

(..

.~-

t..);

.fL

.l-~

E.

""

..r

<e.,t.~

~Ii\~,.t>,f

L'

IA

~).

~.

~;

1.

(A

~'

t.

~~

1.,~,.1,

~.

fI.~

~

l~

Arc

hive

of S

ID

ww

w.S

ID.ir

Page 10: -I ,f'(;.. !i-.. - ATUjournals.atu.ac.ir/article_3159_76e9671f0b327cfbce... · 4 ~..".. ~~ ~ ~]!!) ~ ~ ~ ~

.~j';:;' ~~

~JJ u.u.sJ(.SLb':lls~J,)~ JJ \..~\,'10 ..$JI..\.4~I)

(5Uj\ L..;>L:; ~u-" ~ f".Jj u j 0"4' u~~.J~ ''':''.J~ j).J-C ..)j

u I0"4',Y. d:Jle ~~) ~y 0-:'"-:t..GAj)~ c:~ J~ I..)j~ ,,-:-,jLS:

.~..Ifl ..G..o~.J+:> u-".JA.J-C (5 Lt ~j Ij f".J j

u I (5~LS:lei u I~ ty J~ ~t.s7~(5~~ T..)..I)lb£.. J~ (51'y'

.J~~~ b ~ 0-:' u')~'?' .j~~ <G LS:uT..:..l:Jle) .J~~ '-:-'~ f".Jj

,d:Jle ~)jl) ~.J ~").JTu-"..)j)lb ..:..t~l.)7-":"..)y...o"-:.J~u-" '-:-'.JjI..)uT~

jl~I0-:' 4~li<> ~..)..I ~l:Jle ..:..leli<>'~u-" u-".JA.J-C(5Lt~..Ilj'y' ..:..l:Jle(5\.£...1\

~ u-".JA.J-C(5Lt~..Ilj ,Y. ..:..l:Jle(5\.£.jl (51'y'~4 ~ T4S:~fl j;.:. ..)..1'.)7-j..9-'-"

,~L..;> ~ )j \" .." .. F) ~LS:uT~,? ~ fll .J ..GA..I-GI) (5jL..o:;j I

-GI)~~..)j4 )j..5:..)le~LS:~ .J~~.J~ ~ 4..oGW) ~y:s ~ ~4

uW

'>Jjj-SI viJj,J1.)-7 ~L:JL4 ~,JI~~ ~~ ~~lLo viJ.;I.)-s j ~ viJj,J

("':'~J~-~~)

Ju.J~ t~ Juj) 4S:~~~.J~ ,~..I.J~1Juj) ,Y...:..l:JleUi>1~ J.:b

~lyu-" ~ j.J~ u~ 'I/O F) '(.J;~..:..l:Jle (5Lt~LS:..I..).J-C..)j) ~T <G~L...

u~~.J~ k..l 4S:~~..)j ,~'-:-'~ (5..1.9.:s":"..)y...o"-: I..)~j.J~1 Juj)'y' ..:..l:Jle

.J ~..Ilj .J-7 ..:..l:JG l>::-7~w\':' ...GA..If"~II..) ..)LS:0-:'~y..)y$\j <1.:4,Y.~4 .:3;

J~

]n!!)

1\"(

) ..:..~ 0-:' t ,', .~.<~.J-C '(5..1.9.:s~.)7-.JJu..lfl ~I.:..."~ ~ ..)..1~ .J ~jL::......

"-: ...Ijfl ~..I").JT'y'~ ~ 0-:Y-l: "-:~l:Jle ..:..leli<>d..)U:.:1:.I.Jc.g..)yl~ ..I~ ..1.=0..

~ ~ uL.:..9jAt+u 4S:,.$.")~.J ..I.J~ (5~y.t ~) ~ji:.. (5~ ~~.J

Archive of SID

www.SID.ir

Page 11: -I ,f'(;.. !i-.. - ATUjournals.atu.ac.ir/article_3159_76e9671f0b327cfbce... · 4 ~..".. ~~ ~ ~]!!) ~ ~ ~ ~

L.:; ,~..I~ ~ ~~~ ulol.Lo u-uL...10-=' ~ .~~~ u'o..ll..l>: u~lo ~

lol ~~ ,:-,L :,. ,~y.)~\j ~l.; >: ~I.)o~uJl:.)..I.J <5..11:,~l.; >: I.)0~<L..:.y:.

~ ~~ 0.J-7.J c..:..1..IJ-:!) ~ .J ~ <G U: u~ 0-=1UI~ ) r--.t ,j~

..I).J ) ~.~~ ..J.:..I;\':'o..lc .)7u~lo c..:..1..I~u.J..I.:'0~<L..:.y:. 'o~uJl:.)..I

I.) ~ ~~~ ulol.Lo ,0..l.J.)...S1.).,j) .)7u~lo 0)..11~ ~ uI.)L..;. u.l.c1

<51>: 0~.J~ ,~~I 0:1 u-uL..I.)7 ...GS:ulily ~~I ~ ~ \.:; ~L.. ~lho

.)~u <t.:L-::~ I.)u~~ ~~ ,~)..I ~ ),j \ . . . . . . ) ~ <D~u,)'~

~ ..I.J~ <5~~ ~ .uJ,fi u.)~ ~~ ~ ..I.)y 0:1.)..Ilol ...I)..I~

0:' J ..I~ )~ ~..I.J..b..<>) {;)..;. ,~~ ~ <D ~u'..II..I )~ F \.:;~..I.j:.~

,);.:. .)..1<5.h..l ~~I .)~ 0:' ...I.j:.~ ..I).J .)~ ~ <5.)~ uI.)L..;. ,~ .)..J.)

~I'.:,-~~, ~ \..; :,1 ~1 ..II..~~ ..I1:,<t.>L'1 ~.L<D~~<::<5 v::---::-- ~ u.o .) - .) '-(t-'-'<5 - ~ u ~ ..)->

4.:"~1L....).,j) t~ ~ ...I~ 0..11..1)~ ..I.J..b..<><5~y1 ~ .J ~.Jh

~ Y 0: I~ .J ..GS.:,,j.J4U ),j u~ r/D il ) ~~ 4:> 1-->=~u~lo<5u')'~

.~ o..lIJ.:;,I",>,-"~I..I~ <5u'<t.:l.;)~I'y~.h..l '~.Jh'<5~

~o iS~-.s7.I)..I~j J..Iul:.U1.oJ~ iS~J)

~1..1~ J.:..'~ ) ~~ <D..I-->=~~u.)~ .;lo,j U:\.:;<5~~I).) <L..:.y:.

0~.J,.rJ ~ .~~ ~-->=~ u.)~ ..1\.: 10)..11.)..1,~I)..I J~I u!> l: .J u~lo

',:-,L :.JI~ c..:..1..I~~I) .)..J~ .)~\j u-uL..I.)7,J..:.y. ~lo uW.)~.)..I ~I'y'-'"

.~

I~

]n!!)

Ar'

I.)o..llJ~ u~~ ~ <5~..I1(~~ o..l.j:.uJl:.)..I b «~I..I~ F)) ,jl ~ l: .J

~ J-.$ u-uL...I~ .1.)o..lc >: u~lo u 1.)~ .JI,.h..l ...j.;b ) ,~~~IJ

ulol~1 ~ 0:' .u lo..l.j:.uJl:.)..II.).)..J~ F) <5).li.o.J1~~ ..I)..I~ .)..J~.U::!..ILA;~ ~ ~<t:. ,u I.)~...jy:. 4 ,:-",-"G...,<D~ <5u'<t:.y.:. ~.)J

.)..I~<DJ.;l:~ ~y .)..11.)..Iy. b~l\':' .)..J~ ~ '..I..I~~ o..lc J 0..11..1.)7u~lo

Archive of SID

www.SID.ir

Page 12: -I ,f'(;.. !i-.. - ATUjournals.atu.ac.ir/article_3159_76e9671f0b327cfbce... · 4 ~..".. ~~ ~ ~]!!) ~ ~ ~ ~

~ --.i:~ ut~J r'" Jy..<=>1~1 ~ ,).1.~~~ I>~. ~ w~L, u.;.IJ>.1~

~yU ~~1 ,w~ <G~0-:1~ <ll:1.:L.~ ,).1.J:.~~ )~ I>Jl.h I<>y....

W:'L.:;<5Lt~I)J <G:-cj,)J w~L, J~ 0"41 ut~~ ~ ul 3:>bl:; ~ ~~

.J->=~w,)y..<=><5.l£:.",=4.)7\ ~~,. ~~j I>L,,.:,1~~

:uIJJ~ JJjA JJ ~ ~J'jSV

I>~~~ .b y J'l$ d,)J~- \

)..I;,? .b y d,)J~ - \

J :.1(j"L I.)7 '1.S7~ <5U:~ 1:,1 J'l$ d,)J~ :I>~~~ .b..uy J'l$ d,)J~

,.I"";" 'I>~~~ ~1 .~~~ ~ c~ J~ 'I>J~j..J1utj) .)7 w~L, ~~ J :.1~1:,1 J:.I>,: l:;..\.AIJ~I) ~l$ ~ f'jJ' ~).lA ~~,~ ,)J~ I,)~LtJ'1$

.J~:'~

,w).JQ..":'~ J~ ~J~~ ,)J~ ~IJA I.:~ ~ .b y LtJ'1$<D~L,j

'<5,)~ J£:. ~ J=. j-Y':-" ~).lA ~~ 4:>1u~ 'J~~ w,)y..<=>,)~Q.:Q..I~ ~

J.:,;--b :,1 J'l$ ,)~~ <G:-cj ,).1 J~ ~I L,I .~J ~I) I,) 4.J:~ JG I ~ ~IJ>.1

~ .1).1~ ~~ ,~I.:t).o --9h.)7 J :.I~I.J->=~~ w,)y..<=>~ (I>Jl.:--)~j

,~ c~ J ::.IjlI>Jl.h 1~ 1>.11.1.)7 w~L, -::...91.:,).1~ ,).1 ~jl$ <5LcJI J~I

,)J~ ~J'l$ <G~~ ~ I>~ ~~~ '~<5Lt)j~,)J J'l$ 4l..:..,)J w 1,)~

.J~~

~,)y..<=>,).1,~ ,)J~ I,)J'l$ )..I;,? <D~L,j :)..I;,? .b y J'l$ d,)J~

"---!.JJ~ ..G...,I>~~41 ~ C,;. jI J:.ly~ ,~~ d,)J~ [~ J~ <D

~II.: ~ ~ I>Jl.h 1~4' <51.)7~ C,;. jll~1 uW jll.: J:.ly~ ~I ~,)~

.~

j~

]n!:!>

Nf

I,) I>J~j..Jlutj) ~ w~L.o ~~ ~~ 'I>J~~1utj) .)7 w~L, u.;.IJ>.1 jI 0":1

~LtJ'1$ ,)~~ ~,)J I,) f'jJ' .s:)..Lo ~~ ~ ~I,~ Y',)J L,1...I;lA. -::...91.:,).1

Archive of SID

www.SID.ir

Page 13: -I ,f'(;.. !i-.. - ATUjournals.atu.ac.ir/article_3159_76e9671f0b327cfbce... · 4 ~..".. ~~ ~ ~]!!) ~ ~ ~ ~

1,,

J.)y> I.)y>1 ~1.J7" ,~J';;'~ I~ uJ;<>>,-".)I...s:)-)..~~ .;~le -:,leLio~1.-uJ .c.\)

-:,~le J$ 'o~.)~ ~...Jb..:; d~\ -:'.)~.)J.) ~JIJ~)..) (5'-".)..>7.)~ .

.~~ -:,~I y>1(51-..j)\.;.~I ~ ~~~.)I jll.) oJ\.:i , ..>7

'0:!'..>7G:,~)J )..) .;1.)JLo (5Lt"J\$(5~ oy>j .)J 4-i>~y .) .)~

JI.;-J' ~ 4.l.:Lio~ .)J .~I ~ ~ ~ ~ J)y> 0:!' .)J (5)J~)\S; .) ~

J~ I.)fll (54-i>~y .) fiL;.:u d.)JLo \.:;,~~ ~ -:,~le o)JI ~

.) f"j"J ...s:)..l-o GI) ~.) o~.)~ .b y Lt"J\$0:!1~, ~ -u~)..) ~ (Y

.J~ .)JLo ~

l.j ~ 0:!\ ..>7)..) ,~ t~ I \ '\ '\ A .>:'-"Iy \ T jI 4.S:J.J7"y> ~)l...:.1 c..>"Lt..>7

(.)L;. ~ J;..;.y.. J;..)~ ~ J)~\.:i ,1 (Y jI .J o.)J \ f 'c..>"4' ~ 0:!' o~.)~

0.J7".)(5~JI ~Iy~ '~.J:~ -:,.)~ .)1.b y .)\$ 0:!1~I .) J~ ~ I.).)~

(5"JL.S;<L..5:.b~ 0:!1~ 4-:u ~ uT ,~~ ~IJ \.)oJ.).)\ J;.j) ..>7-:,~le u ~':'<..>7

.~~o~ (.)L:..i..>!~ (5~~ TjI y;.:. J.)y>

~~1.4 ".)I.~I0WS.)l$~ ~ ~.)I.W (.)~lS..4 .)J ~ J (.).)~J

.) Lt~Jb.:;1 jI 'i..>!Y7 (5~~ T.;~le o)JI uL:.S:.)\$4.S:o~ o~J -:,\.S.)I~~

J4--:'~ OJ.).)\ J;.j)..>7 -:,~le,# (5~\$.c.)J \.:;~.>f.~ o~.) U""~I

o)JI uL:.S:.)\$jI 0> r. J.).J..:>..,r. .. <..>1'ole ~ .)J .)~ 0:!1-:,leLio d 4.:.~

0:!1.~\o~ .)L:.S:..>7'(5.>f.o~.) .) ~ (5lp.~ .)J (5.)~ ~J ~ .)~ -:,~le

<L<>\J 1dih3 0:! I~ j ~,-:,.)u;:, .) Jy.:.$ ~J (5~\$.c Jy:-.) ~ 4.S:-UJ~ Uw.:.

.J)J.:a;

J~

]"~

1.0

.~u "ju~l..w..J~.

~ l.j -.L.)J ~ ~I (5.)~1 (5Lt~Jb.:;\ .) ~\.:; oj\.:;-:'~y 0:!'

--"

Archive of SID

www.SID.ir

Page 14: -I ,f'(;.. !i-.. - ATUjournals.atu.ac.ir/article_3159_76e9671f0b327cfbce... · 4 ~..".. ~~ ~ ~]!!) ~ ~ ~ ~

r

~1j9 (.)"L...,I->:.~W ~ t.> I>.JJ~I utj) ->:u4Jle ~->: I>y;.J ,~.j\5; (5I J1

I>.JI.:>->:u4Jle ~ ~~ uL y 0:!' ,~4Jle J ..;;JJ.JuleLio 1w..uyI>~ ~

~y .J~ 0:!1~ ,~~ ~I.J I,)VAT ~->: I>y;.J (51 J\ ~ J £').J~ I,)

J (5).J->:I>~ ~ w»u 0:!1) (5).J<GI:r;..J ~J.J ,)~ ~ uL y 0:!' t; .J~~

wI (.)"L I->:~ ~ C~ (51~)L...:.1 yl0:!l) (5P~ Uf7- .~W 1>.Ju:;""'I,,~

.O~ ~J ~y wl5:~J~ ~4Jle ~-J.: (51->:'..LUly~ ~y ->:..L<>~ ).Jf'~

utJ') 0-=1) uWJI #1 ~4JL" ulelLo ,~Ij9 J ->=:'~0:!1 .Jy;.J ~ leI ..J)~

.~~I>.JlJ.:i 1

j)Jjj.91~j) ~ ~4-1~.)J ($.)IJ~~ ~J t'~1

.Jy;.y (5,)~ uw.;.:; 'I>.JJ~I utj) ->:u4Jle ~->: I>y;.J ~ Uf7-,).J

(5Lt,)~\j ...l:~ .£'.Jfi.~ ut\j ,~ (5~~ 0:!1.)I~£'I.JI..a.:; t+u ~ ~~~

I>,)J.J~ ~I.J-<' ~ (~~ ~ utJ~ ~ ~.j\5; cYo:'~1 J~ (51->:) ~~4Jle

I».JI ,~.J J~ J u)..1;.:, ,)~ ~ ..J.Jfi.~ ,)~ 1~4Jle ,)~le ~->:~

~ ~,fi ~ J;..c ~ uI.J)J .J,)y ,).Jt; ~fi. ~ I>.JJ~Iutj) ->:u4Jle

,).J .-U.J .c.1) I,) cYo:~ ,)~\j ~~ '.J.::>I>~J~ J .J~ lh£.1 (5j~ I>~J~

jl t;,~ 0.:..1.J...>::I,)I>.JJ~1 utj) ->:u4Jle ~~ I>~J~ ~ u:G (54==I).J .J,)y

(5,)~ uw.;.:; j~ ~)..1;.:, 0:!' f'lA:i~ leI ..J~ ~I>~ ~I).J J~I.j.:>. ~~

..J~~I>~.J

OJJjSlu-tj) ~ u~Lo ~ ~ JJ JY:-J-4~1J-4 ~J~ .~

I~

]n!:!>

Af

~4Jle ~ (51->:(5~ (5~~ 'I>.JJ~I utj) ->:u4Jle,).J ~ ~ WJ-J.:

b ,)~ ~ ~I ulel~1 <G,fi0:!1~ J .J~~ ~~ LS7Y-=:-(5ll:~ 1

4..l:Lio ~ ,).Ju I>.JJ~I utj) ->: u4Jle I~ ~I-J.: u 1f'j ';l ~I ,).J .~~, 9,' , ;.,~

Archive of SID

www.SID.ir

Page 15: -I ,f'(;.. !i-.. - ATUjournals.atu.ac.ir/article_3159_76e9671f0b327cfbce... · 4 ~..".. ~~ ~ ~]!!) ~ ~ ~ ~

I~

IPU

:ili;

ll1.D

lWuD

9,H

1;.

c-(I

(.,

"C

~<

[I:

r<>

r..

C"

<P

,.J

)'i

Ir(I

t(I

~,

~~

.t':

:r~

~1-

~'~

.t\

t&

Et

t~

~.~

-~

ib

(.,

(.,

"~

.~~

;1.

~."

~.

(I)

~(':

,.

1b

(.1-

t'r

(.,

~~

~(I

)F

(.t

.rE

(i\'f

~':~

I~

;-- r

1'"

~.

'Ez:

-~

r~~

fC

(,(1

) 1'

~r.

...",

,t-,

b~

1~

".1-

[,

,'(.

I.",I.

r..

'1/

C.

~-

.<

V-,

(I~

f"".

t.~

..1:

,(.

,-'"

;

r1-1:

.~

.'E

LL

'E' k

"c~

~'i

,rr.

.t

b-"

(i\~

'-b

[I'-

b'r.

.~

t~

~.

.~

.I

r..

-,

(.,

,..

To

r..

.n

,I_

I...

.r.r

-(,

L.-,

~~

<v-

,<

.p/':

<.,.

'-,1

:.1

.C

~T

o.r

}~

.'1

/V

\[,.

Ii7~

i'c

F'b

r-}'

)"'.r

'<

[,.'-

~",

c(.

,E

:.

1:z

I'r:

;(,

<"

C'.r

' Eil

=~

I''b

tC

'.I

~.r

r"~

cC

".

[i

-~

,r(I

),,r

"L

t..<

:;""

b,

~.,.

.'.

.,.(,

(."

b'1:

.<

e,,1

/"

-<

e:",

~t

~-

,., f

~'E

,,1~

(,'i'

/':1:

-r.

.b

1/'

"

t.,

(,[;-

.-

E~

V\

-~

(,~

.(,

c~

r,'E

b~

":t

b.

.1:

C-

~~

.(.

,'b

,,

(.,,~

b~'

~.

(.,

C-,

~.

C~

.~

.~

,'~

,CI

r~

,(I)

I'--.

:&

..t

~:

1I

~..

~Ii\

r..

f~

~-

L.'E

~Ir

(.,

br.

.~

~-.

r;z'

1/(.

,y,

,"(.

,(.

,1.

(I)

:-b

~I;

r[:,

~r

~<

[,:t

~'i

t'(;

;r.

.~

1:.

:lI>

--

-c-

.:t

C-

V\

1:.,

CC

(.,

c-t

~&

~i~

<t.

.1.

s:<

r..

11\

~I-,

~~

.:::

~r.

.L.

~-;

:~

t:(.

,C

..£

'.,r

.~

i'C

r.t.

[..C

1~

c~

~li.

:.[

r.~

~,

1\~

~(I

),.

~~

t~

{.~

. f''''.(

,1-

c';'

<[.,

~'

lA,

(I)

~-

r..

.F.

~r.

.~

,'~

:[r

'EE

(.,

t'-

(I)

,.

1f.

~~

~~

,~

.II:

'~

~,

&:

!~;

~~

.b

:-~

~f

l'~

~.

r~

~!t

fLE

t.1-

<{"

~;

(.,

t..

<\-

1,

1:-

~(.r~

\. l

~"

rC

"T

::-c.

...

(I(I

[,.

1

Q..

(.I;

r'-:

-~

.E

r,c'

be.

r..

-r.

.b

I(,

f1

r..

r.'E

I-c

tt.

-!;-

.~.

' f[

~}:

.C

\-

c-[

--

bc.

-r.

.~

...~

.I'

.c

!tr.

.[

r.1

,r.

-l

,C

1:..

(.,

c...

...-

IT

o'(.

,.1

.1'

-r.

.C

i,(.

~:

(,1

,,,""

r(,

~1,

-,

'

K(0

f:t.

Cr.

.C

C

t.'

1,I.

I-I

".

(.,.r

.,

-.1

.1.

;t

:L~

t.'

f:

~~

.,rt.

.c=

~-~

Arc

hive

of S

ID

ww

w.S

ID.ir

Page 16: -I ,f'(;.. !i-.. - ATUjournals.atu.ac.ir/article_3159_76e9671f0b327cfbce... · 4 ~..".. ~~ ~ ~]!!) ~ ~ ~ ~

c

.tf']

e,r

.t1

(.,

JC

,L

.

(..

\;-.

,-(A

e,.'

,-

bG\

G\.

;r-.

c(.

Et

J'C

7f

\t

,.1,

,r-

Ii\

(.,

Eb

\f'

L.1

:-'(.

."'b

J'I.

,r

',b

),G

\1

,rG

\(.

.r.

'."

'E,t

{;.

,\;-

(..

.G

\.r

-G

\,t

(...

1..

f\

c,.r

-{;

.eb

<e,

.['

,fb

L\

\(.

.r

\;-.

,t'

r-

l"1.

.I>

-.

1r

(..

e..

b,r

-1

ff"

,'-,

.--

-'-

I>.

'"c.

\;-.

.tV

Ft-

(>c

1;r

[f

1,"

ct,c

--

'r.C

7(.

....

.,'..,

-(:

-(.

..

\'I.

.G

\

c':

(Af

11

t..t

f\

t-.

EL

C,r

-.t,

;-b

tI;

,,t.

\G

\.

\,.

(."

c

(..

rC

t\t

tc

\c.

G\

c..r

-G

\-

1C

r'C

l(.

.C

1,C

{;L

t''i

{f"r

(1'IO

-.t

.(.

.I;

-1;

l-.

C7

1:-

r'

(.,

C

tr"

t.

-'e.

\

..-<

1r.

.oE

'i£-

fJ'

t'1

;-.

.:''

b:1,

.t

fr

\.

e,(.

,,r

.t'.

r.r-

t(.

,-

,..r

-,t

!OJ

2C

r.:

C

,,

1c

r.);

.c'

:t

C7.

e(.

,",

'1

.t

C

<e,

,:

(..',

.'1-

,,.

.r-

.r-

C7

Cr

G\

.,1

.'c'

(.,

.-

,\;-.

C".

f:-

t'lL

1r"

\IG

\C

f;1

tZ\

t.t

'.t

,.c.

\.'I.

,..t.c

=(.

.f

C

(..,.

1C

'e,

\.r

-(.

,1.

(.".

.Ii

\J

rE

G\

,.,r

(AIi

.'E

CC

.1.

f(.

,b

(..

c-'-

1;-'

\(.

.t

rG

\L

re,

I>'

'-[

\'

Fb.

.r.

1"c,

tC

'0

'r.'

r<

;;"

.<

-f:

tC

f:of

(:-.

.r-

\}c

-,.

c.,

1,.

:1,

.r'

.f

(..

ff."

'";[

\:[.

e':r

c.'.t

e.\

.ce-

t,.

c-,.

,r

(.,

Cl'

bG

,.C

}c'

.t:

l1

t..'

c--

-c.

..

'c,

-'r

(.,

..

I;-

<r.

1...r

-.

(..

(.,

>IP

11U

>1J

..W..a

.9.h

>Arc

hive

of S

ID

ww

w.S

ID.ir

Page 17: -I ,f'(;.. !i-.. - ATUjournals.atu.ac.ir/article_3159_76e9671f0b327cfbce... · 4 ~..".. ~~ ~ ~]!!) ~ ~ ~ ~

<~

J~

]n~

A\

~ ~ ,.j~u-<> 1..'>710T",.j ~Y' "'~ U;.J'" ~I J ..:.:..u.1)~ d:..J" :,I "'~ JI..:..

"'~ :,t;..j",>-" ~L,>-,-" :,1 J .j~ 0\'::' J ",Y-Q £>1",0~ Lt..L<...oi'L, £>!YU-<>

~ ",.j ,~yly 1~ LSI).j <LS:.G.:.I-l:.l:'-7"'~ ~L:JL, uL,\.b, .~ ~l: o

:,1.l:~ ~ ~~ ..s:~ LS~~ T",.j ~ ~'" J r.jJ" LS.jL.d;.S1~J .j~

~u'" JJ44- J u).£. :,I I",LS).j<GI-? .G.:.1j1.;t:; ~J7 °->t7 ~ d':'~1 u-<>L,:;

.~

:~

Marlen Bates, "VAT Fraud: The South Aerican Expenence," VAT

Monitor; November, December 2000.

..

Archive of SID

www.SID.ir