multi-objective optimisation of turbomachinery blades using tabu search timoleon kipourosi

14

Upload: others

Post on 11-Feb-2022

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Multi-objective Optimisation of Turbomachinery Blades Using Tabu Search Timoleon Kipourosi

� ������������ �������������������������� �!�"���#$&%(')�+*,�-����.�0/���#+��*�123���.4�����56�7��#+89':�;���$<=���.*"�0/

>@?BADCFEBG�CFH+IJ?BKCMLONPCRQ�SUTWVYXFHO?BG�E[ZRX\G�]M]F?^S_TO`�?aEBE�V!XUbcG_QPd\Te!G�CFfhg"X\NjikQ�S�TOXFHWl+mnX\Njio XUpq?BEaEsr

tDu�vMw_xyvRzjzj{|xyvRwJ}@zj~�x�w�v��7z�v���{|z_�R}@z��q��{��|�.z�v�������u�vMw_xyvRz�zP{|x�vMwM�R��vRxy�UzP{|~�xy���&���������!�M{|x��Fw_z_������!�M{|x��Fw_z����"�&���7���q�cvRx��|z��&��x�vMwU�F�_�

� �7�_�.�M�M�����|xy��vq������y�Rx���}c�MvR���.xy �~,¡���k��{����|��{����M}@z��R��{��|�.z�v��"���[u�vMw_xyvRzjzj{|xyvRwM�R��vMx��_zj{|~�x��¢���� �����!�F{|x��Mw_z��k�����!�M{|x��Fw_z����"�����7���q�cvRx��|z��;��xyvRwU�F�_�

£ �7�_�.�M�M�����|xy��vq���¤czP{|�\�F�Fvq���.x� �}@z�~�xyw_v�¥c{|���R�W�R}@zj�q��{��|�.zjv\�����[¤0zj{|�_~��R�� �zY¦F jx�zjvR �z�~��� {���vF§qz����¨�cvRxy�Uzj{|~�x��¢���R� {���vM§qzj�a�D©¨��ªU«.¬_¤c¡��F��vMx��|z�����xyvRw_�M���

­;®°¯�±�²�³q´�±_µ.¶�· x�~¸�q���kzP{[�Mz�~� P{|x��kzj~¸� · z7���R�M�yx� ����|xy�_vY���R�0vMzj¹��!�M���|xyº»���F¼¢z� j�|xy�Uzxyv��|z�w�{����|z��½�|�M{|�k���;��  · xyvRzP{��½�M�a���Mz;�Fz�~�xyw_vn�_�F�|x��.xy~|���|x���v�~¾�F~¾�|z��D¿ ¶�· z;~¾�M~¾º�|z��À ��_�Y�RxyvRzj~D��vÁzjÂFxy~¾�|xyvRwÃw_z����.zj��{��Ä�q��{����.zj�|zj{|xy~|���|x���v:~�  · zj�.z_�0�n¹7z��y��ºz�~¾�����R�yxy~ · z��J����}Å�q�� �Æ���w_z���vq�Y��vR���Uzj�F�Y�R���|x�º»�_�\¼¾z� j�|xy�Uz7�_��{|xa��v��[���q� · z ¶ ���M�¦\z���{|  · �_�F�|x��.xy~|���|x���v&���yw_��{|xy� · �D¿ ¶ ¹��� ���~�zc~¾�|�R�Mxyz�~���xyvJ¹ · x�  · � · z"ÇR��¹h  · ��{�º�� j�|zj{|xy~¾�|xy �~��.�_~¾��xy�.�k��{�����v����|�@� · z"���Uzj{����y�q�kzP{��s��{|�;��vR �z,���k�|�M{|�k�_�;��  · xyvRzj{���M�a���Mz�~���{|z&���M�|xy�.xy~�z��W���{|z&xyv\�Uz�~¾�|xyw_���|z��O¿¸È0z�~��R���|~���{|z.�F{|z�~�z�v��|z�����vq�� ��_�Jº�R��{|z���¹,x�� · �Y�M{|z��\xy�_�M~�ÉÊ~�x�vMw_�yzjº»�_�\¼¾zj j�|xy�Uz�Ë"x�v\�Uzj~¾�|x�w_���|xy�_vÌ����� · z��F{|�_�M��zj�D¿

Í ÎRÏ0ÐkÑOÒ�ÓYÔ�Õ¸ÐOÖ|Ò0Ï>@×OG&CMKkØP?BAD?BQjX�Øj?aCMH�C\Ù0X\?BNPÙ^CF?BE lkG_Q�?B]FHWQ�?BQ!X�Ú�×WXFEaEBG�HW]F?BHO]WT¸Ú�CFADKOLOØjX�Øj?aCMHWX\EBEBÛ=G�ÜkK¸G�HWQP?BpFGFT×O?a]M×OEBÛ�Ú�CMHWQ�ØPN�X\?BHOG�l°TUHOCMHkݾEa?BHOG�XFN"KONjCFÞOEBG�A+ß\à�Q,b�?�ØjרADCRQ|Ø,NjG�XFE�ݾbcCMNPEsl.KONjCFÞWEaG�ADQ�TUØP×WG�NjGX\NjG�A&LOEaØP?BKOEBG-á»LWQPLWX\EBEaÛÅÚ�CFHkâW?sÚ�Øj?aHW]Rã.K¸G�NPÙ^CFNjAÌX\HWÚ�G�ADG�ØjNP?sÚ�Q&ØP×WX\ØDXFHÄG�HW]F?BHOG�G�N&AD?a]M×RØQ�G�G�i.ØjC!?BADKONjC�pFG�?aH¨CFKkØj?aAD?sQ�?BHO]TUÙ^CFN"G�ÜOXFA¨KWEaGMTUØP×OG�lkG_Q�?B]FH¨C\ÙØPLONjÞCMAÌXFÚ�×O?BHOG�NjÛ.ÞOEsXFlkG_Q�Tb�?aHO]RQ�CMN CFØP×OG�N7XFG�NjCklkÛqHWX\AD?sÚ,Q�LWN�Ù»XMÚ�G�Q�ßU>@×O?BQ7QPLO]F]MG�Q�ØjQ�XYA&LWE�Øj?�ݾCFÞkä|G_Ú�Øj?apMGcX\KWKONPCRXFÚ�×[T�XHOC\Øj?aCMHDØP×WX\Øc?sQ0NjG�?BHkÙ^CFN�Ú�G_lDÞqÛ&Øj×OG�NjG�Ú�CF]FHW?�Øj?aCMH�Øj×WX�Ø@X\HqÛDÚ�CFHQ�?slkG�N�X�Øj?aCMHDC\Ù[NjCFÞOLWQ�ØPHWG�QjQå Øj×OG@NPG�ØPG�HRØj?aCMH;C\Ù¸KG�N�Ù^CMNPAÌX\HÚ�G0C�pMG�N7X�N�X\HO]MG0CFÙCFK¸G�N�X�Øj?aHW]YÚ�CMHWlk?aØP?BCFHWQ�TU?aH&ØP×OG�Ù»XMÚ�G�C\Ù]FG�CMADG�ØPNjÛ&Ú�×WXFHO]FG_Q�á^GMß ]ß�ØP×ONjCFLW]F×ÌÚ�NjG�G�Kã7G�Ø�Ú\ß å A�LWQ|Ø�X\EsQ�CJ?BHOG�pq?aØjX\ÞWEaÛ�G�HRØjXF?aEOA�LOEaØP?BKOEaGCFÞkä|G_Ú�ØP?BpFG_Q�ß

V�G_Q�KO?aØPG=ØP×O?sQ�CFÞqpq?aCMLWQ.ADC\Øj?ap�X�Øj?aCMH[T�A�LOEaØP?aÝ¢CMÞkä|G�Ú�ØP?BpFG=XFG�NjCqlOÛRHX\AD?BÚDCMKkØP?BAD?BQjX�Øj?aCMHQ�G�G�AÌQ�ØPC&×WXUpFG�Þ¸G�G�H�Q�CMA¨G�b�×WX�Ø,C�pMG�NjEaCqCMiFG�l[ßUæ�C�bcG�pFG�N�TUØ|b�C;NjG�Ú�G�HRØ0Q|ØjLWlk?BG�Q,?BHÌKWXFN�Øj?BÚ�ÝLOEBXFN@×WXUpFG!G�A�ÞONjXMÚ�G_l�A&LWE�Øj?�ݾCFÞkä|G_Ú�Øj?apMGYCMKkØP?BAD?BQjX�Øj?aCMH½XFHWl=QP×OC�bçØj×OG.KCRQPQP?BÞOEaG!Þ¸G�HOG�èOØjQÚ�CFADKWXFNPG_lÌØjC�Q�?BHO]FEBG�ݾCFÞOä|G�Ú�Øj?apMGYCMKkØP?BAD?BQjX�Øj?aCMH�b�?aØP×�XDÚ�CMADKCRQ�?aØPG.CMÞkä|G�Ú�ØP?BpFGYÙ^LOHWÚ�Øj?aCMH[ß

eJX\?slOlkCFH-é�êcë\ìaí î ï\ð¸K¸G�NPÙ^CFNjAñA&LOEaØP?aݾCFÞkä|G_Ú�ØP?BpFGYCFKkØj?aAD?sQPX\ØP?BCFH�CFH=X¨Q�LWKG�NjQPCFHO?sÚ�AD?sQ|ÝQ�?BEaG0?aHOEBG�Ø_ß_>@×WG�Û.Ú�CMA¨KX\NjG,X�HqLOA&Þ¸G�N C\ÙOCFKOØP?BA¨?sQjX�ØP?BCFH;XFEa]MCFNj?�Øj×OAÌQ°LWQP?aHW]�ÞCFØP×&Ú�CFADK¸CMQ�Ý?�ØjG&X\HWl+A�LOEaØP?BKOEaG&CFÞkä|G_Ú�ØP?BpFGJÙ^LWHWÚ�Øj?aCMHWQ�T¸X\HWl�Ú�CFHWÚ�EaLlkGJØP×WX\Ø=ò�K¸G�NPÙ^CFNjAD?aHW]ÌNPG_X\E[A�LOE�Øj?�ÝCFÞkä|G_Ú�ØP?BpFG@CMKkØP?BAD?aó_X�ØP?BCFH¨X\HWl�èWHlk?aHW]JXJg"XFNPG�ØPC�Ù^NjCFHRØ"?sQ7ØP×OG@CFHWEaÛ;G�f¸G_Ú�Øj?apMG�b@XUÛJØPCJèHWlX&QPG�Ø@C\Ù�lkG_Q�?B]FHWQ�QjX�ØP?sQ�Ù^ÛR?BHO]¨Q�G�pFG�N�X\EKG�N�Ù^CMNPAÌXFHWÚ�G!Ú�Nj?�ØjG�Nj?BX.?BH�XFH=?BHWlkLWQ�ØPNj?sX\E�Ú�CFHRØjG�ÜqØjôWß

õ�G�ADG_Ú�é�ê�ë�ìaí�îaöU÷Uð[KG�N�Ù^CMNPAøA&LOEaØP?aݾCFÞkä|G_Ú�ØP?BpFGJCMKkØP?BAD?BQjX�Øj?aCMH½CMH+ÞCFØP×nXDQ�?BHO]MEaG;XFHWlXùA&LOEaØP?aÝ¢G�EaG�ADG�HRؽúUÝ�VûXFG�NjC\Ù^CF?BE¢ß,>@×OG�?BN�?BHMØjG�]MNjX\ØPG�lüXFKOKONjCMXFÚ�×)Ú�CMA&ÞO?BHOG�Q=XÅõ�G�b@ØjCFHkÝIJNPÛqEBC�p=XFlUä|CM?aHRØJý�þ�VÿÚ�CklkGFT¸XÌÞkÝ�Q�KWEa?BHOG�Q�ݾÞWXFQPG�l�KWX\N�X\ADG�ØPG�Nj?sQPX\ØP?BCFH+QPÚ�×OG�ADG&X\HWl+Þ¸C\Øj×

LI2106
Text Box
Lecture Notes in Computer Science, Volume 3410, Jan 2005, Pages 897 - 910
Page 2: Multi-objective Optimisation of Turbomachinery Blades Using Tabu Search Timoleon Kipourosi

X�]FN�XFlk?BG�HRØPÝ¢ÞWXMQ�G_lÃCMKkØP?BAD?BQPG�N�X\HWlÅXÃe!G�HOG�Øj?BÚ�à�EB]FCMNP?aØP×OA á�eJà!ã�ß">@×OG�Û-CFÞOØjX\?BHÅ]FCqCklNPG_Q�LOEaØjQ@CMH½QPCFADG.QP?aADKOEBGJØPG_Q|Ø�KONjCFÞWEaG�ADQ�ß

>@×OGDA&LOEaØP?aÝ¢CMÞkä|G�Ú�ØP?BpFGD?BHMØjG�]MNjX\ØPG�lhlkG�QP?B]FHùQ�ÛkQ�ØPG�AÀLWQPG�lh?aH-ØP×WGÌKONPG_Q�G�HRØ!b�CFNjin×WXMQÞG�G�HçlkG�pMG�EBCFK¸G�l)X\HWl)lkG_QPÚ�NP?BÞG_lÁÞqÛÁIJ?BK¸CFLONjCMQ�é�ê¨ë�ìBíYîaö � ð�ÞOLO?BEBlk?BHO]ÅCMHÁØj×OGnQ�?BHO]MEaG�ÝCFÞkä|G_Ú�ØP?BpFGJ?BHRØPG�]MNjX\ØPG_l=lkG_Q�?B]FH½CFKkØj?aAD?sQPX\ØP?BCFH+Q�ÛkQ�ØPG�AÀá»`�� o�� V!ã�lkG�pFG�EaCMKG_l=ÞqÛ=æYX\NjpFG�Ûî�öMö�ðXFHWlDlkG�QjÚ�Nj?aÞ¸G�l¨ÞqÛ�V!XUb�G�Q�é�ê�ë\ìaí�î � ð¢ßM>@×OG�Q�ÛkQ�ØPG�AÿÚ�CMA&ÞO?BHOG_Q,X\HDG�Ük?sQ|Øj?aHW]WT\G��ÌÚ�?aG�HRØX\HWlDâG�Ük?aÞWEaGY]FG�CMADG�ØPNjÛ¨KWX\N�X\ADG�ØjG�Nj?BQjX�Øj?aCMHÌQPÚ�×OG�ADGFTqX;b�G�EBE�ݾG�Q�ØjXFÞOEa?sQP×OG�l=ý�þ�V KWXFÚ�i�XF]FGX\HWl�XDHOC�pMG�E°A�LOE�Øj?�ݾCFÞOä|G�Ú�Øj?apMG.p�X\Nj?BXFHMØ�CFÙ�ØP×OG&>7X\ÞWL o G�X\N�Ú�×Åá»> o ã�CFKkØj?aAD?sQPX\ØP?BCFHnX\EB]FCFÝNP?aØP×OAûÙ^CFN;Ú�CMHRØP?BHRLWCFLWQYKONjCFÞOEBG�AÌQDî�ö � ð¾ß[>@×OGÌQ�ÛkQ�ØPG�AûÚ�X\H-NjG�XFlO?aEBÛ�ÞGDNjLOH-CFHÃKX\N�X\EBEaG�EÚ�CFADKOLOØPG�N�Q�T°b�×O?BÚ�×ÅÚ�X\HùQ�LOÞQ|Ø�X\HRØP?sX\EBEaÛÃNPG_lkLWÚ�GÌb@X\EBEaݾÚ�EaCkÚ�i�NjLOHÃØj?aADG_Q å X�Q�?B]FHO?aèÚ�X\HRØÞG�HOG�èOØ�b�×WG�H½ØjXMÚ�iREB?BHO]ÌÚ�CFADKOLOØjX�Øj?aCMHWX\EBEBÛ=lkG�AÌXFHWlk?BHO]ÌlkG�QP?a]MH�KWNPCMÞOEaG�AÌQ�ß��HÃKONjG�pq?BCFLWQYbcCMNPiùîaö � ð7ØP×WG¨K¸G�NPÙ^CFNjAÌX\HWÚ�G&CFÙ"ØP×O?sQ.Q�ÛkQ�ØPG�A�×XFQ!ÞG�G�Hh?aHqpFG_Q|Øj?a]RX�ØjG�lÚ�CFHQ�?slkG�Nj?BHO]�XÌÚ�CMA¨KWNPG_QPQPCFN�ÞOEsXFlOG&lkG�QP?B]FH½ØPG_Q|ØJÚ�XFQPGFß>@×OG;G�f�G�Ú�ØP?BpFG�HOG�QjQ�C\Ù�Øj×OG&A�LOE�Øj?�ÝCFÞkä|G_Ú�ØP?BpFG½CFKOØP?BA¨?sQjX�ØP?BCFH:KONjCqÚ�G�lkLWNPG½b�XMQ¨pFG�Nj?aèWG�l:X\HWlÄØP×OG+G�ÜkK¸G�Ú�ØPG�lÁØPN�XFlOG�ݾC\f°Q�Þ¸G�ÝØ|bcG�G�H�Øj×OGÌÚ�×OCMQPG�H�CMÞkä|G�Ú�ØP?BpFG�Q!Ú�CMHkèWNjADG�l°ß��HnØj×OGDbcCMNPi½KONjG�QPG�HRØPG_l�?aHÃØP×O?sQ!KWX\K¸G�N!b�GLWQ�GYCFLON@QPÛqQ�ØPG�A ØPC&ØjXFÚ�iqEBG�ADCFNjG�NjG�XFEa?sQ�ØP?sÚ�ØPLWNPÞ¸CFAÌXFÚ�×W?aHOG�NPÛDlkG_Q�?B]FHÌØjG�Q�Ø@Ú�XFQPG�Q�TFØ�X\iq?BHO]XFlkp�X\HRØ�X\]FG&C\Ù"ØP×WG&]FNjG�X\ØPG�NYÚ�CMADKOLkØjX\ØP?BCFHWXFE�K¸C�bcG�N�CFf¸G�NPG_l+ÞRÛ+G�ÜqKWEaCM?�Øj?aHO]�?�Ø�Q�KX\N�X\EBEaG�EKONPCkÚ�G�QjQ�?BHO]DÚ�X\KX\ÞO?BEa?aØP?BG�Q�ß

� ���RÕ�ÑÖ���ÐOÖ�Ò0Ï3Ò��ÌÐ���� ÎMÏcÐ����,Ñ��7Ð���Ó������MÐ����þ ?B]Wß�ö�KONjG�QPG�HRØ�Q&X+âWC�bñlk?sX\]MNjXFA6QP×OC�b�?BHO]+ØP×WG�Q�ØjX\]MG�Q&C\Ù�ØP×WG=KONjCkÚ�G�QjQ.G�ÜqG_Ú�LkØjG�lÅÞqÛCFLONÌ?BHRØPG�]MNjX\ØPG_lÁA�LOE�Øj?�ݾCFÞOä|G�Ú�Øj?apMG½ØPLONjÞCMAÌXFÚ�×O?BHOG�NjÛÄÞOEsXFlOGnlkG�QP?a]MH:CMKkØP?BAD?BQjX�Øj?aCMHçQ�ÛkQ�ÝØPG�A+ß,>@×OG�èWN�Q|ØÌQ�ØjX\]MG�?sQ�ØP×OG+KWXFNjXFADG�ØPG�NP?sQjX�ØP?BCFHÅCFÙ�ØP×WG½?BHO?aØP?sX\E@ÞOEsXFlkG+lkG_Q�?B]FH[T�?BHOKOLkØØP×ONjCFLO]M×çX\Hü?aHW?�Øj?BXFE!ý�à�V ]FG�CMADG�ØPNjÛÅØjCF]FG�ØP×OG�N�b�?aØP×üÞCMLOHWlOXFNPÛ)Ú�CMHWlk?aØP?BCFHWQDÙ^CMNÌØP×WGâWC�b QPCFEBLkØj?aCMH[ßW>@×OG.]MG�CFADG�ØPNjÛ=?sQ�KWX\N�X\ADG�ØPG�Nj?sQ�G_l=LWQP?BHO]�XÌg"X\NPØP?sX\E[VY?�f�G�NjG�HRØj?BXFE��� RLWX\ÝØP?BCFH�X\KOKWNPCRXFÚ�×hî � ð¾TO]M?apq?BHO]ÌXÌÚ�CFADKWXMÚ�Ø�ÞOLkØ�âWG�Ük?BÞOEaG.NjG�KWNPG_Q�G�HMØ�X�Øj?aCMH=C\Ù7ØP×WG;lkG�QP?a]MH[TO?BHX�lkG_Q�?B]FH-pFG_Ú�ØjCFNJÚ�CFADKONj?sQ�?BHO]½ú � p�XFNP?sX\ÞOEBG�Q�ß°>@×O?sQ!lOG�QP?a]MHhpMG�Ú�ØjCFN!?BQ!Øj×OGD?aHWKOLkØJØPC½ØP×WGADXF?aHùEBCqCFK-C\Ù�ØP×OG�lkG_Q�?B]FHùQPÛqQ�ØPG�A+T[b�×O?sÚ�×ùÚ�CFHWQP?sQ|Ø�QJC\Ù0Øj×OGÌâWC�b Q�?BA&LWEBX\ØP?BCFHùX\HWl-CFKOÝØP?BA¨?sQjX�ØP?BCFHhKONjCqÚ�G�QjQ�G_Q�ß!�YHnNjG�Ú�G�?aKOØYC\Ù�X�HOG�b lkG�QP?B]FHnpMG�Ú�ØjCFN_TX�Ú�CFADKOLOØjX�Øj?aCMHWX\E7ADG�QP×?BQ�XFLkØPCMADX\ØP?sÚ�XFEaEBÛÌ]FG�HOG�N�X�ØjG�lDÙ^NjCFAñØj×OGJ]FG�CFADG�ØjNPÛ�QPKG_Ú�?aèÚ�X\ØP?BCFH[TkXFHWl�Øj×OG�H+XDlkG�Ø�X\?BEaG_lý�þ7V XFHWX\EBÛkQ�?sQ&á»ÞOEBXMlkG�ØPC=ÞWEBXMlkG_ã�?BQYK¸G�NPÙ^CFNjA¨G_l°ß�>@×OG�ADG_Q�×h?BQ!X � V Q�ØPNjLWÚ�ØPLONjG�l�]MNP?slÚ�CFHQ�?sQ|Øj?aHW]�C\ÙWúkö#"%$R÷!"0ú � HOCklkG�Q�?aH;G_XFÚ�×;lk?BNjG�Ú�Øj?aCMH[ß�>@×WG"âWC�bÅQ�?BA&LWEBX\ØP?BCFH.?sQ[K¸G�NPÙ^CFNjA¨G_lÞRÛDX�ý�þ�V(Ú�CklkG�QPCFEBpR?BHO]JØj×OG � V(õ�XUpq?BG�NPÝ o ØPCFiMG�Q7G& RLWX\ØP?BCFHWQ�TMXFHWl¨ØP×W?BQ0NPCMLkØP?BHOG�NjG�ØjLONPHQX\EBE�Øj×OG&HOG_Ú�G_QPQjX\NjÛ=ADG�ØjNP?sÚ�Q�ØP×X�Ø.lkG�QjÚ�Nj?aÞ¸G.Øj×OG&âC�b XFNPCMLOHWl½Øj×OG&ÞOEsXFlOG�î 'Uð¾ß¸`@XFQPG�l+CMHØP×O?sQJG�p�X\EBLWX\ØP?BCFH[T¸ØP×WG¨CMKkØP?BAD?BQjX�Øj?aCMHÃNjCFLkØj?aHWG¨]MG�HOG�NjX\ØPG_QYX�HOG�b lkG�QP?B]FHÃpMG�Ú�ØPCFNYØP×X�Ø.?BQA¨G_Q�×WG�lùX\HWl-G�pUXFEaLX�ØPG_l°T�XFHWl-ØP×O?sQ.KONjCkÚ�G_QPQ.Ú�CFHRØP?BHqLOG�Q.LWHMØj?aEcX�Q|ØjCFKOKO?BHO]nÚ�NP?aØPG�NP?BCFH-?BQA¨G�Ø�ß

à�Ø,ØP×OG�G�HWlDCFÙ¸Øj×OG�CMKkØP?BAD?BQjX�Øj?aCMH¨KWNPCkÚ�G_QPQ�T�Øj×OG�Þ¸G�Q�ØclkG�QP?B]FHÌpFG_Ú�ØjCFN�Q�?BlkG�HRØP?aèWG�lÌXFHWlØP×OG�?aN!XFQjQ�CkÚ�?sX�ØjG�l�âWC�b Q�CMEaLOØP?BCFHWQ�XFNPG�Ú�CFHqpMG�NPØPG�l�?BHMØjC=X�QP?aHW]FEBGJèWEaGMTW?BH�ØP×WG.èWHWXFE Q�ØjX\]MGC\Ù°NPG�KONjG�QPG�HRØjX\ØP?BCFH[ßF>@×W?BQcQ|Ø�X\]FG�?sQ0XMÚ�Ú�CFADKOEB?BQP×OG�l¨ÞqÛ¨LWQ�?BHO]&õ�CFHkÝ)(�HW?�Ù^CMNPA+*�X�Øj?aCMHWX\E`0Ýo KOEB?aHOG_Q�á�õ,(-*�` o ã&îaö&$\ð¢ß�>@×OG�CFKkØj?aAÌX\E ]FG�CFADG�ØjNP?BG�QYÚ�X\H+Øj×OG�HhÞG�G�ÜOX\AD?BHOG�ln?aHÃlOG�ØjXF?aEØP×ONjCFLO]M×[TqÙ^CFN�?BHWQ�ØjXFHWÚ�GMTOÚ�CFHRØjCFLON�KOEBC\Ø�Q�ß

à�ؽØj×OGÅ×OG_X\NPØ+CFÙ�CMLON�Q�ÛkQ�ØPG�A�?BQ�X)A&LWE�Øj?�ݾCFÞkä|G_Ú�Øj?apMG-p�XFNP?sX\HRØÅî�ö � ð;C\Ù�ØP×OGÅb�G�EBEaÝG�Q�ØjX\ÞWEa?sQ�×WG�lD> XFÞOL o G�XFNjÚ�×�CFKkØj?aAD?sQPX\ØP?BCFHÌX\EB]FCMNP?aØP×WA3î�ö/.�ð¾ß\>@×OG�NjG�×WXMQ�ÞG�G�H�QPLOÞWQ�ØjX\HRØj?BXFE

Page 3: Multi-objective Optimisation of Turbomachinery Blades Using Tabu Search Timoleon Kipourosi

CAD database, boundary conditions

Parametrisation Blade / Airfoil parameters, design vector

Optimisation routine

Flow simulation

New design vector Geometry representation (CAD database)

0%132 µ54Rµ¸¶�· z�~¾��{|�R j�|�F{|z@���¸� · z�xyv��|z�w�{����|z��D�Mzj~�x�w�vD�_�F�|xy�.x�~|���|xy�_vD~¾�F~¾�|z��

NPG_Ú�G�HRØ�?BHRØPG�NjG�Q�Ø�?BHnlkG�pMG�EBCFKO?BHO]DA&LOEaØP?aݾCFÞkä|G_Ú�ØP?BpFG.CMKkØP?BAD?BQjX�Øj?aCMH�X\EB]FCFNj?aØP×OAÌQ å ØP×WG;p�XFQ�ØADX\ä|CFNj?�Ø|Û½C\Ùcb�×O?BÚ�×-Ú�CMHWÚ�G�NPHWQYA&LWE�Øj?�ݾCFÞkä|G_Ú�Øj?apMG¨eJà�QDî�÷_ð¾ß�eJàYQ!×WXUpFG�ÞG�G�HhXFKOKOEB?aG_l�ØjCX\G�NjCklkÛqHWX\AD?sÚ�lkG_Q�?B]FH�KONjCFÞOEBG�AÌQ�TRÞWLkØ�TOXFE�Øj×OCFLO]M×�XFÞOEaG!ØjC�EBCkÚ�X�ØjGYCMKkØP?BAÌX\E[lkG_Q�?B]FHQ�TRØP×WGA¨G�ØP×OCkl½KONjC�pFG_lÌØPCÌÞ¸G;QPG�HWQP?�Øj?apMG!ØPCÌÚ�CMHWQ|ØjNjXF?aHRØ�×WXFHWlkEB?aHO]ÌQjÚ�×OG�ADG_Q�X\HWl�NPG/ RLO?aNjG�l½QP?a]FÝHO?�è¸Ú�X\HRØjEaÛ-ADCFNjG=Ú�CMA¨KWLkØjX\ØP?BCFHWXFE"ØP?BADG�ØP×X\HÄX�]MNjXMlk?aG�HRØ�ݾÞWXFQPG�lhADG�ØP×WCql(î�ö�ð¢ß7>@×O?BQ&?BQHOC\Ø�Q�LWNPKONj?sQ�?BHO]Wßq>@×OGJ×O?B]F×OEBÛ�Ú�CMHWQ�ØPN�X\?BHOG�lÌHX�ØPLWNPGYC\Ù ADCRQ|Ø�X\G�NPCklkÛqHWXFA¨?sÚ�lkG_Q�?B]FH�CFKkØj?�ÝA¨?sQjX�ØP?BCFHDKONjCFÞWEaG�ADQ0Q�LO]M]FG_Q|Ø�Q�ØP×WX\ØcX\EB]FCMNP?aØP×WADQ�T\EB?aiMG�eJà�Q�T\Øj×WX�Ø0NjCFLOØP?BHOG�EBÛ&AÌX\iMG�EBXFNP]MGÚ�×WX\HO]MG�QJØjChQPCFEBLkØP?BCFHQ;AÌXUÛhG�ÜkKG�NP?BG�HWÚ�G�lk?6��Ú�LOEaØP?BG�Q�?BHÅØPNjÛq?aHO]ÃØPCnHWG�]FCFØP?sX�ØjGÌÙ^G�XMQ�?BÞOEBGQ�KWXMÚ�G+CFH)Q�LÚ�×:KONjCFÞWEaG�ADQ�T,X\HlÄØj×WX�Ø�CMKkØP?BAD?BQjX�Øj?aCMH:X\EB]FCMNP?aØP×WADQ¨b�×O?sÚ�×)KONPCM]FNjG�QjQ&ÞqÛADXFiq?aHO]�Q�AÌX\EBEWÚ�×WXFHO]FG_Q,X\NjG�EB?aiMG�EBÛ;ØjC;ÞGYADCFNjG�G�f�G�Ú�ØP?BpFGFßRæ�XFNPpMG�Û�X\Ø�ØjNP?BÞOLkØjG�Q"Øj×OG�EBCkÚ�XFEQ�G_X\N�Ú�×!KX\N�XFlk?B]FA X�Ø�Øj×OG0×WG�X\NPØ�CFÙk> o XFQ[Þ¸G�?BHO]�CMHOG0CFÙqØP×OGcNPG_XFQPCFHWQ�Ù^CMN�?aØjQ G�f�G�Ú�ØP?BpFG�HWG�QjQ?aHù×O?sQ.b�CFNjiÁî�öMö�ð¾ß[>@×OGÌG�ÜkG_Ú�LkØj?aCMH-CFÙ@X½EBCkÚ�X\EcQ�G_X\N�Ú�×hX�Ø;G_XFÚ�×-?�ØjG�N�X�Øj?aCMHhCFÙcØj×OG=X\EB]FCFÝNP?aØP×OAÀX\EsQ�C�C\f�G�N�Q�Øj×OGDKCFØPG�HMØj?BXFE�ÞG�HOG�èOØ.CFÙcÞ¸G�?BHO]½XFÞOEBG&ØjC½G_Q|Øj?aAÌX\ØPG�ØP×OGDNjCFÞOLWQ�ØPHWG�QjQC\Ù�ØP×OG¨Ú�LONjNjG�HRØYlkG_Q�?B]FH+ØjC�p�X\Nj?BX\ØP?BCFHWQ�?BHn]MG�CFADG�ØPNjÛ=b�?aØP×OCMLkØ�Øj×OG&HOG�G�l+Ù^CMNYXMlOlk?aØP?BCFHWXFEâWC�b Q�CMEaLOØP?BCFHWQ�î ú�ð¢ß�þOCMN�Øj×OG�QPG&NjG�XMQ�CMHWQ�b�G&×WXUpMG;CFKkØjG�l+ØjC=LWQPG�X=A&LOEaØP?aݾCFÞkä|G_Ú�ØP?BpFG¨> opUXFNP?sX\HRØ�?BH�CMLON�bcCMNPi�ß

�YLON�A&LOEaØP?aÝ¢CMÞkä|G�Ú�ØP?BpFG@> o p�XFNP?sX\HRØ7ØjX\iMG�Q�XFQ7?aØjQ"Q�ØjXFN�Øj?aHO]!K¸CF?BHMØ�Øj×OG�Q�?BHO]MEaG�Ý¢CMÞkä|G�Ú�ØP?BpFG> o ?aADKOEBG�ADG�HRØ�X�ØP?BCFHÌCFÙ7ýcCFHOHWCFN,X\HlÌ>@?aEBEaG�Û½î 7\ð¾ßM>@×W?BQ0LWQ�G_Q0X;æ�CqCFiFG�XFHWlÌZMG�G�pMG�Q"EBCkÚ�XFEQ�G_X\N�Ú�×hX\EB]FCMNP?aØP×WA á»lkG_Q�?B]FHOG_lnÙ^CMN;Ú�CMHMØj?aHqLOCMLWQ!CFKkØj?aAD?sQPX\ØP?BCFH-KONjCFÞOEBG�AÌQ�ã�îaö_ú�ð,Ú�CFLWKOEaG_lb�?�Øj×=Q�×WCFNPØ�T\ADG�lO?aLOA X\HlDEaCMHO].ØPG�NPA ADG�ADCFNj?BG�Q�ØjC.?aADKOEBG�ADG�HRØ@Q�G_X\N�Ú�רlk?BpFG�NjQP?aèÚ�X\ØP?BCFHX\HWl�?aHRØjG�HWQP?�è¸Ú�X�Øj?aCMH[T\XFQ�KWNPG_QPÚ�NP?BÞG_l;ÞqÛ�e!EBC�pFG�N�XFHWl98�X\]MLOHWX¨î�ö/.�ð¾ß\>@×O?sQ"X\EB]FCFNj?aØP×OA XFHWlX\HWXFEaÛkQP?BQÌCFÙ!?aØjQ=KG�N�Ù^CMNPAÌXFHWÚ�G�CMHçÞG�HWÚ�×OAÌX\Nji:Ú�CFHWQ�ØPN�X\?BHOG�l:CFKOØP?BA¨?sQjX�ØP?BCFHçKWNPCMÞOEaG�AÌQÙ^NPCMAñØP×OG.EB?aØPG�N�X�ØjLONjGJXFNPG.lkG_QPÚ�NP?BÞ¸G�l�?aH�lkG�ØjX\?BE[?BH½XÌÚ�CFADKWXFHO?aCMH=KWXFKG�N;î�ö&7\ð¾ß

Page 4: Multi-objective Optimisation of Turbomachinery Blades Using Tabu Search Timoleon Kipourosi

: ;<�=�>�?�cÐOÔ�ÓYÖ����>@×OGJA¨CRQ|Ø@?BA¨K¸CFNPØjXFHRØcâWC�b(KWX\N�X\ADG�ØjG�N�Q,Øj×WX�Ø�X�f�G�Ú�Ø@ØP×OGJK¸G�NPÙ^CFNjADXFHWÚ�GYC\Ù�X;ØjLONPÞ¸CFAÌX\ÝÚ�×O?aHWG�NjÛ�ÞOEsXFlkG.X\NjGA@B âWC�b QPG�KX\N�X�ØP?BCFH-á^ÞOEBCkÚ�i�X\]FGUã�TB EaCRQPQPG�Q@á�X\HqÛ.âWC�bÁÙ^G�X�ØjLONjGcØj×WX�Ø,NjG�lOLWÚ�G_Q7ØP×OG@GC��Ú�?aG�HWÚ�Û�C\ÙWØj×OG@ØPLWNPÞ¸CFAÌXFÚ�×W?aHOGUã�T\XFHWlB lkG�pq?sX�Øj?aCMH�?BH½âWC�b ØjLONPHW?aHO]ßæ�G�NjGnb�GÃQPG�G�i:ØPCÁèWHWl°T@Q�ØjX\NPØP?BHO]ÅÙ^NjCFA XÄ]RXFQDØjLONjÞO?aHWGhÚ�CMADKONPG_QPQPCFN=]FLO?slkGnp�X\HWG

Q�K¸G�Ú�?�èÚ�X�Øj?aCMH[T X�ÞWEBXMlkG=]MG�CFADG�ØPNjÛnØP×X�Ø�G���Ú�?BG�HRØPEBÛh]M?apMG�Q�X�]FCqCklùKONjG�QjQ�LONjGÌNj?BQPG=X�بXKWX\NPØP?sÚ�LOEsX\N�âWC�b Ú�CqGC��Ú�?BG�HRØ_ßO>@×RLQ�TOX¨]FEBCFÞX\E�KG�N�Ù^CMNPAÌXFHWÚ�G!ADG�XFQPLONjGYCFÙ7X¨]F?BpFG�H=ÞOEsXFlOG]FG�CMADG�ØPNjÛ&?sQ"HOG�G�lkG_l¨Ù^CFN0ØP×OG�CMKkØP?BAD?BQjX�Øj?aCMHDKONPCkÚ�G�QjQ�ßA�%��Ú�?BG�HWÚ�Û&?sQ,CFHWEaÛ�CFHOG�CFÙ[XJHRLWA�ÝÞG�N�C\Ù7KCRQPQP?aÞWEaG;lkG_Q�?B]FH½CFÞOä|G�Ú�Øj?apMG�Q@b�×OG�H�LWHWlkG�NPØjXFiq?aHO]ÌlkG�ØjXF?aEBG�l+X\G�NPCklkÛqHWXFAD?BÚ!Q�×X\K¸GCFKkØj?aAD?sQPX\ØP?BCFH[ß7à ]FCqCklùlkG�QP?B]FHÅA&LQ|ØDX\EsQ�C�NjG�QPKG_Ú�Ø&ADG_Ú�×WX\HO?sÚ�XFEcXFHWlùAÌX\HqLkÙ»XFÚ�ØPLONj?BHO]Ú�CFHQ|ØjNjXF?aHRØjQ�b�×W?aEBG�XFÚ�×W?aG�pR?BHO]!ØP×WG�NPG/ MLW?aNjG�lDX\G�NPCklkÛqHWXFAD?BÚ�K¸G�NPÙ^CFNjADXFHWÚ�G.á»b�?�Øj×ÌNPG_Q�K¸G�Ú�ØØPCDâWC�bçØjLONjHO?aHW]WTWQPG�KWXFNjX\ØP?BCFH½X\HWl�]FCqCkl=CFfÝ�lkG_Q�?B]FH½KG�N�Ù^CMNPAÌXFHWÚ�GJG�Ø�Ú\ß�ã�ß

>@×OGYlkG_Q�?B]FH=CFKkØj?aAD?sQPX\ØP?BCFH�CFÙ Ú�CMA¨KWNPG_QPQPCFN,ÞWEBXMlkG�]MG�CFADG�ØPNj?aG_Q,×WXMQ0KONjG�pq?BCFLWQPEBÛ¨Þ¸G�G�HQ|ØjLWlk?BG�l;ÞqÛ.æ�XFNPpMG�ÛÌîaöFö�ðMÙ^NPCMA X�QP?aHW]FEBG�ݾCFÞkä|G_Ú�ØP?BpFG0KG�NjQPKG_Ú�Øj?apMGFß/��H&CFLWN A�LOE�Øj?�ݾCFÞOä|G�Ú�Øj?apMGØPG�Q�ؽÚ�XFQPG�Q=bcGhNPG�ØjX\?BH æ�XFNPpMG�ÛED Q�CFÞOä|G�Ú�Øj?apMG�Ù^LOHWÚ�ØP?BCFH á»G& RLWX\ØP?BCFH öUã�XFQ�X\H G_QPQPG�HRØj?BXFEö�V�áÊØP×WNPCMLO]F×kâC�b�ã�ADG�XMQ�LONjG;CFÙ,ÞOEBXMlkG¨KG�N�Ù^CMNPAÌX\HÚ�GF߸>@×O?sQ�?sQYX=HOCFNjAÌX\EB?BQPG�l½Ù^LWHWÚ�Øj?aCMH?aHWÚ�EaLlk?aHW]hK¸G�HWXFE�Ø|Û-Ù^LOHÚ�ØP?BCFH:ØPG�NPAÌQ&Ù^CFNDQ�K¸G�Ú�?�è¸Ú�âWC�b Ú�×X\N�XFÚ�ØjG�Nj?BQ�ØP?sÚ�XFHWlÅ]FG�CFADG�ØjNPÛÚ�CFHQ|ØjNjXF?aHRØjQ�ß>@×W?BQ!CFÞOä|G�Ú�Øj?apMG;Ù^LOHÚ�ØP?BCFH-Ú�CMHWQ�?slkG�NjQ�ØP×OGDQPKWX\HkÝ�XUpFG�NjXF]FG_l=ÞOEBCkÚ�i�X\]FG;Ù^CFNJX]F?BpFG�H½AÌXFQjQ�âWC�b(N�X�ØjGA@

F SHG II,JLK úA'A.NM\öHO PQ PQ JERd K .TS 7 QVU>W d M/.�X�öYO[Z]\�^Z \T^=_ J#R á|öUã

K 'A.A. Q`U>W d M&.TX�öHObaLcadc JReK .�Sf' Q`U>W d M&.TX�öHO g.�S .Oö/' R��HçG& RLWX�Øj?aCMH öFT�I NPG�KONPG_Q�G�HRØjQ¨ØP×WGnÞOEBCqÚ�i�XF]FGFT,ØP×OGnG�ÜqØPG�HRØ�ØjCÅb�×O?sÚ�×çpR?sQjÚ�CFLQDÙ^CFN�Ú�G_QNPG_Q|ØjNP?sÚ�Ø.Øj×OG�G�f�G�Ú�ØP?BpFGÌâC�b XFNPG_X�?BHÄX+ÞOEsXFlkG=KWXFQjQPXF]FGMT¸b�×W?BÚ�×Å?sQ;KONjCFÞX\ÞOEBÛ�ØP×WG�ADCMQ�ØÚ�Nj?�Øj?BÚ�X\E� RLWX\HRØj?�Ø|Û�?aHD×O?B]F×kÝ�QPKG�G�lDÚ�CMA¨KWNPG_QPQPCFN"lkG_Q�?B]FH[ß\>@×WG�H[T PQ ?BQ"ØP×OG�AÌXFQjQ7âWC�b)NjX\ØPGihZ \�^ ?sQ!ØP×OG=A¨?BHO?BA&LOAÀNjXMlk?BLWQJC\Ù�ØP×OGÌEBG�XMlk?BHO]�G�lk]MGDC\Ù�ØP×OGÌÞOEsXFlOGAh aLc ?BQ.ØP×OGÌAÌXFQjQ�ÝXUpFG�N�X\]MG�lDâC�b ØPLWNPHO?BHO]#hWX\HWl g ADG�XFQPLONjG�Q�Øj×OGJØP?BK�Ú�EBG�X\N�X\HÚ�G!C\Ù7ØP×OG.ÞOEsXFlOGFßW>@×OG.ó�G�NjCQ�LOÞQPÚ�NP?BKkØjQ�?BlOG�HRØP?aÙ^Û+ØP×OG�G& RLO?Bp�X\EBG�HRØ- RLWX\HRØj?�Øj?aG_Q�Ù^CMN�ØP×WG�lOX\ØPLOA ÞOEsXFlkG�]FG�CFADG�ØjNPÛMTOØP×WG?aHO?aØP?sX\E°lkG_Q�?B]FH=?aHÌØj×OG!CFKkØj?aAD?sQPX\ØP?BCFH å X;NjG�X\E�Ú�CMADKONPG_QPQPCFN0ÞOEBXMlkGYlOG�QP?a]MH=Q�×WC�b�HÌ?aH½þ ?B]WßúkßæYX\NjpFG�Û=G�Q�ØjXFÞOEB?BQP×OG�lÃQ�LO?aØjXFÞOEBG;p�X\EBLOG�Q�Ù^CFN�Øj×OG&b�G�?B]F×RØj?aHO]RQ�Ù^CMN�G�XMÚ�×�C\Ù�ØP×WG&K¸G�HWXFE�Ø|ÛØPG�NjAÌQ�ØP×ONjCFLW]F×½G�ÜqØPG�HWQ�?BpFG!ØjG�Q�ØP?BHO]nî�öMö�ð¾ß��H;×O?B]F×OEBÛ.EaCRXFlkG_l;Ú�CMADKONPG_QPQPCFN�Q�T�ØP×OGcâWC�bùØjG�HWlOQ ØjC!QPG�KWXFNjX\ØPG"Ù^NjCFA Øj×OG�ÞOEBXMlkG0LWHWlkG�NÚ�CFHlk?�Øj?aCMHWQ,CFÙ°EaC�büAÌXFQjQ"âWC�b.ßRþ7EaC�bçQPG�KWXFNjX\ØP?BCFHDXFÚ�Ø�Q0XMQ0X.ÞOEBCkÚ�i�X\]FG�?BHÌØj×OG�âWC�büKWX\ØP×[Tb�×O?BÚ�×+EB?aAD?aØjQ�KWNPG_QPQPLONjGYNjG�Ú�C�pFG�NjÛFß

>@×OGJADXMQPQcâWC�b XFQjQ�CkÚ�?sX�ØjG�l=b�?�Øj×=Øj×OG;lkG�QP?B]FH�QP×OCMLOEBl�Þ¸G!G/ RLWX\EB?�Ø|Û�Ú�CFHQ|ØjNjXF?aHOG_lÌÙ^CMNØ|bcC+NjG�XFQPCFHQ�ß�þ7?aN�Q|Ø_T[?aÙ�?aØ;b�XMQ!HOC\Ø_T°ØP×OGÌ?BHOEBG�Ø&lkÛqHWXFAD?BÚ¨×OG_XFlÃÙ^NPCMAûØP×WGÌNPCFØPCFN!b�CFLOEslpUXFNPÛMT�b�×O?BÚ�×)?sQDHOC\ØDADCqlOG�EBEaG_l:ÞqÛùØj×OG+ÞCMLOHWlOXFNPÛÄÚ�CFHWlk?aØP?BCFHQ�ß o G_Ú�CMHWl°T�?�Ù!ØP×WG+X\Ük?BXFE

Page 5: Multi-objective Optimisation of Turbomachinery Blades Using Tabu Search Timoleon Kipourosi

0%132 µ&jWµW¶�· z��M���|�R� �R���_�Fz�w_z����.zj��{��&~ · ��¹,xyvRw.x��|~0��ÂFx����¸�_z��y�� �x��¢���Mxy~¾��{|xy�R�F�|x���v

pFG�EBCkÚ�?aØ|Û�lkNjCFKQ�TFØP×OG�HÌØP×OG�?aHOEBG�Ø@Q|Ø�X�Øj?BÚ�KWNPG_QPQPLONjG�A&LWQ�Ø0Þ¸G�×O?B]F×OG�N�á»QP?BHWÚ�GY?aHOEBG�ØcKONPG_QPQPLONjGX\HWlDâC�b X\HO]MEaG_QcXFNPGYKONPG_QPÚ�NP?BÞ¸G�lWã�TRQPC;Øj×WX�Ø�ØP×OGJQ�ØjX�Øj?BÚ�KONjG�QjQ�LONjG�Nj?sQ�G�XMÚ�NjCMQjQ"Øj×OG!Q�ØjX\ØPCMNb�?aEBEWÞ¸G�EBC�bcG�N�á^CMLkØPEBG�ØcKONPG_QPQPLONjG�?BQ,èOÜkG�lWã�TRXFHWl¨ØP×WG�ÞOEsXFlkG�NjC�b)b�?aEBEWHOCFØcÞ¸G�X\HÌG�f¸G_Ú�Øj?apMGlk?�f�LWQPG�N_ß��� RLWXFEaEBÛFTk?aØ�?BQ@?BADKCMN�Ø�X\HRØ@ØP×WX\Ø�TO?aÙ Øj×OGJAÌXFQjQ�âWC�b ?sQ@èOÜkG�l°TqØj×OGJâWC�bçØjLONjHO?aHW]?aHüØj×OGnQ|Ø�X\]MGnQ�×OCMLOEsl:HWC\Ø�Þ¸GnNPG_lkLWÚ�G�lülkLONj?aHW]ÅCFKkØj?aAD?sQPX\ØP?BCFH[T,CFØP×OG�NPb�?sQPG�Øj×OGÃQ�ØjX\ØP?sÚKONPG_QPQPLONjGYNjG�Ú�C�pFG�NPÛDb�?BEaE[HWC\Ø�Þ¸G;Q�L���Ú�?aG�HMØ_ßO>@×OG�NjG�Ù^CMNPGMTOÚ�CMHMØjNPCME�C\Ù7ØP×OGJâWC�b(ØPLONjHO?BHO]D?BQXFÚ�×O?BG�pMG�l�ÞqÛ=ØPNjG�X�Øj?aHW]¨?aØ�XFQ�X¨K¸G�HWXFE�Ø|Û�ØPG�NjA+ß��H)XMlOlk?aØP?BCFH[T�Øj×OG�NjGnX\NjG=Ø|b�C-ØPG�NPAÌQD?BH:G/ MLX�ØP?BCFH ö�lkG�QjÚ�Nj?BÞO?aHW]hØj×OG�]FG�CFADG�ØjNP?sÚ�XFEÚ�CFHQ|ØjNjXF?aHRØjQ&CFHÅØj×OG=ÞWEBXMlkGFß">@×OG=èWNjQ�Ø�EB?BA¨?aØjQ�Øj×OG�QP×WX\NjKOHOG_QPQ&C\Ù�Øj×OG�ÞWEBXMlkGAD Q&EBG�XMlk?BHO]G�lk]MGFT0b�×W?aEBG�ØP×WGÃQ�G_Ú�CMHWlüX\EBEaC�b�Q�Xùb�G�?B]F×RØjG�lüK¸G�HWXFE�Ø|ÛÁÙ»XFÚ�ØjCFNÌØjCÅØPN�XFlOGnC\f X\G�NjCklkÛRÝHWX\AD?sÚ;K¸G�NPÙ^CFNjADXFHWÚ�G�X\]MXF?aHQ|Ø�ADG�Ú�×X\HO?sÚ�XFE�KONjCUÜk?aAD?aØ|ÛFß>@×WG&CFÞOä|G�Ú�Øj?apMG;Ù^LOHÚ�ØP?BCFHÃpUXFEaLWG?BQJK¸G�HWXFEa?sQPG�l-b�×OG�H-Øj×OGDÞOEBXMlkG�lkG_Q�?B]FH-×WXFQJEBG�QjQ!ØP×X\H)öFßf'�Ú�AÀÚ�EaG_X\N�X\HWÚ�GFß°`�C\ØP×hØP×WG�QPGKG�HWX\EaØ|ÛÃØjG�NjAÌQ;NjG�âWG_Ú�Ø�XnÚ�CFHWÚ�G�NjHùÙ^CFN�NPCMÞOLWQ�Ø&X\G�NjCklkÛqHWX\AD?sÚDKG�N�Ù^CMNPAÌXFHWÚ�GÌÙ^NjCFAÀØP×WGlkG�QP?a]MH[TOQP?aHWÚ�G!ØP×OG_Q�GJ]FG�CFADG�ØjNP?sÚJÚ�×WX\N�XFÚ�ØPG�NP?sQ|Øj?BÚ�QcXFNPGJÚ�EBCMQPG�EBÛÌNjG�EsX�ØPG_l�ØjC¨ØP×OG.CFfÝ�lkG�QP?B]FHKG�N�Ù^CMNPAÌX\HÚ�GJC\Ù ØP×OG.ÞOEsXFlOGA@öFß�à Q�×X\NjK:EBG�XMlk?aHW]hG_lk]FG+KONjCklkLWÚ�G_QÌX-×O?a]M×üpFG�EBCkÚ�?aØ|ÛÅKONjC\èWEBG�X�ØDØP×OG+Ù^NjCFHRØÌC\Ù!ØP×WGÞOEsXFlkGÃXFHWl°T,?BH XFlWlk?�Øj?aCMH[T0QPLWÚ�× XÅlkG_Q�?B]FHüAÌXUÛÁb�G�EBE�×WXUpMG+XÅâX�Ø=QPG�Ú�ØP?BCFHçX�Ø=?aØjQÙ^NPCMHRØ�ß o LWÚ�×ÁX�]MG�CMA¨G�ØPNjÛhNjG�QPLOEaØjQ�?aH:XnpFG�EaCkÚ�?�Ø|Û-KG_X\iùX�بC\f¸Ý¾lkG_Q�?B]FHÄÚ�CFHWlO?�Øj?aCMHWQ�Tb�×O?sÚ�×½ADG_X\HWQ@Øj×WX�Ø�Øj×OG;pMG�EBCqÚ�?�Ø|Û�lk?BQ�ØPNj?BÞOLkØP?BCFH�KWNPCklkLWÚ�G�l½×WXMQ�XD×O?a]M×+KONPCMÞWX\ÞW?aEB?�Ø|ÛC\Ù,G_X\NjEaÛ�ØPN�X\HWQP?aØP?BCFH[TEBXFA¨?BHWXFN�CFN�ØPLONjÞOLOEBG�HRØJQ�G�KWX\N�X�Øj?aCMH[TXFHWlnÚ�CMHWQPG& RLOG�HRØjEaÛ½KCqCMNC\f¸Ý¾lOG�QP?a]MH�K¸G�NPÙ^CFNjAÌX\HWÚ�GFß

úkß�>@×OG;Øj?aK-Ú�EBG�XFNjXFHWÚ�G;?sQYNPG_Q�K¸CFHWQP?BÞOEaG;Ù^CFNYØP×OG¨lkG�pq?sX�ØP?BCFHhÚ�NjG�X�ØjG�l+CMH�ØP×OG�G�HWlÃb�XFEaEsQ�ß��H KWXFN�Øj?BÚ�LOEBXFN�T,ØP×OG-Q�G_Ú�CFHlOX\NjÛÄâWC�b�Q�X\NjGniqHOC�b�HüØPC:Ú�NjG�X�ØjGnC�pFG�N�Ý¢ØPLWNPHO?BHO]ùpFG�NPÛÚ�EBCMQPG½ØPC-ØP×OG�G�HWl)b�XFEaEsQDX\HWlüX-NjG�]F?BCFH:C\Ù!LOHWlkG�N�Ý¢ØPLONjHO?BHO]ÅQ�CMADG+lO?BQ�ØjXFHWÚ�G�XUb@XUÛÙ^NPCMA�ØP×OG�A½ß°>@×OG¨G�f�G�Ú�ØjQYC\Ù,Øj×O?sQYlkG�pq?BX\ØP?BCFHnCMH�ØP×OG¨G�Ük?aØ!pMG�EBCkÚ�?aØ|Û�KONjC\èEaG¨X\HWl�CMHØP×OGD?BHOEBG�ØJ?aHWÚ�?BlOG�HWÚ�GDXFHO]FEBG�Q�ØPC�ØP×WG¨HWG�ÜqØ!ÞWEBXMlkG�NjC�b Ú�XFHÃÞ¸GDpFG�NjÛ+EBXFNP]MG&X\HlÃÚ�XFHQ�LWÞWQ|Ø�X\HRØP?sX\EBEBÛ�?aHÚ�NjG�XFQPGYØP×OG.?BHWÚ�?slkG�HWÚ�G.EBCMQjQ�G_Q�CFH½ØP×OG.HWG�ÜqØ�ÞOEsXFlkGJNjC�b.ßæ�X\NjpFG�ÛhîaöFö�ð�Ù^CFLWHWl+ØP×X�Ø�?aØ!b@XFQ�HOG�Ú�G�QjQPXFNPÛ=ØPC=LQ�G&X�KG�HWX\EaØ|Û½Ù^LOHWÚ�Øj?aCMHÃX\KWKONPCRXFÚ�×

b�?�Øj×nØP×WG�QPG¨Ú�CFHWQ�ØPN�X\?BHRØjQY?aHhCFN�lkG�N�ØPC+Q�LWÚ�Ú�G_QPQ�Ù^LOEBEaÛ+HWXUpq?B]MX�ØjG.ØP×WG�×O?B]F×WEaÛnÚ�CFHWQ�ØPN�X\?BHOG�l[T

Page 6: Multi-objective Optimisation of Turbomachinery Blades Using Tabu Search Timoleon Kipourosi

HOCFHOEB?BHOG�XFNYQPG�X\N�Ú�×nQPKWXFÚ�G&Ú�×WX\N�XFÚ�ØPG�NP?sQ|Øj?BÚ;C\Ù0X\G�NPCklkÛqHWXFAD?BÚ.lkG_Q�?B]FHÃCFKkØj?aAD?sQPX\ØP?BCFHnKONjCFÞOÝEaG�ADQ�ß���ØP×OG�N!Ú�CFHWQ�ØPN�X\?BHRØjQ�TQPLWÚ�×hXMQ�Øj×OCMQPG�CMH�ØP×WG�]MG�CFADG�ØPNj?BÚ;Ù^G�XFQP?BÞO?aEB?aØ|Û½CFÙ0ÞOEsXFlkG¨lkG�ÝQ�?B]FHWQ"XFHWl¨CFH¨ØP×WG�?BN,CFK¸G�N�X�Øj?aCMHWX\ERÙ^G�XMQ�?BÞO?BEa?aØ|Û�á�X.lkG�QP?B]FHDb�×O?sÚ�רKWNPCklkLWÚ�G�Q�LOHQ|ØjG�XFlOÛ;âWC�bKWX�ØPØPG�NjHWQ�?BQ�HOC\ØYXMÚ�Ú�G�KkØ�X\ÞOEBG_ã�TX\NjG.×WXFHWlkEBG�lnXMQ�×WX\N�l�Ú�CMHWQ�ØPN�X\?BHMØ�Q å lkG_Q�?B]FHWQ�pq?aCMEBX\ØP?BHO]ØP×OG�AøX\NjGJHOC\Ø�XMÚ�Ú�G�KkØPG_l°ß

k�lnm oHprq5s&teuwv�xrt&pzy|{#}E~/����t/pz�#������s�t��L��s/���H�CFLON0èWN�Q|ØcØPG�Q�Ø�Ú�XFQPGFTMbcG�?BHRØPNjCklkLWÚ�GYX&QPG�Ú�CMHWlDCFÞOä|G�Ú�Øj?apMG,I�� Q�� áÊØP×WG]*�m o p�X\Nj?BX\ØP?BCFH?aH�ÞOEaCkÚ�i�X\]MG_ã�T�b�×O?sÚ�×;KONjC�pq?BlOG�Q�XFH�XMlOlk?aØP?BCFHWXFEMNjG�KONjG�QPG�HRØ�X�ØP?BCFH.CFÙkØP×OG@QPKWX�Øj?BXFEMp�X\Nj?sX�ØP?BCFH�TX\HWlç×WG�HWÚ�GÃ×OCMA¨CM]FG�HOG�?aØ|ÛFT,CFÙ.ØP×OGhÞOEBCqÚ�i�XF]FG å G�f�G�Ú�Øj?apMG�EBÛ)X)ú\VÀADG�XFQPLONjG�C\Ù;ÞOEsXFlOGKG�N�Ù^CMNPAÌX\HÚ�G�á^G/ RLWX�Øj?aCMH.úMã�T_Q�LOÞOä|G�Ú�Ø�ØPC�Øj×OG0QjX\ADG,Q�G�Ø�C\ÙkK¸G�HWXFE�Ø|ÛYÙ^LOHWÚ�ØP?BCFH;Ú�CFHWQ�ØPN�X\?BHRØjQ&@

F d,G I�� Q��Id� Q�� J9K úA'�.�M�öHO PQ PQ J#Rd K .�S 7 Q`U>W d M/.TX�öYO[Z-\T^Z \�^%_ J#R á�úMã

K '�.i. Q`UiW d M&.�X�öHObadcaLc J#R�K .TS ' QVU>W d M&.�X�öHO g.TS .Wö/' R>@×OG!QjX\ADG!KG�HWX\EaØ|ÛÌØjG�NjADQ@XFNPG!?aHÚ�EBLWlkG�l�?BH=Øj×OG!Ù^CFNjA&LOEsX�Øj?aCMH�C\Ù7G�XFÚ�×�CFÞkä|G_Ú�Øj?apMGY?BH

CFN�lkG�N�ØjC�G�HQ�LONjGJØP×X�Ø�Øj×OG.èWHX\E g"XFNPG�ØPC¨Ù^NjCFHRØ�?slkG�HRØP?aèWG_l�Ú�CFHRØ�X\?BHWQ�CMHOEaÛ½lkG�QP?B]FHWQ�ØP×WX\ØX\NjGDá»HOG�XFN�Ý|ã¾Ù^G_XFQP?aÞWEaGMß

k�l�� �����A{����uwvNxzt/p�y|{#}!~&���At&pz�������s&t��d�Ts&���H CFLON½Q�G_Ú�CMHWl)ØPG_Q|Ø+Ú�XFQPGFTcbcGÃ?aHRØPNjCklkLWÚ�GÃX\H CMÞkä|G�Ú�ØP?BpFG�Ù^LWHWÚ�Øj?aCMH b�×O?sÚ�×� RLWX\HRØP?aèWG_QEaCRQPQPG�Q�XFQjQ�CkÚ�?BX\ØPG�l=b�?�Øj×=Øj×OG.lkG�QP?B]FH[ßk>@×O?sQ�?BQ�lkG�èWHOG_l=?BH�ØjG�NjADQ@CFÙ[ØP×WG!N�X�ØjGYCFÙ�G�HRØjNPCMKRÛ]FG�HWG�N�X�ØP?BCFH-î $\ð¢TQ�LOÞOä|G�Ú�Ø�XF]MX\?BH�ØPC¨ØP×OG;QjX\ADG.QPG�Ø�C\Ù7KG�HWX\EaØ|Û�Ù^LWHWÚ�Øj?aCMH+Ú�CFHWQ�ØPN�X\?BHRØjQ&@

F r G����!� �����T� Z U �� ���!� �����#� Z U ��  J KúA'�. M öHO PQ PQ J#R

d K .�S 7 Q`UiW d M .�X�öHO Z-\�^Z \�^%_ JTR á � ãK '�.A. QVU>W d M/.�X�ö�O¡adcaLc J#R�K .TS ' QVU>W d M/.�X�ö�O g.�S .Oö5' R

��HnXDØPLONjÞ¸CFAÌXFÚ�×O?BHOG.Øj×OG&?sQPG�HRØPNjCFKO?sÚ.G��ÌÚ�?aG�HWÚ�Û½?sQ�lkG�èWHOG�lÃXFQ�Øj×OG&N�X�Øj?aCÌCFÙ"ØP×OG¨XFÚ�ÝØPLWXFEWb�CFNji;ØPC;ØP×OGY?BQPG�HRØPNjCFKW?BÚ@b�CFNji;Ù^CMNcX.b�CFNjiRÝ¢KONjCklkLWÚ�?aHO].lkG�pq?BÚ�G&á»QPLWÚ�×�XFQcXJØPLWNPÞO?BHOGUãX\HWlÄØP×OG+N�X�ØP?BCÃCFÙ�Øj×OG�?sQPG�HRØPNjCFKO?sÚ�bcCMNPi-ØPChØP×WG+XMÚ�ØjLWX\E@b�CFNjihÙ^CMNÌXÃb�CFNjiRݾXFÞWQ�CMNPÞW?aHO]lkG�pq?sÚ�G+á»QPLWÚ�×-XMQYX½Ú�CMADKONPG_QPQPCFN�ã�ß�>@×OGDCFHWEaÛ+Ù»XMÚ�ØPCMNjQ�ØP×X�Ø;Ú�×WX\HW]FG;Øj×O?sQJGC��Ú�?BG�HWÚ�ÛnX\NjGlkG�KWXFN�ØjLONjG�QDÙ^NjCFA ?BQPG�HRØjNPCMKO?BÚ½âC�b.ßc>@×OG_Q�GnAÌXUÛüX\Nj?BQPGnlkLOGÃG�?aØP×OG�N=ØjCÄ×OG�X\Ø�ØPN�X\HQ|Ù^G�NCFN;ØjCÃØj×OG�NjADCklkÛqHWX\AD?sÚ�?BNPNjG�pMG�N�Q�?BÞO?BEa?aØ|ÛFß�þWCFN¨ADCMQ�Ø&ØPLWNPÞ¸CFAÌXFÚ�×W?aHOG_Q.Øj×OG=âC�bñ?BQ¨Ú�EBCMQPGØPC+XFlk?sX\ÞWX\ØP?sÚ=á»HOC=×OG_X�Ø!ØPN�X\HWQ�Ù^G�N�ã�XFHWlÃQPC=CMHOEBÛ½G�HRØPNjCFKqÛ�Ú�NjG�X�Øj?aCMH�ÞqÛ�?aNjNPG�pFG�NjQP?aÞW?aEB?�Øj?aG_QÚ�CFHRØjNP?BÞOLkØjG�Q@Q�?B]FHW?�èÚ�X\HRØPEBÛDØPC¨Øj×OGJEaCRQPQ�C\Ù7GC��Ú�?BG�HÚ�ÛFTkb�×W?BÚ�×½ADG�X\HQ0Øj×WX�Ø�G�HMØjNPCMKqÛÌ]FG�HOÝG�N�X�ØP?BCFH=NjX\ØPG�?sQcØP×OG!CFHWEaÛÌN�X�Øj?aCMHWX\EA¨G_XFQPLONjG�C\Ù C�pFG�N�X\EBEWEBCMQjQc?aH½X\H=XMlk?BXFÞWX�Øj?BÚ�AÌXFÚ�×O?BHOGFß

Page 7: Multi-objective Optimisation of Turbomachinery Blades Using Tabu Search Timoleon Kipourosi

à�HqÛÌ?aNjNjG�pFG�NjQP?BÞOEaG�âWC�b KONjCkÚ�G_QPQ�Ú�NjG�X\ØPG�QcG�HRØjNPCMKRÛÌXFHWl�Øj×qLWQ�NPG_lkLWÚ�G_QcØP×OGJ?sQ�G�HMØjNPCMKO?sÚ�G�ÙÊÝèÚ�?BG�HWÚ�ÛFßq>@×OGYQPCFLWNjÚ�G�Q"CFÙ�EBCMQjQ,?BH=XJØjLONjÞCMADXMÚ�×O?BHOGYÚ�X\HÌÞ¸GYÚ�X\ØPG�]FCFNj?sQ�G_l¨XMQ,KONjC\èEaG�EBCMQjQ�TQ�G_Ú�CFHlOX\NjÛ-á»CFNJG�Hlnb@X\EBEsã�EaCRQPQ�T�X\HWlnØP?BKÃEBG�X\i�XF]FG&EBCMQjQ�ß#��HhADXFHqÛ�ADXMÚ�×O?BHOG�Q�ØP×OG�ØP×WNPG�GX\NjGJÚ�CFADKWXFNjXFÞOEaG!?BH½AÌXF]FHO?aØPLWlOGFTkG�XMÚ�×½XMÚ�Ú�CFLOHRØP?BHO]�Ù^CFN�XFÞCMLkØ;ö5¢ � CFÙ Øj×OGJØPCFØjX\E°EBCMQjQ�ߣ ¤����qÔ,¥|Ð��¦�lnm oHprq5s&te����s&t§�L��s/�>@×OG&CMKkØP?BAD?BQjX�Øj?aCMH�b�XMQ�?aHW?�Øj?BX\ØPG�l�Ù^NPCMA3Øj×OG�lOX\ØPLOA ]MG�CFADG�ØPNjÛ�QP×OC�b�H�?aHhþ ?B]Wß�úk߸þ ?B]Wß� Q�×OC�b�Q!Øj×OGÌKONjCF]MNPG_QPQ!?BH-CMÞkä|G�Ú�ØP?BpFG�ݾQPKWXFÚ�GDC\Ù�ØP×OG�QPG�XFNjÚ�×-KG�N�Ù^CMNPADG_lhÞqÛnCMLON;A�LOE�Øj?�ÝCFÞkä|G_Ú�ØP?BpFG+> o X\EB]FCFNj?aØP×OA C�pFG�N&Øj×OGùö � '�.�?aØPG�NjX\ØP?BCFHWQ¨C\ÙYØP×OG+NjLOH[T�LWQP?aHW]ÃØj×OG�Ú�CFHRØjNPCMEKWX\N�X\ADG�ØjG�N�Q=QPKG_Ú�?aèWG�l(?aH > XFÞOEBGÁöFß o G�G)îaö�7FðYÙ^CMN½X:lkG�Ø�X\?BEaG_l G�ÜkKOEsX\HX�ØP?BCFHçCFÙ;ØP×WG�QPGKWX\N�X\ADG�ØjG�N�Q�ß >@×OG�p�XFEaLOG_Q;CFÙ�ØP×OG_Q�G+Ú�CMHMØjNPCME,KWXFNjXFA¨G�ØPG�NjQ&bcG�NPG=Ú�×WCMQPG�HÅÞWXMQ�G_lÅCFHÄG�ÜqÝKG�NP?BG�HWÚ�GFT�ÞOLkØ.?aØJQP×OCMLOEBlÃÞG¨HOCFØPG�lnØP×WX\Ø;Q|ØjLWlk?BG�Q!?aH)î�ö&7\ð"Q�×WC�b ØP×WX\ØYØj×OGDX\EB]FCFNj?aØP×OA`D QKG�N�Ù^CMNPAÌX\HÚ�GJ?BQ@NjG�EsX�Øj?apMG�EBÛÌ?aHQ�G�HWQ�?aØP?BpFGJØjC¨ØP×OG;Ú�CFHRØPNjCFE�KWXFNjXFA¨G�ØPG�N@QPG�ØPØP?BHO]MQ�ß

¨ ³R®!©3ª`4Rµ¸¶ ���R�D¦Fz���{|  · �°��{����.zP�|zj{c¦Fzj���|xyvMw_~�°��{����.zj�|zj{�« ���y�Mzc}@zj~� j{|xy�M�|xy�_v¬®­>¯n°±­i²�¬ ³±´ �&µ ¶�v\�|zjvR~�x��B�&~�z���{|  · ���B�|zj{ ¬®­i¯n°±­>²�¬ ³±´ xy�|zP{����|xy�_vM~0¹,x�� · ���M�0���R�MxyvMw!�|�!� · z©¨z��Fxy�R� ¶ zj{|� ©¨zj�.��{��=É»© ¶ ©ÌË· ¬®¸&°±¹º²�¬ ³±´ » µ }@xy�UzP{|~�xy�a�¨~�z���{|  · ���a�|zj{ · ¬®¸&°±¹º²º¬ ³±´ x��|zj{����|x���vR~,¹,x�� · �_�F�c�_�R�FxyvRw!�|�!� · z© ¶ ©¹�° ·&¼i½ ° ¾ µ È0z��M�M �z@~¾�|z���~�xÀ¿�z���vq�;{|z�~¾����{������a�|zj{ ¹�° ·&¼i½ ° x��|zj{����|xy�_vR~,¹,x�� · ���M�c�_�M�MxyvRw�|�!� · z�© ¶ ©­ ²º¯�Á �µ ¦ · ��{�� ¶ zj{|� ©¨z��.��{��&~�xÀ¿�zYÃ.� · z@����~¾� ­ ²�¯�Á �\xy~�x��|z��¨�k��x�v��|~0��{|z@�����R�­ ¹�°zÄ&¬zÅ&­i² ª ¶�v�� · z@¡�_vMw ¶ zj{|� ©¨zj�.��{��&z���  · ����{|x����M�yz�x�~0�Fx��\x��Mz���xyv��|� ­ ¹)°zÄ&¬zÅ&­>²�|�.�Fzj�|zj{|�.xyvRz0¹ · xy  · {|z�w_xy��vR~0���°� · z�~�z���{|  · ~��q�� �z · ���Uz��kz�z�vD�Mvq�MzP{�ºzjÂF�M����{|z��Æ>Æ �ÂÇ ¶�vRx��|x����W~¾�|z��D~�xÀ¿�z���~0�kzj{| �zjv\����w_z����°�_��{|x����R�yz@{���vRw_zÆ>Æ�È%É ¬\¿ µ �q�� j�|��{0���;¹ · xy  · ~¾�|z��¨~�xÀ¿�zj~���{|z@{|z��M�M �z�����v¨{|z�~¾����{��|x�vMw

>@×OG&CMKkØP?BAD?BQjX�Øj?aCMH�b�XMQ�NjLOHnCFHhX\HÊ$�ݾHOCklkG�KWX\N�X\EBEaG�E�g�ý Ú�EaLQ|ØjG�N!C\Ùcúkß $MeJæ�ó&g�G�HOÝØP?BLOAË7=AÌXFÚ�×W?aHOG_Q�?BHnCMNjlkG�N�ØjC=NjG�lkLWÚ�G&b@X\EBE�Ý�Ú�EBCkÚ�i�NjLOH�Øj?aADG_QYÞqÛ+G�ÜkKOEBCF?aØP?BHO]�CMLONJQ�ÛkQ�ÝØPG�A`D Q.KWXFNjXFEaEBG�E,Ú�X\KWXFÞO?aEB?aØP?BG�Q�ß[>@×OG�ý�þ�V âWC�bÿQPCFEBLkØj?aCMH-NjG& RLO?BNjG�l�Ù^CMN;G�p�XFEaLWX\ØP?BCFH-C\Ù@XQ�?BHO]FEBG&Ú�X\HWlk?slOX\ØPG&lkG_Q�?B]FH+Ø�X\iMG�Q � A¨?BHqLkØPG_Q�CMHnX=QP?aHO]MEaG.HWCqlOG&C\Ù�Øj×OG�Ú�EaLWQ�ØPG�N�T¸X\HWlnLOKØPCd'Fú;ý�þ�V(G�p�X\EBLWX�Øj?aCMHWQ�á»CFHÌXUpFG�NjXF]FG � ú!G�p�XFEaLWX\ØP?BCFHWQ�ã�X\NjG@NPG/ RLO?aNjG�lDX\Ø,G�XFÚ�×D?aØPG�NjX\ØP?BCFHC\Ù�ØP×OGÌCMKkØP?BAD?BQjX�Øj?aCMH-XFEa]MCFNj?�Øj×OA+ß�>@×qLWQ�T[CMHhCMLON;Ú�EBLWQ�ØPG�N;Xùö � 'A.�?aØPG�N�X�Øj?aCMHhNjLOH-ØjXFiFG_QúM÷�.�×OCMLONjQ.áyä|LWQ�Ø�C�pFG�NJöMöJlWXUÛqQ�ã�ß

þ ?B]Wß=7ÅQP×OC�b�Q�ØP×OGnQPG�Ø�CFÙ!g"XFNPG�ØPC\ݾCFKOØP?BADXFE�QPCFEBLkØj?aCMHWQ¨Ù^CFLOHl)lOLONP?BHO]-ØP×WG+QPG�XFNjÚ�×�ß>@×OG.]FG�CFADG�ØjNPÛ=QP×OC�b�H½?aHnþ7?B]Wß#'�NjG�KONjG�QPG�HRØ�Q�XÌÚ�CFADKONjCFAD?sQ�G.lkG_Q�?B]FH�Ù^NjCFA Øj×OG.AD?BlWlkEaGC\Ù�ØP×WG½g"XFNPG�ØPC+Ù^NjCFHRØ�T7b�×O?sÚ�×Ä?BQDÚ�EaG_X\NjEaÛÌ RLO?�ØjG�lk?af�G�NjG�HRØ�ØjCnØj×OG�lOX\ØPLOA lOG�QP?a]MH[ß7>@×WGEBXFNP]MG�Ú�×WX\HO]MG�Q.AÌXMlkGÌØPCnØP×OG�ÞWEBXMlkG�]FG�CFADG�ØjNPÛ-lkLONj?aHW]�ØP×OG½Q�G_X\N�Ú�×-lOG�ADCFHWQ�ØPN�X�ØjGÌØP×WG

Page 8: Multi-objective Optimisation of Turbomachinery Blades Using Tabu Search Timoleon Kipourosi

0�162 µ�ÍWµ¶�· z����M�|xy�.xy~|���|xy�_v¨~�z���{|  · �q�����|zj{|v��B��{0� · z�§M{|~¾�,�R���_�FxyvRw!�|z�~¾�0 ���~�zâWG�Ük?BÞO?aEB?aØ|Û;C\ÙØP×OG@]FG�CFADG�ØjNPÛJAÌX\HX\]FG�ADG�HRØ�QPÛkQ|ØjG�A LWQPG�l[ß\à:×W?a]M×&Ø|b�?sQ|Ø,XFEaCMHO]�Øj×OG�Q�KWXFH?BQJØj×OG�AÌX\?BHÅÚ�×WX\N�XFÚ�ØPG�NP?sQ|Øj?BÚ�C\Ù�ØP×W?BQ&ÞOEBXMlkGFß�*�G�XMQPQPLONj?aHO]MEaÛMT�ØP×O?sQ.CMKkØP?BAD?BQPG�l-]FG�CFADG�ØjNPÛ×WXFQ!X�QP?aAD?BEBXFNYEBG�XMlk?aHW]=G�lO]FG=án8��cã�KONjC\èWEBG;ØjC�ØP×WG¨QP?aHW]FEBG�ݾCFÞkä|G_Ú�ØP?BpFG.CMKkØP?BAD?BQPG�lÃlkG�QP?a]MHÙ^CFLOHWl½ÞqÛ=æYX\NjpFG�ÛMTOQ�×WC�b�H=?BH+þ7?B]Wß � îaöFö�ð¢ß�¾Ø0Ú�X\HDÞ¸G�Q�G�G�H¨ØP×X�Ø"ØP×WG�KG�N�Ù^CMNPAÌXFHWÚ�G_Q�C\Ù¸ØP×OG�CMKkØP?BAD?BQPG�l¨]FG�CFADG�ØjNP?BG�Q�EBÛq?aHW];X�Ø"ØP×WGEaC�b ÞWEaCkÚ�i�X\]MGYG�HWl=CFÙ�Øj×OG.g"X\NjG�ØPC&Ù^NPCMHRØ.á�þ7?a]ß�7Rãc×WXUpFGYAÌX�ØjÚ�×WG�l�CFN�Q�EB?B]F×RØPEBÛÌG�ÜOÚ�G�G�lkG_lØP×WX\Ø�CFÙWØj×OG@CFKkØj?aAD?sQ�G_l;]FG�CFADG�ØjNPÛJÙ^CMLOHWl�ÞqÛ;æ�X\NjpFG�ÛÌá»þ7?a]ß � ã�ßU>@×W?BQ�×WXMQ7ÞG�G�HDXFÚ�×O?BG�pMG�l?aHÃXFHnCFKOØP?BA¨?sQjX�ØP?BCFHÃNPLOHnØP×WX\ØY?sQYXMÚ�ØPLX\EBEaÛ�QP×OCFNPØPG�N�?BH�ØPG�NPAÌQYC\Ù"ØP×WG&HqLOA&Þ¸G�N!C\Ù�ý�þ�VâWC�b)QPCFEBLkØj?aCMHWQ,NjG& RLO?BNPG_l�ØP×WXFHDØP×WX\Ø0NPG�KCMN�ØjG�l¨ÞqÛ¨æYX\NjpFG�Û�îaöFö�ð7á^LWQP?aHW].ØP×OGYQPXFA¨G�?aHO?aØP?sX\ElkG�QP?a]MHã�TqG�pFG�H�ØP×OCMLO]F×�bcGJX\NjG�Ø�XFÚ�iqEa?BHO]¨X;A&LWE�Øj?�ݾCFÞkä|G_Ú�Øj?apMGYCMKkØP?BAD?BQjX�Øj?aCMH�KONjCFÞOEBG�A+ß���HG�f�G�Ú�Ø"Øj×OG�XFlWlk?�Øj?aCMHWX\Eq?BHkÙ^CFNjAÌX�Øj?aCMH�KONjC�pq?BlOG�l.ØjCJØP×OG�lkG_Q�?B]FHWG�N"ÞqÛ;NjG�pFG_X\EB?aHW]�ØP×WG@ØPN�XFlkG�ÝC\f�Þ¸G�Ø|b�G�G�H�ØP×WG�ADXF?aH¨CFÞOä|G�Ú�Øj?apMG!á»ÞOEBCqÚ�i�XF]FG_ã7XFHWl;Øj×OG�Q�G_Ú�CMHWlOX\NjÛJCFÞkä|G_Ú�Øj?apMGJá^ØP×OG�*�m opUXFNP?sX�Øj?aCMH;?BH�ÞOEBCkÚ�i�X\]FGUã[Ú�CMQ�ØjQ7HOC\Øj×O?BHO]YÞ¸G�Ú�X\LWQPGcØP×OGH RLWX\EB?aØ|Û!CFÙWØj×OGcÞ¸G�Q�Ø,lkG�QP?B]FHWQ Ù^CFLWHWlb�?�Øj×�NPG_Q�K¸G�Ú�Ø�ØPCDØP×WG;KONj?aAÌX\NjÛ�CMÞkä|G�Ú�ØP?BpFGJ×WXUpFGJHOCFØ�Þ¸G�G�H�Ú�CFADKONjCFAD?BQPG�l½X�Ø!X\EBE[ÞqÛ�ØP×WGQ�b�?aØjÚ�×�ØPCÌA�LOE�Øj?�ݾCFÞOä|G�Ú�Øj?apMGJCFKkØj?aAD?sQPX\ØP?BCFH[ß

¦�l�� �����A{�������>s&t��L��s&��YKkØP?BAD?BQPG�lÅ]MG�CMA¨G�ØPNj?aG_QJÙ^CFLWHWl-Ù^CFN�CFLON¨Q�G_Ú�CFHlÃØjG�Q�بÚ�XFQPG=X\NjGÌKONjG�QPG�HRØPG_lù?aHÄþ7?B]MQ�ß�÷qT$OTOïÌX\HlÃö/.OTkb�×O?sÚ�×�Q�×OC�b(NPG_Q�K¸G�Ú�ØP?BpFG�EBÛÌØj×OG.EaC�b�G�Q�Ø�ÞOEBCqÚ�i�XF]FGJlkG�QP?a]MH[TOEBC�bcG_Q|Ø@G�HRØjNPCMKRÛ]FG�HWG�N�X�ØP?BCFHçlkG_Q�?B]FH X\HWl)Ø|b�CÁÚ�CMADKONPCMAD?BQPG�]FG�CFADG�ØjNP?BG�Q�Ù^NPCMA Øj×OGnØjNjXMlkG�ݾC\f Q�LONPÙ»XFÚ�Gá»þ7?a]ß°öFöUã�ßk>@×OG�QPGJÞOEsXFlkG_Q�XFNPGJX\]RX\?BH� RLO?aØPG.lk?af¸G�NPG�HMØ@ØjC�Øj×OG.lOX�ØjLOA ]MG�CFADG�ØPNjÛ¨LQ�G_l�ØjC

Page 9: Multi-objective Optimisation of Turbomachinery Blades Using Tabu Search Timoleon Kipourosi

0%132 µ�赶�· z��°��{|zj�|�J�B{|��v\�,�B�_�RvR�&�B��{0� · z�§M{|~¾�0�|zj~¾�, ���~�z?aHO?aØP?sX�ØjG,Øj×OG0CMKkØP?BAD?BQjX�Øj?aCMH[T�XFHWl.?BH&XFlOlO?�Øj?aCMH.ØP×OG�NPGcX\NjG0Q�?B]FHW?�èÚ�X\HRØ lk?af�G�NjG�HWÚ�G�Q[Þ¸G�Ø|b�G�G�HØP×OG�A½ß@>@×OGÊ8��ñC\ÙJØP×WG�QPG�]FG�CMADG�ØPNj?BG�QÌ?sQ=QP?aAD?BEBXFN�T0ÞOLkØ�lk?af�G�N�QÌÙ^NjCFA Øj×OG<8�� C\ÙJØP×WGQ�?BHO]FEBG�ݾCFÞOä|G�Ú�Øj?apMG=CMKkØP?BAD?BQPG�l:ÞOEsXFlkGùá»þ7?B]Wß � ã�ß,þOLONPØP×WG�NjA¨CMNPGMT�Øj×OG�NjG�X\NjG�Ú�CFHWQP?BlOG�N�X\ÞOEBGlk?�f�G�NjG�HÚ�G�Q=?aH ØP×OGhØPN�X\?BEa?BHO]ÅG_lk]FG)á»>H�cãÌÞG�Ø|bcG�G�HçØj×OGÃA�LOE�Øj?�ݾCFÞOä|G�Ú�Øj?apMGÃX\Hl Q�?BHO]MEaG�ÝCFÞkä|G_Ú�ØP?BpFG.lkG_Q�?B]FHQ�ß�¾Ø¨?sQDbcCMN�Øj×ÄNjG�AÌX\Njiq?aHO]ÃØP×WX\ØDÚ�CFADKONjCFAD?sQ�G�]FG�CMADG�ØPNjÛÅà á»þ7?a]ß,ïMã�lk?sQ�KOEsXUÛkQ&]MG�CFÝA¨G�ØPNj?BÚ�X\E0Ú�×X\N�XFÚ�ØjG�Nj?BQ�ØP?sÚ�Q!Ù^NjCFAÀÞCFØP×ùØj×OG�EBC�bcG_Q|Ø;ÞOEBCkÚ�i�X\]FG�á�þ ?B]Wß"÷\ã.XFHWlhØP×OG=EaC�b�G�Q�ØG�HRØPNjCFKqÛ�]FG�HOG�N�X�Øj?aCMHÁá»þ7?B]Wß�$Rã�lOG�QP?a]MHWQ�ß[æ�C�bcG�pFG�N�TØP×OGDÞO?B]�lk?af¸G�NPG�HWÚ�GDÞ¸G�Ø|b�G�G�HhØP×WG�QPGÞOEBXMlkG�Q&?BQ&?aHÄØP×OG=ØP?BKÄKONjC\èWEBG�Q�ß�þOCMN;Øj×OG=EBC�bcG_Q|Ø;ÞWEaCkÚ�i�X\]MG=lkG�QP?B]FHçá»þ7?B]Wß,÷\ã.XFHWlÄÚ�CMA¨ÝKONPCMAD?BQPG¨lOG�QP?a]MHh`ñá»þ7?B]Wß"ö/.Mã�T¸Ù^CMNYb�×O?sÚ�×hØP×OGDÞOEBCkÚ�iUXF]FG�?BQJX\EBADCMQ�ØJXMQ!EaC�b.T¸ØP×WG�NjG�?sQJXNjXFKO?Bl½Ú�×WXFHO]FG!?aH½Øj×OGJØP?BK�Ú�X\A�ÞG�N�Tkb�×W?BÚ�×½NPG_Q�LWE�Ø�Q@?aH�X�ØP×O?sÚ�i=KWNPCFèWEaGMTqb�×OG�NjG�XMQ�Ù^CFN@ØP×WG]FG�CMADG�ØPNj?BG�Q!?aHùþ7?a]RQ�ß!$+X\Hlhï=ØP×OG�NPGD?sQ.X�QPADCqC\ØP×ùÚ�×WXFHO]FG¨?aHhØP×WGDÚ�X\A�ÞG�N!CFÙ0Øj×OG¨ØP?BKKONPCFèWEBGFßO>@×O?sQ�]FG�CFADG�ØjNP?sÚ�XFE°Ú�×WX\N�XFÚ�ØPG�Nj?sQ|Øj?BÚ�?BQ�QP×WXFNPG_l�b�?aØP×½ØP×OG.ÞWEBXMlkG.?aH�þ7?B]Wß � ß

à�Q"NjG�]RX\N�lOQ"X\G�NPCklkÛqHWXFA¨?sÚ�KG�N�Ù^CMNPAÌXFHWÚ�GMT\X\EBEkØP×OG�ÞOEBXMlkG�Q,×WXUpFG�]MCRCkl°TF?�ß GFßFQPADCqC\ØP×WEaÛpUXFNPÛq?BHO]WT�X\Üq?sX\EkpMG�EBCkÚ�?aØ|Û&lk?sQ|ØjNP?BÞOLkØj?aCMHWQ�ß\æ�C�bcG�pFG�N�T_ØP×WG�NjG�?sQ"HOCFØP?sÚ�G_X\ÞOEBG�âWC�b:QPG�KWXFNjX\ØP?BCFHX\EBCFHO]�ØP×OG;>H�üCFÙ�Øj×OG.ÞOEsXFlkGJCFKOØP?BA¨?sQPG�l�Ù^CFN�EBC�bcG_Q|Ø�G�HMØjNPCMKqÛÌ]FG�HWG�N�X�ØP?BCFH�ß

>@×OG,g"X\NjG�ØjC0Ù^NjCFHRØ�QP×OC�b�Q�ØP×X�Ø�QP?a]MHO?�è¸Ú�X\HRØ[K¸G�NPÙ^CFNjAÌX\HWÚ�G7?BADKONjC�pFG�ADG�HMØ�Q°X\NjG"XFÚ�×O?BG�pRÝX\ÞOEBGFß[þWCFN.?BHWQ|Ø�X\HWÚ�GFT[Ú�CFADKONjCFAD?BQPGDlkG�QP?a]MH-`3á»þ7?a]ß,ö&.RãYNPG_lkLWÚ�G_QYØP×OGÌÞOEBCkÚ�i�X\]FGDQP?a]MHO?�ÙÊÝ?BÚ�X\HRØPEBÛhÚ�CFADKWX\NjG�lÃØPCnØP×OGÌ?BHO?aØP?sX\EclWX�ØPLWA6lkG_Q�?B]FHçá�þ ?B]Wß�úFã!b�?aØP×ÅpMG�NjÛnEa?aØ�ØjEaG=?aHWÚ�NPG_XFQPG?aH+Øj×OG;N�X�ØPG.CFÙ"G�HRØPNjCFKqÛ�]MG�HOG�NjX\ØP?BCFH[ßW>@×WG;EaC�b�G�Q�Ø�ÞOEBCqÚ�i�XF]FG;lkG_Q�?B]FHÅá»þ7?B]Wß°÷\ã@K¸G�NPÙ^CFNjAÌQ

Page 10: Multi-objective Optimisation of Turbomachinery Blades Using Tabu Search Timoleon Kipourosi

0%132 µ&ÏWµ"¶ zj~¾�J ���~�z��/Ð ¶�· z¨���M�|xy�.xy~�z���w_z����.zj��{��½�B��{&�Ì ��_�.�F{|�_�.xy~�z&�k�_xyv��J�_v�� · z¨�°��{|zj�|��a{|�_v���É^��xywM¿qªUË

0�162 µ&ÑWµW¶�· z����M�|xy�.xy~�z��¨w�z��_�.zj��{��;�B��{,� · z�~�xyvRw��yzjº»�_�\¼¾z� j�|xy�Uz��|z�~¾�0 ���~�z�Ò��_�|ÓÚ�CFADKWXFNjXFÞOEBÛJØPC.æ�XFNPpMG�ÛED Q7ÞOEBCkÚ�i�X\]FG�Ý¢CMKkØP?BAD?BQPG�l;ÞOEBXMlkG;á»þ7?B]Wß � ã�ÞWLkØ,×WXFQ"XJQP?a]MHO?aèÚ�XFHMØjEaÛEaC�b�G�N@G�HRØjNPCMKRÛÌ]MG�HOG�NjX\ØP?BCFH½NjX\ØPGMß��HMØjG�NjG�Q�ØP?BHO]FEBÛÄØj×OGÃg"XFNPG�ØPC-Ù^NPCMHRØ=X\EsQ�CÅG�Üq×W?aÞO?aØjQ�XÅQ�×X\NjK òPG�EBÞC�b�ôÅXFNPCMLOHWlüÚ�CMA¨ÝKONPCMAD?BQPG¨lOG�QP?a]MHh`!ß!*�G�EsX�Øj?apMG&ØjC=Øj×O?BQ.lOG�QP?a]MH[T�?�Ø.?sQJKCRQPQP?aÞWEaG�ØPC½NPG_lkLWÚ�G&Øj×OGDÞOEaCkÚ�i�X\]MGCFÞkä|G_Ú�ØP?BpFG&ÞOLkØJCFHOEBÛ�X�Ø�Øj×OGDÚ�CMQ�Ø�CFÙ� RLO?�ØjG&EsX\Nj]FG;?BHWÚ�NPG_XFQPG�Q�?BHÃG�HMØjNPCMKqÛ�]MG�HOG�NjX\ØP?BCFH[ß#�¾Ø?BQDX\EsQPCÃK¸CMQjQ�?BÞOEBG�ØPC-NjG�lkLWÚ�G�Øj×OG+NjX\ØPG=CFÙ�G�HRØjNPCMKRÛ-]FG�HOG�N�X�Øj?aCMHÄÞOLkØDCFHWEaÛÅX�بØP×WG½Ú�CMQ�ØC\Ù0QP?a]MHO?�è¸Ú�X\HRØjEaÛ½?aHÚ�NjG�XFQPG�l+ÞWEaCkÚ�i�X\]MGFß��H�ØP×O?sQ!Ú�XFQPG;Øj×OG�lOG�QP?a]MHOG�NYA¨?B]F×RØ!èWHWl�?aØ� MLW?�ØjGQ|ØjNjXF?a]M×MØPÙ^CFNjb�XFNjlÌØPCÌQ�G�EaG_Ú�Ø�X¨]FCqCkl½Ú�CFADKONjCFAD?sQ�GJlkG_Q�?B]FH[ß

Ô ;hÒcÏ�Õ!¥�Ô-�qÖ|Ò0Ï-�Õ�"Ï�ÓËÖ�Ô�ÐkÔ�Ñ��Ø× Ò,ÑTÙ>@×OG�Ù^CMNPG�]FCM?aHO];ØPG�Q�Ø�Ú�XFQPG�Q�lkG�A¨CMHWQ�ØPN�X�ØPG�ØP×WX\Ø�CMLON�A&LOEaØP?aÝ¢CMÞkä|G�Ú�ØP?BpFG!?aHRØjG�]FN�X�ØjG�l¨ØjLONPÞ¸C\ÝADXMÚ�×O?BHOG�NjÛ&lkG_Q�?B]FH¨CFKkØj?aAD?sQPX\ØP?BCFHÌQPÛqQ�ØPG�A Ú�XFHÌQ�LWÚ�Ú�G_QPQ�Ù^LOEBEaÛ.Ø�XFÚ�iqEBG�NjG�XFEa?sQ�ØP?sÚcNjG�XFE�ݾb�CFNjEBl

Page 11: Multi-objective Optimisation of Turbomachinery Blades Using Tabu Search Timoleon Kipourosi

0%132 µ/ÚkµW¶ z�~¾�0 ���~�zY��Ð ¶�· z��_�M�|xy�.xy~�z��&w_z����.zj��{����B��{0�y��¹�z�~¾�c�R�y�� �Æ_��w_z.É^��xywM¿�_��Ë

KONPCMÞOEBG�AÌQ�T°HWG�]FCFØP?sX�Øj?aHO]�ØP×WGÌ×O?a]M×OEBÛÃÚ�CMHWQ|ØjNjXF?aHWG�l°T�HOCMHOEa?BHOG_X\N.Q�G_X\N�Ú�×hQPKWXFÚ�GFT[XFHWlÃKWNPG�ÝQ�G�HMØj?aHW]�Øj×OG&lkG_Q�?B]FHWG�N@b�?�Øj×nX¨NjXFHO]FGJC\Ù�lkG�QP?B]FHWQ�QP×OC�b�?BHO]¨ØP×OGJØjNjXMlkG�ݾC\f°Q@ÞG�Ø|bcG�G�H½ØP×WGCFÞkä|G_Ú�ØP?BpFG_Q@LOHWlkG�N�Ú�CMHWQ�?slkG�NjX\ØP?BCFH[ß

��H:Þ¸C\Øj×:ØjG�Q�Ø=Ú�XMQ�G_Q¨ØP×OG�K¸G�NPÙ^CFNjAÌX\HWÚ�G½CFÙ�Øj×OGnlkG�QP?B]FHWQ¨Ù^CMLOHWl)AÌX�ØjÚ�×üCMN¨G�ÜOÚ�G�G_lØP×OGDK¸G�NPÙ^CFNjADXFHWÚ�G¨C\Ù0ØP×OGÌCMKkØP?BAD?BQPG�lÃÞOEBXMlkGD?BlOG�HRØP?aèWG�lh?BH-XFHÃG�XFNPEB?BG�N.Q�?BHO]MEaG�Ý¢CMÞkä|G�Ú�ØP?BpFGQ|ØjLWlkÛFßM>@×OG�Ú�CMA¨KWLkØjX\ØP?BCFHWXFERG�f¸CMN�Ø,NjG& RLO?BNjG�l.ØjC;Q�CMEapMG0Øj×OG�QPG�A&LWE�Øj?�ݾCFÞkä|G_Ú�Øj?apMG�KWNPCMÞOEaG�AÌQb�XMQ;HOChA¨CMNPG=ØP×WXFHÅØP×X�Ø�NjG& RLO?BNjG�lùØjChQPCFEBpFGÌØj×OG�QP?aHW]FEBG�ݾCFÞkä|G_Ú�ØP?BpFG=KONPCMÞOEBG�A X\HWl[T ?BHXFlOlk?aØP?BCFHhØPC+G/ MLX\EBEaÛn]MCqCqlÃCFN.Þ¸G�ØPØPG�N;lOG�QP?a]MHWQ�T�Øj×OGÌlkG�QP?B]FHOG�N.?BQ.XFEBQPC�KWNPG_Q�G�HMØjG�lÃb�?�Øj××OG�EBKkÙ^LOE°?BHkÙ^CFNjAÌX�Øj?aCMH=X\Þ¸CFLkØ�ØP×WG�ØjNjXMlkG�ݾC\f°Q0Þ¸G�Ø|b�G�G�H�Øj×OGYCMÞkä|G�Ú�ØP?BpFG_Q0CFÙ�?aHRØjG�NjG�Q�Ø�ßq>@×O?BQlkG�ADCFHQ|ØjNjX\ØPG�Q@pMG�NjÛ�Ú�EBG�XFNPEBÛDØP×OG.p�XFEaLOG.CFÙ A�LOE�Øj?�ݾCFÞOä|G�Ú�Øj?apMGJCFKkØj?aAD?sQPX\ØP?BCFH[ß

>@×OG0Ù»XMÚ�ØjCFN�Q�?BHkâWLOG�HWÚ�?BHO]JGC��Ú�?aG�HWÚ�Û.CFÙOØPLONjÞ¸CFAÌXFÚ�×O?BHOG�NPÛJÞOEsXFlkG_Q�X\HWl;ØP×OG�ØPN�XFlOG�ݾC\f°QÞG�Ø|bcG�G�H�ØP×OG�AÿX\NjG�G�ÜqØPNjG�ADG�EBÛ;Ú�CMADKOEaG�Ü�X\Hl.ØP×WG�NjG�Ù^CFNjG�ØP×O?sQ"X\NjG�X�HOG�G_lOQ7Ù^LONPØP×OG�N"?aHqpMG�Q�ÝØP?B]MX�Øj?aCMH[ßF>@×OG�HWG�ÜqØ0Q|ØjG�KWQ,b�?aEBEOÞ¸G�ØPC.lkG�èWHOG�XMlOlk?aØP?BCFHWXFEkEaCRQPQ�CMÞkä|G�Ú�ØP?BpFG�Q"Ù^CFN�ØP×WG�lkG�QP?a]MHKONPCMÞOEBG�A3G�ÜOX\AD?aHWG�l+X\Þ¸C�pFGMßO>@×RLQ�TOHWG�b CFÞkä|G_Ú�Øj?apMGYÙ^LWHWÚ�Øj?aCMHWQ�b�?BEaE G�p�X\EBLWX\ØPG.?BHWlk?BpR?slkLkÝX\EBEaÛJØj×OG�KONjC\èWEBGcEBCMQjQPG�Q�X\HWl;ØP×OG�QPG�Ú�CFHWlWX\NjÛ!EBCMQjQPG�Q7?aH¨CFN�lkG�N�ØjC!?BADKONjC�pFG�LOHWlkG�NjQ�ØjXFHWlk?BHO]C\Ù�ØP×OGDØjNjXMlkG�ݾC\f°QJÞG�Ø|bcG�G�H-ØP×WG�A ?BHÅlkG�QP?B]FH[ß�>@×WG�QPGÌ?aHqpFG_Q|Øj?a]RX�Øj?aCMHWQ!b�?aEBE,NjG& RLO?BNPG¨ØP×WGØjXFÚ�iqEB?aHW];C\Ù�ØP×WNPG�G�Ý7XFHWl¨Ù^CFLWN�ݾCFÞkä|G_Ú�Øj?apMG�KONPCMÞOEBG�AÌQ0XFHWlDb�?aEBEØP×OG�NPG�Ù^CFNjG�X\EsQ�C;XFEaEBC�büLWQ"ØjCØPG�Q�Ø�ØP×OG�G�f�G�Ú�ØP?BpFG�HOG�QjQ7C\ÙCMLON7A&LOEaØP?aÝ¢CMÞkä|G�Ú�ØP?BpFG@> o p�XFNP?sX\HRØ CMH;Øj×OG�QPGc×W?a]M×OG�N"lk?BADG�HWQP?aCMHKONPCMÞOEBG�AÌQ�ß

>�CJ?BA¨KWNPC�pMGcÙ^LWN�Øj×OG�N�Øj×OG�G�f�G�Ú�ØP?BpFG�HOG�QjQ�C\Ù�CFLON"A�LOEaØP?aÝ¢CMÞkä|G�Ú�ØP?BpFG�> o pUXFNP?sX\HRØ,XJADCFNjGQ�CMKO×O?sQ|Øj?BÚ�X�ØPG_l�QPÛkQ|ØjG�A3Ù^CFN�QPG�EBG�Ú�ØP?BHO]¨ØP×OG;lkG_Q�?B]FH+p�X\Nj?sX\ÞOEBG�Q�ØjCÌÞG.ADCklk?aèWG�l½?BH+QPG�XFNjÚ�×�TÞWXFQPG�l-CFHùØj×OG�b�CFNjiÃCFÙ@IJG�EaEsX\N=îaö/'�ð¢T�b�?aEBE0Þ¸G=lkG�pFG�EBCFK¸G�l[ß >@×O?sQ.b�?BEaE@Q�G�G�iÃØPC�?slkG�HRØP?aÙ^ÛØP×OGÌp�X\Nj?sX\ÞOEBG�QYØP×X�Ø.×WXUpFG¨Øj×OGD]FNjG�X�ØjG�Q�Ø!?BADKWXFÚ�Ø;CFHhØP×OGÌK¸G�NPÙ^CFNjAÌX\HWÚ�G�CFÙ0Øj×OG�Ú�LONjNjG�HRØlkG�QP?a]MHÅX\HWl-KONj?aCMNP?aØP?sQPG�Øj×OG�A6X�Ø;G_XFÚ�×ùEaCkÚ�X\E,QPG�X\N�Ú�×-?�ØjG�N�X�ØP?BCFH�ß!�¾Ø&?BQ;×OCFK¸G�lhØP×X�Ø;Øj×O?BQb�?aEBE[?BA¨KWNPC�pMG�Øj×OG.b�XFEaEaÝ�Ú�EBCqÚ�iÌK¸G�NPÙ^CFNjAÌX\HWÚ�GYCFÙ Øj×OG;QPÛqQ�ØPG�A3QPLOÞWQ�ØjX\HRØj?BXFEaEBÛFß

Page 12: Multi-objective Optimisation of Turbomachinery Blades Using Tabu Search Timoleon Kipourosi

0%132 µ&ÛWµW¶ zj~¾�c ���~�zY��Ð ¶�· z����M�|xy�.xy~�z���w�z��_�.zj��{��&�s��{0����¹7z�~¾��zjv\��{|������w�z�vRzP{����|xy�_v+É^��xywF¿¸�_��ËÜ �/Ý���{�Þ�xn�>�Nß�>àá�>�Et/s>@×OG.èWN�Q|Ø!X\LkØj×OCFNY]FN�X�ØPG�Ù^LOEBEaÛ½XFÚ�iqHOC�b�EBG�lk]MG�Q�ØP×WG�QPLOKOK¸CFNPØ�C\Ù�ØP×WGL�,A�ÞO?BNP?sÚ�CRQ�þOCMLOHWlOX\ÝØP?BCFHÃXFHWl�Øj×OGÌý�XFA&ÞONj?slk]FGd�0LONjCFK¸G�X\Hn> NjLWQ|Ø_߸>@×WG�QPG�Ú�CMHWlnXFLkØP×OCMN!XMÚ�iqHOC�b�EaG_lk]FG_Q@ØP×WGQ�LOKWKCMN�Ø�CFÙqØP×OG�(YI��,HO]M?aHOG�G�Nj?aHW]@XFHWl.g,×qÛkQP?BÚ�X\E o Ú�?aG�HWÚ�G_Q�*�G_Q�G_X\N�Ú�×;ýcCMLOHWÚ�?aEWán�0g o *�ý@ãLOHWlkG�N�]FN�X\HRØ�HRLWA&Þ¸G�N�eâ*-¢�* � 7ö&.A.�¢�.WöFߤã���|��Ñ���Ï�ÕE�����¿�¤0�y����¦O¿y�Eä�w_�����°©�¿y�°��zj�å¿���È�¿åÐ�¦\�|��  · ��~¾�|xy �¤0�R�F{|�U��  · �|��ä��M�|xy�;����¤czP{|�\�F�Fvq���.x� .¦ · ���kz}@zj~�x�w�v¿�æ_�_�F{|vq���W����¤0x�{| j{����a��¿ Í�Í É¾� ¾/¾/ç Ë ¾ µ ç à ¾&ç ���¿�¤0~�~�z��yx�vFº¢©¨x��y�yzj{��U�c¿�¦O¿ÀÐ�È0�_�R�M~¾�[��}�º�¤czj{|���s�_xy�\}@z�~�xyw�v#Ð��[{|�����q���k�7��vR �z��F��¿�ª�� ·Hè z���{°�°{|��¼¾z� j�È0z��k��{���¿M��vMxy�Uzj{|~�x��¢�&���[�����!�F{|x��Mw_z��R}@zj�q��{��|�.zjv\�����[u[vRw�x�vMz�zj{|xyvRwÌÉ»��¬_¬�«UË«\¿��7�y����{��[©�¿T¶P¿¥Y¿y��éÅxy�y~��_v��©�¿#æM¿ÀÐu�ê. jx�zjv\���°��{����.zj�|zP{|x�~|���|xy�_v+���,¥�z�vMzj{|xy .¤cx�{| j{����B�Y¥�zjº���.zj��{���¿iæ_�_�F{|vq���W����¤0x�{| j{����a��¿ Í�j ɾ� ¾/¾ µ�Ë���� ç&¾ Ãq��� » µªF¿��7��vRvR��{��M¤�¿R©�¿y� ¶ xy�y�yzj���F}!¿M¥Y¿ÀÐM¤ ¶ ���R�¨¦Fz���{|  · ©¨zj� · �\�&�s��{"� · zYä��M�|xy�.xy~|���|xy�_v&���������Mx������¹�zP{��7x�{| ��Mxy�|~�¿>¶�©¨z�  · u<æ_�_�F{|vq������ ¦\�F~¾�|z��.~"��vq�D�7��v���{|�_�Ê¿ jT4�j ɾ� ¾/¾&ë Ë"« » «CÃ\« ë �µ�¿@}���¹7z�~��=éü¿�ì�¿ÀÐ"}@z��Uzj�����R�.z�v��&���Y��«�}íì����\xyzj{�º¢¦\�|��ÆUz�~&~��_�y�Uzj{&�s��{����M�R�yxy ����|xy��vÄ�|�Ã��������M�kzj~c��� �|�F{|�k�_�;��  · xyvMzj{���¿q¤�¦R©DuÄ�7��vM�szP{|z�vR �z!�°���kzj{ ë/ë º¾¥ ¶ º » ¬F¿W¤@¦M©DuÄ¥@��~ ¶ �M{|�Mx�vMz�7��vM�szP{|z�vR �z��O¤c�.~¾�|zj{��M���D¿kɾ� ¾/ë&ë Ëç ¿@}���¹7z�~��!éü¿!ì�¿�����z��y�a��{��!éü¿[��¿y�!î@��{|�Uzj���°¦O¿[¤�¿���} · ��vq��~�zjÆ_��{���v�°�°¿[�c¿�� ¦F���Fxy�y�Ê�[¤�¿[©�¿������v\���\È�¿F¦k¿åÐ\©D��vq��w_xyvRw�� · zc¥�z����.zj��{��.xy~�¡Wx��.x��|xyvRw�� · z�¤0�Rxy�yxy���J���°����}Á�|�!©D��vq��w_zc� · z���y��¹�¿O«_«�{��̤�¶¢¤�¤Á�����Mx��¨}��Fvq���.x� j~��7��vM�Bzj{|z�vR jz_��äc{|����vR�M�F�k���y��{|x��R�\¿O¤�¶¢¤�¤,º¾��¬_¬�«�º�« » «U�\¿É»��¬_¬_«_Ë» ¿@}@zj�¨�J¿y�k©¨�M���|xyºïä��\¼¾z� P�|x��_z�ä��M�|xy�.xÀ¿����|xy��v¨�R~�xyvMwJu[�U�_�y�M�|xy��vq��{��¨¤c�yw���{|x�� · �.~�¿iæ_� · v9éÅxy�yzj�ð ¦F��vR~,¡O���W¿y�k� · xy  · z�~¾�|zj{0��� É»��¬_¬F��Ëë ¿@}@zjv\�|��v��æM¿�}!¿ÀÐ�¡W�_~�~�©¨z�  · ��vRxy~��.~°xyv ¶ �F{|�k�_�;��  · x�vMz�~�¿�æ_���M{|vq���\��� ¶ �M{|�k�_�;��  · xyvRzj{���¿ 4�4AÏɾ� ¾/¾ «_Ë ç �\�ºÃ ç µ ç¾ ¿�¥@��xa�M�M��v�0¤�¿y�"��vMxyw · ����}!¿�}!¿y�,���_�y�_vMxÊ�@�c¿ÀÐ0©¨�M���|x� P{|xy�|zP{|xa�Ã}@z�~�xyw_vñä��F�|x��.xy~|���|x���vÄ���!�¦\�R�kzj{|~���vRxy §¶¢vR�yzj������~�z��ù�R�k��vÄ¥��y�_�R����©¨xy~�~�xy�yz+��zj{��B��{|�;��vM �z_¿�æ_�_�F{|vq���������°{|�_�R�M�y~�x���v��vq�D����¹�zP{�¿ j>ò É»��¬_¬�ª�Ë�µ�ª���ÃAµ&µ ë

Page 13: Multi-objective Optimisation of Turbomachinery Blades Using Tabu Search Timoleon Kipourosi

0%132 µ&óWµ ¶ z�~¾�Y ���~�z¨��Ð ¶�· z;�_�F�|x��.xy~�z��+w�z��_�.zP��{����B��{J j�_�.�M{|���.xy~�z.�k�_xyv��!¤ ��v+� · z;�°��{|zj�|��a{|�_v���É^��xywM¿¸����Ë

��¬F¿�¥��y���Uzj{����7¿y�°¡¸��w_�Mvq�F�°©�¿ÀÐ ¶ ���M�n¦Fz���{|  · ¿����y��¹�zP{!¤0 ��_�Fz��.xy ;���M�R�yxy~ · zj{|~��°�7�_~¾�|��véD¤É¾� ¾/¾5» Ë���_¿Hî���{|�UzP���°¦k¿[¤�¿ÀÐ ¶�· z�}@zj~�x�w�v<ä��M�|xy�.xy~|���|xy�_vn��� ¶ �F{|�k�_�;��  · x�vMzj{���� �a���Mz&Èc��¹,~�¿�� · ¿ }!¿}@xy~�~�zj{������|xy�_v¿R��vMx��_zj{|~�x��¢�&��� �����!�M{|x��Fw_zJÉ»��¬_¬U��Ë���\¿Hîc���_ÆUz��OÈ�¿y�#æ_z�z��_z�~�� ¶ ¿åÐW}@x�{|z� P�Y¦Fz���{|  · ¦F�����F�|xy�_v=����ìc�R�.zj{|xy ����[��vR�½¦������|xy~¾�|xy ���� �[{|���Mº�yz��.~�¿>æ_�_�F{|vq���¸���¸� · z�¤0�"©�¿ Û É¾� ¾/ç ��Ë0�\���ÂÃF��� ¾��«F¿�æ_��z�w�w_xÊ�\}!¿\©�¿y�F¤0~�~�z��yx�vFº¢©¨x��y�yzj{��M�c¿F¦k¿y���°��{|Æ\~��F¥Y¿ ¶ ¿��U��x��k���M{|��~�� ¶ ¿y�F�7z��y�Ê� ¶ ¿y�F�7����{|Æ\~��_vW���¿æM¿ÀÐ[©¨�R���|x�º»�_�\¼¾z� P�|x��_z;�°��{����y�yz�� ¶ ���R�+¦Fz���{|  · ¿¶�v#Ð è ���M�#ôY¿y�¸�7�M{|Æ_z_�u,¿y�°¡W�/¿���vR�F�!æ�º�¤�¿y�¦\�.xy� · �ÂæM¿y��©¨zj{|zj����º¢¥��Rzj{|�U��~���æM¿y���7�R�y�yxyvq��{|xa�\��æM¿y��Èc��¹7z_�CæM¿y� ¶ xyvR�F���°¿y�������q��v��¤�¿���¦F  · ¹7zj�szj�^�î0º¢��¿¸ÉÊz��M~�¿ ˱ÐW�°��{����y��zj�[�[{|���R�yz��ñ¦\�_�y�\xyvRw.�B{|���?ì����|�M{|zHè� � ¦Aì «�¶)¶)¶P¿q¡z� j�|�F{|z-ìc���|z�~cxyv�7���.�R�M�|zP{c¦F �xyz�vM �z_�i« ���^¿R«U��ª���¿W¦F�F{|x�vMw_zj{�ºr«�zj{|����wF�q�7zP{|��xyv+É»��¬_¬�ª�Ë » «U��à » ªM��jªM¿�æ_��z�w�w_xÊ�F}!¿\©�¿y�F�°��{|Æ\~��F¥Y¿ ¶ ¿��U��x��k���M{|��~�� ¶ ¿��\�7�a��{|Æ\~��_v�F��¿�æF¿åÐF¤Ä©¨�M���|xyº»���F¼¢z� j�|xy�Uz ¶ ���M�¦\z���{|  · ¤c�yw���{|x�� · � �B��{¨�7�_vM~¾��{���xyvRz��õä��F�|xy�.x�~|���|xy�_v¿�¶¢vTÐ «�{��ö¶�v\��¿7�7��vM�¢¿�u��_�_�y�M�|xy�_vR��{��©¨�M�y�|x�º¢� {|x��|zj{|xy�_vLä��M�|xy�.xÀ¿����|x���v¿U¡z� j�|�F{|z=ì����|z�~ xyv;�7���.�R�F�|zj{7¦F �xyz�vM �z_�\¦\�M{|xyvRw�zj{�ºr« zP{|�a��wM��7zP{|��xyv�É»��¬_¬5µ�Ë

�µ\¿���zj������{��iéü¿Aì�¿åÐR¥�z����.zj��{���©¨�\�Mzj��xyvMwJxyvÌ�7�_�.�M�M�����|x���vq������y�Mxa�&}��Fvq���.x� j~"��vR�&}@zj~�x�w�vä��F�|x��.xy~|���|x���v¿R� · ¿ }!¿R}�x�~�~�zP{������|xy�_vW¿q��vMxy�Uzj{|~�x��¢�&���[�����!�F{|x��Mw_z.É»��¬_¬_�_Ë� ç ¿���xy�k���M{|�_~�� ¶ ¿��q�°��{|Æ\~��W¥Y¿ ¶ ¿y�W¦F���Fxy�y�Ê�k¤�¿O©�¿y��æU��z�w_w�x^�O}Y¿O©�¿ÀÐW©¨�R���|x�º»�_�\¼¾z� P�|x��_z!¤0zj{|�\�F�\ºvR���.xy .}@z�~�xyw_v÷ä��F�|xy�.x�~|���|xy�_v¿#¶¢vTа¥�x���vRvq��ÆU�_w��y�_����J¿°�c¿y�!î��_��~�z��éü¿7ÉÊz��M~�¿ ˱иu�È0�=ä@�¸º¶ ¤0�-}@zj~�x�w�v§ä��M�|xy�.xÀ¿����|x���v#ÐR©¨zj� · �\�M~0��vR�¨¤c�M�R�yxy ����|xy��vR~c�7�_vF�szj{|z�vM �z��°{|�� �z�z��Fx�vMw_~�¿Tä�v�7}@È0�_�ñÉ»��¬_¬�ª�Ë,�°���kzj{cu[È0�=ä�}�ä���¬�¬�ª�ø_��« ¾� » ¿Hìcz��.z� _�©�¿y���OxyvMw_wM�¸}!¿�éü¿y����M���yx����D� ¶ ¿#îY¿Àа©¨�M���|x��k��xyv\����vq�½©¨�R���|x�º����F¼¢z� j�|xy�Uz;¤0zj{|��º�\�MvR���.xy �¦ · ���kzHä��M�|xy�.xÀ¿����|xy�_vW¿q¤�¶¾¤c¤ñæ_���M{|vR���Ê¿ Î�j É»��¬_¬�ª�Ë@��¬/µ » ÃR��¬ ç µ� ë ¿�È0�_w�zj{|~��}!¿��7¿Àи¤cvù¶¢v���{|�\�M�M j�|xy�_v��|�9ì���Èc�"¦�éÅx�� · î�xy~¾�|��{|x� �������zP{|~��kz� j�|xy�Uz_¿°©¨��{|wU��v�����M�s�;��vRv¨���M�R�yxy~ · zj{|~��q¦M��vÌ�M{���vM �xy~� ��;��¤ É»��¬_¬�¬UË

Page 14: Multi-objective Optimisation of Turbomachinery Blades Using Tabu Search Timoleon Kipourosi

0%132 µ�4�òµ°¶ z�~¾�� ���~�z;��Ð ¶�· z!�_�F�|xy�.x�~�z���w�z��_�.zP��{��D�s��{� ��_�.�F{|�_�.xy~�zY�k��xyv\�@�:��v=� · z!�°��{|zj�|��a{|�_v���É^��xywM¿¸����Ë

0%132 µ�4�4qµk¶�· z����M�|xy�.xy~|���|xy�_v&~�z���{|  · �q�����|zj{|v&��vq�J� · z@�°��{|zP�|���a{|�_v��7�B��{"� · z0~�z� ���vq�J�|z�~¾�" ���~�z