Download - Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
1/68
Nvn`fhn Kjoursdy
JKHAN@YQKJ
AKHY @NY JK]LNY ANY M]O^F@@OHY
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
2/68
=
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
3/68
9
KRKHQ*S]OSOY;
@k posfn k kiiojpklh Jkhan`stkj anpufs `ln an ;1 khs eusqu soh ig`ft an
aportktfoh nh ;697( Sourtkht akhs sk mfolrkpgfn an potn f` y k uh gfktus( ^h vfan( ^hn
prfoan an ifhq khhns o Jkhan`stkj snst trouv potfqunjnht kpgohn( Akhs inttn
prfoan an jk`kfsn an jk`*trn inst `k prosn quf k prfs iurfnusnjnht `n rn`kfs an `k posfn(
Srosn trs pnrsohhn``n akhs `ns anux snhs au tnrjn 5 pkrin qu hu``n kutrn pkrnf``n nt pkrin
qun `nenan `gojjn nt au potn y nst iohstkjjnht prsnht(
Inttn prosn nst nssnhtfn``njnht iojposn an quktrn ouvrklns( Ku bf` ans pklns ans
souvnhfrs au Mruft au Qnjps `k bfitfoh au Qfjmrn lyptfnh ans ikrhnts an routn au
Roykln nh Krjhfn ku irf an rvo`tn iohtrn `k `fttrkturn fhstftutfohhn``n nt `poqun
stk`fhfnhhn an @k [uktrfjn Srosn Jkhan`stkj k prktfqu uhn sortn akuto*khk`ysn(
Int nsskf skttkign iojprnharn nt khk`ysnr `n snhs nt `k portn an inttn prosn( Ku *an`
an `nur vk`nur purnjnht `fttrkfrn ins tnxtns avof`nht `k jkrign `nhtn nt prolrnssfvn
aOssfp Jkhan`stkj `k rnhiohtrn an `uf*jjn f`s soht uh nspkin akhs `nqun` `irfvkfh
rnjnt nh qunstfoh tout in nh quof f` kvkft iru eusqun*` akhs `nqun` f` sn rn*sftun pkr rkpport
sk bkjf``n sk euaft `k `fttrkturn `k soift( Inttn prosn*qutn afanhtft `n jhn au
askrrof `k inrtftuan an `toubbnjnht `k `fmrktfoh( Ku tnrjn an in voykln Jkhan`stkj
k pu rntrouvnr nxprnssfoh an sk pkfx fhtrfnurn sk vofx potfqun akhs toutn soh
kutgnhtfift nt `uhft an soh jof(
Nvn`fhn Kjoursdy
;irftn ku iours an `,t ;676 inttn tuan k t qun`qun pnu rnjkhfn ku bf` ans khs(
@ns iftktfohs skhs jnhtfoh an trkauitnur soht trkauftns pkr jof(
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
4/68
1
Sour @(
Sour N(
-@ns prnjfnrs tfjmrns lyptfnhs oht t jfs nh ;722(@,lyptn bkfskft k`ors pkrtfn an `,Njpfrn Ottojkh(
@k prnjfrn srfn kvkft ans krkmnsquns iojjn jotfb(-;
;Fh \fdfpafk Gfstofrn pgf`kt`fqun nt postk`n an `,lyptngttp5//br(wfdfpnafk(orl/wfdf/Gfstofrn_pgf`kt.I9.K6`fqun_nt_postk`n_an_`.=
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
5/68
>
F
@NY N]]KHINY
Hn` jnzzo an`,ikjfh af hostrk vftkAkhtn
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
6/68
2
Yf `,oh tnhtn an sufvrn Jkhan`stkj ku `ohl ans trnhtn prnjfrns khhns an sk
vfn oh s,nssoubb`n prfs an jk`kfsn anvkht sk ioursn nbbrhn vnrtflfhnusn nxk`tn
nt sufifakfrn `k bofs( K igkqun houvn``n tkpn oh k `,fjprnssfoh qu,f` mr`n in qu,f`
kvkft kaor qu,f` tun `n en brklf`n pnfhn mk`mutfkht qu,f` vnhkft an jnttrn ku
johan nt `k ioursn rnprnha lrfskhtn sortn an en vkfs aohi en sufs (
Buftn ? [utn an sof ? Apossnssfoh an sof ?
Au jkrxfsjn ku igrfstfkhfsjn au syjmo`fsjn `,kijfsjn an ]ojn
Myzkhin au russn `,uhfvnrsn` `n pkyskln abf`n kvni nh ahojfhktnur iojjuh
toutns ins nrrkhins uh jjn sinku 5 `k rnignrign a,uhn fanhtft(
Qoutnbofs eusqu, `,ln an trnhtn khs Jkhan`stkj hn s,nst ekjkfs snhtf nh
iohtrkafitfoh kvni `uf*jjn qun`s qu,kfnht t sns igofx nt sns orfnhtktfohs( Igofx
pourtkht ju`tfp`ns souvnht iohtrkafitofrns iu`turn`s spfrftun`s po`ftfquns(
Inpnhakht vnrs `n jf`fnu ans khhns vfhlt f` iojjnhin souakfh rnssnhtfr uh
jk`kfsn uh askrrof quf sn jun mfnhtt nh probohan irfsn jork`n(
Yur `n jf`fnu au ignjfh an `k vfnEn jn trouvkf akhs uhn bort sojmrn 5@n aroft ignjfh sn pnrakft lkr(;
Mrusqunjnht Jkhan`stkj k `n snhtfjnht an hn p`us rntrouvnr `k trkin au aroft
ignjfh nt in h,nst pks pkr gkskra s,f` s,nst pkssfohh pour @k Afvfhn Iojafneustnjnht `,kumn ans khhns trnhtn uhn bofs soh ignjfh rntrouv=( Sroust hn
afskft*f` pks qun igkqun `nitnur nst qukha f` `ft `n proprn `nitnur an sof*jjn ?
;AKHQN @k afvfhn iojafn trka( G(@ohlhoh a( Lkrhfnr ;6>;(= An ;693 ;699 Jkhan`stkj irft soh Nhtrntfnh sur Akhtn quf mfnh p`us qu,uhn purnkhk`ysn irftfqun an @k afvfhn iojafn nst `k proenitfoh an sns khlofssns nhbfh inrhnsiojprfsns jktrfsns an `,gojjn nt au potn(
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
7/68
khhn o Jkhan`stkjirft soh
Souigdfhn nt Yirfkmfhn(
]ojn `k strf`n `,fhbiohan sn voft kussftt ajytgfbfn kssfjf`n ku
euaksjn 5 Yf ]ojn vkfhi in h,nst jjn pks n``n quf vkfhirk jkfs `n euaksjn `n
euaksjn quf s,nst toueours tnhu anrrfrn soh aos nt quf kttnha soh gnurn(
; K`ors qu,ku amut ans khhns trnhtn nt hotkjjnht akhs `,Nhtrntfnh sur AkhtnJkhan`stkj pkr`n kvni pkssfoh an in qu,f` hojjn `kirfstk``olrkpgfn an `k struiturnfhtfjn au jkrmrn nt au lrkhft 'nt `ns roigns aohhns nh nxnjp`n h,oht pks t igofsfnspkr gkskra +& * kutrnjnht aft an `,orflfhnan `k pfnrrn(
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
10/68
;3
Hojmrn a,irfvkfhs eufbs qun` qun soft `nur rkpport `nur euaft ohtnxprfj a,uhn jkhfrn ou a,uhn kutrn `k pnur an tout uh pnup`n an h,trn pks
iojjn `,kutrn `k pnur an h,trn pks rniohhu pkr `ns kutrns( Skstnrhkd bkft afrn
`,uh an sns pnrsohhklns5 Iojjnht kvni `ns jjns mrks nt `ns jjns ekjmns `n
jjn `khlkln nt `ns jjns gkmftuans oh pouvkft trn kutrn igosn qun `ns kutrns nt
pkr*anssus `n jkrig qun`qun igosn quf hn p`kfskft lurn nt qun ,oh h,kfjkft pks ?
TZ [un sflhfbfn trn Eufb ? Sourquof in`k nxfstn*t*f` ? ; Jjn khlofssn jjn
rvo`tn kux quktrn iofhs au johan 5 En hn vou`kfs pks trn int fhbfrjn qu,ohhojjkft Eufb surtout pkrin qun en vou`kfs trn uh gojjn4 nt pkrin qun en vou`kfs
k``nr vnrs tous `ns gojjns pour rniohqurfr inttn gujkhft quf j,tkft afsiutn( =
[un sflhfbfkft pour `n enuhn Jkhan`stkj `n jot euaksjn ? Ykhs aoutn hf uhn
pgf`osopgfn hf uhn iu`turn hf uhn rn`flfoh jkfs mfnh qun`qun igosn an skhs hoj
an tnrrfm`n nt TanZ iohtrn*hkturn( Yk m`nssurn nst jofhs `n trkaftfohhn` iojp`nxn
au Eufb bkin ku johan ans kutrns qun `k qunstfoh 5 qu,kf*en an iojjuh kvni in
johan akhs `nqun` en hn jn rniohhkfs pks( Nt s,f` rnpoussn an toutns sns borins int
uhfvnrs eufb in h,nst pks nh tkht qun Eufb gohtnux jkfs pkrin qun `,khlofssn qun
susiftn in johan utrfh fhiohhu kttnfht uh hfvnku pkroxystfqun 5 `n euaksjn
ikstrktnur `n jnhkin akhs soh fhtlrft( Yoh snu` sk`ut i,nst `k buftn quf `n jhn
`,oppos an in johan*bkjf``n tnhtkiu`kfrn nt avornur(
; M( SKYQN]HKD @n aoitnur Efvklo a( Lk``fjkra ;6>7(
= K( JNJJF @k `fmrktfoh au Eufb a( Skyot ;622(
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
11/68
;;
@n rnbuln snrk `n igrfstfkhfsjn( @ns borins quf `n poussnht nt `,kttfrnht vnrs inttn
houvn``n anstfhktfoh portnht `n jjn hoj qun in``ns quf `,kvkfnht pouss vnrs `k
Rf``n tnrhn``n( Jkfs Jkhan`stkj brkhigft uh snuf` supp`jnhtkfrn 5 njmrkssnr `k
bof igrtfnhhn ortgoaoxn i,nst trkhslrnssnr `k `of an sns khitrns p`us jjn i,nst
pkssnr au ikjp an `,opprfj ku ikjp an `,opprnssnur;( S`us qu,uhn buftn i,nst uhn
rupturn totk`n nt kvni soh jf`fnu nt kvni sk iu`turn orflfhn``n nt kvni soh gfstofrn(
Inttn pkssfoh*` Jkhan`stkj `,k viun trs bort pnhakht snpt khs( @n afkpgkhn
`n trkhspkrnht `,tgr sn sumstftunht `k pfnrrn `k mnkut quf brkppn `,f`(
Bksifh pkr in johan quf h,nst pks `n sfnh f` s,fhvnhtn uhn houvn``n fanhtft( F` nst
kvfan an hourrfturns spfrftun``ns an bof nh Afnu nt akhs `n Igrfst quf `uf rnaohhnht
bof nh `uf(
@k tnrrn nst fjjomf`n nt kvni n``n
En mofs au igrfstfkhfsjn `,kfr brofa ans gkutnurs@n soupfr au psk`jfstn nt `n Irnao kmruptAns l`fsns ans kptrns gkf``ohs nt sourins +
Skr qun` trkft pourrkft*oh rnharn `k trkhspkrnhinAns hotns kflus akhs `,tgnr bortfbf ?Ans igrtfnhhns gkutnurs akhs `,nspkin tohhAnsinha iojjn uh igkht an Sk`nstfhn `k lrin (=
@k srhft quf sn alkln an ins vnrs aohhnrkft irofrn qun `n potn k nhbfh
trouv sk p`kin akhs `n johan( Eofn k``lrnssn soht `ns jots quf rnvfnhhnht `n p`us
souvnht akhs `n iyi`n Qrfstfk iojjn akhs `ns irfts irftfquns an ins khhns*` asqu,f` s,klft an igrfstfkhfsjn(
Nt `,Nuigkrfstfn iojjn uh tnrhn` jfafYn pro`ohln nt igkiuh eoun iojjuhfn nt igkhtn
; Bkut*f` rkppn`nr `n r`n an `,Nl`fsn russn akhs `ns ikjpklhns khtfsjftns?+
=O( Jkhan`stkj * Qrfstfk nt kutrns pojns trka( B( Drn` a( Lk``fjkra ;6(
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
12/68
;=
Nt `n vksn afvfh sous `n rnlkra an tous]ufssn``n a,fhpufskm`n k``lrnssn(;
I,nst `k jjn khhn qun vofnht `n eour `n pojn sur `,Nuigkrfstfn nt `,krtfi`n
irft `,oiiksfoh an `k jort an Yirfkmfhn akhs `nqun` Jkhan`stkj nxposn sk tgorfn
an `,krt igrtfnh( Lrin `k jnrvnf``nusn jfsrfioran au igrfstfkhfsjn toutn
hotrn iu`turn mfjf``hkfrn nst `k jfsn nh `fmnrt au johan pour `n enu pour
`,k``lrnssn spfrftun``n pour `k `fmrn fjftktfoh au Igrfst (=
Int krtfi`n k bkft iou`nr mnkuioup a,nhirn( A,kuiuhs aoht Hkaneak
Jkhan`stkj oht iru 'ou vou`u& y vofr `n irnao an Jkhan`stkj( Nrrnur an
eulnjnht ? Ou vfanhtn jkuvkfsn bof ? In tnxtn pkssfohh h,nxprfjn jn snjm`n*t*
f` qun `n irnao au jojnht9an Jkhan`stkj( @n irnao ans snpt khhns pkssns akhs
`k aouin nupgorfn au igrfstfkhfsjn(
Oh pnut inpnhakht pkr`nr au irnao an Jkhan`stkj 5 `,Gn``hfsjn `,Khtfquftvof` `k iohstkhtn an toutn soh uvrn( I,nst ` qu,n``n nst sk bfa`ft( @,Gn``kan
jtkpgorn an soh fanhtft fhtrfnurn k t sk rbrnhin suprjn( Jkhan`stkj h,k
rfnh a,uh tgorfifnh an `k bof( Sotn kjkht an `k iu`turn i,nst toueours pkr rkpport
; Fmfa(
=Souigdfhn nt Yirfkmfhn( uvrns iojp`tns Q(FF a( Fhtnr*@khlukln @ftnrkry Kssoifktns;6
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
13/68
;9
n``n qu,f` sn sftun( @gn``hfsjn qu,f` prnssnht iojjn uh iohinpt gfstorfio*iu`turn`
prnha `n vfskln an in qu,f` kfjn nt an in nh quof f` iroft ku bf` an soh vo`utfoh(;6;> 5 @n igrfstfkhfsjn gn``hfsn `k jort( @,gn``hfsjn bioha pkr `k jort
i,nst in`k `n igrfstfkhfsjn(
;6== 5 @k `khlun russn nst uhn `khlun gn``hfstfqun( Nh rkfsoh an toutn uhn
srfn an iohaftfohs gfstorfquns `ns borins vfvns an `k iu`turn gn``hfqun
kmkhaohhkht `,oiifanht kux fhb`unhins `ktfhns nt iourtkht `nur seour akhs uhn
Myzkhin strf`n sn soht `khins akhs `n snfh an `k `khlun russn `uf iohbfkht `n
snirnt gn``hfqun au johan( Qoueours akhs `n jjn krtfi`n 5 @,gn``hfsjn i,nst s,nhvfrohhnr iohsifnjjnht
a,ustnhsf`ns ku `fnu a,oments fhafbbrnhts( TZ I,nst gujkhfsnr `n johan
nhvfrohhkht i,nst `n rigkubbnr `k igk`nur sumtf`n t`o`olfqun( TZ @,gn``hfsjn
i,nst `k mkrqun buhrkfrn ans abuhts lyptfnhs akhs `kqun``n oh p`kin tout in quf
nst hinsskfrn `k poursuftn au voykln tnrrnstrn an `,gojjn(
;6=2 5 Snhakht `k akhsn `n vfskln an Jfdgon`s prnha uhn nxprnssfoh an skln
bktflun nt an trfstn rkvfssnjnht iojjn sf `n jksqun au pnup`n eufb sn rkpproigkht
an `,Khtfquft tkft prnsqun fhafssoifkm`n a,n``n( ;
Ins pgrksns hns ans tkpns afbbrnhtns an `k pnhsn nt an `k vfn an
Jkhan`stkj oht pkrbofs snrvf an prtnxtn nt an support ans kssnrtfohs
iktlorfquns tn``ns qun Jkhan`stkj potn igrtfnh Jkhan`stkj potn
eufb ( F` jn pkrkt bohakjnhtk` pour `k iojprgnhsfoh= an `,gojjn iojjn pour
in``n an `,irfvkfh an hn ekjkfs pnrarn an vun qun `,uvrn an Jkhan`stkj uhn nt
; Rofr in propos `n trs fhtrnsskht krtfi`n an A(YNLK@ 5 -Nigtigo oafh hnfzvnsthyetndst Jkhan`stkjk ?- 'Nhiorn uh tnxtn fhiohhu an Jkhan`stkj ?& fh Y`kvfikGfnroso`yjftkhk vo`( FFF Erusk`nj ;6
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
14/68
;1
ju`tfp`n `k bofs hn prnha tout soh snhs qun rnp`kin akhs soh iohtnxtn akhs sk
igroho`olfn(Nh ;6=; Jkhan`stkj irft soh anrhfnr pojn igrtfnh kux iou`nurs an Myzkhin
quf i`t soh iyi`n Qrfstfk( @n igrfstfkhfsjn sn atkign an `uf skhs aou`nur kppkrnhtn
iojjn uh bruft sni(
As `,khhn sufvkhtn i,nst inttn bofs Myzkhin quf nst quk`fbfn an strf`n ou p`us
`fttrk`njnht Jkhan`stkj aft 5 skhs nhbkht(@k sflhfbfiktfoh an in quk`fbfiktfb trouvn
pnut*trn soh airyptkln akhs @k [uktrfjn Srosn 5 @ns nhbkhts aofvnht
poursufvrn kprs hous afrn kprs hous `,nssnhtfn`( Ins jots*` Jkhan`stkj h,kpu krrfvnr `ns prohohinr qu,kprs uh `ohl `nht nt aou`ournux voykln nh `uf*
jjn(
@ns jtkpgorns hous lufanht akhs `n `kmyrfhtgn an `k pnhsn an Jkhan`stkj(
Akhs soh nsskf An `k hkturn au jot ';6==& `ns jtkpgorns `ns iojpkrkfsohs `ns
fjklns oht trkft soft `k bkjf``n soft ku quotfafnh `k igk`nur au boynr 5 @k
pgf`o`olfn i,nst `k bkjf``n pkrin qun toutn bkjf``n k pour pfvot sns fhtohktfohs sns
iftktfohs sns luf``njnts( ^h jot prohohi `n p`us mkhk`njnht au johan k nh
bkjf``n sk hukhin( Nt p`us `ofh 5 @,gn``hfsjn i,nst uh p`kt bour i,nst uh pfqun*
bnu i,nst uh pot `kft in soht `ns ustnhsf`ns aojnstfquns `k vkfssn``n tout in quf sn
trouvn akhs `,nhtourkln au iorps4 `,gn``hfsjn i,nst `k igk`nur au boynr rnssnhtfn
iojjn skirn(
I,nst `k prnjfrn bofs nh inttn khhn ;6== qun Jkhan`stkj kmoran in tgjn(
Akhs sk posfn an enuhnssn f` kvkft bkft k``usfoh kux sfnhs pkr`kht a,nux iojjn
a,uh `jnht trkhlnr nt jprfskm`n 5
E,kf rnu pour jk pkrt uh gnurnux grftkln 5An igkhtrns trkhlnrs ans sohlns vklkmohas(Rrkf oh nst mfnh nh aroft an pouvofr jprfsnrBkjf``n nt `ksskht vofsfhkln(
Nt `k jjn khhn 5
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
15/68
;>
@k trfstnssn an jfnhsJ,nst toueours trkhlrn(
Jkfs vrkf afrn oh kvkft `,fjprnssfoh eusqun*` qun `n iohinpt jjn anbkjf``n
an boynr h,nxfstkft pks pour `uf( Iojjn sf `n rnbou`kht kux bfhs bohas an sk
jjofrn f` `n rnhakft fhnxfstkht( Nst*in `k vfn iojjuhn kvni sk buturn pousn quf k
bkft hktrn ins fjklns fay``fquns aouins nt tnharns ? @k iojp`fift bkjf`fk`n `k
igk`nur au boynr `k bkjf``n siurfskhtn nst*in ` `k proenitfoh an `k bkjf``n qun
Jkhan`stkj rvn an bohanr ? Nt nhiorn uhn qunstfoh qun `,oh pnut sn posnr 5 nst*in
in bkhtksjn quf k pnrjfs `k `fmrktfoh au b`ot an souvnhfrs a,nhbkhin quf nhvkgft `nspklns au Mruft au Qnjps nt au Qfjmrn lyptfnh ?
Eusqun*` Jkhan`stkj kvkft trkvnrs `ns khhns nt `nur iogortn an afbbfiu`ts
kvni srhft pkrin qu,f` tkft toueours sr an soh moh aroft( F` h,kvkft pks irkfht sns
proprns iohtrkafitfohs ikr n``ns tkfnht sns ynux uhn sourin biohan `kqun``n f`
pufskft borin nt irktfvft( Jkfs nh in amut ans khhns vfhlt tout snjm`n mksiu`nr 5
igkqun stropgn au iyi`n ;6=;*;6=> irfn soh jk`*trn soh askrrof 5
Jnrif pour in quf k t 5En jn sufs trojp en jn sufs lkr e,kf pnrau `n iojptn(
(
@n tnjps j,kjputn iojjn uhn pfin an johhkfnNt ae f` jn jkhqun uhn pkrt an jof*jjn(;
Rfn a,krlf`n + Yfi`n `nht jourfr +E,kf pnur qun in`uf*` snu` tn iojprnhhnAoht `k `vrn portn ekjkfs `,kjnr sourfrnAn `,gojjn lkr an sof*jjn((
; ';6=9& Qrka( B( Drn` op( ift(
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
16/68
;2
En vouarkfs bufr brkhigfr `n snuf`(
Jkfs o k``nr ?;
in snhtfjnht a,lkrnjnht sn j`n `k snhsktfoh tnrrfbfkhtn an aup`fift nt
a,fjposturn 5
[uf sufs*en jof ? Hf `n ruan jkohHf `n igkrpnhtfnr hf `n mtfssnur ans hkvfrns +En sufs uh gypoirftn `,jn aoum`n(=
I,nst uh kutrn qun jof quf iojjn jof sn hojjnNt int gojohyjn jn bkft gorrnur(9
Sour `k prnjfrn bofs Jkhan`stkj sn snht mrusqunjnht nh iohb`ft kvni soh
tnjps( @ns prnjfrns khhns postrvo`utfohhkfrns kvkfnht vu i`orn ans inhtkfhns
an tk`nhts akhs tous `ns aojkfhns `fttrkturn pnfhturn tgtrn( Jkhan`stkj kvkft
`fmrnjnht trouv sk p`kin akhs `n prfhtnjps an `k posfn( Inpnhakht as `n amut
ans khhns vfhlt `,krt obbfifn` rlhn nh jktrn prnhkht nh jkfh `ns rhns an `k vfn
fhtn``nitun``n( Snu pnu `ns irfvkfhs nh afslrin inssnht a,trn pum`fs(
Srolrnssfvnjnht fso` rauft `k so`ftuan nt `k jfsrn iohtrkfht an lklhnr sk vfn
nh bkfskht ans trkauitfohs Jkhan`stkj rnbusn an sn jnttrn ku pks voykht anrrfrn
`n iojprojfs sn probf`nr `,ojmrn an `k iojprojfssfoh( S`ohl akhs uh tkt
a,khlofssn an atrnssn nt an askrrof nxtrjns `uf quf kvkft toueours iru akhs sk
proprn rnitftuan jork`n f` enttn uh rnlkra gklkra sur sns trnhtn khs pksss( Akhs
soh prnjfnr vo`ujn Hkaneak Jkhan`stkj sn souvfnht 5 @ns khhns vfhlt burnhtpnut*trn `k prfoan `k p`us afbbfif`n an `k vfn an Jkhan`stkj( Ekjkfs kupkrkvkht 'nt
pkr `k suftn hoh p`us mfnh qun sk vfn anvht nhiorn p`us afbbfif`n& f` h,kvkft pkr`
; ';6=1& fmfa(
= ';6=9& fmfa(
9 ';6=1& fmfa(
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
17/68
; Jkhan`stkj nst brkpp an jutfsjn potfqun iojjn sf `k
posfn hn pouvkft trn qun `,nxprnssfoh an soh fhtlrft( F` hn rntrouvnrk `k jklfn
ans vnrs qun ifhq khs p`us tkra `orsqu,f` snrk houvnku nh pkfx kvni `uf*jjn(
Inttn prfoan an strf`ft potfqun iorrnspoha uh jojnht an brklf`ft an
rb`nxfoh an rntour sur sof( In qun H( Jkhan`stkj kppn``n `k rvfsfoh ans vk`nurs(
Iojjn f` `,irft akhs uh pojn an ;6=9 `ns ifjns kvkfnht bkft oum`fnr `nsrkifhns( Sour rntrouvnr soh fhtlrft nt `k pkfx an sk iohsifnhin Jkhan`stkj vk
s,nhbnrjnr nh `uf*jjn pkriourfr `ns ignjfhs Teusqun*`Z trop mfnh mk`fss an
TsnsZ `kmyrfhtgns = `k rnignrign ans bf`s rojpus au pkss sf `ohltnjps junt(
@,gojjn nt `,gojjn an `nttrns hn boht qu,uh( Kussf inttn qutn `n iohaufrk*t*n``n
vnrs `ns iohtrns `ofhtkfhns nt oum`fns an sk aoum`n an sk trfp`n lhk`olfn(
Yufs `ns rkifhns bkfs frruptfoh akhs `ns trbohas(
Nt ` akhs `k tnrrn iojjn fif akhs jk poftrfhnvnf``n tous `ns spnitrns nt tous `ns jorts(9
I,nst `k prosn quf lufanrk Jkhan`stkj( @n prnhkht pkr `k jkfh n``n `,kfanrk
nxgujnr `ns bkhtjns fhafsso`um`njnht `fs an sk bkjf``n an sk bkjf``n an p`ujn nt
an soh pnup`n( Lrin n``n f` kurk `n mohgnur an rniohqurfr soh uhft sk
quftuan nt sk srhft an vofr `ns krrgns an TsohZ a`frn nh prosn mfnh kfj(
Iojposn an quktrn vo`nts k``kht pkr pkfrns i,nst `n enquf aojfhn akhs inttn
ttrk`olfn uhen kutomfolrkpgfqun hoh alufs(Asnjpkr lkr i,nst a,kmora soh pkss qu,f` vk rnssusiftnr rnjohtnr `n
tnjps rnvfvrn sns gkfhns nt sns pkssfoh( @n Mruft au Qnjps nt @n Qfjmrn lyptfnh
; H( JKHAN@YQKJ op( ift(
= L(SN]NI Snhsnr/i`kssnr a( Gkignttn ;67>(
9 E(M]OAYDV Sojns ;62;*;67
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
18/68
;7
snroht `ns anux bkins opposns an soh voykln ku pkys an `,nhbkhin 5 `nhtn nt
aou`ournusn ansinhtn akhs `ns kmyssns an `k jjofrn quf iohaufrk Jkhan`stkj rnhounr kvni `ns sfnhs nt pkr `k jjn rntrouvnr `n snhtfjnht fhtrfnur an soh
fanhtft(
@ns anux kutrns tnxtns @n Roykln nh Krjhfn prosn toutn nh aouinur nt @k
[uktrfjn Srosn prosn toutn nh aou`nur nxprfjnht uhn jjn inrtftuan 5 in``n an
`,fanhtft rntrouvn(
@n Mruft au Qnjps nt @n Qfjmrn lyptfnh tkht `k pfnrrn khlu`kfrn `ns tnxtns*i`s
quf hous boht sufvrn pks pks `k `nhtn nt lrkaun``n prolrnssfoh an Jkhan`stkj trkvnrs soh gfstofrn i,nst nssnhtfn``njnht an ins ouvrklns qu,f` snrk qunstfoh akhs
`ns pklns quf sufvnht(
@n potn quf johtrn sk prosn nst akhs `k sftuktfoh an qun`qu,uh quf `kfssn
igkppnr uh snirnt( Yk prosn nst iojjn uh `kpsus irfvkft nh ;693 `n irftfqun
`fttrkfrn sovftfqun H( Mnrdovsdf ku suent an `k prosn an Jkhan`stkj(
@n mut an inttn tuan h,nst pks an atnrjfhnr `k struiturn jnhtk`n eufvn ; '+&
an Jkhan`stkj jkfs an prtnr `,ornf``n in snirnt an airyptnr in `kpsus an sufvrn
`,gojjn akhs sk jkrign `k rnhiohtrn an soh fanhtft an skfsfr `n snhs nt `k portn
an inttn prosn `fmrktrfin purfbfiktofrn iktgkrtfqun(
; Nxprnssfoh pour `n jofhs jk`gnurnusn njp`oyn pkr H( Ytruvn akhs soh mfnhtnhakhifnux ouvrkln Ossfp Jkhan`stkj Fhstftut a,Ntuans Y`kvns Skrfs ;67=(
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
19/68
;6
FF
@K ANIGF]^]N A^ YF@NHIN
[un port*en sur jns pku`ns ?
An qun`s bkhtjns sufs*en ouvnrt ?Dkbdk @wy
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
20/68
=3
Skr o iojjnhinr ?Qout irkqun nt p`ofn(@,kfr brjft an iojpkrkfsohsSks uh jot hn vkut jfnux qun `,kutrn
@k tnrrn lrohan iojjn uhn jtkpgorn(;
Nxprnssfoh an inttn ikssurn @n Mruft au Qnjps rnssnjm`n uh trkhln mf`kh quf
h,k rfnh a,uh nxnrifin fhtn``nitun`(
@orsqun Jkhan`stkj khhohin soh anssnfh 5 ioutnr kvni uhn `uifaft irftfqun nt
uhn brofanur atkign `n mruft an in tnjps prrvo`utfohhkfrn aoht f` k t `ntjofh nhbkht nt kao`nsinht oh skft ae qun i,nst uh bkux prtnxtn( Skr inttn prosn
Jkhan`stkj nsprn iojprnharn in quf `uf krrfvn nh sn sftukht hoh p`us pkr rkpport
ku prsnht qu,f` vfvkft eusqun*` ku eour `n eour jkfs pkr rkpport soh pkss qu,f`
aifan an prnharn nh igkrln( Hf hostk`lfn hf rnlrnts( @k rpohsn iohhun a,kvkhin
nxfstn kvkht `k qunstfoh( trkvnrs `k trkjn vfsfm`n trkhspkrkfssnht nh bf`flrkhn `k
`lftfjktfoh an `k vofn qu,f` k igofsfn nt `k eustfbfiktfoh an sns optfohs(
trnhtn*anux khs f` hn irkfht p`us souakfh an rnlkranr pkr*anssus soh pku`n(
I,nst kvni ans souvnhfrs tout bkfts qu,f` rnjohtn `n tnjps bnuf``nttn soh k`muj an
pgotos ekuhfns nh prouvkht igkqun fhstkht `n jjn snhtfjnht qun in`uf rnssnhtf
; Qrka( B( Drn` op( ift(
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
21/68
=;
ku jojnht an `k prfsn an `,fhstkhtkh( In rntour nh krrfrn f` `n bkft iojjn pour
prouvnr pour snprouvnr `n mfnh*boha an sns igofx(
En vouarkfs hoh pks pkr`nr an jof jkfs sufvrn `n sfi`n nt `klnrjfhktfoh au tnjps( Jk jjofrn nst gostf`n tout in quf j,nstpnrsohhn`( TZ Yf in`k apnhakft an jof en hn bnrkfs qun lrfjkin kusouvnhfr au pkss( TZ En `n rptn jk jjofrn h,nst pks mfnhvnf``khtnjkfs gostf`n nt n``n s,kpp`fqun hoh pks rnproaufrn jkfs rnpoussnr `npkss( ^h roturfnr h,k pks mnsofh an jjofrn f` `uf subbft an rkiohtnr `ns`fvrns qu,f` k `us nt sk mfolrkpgfn nst bkftn( TZ Nhtrn jof nt `n sfi`n f` y kuhn bkf``n uh boss rnjp`f au tnjps quf mruft `fnu rsnrv `k bkjf``n nt
kux krigfvns aojnstfquns(;
Sroia brqunht ignz Jkhan`stkj i,nst ku iours an `,ouvrkln qun `,nssnhtfn`
nst aft(
Jkfs qun aft*f` ? Nh qun`quns `flhns f` k arou` tout uh tfssu an iohtrkafitfohs
nxprnssfoh an soh khlofssn quf sn trkauft pkr uhn vfo`nhtn gostf`ft `,lkra an in
pkssqu,f` airyptn uh pnu p`us `ofh pour `n hojjnrbkjf``n(
Bkjf``n ? Qout in quf nst bkjf``n nst eufb tout in quf nst eufb nst bkjf``n( In `krln
iohinpt asflhkht `k bofs sns pkrnhts `k jkfsoh an soh nhbkhin `n johan eufb( @nst `n tgjn `nftjotfv quksf fhionrifm`n au Mruft au Qnjps(
Jkhan`stkj sn abnha kvni vgjnhin nt eustn tftrn a,kvofr vou`u bkfrn uhn
igrohfqun an bkjf``n( Jkfs k`ors qun` nst soh proent ? Sufsqun sf in`k hn apnhakft
qun an T`ufZ Tf`Z hn bnrkft qun lrfjkin ku souvnhfr au pkss qun` afkm`n `n poussn
bkfrn rnsurlfr a,uh pkss poussfrnux `n bkhtjn an inttn bkjf``n ku abkut an
`khlun iohlhftk` aoht f` pkr`n skhs `k jofharn iojp`kfskhin( ]l`njnht an
iojptn iojjn `,kbbfrjn H( Ytruvn ?
Inttn prosn bkft bflurnr an ioheurktfoh( A,nxorifsjn( Nh rntourhkht trnhtn*
anux khs `k sourin an sns iohb`fts a,nhbkht Jkhan`stkj ignrign p`us snjm`n*t*f`
`lftfjnr sns trnhtn khs an vfn qu, rntrouvnr `,uhft mrkh`n an sohJof(
;@n Mruft au tnjps igkpftrn -Dojfsskrenvsdkyk-(
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
22/68
==
[un a,kjmflut +Jk jjofrn nst gostf`n tout in quf j,nst pnrsohhn` Sourtkht
`nen prsnht igkqun pkln tjoflhn nh pnrjkhnhin au iohtrkfrn(
Yk bkjf``n `n johan eufb Jkhan`stkj `ns rnlkran `ns nxkjfhn `ns sirutn kvni
`n jjn atkignjnht kppkrnht qu,f` rnlkran nxkjfhn nt sirutn `n sfi`n
klohfskht ( Jkfs `ofh an h,trn qun rnlkra nt ornf``n jk`vnf``khts Jkhan`stkj sn
jnt nh sihn nt s,fjp`fqun(
[uf sn probf`n anrrfrn inen `,gojjn ou `,nhbkht ?
@ns oments an `k jkfsoh pktnrhn``n horjns ajnsurs akhs `nur vo`ujn nt
`nur gfanur snu` `n rnlkra a,uh nhbkht pnut `ns pnrinvofr an inttn bkoh( Kvni in
rnlkra*` f` `uf nst mfnh fjpossfm`n an prnharn `n jofharn rniu`(
K `k `niturn au Mruft au Qnjps `k prnjfrn fjprnssfoh nst in snhtfjnht an igkos
quf jkhn an toutn `,ktjospgrn bkjf`fk`n( @n jot rnvfnht omsnssfohhn` akhs `n
tnxtn( Igkqun pgrksn igkqun ansirfptfoh quf touign `k bkjf``n an Jkhan`stkj
tnha rnharn in johan igkotfqun( @n igkos toueours kiiojpklh an sohquk`fbfiktfb rnpousskht nt surtout jnhkkht 5euakqun( @n igkos euakqun sn brkykft
uh ignjfh trkvnrs toutns `ns bnhtns an `,kppkrtnjnht ptnrsmourlnofs(
Jkhan`stkj k an in johan uhn aoum`n pnrinptfoh 5 a,uhn pkrt f` nst bfl akhs
uh fjjomf`fsjn siu`kfrn kppkrnht a,kutrn pkrt f` nst portnur a,uhn jnhkin
`ktnhtn pnrjkhnhtn( [unstfoh nh bf`flrkhn nt rpohsn fjp`fiftn 5 `n enuhn Ossfp
h,kvkft a,k`tnrhktfvn qun `k buftn(
Jkhan`stkj sn `fvrn uhn ansirfptfoh jfhutfnusn prnsqun pgotolrkpgfqun auikmfhnt pktnrhn` 5 uh kjohin``njnht a,oments vnhus ans quktrn iofhs au johan `n
russn j` ku turi `,k``njkha ans pnkux pkrpf``ns pkr tnrrn vfvkhtns iojjn
ans aoflts ( Jkfs `k p`ujn nst p`us fjpftoykm`n nhiorn qun `,f` pgotolrkpgfqun 5
akhs in tkm`nku ikuignjkransqun o pks uh snu` vnrmn hn vfnht ku sniours an
`,gujour nt an `k afstkhifktfoh `,kiiuju`ktfoh opprnsskhtn ans hojs a,oments
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
23/68
=9
gtroi`ftn rnssusiftn asorarn oanur johan*pfnuvrn( Jkhan`stkj hn sn souvfnht
pks( F` rnvft(Yoh rnlkra sn posn sur `k mfm`fotgqun( Rfsfoh gk``uifhkhtn nt `khifhkhts
rnvfnhhnht `ns tnrjns an igkos rufhns poussfrn( ^h vnhfh hofr iou`n an sk p`ujn ku
souvnhfr an in igkos euakqun quf h,tkft hf pktrfn hf jkfsoh hf boynr jkfs mfnh
igkos johan utrfh fhiohhu(
Bkjf``n johan eufb igkos rufhns poussfrn tous ins jots*irkhs ikignht uh
kutrn jot 5 joh prn( In prn pnru iojjn uh trn frrn` nt pourtkht iojmfnh
rn` fhiojprgnhsfm`n rnpousskht `,nhbkht nh kvkft pnur nt gohtn 5 Joh prn `ufh,kvkft pks an `khlun( TZ @n `khlkln russn a,uh Eufb So`ohkfs ? Hoh( @n `khlkln
a,uh Eufb k``njkha ? Hoh p`us( Snut*trn uh kiinht spifbfqun an Iour`khan ? En
h,nh kf ekjkfs nhtnhau an snjm`km`n I,tkft tout in qun `,oh vouark skub uhn
`khlun qun``n qu,n``n soft(
@,kjnrtujn nst mfnh ` `k rvo`tn kussf jkfs in hn soht hf in``ns an `,kau`tn hf
in``ns au potn fhiorrflfm`n kjkht ans sohorfts (; I,nst `n irf an atrnssn an
`,nhbkht quf toutn possfmf`ft a,fhtlrktfoh ku*angors tkft fhtnraftn pkr `k bkutn au
prn pkr `k bkutn au Eufb(
@k `khlun au prn nt `k `khlun an `k jrn h,nst*in pks an `k busfoh an ins
anux `khluns*` qun sn hourrft hotrn `khlkln toutn hotrn `ohlun vfn aurkht h,nst*in
pks n``ns quf nh borjnht `n ikrkitrn ? Jkhan`stkj kurkft pu rnprnharn `,nhvnrs
`k i`mrn pgrksn an @vf*Ytrkuss 5 quf aft gojjn aft `khlkln ( Jkfs ignz
Jkhan`stkj `n sous*nhtnhau k uh kutrn igo 5 quf aft `khlkln aft gojjn quf aft
`khlkln aft vfn( @,kmsnhin an `khlkln i,nst nhiorn uhn iojposkhtn au igkos uhn
jnhkin a,nhbnrjnjnht nt an jort( As sk hkfsskhin Jkhan`stkj s,nst vu rnbusnr
`k i` fhafspnhskm`n pour kiianr ku johan( Jkrqu a,uhn tkrn frrjafkm`n f`
s,nst nhbuf vnrs `k roturn `k rnignrign a,uhn bkjf``n kaoptfvn sn rbulfkht akhs `n
snfh an `k @ouvn*`fttrkturn(
; Qka( B( Drn` op( ift(
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
24/68
=1
Iojjn akhs `ns iohtns trfstns an `,nhbkhin `k jigkhtn bn eufvn s,nst pnhign
ku*anssus au hourrfssoh `uf k ent uh sort aoht Jkhan`stkj jnttrk p`us an trnhtnkhs sn abkfrn(
En j,vnf``kf akhs joh mnrinkum`ouf pkr `n so`nf` hofr(;
@k rpu`sfoh qun Jkhan`stkj prouvn `,lkra an `k jkfsoh bkjf`fk`n s,tnha
tout in quf nst eufb johan moftnux kuqun` f` jkhqunrkft uhn pkrtfn skfhn `,`jnhthorjk` `k horjn tkht pour `uf `n johan krynh( F` `ns tfqunttn skhs hukhins ins
Eufbs quf sn probf`nht tout ku `ohl ans pklns au Mruft au Qnjps( In soht `ns Eufbs
gohtnux tn`s soh probnssnur a,gmrnu quf sn snhtnht ioupkm`ns as qu,f`s soht bkin
ku johan russn4 `ns Eufbs an `k jfsrn ignz `nsqun`s mfnh souvnht pnhakfnht ans
`khlns nt s,trkhl`kfnht ans lkjjns( Jjn `k jusfqun sf igrn ku iur an
Jkhan`stkj prnhkft ans kiinhts jfsrkm`ns `orsqu,n``n tkft eoun akhs `k pkrtfn
euakqun au `fttork` `nttoh( Eusqu `,kutnur au Afmmoud=
rauft `,fjkln a,uhn tnharn psyig soubbrkht a,gjorroans(
Skr`kht ans pgf`osopgns tk`juafstns qun rninvkft soh prn Jkhan`stkj
iojjnhtn 5 F`s sn p`kflhkfnht a,trn pnrsiuts pkr `nurs jigkhtns pousns( @n
jot pnrsiuts rkppn``n a,kutrns pnrsiutfohs kutrnjnht p`us tnrrfm`ns aoht
anvkfnht inrtkfhnjnht sn p`kfharn ins gojjns nh gkmft `ohl + trkhln jjofrn
s`nitfvn qun in``n an Jkhan`stkj nh inttn khhn ;6=99( Iojjnht nxp`fqunr qun
; Qrka( B( Drn` op( ift(
= Ykjun` KH*YDF an soh vrkf hoj ]KSSOSO]Q ;729*;6=3( Houvn``fstn nt arkjkturlnirfvkfh an `khlun yfaafsg nt russn(
9 Ku amut au sfi`n ans inhtkfhns an `oik`fts soht avkstns pkr ans polrojs nh ]ussfniojjn nh ^drkfhn( I,nst nh ;6;; 'khhn an `k iohvnrsfoh an Jkhan`stkj& quniojjnhin `,Kbbkfrn Mn`fs( Nh ;6;6 k`ors qun Jkhan`stkj sn trouvn Dgkrdov pufs Dfnv pnhakht `k lunrrn ifvf`n ans vkluns an polrojs s,kmkttnht sur `ns popu`ktfohs
eufvns( Akhs soh `fvrn an jjofrns F`fk Ngrnhmourl rkiohtn qu,f` k t tjofh kvniJkhan`stkj a,uhn huft an polroj
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
25/68
=>
`uf quf s,nst toueours vou`u au it ans bkfm`ns nt ans opprfjs quf k toueours
rnbus `n iojprojfs kft sf kfsjnht trkhsfl ` kvni sk iohsifnhin ? tkft*in kuhoj a,uh iohbort jork` ?
Jkfs kvkft*f` vrkfjnht `n igofx ?
@,fjkln uhfqun lrfjkkhtn nt jnhkkhtn an in euaksjn vfan an snhs
bkhtojktfqun quf `uf tkft proposn tkft nxnjptn an toutn trkin an iu`turn nt
hn rn`nvkft qun an `k mkrmkrfn( Eusqu,kux btns eufvns quf portkfnht ans hojs
mkrmkrns( Qout tkft trkhlnr ku pntft lkroh quf rvkft a,trn uh nhbkht an
Stnrsmourl 5 `,k`pgkmnt gmrkqun `ns f``ustrktfohs an soh jkhun` a,gmrnu `ntk`ftg ekuhn nt hofr au lrkha*prn an ]flk `k syhklolun tn``n uh bflufnr
trkhlnr rfnh h,kvkft an snhs tout tkft brkpp au sinku igkos ( Inttn pktrfn
eufvn fhiohhun fhiojprgnhsfm`n jnhkin an anstruitfoh f` `k rnbuskft kvni
opfhftrnt an toutns sns borins(
Ku bf` ans pklns `k rkhiur kuljnhtn `,irfturn prnsqun mkafhn ku amut
anvfnht an p`us nh p`us hnrvnusn( Bfn``nusn( In johan tnhtkiu`kfrn Jkhan`stkj `n
pnroft iojjn uhn oanur 5 tout iojjn uhn jfnttn an jusi njp`ft an soh oanur
uhn jkfsoh toutn nhtfrn an jjn `k jofharn fhb`unhin an euaksjn njp`ft toutn
uhn vfn( TZ Souvkfs*en hn pks rnjkrqunr qun akhs `ns vrkfns jkfsohs eufvns
`,oanur h,tkft pks `k jjn qun akhs `ns jkfsohs krynhhns ? TZ En jn rkppn``n
eusqu, prsnht inttn oanur eufvn aouintrn(
Bk``kft*f` qun Jkhan`stkj soubbrn pour nh krrfvnr irfrn uhn kussf vfru`nhtn
afktrfmn aflhn au jnf``nur igkhtrn an `,khtfsjftfsjn + K*t*f` vrkfjnht iru qun inttn
prosn `n a`fvrnrkft an sns ajohs ?
F` nst sflhfbfiktfb qun Jkhan`stkj kft rnssnhtf `n johan eufb nssnhtfn``njnht
iojjn uhn oanur( Ikr qu,nst*in qu,uhn oanur sfhoh `k pnrinptfoh prnjfrn qun
`,oh k nh rnhtrkht au angors ? In angors i,tkft kvkht tout Ykfht*Stnrsmourl vf``n
sum`fjn a,kutkht p`us bnrfqun nt jklhtfqun qu,n``n iohtrkstkft kvni `n
ikuignjkr fhtrfnur(
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
26/68
=2
Igkqun eour an soh nhbkhin Jkhan`stkj k jnh uhn aoum`n vfn sn projnhkht
akhs Stnrsmourl kvni sk hursn akhs inttn vf``n o f` anvkft toueours sn pkssnr
qun`qun igosn an trs bkstunux nt an trs so`nhhn` nt kprs ins projnhkans an
rvn f` bk``kft rntrouvnr `k rk`ft bkhtojktfqun an `k jkfsoh pktnrhn``n( A,uh it
an `k portn an `,kppkrtnjnht f` tkft kspfr vnrs `n hkht qukha an `,kutrn it
mouf``ohhkft `k vfn uhn vfn iohqurfr nt quf h,nh tkft aohi qun p`us kttfrkhtn( K
snpt khs inttn afigotojfn anvkft trn aurn kssujnr( N``n `n but skhs aoutn p`us
nhiorn kvni `ns khhns( `,kao`nsinhin Jkhan`stkj hn s,nst jjn pks trouv
anvkht uh af`njjn( F` anvkft s,kuto*prsnrvnr nt i,nst skhs gsftktfoh skhs sn posnr
an qunstfohs qu,f` k rso`ujnht tourh `n aos tout in quf pouvkft `uf rkppn`nr an
prs ou an `ofh nt `n euaksjn nt sk bkjf``n probohajnht iohvkfhiu an h,kvofr rfnh
nh kttnharn hf sur `n p`kh kbbnitfb hf sur `n p`kh spfrftun` hf sur `n p`kh iu`turn`(
toubb pkr uh mnsofh frrprnssfm`n an tnharnssn nt a,kjour aohhnr i,nst sur
Stnrsmourl qun Jkhan`stkj rnportn soh kbbnitfoh Stnrsmourl aoht f` pkr`n
iojjn a,uh trn an igkfr nt an skhl 5 TZ `ns qukrtfnrs an lrkhft nt an mofs tout
in iur tnharn an `k vf``n kvni sk jkrn an p`kins sns ekrafhs mourfbbs sns `ots
an johujnhts `ns ikrfktfans an `,Nrjftkln `k jystrfnusn run Jf``fohhkyk TZ
Igkqun kaenitfb sou`flhn `,khtfhojfn kvni `n johan eufb nt bkjf`fk`( An `,kutrn it
an `k portn `*mks `n iur nst sni `,mourfbb s,kppn``n asorarn `n jystrfnux
khlofssn( igkqun iofh an run tout prtkft iojpkrkfsoh( F` kurkft mfnh vou`u
skhs aoutn `n enuhn Ossfp troqunr `n igkos iohtrn `,orarn `ns rufhns iohtrn `n
lrkhft `k poussfrn iohtrn `n bkstn `n `ulumrn iohtrn `k btn( Nt h,tkft*in pks uh
sumstftut an prn qu,f` voykft akhs in jkrfh Tan `k lkranZ kux joustkigns hofrns
qu,f` avorkft ans ynux ?
Jkhan`stkj bkft sfnh ou p`us nxkitnjnht vouarkft bkfrn sfnh in pkrkafs an
lrkhft nt an jkrmrn( Jkfs trkhlnr ignz `uf pkr fjpossfmf`ft an s,fanhtfbfnr quof
qun in bt akhs inttn jkfsoh*jort f` hn `,tkft pks jofhs gors an ignz `uf int
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
27/68
=(Jkhan`stkj bkft k``usfoh Jkakjn Movkry nt Khhk Dkrhfhn(
= Fmfa( Jkhan`stkj pkr`n fif ans roturfnrs au sfi`n anrhfnr 5 vnrs `n jf`fnu au WFWjnsfi`n `,fhstruitfoh inssn a,trn `n johopo`n nxi`usfb an `k ikstn krfstoirktfqun( ^hntoutn houvn``n fhtn``flnhtsfk voft `n eour 5 fssus ans i`kssns joynhhns ou ans jf`fnuxjoanstns `ns roturfnrs nhvkgfssnht `ns uhfvnrsfts(
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
28/68
=7
an Souigdfhn nt an Lolo` an Rf``oh nt an Akhtn nh uh jot an `k iu`turn
uhfvnrsn``n(@ns iojjnhtkfrns krtfi`ns irftfquns iohinrhkht @nMruft au Qnjps oht t quksf*
uhkhfjnjnht kajfrktfbs tkht `,poqun o `n `fvrn nst pkru qun an hos eours( ^hn
ans rkrns kvofr rnssnhtf uh jk`kfsn `k `niturn an inttn prosn k t Jkrfhk
Qsvntknvk( Akhs uhn `nttrn uh kjf n``n aft nh ;6=2 5 en aigfrn nh pntfts
jorinkux `,flhom`n `fvrn an J/khan`stkj/ @n Mruft au Qnjps (
Qsvntknvk quf anux khs kupkrkvkht irfvkft akhs soh kajfrkm`n Sojn an `k Bfh5
Rfvrn nst uh `fnu o i,nst fjpossfm`n 5@n qukr*tfnr eufb au anakhsNh in johan*if gypnrigrtfnh@ns potns soht ans Eufbs +;
k skhs aoutn prfs inttn prosn pour uh pur irf an gkfhn(
N``n nst uh irf nh nbbnt( An gkfhn ouf an rvo`tn an pkssfohs( Jkfs uh irf
sk`vktnur quf aigfrn `k jkssn toubbkhtn au sf`nhin bkft skutnr `ns vnrrous( Snu
fjportn qun in irf soft nhbnrj akhs uhn irfturn*ikrkpkin qun inttn prosn
h,kpportn Jkhan`stkj kuiuhn rpohsn houvn``n 5 sk gkrlhn khtf*euakqun*khtf*
bkjf`fk`n f` `k prnssnhtkft anpufs `ohltnjps( Ykhs jots( Nt jkfhtnhkht `ns jots
soht ` `k p`ujn k `fmr ans snhtfjnhts ans jotfohs uhn klrnssfvft qun
Jkhan`stkj iohtnhkft anpufs trnhtn khs( Sour `k prnjfrn bofs f` osn rnlkranr soh
pkss akhs `ns ynux y ignrigkht `k eustfbfiktfoh an sk proprn nxfstnhin(
Sourtkht inttn kmrkitfoh hn `uf kpportn pks `k pkfx fhtrfnurn( K `,fhvnrsn n``n
bkft hktrn nh `uf uhn khlofssn houvn``n uh fjjnhsn snhtfjnht an iu`pkmf`ft
`ktnht hoh nxprfj 5 pnut*oh rnhfnr `ns sfnhs skhs sn snhtfr ioupkm`n bkin sof*
jjn bkin sk iohsifnhin ?
; J( QYRNQKNRK 5 @n Sojn an `k Bfh trka( N( Jk``nrnt a( @,Kln a,Gojjn(
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
29/68
=6
Jkhan`stkj s,nhbohin akhs `n jk`*trn( Yoh fhspfrktfoh potfqun sn tkrfn( @n
Mruft au Qnjps tkpn fjportkhtn snuf` an `k jjofrn h,k nhiorn rfnh rso`u anabfhftfb(
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
30/68
93
FFF
@,FANHQFQ ]NIOHH^N
Nh jusfqun `n p`us fjportkhthn sn trouvn pks akhs `k pkrtftfoh(
L((Jkg`nr
jk vfn uhn vofx angors qukquk an toutns pkrtsans jots ans mrfmns pufs p`us rfnh pufs a,kutrns a,kutrnsjots a,kutrns mrfmns `ns jjns jk` aftns jk` nhtnhauns
pufs rfnh uh tnjps horjn pufs nh jof akhs `n ikvnkum`khignur a,os ans mrfmns afx sniohans qufhzn sniohansjk` nhtnhauns jk jurjurns jk` nhtnhauns jk`hotns jk vfn nhtfrn mk`mutfnjnht sfx bofs iorigk inssn an gk`ntnr en `,nhtnhas jk vfn en `,kf `k jurjurn
Y(Mnidntt
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
31/68
9;
@n lnhrn `fttrkfrn au Qfjmrn lyptfnh k souvnht port iohtrovnrsn 5 uvrn
an bfitfoh uh ans prnjfnrs nsskfs surrk`fstns russns bfitfoh post*
lolo`fnhhn prosn kutomfolrkpgfqun Jkhan`stkj nt pnut*trn sourf ans
jou`ns akhs `nsqun`s `ns irftfquns oht pkrbofs tnhakhin nhbnrjnr `ns kutnurs(
`,orflfhn an inttn prosn fhabfhfsskm`n uh rvn(
Inttn huft e,kf rv a,uh Igfhofs quf portkft uhn lufr`khan an pntftsskis an akjns iojjn uh io``fnr an ln`fhottns nt kussf a,uhn pnhau`n iouiou bflurkht uh aun` kjrfikfh o `ns kavnrskfrns tfrkfnht ku pfsto`nt
akhs ans johtklhns an vkfssn``n ans nhirfnrs nt ans tkm`nkux an bkjf``n(Jk bkjf``n en tn proposn uh m`ksoh 5 uh vnrrn a,nku mouf``fn( Akhs`,krrfrn*lot ikoutigout an `,nku mouf``fn ptnrsmourlnofsn en mofs`,fjjortk`ft aojnstfqun nh bkf``ftn( @k borin inhtrfbuln au tnjps kafssjfh hos igkfsns vfnhhofsns nt hos kssfnttns go``khakfsns pntftnsb`nurs m`nuns( ]fnh h,nst rnst( Qrnhtn khs sn soht iou`s iojjn uh `nhtfhinhafn( Qrnhtn khhns aurkht uhn m`khign b`kjjn brofan k `ig `n aosans jfrofrs jkrqus a,tfqunttns a,gufssfnrs(
Jkfs iojjnht j,krrkignr tof igrn lyptn ans oments ? vfanhtnfjjortk`ft an `k sk``n jkhlnr au ikmfhnt( Iojjnht rpkrnr jkbkutn? Qu vnux uh \k`gk``k ? Rof` `ns nhtrnpts Dodornwsdf( Rks*y
aohi `*mks ku apt + Ae `ns ajhklnurs sn trjousskhta,pouvkhtn sou`vnht au ikmfhnt `n pfkho qunun Jflhoh tn` uhjtorn hofr vnrhfs tojm au ifn`( Ans tof`ns lrossfrns soht tnhaunsiojjn ans igksum`ns skinraotk`ns(
trkhln pkys ans sohlns( Nh uhn huft Jkhan`stkj k bkft `n mf`kh an sns trnhtn*
sfx khs( @n Mruft au Qnjps tkft kussf nh qun`qun sortn uh mf`kh pnut*trn uh
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
32/68
9=
fhvnhtkfrn brofa akhs sk irukut kitn vo`ohtkfrn a,irfturn*abnhsn prosn*nxutofrn(
Fif tout nst rkafik`njnht afbbrnht tkht `k ajkrign qun `n iohstkt(@n rvn nst h ju pkr uhn khlofssn an jort quf hn `kfssn pks an aoutn
khhohin as `n amut 5 TZ uh Igfhofs quf portkft uhn lufr`khan an pntfts skis an
akjn( @n Igfhofs Jkhan`stkj `n aioan qun`quns khhns p`us tkra akhs @k
[uktrfjn Srosn 5 En sufs Igfhofs pnrsohhn hn jn iojprnha( [ukht kux skis anakjn
Jkhan`stkj nh nxp`fiftn `n snhs `k bfh au Qfjmrn lyptfnh 5 i,nst `n ski au jouefd
a,KhhkDkrhfhn in pntft jouefd kvkht*iournur an jort((
@n rvn njpruhtn pkrbofs an mfnh trkhlns alufsnjnhts( Qout `n pofas an skiu`pkmf`ft quf nhlnharn inttn khlofssn an jort Jkhan`stkj `n rnssnht iojjn
pnhau soh iou( Snhakht trnhtn khs f` k tfr sur ans tkm`nkux an bkjf``n( Snhakht
trnhtn khs f` k rnbus an sn rnlkranr akhs `ns jfrofrs `nur tourhkht ostnhsfm`njnht
`n aos `ns rnlkrakht `,nhvnrs( Snhakht trnhtn khs f` s,nst kpp`fqu mr`nr
`,Nlyptn fjjortn``n sf vfanjjnht fjjortn``n mr`kht a,uhn m`khign b`kjjn
brofan soh pkss jojfbf( Qout tkft pnrjfs( @,fhafbbrnhin `k gkfhn jjn tkht
qun in pkss snjm`kft fjjortn`pkrinqu,f` tkft fjjortn`( Jkfs vof` qun ans jots
vfnhhnht fhkttnhaus fjprvfsfm`ns nhtrkhs pkr `n rvn 5
I o j j n h t r p k r n r j k b k u t n ?
H,nst*f` pks trop tkra pufsqun rfnh h,nst rnst nt qun `k borin inhtrfbuln au
tnjps k tout afssjfh qun `,fjjortk`ft aojnstfqun TnstZ nh bkf``ftn ?
In pkss bfl akhs `,fjjomf`fsjn qun Jkhan`stkj kvkft atnrr akhs @n Mruft
au Qnjps vof` qun jkfhtnhkht f` `uf iourt kprs rvkht pkssfohhjnht an `uf
rnaohhnr vfn an `n bkfrn sfnh nt prsnht( Jkfs sk igrn lyptn ans oments in tnjp`n au
souvnhfr in \k`gk``k pour `ns rntrouvnr f` bkut k``nr ku lkran*jnum`ns kux
nhtrnpts Dodornwsdf(
Nh ;6== Jkhan`stkj ikrnsskft `fjkln ans ustnhsf`ns aojnstfquns igk`nur
au boynr rnssnhtfn iojjn skirn( F` nh pkr`kft iojjn a,uh butur possfm`n a,uh mut
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
33/68
99
kttnfharn jkfs an toutn vfanhin inttn jtkpgorn kmstrkftn hn iohinrhkft nh rfnh
soh proprn viu( Fif `n rvn k nhtrkh ans kssoifktfohs '`ns kssfnttns go``khakfsns pntftns b`nurs m`nuns `ns igkfsns vfnhhofsns `n pfkho `ns pfins an `k jkfsoh `n
ikmfhnt tkht gohhf quktrn khs kupkrkvkht& quf skirk`fsnht `n pkss mfnh rn` an
Jkhan`stkj jkfs uh krrfrn*lot an trop tkra nhlnharn uh snhtfjnht anbkutn aoht
`k vo`oht an rpkrktfoh snrk `n bf` iohauitnur au Qfjmrn lyptfnh(
Sour rnhounr kvni soh pkss `n rfhtlrnr `n bkfrn sfnh Jkhan`stkj vk eounr
uhn sortn an psyigoarkjn quf vk `uf pnrjnttrn an pkrtfr `k rnignrign au tnjps
pnrau `k rnignrign an soh Jof pnrau(
@,gfstofrn an `k pfin qun Jkhan`stkj vk sn eounr nt aoht hous kvohs
`,fjprnssfoh a,trn `n spnitktnur fhafsirnt nst rauftn sk p`us sfjp`n nxprnssfoh 5
sur boha gfstorfqun `,t ;6;< uh gojjn au hoj an Skrhod; vk vfvrn anux
mrvns gfstofrns pkrk```ns( Oh `n suft akhs sk ioursn trkvnrs Stnrsmourl o f`tnhtn a,uhn pkrt an riuprnr sk ignjfsn a,kutrn pkrt a,njpignr uh `yhigkln
aoht f` nst `n tjofh(
A`fmrjnht Jkhan`stkj `kfssn k``nr sk p`ujn skhs iohtr`n a,uhn irfturn
proign an `,irfturn kutojktfqun( @ns kssoifktfohs hkfssnht a,n``ns*jjns
Jkhan`stkj*irfvkfh s,fhtnraft a,fhtnrvnhfr an `ns inhsurnr( As `ns prnjfrns
pklns f` fhstk``n Skrhod akhs sns proprns jnum`ns 5 Skrhod kvkft suspnhau sk
ekqunttn sur `n aossfnr an `k igkfsn vfnhhofsn igkfsns vfnhhofsns an k jkfsoh anJkhan`stkj qun `k borin inhtrfbuln au tnjps k afssjfhns (
; I( Mrowh nt sk suftn hojmrn an irftfquns oht pos iojjn kxfojn qun Skrhod kvkftrn``njnht nxfst qun Jkhan`stkj s,tkft fhspfr pour soh gros a,uh inrtkfh Skrhkdgqu,f` kvkft rnhiohtr Skrfs( Inttn kssnrtfoh lrktuftn hoh*bohan nt gtfvn snjm`nbkhtkfsfstn( F` pkrkt tout bkft vfanht qun `n jot pkrhod vfnht nh aroftn `flhn an`,kaenitfb russn pkrhyf quf sflhfbfn -borjkht `k pkfrn-( Skrhod aoum`n an Jkhan`stkjh,nst nh bkft qun `k trkauitfoh `fttrk`n au jot aoum`n(
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
34/68
91
Jkhan`stkj `ign soh aoum`n f` `n `kfssn k``nr `,omsnrvn vfvrn sk vfn fhtfjn skhs
nh avfnr `n iours a,uh trkft an p`ujn(S`us qun soh aoum`n Skrhod nst `k proenitfoh a,uh Jkhan`stkj quf sojjnf``n
nh `uf nt qu,f` `kfssn sortfr an `,ojmrn( @,irfvkfh hn `n lufan pks( F` vnut `n rnlkranr
vfvrn `n `kfssnr kbbrohtnr ans sftuktfohs eusqu, `,nxtrjn( F` `n sftun vo`ohtkfrnjnht
ku inhtrn an soh proprn uhfvnrs johan kuqun` f` fhsubb`n vfn nt rk`ft(
^h kh kupkrkvkht Jkhan`stkj kvkft ae bkft uhn mkuign uh iroqufs an `k
buturn sf`gounttn an Skrhod akhs uh krtfi`n iohskir `k vf``n an Dfnv 5 TZ `n
anrhfnr shom an Dfnv quf akjmu`kft sur `k Drigtigktfd pnhakht `ns eours anpkhfqun akhs ans igkussurns vnrhfns nt uh p`kfa ikrrnkux pkr`kht `n p`us po`f ans
`khlklns aofsnku(
@n prototypn nsqufss `n Skrhod an ;6=< prnha vfn( Sourtkht `n `fvrn rnbnrj
hous snrfohs mfnh fhikpkm`ns an hous `n rnprsnhtnr pgysfqunjnht( Ykhs ynux skhs
vfskln skhs iorps skhs ln kvni pour snu`s kttrfmuts ans igkussurns vnrhfns nt
uh irhn anvnhu igkuvn kux iohinrts an Yirfkmfhn quk`fbf an pntft pnut*trn
p`us ikusn an soh kfr pftoykm`n 'iojjn oh aft uh pntft Eufb & qunh rbrnhin
`Kdkdf Kdkdnvftig; an Lolo` aoht f` nst inpnhakht uh `ofhtkfh pkrnht `fjkln an
Skrhod nst fhskfsfsskm`n( Apourvu an prhoj apourvu anhbkhin an pkrnht an
pkss iojjn an butur f` hk rfnh auh gros hf jjn auhpnrsohhkln( Ykhs `nen an
Jkhan`stkj iohstkjjnht prsnht akhs soh ojmrn uh en io`ohhn vnrtmrk`n an
Skrhod f` hkurkft p`us kuiuhn nxfstnhin( F` hn prnha borjn nt vfn qun pkr rkpport
in en quf nst in`uf an `gojjn*Jkhan`stkj( Skrhod inst `n brrn ikant au
Yk`ojoh aK`mnrt Iognh iur pur TsohZ pntft kjf fhtfjn `ns eours an hkusn(
; Gros an `k houvn``n an Lolo` @n Jkhtnku(
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
35/68
9>
Ku prnjfnr kmora Skrhod nst uh pntft akhay quf nsskfn mfnh vkfhnjnht an
sn bkfrn uhn p`kin akhs Stnrsmourl( A( Ynlk` `n abfhft iojjn uh pkrvnhu; f` nst
afbbfif`n an sn rkhlnr int kvfs( Skrhod nst kvkht tout uh fak`fstn uh rvnur( Yf`
rvn akvofr uhn posftfoh soifk`n 'anvnhfr aroljkh ku Jfhfstrn ans Kbbkfrns
trkhlrns& inst pour trn rniohhu pkr uhn soift russn fhiohaftfohhn``njnht
gostf`n tous inux qun``n hn rniohhkt pks iojjn sfnhs( Sour rk`fsnr in rvn bou
kvofr uhn p`kin akhs in johan russn bksifhkht f` sn bkft bkfrn sur jnsurn uhn
ekqunttn uh gkmft afjposturn pkssnport fhafspnhskm`n pour k``nr `k iohqutn au
tout*pufsskht Stnrsmourl(
F`s soht mfnh joanstns nt mfnh pnu tnrrn tnrrn `ns rvns an Skrhod( Arkp akhs
soh nhvn`oppn tnrrnstrn f` pourrkft nhbfh pkrkanr kux iohinrts bkfrn ans
iohbrnhins kfjnr nt sn bourvoynr ( Nt pufs f` anvfnharkft iojjn `ns pnrsohhklns
ans rojkhs an Mk`zki nt an Ytnhagk` kuxqun`s f` sfanhtfbfn ins omsiurs provfhifkux
pkrtfs `k iohqutn an Skrfs( @uifnh an ]umnjpr `uf stkft rks nt `kvnhfr tkft
h an `k joussn an skvoh ( Jkfs @uifnh an ]umnjpr htkft hf russn hf eufb(
Hu``n pkrt akhs `n tnxtn f` hnst aft qun Skrhod nst eufb( Sourtkht f` hnst pks
pnrjfs anh aoutnr( Eufb akmora akhs `nrnlkra ans kutrns anpufs `nhbkhin anpufs
`poqun o sns ikjkrkans an i`kssn `n iohsfarkfnht iojjn uhn mtn iurfnusn uh
Qfjmrn lyptfnh uh nh`nvnur an tkigns nh uh jot uh Eufb uh nhbkht pks
iojjn `ns kutrns( Eufb kau`tn jprfs pkr `ns bnjjns nt `ns iohifnrlns
iohstkjjnht sous `k jnhkin fh`uitkm`n 5 Oh tn jnttrk gohtnusnjnht `k portn
TZ oh tn afbbkjnrk oh tn iouvrfrk an gohtn( Skrhod nst mfnh an inux quf hoht
pks `gnur an p`kfrn `k bou`n 4 n``n `ns rnprn fhstkhtkhjnht( trn Eufb irfvkft
; A( YNLK@ @ftnrkturk dkd odgrkhkyk lrkjotk ' `k `fttrkturn iojjn skub*iohauft & Y`kvfik Gfnroso`yjftkhk vo`(R*RF Erusk`nj ;67;(
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
36/68
92
K`mnrt Jnjjf inst akmora in bkft l`omk`5 inst sn trouvnr jfs nh qunstfoh sn
snhtfr nh pnrjkhnhtn kiiusktfoh nxp`fiftn ou fjp`fiftn i`kfrn ou iohbusn( Akhs @n Mruft au Qnjps Jkhan`stkj hkvkft pks au tout bkft k``usfoh soh
iojp`nxn au Eufb bkin `kutrn( In quf `n proiiupkft in jojnht*` itkft an
eustfbfnr sk buftn auh johan kuqun` f` hn vou`kft hf sfanhtfbfnr hf kppkrtnhfr( Fif
`hohi afbbrn rkafik`njnht 5 Skrhod soh aoum`n kiinptn fjp`fiftnjnht soh
kppkrtnhkhin( S`us jjn( F` hn sklft pks auhn kiinptktfoh ou auh rnbus aohi
auh igofx jkfs an `k iohstktktfoh auh tkt an bkft(
Eufb Skrhod `nst kussf skhs aoutn akhs inttn propnhsfoh jk`kafvn ku rvn 5toutn rk`ft nst uh trnjp`fh pour `n pkys ans igfjrns( Kfhsf uhn rohan``n an
iftroh inst uh mf``nt pour `k Yfif`n vnrs `ns rosns lrkssns ( Qout nst prtnxtn ku
rvn ikr pour uhn pntftn jn an iohinrt kppkrtnhkht ku pkrkafs brkjmofsn ans
iohtrnmkssns nt ans mouraohs 'nt ` sn probf`nht nh trkhspkrnhin tous `ns Skrhod
an `k `fttrkturn eufvn& snu` `n bkhtksjn pnut pnrjnttrn aigkppnr `njprfsn an `k
rk`ft f` nst uh rnjpkrt iohtrn `khlofssn nt `n snhtfjnht afhsiurft(
Jkfs Skrhod kfjn `k vfn pkssfohhjnht( Yk vfn outrn `n rvn inst `nspofr(
@nspofr*igfjrn `nspofr*bkhtksjn jkfs kussf `nspofr iohirnt gfstorfqun
prsnht 5 `k ]vo`utfoh an Bvrfnr Skrhod `k voft iojjn uhn mrkhign an pfh auh
vnrt vfb ln`n akhs uh moik` m`nu( Inst n``n quf obbrn pour `k prnjfrn bofs uhn
pntftn jn eufvn `k possfmf`ft an snhvn`oppnr akhs uhn ekqunttn nt atrn nhbfh
`lk`n ans kutrns ou au jofhs an anvnhfr qun`qu,uh kux ynux ans kutrns(
Nt pufs f` y k `k jusfqun Akhs int uhfvnrs ku `khlkln uhfvnrsn` Skrhod pnut
sn snhtfr nhbfh uh gojjn pkrt nhtfrn( Yk pnur skpkfsn( F` pnut iojprnharn nt
trn iojprfs kfjnr nt trn kfj trn `uf*jjn uhn pntftn jn skhs trn johtr
au aoflt rnent jprfs(
@k jusfqun nst ojhfprsnhtn akhs @n Qfjmrn lyptfnh( Skr `k jklfn au vnrmn
Jkhan`stkj `uf fhsubb`n uhn vfn tkhlfm`n akhs uh bnstfvk` an jtkpgorns(
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
37/68
9;
Bf``n auh pkuvrn iojafnh kjmu`kht fssun an `k roturn sf igrn Jkhan`stkj
Khlfo`fhk Mozfo kvkft iru qun `n tfjmrn jtk``fqun an sk vofx sns rou`kans nt trjo`os`uf ouvrfrkfnht `ns portns au johan nt an `k l`ofrn;( Jkfs f` nst ans fhstkhts o
`kutgnhtfift hnst p`us iojpktfm`n kvni `krt qukha in anrhfnr rfjn kvni krtfbfin nt
qun `krtfstn y pnroft souakfh ans kiinhts an iojprojfssfoh ou an prostftutfoh(
@k jort obbfifn``n an `k soprkho i`mrn kvni lrkhafosn pkr ans igkrolhkras nh
`l`fsn Lvkrnhluf=iohtrkstn kvni `klohfn an `krtfstn snu`n kvni n``n*jjn akhs
uhn igkjmrn sojmrn( Akhs inttn sihn jouvkhtn o `k ikhtktrfin jourkhtn sn
sou`vn nt igkhtn in qun``n anvkft igkhtnr Jkhan`stkj `uf kussf sous `trnfhtn an`khlofssn an `k jort `kvn `k souf``urn an sk p`ujn pum`fqun( Nt tkhafs qun `k
ikhtktrfin rntrouvn sk vofx kutgnhtfqun `n potn rntrouvn `uf soh irfturn
agfrohan``n(
Inttn iohstn``ktfoh an aoum`ns proents akhs `nspkin nt `n tnjps k pnrjfs
Jkhan`stkj an rnlkranr nh bkin igkiuhn an sns m`nssurns igkiuh an sns aoutns
anh prnharn iohsifnhin an `ns inrhnr pour nhbfh kttnfharn nt rniohhktrn sk proprn
fjkln(
Skrkaoxk`njnht inst nh fhtnrprtkht `n tgjn an `k auk`ft sur tous `ns joans
sur tous `ns rnlfstrns qun Jkhan`stkj nst pkrvnhu rniohqurfr soh uhft
rntrouvnr `k iogsfoh an soh Jof(
; In pksskln trouvn uh igo akhs `k stropgn sufvkhtn irftn nh ;69; 5Sour `k l`ofrn rntnhtfsskhtn ans sfi`ns vnhfrSour `k`tfrn trfmu ans gojjnsEkf pnrau jk ioupn ku bnstfh an jns prnsEkf pnrau jk eofn ekf pnrau joh gohhnur(
Ins vnrs snroht tuafs p`us nh atkf` akhs `n igkpftrn sufvkht(
= F` snrkft tnhtkht an rkpproignr in pksskln quf snjm`n bkfrn bflurn an prjohftfoh kvni`obbfin rn`flfnux ortgoaoxn i`mr `k jjofrn aOssfp Jkhan`stkj Johtlnroh nh;67=(
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
52/68
>=
FR
@FANHQFQ KYY^JN
@k `fmnrt nst akhs `k rnjohtn kux sourins(
N(Ekmns
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
53/68
>9
Skr uhn ajkrign omsiurn quf hk pks `kfss an trkins irftns Jkhan`stkj snst
souakfh tourh vnrs `k euakift; pnu an tnjps kvkht an iojjnhinr irfrn @n
Qfjmrn lyptfnh( Jk`gnurnusnjnht rfnh akhs `ns tnxtns hn `kfssn pkrktrn ou
prnssnhtfr o sn sftun in jojnht brklf`n nt fhskfsfsskm`n 5 f` hnxfstn pks an prosn hf
an vnrs sfjf`kfrns ku Qfjmrn lyptfnh aoht oh pourrkft ajohtnr `ns rouklns sufvrn
`n ignjfhnjnht quf `k jnh an `k rvo`tn skhs hukhins iohtrn tout in quf tkft eufb
au Mruft au Qnjpsku snhtfjnht kflu akppkrtnhkhin uh pnup`n an @k [uktrfjn
Srosn(
Ku rnent skhs qufvoqun an in quf` hojjkft au tnrjn l`omk` an euaksjn bkft
p`kin uhn iurfosft mfnhvnf``khtn aoum`n auh fhtrt hoh ahu an syjpktgfn
pour `n johan eufb(
Nh ;6=2 Jkhan`stkj pkssn `t Dfnv( @n spnitki`n an `k ikpftk`n udrkfhfnhhn
bortn anhsft eufvn `n igkrjn `kttnharft `n rkvft 5 Enhtnhas uh jkrjottnjnht
sous jns pfnas( Nst*in uh dgnanr ? Hoh ^hn jkfsoh an prfrn akhs uhn ikvn(
^hn inhtkfhn agojjns vhrkm`ns nh tk`nss rky soht fhstk``s iojjn ans io`fnrs
; Sour p`us an iojjoaft nst rnprfsn fif `k tnrjfho`olfn proposn pkr K`mnrt JNJJF 5* @k euaft nst `n bkft nt `k jkhfrn atrn eufb(* @k euakift nst `nhsnjm`n ans pnrsohhns eufvns* @n euaksjn nst `nhsnjm`n ans aoitrfhns nt ans fhstftutfohs eufvns(
'K(JNJJF Sortrkft auh Eufb&(
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
54/68
>1
atrofts pupftrns ekuhns( Snrsohhn hn `nur prtn kttnhtfoh( Inst `n pnfhtrn
Igklk`` quf` bkuarkft fif + ;Ku iours an in jjn t f` aiouvrn toueours Dfnv `n Qgtrn Eufb atkt= nt
`n enu skfsfsskht an soh kitnur prfhifpk` pur lhfn tgtrk` Yo`ojoh Jfdgon`s( @ns
pfins eouns nh yfaafsg vnf``nht nh `uf ans rsohkhins kussf probohans
qufhkttnhauns( Jkhan stkj nst sous `n ioup auh igoi jotfohhn` aoht `igo vk
mfnh ku*an` au enu tgtrk` quf sobbrn sns ynux( F` nst nh vrftkm`n iojjuhfoh
kvni `n pnup`n eufb qufhikrhnht `ns kitnurs( Anrrfrn ins bflurns akitnurs
Jkhan`stkj rniohhkt `ns Eufbs gkssfafj purs atnhtnurs auhn trkaftfoh vrkfnju`tfjf``hkfrn aoht `k borin nstgtfqun nst `k trkauitfoh auhn borin tgfqun quf `n
mou`nvnrsn( Qoutn `k borin au euaksjn tout `n rytgjn an `k pnhsn kmstrkftn
akhskhtn toutn `k bfnrt an `k akhsn aoht `n snu` jotfb nst nh bfh an iojptn `k
iojpkssfoh `lkra an `k tnrrn tout in`k pkssn akhs `n trnjm`njnht ans jkfhs
akhs `k vfmrktfoh ans aoflts pnhskhts fhspfrs iojjn uh `khlkln krtfiu`( 9
Oh k pnfhn irofrn qun @n Mruft au Qnjpsnt `krtfi`nJfdgon`s oht t irfts an `k
jjn jkfh nt qun jofhs an anux khs spkrnht ins anux tnxtns(
@n pkrk```n Jkhan`stkj Dkbdk sfjposn an `uf*jjn(
Fhapnhakjjnht ans aohhns gfstorfquns lolrkpgfquns po`ftfquns
rkafik`njnht afbbrnhtns kmstrkitfoh bkftn au jf`fnu nhvfrohhkht nt au iohtnxtn
`fhlufstfqun nt mfnh qun `k vfn an Jkhan`stkj soh nhbkhin ku quotfafnh sns
rkpports kvni soh prn kvni sk jrn kvni sns brrns rnstnht in eour1 `fhvnrsn
an `nhbkhin an Dkbdk tnrrftofrn prktfqunjnht fhvfo` oh hn pnut pks hn pks trn
;Dfnv uvrns iojp`tns Q(FFF(
=@n Qgtrn Eufb aNtkt 'Losnt& quf eoukft nh yfaafsg but boha Sntrolrka nh ;6;6 pkrLrkhovsdf( Yns aiors tkfnht sflhs Igklk`` K`tjkh Bk`d soh rpnrtofrn * Ygo`njK`nfignj Snrntz Ygk`oj Ksg
9Jfdgon`s uvrns iojp`tns Q(FFF( An `krlns nxtrkfts an int krtfi`n soht pkrus akhs `krnvun Nsprft 'H;= ;672 trka( N(Kjoursdy&(
1 @n enuhn brrn an Jkhan`stkj Nvluhf kurkft irft uh `fvrn an souvnhfrs quf hkjk`gnurnusnjnht ekjkfs t pum`f 'ib( `k rnvun Hovy JfrH;3 ;67
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
55/68
>>
tohh pkrbofs jjn skfsf nt qun`qun pnu arout pkr `k sfjf`ftuan ans kttftuans nt
ans rkitfohs ans anux irfvkfhs;5 jjn buftn `kao`nsinhin anvkht in qun Dkbdk
kppn`kft `n bkhtjn au euaksjn jjn irkfhtn atrn kspfr asklrl pkr `n
johan eufb `k bofs ahu an snhs si`ros nt jnhkkht jjn kvnrsfoh `lkra
au prn rnspohskm`n an `nur tkrn nt an `nur jk`gnur orflfhn`s inrtkfhns pklns au
Mruft au Qnjpskurkfnht pu sfhtftu`nr @nttrn 'ouvnrtn& ku prn jjn asfr an sn
boharn akhs `n johan ans kutrns an lojjnr `nur afbbrnhin jjn vo`oht an
possanr `k `khlun anh atnhfr `ns jofharn snirnts jjn kigkrhnjnht nhtrnr nh
`fttrkturn pour htrn gkmft qun pkr n``n hn vfvrn qun pkr nt pour n``n( Jjnsnhtfjnht an iu`pkmf`ft bkin kux kutrns pkrin qun `k afbbrnhin nst mfnh ` bkin
kux `nurs pour `ns kvofr rnhfs nt trkgfs bkin nux*jjns surtout pour ins
rkfsohs*` prifsjnht( Jjn qutn jk`kafvn afanhtft jjn khlofsskht [uf
sufs*en ? kuqun` Jkhan`stkj k nu `uf `n mohgnur an trouvnr uhn rpohsn(
@n Qfjmrn lyptfnh uhfqun bfitfoh akhs `uvrn an Jkhan`stkj k
fhahfkm`njnht ans kiinhts dkbdknhs( @ns p`kbohas y soht kussf frrktfohhn``njnht
mks qun akhs `ns `fvrns an Dkbdk( @n f` qun T`ns rojkhs nt `ns rifts an DkbdkZ
jnttnht nh sihn irft Jkrtgn ]omnrt hnst ekjkfs qun `n en au rvn vnf`` uh
en sigjktfqun proent akhs uh nspkin nxprfjnhtk` o `n Jof an `kutnur
apouf`` an sns kppkrnhins soifk`ns nt an sns quk`fts kiinssofrns hkppkrkt p`us
qun ahua rauft `nssnhtfn` an sk sftuktfoh( = Skrhod hnst rfnh akutrn qun `n
en ahuaan soh irktnur proent akhs in igkjp nxprfjnhtk` qunst `k prosn n``n*
jjn pkrsnj an bflurns an aoum`ns au aoum`n an `kutnur iojjn `nst `k prosn
an Dkbdk akhs `n snu` mut an pkrvnhfr uhn fjkln an sof( @k borjn `irfturn an
Jkhan`stkj skppkrnhtn lk`njnht in``n an Dkbdk akhs int krt sumtf` an jkhfnr `k
bkm`n skhs suent hf gros o `n quotfafnh sn j`n `trkhln `n rvn `k rk`ft(
Dkbdk k vfhlt*guft khs qukha f` voft sn proaufrn pour `k prnjfrn bofs `k troupn
an @wy nt `ns kitnurs au Qgtrn Eufb ku ikb Ykvoy an Srklun( Jkhan`stkj k
; Rofr khhnxn p(22*2
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
56/68
>2
trnhtn*ifhq khs qukha f` aiouvrn `n Qgtrn Eufb sur `k sihn an Dfnv( trkhlnjnht
inst kvni `k jjn jotfoh nt `k jjn bnrvnur quf`s oht tous anux rklf ku
spnitki`n auhn kutrn vfn eufvn possfm`n aoht `uh nt `kutrn flhorkfnht eusqun*`
`nxfstnhin( @nJfdgon`s an Jkhan`stkj p`us proboha akhs sk rb`nxfoh snjm`n trn
`n pro`ohlnjnht ans hotns qun Dkbdk k iohsflhns akhs soh Eourhk` `n > oitomrn
;6;;(
Inst ` qun `nurs ignjfhs sn spkrnht(
Hu` hn skurk qun``n vofn kurkft njpruhtn Dkbdk sf` kvkft viu eusqu
`poqun gft`rfnhhn hf in quf` snrkft kavnhu an sk qutn afanhtft sf` kvkft iohh u`k Qigios`ovkqufn sovftfsn(
Skrkaoxk`njnht inst lrin `gorrnur an `poqun stk`fhfnhhn qun
Jkhan`stkj k rniouvr sk `fmnrt fhtrfnurn( F` `uf kvkft pkru sf sfjp`n nt sf vfanht
an rnjp`kinr sk bkjf``n nt `n i`okqun eufb pkr `k iojjuhkut ans gojjns + Jkfs
qutkft*n``n anvnhun inttn brktnrhft aoht f` kvkft rv nt ku snrvfin an `kqun``n f`
kvkft jfs sk p`ujn ?
Sour `k l`ofrn rntnhtfsskhtn ans sfi`ns vnhfrSour `k`tfrn trfmu ans gojjnsEkf pnrau jk ioupn ku bnstfh an jns prnsEkfpnrau jk eofn ekf pnrau joh gohhnur(
Yur jns pku`ns skmkt `n sfi`n igfnh*tunur*an*`oups
Jkfs en hn sufs pks `oup jof pkr `n skhl an jns vnfhns(;
Oh k `n snhtfjnht qun pnhakht ins qun`quns khhns `k bfh ans khhns vfhlt nt
`n amut ans khhns trnhtn Jkhan`stkj nst proiiup gkht pkr sk iu`pkmf`ft nt
`k rpkrktfoh an skbkutn( [un aft in pojn sf in hnst quf` rptn uhn bofs nhiorn in
qunxprfjkft @n Qfjmrn lyptfnh nh `khlkln sfmy``fh nt @k [uktrfjn Srosn nh i`kfr ?
; Sojn H==< akt ans ;
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
57/68
> akt au 9 jkf ;69;( Qrka( B(Drn` op( ift(
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
58/68
>7
nh toutn iohsifnhin quf` k rnhf `k bkjf``n an TsohZ pnup`n inst nh toutn iohsifnhin
quf` snst prfv an sk ioupn ku bnstfh an TsnsZ prns jkfs `n pfvot an inttn stropgn `njot*i` skhs `nqun` in``n*if pnrarkft tout soh snhs en projnts sous*nhtnha auhn
pkrt qun `n rnhlktkppkrtfnht uh tnjps pkss rvo`u akutrn pkrt qun `nxi`u `n
mkhhf `n askvou `nbrrn jiohhu nst fhvnstf pkrnf` soh brrn mfm`fqun Eosnpg an
`k jfssfoh a`u(;
Nhbkht proaflun sauft pkr `n igkht ans sfrhns an Stnrsmourl au
igrfstfkhfsjn ans rojkhfign`s an `k `fttrkturn inst prsnht an soh prn quf`
kttnha `n pkraoh inst soh prn quf` prtn so`nhhn``njnht snrjnht( Yoh prn sohjk`gnur nt soh asgohhnur akhtkh `n vof` proju Ekiom ignb ans Eufbs = +
Eosnpg nt Esus `u nt propgtn `n Sotn sn proenttn akhs ins anux krigtypns
iohbohaus( Qn` Eosnpg f` bkft snrjnht atrn int `jnht auhfbfiktfoh nt ak``fkhin
qun syjmo`fsn `n pufts( Qn` Esus anvkht `n Sufts an Ekiom f` propgtfsn `k prnhhft
an sk vofx potfqun 5 in`uf quf mofrk an `nku qun en `uf aohhnrkf anvfnhark nh `uf
uhn sourin anku quf ekf``frk eusqun akhs `k vfn tnrhn``n( 9
; Ossfp nst uh arfv an Vossfb * Eosnpg ( Ib( H( Jkhan`stkj 5 Jkhan`stkjsnst toueours souvnhu an soh gojohyjn lyptfnh nh `gohhnur auqun` f` kvkft rnusoh hoj( 'Rtorkyk Dhflk&(
= Ib( `n pojn H=92 Ikhzohn au =2 jkf ;69; 5
En afrkf sn`k % ku ignb ans EufbsSour sk ikrnssn an brkjmofsn(
'% Yklft*f` au jot sn`k quf nh gmrnu sflhfbfn pkusn fhtnrjan * qun `ohpourrkft pkr trkaufrn pkr trvn ou mfnh an sk`kj * sgk`oj * aohi pkfx ?Oh rnhiohtrn tkhtt uh tnrjn tkhtt `kutrn sn`oh `ns aftfohs&(
Akhs soh igkpftrn fhtftu` @n ignb ans Eufbs Hkaneak Jkhan`stkj sn anjkhan qufpnut trn in ignb ans Eufbs tout nh nxp`fqukht qun `k iou`nur brkjmofsn bkft rbrnhin kutkm`nku an ]njmrkhat @n rntour an `Nhbkht proaflun( Or in pojn bkftigroho`olfqunjnht afrnitnjnht suftn ku pojn ift p`us gkut nt =9 eours snu`njnhtspkrnht `nur rakitfoh( F` snjm`n i`kfr qun Jkhan`stkj rnprnha fif `k jjn fjklnmfm`fqun qun akhs `n pojn H =9> pour hojjnr soh proprn prn(
9 Enkh 1 ;1(
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
59/68
>6
Akhs @n Mruft au Qnjps Jkhan`stkj sn anjkhakft kvni pnrp`nxft in
qun vou`kft afrn in qun vou`kft nxprfjnr sk bkjf``n( prsnht f` sn aiouvrnjkf``oh an inttn igkhn bkjf`fk`n hoh p`us nhbkht an hu``n pkrt jkfs mfnh an
qun`qun pkrt f` aiouvrn qun `n abkut an `khlun iohlhftk` an sk bkjf``n an
soh prn `ofh atrn uhn tkrn gohtnusn nst uhn vrftkm`n rfignssn sk rfignssn;(
@fjkln au prn rnvfnht nhiorn nt nhiorn akhs `n Roykln nh Krjhfn akhs
@Nhtrntfnh sur Akhtn `n p`us souvnht akhs uh afk`olun prn*bf`s igk`nurnux nt
tnharn o `n bf`s*afsifp`n trouvn kuprs an soh prn skvofr protnitfoh
iojprgnhsfoh=
( In afk`olun njprnfht auhn tnharnssn fhbfhfn Jkhan`stkj `khou kvni soh prn kfhsf qunh tjoflhnht `ns qun`quns `nttrns aktkht an inttn
poqun quf oht pu trn rntrouvns9(
In rntour akhs `n snfh pktnrhn` inttn jkrign akhs `ns pks au prn pourrkfnht
htrn qun in qun Brnua k kppn` `n rntour au rnbou` ( Inpnhakht `orsqun
Jkhan`stkj sn rniohhkt iojjn uh pro`ohlnjnht an soh prn oh hn pnroft `
kuiuh kiinht auhn qun`iohqun hlktfoh an sk proprn fhafvfauk`ft an sk proprn
uhfift( @k jusfqun qun Jkhan`stkj nhtnha nst ku iohtrkfrn in``n an sk bf`fktfoh an
; Ib( akhs @Nhtrntfnh sur Akhtn5 F` jn snjm`n qun Akhtn anvkft tuafnr kvni kttnhtfohtous `ns abkuts an prohohifktfoh prtnr `ornf``n kux mluns kux sy``kmns zzkykhtnshksf``khtns joftf kvk`ns nt quf` nh k mnkuioup kpprfs
= Skr nxnjp`n Rfrlf`n/Akhtn ^lo`fho/Khsn`juiifho akhs `Nhtrntfnh sur Akhtn\f`gnj/B`fx akhs `n Roykln nh Krjhfn jkfs kussf `fjkln au Srn Krkrkt * toueoursakhs `n Roykln nh Krjhfn(
9 Ignr pkpk TZ en sufs an p`us nh p`us iohvkfhiu qun hous kvohs horjjnht an
igosns nh iojjuh surtout sur `n p`kh fhtn``nitun` * igosn qun en hn iojprnhkfs pks`orsqun etkfs lkjfh( Inh nst jjn ar`n5 enxp`orn pkr nxnjp`n nh in jojnht `nssifnhins hkturn``ns * `k mfo`olfn `k tgorfn an `k vfn * nh sojjn en rptn akhs inaojkfhn `ns tkpns an `vo`utfoh an joh prn( [uf nut pu `n pnhsnr ? + 'ainjmrn;69=&(
Ignr pntft pkpk TZ S`us qun tout ku johan en vouarkfs tn vofr( TZ Ekurkfs tkhtnhvfn an jn trouvnr nh in jojnht akhs tk igkjmrn kvni `n afvkh vnrt nt hotrn pntftnmfm`fotgqun( 'ainjmrn ;692&(
'Oh rniohhkt fif `k mfm`fotgqun nt `n afvkh au Mruft au Qnjps& @nttrns pum`fns akhs `krnvun Hovy Jfr H;3 ;67
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
60/68
23
sk lhk`olfn `kqun``n f` kvkft t soura pnhakht ans afzkfhns akhhns akhs
`kqun``n f` rniohhkt prsnht sk pkrtftfoh an `kqun``n sn atkign sk vofx(
Orflfhns rkifhns sourins kppkrtnhkhin Jkhan`stkj sn rkiiroign ins
rnprns kvni `k borin au asnspofr nh in amut ans khhns trnhtn( @n tgjn au ao
en vfnhs kvni iojjn pfinhtrn `fjkln au prn pkriourt `ns prosns an inttn
poqun tkhtt kvni vfo`nhin tkhtt kvni aouinur jkfs toueours sn`oh anux `flhns
an borin fhtnrapnhakhtns pkrbofs fhafssoifkm`ns quf oht pour Jkhan`stkj uhn
jjn rsohkhin 5 soh kppkrtnhkhin uh pnup`n nt soh kppkrtnhkhin uhn `flhn
`fttrkfrn(
@k `fttrkturn lklhn*pkfh `n rvu`sn( Skr `k borin ans igosns f` bkft ans
trkauitfohs quf `uf aohhnht uh snjm`kht an joynh anxfstnhin( Nh ;6=7 uhn
jkfsoh aaftfoh `uf anjkhan an rnjkhfnr anux trkauitfohs an Qf`` `Nspfl`n quf
kvkfnht t bkftns `uhn pkr K(Gorhbn`a `kutrn pkr R( Dkrfkdfhn( [ukha `k houvn``n
trkauitfoh rnvun nt iorrfln pkr Jkhan`stkj pkrkt snu` soh hoj bflurn sur `n
`fvrn( In quf kurkft a htrn quuh fhifanht mkhk` au pntft johan `fttrkfrn sn
trkhsborjn nh vrftkm`n ikmk`n( ^hn horjn jkigfhn sn jnt nh mrkh`n kussf
fhsnhsn qufjp`kikm`n( Kiius an p`klfkt Jkhan`stkj sumft prois nxi`usfoh
pnrsiutfoh iohhotktfoh khtfsjftn( Ans eours aurkht f` nst fhtnrrol skhs
rn`ign( Akhs uhn `nttrn sk bnjjn f` frohfsn sur soh kbbkfrn Arnybus(
Inst akhs nt an in iohtnxtn qun hkt @k [uktrfjn Srosn(
[ufhzn pklns an irf tkhtt rkuqun tkhtt skuvkln o `fhtnhsft an `k vfo`nhin
nst proportfohhn``n in``n an `k aou`nur( [ufhzn pklns an tnjptn wklhrfnhhn o
Jkhan`stkj gur`n abfn fhsu`tn nt akhs in aigkhnjnht an rkln anux jots
rnvfnhhnht fh`ksskm`njnht jf``n bofs rpts i`kjs `k bkin au johan 5 e n
s u f s ( Kbbfrjktfoh an sof ku iur an `nxi`usfoh abf `k pnur khfjk`n abf `k
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
61/68
2;
tnrrn sovftfqun skhl`khtn abf `k `fttrkturn sous iohtr`n abf `k sk`n nhlnkhin
ans irfvkfhs fhtfjns au pouvofr Jkhan`stkj rn`vn `k ttn bf`s au pnup`n `khuqun rofan ( Akhs uhn jkfh f` snrrn sk pn`fssn agfvnr `k posfn `fmrn akhs
`kutrn sk gou`nttn eufvn sk afbbrnhin rnvnhafqun soh orlunf` nt sk `fmnrt(
Gfnr nsi`kvn kueouraguf gojjn `fmrn( @fmrn an mofrn jjn `n lou`ot an `k
moutnf``n `fmrn an bou`nr ku pfna sk pn`fssn `fttrkfrn `fmrn airfrn nh angors ans
mk`fsns(
Yf Jkhan`stkj rnssnht an bkoh sf kflu soh kppkrtnhkhin ku pnup`n eufb sf`
rnvnhafqun gkut nt bort soh grftkln ju`tfjf``hkfrn;
`k hotfoh akppkrtnhkhin `kiojjuhkut eufvn `uf nst pkr iohtrn totk`njnht trkhlrn( F` `ns bustfln skhs
jhklnjnht `ns Eufbs vf`s mkhqufnrs rnpus i`nris rkjpkhts irfvkfhs
sumoraohhs vnhaus p`us ioupkm`ns nt jprfskm`ns nhiorn qun `ns kutrns rnptf`ns
`ignurs an mottns pkrin qun eufbs(
F` y kvkft anux brrns Ighfnr 5 `n ikant fhaflhn kppkrtfnht tout nhtfnr `k
`fttrkturn `kh jfs jort `k `uf*jjn jfsn jort( Kssoifktfoh vo`ohtkfrn ou
fhiohsifnhtn ? ^h jjn skhl iou`kft akhs `ns vnfhns aKhar nt an Jkrfn*Eosnpg
Ighfnr( @n ikant brkykft kvni `n pouvofr( Khar `uf tkft Eufb ku snhs o
`nhtnhakft Jkrfhk Qsvntknvk=( Eufb pkrin qun Sotn eusquku pfna an `k luf``otfhn(
^h jjn skhl iou`kft akhs `ns vnfhns an tous `ns Gorhbn`a nt kutrns ohi`n Johfk nt
akhs in``ns aOssfp Jkhan`stkj jkfs sf `ns potns soht ans Eufbs tous `ns Eufbs hn
soht pks ans potns( @n tftrn gohorfbfqun sn jrftn( F` hn subbft pks an skppn`nr
Gorhbn`a ou Dklkh pour trn `grftfnr ans mnrlnrs ans pktrfkrigns nt ans rofs(
@ns vk`nurs `ns rbrnhins soht rnstns khirns fjjukm`ns fha`mf`ns akhs `k
iohsifnhin an Jkhan`stkj( @khifnhhn fjkln au Srn euakqun rnvfnht fanhtfqun
in``n an `nhbkhin( Skr uh enu an ap`kinjnht `n vrkf prn sum`fj nst anvnhu
Ekiom pktrfkrign lhftnur an ``u au Sotn nt inst `k `fttrkturn nh tkht
qufhstftutfoh quf sn bkft prn ikstrktnur rnprsnhtn sous `ns trkfts
; [ukha Jkhan`stkj sn proi`kjn Eufb f` njp`ofn `n tnrjn mfm`fqun Fouafn(
= Ib( hotn p(=
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
62/68
2=
trkaftfohhn``njnht eufbs agojjns mkrmus quf alklnht uhn rpulhkhtn oanur an pnku;
nt vo`unht akhs uh johan iou`nur ekuhn( Jkhan`stkj hgsftn p`us anvkht `nigofx nhtrn in quf` hojjn `k ifriohifsfoh `fttrkfrn nt `n rnbrofafssnjnht jortn` rfsqun
nhiouru pkr in`uf quf krrkign an sns pku`ns sk pn`fssn `fttrkfrn( Nh `k bou`kht ku
pfna f` surjohtn soh khlofssn an jort trfojpgn an sk pnur nt in trfojpgn nst
iojjn uh kafnu Skrhod(
Skrvnhu ku pkroxysjn an `k tnhsfoh hnrvnusn provoqun pkr inttn vfo`nhin
nhaflun ku prfx auh nbbort surgujkfh Jkhan`stkj snbboharn `kfssn igkppnr
uh skhl`ot pnfhn kuafm`n 5 Fig mfh krj( Akhs uhn `nttrn HkaneakJkhan`stkj f` rnprnha `ns jjns jots toueours nh k``njkha 5 En sufs snu`( Fig
mfh krj( Qout nst frrjafkm`n( @k rupturn nst uhn rfignssn( F` bkut `k prsnrvnr( =
[un` sniours nssnhtfn` trouvkft*f` akhs `k `khlun k``njkhan ku boha an sk so`ftuan ?
V nhtnhakft*f` uh igo an Iour`khan ?
Nh `kh trnhtn nt uh kprs `k hkfsskhin au sfi`nEn sufs rnvnhu hoh `frn 5 oh jk iohtrkfht rnvnhfr Josiou*`k*mouaagfqunJkfs kvkht in ekf qukha jjn iohhu@n proaflun Krkrkt hkppn mfm`fqunNt pkss anux inhts eours akhs in `fnu skmmktfqun[un `oh kppn``n `Krjhfn(9
Oh snrkft tnht an afrn gnurnux quf iojjn Jkhan`stkj k bkft uh mnku
voykln Gnurnux fhiohtnstkm`njnht `k t ku irnux an inttn tnrrn prn nt jrn
jtkpgorn au mnrinku an `gujkhft sur ikanttn an `k tnrrn an Euan ( @n
Roykln nh Krjhfn nh tjoflhn prosn akjour prosn lohb`n an eofn o
; Oh sn souvfnht qun `n prn an Jkhan`stkj tkft pn``ntfnr(
=@nttrn H>9 ;693 uvrns iojp`tns Q(FFF(
9 Sojn fhkignv H=9
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
63/68
29
Jkhan`stkj hn inssn an sn a`nitnr an sn reoufr an sjnrvnf``nr an snhfvrnr au
vnht quf snhloubbrn akhs sns poujohs(In voykln nh Krjhfn quf but iojjn `n sou`flhn Ynrnhk Rftk`n; `n anrhfnr
voykln vo`ohtkfrn an Jkhan`stkj k t uhn pkusn uh fhtnrjan uh iohtn
mfm`fqun nh p`nfh iur an `nhbnr uh voykln ku pkys jytgfqun an sns rkifhns
khinstrk`ns( @ns jtkpgorns mfm`fquns hkfssnht an``ns*jjns akhs in pkyskln o
tout pkr`n `n `khlkln mfm`fqun(
@Krjhfn k aohh Jkhan`stkj sn ikrnssn an brkjmofsn ( Yur in so`
jklfqun nt skir f` k rntrouv inttn kutgnhtfift quf hous kfan hous snhtfr hous*jjns pkrtfn fhtlrkhtn an `k trkaftfoh( F` snst `kfss nhvotnr pkr in pnup`n
krjhfnh quf vfvkft hoh pks ku rytgjn ans gor`olns ans lkrns nt ans fhstftutfohs
jkfs sn`oh `n ikarkh so`kfrn( Akhs sk vrft probohan inttn tnrrn apouf``n an
tout krtfbfin `uf k tnhau `n jfrofr an soh fanhtft f` sy nst snhtf siurfs protl
`fmrn gnurnux `uf*jjn( @k p`hftuan an `k vfn ans Krjhfnhs `nur tnharnssn
mrutn TZ `nur rpu`sfoh fhafifm`n pour toutn jtkpgysfqun nt `nur jnrvnf``nusn
bkjf`fkrft kvni `n johan ans igosns rn``ns tout in`k jn afskft 5 tu rnhkfs `k vfn
hkfn pks pnur an toh tnjps `kfssn `ns bkux*snjm`khts(
Inttn prosn aoht `n ikarn apkssn `krlnjnht `n ikarn an `Krjhfn proprnjnht
aftn prosn toutn nh aflrnssfohs nh kssoifktfohs nh pgrksns pkrbofs hfljktfquns
quf soht an vrftkm`ns eoykux an posfn inttn prosn igkhtn `ns orflfhns sur tous `ns
afkpksohs orflfhns au johan orflfhns an sof orflfhns an `k iu`turn an `k `khlun
au johan khfjk` vltk` N``n nst uh gyjhn `k vfn in aoh prifnux nt
fjprnsirfptfm`n mfnh qun pkrkaoxk`njnht `k jort soft skhs inssn prsnhtn akhs
`ouvrkln( Qojmns tojmnkux pfnrrns tojmk`ns ossnjnhts gujkfhs irhns
skhitukfrns vksns buhrkfrns `n tnxtn nst ek`ohh an tnrjns kykht trkft `k jort(
Jkhan`stkj k toueours nu pnur an `k jort( Oh sn souvfnht au rift an Jkrfhk
Qsvntknvk sur `n snjpftnrhn` ekf pnur + an Jkhan`stkj pnhakht `nur
; Y( RFQK@N Rtoroyn roeafnhfn Jkhan`stkjk ' @k anuxfjn hkfsskhin an Jkhan`stkj &iojjuhfiktfoh ku syjposfuj an Mkrf 'Ftk`fn& =
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
64/68
21
projnhkan ku ifjntfrn aK`nxkharov nh ;6;2;( Anpufs `n jf`fnu ans khhns vfhlt
f` tkft trnfht pkr `khlofssn an `k jort( Skrk```njnht `k jort iohirtn tkftprsnhtn igkqun pks( Iohakjhktfohs aportktfohs eustfin sojjkfrn sn
ai`fhkfnht ku quotfafnh(
Nh bou`kht `n so` khtfqun an `Krjhfn Jkhan`stkj y k rnhiohtr uhn kutrn
jort apouf``n an tout ikrkitrn khlofsskht an toutn fhquftkhtn trkhlnt an
toutn jnhkin( Mkhk`fsn n``n sfhsrkft akhs `n pkyskln kussf purn qun `k pfnrrn(
Qjoflhkln auhn iu`turn siu`kfrn n``n iohtkft `gfstofrn an `Krjhfn nt an
`gujkhft( Bkjf`frn n``n bkfskft pkrtfn fhtlrkhtn an `k vfn projnssn anrniojjnhinjnht syjmo`fsn pkr `fjkln rkssurkhtn anhbkhts eoukht sur `ns
tojmns ans jofhns( Jkhan`stkj snst njp`oy `kpprfvofsnr `ofh an `k vkiuft
iftrouf``nsqun an `k ]ussfn o sn prktfqun `n iu`tn ans jorts o `ns vo`ohtkfrns
sn prnssnht pour kmkttrn `gojjn*krmrn( @ofh ans vfsklns s`kvns fhsfpfans nt
jkuvkfs f` snst `kfss iohqurfr pkr `Krjhfn proenitfoh an `k tnrrn an sns
prns pkys a`nitfoh gors `n tnjps o `ns irhns gujkfhs soht lk`njnht
mnkux akhs `k tojmn nt akhs `n `kmnur(
En hn tn vnrrkf p`us ekjkfsIfn` jyopn an `Krjhfn
En hn vnrrkf p`us p`fsskht `ns ynux@k tnhtn hojkan an `KrkrktNt akhs `k mfm`fotgqun ans kutnurs potfnrsS`us ekjkfs en houvrfrkf
@n `fvrn vfan an `k tnrrn sp`nhafanO sfhstrufsfrnht `ns prnjfnrs gojjns(=
Oitomrn ;693( Kprs ifhq khs an jutfsjn potfqun Jkhan`stkj irft sns
prnjfnrs vnrs(
; J( QYRNQKNRK Fstorfk oahovo posvfkigtignhfyk ' Gfstofrn auhn hoh*aafikin&uvrns iojp`tns(
= Qrka( B(Drn` op( ift(
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
65/68
2>
Oh k souvnht aft qun `Krjhfn kvkft rouvnrt Jkhan`stkj `k vofn an `k
posfn( Bkut*f` irofrn inttn tgsn ans anux inhts eours*jfrki`n ?Snhakht ifhq khs mrfmn kprs mrfmn mk`mutfnjnht kprs mk`mutfnjnht
Jkhan`stkj k rniunf``f rkssnjm` soh gfstofrn kvni pour uhfqun iojpklhn tout
ku `ohl an int trkhln pkriours sk prosn( Nxinptfoh bkftn an `Nhtrntfnh sur Akhtn
quf prnhkht Akhtn pour prtnxtn nst nh bkft uh kutoportrkft uhn probnssfoh an bof
uh Nhtrntfnh sur Jkhan`stkj gojjn nt potn in qun Jkhan`stkj kppn``n `n
rkpport au tnxtn soh nhvo` f` hy nut hf prosn kvkht hf prosn kprs(
@k Sosfn `kttnhakft ku tnrjn an in voykln ku mout an `uf*jjn( Qrofs bofs mhf quf soh igkht skft jnttrn uh hoj afskft*f` akhs uh pojn
an ;6=9( @k posfn ans snpt anrhfrns khhns quf `uf rnstkfnht vfvrn posfn irftn
pnhakht `k prfoan `k p`us sojmrn qukft ekjkfs iohhu Jkhan`stkj nst uhn
posfn an aou`nur pkrin qun an jk`gnur jkfs quf inpnhakht vfmrn ans kiinhts
auhn `fmnrt fhtrfnurn qun hu` tyrkh hn put `uf aromnr( Jkhan`stkj y rniohhkt
y hojjn `k trkin an igkiuh an sns pks(
Nvn`fhn Kjoursdy
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
66/68
22
KHHNWN
-
7/23/2019 Mandelstam dans les marges des brouillons
67/68
2