simulation on the degas array - gsi indico (indico) · 28 degas clusters, consist of 84 ge...

40
GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 1/64 Simulation on the DEGAS array Gammaspektroskopie GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH Guang-Shun LI & Cesar Lizarazo NUSPIN 2017 Workshop

Upload: others

Post on 31-Aug-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 1/64

Simulation on the DEGAS array

GammaspektroskopieGSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH

Guang-Shun LI &Cesar Lizarazo

NUSPIN 2017 Workshop

Page 2: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 2/64

Outline

Research motivation1

Simulation on the DEGAS3

Summary4

Examining the simulation framework2

Page 3: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 3/64

HISPEC/DESPEC program at the NUSTAR project

HISPEC: High-resolution In-flight SPECtroscopyDESPEC: DEcay SPECtroscopy

Page 4: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 4/64

DESPEC: DEcay SPECtroscopy

DESPEC Germanium Array Spectrometer (DEGAS)

RIB from Super-FRS

(picture from DESEPC collaboration)

Page 5: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 5/64

DESPEC: DEcay SPECtroscopy

Requirements:DESPEC Germanium Array Spectrometer (DEGAS)

highhigh highRIB from Super-FRS

(picture from DESEPC collaboration)

Page 6: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 6/64

DESPEC: DEcay SPECtroscopy

Requirements:DESPEC Germanium Array Spectrometer (DEGAS)

highhigh high

RISING configuration

Page 7: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 7/64

DESPEC: DEcay SPECtroscopy

DEGAS configuration candidates

Requirements:DESPEC Germanium Array Spectrometer (DEGAS)

highhigh high

RISING configuration

Page 8: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 8/64

DESPEC: DEcay SPECtroscopy

DEGAS configuration candidates

Requirements:DESPEC Germanium Array Spectrometer (DEGAS)

highhigh high

DEGAS I configurationRISING configuration

Page 9: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 9/64

HPGe detector and BGO shields

Geometry in Geant4

Source: 60Co in front of HPGe

Simulation on the spectra of HPGe with BGO shields

Page 10: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 11/64

BGO as passive shield

BGO as active shield

Simulation

Experiment

Simulation on the spectra of HPGe with BGO shields

Page 11: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 12/64

Simulation on Eruoball Cluster and BGO Back-catcher

EUROBALL Cluster and BGO Back-catcher

Geometry in Geant4

Source: 137Cs top and bottom

Page 12: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 13/64

a

b

c

Energy distribution of full energy sharing events

137Cs

Smaller scattering angle at Geleads to smaller energy deposition in Ge and larger energy depostion in BGO

θ

Page 13: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 14/64

137Cs

θ

Energy distribution of events in coincidence

Larger scattering angle at Ge leads to larger energy deposition in Ge and smaller energy depostion in BGO

a

b

Page 14: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 15/64

Clover detetor Geometry in Geant4

Source: 137Cs in front of the detector

Simulation on the Clover detector

Page 15: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 17/64

Percentage of two-elements energy sharing event

1 2 4 1

34 3

332

1 14 2

4

2

Source: 137Cs in front of the detector(CAD file)

Page 16: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 18/64

Absolute efficiency measurement

60Co, 152Eu, and 133Ba sources Pb shield

One neutron transfer reaction in the 9Be+89Y systemG. S. Li et al. EPJ WoC 86, 00024 (2015)

Geometry in the simulation

Page 17: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 19/64

Comparison of the absolute efficiency

10% insensitive volume of cone shape is assumed in the simulation

Page 18: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 20/64

Simulation on the RISING configuration

15 EUROBALL Clusters, consist of 105 Ge crystals, in three angular rings, 22 cm to the center

Page 19: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 21/64

Simulation on the DEGAS I configuration

26 DEGAS clusters, consist of 78 Ge crystals, distance from the center: 12cm(back), 12cm(top and bottom), 22cm(left and right)

Mechanical lay-out of the DEGAS detector (CAD design file)10% insensitive volume of at back of Ge is assumed

Page 20: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 22/64

28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation detector

Simulation on the DEGAS II configuration

Mechanical lay-out of the DEGAS detector (CAD design file)10% insensitive volume of at back of Ge is assumed

Page 21: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 23/64

8 cm Pb-Wall assumed for all the three configurations

Pb wall

Page 22: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 25/64

Gamma source considered

γ1γ2

γ3

γ…… …

Gamma ray emitted from center of 8cm x 24 cm plate (AIDA), with intensity of Gaussian distribution

Non-cascade gamma ray

Page 23: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 26/64

Red ones

Magenta ones

Blue onesYellow ones

Different position, different efficiency

Efficiency of each DEGAS cluster

Page 24: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 27/64

Efficiency of each DEGAS cluster

Red ones

Magenta ones

Blue onesYellow ones

Light blue ones

Different position, different efficiency

Page 25: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 30/64

Comparison of the efficiency

The efficiencies are deduced from Ge crystals without add-back between them

Page 26: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 31/64

Gamma source considered

γ1γ2

γ3

γ…… …

Gamma ray emitted from center of 8cm x 24 cm plate (AIDA), with intensity of Gaussian distribution

γ1

γ2

γ3

γ6

… …

Non-cascade gamma ray

cascade

Page 27: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 32/64

Add-back analysis

Without add-backInter-cluster add-back

Page 28: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 35/64

Add-back analysis

Without add-backInter-cluster add-back

More adding,more full energyevents

Less adding,less summingevents

Page 29: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 36/64

Interactions in the DEGAS II configuration

122 keV gamma ray

two crystals

1408 keV gamma ray

Page 30: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 37/64

Interactions in the DEGAS II configuration

Two crystals shared full-energy events, 70% happenbetween neighbors

122 keV gamma ray

two crystals

1408 keV gamma ray

Page 31: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 38/64

Interactions in the DEGAS II configuration

Two crystals shared full-energy events, 70% happenbetween neighbors

122 keV gamma ray

two crystals

1408 keV gamma ray

Try to avoid using lower energy gamma ray to add back, toreduce the risk of “false” gamma-ray summing

Page 32: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 40/64

Add-back factor from the selected window

γ1 – γ2 for 779 keV

γ1 γ2-γ1 γ2+

< 0.6

γ1 γ2-γ1 γ2+

< 0.2

Inter-cluster neighbors :

cross-cluster neighbors :

γ1 – γ2 for 1408 keVWindow must be chosen according to physical request !!!

window

window

Page 33: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 41/64

γ1 – γ2 for 779 keV

γ1 γ2-γ1 γ2+

< 0.8

γ1 γ2-γ1 γ2+

< 0.2

Inter-cluster neighbors :

cross-cluster neighbors :

γ1 – γ2 for 1408 keVWindow must be chosen according to physical request !!!

Add-back factor from the selected window

window

window

Page 34: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 42/64

Possibility of wrong crystal assignment in add-back

Percentage of larger energy deposition Ge crystal carrying earlierγ-ray interaction time in the two crystals energy sharing events

25% wrong assignment

Page 35: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 45/64

Comparison of the background suppression

Plus

AIDA Source Background Source

Page 36: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 46/64

Comparison of the background suppression

The DEGAS II configuration give the best P/T ratio

Plus

AIDA Source Background Source

Page 37: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 47/64

Future work on simulation—DEGAS I as example

Additional scintillators and passive shielding elements in the gaps of the DEGAS configuration, like the ones in the picture

(CAD file) (CAD file)

Page 38: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 48/64

Summary

Good agreement between simulation and experiment results…spectra, scattering and efficiency

The DEGAS II configuration, 28 clusters in a more compact box goemtry gives the largest efficiency and best background suppression

Add-back using inter-cluster and corss-cluster neighboring crystals give improved efficiency

Improvement is expected using addtinal scintillators and passive shielding elements in the gaps

Page 39: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 49/64

Acknowledgement

M. L Liu, X. H. Zhou ……IMP, Lanzhou

J. Gerl, I. Kojouharov , H. Schaffner, M. Górska, S. Saha… … GSI, Darmstadt

DEGAS workgroup ……

Page 40: Simulation on the DEGAS array - GSI Indico (Indico) · 28 DEGAS clusters, consist of 84 Ge crystals, a space with cross section of 26 cm × 11 cm inside is reserved for the implantation

GSI Helmholtzzentrum für Schwerionenforschung GmbH 50/64

Thank you for your attention!