identification of type 2 diabetes loci in 433,540 east …1 1 identification of type 2 diabetes loci...
TRANSCRIPT
1
Identificationoftype2diabeteslociin433,540EastAsianindividuals12CassandraNSpracklen1,83,MomokoHorikoshi2,83,YoungJinKim3,83,KuangLin4,83,FionaBragg4,Sanghoon3Moon3,KenSuzuki2,5,6,7,ClaudiaHTTam8,9,YasuharuTabara10,Soo-HeonKwak11,FumihikoTakeuchi12,4JirongLong13,VictorJYLim14,Jin-FangChai14,Chien-HsiunChen15,MasahiroNakatochi16,JieYao17,Hyeok5SunChoi18,ApoorvaKIyengar1,HannahJPerrin1,SarahMBrotman1,MartijnvandeBunt19,20,AnnaL6Gloyn19,20,21,JenniferEBelow22,23,MichaelBoehnke24,DonaldWBowden25,26,JohnCChambers27,28,29,30,31,7AnubhaMahajan19,20,MarkIMcCarthy19,20,21,#,MaggieCYNg22,25,LaurenEPetty22,23,WeihuaZhang28,29,8AndrewPMorris20,32,33,LindaSAdair34,ZhengBian35,JulianaCNChan8,9,36,37,Li-ChingChang15,Miao-Li9Chee38,Yii-DerIdaChen17,Yuan-TsongChen15,ZhengmingChen4,Lee-MingChuang39,40,ShufaDu34,10PennyGordon-Larsen34,MyronGross41,XiuqingGuo17,YuGuo35,SoheeHan3,Annie-GreenHoward42,11WeiHuang43,Yi-JenHung44,45,MiYeongHwang3,Chii-MinHwu46,47,SahokoIchihara48,MasatoIsono12,12Hye-MiJang3,GuozhiJiang8,9,JostBJonas49,YoichiroKamatani5,50,TomohiroKatsuya51,52,Takahisa13Kawaguchi10,Chiea-ChuenKhor53,54,KatsuhikoKohara55,Myung-ShikLee56,NannetteRLee57,LimingLi58,14JianjunLiu53,59,AndreaOLuk8,9,JunLv58,YukinoriOkada7,60,MarkAPereira61,Charumathi15Sabanayagam38,62,63,JinxiuShi43,DongMunShin3,WingYeeSo8,36,AtsushiTakahashi5,64,Brian16Tomlinson8,Fuu-JenTsai65,RobMvanDam14,59,66,Yong-BingXiang67,KenYamamoto68,Toshimasa17Yamauchi6,KyungheonYoon3,CanqingYu58,Jian-MinYuan69,70,LiangZhang38,WeiZheng13,Michiya18Igase71,YoonShinCho18,JeromeIRotter72,Ya-XingWang73,WayneHHSheu45,47,74,MitsuhiroYokota75,19Jer-YuarnWu15,Ching-YuCheng38,62,63,Tien-YinWong38,62,63,Xiao-OuShu13,NorihiroKato12,Kyong-Soo20Park11,76,77,E-ShyongTai14,59,78,FumihikoMatsuda10,Woon-PuayKoh14,79,RonaldCWMa8,9,36,37,Shiro21Maeda2,80,81,IonaYMillwood4,82,JuyoungLee3,TakashiKadowaki6,84*,RobinGWalters4,82,84*,Bong-Jo22Kim3,84*,KarenLMohlke1,84*,XuelingSim14,84*23241 DepartmentofGenetics,UniversityofNorthCarolinaatChapelHill,ChapelHill,NC,USA252 LaboratoryforEndocrinology,MetabolismandKidneyDiseases,RIKENCentreforIntegrative26
MedicalSciences,Yokohama,Japan273 DivisionofGenomeResearch,CenterforGenomeScience,NationalInstituteofHealth,Cheongju-28
si,Korea294 NuffieldDepartmentofPopulationHealth,UniversityofOxford,Oxford,UK305 LaboratoryforStatisticalandTranslationalGenetics,RIKENCentreforIntegrativeMedical31
Sciences,Yokohama,Japan326 DepartmentofDiabetesandMetabolicDiseases,GraduateSchoolofMedicine,TheUniversityof33
Tokyo,Tokyo,Japan347 DepartmentofStatisticalGenetics,OsakaUniversityGraduateSchoolofMedicine,Osaka,Japan358 DepartmentofMedicineandTherapeutics,TheChineseUniversityofHongKong,HongKong,36
China379 ChineseUniversityofHongKong-ShanghaiJiaoTongUniversityJointResearchCentreinDiabetes38
GenomicsandPrecisionMedicine,TheChineseUniversityofHongKong,HongKong,China3910 CenterforGenomicMedicine,KyotoUniversityGraduateSchoolofMedicine,Kyoto,Japan4011 DepartmentofInternalMedicine,SeoulNationalUniversityHospital,Seoul,SouthKorea4112 DepartmentofGeneDiagnosticsandTherapeutics,ResearchInstitute,NationalCenterforGlobal42
HealthandMedicine,Tokyo,Japan4313 DivisionofEpidemiology,DepartmentofMedicine,VanderbiltUniversityMedicalCenter,44
Nashville,TN,USA4514 SawSweeHockSchoolofPublicHealth,NationalUniversityofSingaporeandNationalUniversity46
HealthSystem,Singapore,Singapore4715 InstituteofBiomedicalSciences,AcademiaSinica,Taipei,Taiwan48
.CC-BY 4.0 International licensecertified by peer review) is the author/funder. It is made available under aThe copyright holder for this preprint (which was notthis version posted June 28, 2019. . https://doi.org/10.1101/685172doi: bioRxiv preprint
2
16 DepartmentofNursing,NagoyaUniversityGraduateSchoolofMedicine,NagoyaUniversity49Hospital,Nagoya,Japan50
17 DepartmentofPediatrics,TheInstituteforTranslationalGenomicsandPopulationSciences,51LABioMedatHarbor-UCLAMedicalCenter,Torrance,CA,USA52
18 BiomedicalScience,HallymUniversity,Chuncheon,SouthKorea5319 OxfordCentreforDiabetes,EndocrinologyandMetabolism,UniversityofOxford,Oxford,UK5420 WellcomeCentreforHumanGenetics,UniversityofOxford,Oxford,UK5521 OxfordNIHRBiomedicalResearchCentre,OxfordUniversityHospitalsNHSFoundationTrust,56
ChurchillHospital,Oxford,UK5722 VanderbiltGeneticsInstitute,DivisionofGeneticMedicine,VanderbiltUniversityMedicalCenter,58
Nashville,TN,USA5923 HumanGeneticsCenter,SchoolofPublicHealth,TheUniversityofTexasHealthScienceCenterat60
Houston,Houston,TX,USA6124 DepartmentofBiostatisticsandCenterforStatisticalGenetics,UniversityofMichigan,AnnArbor,62
MI,USA6325 CenterforGenomicsandPersonalizedMedicineResearch,CenterforDiabetesResearch,Wake64
ForestSchoolofMedicine,Winston-Salem,NC,USA6526 DepartmentofBiochemistry,WakeForestSchoolofMedicine,Winston-Salem,NC,USA6627 LeeKongChianSchoolofMedicine,NanyangTechnologicalUniversity,Singapore,Singapore6728 DepartmentofEpidemiologyandBiostatistics,ImperialCollegeLondon,London,UK6829 DepartmentofCardiology,EalingHospital,LondonNorthWestHealthcareNHSTrust,Middlesex,69
UK7030 ImperialCollegeHealthcareNHSTrust,ImperialCollegeLondon,London,UK7131 MRC-PHECentreforEnvironmentandHealth,ImperialCollegeLondon,London,UK7232 DepartmentofBiostatistics,UniversityofLiverpool,Liverpool,UK7333 SchoolofBiologicalSciences,UniversityofManchester,Manchester,UK7434 DepartmentofNutrition,GillingsSchoolofGlobalPublicHealth,UniversityofNorthCarolinaat75
ChapelHill,ChapelHill,NC,USA7635 ChineseAcademyofMedicalSciences,Beijing,China7736 HongKongInstituteofDiabetesandObesity,TheChineseUniversityofHongKong,HongKong,78
China7937 LiKaShingInstituteofHealthSciences,TheChineseUniversityofHongKong,HongKong,China8038 SingaporeEyeResearchInstitute,SingaporeNationalEyeCentre,Singapore,Singapore8139 DivisionofEndocrinology&Metabolism,DepartmentofInternalMedicine,NationalTaiwan82
UniversityHospital,Taipei,Taiwan8340 InstituteofPreventiveMedicine,SchoolofPublicHealth,NationalTaiwanUniversity,Taipei,84
Taiwan8541 DepartmentofLaboratoryMedicineandPathology,UniversityofMinnesota,Minneapolis,MN,86
USA8742 DepartmentofBiostatistics,CarolinaPopulationCenter,GillingsSchoolofGlobalPublicHealth,88
UniversityofNorthCarolinaatChapelHill,ChapelHill,NC,USA8943 DepartmentofGenetics,Shanghai-MOSTKeyLaboratoryofHealthandDiseaseGenomics,90
ChineseNationalHumanGenomeCenteratShanghai,Shanghai,China9144 DivisionofEndocrineandMetabolism,Tri-ServiceGeneralHospitalSongshanBranch,Taipei,92
Taiwan9345 SchoolofMedicine,NationalDefenseMedicalCenter,Taipei,Taiwan9446 SectionofEndocrinologyandMetabolism,DepartmentofMedicine,TaipeiVeteransGeneral95
Hospital,Taipei,Taiwan96
.CC-BY 4.0 International licensecertified by peer review) is the author/funder. It is made available under aThe copyright holder for this preprint (which was notthis version posted June 28, 2019. . https://doi.org/10.1101/685172doi: bioRxiv preprint
3
47 SchoolofMedicine,NationalYang-MingUniversity,Taipei,Taiwan9748 DepartmentofEnvironmentalandPreventiveMedicine,JichiMedicalUniversitySchoolof98
Medicine,Shimotsuke,Japan9949 DepartmentofOphthalmology,MedicalFacultyMannheimoftheUniversityofHeidelberg,100
Mannheim,Germany10150 LaboratoryofComplexTraitGenomics,DepartmentofComputationalBiologyandMedical102
Sciences,GraduateSchoolofFrontierSciences,TheUniversityofTokyo,Tokyo,Japan10351 DepartmentofClinicalGeneTherapy,OsakaUniversityGraduateSchoolofMedicine,Osaka,104
Japan10552 DepartmentofGeriatricandGeneralMedicine,GraduateSchoolofMedicine,OsakaUniversity,106
Osaka,Japan10753 GenomeInstituteofSingapore,AgencyforScience,TechnologyandResearch,Singapore,108
Singapore10954 DepartmentofBiochemistry,NationalUniversityofSingapore,Singapore,Singapore11055 DepartmentofRegionalResourceManagement,EhimeUniversityFacultyofCollaborative111
RegionalInnovation,Ehime,Japan11256 SeveranceBiomedicalScienceInstituteandDepartmentofInternalMedicine,YonseiUniversity113
CollegeofMedicine,Seoul,SouthKorea11457 DepartmentofAnthropology,SociologyandHistory,UniversityofSanCarlos,CebuCity,115
Philippines11658 DepartmentsofEpidemiology&Biostatistics,PekingUniversityHealthScienceCentre,Peking117
University,Beijing,China11859 DepartmentofMedicine,YongLooLinSchoolofMedicine,NationalUniversityofSingaporeand119
NationalUniversityHealthSystem,Singapore,Singapore12060 LaboratoryofStatisticalImmunology,ImmunologyFrontierResearchCenter(WPI-IFReC),Osaka121
University,Osaka,Japan12261 DivisionofEpidemiologyandCommunityHealth,SchoolofPublicHealth,UniversityofMinnesota,123
Minneapolis,MN,USA12462 Ophthalmology&VisualSciencesAcademicClinicalProgram(EyeACP),Duke-NUSMedicalSchool,125
Singapore,Singapore12663 DepartmentofOphthalmology,YongLooLinSchoolofMedicine,NationalUniversityofSingapore127
andNationalUniversityHealthSystem,Singapore,Singapore12864 DepartmentofGenomicMedicine,NationalCerebralandCardiovascularCenter,Osaka,Japan12965 DepartmentofMedicalGeneticsandMedicalResearch,ChinaMedicalUniversityHospital,130
Taichung,Taiwan13166 DepartmentofNutrition,HarvardT.HChanSchoolofPublicHealth,Boston,MA,USA13267 StateKeyLaboratoryofOncogeneandRelatedGenes&DepartmentofEpidemiology,Shanghai133
CancerInstitute,RenjiHospital,ShanghaiJiaotongUniversitySchoolofMedicine,Shanghai,China13468 DepartmentofMedicalBiochemistry,KurumeUniversitySchoolofMedicine,Kurume,Japan13569 DivisionofCancerControlandPopulationSciences,UPMCHillmanCancerCenter,Universityof136
Pittsburgh,Pittsburgh,PA,USA13770 DepartmentofEpidemiology,GraduateSchoolofPublicHealth,UniversityofPittsburgh,138
Pittsburgh,PA,USA13971 DepartmentofAnti-agingMedicine,EhimeUniversityGraduateSchoolofMedicine,Ehime,Japan14072 DepartmentsofPediatricsandMedicine,TheInstituteforTranslationalGenomicsandPopulation141
Sciences,LABioMedatHarbor-UCLAMedicalCenter,Torrance,CA,USA14273 BeijingInstituteofOphthalmology,OphthalmologyandVisualSciencesKeyLaboratory,Beijing143
TongrenHospital,CapitalMedicalUniversity,Beijing,China144
.CC-BY 4.0 International licensecertified by peer review) is the author/funder. It is made available under aThe copyright holder for this preprint (which was notthis version posted June 28, 2019. . https://doi.org/10.1101/685172doi: bioRxiv preprint
4
74 DivisionofEndocrinologyandMetabolism,DepartmentofMedicine,TaichungVeteransGeneral145Hospital,Taichung,Taiwan146
75 KurumeUniversitySchoolofMedicine,Kurume,Japan14776 DepartmentofInternalMedicine,SeoulNationalUniversityCollegeofMedicine,Seoul,South148
Korea14977 DepartmentofMolecularMedicineandBiopharmaceuticalSciences,GraduateSchoolof150
ConvergenceScienceandTechnology,SeoulNationalUniversity,Seoul,SouthKorea15178 Duke-NUSMedicalSchool,Singapore,Singapore15279 HealthServicesandSystemsResearch,Duke-NUSMedicalSchool,Singapore,Singapore15380 DepartmentofAdvancedGenomicandLaboratoryMedicine,GraduateSchoolofMedicine,154
UniversityoftheRyukyus,Okinawa,Japan15581 DivisionofClinicalLaboratoryandBloodTransfusion,UniversityoftheRyukyusHospital,Okinawa,156
Japan15782 MedicalResearchCouncilPopulationHealthResearchUnit,UniversityofOxford,Oxford,UK158# Currentaddress:Genentech,SanFrancisco,CA,USA15916083 Theseauthorscontributedequallytothiswork.16184 Theseauthorsjointlysupervisedthiswork.162* Correspondingauthor 163
.CC-BY 4.0 International licensecertified by peer review) is the author/funder. It is made available under aThe copyright holder for this preprint (which was notthis version posted June 28, 2019. . https://doi.org/10.1101/685172doi: bioRxiv preprint
5
SUMMARY164Meta-analysesofgenome-wideassociationstudies(GWAS)haveidentified>240lociassociatedwith165type2diabetes(T2D),howevermostlocihavebeenidentifiedinanalysesofEuropean-ancestry166individuals.ToexamineT2DriskinEastAsianindividuals,wemeta-analyzedGWASdatain77,418cases167and356,122controls.Inthemainanalysis,weidentified298distinctassociationsignalsat178loci,and168acrossT2Dassociationmodelswithandwithoutconsiderationofbodymassindexandsex,weidentified16956locinewlyimplicatedinT2Dpredisposition.CommonvariantsassociatedwithT2DinbothEastAsian170andEuropeanpopulationsexhibitedstronglycorrelatedeffectsizes.Newassociationsincludesignals171in/nearGDAP1,PTF1A,SIX3,ALDH2,amicroRNAcluster,andgenesthataffectmuscleandadipose172differentiation.Atanotherlocus,eQTLsattwooverlappingT2Dsignalsactthroughtwogenes,NKX6-3173andANK1,indifferenttissues.Associationstudiesindiversepopulationsidentifyadditionallociand174elucidatediseasegenes,biology,andpathways.175176Type2diabetes(T2D)isacommonmetabolicdiseaseprimarilycausedbyinsufficientinsulinproduction177and/orsecretionbythepancreaticβcellsandinsulinresistanceinperipheraltissues1.Mostgeneticloci178associatedwithT2DhavebeenidentifiedinpopulationsofEuropean(EUR)ancestry,includingarecent179meta-analysisofgenome-wideassociationstudies(GWAS)ofnearly900,000individualsofEuropean180ancestrythatidentified>240lociinfluencingtheriskofT2D2.Differencesinallelefrequencybetween181ancestriesaffectthepowertodetectassociationswithinapopulation,particularlyamongvariantsrare182ormonomorphicinonepopulationbutmorefrequentinanother3,4.Althoughsmallerthanstudiesin183Europeanpopulations,arecentT2Dmeta-analysisinalmost200,000Japaneseindividualsidentified28184additionalloci4.TherelativecontributionsofdifferentpathwaystothepathophysiologyofT2Dmayalso185differbetweenancestrygroups.Forexample,inEastAsian(EAS)populations,T2Dprevalenceisgreater186thaninEuropeanpopulationsamongpeopleofsimilarbodymassindex(BMI)orwaistcircumference5.187Weperformedthelargestmeta-analysisofEastAsianindividualstoidentifynewgeneticassociations188andprovideinsightintoT2Dpathogenesis.189190RESULTS191Weconductedafixed-effectinverse-varianceweightedGWASmeta-analysiscombining23studies192imputedtothe1000GenomesPhase3referencepanelfromtheAsianGeneticEpidemiologyNetwork193(AGEN)consortium(SupplementaryTables1-3).Weperformedsex-combinedT2Dassociationwithout194BMIadjustmentin77,418T2Dcasesand356,122controls(effectivesamplesize,Neff=211,793)andwith195BMIadjustmentin54,481T2Dcasesand224,231controls(Neff=135,780).InthesetofstudieswithBMI-196adjustedanalyses,wealsotestedforT2Dassociationinmodelsstratifiedbysex(SupplementaryFigure1971).Wedefined“lead”variantsasthestrongestT2D-associatedvariantswithP<5x10-8anddefinedthe198region+/-500kbfromtheleadvariantasalocus.Alocuswasconsiderednoveliftheleadvariantwas199locatedatleast500kbawayfrompreviouslyreportedT2D-associatedvariantsinanyancestry.200201Usingsummaryassociationstatisticsfor~11.7millionvariantswithoutadjustmentforBMI202(SupplementaryFigure1;SupplementaryTables1-3),weidentifiedleadvariantsat178locitobe203associatedwithT2D,ofwhich49werenovel(Table1;SupplementaryFigure2;SupplementaryTable4).204Leadvariantsatallnovellociwerecommon(MAF≥5%;SupplementaryFigure3),exceptfortwolow-205frequencyleadvariantsnearGDAP1(MAF=2.4%),whichregulatesmitochondrialproteinsandmetabolic206fluxinskeletalmuscle6,andPTF1A(MAF=4.7%),whichencodesatranscriptionfactorrequiredfor207pancreaticacinarcelldevelopment7.LeadvariantsmetastricterP-valuethresholdforsignificancebased208onBonferronicorrectionfor11.7milliontests(P<4.3x10-9)at147ofthe178loci,including31ofthe49209novelloci.210211
.CC-BY 4.0 International licensecertified by peer review) is the author/funder. It is made available under aThe copyright holder for this preprint (which was notthis version posted June 28, 2019. . https://doi.org/10.1101/685172doi: bioRxiv preprint
6
UsingGCTA8,weidentified298distinctsignalsthatmetalocus-widesignificancethresholdofP<1x10-5212(SupplementaryTable5),204ofwhichweregenome-widesignificant(P<5x10-8).Overall,weobserved2132-4signalsat50lociand≥5signalsat11loci.Amongthe49novelloci,9locihadtwosignalsandthe214locusatWNT7Bhadthreesignals.Amongthetenlociwiththemostsignificantmeta-analysisP-valuesof215association,sevencontained≥5distinctsignals(16signalsatINS/IGF2/KCNQ1;7signalsatCDKN2A/B216andGRM8/PAX4/LEP;5signalsatCDKAL1,HHEX/IDE,CDC123/CAMK1D,andTCF7L2;Supplementary217Figure4;SupplementaryTables5).ThesevendistinctassociationsignalsattheGRM8/PAX4/LEPlocus218span1.4Mb,andnoevidenceofT2Dassociationatthislocushasyetbeenreportedinnon-EastAsian219ancestrygroups2,9(SupplementaryFigure4C).Jointanalysesconfirmedindependentassociations(LD220r2=0.0025)attwopreviouslyreportedPAX4missensevariants10,rs2233580[Arg192His:riskallele221frequency(RAF)=8.6%,OR=1.31,95%CI1.27–1.34,PGCTA=3.0x10
-89]andrs3824004(Arg192Ser:222RAF=3.4%,OR=1.23,95%CI1.19-1.28,PGCTA=4.3x10
-29).Theassociationsignalsatthislocusalsoinclude223variantsnearLEP,whichencodesleptin,ahormonethatregulatesappetite11;increasedleptinlevelsare224associatedwithobesityandT2D,withgreaterincreaseinleptinlevelsperunitofBMIinChinese225individualscomparedtothoseofAfrican-American,European,andHispanicancestries12.226227AtthepreviouslyreportedANK1/NKX6-3locus2,13,14,weobservedthreedistinctT2Dassociationsignals,228twoofwhichoverlapandconsistofvariantsspanningonly~25kb(Figure1).Givenconflicting229interpretationofcandidategenes2,15,16,wecomparedtheT2D-associationsignalsidentifiedinEastAsian230individualstoeQTLsreportedatthislocusinislets2,16-18,subcutaneousadipose19,andskeletalmuscle15.231Atthestrongestsignal,theleadT2D-associatedvariant,rs33981001,isinhighLDwiththeleadcis-eQTL232variantforNKX6-3inpancreaticislets(rs12549902;EASLDr2=0.79,EURr2=0.83)16,andtheT2Drisk233alleleisassociatedwithdecreasedexpressionofNKX6-3(β=-0.36,P=6.1x10-7;Figure1)20.NKX6-3,or234NK6homeobox3,encodesapancreaticislettranscriptionfactorrequiredforthedevelopmentofalpha235andβcellsinthepancreas21andhasbeenshowntoinfluenceinsulinsecretion16.AtthesecondT2D-236associationsignal,rs62508166isinhighLDwiththeleadcis-eQTLvariantforANK1insubcutaneous237adiposetissue19andskeletalmuscle15(rs516946;EASLDr2=0.96,EURr2=0.80),andtheT2Driskalleleis238associatedwithincreasedexpressionofANK1(subcutaneousadipose:β=0.20,P=1.8x10-7;skeletal239muscle:β=1.01,P=2.8x10-22).ANK1belongstotheankyrinfamilyofintegralmembraneproteinsthathas240beenshowntoaffectglucoseuptakeinskeletalmuscle,andchangesinexpressionlevelsmayleadto241insulinresistance22.Together,theseGWASandeQTLsignalssuggestthatvariantswithinthis~25kb242regionacttoincreaseordecreaseexpressionlevelsoftwodifferentgenesindifferenttissuesto243increaseT2Drisk.244245InT2DassociationanalysesadjustedforBMI,weidentifiedanadditionaltenloci,fourofwhichwerenot246reportedpreviouslyforT2D,includinglocinearMYOM3/SRSF10,TSN,GRB10,andNID2(Supplementary247Figure5A;SupplementaryTable4).AttheNID2locus,theT2DriskalleleisassociatedwithlowerBMIin248EastAsianindividuals,consistentwithalipodystrophyphenotype23,24.Amongthecombined188loci249identifiedinmodelswithandwithoutadjustmentforBMI,effectsizeswerehighlycorrelated(Pearson250correlationr=0.99;SupplementaryFigures1and6).Thelocuswiththestrongestheterogeneitybetween251thetwomodelswasFTO(Phet=5.6x10
-3),althougheventhislocusfailedtosurpassaBonferroni-252correctedthresholdforsignificantheterogeneity(Phet<0.05/188=2.7x10
-4).253254Insex-stratifiedanalysesofmales(28,027casesand89,312controls)andfemales(27,370casesand255135,055controls),weidentifiedoneadditionalnovelmale-specificlocusnearIFT81andtwoadditional256novelfemale-specificlocinearCPS1andLMTK2(SupplementaryFigure5Band5C;SupplementaryTable2576).TheleadCPS1variantrs1047891(Thr1412Asn)hasbeenreportedpreviouslytohaveastronger258effectinfemalesthaninmalesforcardiovasculardiseaseandseveralbloodmetabolites25.Taken259
.CC-BY 4.0 International licensecertified by peer review) is the author/funder. It is made available under aThe copyright holder for this preprint (which was notthis version posted June 28, 2019. . https://doi.org/10.1101/685172doi: bioRxiv preprint
7
together,weidentifiedatotalof56novellociacrossBMI-unadjusted,BMI-adjusted,andsex-stratified260models.261262AmongallT2D-associatedloci,aregionspanningalmost2Mbonchromosome12nearALDH2exhibited263thestrongestdifferencesbetweensexes(rs12231737,Phet=2.6x10
-19),withcompellingevidenceof264associationinmales(P=5.5x10-27)andnoevidenceforassociationinfemales(P=0.19)(Supplementary265Figure7;SupplementaryTable6).Further,jointconditionalanalysesrevealedtwoconditionallydistinct266signals(rs12231737,PGCTA=1.7x10
-21;rs557597782,PGCTA=4.7x10-7)inmalesonly.ALDH2encodes267
aldehydedehydrogenase2familymember,akeyenzymeinalcoholmetabolismthatconverts268acetaldehydeintoaceticacid.ThisstretchofT2DassociationsinmalesreflectsalongLDblockthat269aroseduetoarecentselectivesweepinEastAsianindividualsandresultsinflushing,nausea,and270headachefollowingalcoholconsumption26.Themostsignificantlyassociatedmissensevariantin271moderateLDwithrs12231737(r2=0.68)wascommonfunctionalvariantrs671(ALDH2Glu504Lys:272RAF=77.4%,OR=1.16,95%CI1.15–1.18,Pmales=4.2x10
-24),whichleadstoreducedALDH2activityand273reducedalcoholmetabolism,andhavepreviouslybeenreportedtobeassociatedwithcardiometabolic274traitsinEastAsianpopulations;theT2Driskalleleisassociatedwithbettertoleranceforalcoholand275increasedBMI,increasedsystolicanddiastolicbloodpressure,andincreasedtriglycerides,butincreased276high-densitylipoprotein,decreasedlow-densitylipoprotein,anddecreasedcardiovascularrisk27-31.The277strongsexualdimorphismobservedatthislocusmaybeduetodifferencesinalcoholconsumption278patternsbetweenmalesandfemales27,29and/ordifferencesintheeffectofalcoholoninsulin279sensitivity32.280281WithaneffectivesamplesizecomparabletothelargeststudyofT2DinEuropeanindividuals(EastAsian282Neff=211,793;EuropeanNeff=231,436)
2andimputationtoadense1000Genomesreferencepanel,our283resultsprovidethemostcomprehensiveandprecisecatalogueofEastAsianT2Deffectstodatefor284comparisonsacrossancestries(Figure2;SupplementaryTable7).For178EAST2Dlociand231EURT2D285loci(unadjustedforBMI)identifiedinaEuropeanmeta-analysis2,wecomparedtheper-alleleeffect286sizesforthe343variantsavailableinbothdatasets(i.e.polymorphicandpassedqualitycontrol),287includingleadvariantsfrombothancestriesatsharedsignals.Overall,theper-alleleeffectsizes288betweenthetwoancestriesweremoderatelycorrelated(r=0.54;Figure2A).Whenthecomparisonwas289restrictedtothe290variantsthatarecommon(MAF≥5%)inbothancestries,theeffectsizecorrelation290increasedtor=0.71(Figure2B;SupplementaryFigure8).Thiseffectsizecorrelationfurtherincreasedto291r=0.88for116variantssignificantlyassociatedwithT2D(P<5x10-8)inbothancestries.Whiletheoverall292effectsizesforall343variantsappear,onaverage,tobestrongerinEastAsianindividualsthan293European,thistrendisreducedwheneachlocusisrepresentedonlybytheleadvariantfromone294population(SupplementaryFigure9).Specifically,manyvariantsidentifiedwithlargereffectsizesinthe295Europeanmeta-analysisaremissingfromthecomparisonbecausetheywererare/monomorphicor296poorlyimputedintheEastAsianmeta-analysis,forwhichimputationreferencepanelsareless297comprehensivecomparedtotheEuropean-centricHaplotypeReferenceConsortiumpanel.298299Variantsexhibitingthelargestdifferencesineffectsizesacrossancestriesaregenerallyrare(MAF300≤0.1%)inEuropeanpopulationsbutcommon(e.g.PAX4,RANBP3L)orlowfrequency(e.g.ZNF257,301DGKD)inEastAsianpopulations.Forexample,rs142395395nearZNF257(RAF=96.9%,OR=1.24,95%CI3021.19-1.29,P=7.0x10-23)hasbeenreportedonlytwicein15,414individualsofnon-FinnishEuropean303ancestryfromthegnomADdatabase33.Thisvarianttagsapreviouslydescribedinversionof415kb304observedonlyinEastAsianindividualsthatdisruptsthecodingsequenceandexpressionofZNF257,as305wellaslymphoblastoidexpressionof81downstreamgenesandtranscripts34.Thesedatasuggestthat306ZNF257and/ordownstreamtargetgenesinfluenceT2Dsusceptibility(SupplementaryFigure10).307
.CC-BY 4.0 International licensecertified by peer review) is the author/funder. It is made available under aThe copyright holder for this preprint (which was notthis version posted June 28, 2019. . https://doi.org/10.1101/685172doi: bioRxiv preprint
8
308Weidentifiedmanylociforwhichtheleadvariantsexhibitedsimilarallelefrequenciesandeffectsizesin309boththeEastAsianandEuropeanmeta-analyses,butonlyreachedgenome-widesignificanceintheEast310Asianmeta-analysis.Givensharedsusceptibilityacrossancestrygroups,theselocimaybedetectedin311non-EastAsianpopulationswhensamplesizesincrease.Amongthesevariantsisrs117624659,located312nearNKX6-1(PEAS=2.0x10
-16,PEUR=2.2x10-4).Thisleadvariantoverlapsahighlyconservedregionthat313
showsopenchromatinspecifictopancreaticislets.Weconductedtranscriptionalreporterassaysin314MIN6mouseinsulinomacellsandobservedthatrs117624659exhibitedsignificantallelicdifferencesin315enhanceractivity(Figure3;SupplementaryFigure11).Inthepancreas,NK6homeobox1(NKX6.1)is316requiredforthedevelopmentofinsulin-producingβcellsandisapotentbifunctionaltranscriptional317regulator35.Further,inactivationofNkx6.1inmicedemonstratedrapid-onsetdiabetesduetodefectsin318insulinbiosynthesisandsecretion36.Unexpectedly,theT2Driskalleleshowedincreasedtranscriptional319activity,suggestingthatthevariantdoesnotactinisolationorthatNXK6-1isnotthetargetgene.320321AtoneofthenovelT2D-associatedlocinearSIX3,theriskalleleofEastAsianleadvariantrs12712928322(RAF=40.2%,OR=1.06,95%CI1.04–1.07,P=3.2x10-14)iscommonacrossnon-EastAsianancestries,323rangingfrom16.0%inEuropeansto26.4%inSouthAsians;however,therewasnoevidenceof324associationintheotherancestrygroups(meta-analysis:OR=0.98,95%CI0.96–0.99,P=2.9x10-3)(Figure3254A;SupplementaryFigure12;SupplementaryTable8).WithintheEastAsianmeta-analysis,the326directionofeffectisconsistentacrossEastAsiancountries(Figure4B)andwithinthecontributing327cohorts(SupplementaryFigure13).TheT2Driskallelers12712928-Cisassociatedwithhigherfasting328glucoselevelsinEastAsianpopulations37,38,hasthestrongestassociationwithlowerexpressionlevelsof329bothSIX3andSIX2inpancreaticislets17,anddemonstratedallele-specificbindingtothetranscription330factorGABPAandsignificantlylowerlevelsoftranscriptionalactivity38.Whilelargerstudiesinother331ancestrygroupscouldimprovetheaccuracyoftheeffectestimate,currentevidencesuggeststhatthe332T2DassociationnearSIX3isspecifictoEastAsianpopulations.333334ToidentifypotentialcandidategenesunderlyingtheT2D-associationsignalsidentifiedinEastAsian335individuals,wefurthercharacterized88loci,includingknownandnovelloci,forwhichtheleadvariant336attheprimaryEastAsianassociationsignalislocated>500kbfromtheleadvariantofanyprimary337EuropeanT2Dassociationsignal2(SupplementaryTable9).Wecharacterizedlociusingpriortrait338associations,cis-regulatoryeffectsonexpression(colocalizedeQTL),predictedeffectsonprotein339sequence,andaliteraturesearch(SupplementaryTables10-13).Basedonassociationresultsfrom340cardiometabolictraitconsortia39,BiobankJapan40,andtheUKBiobank41,theleadT2D-associated341variantat19ofthe88lociwasassociated(P<5x10-8)withatleastoneadditionalcardiometabolictrait,342mostfrequentlyBMIorafatmass-relatedtrait(16loci;SupplementaryTables10and12).At12ofthe343examinedloci,T2Dsignalswerecolocalizedwithcis-eQTLsfortranscriptsinsubcutaneousadipose344tissue(n=5),skeletalmuscle(n=3),pancreas(n=2),pancreaticislets(n=3),orwholeblood(n=5;345SupplementaryTables11-12).At19loci,theleadT2D-associatedvariantoravariantinhighLDwithit346(EastAsianr2>0.80)altertheproteinsequence(SupplementaryTables12).Thesevariantsaffect347mesenchymalstemcelldifferentiationandadipogenesis(GIT2,STEAP2andJMJD1C),musclestemcell348biology(CALCR),glucosemetabolism(PGM1andSCTR),andinsulinsecretion(FGFR4;Supplementary349Table13).Whilemechanisticinferenceisrequired,thesepotentialmolecularmechanismssuggestnew350T2DsusceptibilitygenesprimarilydetectedbyanalysesinEastAsians.351352T2DlociwerealsoidentifiedatclustersofnoncodingRNAswithrolesinisletβcellfunction.Onelocus353includesasetofmicroRNAsspecificallyexpressedinisletβcells,thematernallyexpressednoncoding354RNAMEG3,andthepaternallyexpressedgeneDLK1.TargetsofthemicroRNAsatthislocusincreaseβ355
.CC-BY 4.0 International licensecertified by peer review) is the author/funder. It is made available under aThe copyright holder for this preprint (which was notthis version posted June 28, 2019. . https://doi.org/10.1101/685172doi: bioRxiv preprint
9
cellapoptosis42,andreducedMeg3impairsinsulinsecretion43.DLK1inhibitsadipocytedifferentiation,356protectingfromobesity44,andpromotespancreaticductalcelldifferentiationintoβcells,increasing357insulinsecretion45,46.OthervariantsnearMEG3havebeenassociatedwithtype1diabetes(EASandEUR358LDr2=0withEASleadvariant)47.TheothernoncodingRNAlocusistheMIR17HGclusterofmiRNAsthat359regulateglucose-stimulatedinsulinsecretionandpancreaticβcellproliferationstress48;oneofthese360microRNAs,miR-19a,affectshepaticgluconeogenesis49.YetanotherindependentT2Dassociationlocus361islocatednearTRAF3,whichisadirecttargetoftheMIR17HGmicroRNAclusterandpromotes362hyperglycemiabyincreasinghepaticglucoseproduction50,51.TheT2Dassociationresultssuggestthat363thesenoncodingRNAsinfluencediseasesusceptibility.364365DISCUSSION366TheseT2DGWASmeta-analysesinthelargestnumberofEastAsianindividualsanalyzedtodate367identified56novelloci,providingadditionalinsightintothebiologicalbasisofT2D.Theresults368emphasizesubstantialsharedT2DsusceptibilitywithEuropeanindividuals,asshownbythestrong369correlationofeffectsizesamongT2D-associatedgeneticvariantswithcommonallelefrequenciesin370bothEastAsianandEuropeanancestrypopulations.TheresultsalsodetectnovelassociationsinEast371Asianindividuals,severalofwhichareidentifiedbecausetheyhavehigherallelefrequenciesinEast372Asianpopulations,exhibitlargereffectsizes,and/orareinfluencedbyotherenvironmentalriskfactors373orlifestylebehaviorssuchasalcoholconsumption.374375Theidentifiedlocipointtomultipleplausiblemolecularmechanismsandmanynewcandidategenes376linkingT2Dsusceptibilitytodiversebiologicalprocesses.AnnotationoflociidentifiedintheEastAsian377meta-analysissuggestsasubstantialroleforinsulinresistanceinT2DpathogenesisamongEastAsian378individualsthroughskeletalmuscle,adipose,andliverdevelopmentandfunction.Wealsoprovide379evidencethatmultipledistinctassociationsignalsinthesameregiondonotnecessarilyactthroughthe380samegene.Conditionallydistinctassociationsignalsincloseproximitycanaffectdifferentgenesthat381mayactindifferenttissuesbydifferentmechanisms,emphasizingthevalueofidentifyingfunctional382variantsthatenablevariant-to-genelinkstobeexamineddirectly.Ourresultsprovideafoundationfor383futurebiologicalresearchinT2Dpathogenesisandofferpotentialtargetsformechanismsfor384interventionsindiseaserisk.385386METHODS387Ethicsstatement388Allhumanresearchwasapprovedbytherelevantinstitutionalreviewboardsforeachstudyattheir389respectivesitesandconductedaccordingtotheDeclarationofHelsinki.Allparticipantsprovidedwritten390informedconsent.391392Studycohortsandqualitycontrol393TheEastAsiantype2diabetes(T2D)meta-analyseswereperformedwithstudiesparticipatinginthe394AsianGeneticEpidemiologyNetwork(AGEN),aconsortiumofgeneticepidemiologystudiesofT2Dand395relatedtraitsconductedinindividualsofEastAsianancestry,andtheDiabetesMeta-analysisofTrans-396ethnicAssociationStudies(DIAMANTE),aconsortiumexaminingthegeneticcontributiontoT2Dacross397diverseancestrypopulationsincludingAfrican-American,EastAsian,European,Hispanic,andSouth398Asian.TheEastAsianmeta-analysisincluded77,418T2Dcasesand356,122controlsfrom23GWAS,399includingthreebiobanks,CKB,KBA52,53,andBBJ4[effectivesamplesize(Neff)=211,793;Supplementary400Figure1].AsubsetofstudieswasanalyzedinBMI-adjustedandsex-specificmodels(54,481cases,401224,231cases;Neff=135,780).Foreachstudy,T2Dcasecontrolascertainmentisdescribedin402SupplementaryTable1andsummarystatisticsareprovidedinSupplementaryTable2.Includedstudies403
.CC-BY 4.0 International licensecertified by peer review) is the author/funder. It is made available under aThe copyright holder for this preprint (which was notthis version posted June 28, 2019. . https://doi.org/10.1101/685172doi: bioRxiv preprint
10
weregenotypedoneithercommerciallyavailableorcustomizedAffymetrixorIlluminagenome-wide404genotypingarrays.Arrayqualitycontrolcriteriaimplementedwithineachstudy,includingvariantcall405rateandHardy-Weinbergequilibrium,aresummarizedinSupplementaryTable3.Toharmonizestudy-406levelgenotypescaffoldforimputationto1000Genomes(1000G)referencepanels,eachstudyadopted407auniformprotocolforpre-imputationqualitychecks.Eachstudyappliedtheprotocoltoexclude408variantswith:i)mismatchedchromosomalpositionsorallelesnotpresentinthereferencepanel;ii)409ambiguousalleles(AT/CG)withminorallelefrequency(MAF)>40%inthereferencepanel;oriii)410absoluteallelefrequencydifferences>20%comparedtoEastAsian-specificallelefrequencies.The411genotypescaffoldforeachstudywasthenimputedtothe1000GPhase1or3referencepanel54using412minimac355orIMPUTEv256.InBMI-unadjustedanalyses,allstudieswereimputedto1000GPhase3.In413BMI-adjustedandsex-stratifiedanalyses,allstudieswereimputedto1000GPhase3exceptforBiobank414Japan14,whichwasimputedtothe1000GPhase1referencepanel.415416Study-levelassociationanalyses417Withineachstudy,allvariantsweretestedforassociationwithT2Dassuminganadditivemodelof418inheritancewithinaregressionframework,includingage,sex,andotherstudy-specificcovariates419(SupplementaryTable3).Toaccountforpopulationstructureandrelatedness,associationanalyses420wereeitherperformedusingFIRTH57ormach2datwithadditionaladjustmentforprincipalcomponents421inunrelatedindividualsoralinearmixedmodelwithkinshipmatriximplementedinBOLT-LMM58.In422studiesanalyzedwiththelinearmixedmodel,alleliceffectsandstandarderrorswereconvertedtothe423log-oddsscalethataccountsforcase-controlimbalance59.Withineachstudy,variantswereremovedif424the:i)imputationqualityscorewaspoor(minimac3r2<0.30;IMPUTE2infoscore<0.40);ii)combined425casecontrolminorallelecount<5;oriii)standarderrorofthelog-OR>10.Forasubsetofthestudies,426BMIwasaddedasanadditionalcovariate,andassociationanalyseswerealsoperformedseparatelyin427malesandfemales.Foreachstudyandmodel,associationstatisticswerecorrectedwithgenomic428controlinflationfactor60calculatedfromcommonvariants(MAF≥5%)(SupplementaryTable3).ForBBJ,429weappliedthegenomiccontrolinflationfactor1.21asreported4.430431Sex-combinedmeta-analysis432Wecombinedstudy-levelassociationstatisticsusingfixedeffectsmeta-analysiswithinverse-variance433weightingoflog-ORsimplementedinMETAL61.Variantswithallelefrequencydifferences>20%between4341000GenomesPhase1and3panelswereexcludedfromthemeta-analysis.Toassessexcessinflation435arisingfromcrypticrelatednessandpopulationstructure,weappliedLDscoreregressiontothemeta-436analysissummarystatisticstoestimateresidualinflationofsummarystatistics,usingasetof1,889437unrelatedChineseindividualsfromtheSingaporeChineseEyeStudy62.TheLDscoreregression438interceptswere0.991forBMI-unadjusted,and1.0148forBMI-adjustedmodels.AstheLDscore439regressioninterceptsindicatedabsenceofexcessinflation,themeta-analysisresultswerecorrectedfor440inflationusingtheseLDscoreregressionintercepts.Forsubsequentanalyses,weconsideredonly441variantsthatwerepresentinatleast50%oftheeffectivesamplesizeNeff[computedas4/(1/Ncases+4421/Ncontrols)]
61.Heterogeneityinalleliceffectsizesbetweenstudieswereassessedwithfixedeffects443inversevarianceweightedmeta-analysisPhet.WefurthercomparedthegeneticeffectsfromBMI-444unadjustedandBMI-adjustedmodelsusingfixedeffectsinversevarianceweightedmeta-analysisPhet.445Lociweredefinedasnoveliftheleadvariantis:(1)atleast500kbawayandconfirmedbyGCTAtobe446conditionallyindependentfrompreviouslyreportedT2D-associatedvariantsinanyancestry,and(2)447assessedusingLocusZoomplotsanddetailedliteraturereviewtobeawayfromknownlociwith448extendedLD.449450Sex-differentiatedmeta-analysis451
.CC-BY 4.0 International licensecertified by peer review) is the author/funder. It is made available under aThe copyright holder for this preprint (which was notthis version posted June 28, 2019. . https://doi.org/10.1101/685172doi: bioRxiv preprint
11
Themeta-analysesdescribedabovewererepeatedformalesandfemalesseparately.Themale-specific452meta-analysesincludedupto28,027casesand89,312controls(Neff=65,660)andthefemale-specific453analysesincludedupto27,370casesand135,055controls(Neff=70,332).LDscoreregressionintercepts454were1.0035forBMI-unadjustedand1.0034forBMI-adjustedmodelsinmalesand1.0035forBMI-455unadjustedand1.0034forBMI-adjustedmodelsinfemales.Wefurtherperformedatestfor456heterogeneityinalleliceffectsbetweenmalesandfemalesasimplementedinGWAMA63,64.457458Detectionofdistinctassociationsignals459Todetectmultipledistinctassociationsignalsateachassociatedlocus,wecombinedoverlappingloci460whenthedistancebetweenanypairofleadvariantswas<1Mb.Wethenperformedapproximate461conditionalanalysesusingGCTA8withgenome-widemeta-analysissummarystatisticsandLDestimated462from78,000samplesfromtheKoreanBiobankArray53.463464ComparinglocieffectsbetweenEastAsianandEuropeanpopulations465Wecomparedtheper-alleleeffectsizesofleadvariantsidentifiedfromtheEastAsianBMI-unadjusted466sex-combinedmeta-analysis(178leadvariants)andEuropeanBMI-unadjustedsex-combinedmeta-467analysis2(231leadvariants;SupplementaryTable7).Acrossthe409associatedvariantsfromthetwo468ancestries,11leadvariantsoverlapped,resultingin398uniquevariants.AsthevariantsintheEuropean469analysiswereimputedusingtheHaplotypeReferenceConsortiumreferencepanelanddidnotinclude470indelvariants,avariantinstrongLD(EastAsianr2>0.90)withtheleadEastAsianvariantwasusedwhen471theleadvariantwasanindel,whenpossible.IftheleadEastAsianvariantoravariantinstrongLD(East472Asianr2>0.90)wasnotavailableintheEuropeandatafromDIAMANTE,weusedresultsfromaprevious473Europeantype2diabetesmeta-analysis65.Theeffectsizecomparisonplotwasrestrictedto343variants474wheredatawasavailableforbothancestries(Figure2A).ForlocithatweresignificantinboththeEast475AsianandEuropeanmeta-analyses,iftheleadvariantsweredifferent,bothleadvariantswereplotted476(seeSupplementaryTable7).Effectsizeplotswerefurtherrestrictedto:i)290leadvariantswith477MAF≥5%inbothEastAsianandEuropeanmeta-analyses(SupplementaryFigure7);ii)162leadvariants478significantintheEastAsianmeta-analysis(SupplementaryFigure8A);andiii)192leadvariants479significantintheEuropeanmeta-analysis(SupplementaryFigure8B).480481Associationswithothermetabolictraitsandoutcomes482WeusedtheType2DiabetesKnowledgePortal39toexploreassociationsofthenewlyidentifiedlociwith483othermetabolictraitsandoutcomes.Associationstatisticsfromthefollowingconsortiawereavailable484forqueryontheportal(lastaccessedMarch18,2019):coronaryarterydiseasefromCARDIoGRAM66,485BMIandwaist-hip-ratiofromGIANT67,68,lipidtraitsfromGLGC69,andglycemictraitsfromMAGIC70,71.486Additionally,weusedavailabledatafromAGENEastAsianmeta-analysesforlipids72andadiponectin73,487alongwiththephenotypicdatafromtheUKBiobank74.Effectsizeswereobtainedfrompubliclyavailable488summarystatisticfiles.489490Colocalizationwithexpressionquantitativetraitloci(eQTL)491WesearchedpubliclyavailableeQTLdatabasessuchasGTEx75andtheParkerlabIsletBrowser17,to492identifycis-eQTLsatthenovellociinadipose(subcutaneousandvisceral),blood,pancreas,pancreatic493islet,andskeletalmuscletissue.Wealsosearchedforcis-eQTLsinsubcutaneousadiposetissuedata494fromtheMETSIMstudy19.ColocalizedeQTLswereidentifiediftheleadexpressionlevel-associated495variantandtheGWASleadvariantwereinhighLD(r2>0.80)inEuropeanstoaccommodatethe496predominantlyEuropeaneQTLdata.Reciprocalconditionalanalyseswerealsoperformedusingthe497METSIMdatatodetermineiftheGWASleadvariantandtheleadeSNPwerepartofthesameeQTL498signal.499
.CC-BY 4.0 International licensecertified by peer review) is the author/funder. It is made available under aThe copyright holder for this preprint (which was notthis version posted June 28, 2019. . https://doi.org/10.1101/685172doi: bioRxiv preprint
12
500Literaturereview501WeconductedatraditionalliteraturereviewtoidentifycandidategenesateachnovellocususingNCBI502EntrezGene,PubMedandOMIM.Weincludedgenesymbolsandthefollowingkeywordsassearch503termsinPubMed:diabetes,glucose,insulin,islet,adipose,muscle,liver,obesity.Agenewasconsidered504apotentialcandidateifanapparentlinktoT2Dbiologyexistedbasedonpriorstudiesofgenefunction.505506FunctionalannotationandexperimentationatNKX6-1507WeusedENCODE76,ChromHMM77,andHumanEpigenomeAtlas78dataavailablethroughtheUCSC508GenomeBrowsertoidentifycandidatevariantsattheassociationsignalnearNKX6-1thatoverlapped509open-chromatinpeaks,ChromHMMchromatinstates,andchromatin-immunoprecipitationsequencing510(ChIP-seq)peaksofhistonemodificationsH4K4me1,H3K4me3,andH3K27ac,andtranscriptionfactors511inthepancreasandpancreaticislets.MIN6mouseinsulinomacells79and823/13ratinsulinomacells80512wereculturedinDMEM(Sigma)supplementedwith10%FBS,1mMsodiumpyruvate,and0.1mMbeta-513mercaptoethanol.Thecellculturesweremaintainedat37°Cwith5%CO2.Tomeasurevariantallelic514differencesinenhanceractivityattheNKX6-1locus,wedesignedoligonucleotideprimers(forward:515CCCTAGTAATGCCCTTTTTGTT;reverse:TCAGCCTGAGAAGTCTGTGA)withKpnIandXholrestrictionsites,516andamplifiedthe400-bpDNAregion(GRCh37/hg19-chr4:85,339,430-85,339,829)around517rs117624659.Aspreviouslydescribed80,weligatedamplifiedDNAfromindividualshomozygousforeach518alleleintothemultiplecloningsiteofthepGL4.23(Promega)minimalpromoterluciferasereporter519vectorinboththeforwardandreverseorientationswithrespecttothegenome.Cloneswereisolated520andsequencedforgenotypeandfidelity.2.1x105MIN6or3.0x105823/13cellswereseededperwell521andgrownto90%confluencein24-wellplates.Weco-transfectedfiveindependentluciferase522constructsandRenillacontrolreportervector(phRL-TK,Promega)usingLipofectamine2000(Life523Technologies)andincubated.48-hourspost-transfection,thecellswerelysedwithPassiveLysisBuffer524(Promega).LuciferaseactivitywasmeasuredusingtheDual-luciferaseReporterAssaySystem(Promega)525permanufacturerinstructionsandaspreviouslydescribed81.526 527
.CC-BY 4.0 International licensecertified by peer review) is the author/funder. It is made available under aThe copyright holder for this preprint (which was notthis version posted June 28, 2019. . https://doi.org/10.1101/685172doi: bioRxiv preprint
13
REFERENCES5281 Stumvoll,M.,Goldstein,B.J.&vanHaeften,T.W.Type2diabetes:principlesofpathogenesis529
andtherapy.Lancet(London,England)365,1333-1346,doi:10.1016/s0140-6736(05)61032-x530(2005).531
2 Mahajan,A.etal.Fine-mappingtype2diabeteslocitosingle-variantresolutionusinghigh-532densityimputationandislet-specificepigenomemaps.NatGenet50,1505-1513,533doi:10.1038/s41588-018-0241-6(2018).534
3 Cho,Y.S.etal.Meta-analysisofgenome-wideassociationstudiesidentifieseightnewlocifor535type2diabetesineastAsians.NatGenet44,67-72,doi:10.1038/ng.1019(2011).536
4 Suzuki,K.etal.Identificationof28newsusceptibilitylocifortype2diabetesintheJapanese537population.NatGenet51,379-386,doi:10.1038/s41588-018-0332-4(2019).538
5 Huxley,R.etal.Ethniccomparisonsofthecross-sectionalrelationshipsbetweenmeasuresof539bodysizewithdiabetesandhypertension.Obesityreviews:anofficialjournalofthe540InternationalAssociationfortheStudyofObesity9Suppl1,53-61,doi:10.1111/j.1467-541789X.2007.00439.x(2008).542
6 Lassiter,D.G.,Sjogren,R.J.O.,Gabriel,B.M.,Krook,A.&Zierath,J.R.AMPKactivation543negativelyregulatesGDAP1,whichinfluencesmetabolicprocessesandcircadiangene544expressioninskeletalmuscle.MolMetab16,12-23,doi:10.1016/j.molmet.2018.07.004(2018).545
7 Hoang,C.Q.etal.TranscriptionalMaintenanceofPancreaticAcinarIdentity,Differentiation,546andHomeostasisbyPTF1A.Molecularandcellularbiology36,3033-3047,547doi:10.1128/MCB.00358-16(2016).548
8 Yang,J.etal.Conditionalandjointmultiple-SNPanalysisofGWASsummarystatisticsidentifies549additionalvariantsinfluencingcomplextraits.NatGenet44,369-375,S361-363,550doi:10.1038/ng.2213(2012).551
9 Fuchsberger,C.etal.Thegeneticarchitectureoftype2diabetes.Nature536,41-47,552doi:10.1038/nature18642(2016).553
10 Kwak,S.H.etal.NonsynonymousVariantsinPAX4andGLP1RAreAssociatedWithType2554DiabetesinanEastAsianPopulation.Diabetes67,1892-1902,doi:10.2337/db18-0361(2018).555
11 Klok,M.D.,Jakobsdottir,S.&Drent,M.L.Theroleofleptinandghrelinintheregulationoffood556intakeandbodyweightinhumans:areview.Obesityreviews:anofficialjournalofthe557InternationalAssociationfortheStudyofObesity8,21-34,doi:10.1111/j.1467-558789X.2006.00270.x(2007).559
12 Rasmussen-Torvik,L.J.etal.Associationsofbodymassindexandinsulinresistancewithleptin,560adiponectin,andtheleptin-to-adiponectinratioacrossethnicgroups:theMulti-EthnicStudyof561Atherosclerosis(MESA).AnnEpidemiol22,705-709,doi:10.1016/j.annepidem.2012.07.011562(2012).563
13 Morris,A.P.etal.Large-scaleassociationanalysisprovidesinsightsintothegeneticarchitecture564andpathophysiologyoftype2diabetes.Naturegenetics44,981-990,doi:10.1038/ng.2383565(2012).566
14 Imamura,M.etal.Genome-wideassociationstudiesintheJapanesepopulationidentifyseven567novellocifortype2diabetes.NatCommun7,10531,doi:10.1038/ncomms10531(2016).568
15 Scott,L.J.etal.Thegeneticregulatorysignatureoftype2diabetesinhumanskeletalmuscle.569NatCommun7,11764,doi:10.1038/ncomms11764(2016).570
16 vandeBunt,M.etal.TranscriptExpressionDatafromHumanIsletsLinksRegulatorySignals571fromGenome-WideAssociationStudiesforType2DiabetesandGlycemicTraitstoTheir572DownstreamEffectors.PLoSGenet11,e1005694,doi:10.1371/journal.pgen.1005694(2015).573
17 Varshney,A.etal.Geneticregulatorysignaturesunderlyingisletgeneexpressionandtype2574diabetes.ProcNatlAcadSciUSA114,2301-2306,doi:10.1073/pnas.1621192114(2017).575
.CC-BY 4.0 International licensecertified by peer review) is the author/funder. It is made available under aThe copyright holder for this preprint (which was notthis version posted June 28, 2019. . https://doi.org/10.1101/685172doi: bioRxiv preprint
14
18 Thurner,M.etal.Integrationofhumanpancreaticisletgenomicdatarefinesregulatory576mechanismsatType2Diabetessusceptibilityloci.eLife7,doi:10.7554/eLife.31977(2018).577
19 Civelek,M.etal.GeneticRegulationofAdiposeGeneExpressionandCardio-MetabolicTraits.578AmJHumGenet100,428-443,doi:10.1016/j.ajhg.2017.01.027(2017).579
20 vandeBunt,M.etal.ThemiRNAprofileofhumanpancreaticisletsandbeta-cellsand580relationshiptotype2diabetespathogenesis.PLoSOne8,e55272,581doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0055272(2013).582
21 Henseleit,K.D.etal.NKX6transcriptionfactoractivityisrequiredforalpha-andbeta-cell583developmentinthepancreas.Development132,3139-3149,doi:10.1242/dev.01875(2005).584
22 Yan,R.etal.Anoveltype2diabetesriskalleleincreasesthepromoteractivityofthemuscle-585specificsmallankyrin1gene.SciRep6,25105,doi:10.1038/srep25105(2016).586
23 Wen,W.etal.Genome-wideassociationstudiesinEastAsiansidentifynewlociforwaist-hip587ratioandwaistcircumference.SciRep6,17958,doi:10.1038/srep17958(2016).588
24 Akiyama,M.etal.Genome-wideassociationstudyidentifies112newlociforbodymassindexin589theJapanesepopulation.NatGenet49,1458-1467,doi:10.1038/ng.3951(2017).590
25 Hartiala,J.A.etal.Genome-wideassociationstudyandtargetedmetabolomicsidentifiessex-591specificassociationofCPS1withcoronaryarterydisease.NatCommun7,10558,592doi:10.1038/ncomms10558(2016).593
26 Okada,Y.etal.Deepwhole-genomesequencingrevealsrecentselectionsignatureslinkedto594evolutionanddiseaseriskofJapanese.NatCommun9,1631,doi:10.1038/s41467-018-03274-0595(2018).596
27 Xu,F.etal.ALDH2geneticpolymorphismandtheriskoftypeIIdiabetesmellitusinCAD597patients.HypertensRes33,49-55,doi:10.1038/hr.2009.178(2010).598
28 Kato,N.etal.Meta-analysisofgenome-wideassociationstudiesidentifiescommonvariants599associatedwithbloodpressurevariationineastAsians.NatGenet43,531-538,600doi:10.1038/ng.834(2011).601
29 Takeuchi,F.etal.ConfirmationofALDH2asaMajorlocusofdrinkingbehaviorandofits602variantsregulatingmultiplemetabolicphenotypesinaJapanesepopulation.CircJ75,911-918603(2011).604
30 Kim,Y.K.etal.Evaluationofpleiotropiceffectsamongcommongeneticlociidentifiedfor605cardio-metabolictraitsinaKoreanpopulation.Cardiovasculardiabetology15,20,606doi:10.1186/s12933-016-0337-1(2016).607
31 Ma,C.etal.Associationsbetweenaldehydedehydrogenase2(ALDH2)rs671genetic608polymorphisms,lifestylesandhypertensionriskinChineseHanpeople.SciRep7,11136,609doi:10.1038/s41598-017-11071-w(2017).610
32 Schrieks,I.C.,Heil,A.L.,Hendriks,H.F.,Mukamal,K.J.&Beulens,J.W.Theeffectofalcohol611consumptiononinsulinsensitivityandglycemicstatus:asystematicreviewandmeta-analysisof612interventionstudies.DiabetesCare38,723-732,doi:10.2337/dc14-1556(2015).613
33 Lek,M.etal.Analysisofprotein-codinggeneticvariationin60,706humans.Nature536,285-614291,doi:10.1038/nature19057(2016).615
34 Puig,M.etal.FunctionalImpactandEvolutionofaNovelHumanPolymorphicInversionThat616DisruptsaGeneandCreatesaFusionTranscript.PLoSGenet11,e1005495,617doi:10.1371/journal.pgen.1005495(2015).618
35 Iype,T.etal.ThetranscriptionalrepressorNkx6.1alsofunctionsasadeoxyribonucleicacid619context-dependenttranscriptionalactivatorduringpancreaticbeta-celldifferentiation:evidence620forfeedbackactivationofthenkx6.1genebyNkx6.1.Molecularendocrinology(Baltimore,Md.)62118,1363-1375,doi:10.1210/me.2004-0006(2004).622
.CC-BY 4.0 International licensecertified by peer review) is the author/funder. It is made available under aThe copyright holder for this preprint (which was notthis version posted June 28, 2019. . https://doi.org/10.1101/685172doi: bioRxiv preprint
15
36 Taylor,B.L.,Liu,F.F.&Sander,M.Nkx6.1isessentialformaintainingthefunctionalstateof623pancreaticbetacells.CellRep4,1262-1275,doi:10.1016/j.celrep.2013.08.010(2013).624
37 Kim,Y.J.etal.Large-scalegenome-wideassociationstudiesinEastAsiansidentifynewgenetic625lociinfluencingmetabolictraits.NatGenet43,990-995,doi:10.1038/ng.939(2011).626
38 Spracklen,C.N.etal.IdentificationandfunctionalanalysisofglycemictraitlociintheChina627HealthandNutritionSurvey.PLoSGenet14,e1007275,doi:10.1371/journal.pgen.1007275628(2018).629
39 Type2DiabetesKnowledgePortal,<http://www.type2diabetesgenetics.org/home/portalHome>630(2019).631
40 Kanai,M.etal.GeneticanalysisofquantitativetraitsintheJapanesepopulationlinkscelltypes632tocomplexhumandiseases.NatGenet50,390-400,doi:10.1038/s41588-018-0047-6(2018).633
41 Bycroft,C.etal.TheUKBiobankresourcewithdeepphenotypingandgenomicdata.Nature634562,203-209,doi:10.1038/s41586-018-0579-z(2018).635
42 Kameswaran,V.etal.EpigeneticregulationoftheDLK1-MEG3microRNAclusterinhumantype6362diabeticislets.Cellmetabolism19,135-145,doi:10.1016/j.cmet.2013.11.016(2014).637
43 You,L.etal.DownregulationofLongNoncodingRNAMeg3AffectsInsulinSynthesisand638SecretioninMousePancreaticBetaCells.JCellPhysiol231,852-862,doi:10.1002/jcp.25175639(2016).640
44 Moon,Y.S.etal.MicelackingpaternallyexpressedPref-1/Dlk1displaygrowthretardationand641acceleratedadiposity.Molecularandcellularbiology22,5585-5592,642doi:10.1128/mcb.22.15.5585-5592.2002(2002).643
45 Wang,Y.etal.OverexpressionofPref-1inpancreaticisletbeta-cellsinmicecauses644hyperinsulinemiawithincreasedisletmassandinsulinsecretion.BiochemBiophysResCommun645461,630-635,doi:10.1016/j.bbrc.2015.04.078(2015).646
46 Rhee,M.etal.Preadipocytefactor1inducespancreaticductalcelldifferentiationintoinsulin-647producingcells.SciRep6,23960,doi:10.1038/srep23960(2016).648
47 Onengut-Gumuscu,S.etal.Finemappingoftype1diabetessusceptibilitylociandevidencefor649colocalizationofcausalvariantswithlymphoidgeneenhancers.NatGenet47,381-386,650doi:10.1038/ng.3245(2015).651
48 Chen,Y.etal.MicroRNA-17-92clusterregulatespancreaticbeta-cellproliferationand652adaptation.MolCellEndocrinol437,213-223,doi:10.1016/j.mce.2016.08.037(2016).653
49 Dou,L.etal.MiR-19amediatesgluconeogenesisbytargetingPTENinhepatocytes.MolMedRep65417,3967-3971,doi:10.3892/mmr.2017.8312(2018).655
50 Chen,Z.etal.HepatocyteTRAF3promotesinsulinresistanceandtype2diabetesinmicewith656obesity.Molecularmetabolism4,951-960,doi:10.1016/j.molmet.2015.09.013(2015).657
51 Liu,F.,Cheng,L.,Xu,J.,Guo,F.&Chen,W.miR-17-92functionsasanoncogeneandmodulates658NF-kappaBsignalingbytargetingTRAF3inMGC-803humangastriccancercells.IntJOncol53,6592241-2257,doi:10.3892/ijo.2018.4543(2018).660
52 Kim,Y.,Han,B.G.&Ko,G.E.S.g.CohortProfile:TheKoreanGenomeandEpidemiologyStudy661(KoGES)Consortium.IntJEpidemiol46,e20,doi:10.1093/ije/dyv316(2017).662
53 Moon,S.etal.TheKoreaBiobankArray:DesignandIdentificationofCodingVariantsAssociated663withBloodBiochemicalTraits.SciRep9,1382,doi:10.1038/s41598-018-37832-9(2019).664
54 The1000GenomesProjectConsortium.etal.Aglobalreferenceforhumangeneticvariation.665Nature526,68-74,doi:10.1038/nature15393(2015).666
55 Das,S.etal.Next-generationgenotypeimputationserviceandmethods.NatGenet48,1284-6671287,doi:10.1038/ng.3656(2016).668
56 Howie,B.,Marchini,J.&Stephens,M.Genotypeimputationwiththousandsofgenomes.G3669(Bethesda)1,457-470,doi:10.1534/g3.111.001198(2011).670
.CC-BY 4.0 International licensecertified by peer review) is the author/funder. It is made available under aThe copyright holder for this preprint (which was notthis version posted June 28, 2019. . https://doi.org/10.1101/685172doi: bioRxiv preprint
16
57 Ma,C.,Blackwell,T.,Boehnke,M.&Scott,L.J.Recommendedjointandmeta-analysisstrategies671forcase-controlassociationtestingofsinglelow-countvariants.GenetEpidemiol37,539-550,672doi:10.1002/gepi.21742(2013).673
58 Loh,P.R.etal.EfficientBayesianmixed-modelanalysisincreasesassociationpowerinlarge674cohorts.NatGenet47,284-290,doi:10.1038/ng.3190(2015).675
59 Cook,J.P.,Mahajan,A.&Morris,A.P.Guidancefortheutilityoflinearmodelsinmeta-analysis676ofgeneticassociationstudiesofbinaryphenotypes.EurJHumGenet25,240-245,677doi:10.1038/ejhg.2016.150(2017).678
60 Devlin,B.&Roeder,K.Genomiccontrolforassociationstudies.Biometrics55,997-1004(1999).67961 Willer,C.J.,Li,Y.&Abecasis,G.R.METAL:fastandefficientmeta-analysisofgenomewide680
associationscans.Bioinformatics26,2190-2191,doi:10.1093/bioinformatics/btq340(2010).68162 Bulik-Sullivan,B.K.etal.LDScoreregressiondistinguishesconfoundingfrompolygenicityin682
genome-wideassociationstudies.NatGenet47,291-295,doi:10.1038/ng.3211(2015).68363 Magi,R.,Lindgren,C.M.&Morris,A.P.Meta-analysisofsex-specificgenome-wideassociation684
studies.GenetEpidemiol34,846-853,doi:10.1002/gepi.20540(2010).68564 Magi,R.&Morris,A.P.GWAMA:softwareforgenome-wideassociationmeta-analysis.BMC686
Bioinformatics11,288,doi:10.1186/1471-2105-11-288(2010).68765 Scott,R.A.etal.AnExpandedGenome-WideAssociationStudyofType2Diabetesin688
Europeans.Diabetes66,2888-2902,doi:10.2337/db16-1253(2017).68966 Schunkert,H.etal.Large-scaleassociationanalysisidentifies13newsusceptibilitylocifor690
coronaryarterydisease.NatGenet43,333-338,doi:10.1038/ng.784(2011).69167 Turcot,V.etal.Protein-alteringvariantsassociatedwithbodymassindeximplicatepathways692
thatcontrolenergyintakeandexpenditureinobesity.NatGenet50,26-41,693doi:10.1038/s41588-017-0011-x(2018).694
68 Justice,A.E.etal.Protein-codingvariantsimplicatenovelgenesrelatedtolipidhomeostasis695contributingtobody-fatdistribution.NatGenet51,452-469,doi:10.1038/s41588-018-0334-2696(2019).697
69 Willer,C.J.etal.Discoveryandrefinementoflociassociatedwithlipidlevels.NatGenet45,6981274-1283,doi:10.1038/ng.2797(2013).699
70 Dupuis,J.etal.Newgeneticlociimplicatedinfastingglucosehomeostasisandtheirimpacton700type2diabetesrisk.NatGenet42,105-116,doi:10.1038/ng.520(2010).701
71 Soranzo,N.etal.Commonvariantsat10genomiclociinfluencehemoglobinA(1)(C)levelsvia702glycemicandnonglycemicpathways.Diabetes59,3229-3239,doi:10.2337/db10-0502(2010).703
72 Spracklen,C.N.etal.AssociationanalysesofEastAsianindividualsandtrans-ancestryanalyses704withEuropeanindividualsrevealnewlociassociatedwithcholesterolandtriglyceridelevels.705HumMolGenet27,1122,doi:10.1093/hmg/ddx439(2018).706
73 Wu,Y.etal.Ameta-analysisofgenome-wideassociationstudiesforadiponectinlevelsinEast707AsiansidentifiesanovellocusnearWDR11-FGFR2.HumMolGenet23,1108-1119,708doi:10.1093/hmg/ddt488(2014).709
74 Sudlow,C.etal.UKbiobank:anopenaccessresourceforidentifyingthecausesofawiderange710ofcomplexdiseasesofmiddleandoldage.PLoSmedicine12,e1001779,711doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1001779(2015).712
75 Gamazon,E.R.etal.Usinganatlasofgeneregulationacross44humantissuestoinform713complexdisease-andtrait-associatedvariation.NatGenet50,956-967,doi:10.1038/s41588-714018-0154-4(2018).715
76 AnintegratedencyclopediaofDNAelementsinthehumangenome.Nature489,57-74,716doi:10.1038/nature11247(2012).717
.CC-BY 4.0 International licensecertified by peer review) is the author/funder. It is made available under aThe copyright holder for this preprint (which was notthis version posted June 28, 2019. . https://doi.org/10.1101/685172doi: bioRxiv preprint
17
77 Ezzat,S.etal.Thecancer-associatedFGFR4-G388Rpolymorphismenhancespancreaticinsulin718secretionandmodifiestheriskofdiabetes.CellMetab17,929-940,719doi:10.1016/j.cmet.2013.05.002(2013).720
78 Kundaje,A.etal.Integrativeanalysisof111referencehumanepigenomes.Nature518,317-721330,doi:10.1038/nature14248(2015).722
79 Miyazaki,J.etal.Establishmentofapancreaticbetacelllinethatretainsglucose-inducible723insulinsecretion:specialreferencetoexpressionofglucosetransporterisoforms.Endocrinology724127,126-132,doi:10.1210/endo-127-1-126(1990).725
80 Hohmeier,H.E.etal.IsolationofINS-1-derivedcelllineswithrobustATP-sensitiveK+channel-726dependentand-independentglucose-stimulatedinsulinsecretion.Diabetes49,424-430(2000).727
81 Fogarty,M.P.,Cannon,M.E.,Vadlamudi,S.,Gaulton,K.J.&Mohlke,K.L.Identificationofa728regulatoryvariantthatbindsFOXA1andFOXA2attheCDC123/CAMK1Dtype2diabetesGWAS729locus.PLoSGenet10,e1004633,doi:10.1371/journal.pgen.1004633(2014).730
731732733734735736737738739740741742743744745746747748749750751752753754755756757758759760761762763764765
.CC-BY 4.0 International licensecertified by peer review) is the author/funder. It is made available under aThe copyright holder for this preprint (which was notthis version posted June 28, 2019. . https://doi.org/10.1101/685172doi: bioRxiv preprint
18
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS766Thisworkwassupportedbysubawards(toX.SandY.S.C.)fromNIDDKU01DK105554(JoseC.Florez).767Theauthorsthankallinvestigators,staffmembersandstudyparticipantsfortheircontributionstoall768participatingstudies.Afulllistoffunding,andindividualandstudyacknowledgementsareavailablein769SupplementaryMaterials.770771AUTHORCONTRIBUTIONS772Projectcoordination:K.L.M,X.S.Writing:C.N.S.,E.S.T,M.B.,M.H.,Y.J.K.,K.L.,K.L.M,X.S.Coreanalyses:773C.N.S.,M.H.,Y.J.K.,K.L.,A.K.I.,H.J.P.,S.M.B.,X.S.eQTLlookups:M.vdB,A.L.G.DIAMANTEanalysisgroup:774J.E.B.,M.B.,D.W.B.,J.C.C.,A.M.,M.I.M.,M.C.Y.N.,L.E.P.,W.Zhang.,A.P.M.Statisticalanalysisin775individualstudies:Y.T.,M.H.,K.S.,X.S.,F.T.,M.N.,C.N.S.,K.L.,F.B.,Y.J.K.,S.Moon.,C.H.T.T.,J.Y.,X.G.,776J.Long.,J.F.C.,V.J.Y.L.,S.H.K.,H.S.C.,C.H.C.Individualstudydesignandprincipalinvestigators:M.Igase.,777T.Kadowaki.,Y.X.W.,N.K.,M.Y.,K.L.M.,R.G.W.,E.S.T.,B.J.K.,R.C.W.M.,J.I.R.,F.M.,X.O.S.,C.Y.C.,W.P.K.,778T.Y.W.,K.S.P.,Y.S.C.,W.H.H.S.,J.Y.W.Genotypingandphenotyping:K.K.,A.T.,Y.K.,T.Y.,Y.O.,J.B.J.,779T.Katsuya.,M.Isono.,S.I.,K.Yamamoto.,A.H.,S.D.,W.H.,J.S.,P.G.L.,C.Y.,Y.G.,Z.B.,J.Lv.,L.L.,Z.C.,N.R.L.,780L.S.A.,J.Liu.,R.M.vD.,S.H.,K.Yoon.,H.M.J.,D.M.S.,G.J.,A.O.L.,B.T.,W.Y.S.,J.C.N.C.,M.Y.H.,Y.D.I.C.,781T.Kawaguchi.,Y.B.X.,W.Zheng.,L.Z.,C.C.K.,M.A.P.,M.G.,J.M.Y.,C.S.,M.L.C.,M.S.L.,C.M.H.,L.M.C.,782Y.J.H.,L.C.C.,Y.T.C.,F.J.T.,J.I.R.783784AUTHORINFORMATION785786Summary-levelstatisticswillbeavailableattheAGENconsortiumwebsite787https://blog.nus.edu.sg/agen/summary-statistics/andtheAcceleratingMedicinesPartnershipT2D788portalhttp://www.type2diabetesgenetics.org/.789790Theauthorsdeclarenocompetinginterest.791792Correspondenceandrequestsformaterialsshouldbeaddressedtomohlke@med.unc.eduand/or793ephsx@nus.edu.sg.794795WEBRESOURCES796Pre-imputationpreparationandqualitycontrol,http://www.well.ox.ac.uk/~wrayner/tools/797MichiganImputationServer,https://imputationserver.sph.umich.edu/index.html798EPACTS,https://github.com/statgen/EPACTS799RVTESTS,https://github.com/zhanxw/rvtests800METAL,http://csg.sph.umich.edu/abecasis/metal/801LDSC,https://github.com/bulik/ldsc802GWAMA,https://www.geenivaramu.ee/en/tools/gwama803Type2DiabetesKnowledgePortal,http://www.type2diabetesgenetics.org804GTExPortal,https://gtexportal.org/home/805ParkerlabIsletBrowser,http://theparkerlab.org/tools/isleteqtl/806807808809810811812813
.CC-BY 4.0 International licensecertified by peer review) is the author/funder. It is made available under aThe copyright holder for this preprint (which was notthis version posted June 28, 2019. . https://doi.org/10.1101/685172doi: bioRxiv preprint
19
Table1.Novelleadvariantsassociatedwithtype2diabetesinEastAsians814Locus Leadvariant Chr Pos RA NRA RAF Neff Cases
(N)
Controls
(N)
OR(95%CI) P
VWA5B1 rs60573766 1 20,688,352 C T 0.635 210,985 77,181 354,521 1.04(1.03-1.06) 4.30E-10MAST2 rs562138031 1 46,244,900 C CT 0.726 210,231 76,984 350,185 1.06(1.04-1.07) 8.66E-12PGM1 rs2269239 1 64,109,359 C G 0.813 211,039 77,221 351,786 1.06(1.04-1.07) 5.81E-10TSEN15 rs1327123 1 184,014,593 C G 0.460 210,985 77,181 354,521 1.04(1.03-1.05) 6.40E-09MDM4 rs201297151 1 204,474,581 CAAAAAAAA C 0.440 210,231 76,984 350,185 1.04(1.03-1.05) 4.64E-08SIX3 rs12712928 2 45,192,080 C G 0.402 211,321 77,275 355,448 1.06(1.04-1.07) 3.16E-14IKZF2 rs75179644 2 213,687,103 T C 0.899 210,985 77,181 354,521 1.08(1.05-1.10) 6.01E-10ZBTB20 rs6768463 3 114,964,264 T A 0.614 211,793 77,418 356,122 1.05(1.03-1.06) 3.19E-11TFRC rs9866168 3 195,830,310 T A 0.640 210,985 77,181 354,521 1.05(1.03-1.06) 1.31E-09RANBP3L rs16902871 5 36,257,018 G A 0.149 211,793 77,418 356,122 1.06(1.04-1.08) 3.34E-09PCSK1 rs11960326 5 95,850,807 C T 0.416 211,680 77,388 355,625 1.04(1.03-1.05) 3.74E-09REPS1 rs556058292 6 139,259,142 C CT 0.651 210,985 77,181 354,521 1.04(1.03-1.06) 1.42E-08HIVEP2 rs9390022 6 143,056,556 T C 0.800 211,793 77,418 356,122 1.05(1.03-1.07) 6.35E-09ZNF713 rs565050730 7 55,984,953 GA G 0.334 210,985 77,181 354,521 1.04(1.03-1.06) 4.78E-08STEAP1 rs62469016 7 89,752,238 C G 0.223 211,793 77,418 356,122 1.07(1.05-1.08) 1.52E-15CALCR rs2074120 7 93,107,093 A C 0.323 211,793 77,418 356,122 1.04(1.03-1.06) 8.38E-09GRM8/PAX4 rs117737118 7 126,526,991 G A 0.093 209,652 76,825 348,561 1.18(1.15-1.21) 1.01E-31ASAH1 rs34642578 8 17,927,609 T C 0.053 210,985 77,181 354,521 1.09(1.06-1.13) 1.67E-09ZNF703 rs12680217 8 37,397,803 T C 0.553 211,457 77,324 355,195 1.05(1.03-1.06) 1.64E-11GDAP1 rs149265787 8 75,214,398 G A 0.024 211,694 77,392 355,608 1.14(1.10-1.19) 5.68E-10TRIB1 rs10103720 8 126,471,770 C T 0.378 211,793 77,418 356,122 1.04(1.03-1.06) 3.33E-09EFR3A rs73708055 8 132,879,882 G A 0.252 211,793 77,418 356,122 1.04(1.03-1.06) 4.41E-08DMRT2 rs1016565 9 1,032,567 A G 0.421 211,793 77,418 356,122 1.04(1.02-1.05) 2.18E-08PTCH1 rs113154802 9 98,278,413 C T 0.888 210,985 77,181 354,521 1.06(1.04-1.08) 4.91E-08ABCA1 rs201375651 9 107,597,527 CA C 0.395 211,793 77,418 356,122 1.04(1.03-1.06) 2.56E-08PTF1A rs77065181 10 23,487,778 A G 0.047 211,098 77,211 355,018 1.09(1.06-1.13) 1.63E-08ARID5B rs141583966 10 63,712,602 G GGTGT 0.909 210,066 76,938 349,783 1.08(1.05-1.11) 6.58E-10JMJD1C rs148928116 10 64,976,133 T TA 0.795 210,985 77,181 354,521 1.06(1.05-1.08) 2.31E-13ARHGAP19 rs10736116 10 99,056,921 C G 0.306 211,793 77,418 356,122 1.05(1.03-1.06) 9.21E-11BBIP1 rs7895872 10 112,678,657 T G 0.579 210,985 77,181 354,521 1.05(1.03-1.06) 2.29E-11BDNF rs988748 11 27,724,745 G C 0.565 211,793 77,418 356,122 1.04(1.03-1.06) 1.62E-10FAIM2 rs77978149 12 50,269,863 T C 0.090 210,406 77,022 352,897 1.08(1.05-1.10) 3.89E-09ALDH2 rs149212747 12 111,836,771 A AC 0.795 210,231 76,984 350,185 1.07(1.05-1.09) 2.07E-11RBM19 rs7307263 12 114,123,722 G C 0.427 210,985 77,181 354,521 1.04(1.02-1.05) 3.96E-08FGF9 rs9316706 13 22,589,883 A G 0.351 211,793 77,418 356,122 1.04(1.03-1.06) 3.33E-09NYNRIN rs12437434 14 24,878,370 C T 0.713 211,039 77,221 351,786 1.05(1.03-1.06) 1.02E-09LRRC74A rs140431144 14 77,382,093 TA T 0.327 207,126 75,090 353,783 1.05(1.03-1.06) 9.21E-11DLK1/MEG3/
miRNA
cluster
rs73347525 14 101,255,172 A G 0.756 205,739 74,694 350,558 1.06(1.04-1.08) 5.54E-11
TRAF3 rs55700915 14 103,237,952 A G 0.434 211,039 77,221 351,786 1.04(1.03-1.06) 1.50E-08HERC2 rs76704029 15 28,546,173 T C 0.732 173,598 66,475 264,668 1.06(1.04-1.08) 3.03E-08MYO5C rs149336329 15 52,587,740 G T 0.949 210,231 76,984 350,185 1.11(1.07-1.14) 1.31E-09RGMA rs61021634 15 93,825,384 A G 0.438 210,985 77,181 354,521 1.05(1.03-1.06) 9.47E-12IGF1R rs79826452 15 99,366,409 A G 0.890 210,985 77,181 354,521 1.07(1.04-1.10) 3.80E-08PKD1L3 rs12600132 16 72,022,534 T C 0.432 211,793 77,418 356,122 1.04(1.03-1.05) 5.95E-09ZFHX3 rs6416749 16 73,100,308 C T 0.375 210,460 77,062 350,162 1.05(1.04-1.07) 3.40E-12SUMO2 rs35559984 17 73,187,031 CA C 0.652 206,547 74,931 352,159 1.05(1.03-1.07) 7.88E-09ZNF799 rs4604181 19 12,509,536 A C 0.514 209,652 76,825 348,561 1.04(1.03-1.06) 1.80E-08ZNRF3 rs147413364 22 29,380,119 T TA 0.357 210,874 77,175 351,384 1.04(1.03-1.06) 3.38E-08WNT7B rs28637892 22 46,313,618 T G 0.215 175,881 63,772 319,376 1.05(1.04-1.07) 3.66E-09SinglevariantassociationresultsfromEastAsianfixed-effectinverse-variancemeta-analysis(BMI-unadjustedsex-combinedmodeladjustedforage,sex,andstudy-specificcovariates)usingMETAL.Lociweredefinedasnoveliftheleadvariantis(1)atleast500kbawayandconfirmedbyGCTAtobeconditionallyindependentfrompreviouslyreportedT2D-associatedvariantsinanyancestry,and(2)assessedusinglocuszoomplotsandbiologylookupstobeawayfromknownlociwithextendedLD.Fouradditionalvariantsmetthedefinitionforanovellocusbutarelocatedwithinthepreviouslyreportedmajorhistocompatibilitycomplex(MHC)region;seeSupplementaryTableS5forthefulllistofdistinctassociationsignalsattheMHCregion.rs4804181was>500kbfromprimarysignalrs3111316inEuropeanmeta-analysis,but<500kbfromtheirsecondarysignalrs755734872.Genome-widesignificantassociationisdefinedasP<5.0E-08.Physicalpositionbasedonhg19.EffectallelesareassoicatedwithincreasedriskforT2D.OddsratiosreflectperalleleeffectsofvariantsonT2Drisk.Abbreviations:Chr,chromosome;Pos,position;RA,riskallele;NRA,non-riskallele;RAF,riskallelefrequency;Neff,effectivesamplesize;OR,oddsratio;CI,confidenceinterval;P,P-value
815816817818819
.CC-BY 4.0 International licensecertified by peer review) is the author/funder. It is made available under aThe copyright holder for this preprint (which was notthis version posted June 28, 2019. . https://doi.org/10.1101/685172doi: bioRxiv preprint
Figure 1: Two distinct T2D-association signals at the ANK1-NKX6-3 locus associated with expression levels of two transcripts in two tissues. (A) Regional association plot for East Asian sex-combined BMI-unadjusted meta-analysis at ANK1-NKX6-3 locus. Approximate conditional analysis using GTCA identified three distinct T2D-association signals at this locus (signal 1, rs33981001; signal 2, rs62508166; signal 3, rs144239281, in order of strength of association). Using 1000G Phase3 East Asian LD, variants are colored in red and blue with the first and second distinct signals respectively (lead variants represented as diamonds). (B) Variant rs12549902, in high LD (EAS LD r2=0.80, EUR r2=0.83) with T2D signal 1, shows the strongest association with expression levels of NXK6-3 in pancreatic islets in 118 individuals16. (C) Variant rs516946, in high LD (EAS LD r2=0.96, EUR r2=0.80) with T2D signal 2, shows the strongest association with expression levels of ANK1 in subcutaneous adipose tissue in 770 individuals19. As rs62508166 is not available in the subcutaneous adipose tissue data set, a variant in perfect LD (rs28591316) was used and is represented by the blue diamond variant.
.CC-BY 4.0 International licensecertified by peer review) is the author/funder. It is made available under aThe copyright holder for this preprint (which was notthis version posted June 28, 2019. . https://doi.org/10.1101/685172doi: bioRxiv preprint
SFRP1 GOLGA7
GINS4
AGPAT6
NKX6 3
ANK1
KAT6A AP3M2
PLAT
41.2 41.4 41.6 41.8 42Position on chr8 (Mb)
rs62508166 (Signal 2)
0
2
4
6
log 1
0(pva
lue)
ANK1 eQTL Results (Sub. Adipose)
0
2
4
6
log 1
0(pva
lue)
NKX6-3 eQTL Results (Pan. Islets)
rs33981001 (Signal 1)
Figure 1
rs33981001 (Signal 1)
rs62508166 (Signal 2)
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
r2with reference SNPAGEN T2D GWAS Results
0
5
10
15
20
25
log 1
0(pva
lue)
.CC-BY 4.0 International licensecertified by peer review) is the author/funder. It is made available under aThe copyright holder for this preprint (which was notthis version posted June 28, 2019. . https://doi.org/10.1101/685172doi: bioRxiv preprint
−0.25
0.0
0.25
0.50
0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3Per−allele effect size in EAS (SE)
Per−
alle
le e
ffect
siz
e in
EU
R (S
E)A
B
−0.1
0.0
0.1
0.2
0.00 0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20Per−allele effect size in EAS (SE)
Per−
alle
le e
ffect
siz
e in
EU
R (S
E)
EUR onlyEUR and EASEAS only
LEP
PAX4
RANBP3L
PTF1A
TCF7L2
NKX6-1
KCNQ1
ZNF257ZNF738
ATG16L1
P<5x10-8 in:
Figure 2: Effect size comparison of lead variants identified in this T2D GWAS BMI-unadjusted meta-analysis in East Asians and previous T2D GWAS meta-analysis in Europeans2. For 343 lead variants identified from the two BMI unadjusted meta-analyses, per-alleleeffect sizes (beta) from Europeans meta-analysis (y-axis) were plotted against per-allele effect sizes from this East Asians meta-analysis (x-axis). (A) All 343 lead variants; (B) 290 lead variants with minor allele frequency at least 5% in both ancestries. Variants are colored purple if they were significant (P<5x10-8) in East Asians only, green if they were significant in Europeans only, and blue if they were significant in both East Asians and Europeans (see Methods and Supplementary Table 7).
.CC-BY 4.0 International licensecertified by peer review) is the author/funder. It is made available under aThe copyright holder for this preprint (which was notthis version posted June 28, 2019. . https://doi.org/10.1101/685172doi: bioRxiv preprint
A B
C-log 1
0(P-
valu
e)
0
20
40
60
80
100
Recom
bination rate (cM/M
b)
0.20.40.60.8
r2
LOC101928978
85.2 85.4Position on chr4 (Mb) Forward Reverse
Rela
tive
Luci
fera
se A
ctivi
ty
P = 0.0003
EmptyVector
T C T C
P = 0.0001
0
10
20
30
40
85,340,000rs142390274 rs117624659
hg19 Chr4
DNA Element
Islet ChromHMM
100 Vertebrate
Conservation
Islet H3K4me3
Islet H3K4me1
Islet FAIRE
85,330,000
0
5
10
15
NKX6-1
Figure 3: rs117624659 at NKX6-1 locus exhibits allelic differences in transcriptional activity. (A)
rs117624659 (purple diamond) shows the strongest association with type 2 diabetes in the region. Variants are
colored based on 1000G Phase 3 East Asian LD with rs117624659. (B) rs117624659 and an additional candidate
variant rs142390274 in high pairwise LD (r2>0.80) span a 22 kb region approximately 75 kb upstream of NKX6-1.
rs117624659 overlaps a region of open chromatin in pancreatic islets and lies within a region conserved across
vertebrates. (C) rs117624659-T, associated with increased risk of T2D, showed greater transcriptional activity in
an element cloned in both forward and reverse orientations with respect to NKX6-1 in MIN6 cells compared to
rs117624659-C and an “empty vector” containing a minimal promoter.
.CC-BY 4.0 International licensecertified by peer review) is the author/funder. It is made available under aThe copyright holder for this preprint (which was notthis version posted June 28, 2019. . https://doi.org/10.1101/685172doi: bioRxiv preprint
T2D Odds ratio
0.91 0.95 1.00 1.05
AFR
EAS
EUR
HIS
SAS
Combined
rs12712928
Ancestry OR (95% CI) P
2.9E-02
3.2E-14
1.0E-02
6.9E-02
7.8E-01
7.1E-04
0.95 (0.90-0.99)
1.06 (1.04-1.07)
0.98 (0.96-1.00)
0.97 (0.90-1.05)
1.00 (0.96-1.03)
1.02 (1.01-1.03)
T2D Odds ratio
Chinese
Japanese
Korean
Malay/Filipino
Combined
rs12712928
East AsianPopuations OR (95% CI) P
4.2E-06
3.0E-06
1.7E-04
1.6E-01
3.2E-14
1.06 (1.03-1.09)
1.05 (1.03-1.07)
1.06 (1.03-1.10)
1.10 (0.96-1.25)
1.06 (1.04-1.07)
A
B
0.98 1.02 1.07 1.12 1.17
Figure 4: Forest plots of BMI-unadjusted meta-analysis association results at SIX3-SIX2 locus. Odds ratios (black boxes) and 95% confidence intervals (horizontal lines) for T2D associations at the lead East Asian variant (rs12721928) are presented(A) across ancestries of African-American (AFR), East Asian (EAS), European (EUR)2, Hispanic (HIS), and South Asian (SAS) individuals, and (B) within East Asians by four major East Asian populations (Chinese, Japanese, Korean, and Malay/Filipino combined due to small sample sizes). The size of the box is proportional to the sample size of each contributing population.
.CC-BY 4.0 International licensecertified by peer review) is the author/funder. It is made available under aThe copyright holder for this preprint (which was notthis version posted June 28, 2019. . https://doi.org/10.1101/685172doi: bioRxiv preprint
20
FIGURELEGENDS820821Figure1:TwodistinctT2D-associationsignalsattheANK1-NKX6-3locusassociatedwithexpression822levelsoftwotranscriptsintwotissues.(A)RegionalassociationplotforEastAsiansex-combinedBMI-823unadjustedmeta-analysisatANK1-NKX6-3locus.ApproximateconditionalanalysisusingGTCAidentified824threedistinctT2D-associationsignalsatthislocus(signal1,rs33981001;signal2,rs62508166;signal3,825rs144239281,inorderofstrengthofassociation).Using1000GPhase3EastAsianLD,variantsare826coloredinredandbluewiththefirstandseconddistinctsignalsrespectively(leadvariantsrepresented827asdiamonds).(B)Variantrs12549902,inhighLD(EASLDr2=0.80,EURr2=0.83)withT2Dsignal1,shows828thestrongestassociationwithexpressionlevelsofNXK6-3inpancreaticisletsin118individuals16.(C)829Variantrs516946,inhighLD(EASLDr2=0.96,EURr2=0.80)withT2Dsignal2,showsthestrongest830associationwithexpressionlevelsofANK1insubcutaneousadiposetissuein770individuals19.As831rs62508166isnotavailableinthesubcutaneousadiposetissuedataset,avariantinperfectLD832(rs28591316)wasusedandisrepresentedbythebluediamondvariant.833834Figure2:EffectsizecomparisonofleadvariantsidentifiedinthisEastAsianT2DGWASBMI-835unadjustedmeta-analysisandpreviousEuropeanT2DGWASmeta-analysis2.836For343leadvariantsidentifiedfromthetwoBMIunadjustedmeta-analyses,per-alleleeffectsizes(β)837fromtheEuropeanmeta-analysis(y-axis)wereplottedagainstper-alleleeffectsizesfromthisEastAsian838meta-analysis(x-axis).(A)All343leadvariants;(B)290leadvariantswithminorallelefrequency≥5%in839bothancestries.Variantsarecoloredpurpleiftheyweresignificant(P<5x10-8)intheEastAsiananalysis840only,greeniftheyweresignificantinEuropeananalysisonly,andblueiftheyweresignificantinboth841theEastAsianandEuropeananalysis(seeMethodsandSupplementaryTable7).Thedasheddiagonal842linerepresentsthetrendlineacrossallplottedvariants.843844Figure3:rs117624659atNKX6-1locusexhibitsallelicdifferencesintranscriptionalactivity.(A)845rs117624659(purplediamond)showsthestrongestassociationwithT2Dintheregion.Variantsare846coloredbasedon1000GPhase3EastAsianLDwithrs117624659.(B)rs117624659andanadditional847candidatevariantrs142390274inhighpairwiseLD(r2>0.80)spana22kbregionapproximately75kb848upstreamofNKX6-1.rs117624659overlapsaregionofopenchromatininpancreaticisletsandlies849withinaregionconservedacrossvertebrates.(C)rs117624659-T,associatedwithincreasedriskofT2D,850showedgreatertranscriptionalactivityinanelementclonedinbothforwardandreverseorientations851withrespecttoNKX6-1inMIN6cellscomparedtors117624659-Candan“emptyvector”containinga852minimalpromoter.853854Figure4:ForestplotsofBMI-unadjustedmeta-analysisassociationresultsatSIX3-SIX2locus.Odds855ratios(blackboxes)and95%confidenceintervals(horizontallines)forT2DassociationsattheleadEast856Asianvariant(rs12721928)arepresented(A)acrossancestriesofAfrican-American(AFR),EastAsian857(EAS),European(EUR)2,Hispanic(HIS),andSouthAsian(SAS)individuals,and(B)withinfourmajorEast858Asianpopulations(Chinese,Japanese,Korean,andMalay/Filipinocombinedduetosmallsamplesizes).859Thesizeoftheboxisproportionaltothesamplesizeofeachcontributingpopulation.860861SupplementaryFigure1:Flowchartofstudydesign,depictingthedifferentdataanalysesperformed.862863SupplementaryFigure2:ManhattanplotforEastAsianT2Dmeta-analysisassociationresultsinmodel864unadjustedforBMI.-log10(P)fromfixedeffectsinversevarianceweightedgenome-widemeta-analysis865associationresultsforeachvariant(y-axis)wasplottedagainstthegenomicposition(hg19;x-axis).866KnownT2Dlociachievinggenome-widesignificance(P<5.0x10-8)meta-analysisareshowninblue.Loci867
.CC-BY 4.0 International licensecertified by peer review) is the author/funder. It is made available under aThe copyright holder for this preprint (which was notthis version posted June 28, 2019. . https://doi.org/10.1101/685172doi: bioRxiv preprint
21
achievinggenome-widesignificancethatarepreviouslyunreportedforT2Dassociationareshownin868red.869870SupplementaryFigure3:Therelationshipbetweeneffectsizeandminorallelefrequency.Oddsratios871(y-axis)andminorallelefrequencies(x-axis)for178primaryassociationsignalsfromtheT2DBMI-872unadjustedmodels.873874SupplementaryFigure4:RegionalassociationplotsatsevenT2Dassociatedlociwiththestrongest875associationP-valueandmorethanfivedistinctassociationsignalsinEastAsians.(A)INS/IGF2/KCNQ1,876(B)CDKN2A/B,(C)PAX4/LEP,(D)CDKAL1,(E)HHEX/IDE,(F)CDC123/CAMK1D,and(G)TCF7L2.Variants877arecoloredbasedonEastAsian1000GPhase3LDwiththeleadvariantsforeachassociationsignal,878shownasdiamonds.879880SupplementaryFigure5:MiamiplotsofEastAsianT2Dmeta-analysisassociationresultsadjustedfor881BMI.Foreachplot,-log10(P)fromfixedeffectsinverse-varianceweightedgenome-widemeta-analysis882associationresultsforeachvariant(y-axis)wasplottedagainstthegenomicposition(hg19;x-axis).(A)883Sex-combinedmeta-analysesinmodelsunadjustedforBMI(top)andadjustedforBMI(bottom).Both884sex-combinedmodelsincludethesamesetofstudiesforcomparablesamplesize.NovelT2D-associated885lociareshowninblue(modelsunadjustedforBMI),purple(modelsadjustedforBMI),orgreen(both);886(B)sex-specificmeta-analysesformales(top)andfemales(bottom)withoutBMIadjustment;and(C)887sex-specificmeta-analysesformales(top)andfemales(bottom)withBMIadjustment.For(B)and(C),888locisignificantlyassociatedwithT2Dinfemalesonlyareshowninpurpleandlocisignificantlyassociated889withT2Dinmalesonlyareshowninblue.890891SupplementaryFigure6:Effectsizecomparisonofleadvariantsinsex-combinedmodelsunadjusted892andadjustedforBMI.At178leadvariantsidentifiedintheEastAsianBMI-unadjustedsex-combined893T2Dmeta-analysis,per-alleleeffectsizes(β)fromBMI-adjustedsex-combinedmodelswereplotted894againstBMI-unadjustedsex-combinedmodel.Bothsex-combinedmodelsincludethesamesetof895studiesforcomparablesamplesize.Errorbarsindicate95%confidenceintervals.Effectsizesbetween896thetwomodelsarehighlycorrelatedwithaPearsoncorrelationcoefficientr=0.99(SupplementaryTable8974).898899SupplementaryFigure7:Regionalplotsofmale-specificT2D-associatedlocus,ALDH2.(A)Malesonly,900(B)sex-combined,and(C)femalesonly.Foreachplot,-log10(P)fromassociationresultsforeachvariant901(y-axis)wasplottedagainstthegenomicposition(hg19;x-axis).Theleadvariantrs12231737plottedis902theleadvariantfromBMI-unadjustedmale-specificmeta-analysis,andalsothesex-combinedmeta-903analysisfromthesamesubsetofindividualsincludedinthesex-stratifiedanalyses.Thisleadvariant904rs12231737isinhighLDwithrs77768175,identifiedfromthelargerBMI-unadjustedsex-combined905meta-analysis(EastAsianr2=0.80).VariantsareshadedbasedonEastAsian1000GPhase3LDwiththe906leadvariant,shownasapurplediamond.907908SupplementaryFigure8:Effectsizecomparisonofcommonleadvariants(MAF≥5%)identifiedinEast909Asianmeta-analysisandpreviouslypublishedEuropeanT2DGWASmeta-analysis2.910For290leadvariantswithMAF≥5%inbothEastAsianandEuropeanBMI-unadjustedmeta-analyses,911per-alleleeffectsizes(β)fromMahajanetal.2(y-axis)wereplottedagainstper-alleleeffectsizesfrom912thisEastAsianmeta-analysis(x-axis).VariantsarecoloredpurpleiftheyweresignificantintheEast913Asianmeta-analysisonly,greeniftheyweresignificantinEuropeanmeta-analysisonly,andblueifthey914
.CC-BY 4.0 International licensecertified by peer review) is the author/funder. It is made available under aThe copyright holder for this preprint (which was notthis version posted June 28, 2019. . https://doi.org/10.1101/685172doi: bioRxiv preprint
22
weresignificantinboththeEastAsianandEuropeanmeta-analyses.Errorbarsindicate95%confidence915intervals.(seeMethodsandSupplementaryTable7).916917SupplementaryFigure9:EffectsizecomparisonofleadvariantsidentifiedinEastAsianBMI-918unadjustedmeta-analysisandpreviouslypublishedEuropeanT2DGWASmeta-analysis2.919For343leadvariantsidentifiedfromthetwoBMI-unadjustedmeta-analyses,per-alleleeffectsizes(β)920fromaEuropeanmeta-analysis(y-axis)wereplottedagainstper-alleleeffectsizesfromthisEastAsian921meta-analysis(x-axis).(A)162leadvariantssignificantintheEastAsianmeta-analysis(purple)orboth922theEastAsianandEuropeanmeta-analysis(blue)and(B)192leadvariantssignificantintheEuropean923meta-analysis(green)orboththeEastAsianandEuropeanmeta-analysis(blue).Theseplotsincludeonly924onevariantperlocus,incontrasttoFigure2andSupplementaryFigure8.925926SupplementaryFigure10:T2D-associationnearZNF257anditsrelationshipwithapreviouslyreported927ZNF257inversion.TheleadT2D-associatedvariantrs142395395nearZNF257tagsaninversionobserved928almostexclusivelyinEastAsianindividuals.Weobservedanassociationbetweenthevariantstagging929theinversionandadecreasedriskforT2D.Inthereferencehaplotype(“Reference”),thereisno930disruptiontoZNF257anditspromoter,thusthereisnormalZNF257functionandnormalexpressionof931downstreamtranscripts.Whenthealternateallelesarepresent(“Inversion”),aninversionisobserved,932markedbytheseparationofthepromoterandfirsttwoexonsofZNF257fromtherestofthegeneand933movingthemover400kbupstream.WhilethishasnotbeenobservedtoaffectexpressionofZNF208,934ZNF43,orZNF100,theinversionresultsinalossofZNF257functionandalteredexpressionof935downstreamtargets33.936937SupplementaryFigure11:rs117624659atNKX6-1exhibitsallelicdifferencesintranscriptionalactivity.938(A)ChromatinmarksinpancreaticisletsintheintergenicregionnearNKX6-1fromtheUCSCGenome939Browser(hg19)spanningtheleadT2Dassociatedvariant,rs117624659,andtheonlyothercandidate940variantrs142390274inhighLD(EastAsianr2>0.80)withrs117624659.NKX6-1istranscribedfromright941toleft.rs117624659overlapsregionsofaccessiblechromatininhumanpancreaticisletsdetectedby942isletFAIRE-seqalongwithH3K4me1andH3K4me3ChIP-seq.Italsooverlapsaconservedregionin943vertebrates.ThetestedcandidateregulatoryDNAelementisrepresentedbyahorizontalblack944rectangleintheupperportionofthefigure.(B)rs117624659attheNKX6-1locusexhibitedsignificant945allelicdifferencesintranscriptionalactivityinMIN6mouseinsulinomacellsonasecondday.(C-D)946rs11762465attheNKX6-1locusdidnotexhibitsignificantallelicdifferencesintranscriptionalactivityin947832/13ratinsulinomacellsonexperimentalday1(C)orday2(D).948949SupplementaryFigure12:Forestplotsof49novelT2D-associatedvariantsusingdatafromfive950ancestriesintheDIAMANTEconsortium.T2Dmeta-analysisresultsforthe49novelT2D-associated951variantsidentifiedinthisEastAsianmeta-analysiswereobtainedfromtheotherfourancestrygroups952withintheDIAMANTEconsortium(African-American,European,Hispanic,andSouthAsian)for953comparison.Oddsratios(blackboxes)and95%confidenceintervals(horizontallines)fortheassociation954betweentheleadEastAsianvariantsandT2Dfromeachancestryarepresented,alongwithacombined955oddsratioandP-value.Thesizeoftheboxisproportionaltothesamplesizeofeachcontributing956ancestrygroup.957958SupplementaryFigure13:ForestplotofBMI-unadjustedEastAsianmeta-analysisassociationresults959atSIX3-SIX2locusfromeachcontributingcohort.Oddsratios(blackboxes)and95%confidence960intervals(horizontallines)forT2DassociationsattheleadEastAsianvariant(rs12721928)arepresented961
.CC-BY 4.0 International licensecertified by peer review) is the author/funder. It is made available under aThe copyright holder for this preprint (which was notthis version posted June 28, 2019. . https://doi.org/10.1101/685172doi: bioRxiv preprint
23
foreachEastAsiancontributingcohort.Thesizeoftheboxisproportionaltothesamplesizeofeach962dataset.FullstudynamescanbefoundinSupplementaryTable1.963
.CC-BY 4.0 International licensecertified by peer review) is the author/funder. It is made available under aThe copyright holder for this preprint (which was notthis version posted June 28, 2019. . https://doi.org/10.1101/685172doi: bioRxiv preprint