)&3e)&)&'v-9 )l5 u /b$ …cs.joensuu.fi/pages/whamalai/expert/es1.pdf1..... ¡...

21

Upload: others

Post on 03-May-2020

11 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: )&3E)&)&'V-9 )l5 U /b$ …cs.joensuu.fi/pages/whamalai/expert/es1.pdf1..... ¡ '=" ? '=" ±

� �������� � �� � ������ ���������� ���������� ��

!#"�$&%('*),+.-0/(12)4365�78-9/;:,'=<=<><=3@?A12"

BDC 3E"(3.14?A<GF�"(-.:,<=3.H C 3�-AIJ3LK�MN3.1O$�)�7�)�$43EPQ)R?S"(H�$&%(3.'=1TM�-9)&)&'=U('=<V'W$4'V3E)B %(-.: $4-Q'*PQM(<=3EPX3E"�$Y?Z)27�)�$43EP I[-61�78-9/(1�-.:�"\M(1�-0U(<=3EPB %(-.: $4-Q+.-9PQM]?S1�3^H_'*`a3.1�3E"�$,)27b)2$c3EPd)Y?e"(H;)43.<=3.+f$�$&%(3gU�3E)�$�-9"(3B )&3fh83.14?S<iPQ3f$f?e)&F�'=<V<*)j<V'*F 3d"(3f: <V3@?S1�"('*" C PX3f$&%(-kH�)l5 C 1m-9/_M�:n-01�F�'*" C 5M(1�-9U(<V3EP )4-0<ohb'*" C 5p'*"�I[-612Pq?l$4'V-9"r1�3f$41m'=3fh�?S<s5�t=t=t

u�v]w�xey{z}|~z��l�p���[y� 3.+f$4)�P�?S)2$c3.1���<=3fh83.<�+.-0/(12)43

� <�?e)&)&3E)l��� 3.H ���S�L�.�����.�0� �6� �f�_t���t��O�0��t��0�0ta�9�6� �

��3@?A+c%(3.1E�b� '=<*%(3.<=PQ'V'*"]?X�,�ePq�S<��S'="(3E" ¢¡ 3.3f$c'*" C $4'*PX3E)l��� 3.H �{��t��0�l�L���_t��0��5£:�%]?SP�?A<¤?S'�¥�+E){t§¦O-k3E"_)&/_/>t©¨Nª

«J1m3.1�3.¬8/('V+.'W$c3E){�(U]?e)4'=+­Fk"(-.:,<=3.H C 3­-AI®<V- C '=+E)¯?e"(H;M(1m-9U]?SU('=<='o$¢7°+@?A<=+E/(<*/_)

±

Page 2: )&3E)&)&'V-9 )l5 U /b$ …cs.joensuu.fi/pages/whamalai/expert/es1.pdf1..... ¡ '=" ? '=" ±

� ����� �i�_� ���Y�N�

B�� -d3LKp?eP°5b"(-dH_3EPQ- )&3E)&)&'V-9"_)l5�U_/b$�)2$c'=<V<a:n3¯:,'=<=<><=3@?A12"�B «J1m3EM]?S1m3¯I[-01��{�D%(-9/(1�)n:n-01�F��l:n3.3EF}?e)�'*"\"(-612Pq?S<G+.-0/(12)43E)�

�0t�� �_x@�{�� ���®�_�{����� �[�£y{y.zky   7�-0/°+@?e"\H_1m-9Mr?@$�PX-9)�$Y�6���{� +.<�?e)&)&3E)Lª��t�� [email protected]��a�l�_�{�[v���y ?eU�-9/b$ZP�?A'*" 3LKbM�3.1O$�)�7�)2$c3EPd)l��� )2$4/(H_3E"�$�M]?A'=1C 'Wh83E)�? �0��PX'*" M(1m3E)&3E"�$f?l$c'=-9" ?SUN-0/b$­)&-0PQ3d3LKbM�3.1 $­)27b)2$c3EP :,'W$4%)&-0PQ3 ��z� 6�lw�x@z�� �_�{z�x@� �(� I[-01�-A$&%(3.1�)�$&/(H_3E"�$4){t��n%(3f7�)m%(-0/(<=H\?S<=)&-H_3E)&' C "X)&-0PQ3 z���z�x� �[y.z��l�py�� ?eU�-9/b$i$4%(3 $4-9M('V+�?e"(H�+c%(3.+ F�$&%(3�)&-S�<*/b$4'V-9"_)lt �i?S+ % 3LK�3.1�+.'=)&3�$L?S)mF�)m%(-0/(<=H�$f?eF 3�?eM_M(1m-EK_'*Pq?l$43.<o7���%(-0/(12):�-612FNt

�bt�! �>z�x" �[y.zky �G!s"\$&%(3jU�3 C '*"_"('=" C -AIi+.-9/(1�)&3Z3LK�3.1m+.'*)43E)g?eU�-0/b$¯'*"�$c1�-S�H�/(+f$4'=-0" <=3.+f$4/(1�3E)j?e"(H ?S<=<®)�$&/(H_3E"�$­M(1�3E)43E"�$f?l$4'V-9"_)lt�� 3.3EF�<W7r3LK�3.1 �+.'*)43E)X$L?SF63 ?eM_M(1�-.K�'=P�?@$43.<W7 � %(-9/(12)�:�-612F '=" $4%(3°U�3 C '="_"('*" C -9I+.-9/(12)436t

�(t�# zk�(x��~�$��� |~�[�(x&% �'�i?A+c% )�$&/(H_3E"�$ :,1�'o$43E) ? M�3.12)4-9"]?A<^<=3@?S1�"('*" CH_'¤?S1O7 ?e"(H 1�3f$4/(12"_)­?dM('=3.+.3�-AI 'o$R:�3.3EF�<W78tN� %(3j<V3.+f$&/(1m3.1�:�'V<=< C 'Wh83I[3.3.H�U]?S+cF "(3LK�$:n3.3EFNtk�n%(3R<V3@?S1�"('*" C H_'¤?A1�'=3E)�?A1�3R3fh�?A<*/]?l$c3.H�'*"Q$4%(33E"(H -9IJ+.-0/(12)436t

� t�� x@v)(Ez� 6�+*�vpx,�>y � %(3 M(1m-S¦23.+f$¢:n-01�Fk)T?S1�3TPq?SH_3 '=" C 1�-0/_M_) -AI]$&%(1m3.3)2$4/(H_3E"�$&)   -A$&%(3.1Y$&%]?S" '*" $&%(3DM(1m3E)&3E"�$f?l$c'=-9"_)LªLt��n%(3DM(1m-S¦23.+f$&)�?S1m3MN3.12I[-01�PQ3.H '*" )43fh�3.14?A<�M_%]?e)43E)l�®)mM�3.+.'*¨p+@?l$4'V-9"   $c-9M('V+}?e"(H H£?l$L?6ªL5H_3E)&' C "   %(-{: $4-Q'*PQM(<=3EPX3E"�$Lªf5_'=PdM(<V3EPQ3E"�$f?l$c'=-9" ?e"(H�$43E)�$4'=" C

-

Page 3: )&3E)&)&'V-9 )l5 U /b$ …cs.joensuu.fi/pages/whamalai/expert/es1.pdf1..... ¡ '=" ? '=" ±

!�� �(� w��_�{�[v��«J1m-A¦O3.+f$¢:n-01�Fk)R�8���«J1m3E)&3E"8$L?l$c'=-0"_)¯�9����a3@?S1�"('*" C H_'¤?S1m'=3E)¯�0����~K_3.1�+.'*)43E)l�£�0���

«J1m3E)&3E"8$L?l$c'=-0"_) :,'=<V<aU�3g3fh ?A<*/]?@$43.H U�7q)�$&/(H_3E"�$4)R?S"(H�$4%(3Y$43@?S+ %(3.1   ?A+L�+.-01mH_'*" C $4-d%(-.: PZ/(+c%�7�-0/°<=3@?A12"�$fª�b-61 <V3@?S12"('=" C H_'¤?S1m'=3E)l5�:�3�:,'=<=<�¨bKq$4%(3^H_3f$L?A'=<=3.H°+.1�'W$c3.1�'�?�$c- C 3f$&%(3.1 �

Page 4: )&3E)&)&'V-9 )l5 U /b$ …cs.joensuu.fi/pages/whamalai/expert/es1.pdf1..... ¡ '=" ? '=" ±

�D���J� ��� ��� ��� �J���

� � ���~z� z �£������������

B � %]?@$Y?A1�3�7�-0/(1T3LK�MN3.+f$c'=-0"_) �B � %]?@$�H_-D7�-9/ F�"(-.: U�3�I[-01m3E%]?e"(H��B � %]?@$�'=)n78-9/(1TPQ-A$4'Wh�?@$4'=-0"��

!�� z�x&% *Zz8z ��

B � %]?@$ 78-9/ %]?�h�3­<V3@?S12"8$¯?S"(H�:�%]?@$T78-9/ %]?�h�3^"(-A$��B�� 3f$J78-9/(1�)&3.<*I�<=3@?A12"('*" C�C -�?A<*)l50:�%]?l$i78-9/Q)m%(-0/(<=HQ<=3@?S1�"�-01J¨("(H -0/b$&�� %(3.+cF ?A<*)4-�5('oI�7�-0/ %]?fh83g1�3@?S+ %(3.H�7�-9/(1 M(1�3fhb'V-9/_)�<=3@?A12"('*" CdC -8?S<*)&�

B �Y<=< 3LKbM�3.1m'=3E"(+.3E)l5GI[3.3.<='=" C )l5�+c%]?S" C 3E)�'*" PQ-A$4'Wh�?@$4'=-0" ?S1m3�?A<*)4-°'*P �MN-61 $f?e"�$,�

B �~KbM(<�?S'*"�$&%(3�"(3f: -01�H_'��X+E/(<W$�$4%('*" C )�:�'W$4%�78-9/(1�-{:�"q:�-61�H�)&�b��1O7$4-r1�3.<¤?@$43Q$4%(3EP $c- 78-9/(1�M(1�3fh�'=-9/_)ZFk"(-{:�<V3.H C 365 ?e"(H '*"�h83E"�$Z"(3f:?eM_M(<='V+@?l$c'=-9"_)

Page 5: )&3E)&)&'V-9 )l5 U /b$ …cs.joensuu.fi/pages/whamalai/expert/es1.pdf1..... ¡ '=" ? '=" ±

� � ���~z°z�� |

B � -9PZU('="(3Z?S<V<~M('=3.+.3E)R-9IJF�"(-.:,<=3.H C 3Z'="�$4-�-0"(3Z?S"(H°H_14?�: $4%(3^¨("]?S<M('=+f$&/(1m3   U�7�:�-61�H�),-01�H_14?�:�'=" C ?Z+.-9"(+.3EMb$�P�?SM]ª

B ��h�?S<=/]?l$43^7�-0/(1T:�%(-0<V3�<V3@?S12"('=" C M(1�-k+.3E)&)RH�/(1�'=" C $&%(3j+.-9/(12)436����'VH7�-9/\1m3@?S+c% 7�-9/(1 C -8?S<=) � �Y1m3�7�-0/\) ?@$4'=)�¨p3.H\-61 "(-A$��

� � �p|�|�� �{��v �

B � -9/ +@?S"D:�1m'W$c3T-61 H_14?�: ?e"�7k$4%('*" C 78-9/D:,'*)&%��­$4%(3n)�$¢7b<V3T'=)J$4-A$L?S<V<W7I[1�3.3

B�� 3f$4/(12" 78-9/(1TM('=3.+.3g-AI <=3@?S1�"('*" C H_'¤?A1 7q:n3.3EF�<o7;-9" M]?SM�3.1E5b)4-Z$4%]?l$7�-9/(1q$c3@?S+c%(3.1;+@?e" C 'oh�3 7�-9/ '*"(H_'ohb'=H�/]?A<¯I[3.3.H�U]?S+cF ?e"(H ?e"_)�:�3.17�-9/(1�¬8/(3E)�$4'V-9"_)

B�� ?fh83^-0<=H°<=3@?S1�"('*" C H_'¤?A1�'V3E)TI -01 ¨("]?S<G3fh�?A<*/]?l$c'=-0"

Page 6: )&3E)&)&'V-9 )l5 U /b$ …cs.joensuu.fi/pages/whamalai/expert/es1.pdf1..... ¡ '=" ? '=" ±

� ����� ��� � �'�J��� �����R�����,�O�

�f�(t �bt�!s"8$41�-�H�/(+f$4'=-0" $c- ��KbM�3.1 $,)27b)2$c3EPd)l5p+.-9/(12)43�-{h�3.1Ohb'=3f: ?S"(H :n-012F?S<V<=-k+@?@$4'V-9"���0t �bt£� ?e)4'=+Y$�7�M�3E) -AI � � ){5�1�/(<=3L�¢U]?S)&3.H�5�I[/_"(+f$4'=-0"]?S<~?e"(H�M(1�-9U]?SU('=<V'*)�$4'=+)�7�)2$c3EPd)���bt �bt � � ){5�)2$4/(H_3E"�$,M(1�3E)43E"�$L?@$4'=-0"_)� t��.�bt � � ){5�)2$4/(H_3E"�$,M(1�3E)43E"�$L?@$4'=-0"_)�{��tV�{��t � � )l5b)�$&/(H_3E"�$,M(1�3E)43E"�$f?l$4'V-9"_)�.�btV�{��t � � )l5�<¤?S)2$Z)2$4/(H_3E"�$�M(1m3E)&3E"8$L?l$c'=-0"_){t � -0PdM]?A1�'=" C ?e"(H 3fh�?A<*/]?l$��'*" C )�7�)2$c3EPd)   <V3.+f$&/(1m3.14ªLt�� 3 C '*"_"('*" C M(1m-S¦23.+f$¢:n-01�Fk){t�9�btV�{��t�� -612F�)&M�3.+.'o¨p+@?@$4'=-0"_)   $c-9M('=+�� H£?l$L?6ªL5()&%(-01 $,M(1�3E)43E"�$f?l$4'V-9"_)lt��t��0�0tk� -612FdM(<¤?e"_)   PX3f$&%(-kH�� %(-.: $c-�'=PdM(<V3EPQ3E"8$LªL5�)&%(-01O$nM(1�3E)43E"�$L?l�$4'V-9"_)lt��t��0�0tN�,3f$L?A'=<V3.H M(<¤?S"_) :,'W$4%°+.<¤?S)m),H_'¤? C 1c?ePQ)Y?S"(H;P�?A'*"r?A< C -61�'o$&%_PQ){t�.�btV�6�9tN!#PdM(<V3EPQ3E"�$f?l$c'=-9"_)l5_)m%(-61 $,M(1�3E)43E"�$L?@$4'=-0"_) ��9�btV�6�9t �RU�-9/b$T$43E)�$4'*" C 5pH_3E)&' C "('*" C $43E)�$,M(<¤?e"_)lt��,$&%(3.1 3fh�?A<*/]?l$c'=-0"   1m3L�)�$41�'V+f$4'V-9"_)l5_$4'*PX3j?e"(H;)&M]?S+.3^1m3.¬8/('=1m3EPQ3E"8$&),3f$4+6t ª�0�btV�6�9t � /_M�3.12)43E)m)4'=-0"   �Q%]ªL5b¨("]?S<�M(1�3E)43E"�$L?@$4'=-0"_)

Page 7: )&3E)&)&'V-9 )l5 U /b$ …cs.joensuu.fi/pages/whamalai/expert/es1.pdf1..... ¡ '=" ? '=" ±

� �'�® �J��� �a���j�G�� ����� ��~� ���

�Gz � z�xe�p�n|~z�� �~���{��v�� y

� � +.-0PdM_/b$c3.1 )�7�)�$43EP :�%('V+c%°3EPZ/(<¤?@$43E)�$4%(3­H_3.+.'*)4'=-0"��¢P�?SF�'*" C ?eU('V<='o$¢7-AIi?Z%k/_Pq?e" 3LKbM�3.1O$ �

� � +.-9PQM_/b$43.1})27�)�$43EP +@?SM]?eU(<V3 -AI C 'Whb'=" C ?SH�hb'V+.3 '*" ? M]?S1 $c'=+E/(<�?S1Fk"(-{:�<V3.H C 3­H_-0P�?A'*" �

� � PX-kH_3.<a-9I�$&%(3^3LK�MN3.1O$4'=)&3­-9I~$&%(3gU�3E)�$�M(1c?S+f$4'o$4'V-9"(3.12)�-AI�$4%(3¯¨p3.<=H �

Page 8: )&3E)&)&'V-9 )l5 U /b$ …cs.joensuu.fi/pages/whamalai/expert/es1.pdf1..... ¡ '=" ? '=" ±

B ?eM_M(<='V+@?l$c'=-9" -9I������������ ��������������������������   )&'=P�/(<�?l$c3E)T'*"8$43.<=<V' C 3E"�$�U�3L�%]?fhb'V-9/(1cª

B 1�-k-A$&),'*" �!�"��$#�� %&�'�������)(*#��+#   /b$4'V<='o$¢7°-AIJH_3.+.'*)4'=-9"]ªB ?S<*)4-g1�3.<�?l$43.HZ$4--, �.�/0���1�324�"�&���5�6�0�   <=3@?A12"('*" C PX-kH_3.<=) I[1m-9P H£?l$f?0ª?e"(H7�8�9�:�;,<���5���0�   H_'=)&+.-{h�3.1m'*" C "(3f: M]?@$�$c3.12"_),'*"\H£?@$L?0ª

B MN3.12I[-01�Pd)n?l$ $&%(3�<=3fh83.<£-9I~?e"�3LKbM�3.1O$   $c-D?S)m)4'*)�$�?e"�3LKbM�3.1 $�-01 3fh83E"'*"_)�$43@?SH°-AI ?S"\3LKbM�3.1 $Lª

B %]?fh83gUN3.3E"\H_3E)4' C "(3.H I[-01R?�"]?A1�1m-.: M(1�-0U(<=3EP H_-9Pq?S'="B +@?e"rUN3j'*PQM(<=3EPX3E"�$43.H ?e)^?e" ���=�����6�)�>�?�����@�A�?���=�CB ? M]?S1O$¯-AI )4-AI�$��:T?A1�365�:�%('V+c% PQ-0"('W$4-612)\$&%(3 )�7�)�$43EP ?S"(H -A`a3.1�)\%(3.<*M>5�:�%(3E" 'W$+.-9"_)4'=H_3.12),'o$�'*)�"(3.3.H_3.H

D

Page 9: )&3E)&)&'V-9 )l5 U /b$ …cs.joensuu.fi/pages/whamalai/expert/es1.pdf1..... ¡ '=" ? '=" ±

� �'�® �,�G� � � � �R� �

�Gz � z�xe�p� �+% � zkydv����l�py��y

B ��'�? C "(-0)&'=){�6¨("(H_'*" C Is?e/(<o$&) '="D$&%(3n)27�)�$43EP -61 H_'*)43@?e)43E)i-AI�<='Wh�'*" C -01 �C ?e"('=)mPQ)l5£36t C tpM(1m'*"�$c3.1�Is?S/(<W$¯H_3f$c3.+f$4'=-0"})�7�)�$43EP°5�?e/b$c-9Pq?l$4'V+�PX3.H��'=+@?S<�?SH�h�'=+.-01�),'*" $&%(3­"(3f$l5GtVt=t

B ¡ -0"('W$c-01�'=" C �l+.-9"8$4'*"�/(-9/_)�'*"8$43.12M(1m3f$43f$c'=-9"Z-AI�)&' C "]?S<=){5l36t C t.U(1�3@?l$c'*" C �)m/_M_M�-01O$ P�?A+c%('*"(3E)®'*"�%(-9)&M('W$L?A<*)l5A+.-0"�$41m-0<V<='*" C )�7�)2$c3EPd)®'*"Z'*"(H�/_)�$41 7

B «J<¤?S"_"('*" C �eM(1�-�H�/(+.'*" C ?�)&3.¬8/(3E"(+.3 -AIN?A+f$4'V-9"_)JI[-01 ?S+c%('V3fhb'*" C ?TM]?S1 �$4'=+E/(<�?S1 C -�?S<   36t C t�H_3E)&' C "('=" C ?e" '=H_3@?S< +E/(1m1�'=+E/(<=/_P I[-61j?�)4+c%(-k-6< 5'*"�$c3.14?S+f$c'Wh83 C /('=H_3E)qI[-01q1�3EM]?S'V1�'=" C ? +@?A1E5"]?�hb' C ?l$c'*" C ?e" 3LKbM(<=-S�14?l$c'=-0"°1�-0UN-A$Y'*" ¡ ?S1�) ª

B !s"_)�$41�/(+f$4'V-9"   '*"�$c3.<=<=' C 3E"�$�$4/b$4-61�'*" C )�7�)�$43EPQ) ªf�83E)&M�3.+.'¤?A<=<W7QI[-01M(14?A+L�$4'*)4'*" C M_%87�)&'V+@?S< )&F�'=<V<*) <V'*F 3qM(<�?e"(3�)4'*PZ/(<�?l$4-612)l5®U_/b$D"(-.:�?SH£?�7�)d'="?S<=<><=3fh83.<*)l5_3E)&M�3.+.'¤?A<=<W7 '*"°H_'=)2$f?e"(+.3^<V3@?S12"('=" C

B «J1�3.H_'V+f$4'V-9">�AI[-01m3.+@?e)�$4'=" C I�/b$&/(1m3n3fh�3E"8$&)   36t C t8?AH�hb'=+.'=" C M(1m'=+.'=" C ?A+L�+.-01�H_'=" C $c- Pq?S1�F63f$��(/(+f$&/]?l$c'=-0"_) ª

Page 10: )&3E)&)&'V-9 )l5 U /b$ …cs.joensuu.fi/pages/whamalai/expert/es1.pdf1..... ¡ '=" ? '=" ±

��� �i� �Y�O�~�

� xew~�[z�� � �£y.zk| y %>y.�{z�� � vpx��£w��{v�� v������[zr�.x@v£w�����z��cy �~vavp�{������n%(3­)27�)�$43EP +.-0"_)&'=)2$Y-9IJ)4'*PQM(<=3 � '*I tVt=t�$&%(3E" � 12/(<V3E){5�:,'W$&%}/_"(+.3.1 $f?S'*"8$¢7PX3@?e)&/(1�3E)lt �b-61T3LK£?ePQM(<=36�

� !sIG$4%(3�1m3E)m/(<o$�-AI>$c1 7b'=" C $&%(3Y)2$f?S1O$43.1 '=) $&%(3¯+@?S1 +.14?e"_F�)n"(-01�P�?A<=<W7 ?S"(H? C ?e)¯)mPX3.<=<®'*)¯"(-S$gM(1�3E)43E"�$Y:�%('=<=3j$c1 7b'=" C $4%(3Z)2$f?S1O$43.1g�n%(3E"}$&%(3 C ?e)$L?S"_F�'=)�3EPQMb$¢7q:�'W$4%r�0� � +.-0"�¨pH_3E"(+.3 �

�n%(3^-0"���<='="(3­H_3EPQ- +@?e" U�3¯I[-9/_"(H -0">����������� ������������������������������������! "#�$� %&�'�(����(��)��*�n%(3g)�7�)�$43EP '*),H_3E)4+.1�'*U�3.H -0"���������� ������������������������������������! "#�$� %&�'�(����

±,+

Page 11: )&3E)&)&'V-9 )l5 U /b$ …cs.joensuu.fi/pages/whamalai/expert/es1.pdf1..... ¡ '=" ? '=" ±

� � %]zky.� � � �pw~�{v�� v � ����zr�.xev£w ���[z y �~vavp�{������n%(3}'=H_3@? '=)Q$4- H_'¤? C "(-0)&'��{3\$4%(3\PX-9)�$�M(1�-9U]?SU(<=3r1�3@?S)&-0"_)�I[-61�?e/b$4-S�PX-9U('=<V3 )�$L?A1 $��¢/_M M(1m-9U(<V3EPd)Z?S"(H 3fh�?S<=/]?l$c3 $4%(3 M(1m-9U]?eU('V<='o$¢7 $&%]?l$^$4%(33E" C '="(3Z:n-01�Fk){5�:�%(3E" :n3D¨bK ?q+.3.1O$L?S'=" +.-0PdM�-9"(3E"8$lt �b-61¯3LK£?ePQM(<=3 '*I:n3j-0U_)&3.1Oh�3�$&%]?@$R$&%(3 C ?S/ C 3�'*)�3EPQMb$�7   :�%(3f$&%(3.1Y-01,"(-A$,$&%(3.1�3�'*)YI�/��3.<¤ªf5_:�3�+@?e"r+@?S<V+E/(<¤?l$c3�$&%(3­M(1m-9U]?SU('=<='o$¢7°$&%]?l$,$4%(3�+@?A1�)2$f?S1 $4)^?eI�$43.1T:n3%]?�h�3g¨p<V<=3.H�$&%(3�$f?e"_FNt

�n%('=)J3LK£?ePQM(<=3�'*)®I[1m-9P � 1m3.3E)&365���t � tV5 �T3.+ F63.12Pq?e">5 ��t6?e"(H � -9PQPQ3.<=)&365�Zt=�a��1m-9/_U(<=3E)&%(-k-A$4'*" C�� "(H_3.1 � "(+.3.1O$L?A'*"�$�78t���3.+c%_"('V+@?S<J1�3EM�-01O$ ¡ � � �� � �O�A�S�O���58�.�0�A�_t ���������� ������ �*������)���� �� ��� �(��������� ��� $��'������)��&� ������%���� ���#� ��)�� ����� "�������(���&������������� ������!"#��$�%

±�±

Page 12: )&3E)&)&'V-9 )l5 U /b$ …cs.joensuu.fi/pages/whamalai/expert/es1.pdf1..... ¡ '=" ? '=" ±

� |~z� �[y.�[v�� �.x@z8z � vpx � zk|~�� ��p�n|~�[� ���~v]y.�[y�R"}�,!��,�¢M�-9)4'W$c'Wh�3¯M]?@$4'=3E"8$T%]?e) +.-0PQ3,$4-�$4%(3Y3EPX3.1 C 3E"(+f7�H_3EM]?A1 $4PQ3E"�$I[-61 +@?S1�36t � %]?l$°'=) $&%(3 /(1 C 3E"(+f7 -AIj$&%(3 hb'*)4'W$ � �n%(3 "k/(12)43 )&%(-9/(<VH+.<¤?S)m)4'oI 7;M]?@$4'=3E"8$&)�?e)Y�9B�3EPX3.1 C 3E"�$l5��ABY/(1 C 3E"�$@5£�9BY"(-9"��¢/(1 C 3E"�$@t

�n%('=)�3LK£?ePQM(<=3¯'*)TI[1�-0P �a3f:�'=){5 � t ��t=���Y"°!#"�$c1�-kH�/(+f$c'=-0" $4- � <¤?S)m)4'o¨p+@?l�$4'V-9" ?e"(H � 3 C 1�3E)&)&'V-9" ��1m3.3   � � � ��ª'�R"]?A<W7�)4'*)lt �R"_"k/]?A< ¡ 3.3f$4'*" C -9I$&%(3 � -k+.'V3f$¢7qI -01 ��+@?SH_3EPX'=+ �®PX3.1 C 3E"(+f7 ¡ 3.H_'=+.'="(3�'=" � ?e" �b14?S"(+.'*)4+.-�5� ?A<='*I[-01�"('¤?�50�9�0�6��t ���������� ������ ��)��# � �����&��*�#��������)��'����#� ����� � ���� t

± -

Page 13: )&3E)&)&'V-9 )l5 U /b$ …cs.joensuu.fi/pages/whamalai/expert/es1.pdf1..... ¡ '=" ? '=" ±

� � � � ��� � �b� �Y�k� ���,� �

B %(3.<*Mq'*I~3LK�MN3.1O$4'=)&3�'*)�)4+@?S12)4365�3LKbM�3E"_)4'Wh�3�-01 /_"]?�h�?S'=<�?eU(<V3 � $41c?S'="('*" C"(3f: %k/_Pq?e" 3LKbM�3.1 $4),'*) $4'*PX3L��+.-9"_)&/_PX'*" C ?S"(H 3LKbM�3E"_)&'oh�3

B ) ?�h�3\$4'=PQ365iU�3.+@?e/_)43;$4%(3f7 ?A1�3\Is?e)�$\?e"(H $&%(3°) ?SPQ3°)27�)�$43EP +@?S")&3.1Oh�3g)43fh�3.14?A<>/_)&3.1�)TM]?A14?S<V<=3.<V<W7

B H_- "(-S$�I[-01 C 3f$Y-01TPq?eF63g%�/_P�?S";3.1m1�-612)B ?S1�3 +.-0"_)&'=)2$c3E"�$l� )4'*PX'=<¤?A1 )4'W$4/]?l$c'=-9"_) ?A1�3}?A<W:�?f7�)�%]?S"(H_<=3.H '=" $4%(3) ?SPQ3Y:�?f7

B +@?e"\+.-9PZU('="(3gFk"(-.:,<=3.H C 3­-AI PZ/(<o$4'*M(<V3^%k/_Pq?e"\3LKbM�3.1O$&)� v�*�z � z�x�� ! ��y

B ?S1�3�$c-S$f?S<=<o7°H_3EMN3E"(H_3E"8$�-9" $4%(3.'=1TFk"(-.:,<=3.H C 3­U]?e)43B /_)m/]?A<=<W7;P�?S"]? C 3^-9"(<W7 -9"(3�:�?f7 -AI 1�3@?e)4-9"('=" CB H_-9"���$�%]?fh83­+.-9PQPX-9";)&3E"_)43 �B +@?e"_"(-S$�?SH£?SMb$T$c- "(3f: )&'o$&/]?l$c'=-0"_)R+.1�3@?l$c'Wh83.<W7°<='=F63^M�3.-9M(<V3^+@?e"B H_-9"���$­1�3.+.- C "('��{3Z:�%(3E" "(-\?e"_)�:n3.1¯3LK_'*)�$&)­-01R:�%(3E" $&%(3ZM(1�-0U(<=3EP'*)�-9/b$&)4'=H_3g$43.'=1R?S1m3@?D-9IJ3LKbM�3.1O$4'*)43 �

± �

Page 14: )&3E)&)&'V-9 )l5 U /b$ …cs.joensuu.fi/pages/whamalai/expert/es1.pdf1..... ¡ '=" ? '=" ±

� ��� �� ���

B PQ3.H_'V+@?S<T)&-9I�$¢:�?S1m3°$4-k-6<*)�U�3 C /_" $c- 3EPQ3.1 C 3\H�/(1m'*" C �.���9� � ){536t C t¡ � � ! �   � $f?e"�I[-61�H � "('Wh�3.1�)&'o$¢7 �.���9� ªgI -01 ?S'=H_'=" C M_%87�)&'V+.'¤?S"_)Z'="H_'¤? C "(-9)4'*" C ?e"(H $c1�3@?@$4'*" C M]?l$c'=3E"�$4)�:,'W$&% '="�I[3.+f$4'V-9/_)qU(<V-k-kH H_'*)2�3@?e)43E)

B $&%(3Q¨p12)�$�)�7�)�$43EPQ)j:�3.1m3X)&'=PdM(<V3�12/(<=3L�¢U]?S)&3.H )27�)�$43EPQ)ZH_3�¨("(3.H U87%k/_P�?S" 3LKbM�3.1 $&)

B�� 3fh8-0<=/b$4'=-0"}'=" $&%(3^<¤?@$43 �6� � ){��� ?�7�3E)4'¤?e"}"(3f$¢:n-01�Fk)B '*" �.�6�0� � ),)43fh�3.14?A<G"(3f: ?eM_M(<V'=+@?l$c'=-0"_)g?e"(H;PX3f$&%(-kH�)B "(-.:�?SH£?�7�) � �g! �#$4-k-6<*) � � C 3E"(3.1c?S<^Pq?eF 3L��'W$2�#78-9/(1�)&3.<*IQ3LKbM�3.1 $°)�7�)2�$43EPQ)

B ��h�-6<*/b$c'=-9">�01�/(<=3L�¢U]?e)43.HZ)�7�)2$c3EPd)�� � "(+.3.1 $f?S'=" 12/(<V3E)�� � ?�7�3E)4'¤?e""(3f$¢:n-01�Fk){5("(3E/(1c?S<�"(3f$¢:n-01�Fk){5pH_3.+.'=)&'V-9";$c1�3.3E)l5�tVt=t

B ��3E"(H_3E"(+f7DI[1�-0P Pq?e"k/]?A<=<W7X+.-9"_)�$412/(+f$c3.H � ?SHQ%(-k+�PX-kH_3.<*) � $4-�� ����/0���1� �$�"�&���5�6�0�65�)27�)�$43EPQ)l5�:�%('=+c%\+@?S"\<=3@?S1�";$&%(3EPQ)43.<Wh�3E)

± �

Page 15: )&3E)&)&'V-9 )l5 U /b$ …cs.joensuu.fi/pages/whamalai/expert/es1.pdf1..... ¡ '=" ? '=" ±

���,� ��~� ��� �Y����_���£ �O� �

� z�x�� �$�~vp�[v � %� � vG|~z8��� � ������� B ?�PQ-�H_3.<®)�$41�/(+f$&/(1m3 � ?e"(H ?S)m)4' C "(3.H M]?l�14?SPQ3f$c3.1 h�?S<=/(3E) tk!4t 36t�'W$ '=)�?S"X'="_)2$f?e"(+.3,-9I�? C 'oh�3E"XPX-kH_3.<_)�$412/(+f$4/(1�36t

�n%(3 � vG|~z8�®yE�.xew� 6�lw�xez � '=) ?Y)2$c12/(+f$4/(1�3 :�%('V+c%QH_3f$c3.12PX'*"(3E) $4%(3 M]?l�14?SPQ3f$c3.12),1�3.¬k/('=1�3.H\I[-01�+.-9"_)�$41�/(+f$4'=" C ?DPX-kH_3.< t(� 7bM('=+@?S<V<W7 $&%(3^)�$41�/(+L�$&/(1m3�+.-0"_)&'=)2$4)T-9I�h ?A1�'�?eU(<=3E)R?e"(H�$&%(3.'V1�1�3.<¤?@$4'V-9"_)   36t C tb+.-0"(H_'W$4'V-9"]?A<GH_3L�M�3E"(H_3E"(+.'=3E)LªLt

�n%(3 � vG|~z8� �®�_xe��� z��{z�xey� ?S1m3 ?S)m)4' C "(3.H "�/_PQ3.1m'=+@?S<�h ?A<*/(3E)q<V'*F 3M(1�-0U]?eU('V<='W$c'=3E)R'="}� ?�7�3E)4'¤?S"\"(3f$�:�-612Fq-61 <='="(3@?S1T+.-k3 �Q+.'V3E"�$&)   ?SUN-{h�3��n5� 5���ª�'*"\<='="(3@?S1�1�3 C 1�3E)&)&'V-9">t

� v�|~z8���[����� � �_xS�p|~����� �;$&%(3 C 3E"(3.14?S<®PX-kH_3.<=<V'*" C M(1m'*"(+.'=M(<=3E)g/_)&3.H�t�n%(3iPQ-kH_3.<V<='=" C M]?A14?AH_' C P +.-0"_)&'=)2$®-9I�U]?S)&'V+ H_3�¨("('W$c'=-0"_){5A?S)m)&/_PdMb$c'=-0"_){5?e"(Hj$c3.+c%_"('=¬k/(3E)®I -01 +.-9"_)�$41�/(+f$4'*" C ?S"(HZ/_)&'=" C +.3.1O$L?S'=" F�'="(HD-AI]PQ-kH_3.<=){t

± �

Page 16: )&3E)&)&'V-9 )l5 U /b$ …cs.joensuu.fi/pages/whamalai/expert/es1.pdf1..... ¡ '=" ? '=" ±

� �[z�xe�_x" � % v � v �� z �~�ly

Bayesiannetworks

Decisiontrees

Linearregression

A

B

C

A

B

C

δ 1

C

A

B

A

B

C

A

C

B

Modellingparadigms

Modelfamily

Modelclass

A

B CP(B|A)P(B| A)

P(C|A)P(C| A)

P(A)

Model

....

..

2

AB C

δ

δ

B CA

3

¡ -kH_3.<=<V'*" C M]?S1c?SH_' C Pd)^<V'*F63�� ?f783E)&'�?e" "(3f$�:n-012F�){5GH_3.+.'*)4'=-0" $41m3.3E)­?S"(H<='="(3@?S1�1�3 C 1�3E)&)&'V-9"}H_3E)4+.1�'=U�3�$&%(3 C 3E"(3.1c?S<>PX-kH_3.<=<V'*" C M(1m'*"(+.'=M(<=3E),/_)43.H�t

� PX-kH_3.< Is?ePX'=<o7 '=)Q?;)43f$ -AI�PQ-kH_3.<)�$412/(+f$4/(1�3E) '=" $&%(3 C 'Wh83E" PX-kH��3.<=<V'*" C M]?A14?SH_' C P°t��nt C t6'*"q� ?f783E)&'�?e"Q"(3f$¢:n-01�Fk) PX-kH_3.<V<='*" C M]?A14?SH_' C P ?PX-kH_3.<�Is?SPQ'V<W7\+.-9"_)4'*)�$&)R-9IJH_'o`a3.1m3E"�$ C 14?SM_%\)�$412/(+f$4/(1�3E)�:,'W$&%\h�?S1�'�?eU(<V3"(-kH_3E)Y?e"(H +.-0"(H_'W$4'V-9"]?A<>H_3EM�3E"(H_3E"(+.'V3E)   3.H C 3E) ª�U�3f$¢:n3.3E";h�?S1m'¤?SU(<=3E)lt

� PX-kH_3.<(+.<�?e)&) '=)T?¯)43f$ -AI>PQ-�H_3.<*) :,'W$4%;?¯¨bK_3.Hd)�$41�/(+f$&/(1m3,U_/b$ H_'*`�3.1 �3E"�$gM]?S14?SPQ3f$c3.12) �� tG!#"}$&%(3D+@?e)43D-AI � ?f783E)&'�?e" "(3f$�:n-012F�)¯$&%(3ZM]?S1c?eP �3f$43.1�)­?A1�3�M(1�'V-01�M(1�-0U]?eU('=<V'W$c'=3E)�?e)&)4-k+.'¤?@$43.H}$4-�1�-k-A$¯"(-kH_3E)­?e"(H +.-9"(H_'W�$4'V-9"]?A<�M(1m-9U]?SU('=<='o$4'V3E)g?e)&)&-�+.'¤?l$c3.H $4-d"(-9"���1m-k-S$,"(-kH_3E)lt

� PX-kH_3.<J'*)j?e" 'W$43EP '=" ?�PQ-kH_3.<®+.<¤?S)m)¯:,'W$&% ?Q¨bK_3.H )2$c12/(+f$4/(1�3X?S"(H¨bK�3.H;M]?A14?ePX3f$43.1�){t

±

Page 17: )&3E)&)&'V-9 )l5 U /b$ …cs.joensuu.fi/pages/whamalai/expert/es1.pdf1..... ¡ '=" ? '=" ±

u�v ��yE�.xSw� 6�{��v�� �~x@v 6zkyly � �#xev�� ���~z ��� ���[z�� z����{vpx��*y � vp�$��� v��� �[z *���0t � "(H_3.12)�$L?S"(H_'*" C $&%(3 H_-9Pq?S'=">�.'="�$43.1Ohb'=3f: %k/_Pq?e"^3LKbM�3.1O$&)®?e"(H^1m3@?SH<='W$c3.14?@$&/(1�36t£� %]?l$g?S1m3­$4%(3­)�7�)�$43EP I�/_"(+f$c'=-0"]?S<='o$4'V3E) � � M�3.+.'¤?A<�/b$c'=<W�'W$4'V3E),-01 1m'*)&Fk)��

��t(�Y?@$L?DP�?S"]? C 3EPX3E"�$@��:�%]?@$�?S"(H;%(-.: $4-Q+.-0<V<=3.+f$ � «J1�3EM(1m-k+.3E)&)&'=" C ��bt(��3�¨("(3Y$&%(3gPX-kH_3.<G)2$c12/(+f$&/(1m3   )&3.3gU�3.<=-{:Yªft �®)&MN3.+.'�?S<V<W7;+@?S/_) ?A<�1m3L�<¤?l$c'=-0"_)¯?S1�3^'=PdM�-61 $L?S"�$&�

�(t(��3�¨("(3Y$&%(3gPX-kH_3.<GM]?S14?SPQ3f$c1�3E)l5�/_)&/]?S<V<W7 I[1�-0P H£?@$L?�t� t �3.1�'o¨p+@?@$4'V-9";?S"(HQ3fh�?A<*/]?l$c'=-0">�k� 3E)2$$&%(3�)27b)2$c3EP �b�T-.: )43E"_)&'o$4'Wh83R'W$'*)TI[-01T)mPq?S<V<�+ %]?e" C 3E)�'*" $4%(3­H£?l$f? �   BY)43E"_)4'W$4'ohb'W$�7 ?e"]?A<W7�)4'*)Lª

± �

Page 18: )&3E)&)&'V-9 )l5 U /b$ …cs.joensuu.fi/pages/whamalai/expert/es1.pdf1..... ¡ '=" ? '=" ±

� v£w�xq� ���~xev£� ��zky

EXPERT

MODEL STRUCTURE +MODEL PARAMETRES

MODEL=

DATA

DATA PATTERNS

STRUCTUREMODEL

STRUCTUREMODEL

MODEL STRUCTURE +MODEL PARAMETRES

MODEL=LEARNINGMACHINE

DATA

MODELPARAMETRES

MODELPARAMETRES

LEARNINGMACHINE

defines1)

3)

EXPERT

4)

DATA2)

DATAMINING interprets defines

4 APPROACHES FOR ES CONSTRUCTION

± D

Page 19: )&3E)&)&'V-9 )l5 U /b$ …cs.joensuu.fi/pages/whamalai/expert/es1.pdf1..... ¡ '=" ? '=" ±

�0t���14?AH_'W$4'V-9"]?A<�?eM_M(1�-8?S+c%>��$&%(3 3LKbM�3.1 $�H_3�¨("(3E)�U�-S$&%^$&%(3 PX-kH_3.<A)�$412/(+L�$&/(1�3j?S"(H�$&%(3gM]?A14?ePX3f$41m3E)B )4'*PQM(<=3j?e"(H I#?e)�$�PX3f$&%(-kHB 3LKbM�3.1 $,Fk"(-{:�)T$&%(3 C 3E"(3.14?A<�+@?S/_) ?A<='W$c'=3E)R¬8/('o$43¯:n3.<=<B "k/_PX3.1�'V+gPQ3@?S)m/(1m3E)   M]?S14?SPQ3f$c1�3E)Lª�?S1�3­%]?S1�H�$c-d3E)�$4'=P�?@$43

��t ¡ ?A+c%('*"(3 �a3@?S1�"('*" C �2?SM_M(1�-8?S+c%>� $&%(3q:�%(-0<=3 PX-kH_3.<�'*)QH_3�¨("(3.H U87¡ �}$43.+ %_"('=¬8/(3E)B )4'*PQM(<=3gPX-kH_3.<�)�$412/(+f$4/(1�3E)�+@?e" U�3g<=3@?A12"�$�Is?e)�$l5_U_/b$�<V3@?S12"('=" C ?C 1c?eM_%��¢)�$41�/(+f$&/(1�3'*) C 3E"(3.1c?S<V<W7 � «~�¢%]?A1�HgM(1�-0U(<=3EP �   '*"�$c14?S+f$f?eU(<V3I[-61T<�?S1 C 3�H£?@$L?�)43f$&)Lª

B )43fh�3.14?A<GPX-kH_3.<�)�$41�/(+f$&/(1m3E)�+@?S";UN3g3.¬8/]?A<=<o7�M(<¤?S/_)&'=U(<=3 �q1�3.+.- C �"(' �{'=" C +@?S/_) ?A<�1m3.<¤?@$4'=-0"_)m%('=M_)Y'*) h�3.1O7 %]?A1�H �

B ?S+.+E/(1c?l$c3 "k/_PQ3.1m'=+ M]?S1c?ePX3f$41�3E)l5�'*I�$&%(3 H£?l$f? )&3f$°:T?S) C -�-kH  <�?S1 C 3Z?S"(H 1�3EM(1m3E)&3E"�$f?l$c'Wh�3@ª

± �

Page 20: )&3E)&)&'V-9 )l5 U /b$ …cs.joensuu.fi/pages/whamalai/expert/es1.pdf1..... ¡ '=" ? '=" ±

�bt � -9PQM(1�-0PQ'=)&3q?SM_M(1�-�?A+c%>� �n%(3X3LKbM�3.1 $DH_3�¨("(3E)g$&%(3XPX-kH_3.< )�$41�/(+L�$&/(1�365£?e"(H $4%(3gM]?S1c?ePX3f$41�3E)�?A1�3^<=3@?A12"�$,I[1m-9P H£?l$f?B +.-9PZU('="(3E)G$4%(3i3LKbM�3.1 $ � )~Fk"(-{:�<V3.H C 3-9" C 3E"(3.14?S<�+@?S/_) ?A<='W$c'=3E) ?S"(H+.-9PQM_/b$L?@$4'V-9"]?S<>PX3@?e"_)TI[-01�H_3�¨("('*" C M]?S1c?ePX3f$41�3E)

B $&%(3^H£?@$L?Q?e"(H 3LKbM�3.1O$ � )�Fk"(-{:�<V3.H C 3j+@?e" U�3g+.-9"�$c14?S1O7 ��(t_! $c3.14?@$4'Wh83�?eM_M(1m-�?S+ %   � 3.36���,3E)&+.1m'*Mb$4'oh�3�?S"(HdM(1m3.H_'=+f$c'Wh�3�PX-kH_3.<V<='*" CU�7 � �,ªf�]�lª ��?l$f?­PQ'="('*" C 1�3fh�3@?A<*)nM]?@$�$c3.12"_)n'*"�$&%(3RH£?@$L?�t �Y"q3LKk�MN3.1O$�H_3�¨("(3E) $4%(3�PX-kH_3.<N)�$41�/(+f$&/(1�3j?A+.+.-01mH_'*" C $c-Z$4%(3E)&3¯M]?l$m$43.1�"_){t�0ª � %(3gPQ-�H_3.<aM]?S1c?ePX3f$41m3E)Y?A1�3­<V3@?S1�"�$�I 1�-9P H£?l$f?�tB H£?l$f?d?S"(H;PQ-�H_3.<a)�$412/(+f$4/(1�3�?A1�3^"(-{: +.-9"_)4'*)�$43E"�$B +@?e" U�3j?SM_M(<='=3.H�$c- "(3f: ?e"(H;M�-k-61�<W7;Fk"(-{:�"°H_-0P�?A'*"_)

� �py�� � %]?@$g-A$&%(3.1g?AH�h�?e"�$f? C 3E)�?S"(H H_'*)L?SH�h�?e"8$L? C 3E)­H_-X78-9/ '*"8h�3E"�$'*"\3@?A+c%\-AI $&%(3j?SM_M(1�-�?A+c%(3E)��

- +

Page 21: )&3E)&)&'V-9 )l5 U /b$ …cs.joensuu.fi/pages/whamalai/expert/es1.pdf1..... ¡ '=" ? '=" ±

� z�� �_x���y

B ��'=F63.<V'*%(-k-kH �� '=PdM�-01O$L?S"(+.3   /b$4'=<V'W$�7(ªL�^36t C tR$&%(3 PQ-0)2$ M(1�-0U]?eU(<V3PQ3.H_'V+@?S<NH_'¤? C "(-9)4'*)�'*)l� � � %(3.1�3g'*) "(-S$&%('=" C :�1m-9" C '="�78-9/>5k78-9/D¦ /_)2$%]?fh83¯?g+.-6<=H � 58U_/b$$4%(3Y�A1�H�M(1�-9U]?SU(<=3   "(-S$n1�3EM�-61 $43.H£ª H_'�? C "(-0)&'=)n'*)<*/_" C +@?S"(+.3.1Et

B ��-0"���$�$c3E)2$j:�'o$&% $&%(3Q)L?ePX3XH£?l$L?;)&3f$�7�-9/ %]?�h�3X/_)43.H I[-01�PQ-�H_3.<+.-9"_)�$412/(+f$c'=-0" �D?e"�7ZPQ-kH_3.<8:�'V<=<�$&%(3E"�:n-01�FjM�3.12I[3.+f$4<o7 � � H_'=)2$c'*"(+f$$414?A'*"('=" C ?S"(H�$43E)�$�)43f$&)

B !s" 3fh83.1 7 PQ-kH_3.<V<='=" C M]?A14?AH_' C P $4%(3.1�3�'=)Z)&-0PQ3 � � � # � $&%(3f7 )&/('W$UN3f$m$43.1jI[-61j)4-9PX3�M(1m-9U(<=3EPQ)�$&%]?S" -A$&%(3.12)lti� 3.+.-9PX3�+.-0"_)&+.'V-9/_) -9I$&%(3gU('¤?S)R?S"(H )43.<=3.+f$ $4%(3gU�3E)2$,-9"(3 �

-s±