Groupe de Recherche International coordination action of the International Network of Territorial Intelligence

Jean-Jacques GIRARDOT Université de Franche-Comté, Besançon, France

Maison des Sciences de l’homme et de l’Environnement, USR 3124 CNRS Laboratoire ThéMA Théoriser et Modéliser pour Aménager, UMR 6049 CNRS

Coordinateur du GDRI caINTI

PECS, Hungary, 2011, June 2-4

2

GDRI caINTI / new-LiFE The GDRI caINTI, International Research Group "coordination action of the International Network of Territorial Intelligence", is a scientific coordination network of the French National Centre for Scientific Research, which gathers 7 participants of five countries. It began on 1 January 2011 for a term of four years, until December 2014. Work plan is draft now. It aims at strengthening the integration of European research in territorial intelligence in order to give it an international dimension.

new-LiFE “A development driven by well being for a successful socio-ecological transition in Europe” is a large scale project for FP7 that meets 39 participants of 17 countries. Response will occur in July. If it is positive we will have to draft work plan before end of october.

3

4

GDRI caINTI Participants The GDRI caINTI gathers 7 research teams, 5 countries

•  MSHE, USR 3124 Maison des Sciences de l’Homme et de l’Environnement CNRS / UFC / UTBM, France, mshe.univ-fcomte.fr

•  ThéMA, UMR 6049 Théoriser et Modéliser pour Aménager, CNRS / UFC / UB, France, thema.univ-fcomte.fr

•  ESO, UMR 6590 Espaces et Sociétés, CNRS / URENNES2, France, eso.cnrs.fr

•  OLE, Observatorio Local de Empleo, UHU, Spain, www.ole.uhu.es

•  SEGEFA, Service d'Étude en Géographie Économique Fondamentale et Appliquée, ULG / FNRS, Belgique, www.segefa.be

•  DISUFF, Dipartimento di Scienze Umane, Filosofiche e della Formazione, University of Salerno (UNISA), Italie, www.unisa.it

•  TAG, Territorio Actores Gobernanza, UNLP / CONICET, Argentine, www.equipotag.blogspot.com

5

Territorial engineering In knowledge-based society, information and communication technology and knowledge management allow us to share information and collaborate to exploit it in order to develop relevant cooperative projects and to coordinate tasks in an efficient cooperation and with a positive impact.

With project management, evaluation, foresight, geographic information systems, methods of data analysis and spatial analysis tools, they constitute the basis for territorial engineering, of which Catalyse, a method in use in Europe since 1989, is an example.

6

Territorial intelligence Territorial intelligence suggests action-research that has two mutually-enriching objectives, a scientific and a practical one.

•  It aims to be the polydisciplinary field of universal knowledge on the structures and dynamics of territories in a sustainable development perspective.

•  It offers stakeholder partnerships a cognitive process and tools towards the co-construction of a collective intelligence for, with and by the territorial community, which will enable this community to develop its territory in a sustainable manner.

7

ENTI Since 2002, territorial intelligence has been at the centre of the fundamental and applied reflections of the European Network of Territorial Intelligence, ENTI, which began its expansion and integration with the European project caENTI (coordination action of the ENTI) supported by the European Union FP6 from March 2006 to February 2009.

8

new-LiFE Work Packages WP1 [well-being] Towards a new culture of development driven by well-being, lead by Cyril MASSELOT, CNRS-MSHE (France) WP2 [territories] Territorial dimensions of the combination of development objectives, lead by Frances FAHY, NUIG (Ireland) WP3   [observation] The territorial observation catalyst for collective intelligence of territories, lead by Guénaël DEVILLET, ULG (Belgique)  WP4   [innovation] Integrated innovation and coordination of research, innovation and industrial policies, lead by Aleksandra GAWEŁ, UEP (Polska) WP5 [reforms] Structural reforms to ensure a minimum welfare for everyone and improve the well-being of each and all, lead by Timo TOIKKO, SeaMK (Finland) WP6 [governance] Governance initiatives to ensure social cohesion, lead by Blanca MIEDES, Universidad de Huelva (España) WP7 [convergence]- Integration of research results with stakeholders’ expectations, lead by Jean-Jacques GIRARDOT, CNRS-MSHE (France)  WP8   [dissemination] Stakeholder liaison, exploitation and dissemination, lead by François SILVA, ESCEM (France) WP9 [management] – Project management, lead by Jean-Jacques GIRARDOT, MSHE CNRS-MSHE (France)

9

WP1 [well-being] WP1 [well-being] Towards a new culture of development driven by well-being, lead by Cyril MASSELOT, CNRS-MSHE (France) WP1A <well-being> Language and uses of "well being", animated by Éric BOUTIN, CNRS-ISCC (France) WP1B <culture> Cultural contexts of socio-ecological transition, animated by Tulia SACCHERI, UNISA (Italy)

WP1Ba <<identity>>, animated by Sophie LACOUR, UPEMLV (France) WP1Bb <<gift>>, animated by O. GALIBERT, UB (France)

WP1C <temporality> New temporalities of well being, animated by Sophie LACOUR, UPEMLV (France) WP1D <learning> Learning and sustainable development: education for and by sustainable development, and training for improve practices in some key jobs, animated by Christian BOURRET, UPEMLV (France)

WP1Da <<education>> Education for and by sustainable developement –Animated by Jean-Luc FAUGUET, Université de Provence (France) WP1Db <<training>> Training in sustainable developement – animated by Antonio IANNACONE, UNISA

WP1R  <report> Scientific report, animated by Cyril MASSELOT, CNRS-MSHE (France)

10

WP2 [territories] WP2 [territories] Territorial dimensions of the combination of development objectives, lead by Frances FAHY, NUIG (Ireland) WP2A <territory> Understanding territories: linking communities and space, animated by  Horacio BOZZANO, UNLP (Argentina)

WP2B <systems> Analysis of territorial multi-sectorial interactions: approaches and theoretical, animated by Serge SCHMITZ, ULG (Belgique) 

WP2C <initiatives> Main learning of regional and local government sustainability strategies and initiatives in the International and European arena, animated by Csila FILO, PTE (Hungary)

WP2D <agenda> Survey on advance and lacks of European Territorial Agenda in favoring global approach and multilevel governance, animated by Michael FLINTER,UNIBR (Germany)

WP2R Report “Strengthening local capacities for socio-ecological transition”, animated by Frances FAHY, NUIG (Ireland)

11

WP3 [Observation] WP3 [Observation] The territorial observation catalyst for collective intelligence of territories, lead by Guénaël DEVILLET, ULG (Belgique) WP3A <combination> From theoretical models of combined development objectives to indicators, animated by Philippe WOLOSZYN, CNRS-ESO (France) WP3B <methods> Fundamental methods and generic tools for territory analysis, animated by Serge ORMAUX, CNRS-MSHE (France) WP3C <indicators> Sustainable development indicators for local level, animated by Claire HAGGETT, EDINBURGH (United Kingdom). WP3D <Modelling> Modelling territorial information systems accessible to sustainable development actors, animated by Sylvie DAMY, CNRS-MSHE

WP3Da << secondary indicators >>, animated by Celia SANCHEZ, University of Huelva, Spain WP3Db << local observation tools >>, animated by Remi THOMAS, CNRS-MSHE

WP3E <web-mapping> Design and implementation of a global web mapping, animated by Peter PEHANI, ZRC SAZU (Slovenia) WP3R <report> Strengthening local capacities for socio-ecological transition, animated by Guénaël DEVILLET, ULG (Belgique).

12

WP4 [Innovation] WP4 [Innovation] Integrated innovation and coordination of research, innovation and industrial policies, lead by Aleksandra GAWEŁ, UEP (Polska) WP4A <integration> Connecting society, research, business and policy in creation and introduction of innovations, animated by Rafael CACERES, USE (Spain) WP4B <coopetition> Coopetition as market orientation in innovation-driven and knowledge-based society – animated by Marek REKOWSKI, UEP (Poland) WP4C <proposals> Proposals from positive experiences of social and ecological innovation, animated by Jean-Guy HENCKEL, COCAGNE (France).

WP4Ca <<experiences>> Inventory of existing innovative experiences, animated by Évelyne BRUNAU, MLPE (France)

WP4D <jobs> innovative employment and job prospective – humanistic workplace for creativity and personal development of working people – animated by Eddie SOULIER, CRNS-UTT (France)

WP4Da <<new organization of working>>, animated by Géraldine de La RUPELLE, ESCEM (France) WP4Db <<job prospective>>, animated by Aline SCOUARNEC, ESSEC (France) WP4Dc << Digital socialization >>, animated by O. GALIBERT, UB (France) WP4De <<RSE>>

WP4R <report> Synthetic Report, animated by Alexandra GAWEL, UEP (Poland)

13

WP5 [reforms] WP5 [reforms] Structural reforms to ensure a minimum welfare for everyone and improve the well-being of each and all, lead by Timo TOIKKO, SeaMK (Finland) WP5A <structures> Economic growth versus social welfare structures, animated Marju MEDAR. TUPC, Estonia

WP5B <reforming> Structural reforms at maintaining and expanding welfare society at European and territorial level, animated by Anne GREEN, WARWICK (United Kingdom)

WP5C <floor> Universal social protection floor, animated by Manuela Fernandez, UHU, Spain

WP5D <solutions> Bridging science, business, society and politics for creating better well-being – animated by Maciej PIETRZYKOVSKY, UEP

WP5D <report> animated by Timo TOIKKO, SeaMK (Finland)

14

WP6 [Governance] WP6 [Governance] Governance initiatives to ensure social cohesion, lead by Blanca MIEDES, Universidad de Huelva (España) WP6A <coordination> European governance and evaluation as orientation of decision making processes, animated by Päivi RINNE,SeAMK Finland WP6B <cooperation> Partnerships and smart evaluation as drivers of a cooperative governance for a new path of development, animated by Sergei SHUBIN,ABDN United Kingdom

WP6Ba <<widening>> How politics can help ecological and social innovation?, animated by Julia FERNÁNDEZ QUINTANILLA, ACCEM (Spain)

WP6C < participation > From participatory processes to political decision making process in a multi-scale context: analysis and proposals, animated by Guillaume FABUREL, AMENITES (France). WP6D <gender> Integrating the gender dimension in the new path of development, animated by Dolores REDONDO TORONJO, Universidad de Huelva (Espana) WP6E <cohesion> Social Cohesion and resilience of most disfavoured territories and groups. UBA Runamia, animated by Mihai PASCARU, UAB (Romania) WP6R <agenda> Political Agenda for a new European wellbeing-based path of development, animated by Blanca MIEDES, UHU (Spain)

15

WP7 [Convergence] WP7 [Convergence]- Integration of research results with stakeholders’ expectations, lead by Jean-Jacques GIRARDOT, CNRS-MSHE (France)

Scientific committee, chaired by Blanca MIEDES Advisory Board

16

WP8 [Dissemination] WP8 [Dissemination] Stakeholder liaison, exploitation and dissemination, lead by François SILVA, ESCEM (France) WP8A <press> press relation, animated by François SILVA, ESCEM (France) WP8B <panel> Panel of external advisers (experts, stakeholders and politics), animated by Maria-José ASENSIO, UHU (Spain)

WP8Ba <<network>> Internal network of national animators – Teresa ACEYTUNO WP8C <Impact> Impact measurement, animated by Pascal ECHARDOUR,ESCEM France WP8D. <portal> Portal of territorial intelligence, animated by Cyril MASSELOT, Université de Franche-Comté, France

WP8Da <<Internet>> territorial intelligence and project documents, WP8Dc <<Workspaces>> intranet workspaces, internal communication, animated by Peter ACS, PTE, Hungary WP8Dd <<community>> Downloads of territorial intelligence tools and guidelines, animated by Remi THOMAS, CNRS-MSHE, France

WP8E <SciPub> scientific publication, animated by Philippe DUMAS, CNRS-ISCC, (France) WP8F <conference> Annual international conference of territorial intelligence and organisation of project meetings, animated by Allyson MAREK, ULG (Belgium) WP8G <mofti> On-line education material for a European Master of Territorial Intelligence, animated by Csilla FILO, PTE, Hungary

17

WP9 [management] WP9 [management] – Project management, lead by Jean-Jacques GIRARDOT, MSHE CNRS-MSHE (France) WP9A <administrative> Project administrative coordination, animated by Isabelle MOURET, CNRS-MSHE (France), Financial and scientific reporting reporting animated by CNRS-DR6.

WP9B <quality> Research quality assessment, animated by Daniel ELHERS, UDE (Germany)

WP9C <outcome> Outcome mapping, animated by Pascal ECHARDOUR ESCEM (France)

General assembly (participant representatives)

Executive committee

Board (participant and team representatives + WP leaders + tasks animators)

Plenary assembly (all researchers)

18

GDRI caINTI activities To strengthen the integration of territorial intelligence research and to give it an international dimension, the participant teams of the GDRI caINTI will establish :

•  A standing virtual cooperation network using the portal www.territorial-intelligence.eu

•  A concerted cooperation project

•  A periodic scientific meetings hosting the debate on scientific results and prospects, publicize them and updating the cooperation project.

19

GDRI caINTI coordination project 4 research axis and 2 cross cutting topics: T. [territories] Territories linking places and communities in the transition to sustainable development (lead by S. ORMAUX, ThéMA, France)

I.   [intelligence] Information, communication, knowledge in an alternative culture of development guided by any- and everybody well-being (lead by C. MASSELOT, MSHE, France)

G. [governance] Governance agenda organizing structural reforms and initiatives for the socio-ecological transition (lead by B. MIEDES, OLE, Spain)

O.   [observation] Models and observation systems for sustainable development of territories (lead by G. DEVILLET, SEGEFA, ULG, Belgium)

V.   [vulnerability] Vulnerability of territories and vulnerable populations (lead by P. WOLOSZYN, ESO, France)

G. [gender] Gender and sustainable development of territories (lead by D. REDONDO, OLE, Spain)

20

[territories] T. [territories] Territories linking places and communities in the transition to sustainable development (lead by S. ORMAUX, ThéMA) This axis will continue the state of art concerning the combination of economic, social, environmental and cultural objectives of sustainable development, on: • Analysis of the territorial intelligence concept and practises <TO ontology>, H BOZZANO, TAG, Argentina (= WP2A <territory> H. BOZZANO, UNLP, WP1A <well-being>” E. BOUTIN, CNRS-ISCC) • The scientific fundamental methods and generic tools of territories analysis <TM methods>, S. SCHMITZ, SEGEFA, Belgium (=WP3B   <methods> S. ORMAUX, CNRS) • Territorial development systems such as clusters, science and industrial parks, development partnership underlying current development in a bottom-up dynamic <TS systems>, F. FAHY, NIU, Eire (= WP2 [systems]) Axis [territories] will strengthen the scientific dimension of territorial intelligence, a concept responding to new challenges arising from the exacerbation of tensions between the dimensions of development in the global context of the emerging knowledge-based society in very unevenly developed territories. It will give suggestions for a structural reforms for ecological and social transition crossed with global research road map.

21

[intelligence] I.   [intelligence] Information, communication, knowledge in an alternative culture of development guided by well-being (lead by C. MASSELOT, MSHE) This axis will synthesize research concerned with the changing modes and patterns of production and consumption and with the mobilization of social capital to build alternative development paths:

•  The process of information and communication in the context of cooperation and participation <IC info-com E. BOUTIN I3M> (= WP3A <info-com>)

•  The new culture of sustainable development and cultural contexts of the socio-ecological transition <IK culture> T. SACCHIERI DISUFF (= WP 1B <culture>)

•  The education for and by sustainable development, training and learning professional practice and citizenship behavior <IE education> C. BOURRET UPEMLV (= WP1C <éducation>)

It will lay the foundations for a development model driven by any- and everybody well-being. It will suggest structural reforms and governance initiatives for changing behavior through establishing the referent research activities.

22

[governance] G.  [governance] Governance agenda organizing structural reforms and initiatives for the socio-ecological transition (lead by B. MIEDES, OLE, Spain) This axis will continue to enable the discussions and analysis of practices that promote democratic and participatory territorial governance, oriented towards the resolution of the tensions, which affect the sustainable development of territories. It will pay particular attention to the areas of employment and innovation.

•  It will establish an agenda of governance for socio-ecological transition on:<3GA agenda> M. FLINTNER UNIBR (=WP2D <agenda>)

•  Structural reforms that help maintain and develop the welfare society to improve the any- and everybody well being. <GR reforms> T. TOIKKO SEAMK> (=WP5 [reforms] )

•  Governance initiatives in coordination and concertation, cooperation and participation especially in the areas of employment and innovation <GI initiatives> C. FILO PTE (=WP2C <initiatives>, =WP6A <coordination>, WP6B <cooperation> WP4B <coopetition>, WP6C < participation >, =WP4D <jobs>, WP4A <integration>, WP4C <proposals>)

23

[observation] O.   [observation] Models and observation systems for sustainable development of territories (lead by G. DEVILLET, SEGEFA, Belgium) This axis will compare models of territorial observation and specifications for observation integrated tools for territories in the context of information transparency and tools accessibility for territorial community.

•  It will identify specific indicators relevant to sustainable development (particularly in the social, environmental and cultural areas where they need to be adapted) and available at the local level (which constitutes mainly a major difficulty) in agreement with theoretical models of combined development objectives, and with following international standards <OI indicators> C. HAGGETT, EDINBURGH (= WP3A <combination>, WP3C <indicators>)

•  It will continue modelling territorial observation systems available for local actors and citizens <OM modelling> S. DAMY, MSHE (= WP3D <modelling>)

•  It will establish concrete specifications for a web mapping system of indicators of sustainable development at an international level for data integration at different scales <OW web-mapping> P. PEHANI SRC SAZU (= WP3E. <web mapping>)

•  Axis [observation] will provide specifications for forecasting, assessment, and governance tools and sustainable development actions monitoring.

24

[vulnerability] V.   [vulnerability] Vulnerability of territories and populations vulnerable (lead by P. WOLOSZYN, ESO) This transversal theme will offer adaptative strategies to increase the resilience of populations and the most vulnerable territories.

•  It will explore how regional vulnerabilities can be a lever for the consideration of global issues into local action <VI>

•  It will make proposals for the establishment of a minimal system of social protection <VI floor> M. FERNANDEZ OLE > (= WP5C <floor> )

•  It will analyze the convergence of adaptative actions to strengthen the resilience of the territories and most disadvantaged groups as parts of a coherent strategy for social cohesion, with both introducing political priorities for local action and adapt public action goals to the socio-ecological new i-deal. <VG cohesion> M. PASCARU UAB (= WP6E <cohesion> M. PASCARU UAB)

•  It will suggest specific indicators to improve the visibility of the vulnerability of the resilience of territories and populations. Thus, amenities access inequalities should be mapped through «  ambiantope  » environmental enhanced cognitive modelling. <VO>

[gender] [gender]

25

[gender] G. [gender] Gender and sustainable development of territories (lead by D. REDONDO, OLE) This transversal theme will introduce the view of gender in all areas of the project.

•  It will study the implications of the gender concept in the ontology of territorial intelligence <GT>

•  It will analyze the integration of gender dimension in defining new modes of development and the implications of inequality between men and women in the new culture of development <GI>

•  It will assess the ability of participatory methods to reduce gender imbalance <GG>

•  It will define gender equality indicators <GO>

26

Dissemination tasks: •  <DP portal> Portal of territorial intelligence C. MASSELOT MSHE (=WP8D

<portal>) •  <<MPA animation>> Internal network of national animators T. ACEYTUNO OLE, •  <<MPW workspaces>> intranet workspaces, internal communication, P ACS, PTE •  <<community>> Downloads of territorial intelligence tools and guidelines R THOMAS,

MSHE) •  <DC Conference> A. MAREK SEGEFA (=WP8F <conference>

•  <<DCI Internet conference>> C. BARRIONUEVO TAG •  <DM mofti> On-line education material for a European Master of Territorial

Intelligence, C. FILO PTE) (=WP8Db <mofti>) •  <DJ jofti> P. DUMAS I3M> Journal of Territorial •  <DP panel> Panel of experts, stakeholders and policy makers M-J. ASENSIO

OLE (= WP8B <panel>) •  <DB people> Press relation François SILVA, ESCEM

27

[management Management task

•  <MD day-to-day> I. MOURET MSHE

•  <MQ quality> Research quality assessment D. ELHERS UNIDUE (= WP9B <quality>)

•  <MO outcome> Impact measurement P. ECHARDOUR ESCEM (= WP8C <Impact>)

28

[outcome mapping]

29

[outcome mapping]

شكرا الهتمامكم Merci pour votre attention

Thank you for your attention Gracias por su atención

Vă mulţumesc pentru atenţie Köszönöm a figyelmet 謝謝您的關注

Grazie per la vostra attenzione Vielen Dank für Ihre Aufmerksamkeit

Kiitos huomiota Σας ευχαριστώ για την προσοχή σας

Dziękuję za uwagę Спасибо за Ваше внимание

İlginiz için teşekkürler