−xb ®lg¡−l¾p ew -49/2005...2016/09/07 · ¯v’bxq chv©‡qi ivr‰bwzk †bzv kgx©myb...
TRANSCRIPT
Ef¢Øqa ¢hQ¡lf¢a Se¡h Jh¡uc¤m q¡p¡e
Hhw ¢hQ¡lf¢a L«o·¡ ®che¡b
−Xb ®lg¡−l¾p ew-49/2005
l¡øÊ -he¡j-
e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l Nw
p−‰
−g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew-1452/2005 Hhw ®Sm Bf£m ew-415/2005 c¤m¡m ¢ju¡ Jl−g c¤m¡m ...... Bf£mL¡l£
p−‰ −g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew-1513/2005 Hhw −Sm Bf£m ew-410/2005 j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h iCu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h ........Bf£mL¡l£ p−‰ −g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew-1515/2005 1.BCu¤h Bm£, 2. l¢Lh E¢Ÿe plL¡l Jl−g f¡è¤ plL¡l Hhw 3. e¤l¦m B¢je Jl−g B¢je ....... Bf£mL¡l£ p−‰ −g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew-1572/2005 Hhw −Sm Bf£m ew-412/2005 −j¡q¡Çjc Bm£ ....... Bf£mL¡l£
p−‰ −g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew-1703/2005 Hhw −Sm Bf£m ew-411/2005 −p¡q¡N Jl−g pl¦ ....... Bf£mL¡l£
p−‰ −g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew-1739/2005 Hhw −Sm Bf£m ew-409/2005 e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l ....... Bf£mL¡l£
p−‰ −g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew-1808/2005
2
j¢el ....... Bf£mL¡l£
p−‰ −g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew-1813/2005 Hhw −Sm Bf£m ew-413/2005 S¡q¡‰£l Jl−g hs S¡q¡‰£l Jl−g juje¢pwq¡ S¡q¡‰£l ....... Bf£mL¡l£ p−‰ −g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew-1844/2005 Hhw −Sm Bf£m ew-414/2005 B¢jl Jl−g B¢jl ®q¡−pe ....... Bf£mL¡l£
p−‰ −g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew-1845/2005 S¡q¡‰£l Jl−g ®j¡x S¡q¡‰£l Bmj ....... Bf£mL¡l£ p−‰ −g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew-2862/2007 (®Sm Bf£m ew- 1189/2006 q−a Eá§a) lae Jl−g ®R¡V lae ....... Bf£mL¡l£
p−‰ −g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew-8330/2010 (®Sm Bf£m ew-139/2010 q−a Eá§a) lae ¢ju¡ Jl−g lae Jl−g hs lae Jl−g hs ¢ju¡ ....... Bf£mL¡l£ p−‰ −g±Sc¡l£ ¢h¢hd j¡jm¡ ew-14222/2015 Hhw −Sm Bf£m ew-1322/2005 Bh¤ p¡m¡j Jl−g p¡m¡j
....... clM¡Ù¹¡L¡l£/Bf£mL¡l£
p−‰ −g±Sc¡l£ ¢h¢hd j¡jm¡ ew-10842/2006 n¢qc¤m Cpm¡j ¢nf¤ ....... clM¡Ù¹¡L¡l£
p−‰ −g±Sc¡l£ ¢h¢hd j¡jm¡ ew-41411/2014 −m¡Lj¡e ®q¡−pe Jl−g h¤m¤ ....... clM¡Ù¹¡L¡l£
p−‰ −Sm Bf£m ew-295/2007
3
q¡¢gS Jl−g L¡e¡ q¡¢gS ....... Bf£mL¡l£
p−‰ −Sm Bf£m ew-959/2007 Bm-B¢je ....... Bf£mL¡l£
-he¡j-
l¡øÊ .......¢hh¡c£fr (pLm ®g±x Bf£m, ®Sm Bf£m Hhw ®g±x ¢h¢hd j¡jm¡ pj§−q)
Se¡h j¡qh¤−h Bmj, HÉ¡Ve£Ñ ®Se¡−lm p−‰ ¢jp l¦e¡ e¡q¡¢le HÉ¡¢e, −Xf¤¢V HÉ¡Ve£Ñ ®Se¡−lm, Se¡h h¢nl Bq−jc, pqL¡l£ HÉ¡Ve£Ñ ®Se¡−lm, ¢jp j”¤ e¡Se£e, pqL¡l£ HÉ¡Ve£Ñ ®Se¡−lm Hhw ¢jp Cu¡p¢je ®hNj ¢h¢b, pqL¡l£ HÉ¡Ve£Ñ ®Se¡−lm
||||||||||||||l¡øÌ f−r Se¡h Hj| B¢jl¦m Cpm¡j, ¢p¢eul BCeS£h£ p−‰ Se¡h Bë¤m j¢ae Mpl¦, ¢p¢eul BCeS£h£, Se¡h p¡−S¡u¡l ®q¡−pe, Se¡h −nM gS−m e§l a¡fp Hhw Se¡h Hp.Hj.Bm£j, BCeS£h£NZ ||||||||||||||l¡øÌ f−r ¢e−u¡¢Sa ¢h‘ BCeS£h£NZ−L pq¡ua¡L¡l£ Se¡h ¢V|HCQ| M¡e, ¢p¢eul BCeS£h£ p−‰ Se¡h H|®S| ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£, ¢p¢eul BCeS£h£, Se¡h gup¡m HCQ. M¡e, Se¡h M¤l¢nc Bmj M¡e, Se¡h q¡¢hh¥l lqj¡e plL¡l, Se¡h j¡ue¤¢Ÿe Hhw Se¡h ®j¡q¡Çjc Bqp¡e, BCeS£h£NZ
|||||||||||||Bf£mL¡l£l f−r (®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew 1739/2005 Hhw
®Sm Bf£m ew 409/2005) Se¡h M¾cL¡l j¡qh¤h ®q¡−pe, ¢p¢eul BCeS£h£ p−‰ Se¡h ®nM ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£, Se¡h Hj| j¡p¤c l¡e¡, Se¡h glq¡c S¡j¡e, ¢jp e¡p¢le M¾cL¡l, Se¡h ¢eu¡S ®j¡q¡Çjc j¡qh¤h Hhw Se¡h j¤Ù¹¡¢gS¤l lqj¡e, BCeS£h£NZ ||||||||||||| Bf£mL¡l£/clM¡Ù¹L¡l£ (®g±x Bf£m ew 1515/2005-H Bf£mL¡l£ ew 1 Hhw 3; Hhw ®g±x ¢h¢hd j¡jm¡
4
ew14222/2005, −g±x ¢h¢hd j¡jm¡ ew 10842/2006, ®g±x Bf£m ew 8330/2005 Hhw ®Sm Bf£m ew 1322/2005) Se¡h jJc¤c Bq−jc, ¢p¢eul BCeS£h£ p−‰ Se¡h B−e¡u¡l¦m Cpm¡j, BCeS£h£
||||||||||||Bf£mL¡l£l f−r (®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew 1515/2005 Hl 2 ew Bf£mL¡l£)
Se¡h p¡Cg¥¢Ÿe j¡qj¤c, BCeS£h£ |||||||||||||Bf£mL¡l£l f−r
(®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew 1452/2005 p−‰ ®Sm Bf£m ew 415/2005) Se¡h M¤l¢nc Bmj M¡e, BCeS£h£
|||||||||||||Bf£mL¡l£l f−r (®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew 1513/2005 Hhw
®Sm Bf£m ew 410/2005) Se¡h ®~puc ¢jS¡e¤l lqj¡e, BCeS£h£ p−‰ Se¡h ®j¡x Bh¤m L¡m¡j f¡VJu¡l£, BCeS£h£
|||||||||||||Bf£mL¡l£l f−r (®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew 1572/2005 Hhw
®Sm Bf£m ew 412/2005) Se¡h Hp| Hj| S¡¢qc¤l lqj¡e, BCeS£h£
|||||||||||||Bf£mL¡l£l f−r (®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew 1703/2005 Hhw
®Sm Bf£m ew 411/2005) Se¡h Bm¡m E¢Ÿe, BCeS£h£
|||||||||||||Bf£mL¡l£l f−r (®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew 1808/2005)
Se¡h Hp| Hj| n¡qS¡q¡e, BCeS£h£ p−‰ Se¡h ®j¡x L¢mj¤õ¡q jS¤jc¡l, BCeS£h£
|||||||||||||Bf£mL¡l£l f−r (®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew 1813/2005 Hhw
®Sm Bf£m ew 413/2005) Se¡h Hp| Hj| n¡qS¡q¡e, BCeS£h£ p−‰ Se¡h j¡p¤c Bq−jc p¡Dc, BCeS£h£
|||||||||||||Bf£mL¡l£l f−r (®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew 1844/2005 Hhw
®Sm Bf£m ew 414/2005) Se¡h j¡p¤c Bq−jc p¡Dc, BCeS£h£ p−‰ Se¡h ®j¡x l¡−nc¤‹¡j¡e h¤p¢eu¡, BCeS£h£
|||||||||||||Bf£mL¡l£l f−r (®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew 1845/2005) Se¡h H.Hj. j¡qh¤h E¢Ÿe, BCeS£h£
5
|||||||||||||clM¡Ù¹L¡l£l f−r (®g±Sc¡l£ ¢h¢hd j¡jm¡ ew 41411/2014)
Se¡h −qm¡m E¢Ÿe ®j¡õ¡, BCeS£h£ p−‰ Se¡h Hj.H. Jq¡h, BCeS£h£
|||||||||||||Bf£mL¡l£l f−r (−Sm Bf£m ew 295/2007)
Se¡h H.Hj. −j¡x B¢SS¤m qL, −ØVV ¢X−g¾p BCeS£h£ |||||||||||||A¢ik¤š² e¤l¦m Cpm¡j ¢cf¤,
B−e¡u¡l ®q¡−pe Be¤, gup¡m, l¢e ¢ju¡ Jl−g l¢e g¢Ll, ¯puc Bq−jc jSe¤, S¡q¡wN£l, ¢fa¡- L¡−nj j¡chl, j¢nEl lqj¡e jö Hhw −M¡Le .........HC pLm A¢ik¤š² fm¡aL Bp¡j£N−Zl f−rz
öe¡e£l a¡¢lMx 14-01-2016, 28-01-2016, 04-02-2016, 11-02-2016, 17-02-2016, 18-02-2016, 08-03-2016, 09-03-2016, 10-03-2016, 15-03-2016, 16-03-2016, 29-03-2016, 30-03-2016, 31-03-2016, 05-04-2016, 06-04-2016, 07-04-2016, 12-04-2016, 04-05-2016, 05-05-2016, 08-05-2016, 09-05-2016, 10-05-2016, 11-05-2016, 12-05-2016, 15-05-2016, 16-05-2016, 24-05-2016, 25-05-2016, 06-06-2016, 07-06-2016, 08-06-2016 ¢MËx Hhw l¡−ul a¡¢lMx 15-06-2016 ¢MËx
¢hQ¡lf¢a Jh¡uc¤m q¡p¡e.
1. AÎ †W_ †idv‡i‡Ý Ges G ms‡M GK‡Î ïbvbxK„Z †dŠR`vix
Avcxjmg~‡n, ®g±Sc¡l£ ¢h¢hd ®j¡LŸj¡pj§−q I †Rj Avcxj mg~‡n wm÷vi
wePvicwZ K…òv †`ebv_ KZ…©K cÖ Ë iv‡qi mv‡_ m¤ú~Y© GKgZ †cvlY K‡i
Avwg Avgvi wbR¯ wKQz cÖvmswMK e³e¨ I ch©‡e¶Y cÖ vb KiwQ|
6
2. cÖwZwU nZ¨vKvÛB AgvbweK hv mgv‡R ¶Z m„w÷ K‡i,
Rbgvby‡li wbivcËv‡ev‡a Pig AvNvZ nv‡b| mymsMwVZ Avµg‡bi
djkÖ“wZ‡Z msNwUZ †h nZ¨vKvÛ‡K †K›`ª K‡i GB †W_ †idv‡iÝ Avgv‡`i
Kv‡Q cvVv‡bv n‡q‡Q Zv wbtm‡›`‡n RNb¨Zg I Kvcyi“‡lvwPZ NUbv| GB
wbg©g NUbv †Kej NUbvi wkKvi e¨w³‡`i cÖvY ‡K‡o †bqwb------i³v³
K‡i‡Q mf¨ mgvR‡K, gvby‡li my ’ †PZbv‡K, gvbeZv‡K | evsjv‡`‡ki
BwZnv‡m G ai‡bi ˆckvwPK mymsMwVZ nZ¨vKvÛ AZx‡Z Lye KgB msNwUZ
n‡q‡Q| G NUbvq ivR‰bwZK `ye„©Ëvq‡bi ¯úó wPÎ cÖwZdwjZ n‡q‡Q|
UsMxi †bvqvMvuI Gg.G gwR` ¯‹zj cÖvsM‡b AmsL¨ Rbgvby‡li Dcw¯’wZ‡Z
cwiPvwjZ mymsMwVZ Avµg‡bi gva¨‡g †h bviKxq nZ¨vhÁ msNwUZ nq Zv
†_‡K GwU mg¨K Dcjwä Kiv hvq †h, ivRbxwZ‡Z `ye©„Ëvqb µ‡gB †Kvb
chv©‡q †cŠu‡Q‡Q|
3. Avgv‡`i msweavb I cÖvmswMK Ab¨vb¨ AvBb Abyhvqx †Kvb
ivR‰bwZK `j wbev©P‡bi gva¨‡g RbMY KZ…©K wbev©wPZ n‡q ivóª
cwiPvjbvi `vwqZ¡ MÖnb K‡i| G `vwqZ¡ Rbgvby‡li PvIqv-cvIqv c~ib K‡i
Zv‡`iB Kj¨vb I cÖZ¨vkv c~i‡bi gva¨‡g †`‡k AvB‡bi kvmb cÖwZôv
Kiv| miKvi MVb K‡i ivóª cwiPvjbvi `vwqZ¡ cÖvß ivR‰bwZK `jwUi
wbev©wPZ RbcÖwZwbwa‡`i Z_v msm` m`m¨MY‡K wb‡qB MwVZ nq gš¿xmfv|
wbev©wPZ msm` m`m¨‡`i ev miKvi MVbKvix `‡ji D”P chv©‡qi
7
†bZ…e„›`‡K ZvB eûjvs‡k wbR wbev©Pbx GjvKvi ¯’vbxq ivR‰bwZK Kgx©‡`i
Dci wbf©ikxj _vK‡Z †`Lv hvq| Avevi A‡bK †¶‡Î GwUI †`Lv hvq †h,
¯’vbxq chv©‡qi ivR‰bwZK †bZv Kgx©MYB Zv‡`i mg_©b I Kg©KvÛ Øviv
GgbwK D”P chv©‡qi †bZ„e„›`‡K cÖfvweZ I cwiPvwjZ Ki‡Z m¶g nb|
G gvgjvq Av‡jvP¨ wbg©g NUbv I Gi mv‡_ m¤ú„³ cÖvmswMK Ae ’v n‡Z
ivRbxwZi GB Amy ’ w`KwU cÖwZdwjZ n‡q‡Q|
4. ‡h gvgjvwU‡Z AvR Avgiv ivq I wm×vš— w`w”Q †mLv‡b GKRb
D‡j−L‡hvM¨ mvRvcÖvß Awfhy³ n‡jb RvZxqZvev`x hye`‡ji †K›`ªxq †bZv
Rbve byi“j Bmjvg miKvi| A_v©r wZwb wQ‡jb NUbvi mgq miKv‡i _vKv
ivR‰bwZK `‡ji AsM msMV‡bi GKRb †bZv| gvgjvq cÖwZfvZ NUbv
n‡Z GwU D‡V G†&m‡Q †h, byi“j Bmjvg miKv‡ii ms‡M ZLbKvi we‡ivax
ivR‰bwZK `j AvIqvgx jx‡Mi AsM msMVb AvIqvgx hyejx‡Mi †K› ªxq
†bZv Rbve gvndzRyi ingvb gn‡ji ivR‰bwZK ˆeixZvi cvkvcvwk wQj
A_©‰bwZK msNvZ| ivRbxwZwe` QvovI byi“j Bmjvg miKvi wQ‡jb GKRb
¯’vbxq e¨emvqx| gvndyRyi ingvb gnjI wQ‡jb GKRb e¨emvqx| gvgvjvq
Dc¯’vwcZ mv¶¨ cÖgvbvw`, Ae ’v I cÖvmswMK NUbv n‡Z GwU cÖZxqgvb
n‡q‡Q †h, ’vbxqfv‡e gv`K e ¦emv wbqš¿b‡K †K›`ª K‡i Df‡qi g‡a¨
GKUv Ø›Ø PjwQj| gn‡ji ivR‰bwZK `j AIqvgx jxM NUbvi mgq wQj
we‡ivax Ae ’v‡b| Zv m‡Z¡I gnj GjvKvq byi“j Bmjvg miKv‡ii
8
wbiew”Qbœ gv`K e¨vemvq evav m„wó KiwQ‡jb| Avi GwUB wQj gnj‡K
wPiZ‡i mwi‡q †`qvi cwiKíbvi KviY| Avi GB Acivag~jK cwiKíbvi
†nvZv byi“j Bmjvg miKvi Zvi msMx‡`i wb‡q iPbv K‡i GB cwiKíbv ev
lohš¿| GwU wePv‡i cÖgvwbZ n‡q‡Q | gvgvjvi Ab¨Zg mvRvcÖ&vß mn‡hvMx
Awfhy³ gvneyeyi ingv‡bi ¯xKv‡ivw³g~jK Rvevbew›`‡ZI GwU Aåvš—fv‡e
cªwZdwjZ n‡q‡Q hv wc.Wwe−D-3 Ges wc.Wwe−D-34 Gi mv¶¨ Øviv mgw_©Z
n‡q‡Q †`Lv hvq|
5. GLv‡b GKwU welq ¯úó Kiv cÖ‡qvRb †h, mvRvcÖvß mn‡hvMx
Awfhy³ gvneyeyi ingv‡bi ¯xKv‡ivw³g~jK Revbew›` we‡k−lY Ki‡j GwUB
cÖZxqgvb nq †h, byi“j Bmjvg miKvi Ges Zvi msMx cvày miKvi, byi“j
Bmjvg `xcy, giKz‡bi byi“j Avgxb, AvBqye, gvneyeyi ingvb I †gvnv¤§`
Avjx Ms NUbvi 10/12 w`b c~‡e© giKy‡bi byi“j Avwg‡bi evox‡Z mg‡eZ
n‡q ïaz gvndzRyi ingvb gnj‡K nZ¨vKv‡Ûi cwiKíbv K‡i| GKB mv‡_
wc.Wwe−D-11 Ges wc.Wwe−D-12 h_vµ‡g †gvt Rvgvj I †gvt dwi` DwÏb
Gi mv¶¨ n‡Z †`Lv hvq †h, NUbvi w`b byi“j Bmjvg miKvi Zvi Mvox‡Z
K‡i byi“j Bmjvg `xcy Ges Zvi fvB knx`yj Bmjvg kxcy‡K mvnviv
gv‡K©‡Ui mvg‡b bvwg‡q †`q Ges bvgv‡bvi Av‡M Zv‡`i wcV Pvc‡o
Zv‡`i‡K †Kvb GKwU KvR Ki‡Z Drmvn †`q| H byi“j Bmjvg `xcy
NUbvi 10/12 `wb Av‡M giKy‡Yi byi“j Avwg‡bi evox‡Z byi“j Bmjvg
9
miKvi mn Ab¨‡`i mv‡_ mg‡eZ n‡q †Mvcb cwiKíbvq Ask †bq|
djkÖ“wZ‡Z Mvox †_‡K byi“j Bmjvg `xcy I Zvi fvB knx yyj Bmjvg
kxcy‡K bvwg‡q †`qvi mgq byi“j Bmjvg miKvi †h †`vlven AvPiY
K‡iwQj g‡g© ewY©Z `yÕRb mv¶x hv e‡j‡Q Zv Ges cÖvmswMK wn‡m‡e
mvRvcÖvß Avmvgx gvneyeyi ingv‡bi ¯x‡Kviw³g~jK Revbew›`i mv‡_ GK‡Î
we‡ePbvq wb‡j wbwØ©avq Acivag~jK loh‡š¿i welqwU cÖgvwbZ nq Ges
GwUI cÖvgwbZ nq †h, & cwiKíbv I loh‡š¿i †nvZv Z_v Ôgv÷vi gvBÛÕ
wQ‡jb mvRvcÖvß Awfhy³ byi“j Bmjvg miKvi| GwUI ˆeafv‡e AbywgZ nq
†h, byi“j Bmjvg miKvi Zvi ¯’vbxq ivR‰bwZK cÖfve Øviv mn‡RB Zvi
msMx‡`i H loh‡š¿i Ask n‡Z I g~j Aciva msNU‡b m‡PZbfv‡e
DrmvwnZ I cÖ‡ivwPZ Ki‡Z †c‡iwQ‡jb|
6. Gev‡i GwU wggvswmZ n‡Z n‡e †h, bviKxq nZ¨vKvÛwU H
Acivag~jK loh‡š¿i djkÖ“wZ wQj wKbv | mvRvcÖvß mn‡hvMx Awfhy³
gvneyeyi ingv‡bi ¯xKv‡ivw³g~jK Revbew›` n‡Z GwUI cÖZxqgvb nq †h,
NUbvi w`b A_v©r 07.05.2004 Zvwi‡L Av‡iKwU `j NUbv ’‡j Dcw ’Z
†_‡K G‡jvcv_vix ¸wj Quy‡o Rbve Avnmvb Dj−vn gv÷vi Ggwc I iZb
bv‡g GKRb‡K nZ¨v K‡i Ges H mk ¿ Avµg‡b gvndzRyi ingvb gnj mn
Av‡iv A‡b‡KB AvnZ nb|
10
7. NUbvi mgq AvµgbKvix‡`i H `‡j †K †K wQ‡jb ? gvneyeyi
ingv‡bi ¯xKv‡ivw³g~jK Revbew›` e‡j †h, H `‡j wQj Av‡bvqvi †nv‡mb
Ii‡d Avby, Kvbv nwdR, mvjvg, †mvnvM, eo iZb, RvnvsMxi wcZv Kv‡kg
gvZei, gwkDi ingvb Ii‡d gï I gvneyeyi ingvb Ii‡d gvneye|
GQvovI cÖZ¨¶`kx© wc.Wwe−D-1, 2 I Ab¨vb¨ mv¶xi ALwÛZ mv¶¨ Abyhvqx
07.05.2004 Zvwi‡L NUbv¯’j Z_v mfv ’‡j G‡m byi“j Bmjvg `xcy,
knx`yj Bmjvg kxcy Ms Avnmvb Dj−vn gv÷vi‡K j¶¨ K‡i ¸wj K‡i|
giKz‡bi Avgx‡bi evox‡Z lohš¿g~jK mfv I NUbvi gv‡Si 10/12 w`‡bi
g‡a¨ `xcy I kxcy Gi mv‡_ byi“j Bmjvg miKv‡ii I Zvi mn‡hvMx‡`i
Avi †Kvb lohš¿g~jK ˆeVK n‡qwQj wKbv Zv cwi¯‹vi bq -- GwU wVK|
wKš‘ NUbvi w`b byi“j Bmjvg miKvi KZ…©K `xcy I kxcz†K wbR Mvox‡Z
K‡i wb‡q Avmv I †`vlven AvPiY Øviv Zv‡`i‡K Drmvn I cÖ‡ivPbv †`qv
Ges NUbvi w`b `xcy I kxcy KZ…©K mivmwi Avnmvb Dj−vn gv÷vi‡K j¶¨
K‡i ¸wj Kiv m‡›`nvZxZfv‡e cÖgvb K‡i †h, gvndzRyi ingvb gnj‡K
nZ¨vi cvkvcwk Avnmvb Dj−vn gv÷vi‡KI nZ¨vi lohš¿ n‡qwQj| Avi GB
loh‡š¿i m‡PZb I mwµq Ask wQj byi“j Bmjvg miKvi Ges GB lohš¿
P~ovš— cwibwZ jvf K‡i w`ev‡jv‡K mfv ’‡j mk¯¿ mymsMwVZ Avµg‡bi
gva¨‡g ¸wj K‡i GjvKvi mevi wcÖq I mr ivRbxwZK Avnmvb Dj−vn
gv÷v‡ii g„Z y NUv‡bvi ga¨ w`‡q|
11
8. †Kvb NUbv ev Gi mv‡_ cÖvmswMK †Kvb NUbvi mg_©‡b cÖZ¨¶
mv¶¨ bvI _vK‡Z cv‡i| cÖwZfvZ Ae¯’v I cÖvmswMK †`vlven NUbv n‡Z G
m¤ú‡K©© ‰ea Abygvb MÖnb Kiv AvBb wm×| GB gvgjvi NUbv, Ae¯’vw` I
mv¶¨ cÖgvbvw` n‡Z GwU Aåvš—fv‡e cªZxqgvb nq †h, giKy‡Yi Avwg‡bi
evox‡Z Awfhy³iv hLb lohš¿g~jK ˆeVK KiwQj ZLbB Zviv NUbvi w`b
AvIqvgx †¯^”Qv‡meK jx‡Mi AbywôZe¨ mfv I H mfvq gvndyRyi ingvb
gnjmn A‡b‡KiB Dcw¯’Z _vKvi welqwU RvbZ| cieZx© NUbv cÖevn,
mv¶¨ I cÖwZfvZ Ae ’vw` n‡Z GwUB ˆeafve cÖZxqgvb nq|
9. mvavibZt †Kvb ivR‰bwZK `‡ji †Kvb mfv ev MYmgv‡ek
AbywôZ nIqvi welqwUmn mfvq †bZ…e„‡›`i AvMgb Ges mfv Abyôv‡bi
¯’vb I mgq ’vbxqfv‡e gvBwKs K‡i K‡qKw`b Av‡M †_‡KB RbMY‡K
AewnZ Kiv nq| Av‡jvP¨ nZ¨vKv‡Ûi NUbvwU N‡U‡Q w`ev‡jv‡K GKwU
ivR‰bwZK `‡ji Rbmgv‡e‡k| GLb cÖkœ n‡jv, GiKg GKwU Rbmfvq
†hLv‡b Avnmvb Dj−vn gv÷vi Ggwc , UsMx †cŠimfvi †gqi I Ab¨vb¨
AvIqvgx jx‡Mi †bZ…e„›`mn AvIqvgx jx‡Mi `jxq †bZv Kgx© I mvaviY
gvbyl Dcw¯’Z _vK‡eb GwU †R‡bI mvRvcÖvß Awfhy³iv †Kej gvndyRyi
ingvb gnj‡K nZ¨v Kivi Rb¨ H mfv¯’j †Kb †e‡Q †bq ev Zv‡`i j¶¨
wK †Kej gvndyRyi ingvb gnjB wQj ?
12
10. w`ev‡jv‡K mfv ’‡j wbwe©Pvi ¸wjel©b K‡i msMwVZ mk ¿
Avµgb cÖgvb K‡i †h, j¶¨ †Kej gvndzRyi ingvb gnj wQjbv|
AµgbKvix‡`i j¶¨ wQj gnj I Avnmvb Dj−vn gv÷vi mn Av‡iv A‡b‡Ki
cÖvY nvbx NUv‡bv| cÖKvk¨ w`ev‡jv‡K Rbmfv¯’‡j msNwUZ GB Avµgb
cwiPvjbvq Awfhy³iv †Kvb gyLveiYI (gv¯‹) e¨envi K‡iwb| GwU Afªvš—
fv‡e BswMZ K‡i †h, Aciva msNUbKvix wn‡m‡e wPwýZ nIqvi †Kvb fq
ev ksKv Zv‡`i wQjbv| Aciva msNU‡bi aiY , ¯’vb I mgq Ges
cvwicvwk¦©©K Ae¯’v wØavnxbfv‡e GB BswMZ †`q †h, Zviv wbwðZ wQj †h,
wPwýZ n‡jI `jxq myi¶vq I c„ô‡cvlKZvq Zviv AvB‡bi evB‡iB †_‡K
hv‡e| Zv‡`i GB AvPiY cÖgvb K‡i †h, Zviv KZUv †ec‡ivqv I mwnsm
wQj| Pig †ec‡ivqv Dk„sLj ivR‰bwZK `ye„©ËivB †Kej G ai‡bi kw³i
aviY I PPv© Ki‡Z cv‡i|
11. DwØMœZvi mv‡_ j¶¨ Kiv hvq †h, Avgv‡`i †`‡k ivR‰bwZK
`j¸‡jvi g‡a¨ G cÖK…„wZi ee©i Dk„sLjZvi AcPPv©Kvix `jxq Kgx©‡`i
cwinvi Kivi cÖeYZv †`Lv hvq bv| eis A‡bK †¶‡ÎB ivR‰bwZK
`j¸‡jv GB cÖK…wZi Dk„sLj Kgx©‡`i DciB wbf©ikxj hv wKbv †`‡k my ’
ivR‰bwZK ms¯‹…wZi weKvk I PP©vi c‡_ GK weivU Aš—ivq| Gi“c
ivR‰bwZK Acms¯‹…wZi PPv© Ae¨vnZ _vK‡j †`‡k AvB‡bi kvmb cÖwZôvq
13
¯’weiZv †`Lv ‡`‡e| mvgvwRK myi¶v ûgwKi gy‡L co‡e| gyL _ye‡o co‡e
Rbgvby‡li cÖZ¨vwkZ MYZš¿|
12. G gvgjvq ïay ee©i nZ¨vKv‡Ûi NUbv cÖwZdwjZ nqwb ,
ivRbxwZ wKfv‡e `ye„©ËvwqZ n‡q‡Q Ges Ggb ye©„Ëvqb wKfv‡e Aciva
msNUbKvix‡`i kw³ I mvnm †RvMvq †mwUI ¯úófv‡e cÖwZdwjZ n‡q‡Q|
A_P GwU A¯xKvi Kiv hvq bv †h, ivR‰bwZK `ye©…Ëvqb ‡`k‡K A_©‰bwZK,
mvgvwRK , ivR‰bwZK I mvs¯‹…wZKfv‡e aŸsm K‡i †`q| MYZ‡š¿i j¶¨B
n‡jv RbKj¨vb I gvbevwaKvi wbwðZ Kiv| Avi my ’ MYZš¿ Av‡m †Kej
my ’ ivR‰bwZK aviv I PPv©i c_ a‡i -- †Kvbfv‡eB Gi ye„©Ëvq‡bi c_
a‡i bq|
13. †Kvb wØav QvovB ZvB ejv hvq †h, hviv ivRbxwZ‡K ev †`‡ki
ivR‰bwZK cwi‡ek‡K KjywlZ K‡ib, `ye„©Ëvq‡bi Ave‡Z© †V‡j w`‡Z
DrmvwnZ K‡ib ZvivB ivR‰bwZK `ye„©Ë‡`i wk‡ivgwb| †`k hLb µ‡gB
A_©‰bwZKfv‡e ¯vej¤x n‡q DV‡Q, MYZš¿ cÖwZôvi ¯v‡_© mK‡jiB hLb
wbweó nIqv DwPZ †mB mg‡q ivRbxwZ‡Z GB ai‡bi `ye„©Ëvqb †Kvbfv‡eB
KvswLZ bq| `ye„©ËvwqZ ivRbxwZ †`k‡K aŸsm Qvov Ab¨ †Kvb Mš—‡e¨ wb‡q
†h‡Z cv‡ibv| G cÖms‡M Justice Dipak Misra KZ…©K Krishna
Murthi vs. Siva Kumar kxl©K gvgjvq cÖ Ë GB ch©‡e¶YwU
cÖwYavb‡hvM¨ t
14
Any kind of criminalization of politics is an
extremely lamentable situation. It is an
anathema to the sanctity of democracy. The
criminalization creates a concavity in the heart
of democracy and has the potentiality to
paralyze, comatose and strangulate purity of
the system. [(2015) 3 SCC 467 Para 33].
14. mvRvcÖvß Awfhy³ byi“j Bmjvg miKv‡ii Uv‡M©U wQj gvndyRyi
ingvb gnj Ges Rbve Avnmvb Dj−vn gv÷vi Df‡qB| mv¶x‡`i mv¶¨
n‡Z GwU ¯úófv‡e cvIqv hvq †h, gnj wQj byi“j Bmjvg miKv‡ii
e¨emvwqK cªwZØ›`x , Avi Avnmvb Dj−vn gv÷vi wQ‡jb Zvi Ges Zvi
cwiev‡ii ivR‰bwZK cÖwZØ›`x| Ggb ˆeixZvi m~Î a‡iB lohš¿ Ges
AZtci cÖKvk¨ Rbmfvq Avµgb| Awfbœ Avµgb Pvwj‡q Rbmfvq
Dcw ’Z `yÕRb‡K c„w_ex †_‡K mwi‡q w`‡q GK wX‡j yB cvLx gvivi
my‡hvMwU byi“j Bmjvg miKvi nvZQvov Ki‡Z Pvbwb| ZvB wZwb Zvi
‡`vlven Kg© I Acivag~jK AvPi‡Yi cwibwZ †R‡bB Zvi msMx‡`i‡K
DrmvwnZ K‡i‡Qb hv cÖKvivš—‡i wbg©g nZ¨vKvÛ msNU‡bi Ôwb‡ ©kÕ cÖ v‡bi
bvgvš—i| mvRvcÖvß Awfhy³ byi“j Bmjvg miKvi wb‡R‡K ÔwKwjs wgk‡biÕ
I nZ¨vKv‡Ûi †nvZv ev Ôgv÷vi gvBÛÕ wn‡m‡e cÖgvb K‡i‡Qb| Zvi GB
Acivag~jK Kg©Kv†Ûi cwibwZ‡ZB yÕRb wb‡`v©l gvbyl Zvu‡`i Rxeb
nvwi‡q‡Qb Ges Rbmfvq Dcw¯’Z AmsL¨ gvbyl c½yZ¡¡ eiY K‡i‡Qb|
Avµg‡bi wfKwUg gvndzRyi ingvb gnj c½y‡Z¡i Rxeb hvcb Ki‡Qb, Zvui
15
kix‡ii wbævsk GLb Aek| cÖvK…wZK wµqvKg© wbR wbqš¿‡b ivL‡Z
cv‡ibbv| wK AgvbweK wbg©gZvi cÖwZdjbB bv N‡U‡Q w`ev‡jv‡K H
mymsMwVZ Avµg‡bi gva¨‡g !
15. ‡h ’v‡b I †hfv‡e nZ¨vKvÛwU msNwUZ n‡q‡Q †mwU‡K GK
K_vq ejv P‡j c~e©cwiKwíZ Ôe¨vcK nZ¨vKvÛÕ ev Ôgvm wKwjsÕ| NUbv ’‡j
Rbmfv PjvKv‡j GKB& mg‡q wZb w`K †_‡K Pvjv‡bv mk¯¿ Avµg‡b
mfv ’‡j Dcw¯’Z A‡bK ‡jvK g„Z yeiY Ki‡Z cviZ| †hLv‡b †Kvb
Aicvag~jK Kg©KvÛ Øviv bxwin gvbyl nZ¨vi D‡Ï&‡k¨ wbi ¿ Rbmfv ev
Rbmg‡e‡k Avµgb Pvjv‡bvi Kvi‡Y hw` AmsL¨ gvbyl wbnZ nIqvi
AvksKv wQj e‡j †`Lv hvq Ges H Avµg‡b hw` GKRb gvbylI wbnZ nb
Z‡e H cÖK…wZi nZ¨vKvÛ Aek¨B Ôe¨vcK nZ¨vKvÛÕ ev ‘Mass Killing’.
wbtm‡›`‡n ejv hvq †h, byi“j Bmjvg miKvi, byi“j Bmjvg `xcy Ms GB
‘Mass Killing’ Gi Rb¨ mivmwi `vqx| Avµg‡b cÖZ¨¶ Ask bv wb‡jI
†h‡nZz, H Avµgb Acivag~jK lohš¿ I cwiKíbvi cwibwZ Ges †h‡nZz,
byi“j Bmjvg miKvi I Ab¨iv loh‡š¿i mwµq I m‡PZb Ask †m‡nZz,
byii“j Bmjvg miKviI msNwUZ ‘Mass Killing’Gi Rb¨ mgfv‡e I
mivmwi `vqx|
16. cÖwmwKDkb c‡¶i mv¶x‡`i mv¶¨ I Ab¨vb¨ `vwjwjK mv¶¨
chv©‡jvPbvq †`Lv hvq †h, Acivag~jK loh‡š¿i mv‡_ AvmvgxM‡Yi
16
m¤ú„³Zv m‡›`nvZxZfv‡e cÖgvwbZ n‡q‡Q| Avi GB loh‡š¿i m~Î a‡i
AvmvgxMY NUbv¯’j Rbmfv ’‡j mymsMwVZ Avµgb Pvwj‡q mfv ’‡j
Dcw ’Z Avnmvb Dj−vn gv÷vi I Igi dvi“K iZb‡K nZ¨v K‡i Ges
AvG“g‡bi d‡j A‡bK gvbyl nb gvivZ¥Kfv‡e AvnZ| Aek¨B GwU †Kvb
AvKw¯§K Avµgb wQjbv| mv¶¨ cÖgvbvw` n‡Z D‡V Avmv mvwe©K NUbv GB
AcÖwZ‡iva¨ wm×v‡š— Avm‡Z mvnvh¨ K‡i †h, w`ev‡jv‡K GKwU Rbmgv‡e‡k
GB Ôe¨vcK nZ¨vKvÛÕ ev ‘Mass Killing’ Gi mv‡_ Acivag~jK
loh‡š¿i I cwiKíbvi †hvMm~Î wQj †hwUi mwµq Ask I gv÷vigvBÛ wQj
mvRvcÖvß Awfhy³ byi“j Bmjvg miKvi|
17. hyw³ZK© ïbvbxKv‡j AvmvgxMY c‡¶ GB g‡g© eËe¨ ivLv nq
†h, cÖwmwKDkb c‡¶i mv¶xMY †dŠR`vix Kvh©wewai 161 avivq cÖ Ë
Zv‡`i e³e¨ †_‡K m‡i G‡m wePviKv‡j AmvgÄm¨c~Y© e³e¨ w`‡q‡Qb Ges
GKBmv‡_ ‡dŠR`vix Kvh©wewai 161 avivq cÖ Ë Zv‡`i e³‡e¨i cªwZ `„wó
AvKl©Y K‡i mv‡Rkb w`‡q Rvevbew›`‡Z cÖ`Ë e³e¨ †_‡K mv¶x‡`i
mwi‡q †bqv n‡q‡Q| wecix‡Z G cÖms‡M cÖwmwKDkbc‡¶i AvBbRxexMY
AIR 1932 Calcuta Page 375 Gi Emperor vs.
Karimuddin Sheikh and others †gvKÏgvi wm×vš— D×…Z K‡ib
†hLv‡b ejv n‡q‡Q †h, suggestion by pleader do not amount to
evidence unless same is accepted by the witness.
17
18. mvRvcÖvß Awfhy³ byi“j Bmjvg miKvi c‡¶ weÁ
AvBbRxexMY hyw³ZK© Dc¯’vbKv‡j GB g‡g© e³e¨ iv‡Lb †h, byi“j Bmjvg
miKv‡ii wei“‡× AvbxZ Awf‡hvMwU Ôm‡›`nvZxZfv‡eÕ cÖgvwbZ nqwb|
KviY byi“j Bmjvg miKvi Awfhy³ `xcy I kxcy‡K Avnmvb Dj−vn gv÷vi
nZ¨vKv‡Û cÖ‡ivwPZ K‡iwQ‡jb ev Drmvn w`‡qwQ‡jb †m g‡g© †Kvb mv¶x
ev`xc¶ Dc ’vcb Ki‡Z cv‡iwb| †hnZz, GB Awf‡hvMwU m‡›`nvZxZfv‡e
cÖgvwbZ nqwb †m‡nZz, mvRvcÖvß AcxjKvix byi“j Bmjvg miKvi Ô‡ewbwdU
Ae WvDUÕ ev m‡›`‡ni myweav †c‡Z AwaKvix|
19. Avmvgxc‡¶i Dc‡iv³ e³e¨ †gv‡UI MÖnb‡hvM¨ bq| KviY
cvwicvwk¦©K Ae ’vw` cÖgvb K‡i †h, g~j NUbv Z_v nZ¨vKv‡Ûi NUbvi mv‡_
loh‡š¿i †hvMm~Î ev Ô†b·vmÕ wQj e‡j cÖgvwbZ n‡q‡Q| Acivag~jK
lohš¿ †Kvb `„k¨gvb welq bq| GwU †Mvc‡bB iwPZ nq -- KvD‡K mv¶x
†i‡L bq| ZvB GwU ejvi †Kvb my‡hvM †bB †h, GBi“c Acivag~jK KvR
iwPZ Kivi welqwU AeavwiZfv‡e cÖZ¨¶ mv¶¨ ØvivB cÖvgwbZ n‡Z n‡e|
Acivag~jK loh‡š¿i welqwU GgbwK †Kvb wbw`©ó gvgjvq cÖwZfvZ g~j
Aciv‡ai mv‡_ m¤úwK©Z †Kvb Ae¯’v I cÖvmswMK NUbv ev NUbvmg~‡ni
Av‡jv‡KI Abygvb Kiv AvBb wm×| yB ev Z‡ZvwaK e¨w³i GgbwK †Kej
GKwU gvÎ Acivag~jK KvR ev AvPiY ev K_v n‡ZI GwU ˆeafv‡e Abygvb
18
Kiv †h‡Z cv‡i †h, Zv‡`i g‡a¨ ‡Kvb †eAvBbx KvR ev Aciva msNU‡b
g‰ZK¨ wQj hv cÖKvivš—‡i Ô Acivag~jK loh‡š¿iÕ bvgvš—i|
20. mvRvcÖvß Awfhy³ `xcy I kxcy NUbv¯’‡j wbwe©Pv‡i ¸wj K‡i
nZ¨vKvÛ msNwUZ K‡i GwU cÖgvwbZ| NUbvi c~‡e© Hw`b Awfhy³ byi“j
Bmjvg miKvi mvRvcÖvß `xcy I kxcy‡K wbR Mvox‡Z K‡i bvwg‡q †`q Ges
Zvi †`vlven AvPiY Øviv Zv‡`i‡K Drmvn I cÖ‡ivPbv w`‡qwQj hv
cÖgvwbZ| B‡Zvg‡a¨B e‡jwQ †h, mv¶¨ I cÖwZfvZ Ae¯’vw` n‡Z GwU
¯úófv‡e cÖgvwbZ †h, byi“j Bmjvg miKvi Acivag~jK loh‡š¿i
Ôgv÷vigvBÛÕ| G Kvi‡Y g~j Aciva msNU‡b Zvi Õculpable
instigation, encouragement and facilitation’ GgbwK
nZ¨vK‡Ûi NUbvqI Zvi AskMÖnb‡KB [Particpation] cÖgvb K‡i|
21. Avmvgx AvcxjKvix byi“j Bmjvg miKvi c‡¶ wbhyw³q weÁ
wmwbqi AvBbRxex Rbve wU.GBP.Lvb, Rbve G.‡R †gvn¤§` Avjx Ges
Bp¡j£ BCu¤h Bm£, e¤l¦m B¢je Jl−g B¢je Hhw ®m¡Lj¡e ®q¡−pe
Jl−g h¤m¤l c‡¶ wbhyw³q weÁ wmwbqi AvBbRxex Rbve †Lv›`Kvi gvneye
†nv‡mb Awfbœ hyw³i cÖwZaŸwb K‡i e‡jb †h, AvmvgxMY m‡›`‡ni myweav
†c‡Z AwaKvivx | KviY wn‡m‡e Zvuiv GB cÖev‡`i cÖwZ `„wó AvKl©Y K‡ib
†h, ÒAv`vjZ‡K †`L‡Z n‡e kZ Awfhy³ Qvov †c‡jI †Kvb wb‡`v©l e¨w³
†hb †Kvbfv‡e mvRv bv cvbÓ|
19
22. Dc‡iv³ e³‡e¨i wecix‡Z State of Panjab vs. Karnail
Singh (2003) 11 SCC 271, para 12 G cÖKvwkZ gvgjvq Justice
Arijit Pasaayat Gi wb¤œewY©Z ch©‡e¶YwU cÖwYavb‡hvM¨ t
Exaggerated devotion to the rule of benefit of
doubt must not nurture fanciful doubts or
lingering suspicion and thereby destroy social
defence. Justice cannot be made sterile on the
plea that it is better to let hundred guilty
escape than punish an innocent. Letting guilty
escape is not doing justice according to law.
23. wePvicwZ W. cvQv‡q‡Zi GB ch©‡e¶‡Yi mv‡_ Avwg m¤ú~Y©
GKgZ †cvlY KiwQ| GB cÖms‡M Sate of UP vs. Anil Singh,
1988 Supp SCC 686, para 17 G weÁ wPviK K. Jagannatah
Shetty cÖ Ë ch©‡e¶YwUI D‡j−L‡hvM¨fv‡e cªwYavb‡hvM¨ hv wb¤œi“c t
It is necessary to remember that a judge
does not preside over a criminal trial
merely to see that no innocent man is
punished. A judge also presides to see
that a guilty man does not escape. One
is importanmt as the other. Both are
public duties which the judge has to
perform.
24. weÁ wePvi‡Ki mv‡_ GKgZ †cvlY K‡i ïay GUzKz ej‡Z PvB
†h, †Kvb wb‡`vl© e¨w³ †hb A‡nZzK mvRv †fvM bv K‡ib GwU †`Lvi
20
cvkvcvwk GwUI †`L‡Z n‡e †hb †Kvb †`vlx e¨w³ GgbwK †Kvb fanciful
doubts Gi ARynv‡Z AvB†bi dvuK w`‡q †ewi‡q bv hvq| mvgvwRK
myi¶vi ¯v‡_©B welqwU g‡b ivLv Awbevh© |
25. GB gvgjvq miKvic¶ mv¶¨ cÖgvbvw` Øviv †h mKj Avmvgxi
wei“‡× AvbxZ Awf‡hvM cÖgvb Ki‡Z cv‡iwb g‡g© cÖZxqgvb n‡q‡Q Zv‡`i
cÖwZ wb¤œ A`vjZ cÖ Ë mvRv evwZj K‡i Zv‡`i Lvjv‡mi Av‡`k cÖ vb
K‡iwQ| wVK †Zgwbfv‡e Avmvgxc‡¶i weÁ AvBbRxexM‡bi AbyK¤úv
cÖ k©‡bi wb‡e`bI MÖnb Kwiwb| GwU mZ¨ †h, mvRvcÖvß AvmvgxMY
A‡b‡KB `xN© 10/12 ermi hver Kvivevm Ki‡Qb | wKš‘ Dc¯’vwcZ mv¶¨
cÖgv‡b hw` Awf‡hvM cÖgvwbZ nq Ges Awf‡hv‡Mi e¨vcKZv hw` fqven nq
Z‡e †m‡¶‡Î Abyi“c Kvivevm †`vlx Awfhy³‡K AbyK¤úv cÖ k©‡bi †Kvb
KviY wn‡m‡e we‡ePbvq †bqv mgxPxb I †hŠw³K bq| †Kvb A‡hŠw³K
ARynv‡Z G ai‡bi AbyK¤úv cÖ k©b cÖKvivš—‡i b¨vq wePv‡ii avibv Ges
wePvi e¨e ’v m¤ú‡K© Rbg‡b fzj evZv© †`q| G‡¶‡Î State of MP
vs. Surendra Singh (2015) 1 SCC 222, para 13 Gi gvgjvq
Justice M.Y Eqbal GK ch©‡e¶‡Y e‡jb †h,
Undue sympathy to impose inadequate
sentence would do more harm to the
justice system to undermine the public
confidence in the efficacy of law. It is
21
the duty of every court to award proper
sentence having regard to the nature of
the offence and the manner in which it
was executed or committed.
26. weÁ wePvi‡Ki GB ch©‡e¶‡Yi mv‡_ Avwg m¤ú~Y© GKgZ
†cvlb K‡i ej‡Z PvB †h, RNb¨ loh‡š¿i gva¨‡g w`ev‡jv‡K cÖKvk¨
Rbmfvq mymsMwVZ Avµgb Pvwj‡q Avnmvb Dj−vn gv÷vi Ges iZ‡bi
nZ¨vKvÛ msNwUZ n‡q‡Q Ges GB welq¸‡jv we‡ePbvq †`vlx mve¨ ’
Awfhy³‡`i cÖwZ AbyK¤úv cÖ k©‡bi †Kvb †hŠw³K AeKvk †bB|
27. GwU wew`Z †h, Avnmvb Dj−vn gv÷vi Rxe‡bi ïi“‡Z wQ‡jb
GKRb wk¶K| cieZx©‡Z cÖavb wk¶K Ges GKRb wbev©wPZ RbcÖwZwbwa|
BDwbqb cwil‡`i †Pqvig¨vb †_‡K ïi“ K‡i Dc‡Rjv cwil‡`i †Pqvig¨vb
Ges me‡k‡l RvZxq msm‡`i GKRb m`m¨ wn‡m‡e GKvwaKevi wbev©wPZ
n‡qwQ‡jb| GjvKvq wZwb wQ‡jb `jgZ wbwe©‡k‡l mK‡ji wcÖq I
kÖ×vfvRb e¨w³Z¡ | msm` m`m¨ wnm‡e RbKj¨v‡b wZwb cvjb K‡i‡Qb
Zvui cweÎ ¸i“ `vwqZ¡ | wZwb UsMx MvRxcyi GjvKvq gv`K we‡ivax cÖPvibv
Ges Kvh©µ‡g wQ‡jb m‡Pó | mv¶x‡`i mv¶¨ n‡ZI cvIqv hvq †h,
Rxe‡bi †kl gyn~‡Z©I gv`K e¨emvqx Z_v mš¿vmx‡`i wbg~©‡j Zuvi KÚ wQj
†mv”Pvi| ivRbxwZi AsM‡b GgbB GK wb®‹jyl I RbKj¨v‡b m`v D`¨gx
GKRb gvbyl‡K nZ¨v Kiv nq| mgvR nvivq GK w`K wb‡`©kK‡K| GKB
22
mv‡_ Zvu‡K nZ¨vi ga¨ w`‡q Zvui ¿x‡K ¯vgxi fvjevmv †_‡K, mš—vb‡`i
wcZ…‡ø&n †_‡KI ewÂZ Kiv nq| nZ¨vKv‡Û wbnZ Igi dvi“K iZb‡K
nZ¨vi ga¨ w`‡q ‡`‡ki fwel¨Z KvÛvix Zvi“b¨‡K Pig AvNvZ Kiv nq|
Avnmvb Dj−vn gv÷vi †eu‡P _vK‡j Av&Bb mfvq Ae`vb ivLvi gva¨‡g
RbKj¨v‡b wb‡ew`Z nIqvi Av‡iv my‡hvM †c‡Zb, Ki‡Z cvi‡Zb Av‡iv
A‡bK myKg©| mgvR I RvwZ n‡Z cviZ Av‡iv DcK…Z| mvRvcÖvß
Awfhy³iv Avnmvb Dj−vn gv÷vi‡K nZ¨vi ga¨ w`‡q mgvR, RvwZ I
GjvKvi gvbyl‡K mg„w×i c‡a nvuUvi †mB my‡hvM †_‡K ewÂZ K‡i‡Q|
e¨w³‡K nZ¨vi cvkvcvwk nZ¨v Kiv n‡q‡Q Av`k©‡K, ˆbwZK D`¨g‡K|&
AvR‡Ki mgv‡R Avnmvb Dj−vn gv÷v‡ii g‡Zv Av`k©evb ivRbxwZ‡Ki
eoB Afve|
28. Avnmvb Dj−vn gv÷v‡ii ¯¿x , cyÎ , ¯Rb †hgb GB wbg©g
nZ¨vKv‡Ûi wePvi Pvb wVK GKB fv‡e NUbvq wbnZ Igi dvi“K iZ‡bi
wcZv-gvZv , ¯R‡bivI wePvi cÖZ¨vkx| Avevi 2005 mv‡ji 16 GwcÖj `ª“Z
wePvi UªvBeybvj-1 KZ…©K ivq cÖ v‡bi w`b †_‡K ev Zvi ci †_‡K ‡h
mvRvcÖvß Awfhy³iv KvivMv‡i Av‡Qb ZvivI b¨vq wePvi cÖZ¨vkx| wKš‘
NUbv Z_v nZ¨vKv‡Ûi aib, ¯’vb I e¨vcKZv Ges mv¶¨ cÖgvbvw`i
Av‡jv‡K GB nZ¨vKv‡Ûi mv‡_ †`vlx mve¨ ’ Awfhy³‡`i m¤ú„³Zv I
Ab¨vb¨ cÖvmswMK welqvw` GK‡Î we‡ePbvq Avgiv G&B ivq cª vb Kijvg|
23
GB gvgjvq mvRv cÖ v‡bi †¶‡Î aggravating circumstances Gi
cÖ‡qvRbxq Dcv`vb wn‡m‡e Awfhy³‡`i A‰bwZK cÖZvc I Ae ’vb, NUbvi
mv‡_ Zv‡`i m¤ú„³Zvi e¨vcKZv I mv¶x‡`i mv¶¨ I cÖvmswMK welqvw`
GK‡Î we‡ePbvq wb‡q wm÷vi wePvicwZ K…òv †`ebv_ †h we¯—vwiZ ivq
cÖ vb K‡i‡Qb Zvi mv‡_ Avwg m¤ú~b© GKgZ †cvlb KiwQ|
¢hQ¡lf¢a L«o·¡ ®che¡b.
−g±Sc¡l£ L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 374 d¡l¡l ¢hd¡ej−a HC ®Xb ®lg¡−l¾p¢V Bp¡j£
1) e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l, 2) e¤l¦m Cpm¡j ¢cf¤, 3) ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£, 4) j¡qh¤h¤l
lqj¡e j¡qh¤h, 5) B¢jl, 6) °puc Bq−jc jSe¤, 7) S¡q¡‰£l Jl−g hs
S¡q¡‰£l, ¢fa¡- e§l ®q¡−pe NZ−L cä¢h¢dl 302/120M/34 d¡l¡u Hhw 8)
n¢qc¤m Cpm¡j ¢nf¤, 9) q¡¢gS Jl−g L¡e¡ q¡¢gS, 10) B−e¡u¡l ®q¡−pe Jl−g
Be¤, 11) gup¡m, 12) ®p¡q¡N Jl−g pl¦, 13) ®m¡Lj¡e ®q¡−pe Jl−g h¤m¤,
14) Bm-B¢je, 15) lae ¢ju¡ Jl−g hs ¢ju¡, 16) l¢Z ¢ju¡ Jl−g l¢Z
g¢Ll, 17) S¡q¡‰£l, ¢fa¡- L¡−nj j¡chl, 18) lae Jl−g ®R¡V lae, 19)
Bh¤ p¡m¡j Jl−g p¡m¡j, 20) j¢nEl lqj¡e Jl−g jö, 21) ®M¡Le Hhw 22)
c¤m¡m ¢ju¡ NZ−L cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u â¦a ¢hQ¡l VÊ¡Ch¤Ée¡m-1, Y¡L¡l ¢h‘
¢hQ¡lL fÐcš jªa¥Écä¡−cn Q§s¡¿¹Ll−Zl SeÉ EfÙÛ¡fe Ll¡ qu, k¡ öe¡e£ ®n−o
l¡u fÐc¡−el SeÉ ®eu¡ qmz
24
A¢i−k¡−Nl pw¢rç ¢hhlZ x
A¢i−k¡−Nl pw¢rç ¢hhlZ HC −k, Cw 07/05/2004 a¡¢lM ®l¡S
öœ²h¡l ®hm¡ Ae¤j¡e 10.00 O¢VL¡l pju VwN£ ®f±l Hm¡L¡l −ey¡u¡N¡J Hj.H.
j¢Sc EµQ ¢hcÉ¡mu j¡−W VwN£ b¡e¡ BJu¡j£ ®üµR¡−phL m£−Nl 10 ew Ju¡−XÑl
¢œh¡¢oÑL p−Çjme Qm¡L¡−m Ae¤ù¡−el ®no fkÑ¡−u ®hm¡ Ae¤j¡e 12.35 ¢j¢e−Vl
pju p−ÇjmeÙÛm ®b−L HS¡q¡lL¡l£ ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡epq AeÉ¡eÉ pL−m
pi¡ÙÛm aÉ¡N Ll¡l j¤q§−aÑ Bp¡j£ 1) e¤l¦m Cpm¡j ¢cf¤, 2) n¢qc¤m Cpm¡j ¢nf¤,
3) A¢qc¤m Cpm¡j ¢Vf¤, 4) q¡¢gS Jl−g L¡e¡ q¡¢gS, 5) B−e¡u¡l ®q¡−pe
Be¤, 6) gup¡m, 7) −p¡q¡N Jl−g pl¦, 8) h¤m¤ ¢ju¡, 9) Bm B¢je, (10) lae
¢ju¡, (11) l¢e, (12) −p¡−qm, (13) ¯puc Bq¡Çjc jSe¤, (14) j¡q¡h¤h, (15)
j¢el, (16) c¤m¡m, (17) S¡q¡‰£l pq A‘¡ae¡j¡ 10/12 Se ®m¡L Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m
Cpm¡j ¢cf¤l ®ea«−aÅ B−NÀu¡−Ù» p¢‹a q−u …¢m Ll−a Ll−a pi¡ÙÛ−ml ¢c−L
B−pz
Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j ¢cf¤, nq£c¤m Cpm¡j ¢nf¤ HS¡q¡lL¡l£l hs i¡C
Bqp¡eEõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f®L mrÉ L−l Efk¤Ñf¢l …¢m L−lz …¢m¢hÜ q−u
Bqp¡eEõ¡q j¡ø¡l j¡¢V−a m¤¢V−u f−sz Afl¢c−L AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl …¢m−a
pi¡ÙÛ−m j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm, q¡−pj j¢õL, nl£g E¢Ÿe BL¡n, S¡j¡m
®q¡−pe, h¡cm f¡−V¡u¡l£, ®M¡l−nc Bmj, h¡h¤mpq pq ®j¡V 10/12 Se Bqa
quz Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f®L Y¡L¡l p¢Çj¢ma p¡j¢lL q¡pf¡a¡−m ®eu¡
q−m X¡š²¡ll¡ a¡−L jªa ®O¡oZ¡ L−lz H pju Jjl g¡l¦L laeJ jªa¥ÉhlZ L−lz
HS¡q¡lL¡l£ ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e a¡l HS¡q¡−l E−õM L−le ®k, S¡a£ua¡h¡c£
25
k¤hc−ml ®L¾cУu ®ea¡ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l Hl f§hÑ f¢lLÒfe¡ j−a a¡lC f¡¢ma
pnÙ» p¿»¡p£−cl ¢c−u HC qaÉ¡L¡ä¢V OV¡−e¡ q®u−Rz
ac¿¹L¡l£ LjÑLaÑ¡l c¡¢MmL«a Q¡SÑn£Vx
ac¿¹L¡l£ LjÑLaÑ¡ A¢i−k¡−Nl ac¿¹ ®n−o A¢ik¤š² (1) e¤l¦m Cpm¡j
¢cf¤, (2) n¢qc¤m Cpm¡j ¢nf¤, (3) A¢qc¤m Cpm¡j ¢Vf¤, (4) q¡¢gS Jl−g L¡e¡
q¡¢gS, (5) B−e¡u¡l ®q¡−pe Jl−g Be¤, (6) gup¡m, (7) ®p¡q¡N Jl−g pl¦,
(8) ®m¡Lj¡e ®q¡−pe Jl−g h¤m¤, (9) Bm B¢je, (10) lae ¢ju¡ Jl−g lae
Jl−g hs ¢ju¡, (11) l¢Z ¢ju¡ Jl−g l¢Z g¢Ll, (12) ¯puc Bq−jc jSe¤,
(13) S¡q¡wN£l, ¢fa¡- L¡−nj j¡chl, (14) lae Jl−g ®R¡V lae, (15) Bh¤
p¡m¡j Jl−g p¡m¡j, (16) j¢nEl lqj¡e Jl−g jö, (17) ®M¡Le, (18)
S¡q¡wN£l Jl−g hs S¡q¡wN£l Jl−g juje¢pwN¡ S¡q¡wN£l, ¢fa¡- e§l ®q¡−pe,
(19) B¢jl, (20) S¡q¡wN£l, ¢fa¡- ®j−ql Bm£, (21) e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l,
(22) ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£, (23) l¡¢Lh E¢Ÿe plL¡l Jl−g f¡è¤ plL¡l, (24) e¤l¦m
Bj£e Jl−g Bj£e, (25) BCk¤h Bm£, (26) j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h, (27)
j¢el, (28) c¤m¡m ¢ju¡, (29) L¢hl ®q¡−pe Hhw (30) Bh¤ q¡uc¡l h¡h¤ Jl−g
¢jlf¤Cl¡ h¡h¤N−Zl ¢hl¦−Ü cä¢h¢dl 120M/324/326/307/302/34/109/212
d¡l¡u A¢i−k¡Nfœ c¡¢Mm L−lz A¢i−k¡Nf−œ qaÉ¡L¡−äl
Motive/L¡lZ/E−ŸnÉ pÇf−LÑ E−õM Ll¡ qu −k, HL¢c−L l¡S¯e¢aL fÊ¢afr
Afl¢c−L A¯hd j¡cL hÉhp¡u h¡d¡ c¡e Ll¡u e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l, e¤l¦m
Cpm¡j ¢cf¤ J n¢qc¤m Cpm¡j ¢nf¤pq AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl ¢e−u HL¢c−L j¡qg¥S¤l
26
lqj¡e jqm−L qaÉ¡l SeÉ osk¿» L−l, AeÉ¢c−L p¡wpc Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l−L
HLC p¤−k¡−N M¤e Ll¡l f¢lLÒfe¡ L−lz
A¢ik¤š²−cl ¢hl¦−Ü N¢Wa Q¡SÑ x
Avmvgx (1) e¤l¦m Bmjvg ¢`cy (cjvZK), (2) n¢q`yj Bmjvg wkcy
(cjvZK), (3) Awn yj Bmjvg wUcy (cjvZK) (4) nvwdR Ii‡d Kvbv nvwdR
(cjvZK) (5) Av‡bvqvi †nvm‡b Ii‡d Avby (cjvZK), (6) dqmvj (cjvZK),
(7) †mvnvM Ii‡d ml¦ (fm¡aL) (8) †jvKgvb †nv‡mb Ii‡d eym¤ (cjvZK)
(9) Avj-Avwgb (cjvZK) (10) iZb wgqv Ii‡d eo wgqv (cjvZK) (11) iwb
wgqv Ii‡d iwb dwKi (cjvZK) (12) ˆmq` Avn−j` gRby (cjvZK) (13)
Rvnv½xi, wcZv- Kv‡kg gv`ei (cjvZK) (14) iZb Ii‡d †QvU iZb
(cjvZK), (15) Avey mvjvg Ii‡d p¡m¡j (cjvZK) (16) j¢nEl ingvb Ii‡d
gï (cjvZK), (17) †LvKb (cjvZK), (18) Rvnv½xi Ii‡d eo Rvnv½xi
Ii‡d gqgbwmsMv Rvnv½xi, wcZv- b~i †nv‡mb (Dcw ’Z), (19) Avwgl
(Dcw ’Z) (20) Rvnv½xi, wcZv −j−ql Avjx (Dcw ’Z) (21) e¤l¦m Cpm¡j
miKvi (Dcw ’Z) (22) †gvn¤§` Avjx (Dcw ’Z) (23) ivwKe DwÏb miKvi
Ii‡d cvày miKvi (Dcw ’Z), (24) e¤l¦m Avwgb Ii‡d Avwgb (Dcw ’Z), 25)
AvBqye Avjx (Dcw ’Z), (26) gvneyeyi ingvb gvneye (Dcw ’Z), (27) j¢el
(Dcw ’Z), (28) `yjvj wgqv (Dcw ’Z), (29) Kwei †nv‡mb (Dcw ’Z) Ges
(30) Avey nvq`vi evey Ii‡d wgicyBiv evey (cjvZK) Hl ¢hl¦−Ü
----------------AvmvgxMY
27
1-28 b¤i AvmvgxMY c~e© nœ¦a¡ekZ ci¯úi ‡hvMmvR‡k GKB
D‡Ï‡k¨ wbnZ Avnmvb Eõ¡q gvóvi (Gg.wc) I gvndzRyi ingvb gnjÕ‡K nZ¨v
Kivi Rb¨ cwiKíbv I Aciva g~jK lohš¿ K‡i‡Q|
HC lohš¿, cwiKíbv I ûKz−j MZ 07.05.04 Bs Zvwi‡L 12.35 wg¢eV
Hl mgq MvRxcyi †Rjvi UsMx _vbvi A¿¹NÑa †bvqvMuvI Gg, Gg gwR` D”P
we`¨vj‡qi gv‡V †¯”Qv†meK jxM Gi m‡¤§jb Efm−rÉ Av‡qvwRZ mfvg‡Â
Efk¤Ñf¢l ¸wj K‡i Avnmvb Eõ¡q gvóvi Gg,wcÕ‡K nZ¨v f§hÑL
cÖ_gZt `Ûwewa 120-L/302/34 avivq
¢àa£uax GKB fv‡e D³ mgq D³ NUbv ’‡j Dcw ’Z wfKwUg iZb‡K
¸wj K‡i nZ¨v K‡i `Ûwewai 120-L/302/34 avivq
Z…Zxqa t HC mgq NUbv ’‡jl g‡Â Dcw ’Z (1) gvndzRyi ingvb gnj
(2) evejy (3) †Lvi‡k` Avjg (4) nv‡mg j¢õL (5) kixd DwÏb AvKvk (6)
Rvgvj †nv‡mb (7) ev`j cv‡UvqvixÕ‡K nZ¨vi D‡Ï‡k¨ ¸wj K‡i i³v³ RLg
K‡i `Ûwewal 120-L/307/34 avivq
Ges
Avmvgx (29) Kwei J (30) Avey nvq`vi evey Ii‡d wgicyBiv evey
cjvZK Avmvgx‡`i AvkÖq w`‡q `wÛwewa 212 avivq n¡¢Ù¹ −k¡NÉ Aciva K‡i‡Q
j−jÑ ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma Q¡SÑ NWe L−le Hhw fÐL¡nÉ Bc¡m−a f−s öe¡ez
Ef¢ÙÛa Bp¡j£l¡ ¢e−S−cl ¢e−cÑ¡o c¡h£−a ¢hQ¡l fСbÑe¡ L−lz
Ef¢ÙÛa p¡r£−cl Sh¡eh¾c£ J ®Sl¡l p¡lpw−rfx
28
P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e HC j¡jm¡l HS¡q¡lL¡l£z ¢a¢e Cw
07/05/2004 a¡¢lM ®l¡S öœ²h¡l ®hm¡ Ae¤j¡e 12.35 ¢j¢e−V pwO¢Va OVe¡u
Cw 08/05/2004 a¡¢lM ®hm¡ 23.45 ¢j¢e−Vl pj−u VwN£ b¡e¡u fÐcnÑe£-1
¢Q¢q²a HS¡q¡l¢V c¡−ul L−lez HC p¡r£ Bc¡m−a HS¡q¡l h¢ZÑa ¢hhlZ E−õ−M
h−me ®k, OVe¡l ¢ce VwN£ b¡e¡ BJu¡j£ ®üµR¡−phL m£−Nl 10 ew Ju¡−XÑl
¢œh¡¢oÑL p−Çjme ¢Rmz HC pi¡ pL¡m Ae¤j¡e 10.00 O¢VL¡l ¢c−L öl¦ quz
pi¡u fÐd¡e A¢a¢b ¢R−me p¡r£l hs i¡C ¢eqa Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢fz
pi¡f¢aaÅ L−le j¤¢Shl lqj¡e z j−’ B−l¡ Ef¢ÙÛa ¢R−me VwN£ ®f±l ®jul
HÉ¡X−i¡−LV BSja Eõ¡q My¡e, VwN£ b¡e¡ BJu¡j£ m£−Nl pi¡f¢a gSm¤m qL,
p¡d¡lZ pÇf¡cL lSh Bm£, n¡jp¤æ¡q¡l iCu¡, j¡q¡g¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm, hSm¤l
ln£c, Sue¡m q¡S¡l£, L¡S£ ¢lu¡Sz BJu¡j£ m£N, k¤hm£N, R¡œm£N, ®üµR¡−phL
m£N, j¢qm¡ m£−Nl ®m¡LSe pi¡u Ef¢ÙÛa ¢R®mez ®hm¡ Ae¤j¡e 12.35 ¢j¢e−V
pi¡ ®n−o Ef¢ÙÛa ®ea«hª¾c p−ÇjmeÙÛm aÉ¡N Ll¡l j¤q§−aÑ ®h¡j¡ ¢h−Øg¡l−Zl në
f¡Ju¡ k¡u Hhw j−’l ¢fRe ®b−L Efk¤Ñf¢l N¤¢m q−a b¡−Lz H pju Bqp¡e
Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f pq AeÉ¡eÉl¡ j−’ ö−u f−sez 1/2 ¢j¢eV fl Bqp¡e Eõ¡q
j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f E−W cy¡s¡e Hhw djL ¢c−u h−me “−a¡l¡ L¡l¡, ®a¡l¡ ¢L Ll¢Rpz”
p¡r£ S¡e¡e ®k, H pju Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f ®L mrÉ L−l Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m
Cpm¡j ¢cf¤, nq£c¤m Cpm¡j ¢nf¤, A¢qc¤m Cpm¡j ¢Vf¤, L¡e¡ q¡¢gS, B−e¡u¡l
®q¡−pe Be¤, gup¡m, ®p¡q¡N, d¤e¤ ¢ju¡, Bm B¢je, hs lae, l¢e, ®p¡−qm,
°puc Bqjc jSe¤, j¡qh¤h, j¢el, c¤m¡m, S¡q¡wN£l, ®R¡V lae, ®M¡Le, L¡m¡j,
j¢nEl lqj¡e jn¤, hs S¡q¡wN£l, B¢jl, B¢j−ll ®R¡V i¡C S¡q¡wN£lNZ qaÉ¡l
29
E−Ÿ−nÉ f§hÑ f¢lLÒfe¡ j−a a¡−cl q¡−a b¡L¡ AÙ» ¢c−u …¢mhoÑe Ll−a b¡−Lz
a¡−cl q¡−a ¢fÙ¹m J ¢limh¡l ¢Rmz Bp¡j£ ®R¡V la−el q¡−a HL¢V L¡V¡ h¾c¤L
¢Rmz H pju j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm, n¢lg E¢Ÿe BL¡n, ®M¡l−nc Bmj,
®p¡−qm, q¡−nj j¢õL, h¡h¤m pq B−l¡ 10/12 Se hÉ¢š² Bqa qu z Bqp¡e
Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f−L Bqa AhÙÛ¡u fÐb−j VwN£ q¡pf¡a¡m, f−l jq¡M¡m£
hrhÉd£ q¡pf¡a¡m Hhw ®pM¡e ®b−L p¢Çj¢ma p¡j¢lL q¡pf¡a¡−m ®eu¡ quz
p¢Çj¢ma p¡j¢lL q¡pf¡a¡−m ®eu¡l fl LaÑhÉla X¡š²¡lNZ Bqp¡e Eõ¡q
j¡ø¡l−L jªa ®O¡oZ¡ L−lz H pju …¢mhoÑ−Z Bqa Jjl g¡l¦L laeJ jªa¤ÉhlZ
L−lz
P.W-2 −j¡x lSh Bm£ a¡l p¡−rÉ E−õM L−le ®k, pi¡ pj¡ç
®O¡oZ¡l p¡−b p¡−b ®m¡LSe kMe Q−m k¡h¡l fËÙº¢a ®eu ¢WL aMe ®hm¡ 12.35
¢j¢e−Vl pju ®h¡j¡ g¡V¡l ¢hLV në qu Hhw p¡−b p¡−b Efk¤Ñf¢l …¢m öl¦ qu z
H pju ¢eqa Hj| ¢f| p¡−qhpq HC p¡r£ J AeÉ¡eÉl¡ ®V¢h−ml ¢e−Q j¡¢Vl Efl
ö−u f−sz aMe p¡j−el ¢cL ®b−LJ …¢m öl¦ qu z H pju Hj| ¢f p¡−qh E−W
c¡ys¡e Hhw q¡a EyQ¥ L−l dj−Ll p¤−l h−me, “®a¡l¡ L¡l¡, ¢L Ll¢Rp” z aMe
p¡r£ E−W c¡ys¡u Hhw ®cM−a f¡u ¢eqa Hj| ¢f| p¡−qh J jqm−L qaÉ¡ Ll¡l
E−Ÿ−nÉ j−’l p¡j−el c¢rZ ¢cL ®b−L ¢cf¤, ¢nf¤, ¢Vf¤, N¡S£ h¡s£l −R¡V lae,
BEk f¡s¡l ®M¡Le, juje¢pw−ql S¡q¡wN£l, q¡¢lpf¤−ll Bm B¢je Hhw
®N¡f¡mf¤−ll Be¤, L¡e¡ q¡¢gS, p¡m¡j, hs lae, ®p¡q¡N, juje¢pw−ql
S¡q¡wN£l, Be¤l hå¥ j¢nEl j−’l ¢c−L J pi¡ÙÛ−ml ¢c−L H−m¡f¡b¡¢s …¢m
Ll−Rz HC p¡r£ a¡l Sh¡eh¾c£−a B−l¡ E−õM L−le ®k, ¢a¢e Bp¡j£ ¢cf¤l
30
LÉ¡X¡l h¡¢qe£, ®N¡f¡mf¤−ll Be¤, L¡e¡ q¡¢gS, p¡m¡j, hs lae, ®p¡q¡N,
jlL¥−el S¡q¡wN£l J Be¤l hå¥ j¢nEl lqj¡e jö, j¡qh¤h®L(Bf¢š) ú¥−ml
®fR−el l¡Ù¹¡ ¢c−u Q−m ®k−a ®c−Mez Bp¡j£ ®R¡V la−el q¡−a HL¢V L¡V¡ h¾c¤L
J AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£l q¡−a ¢fÙ¹m J ¢limh¡l ¢Rmz
P.W-3 −j¡x Bh¤m L¡−nj a¡l p¡−rÉ E−õM L−le ®k, ¢a¢e a¡l hå¥
Cpj¡Cm J Bx lqj¡e−L ¢e−u ®qm¡m L¢jne¡−ll h¡¢s−a k¡e, Hj,¢f qaÉ¡l
10/12 ¢ce f§−hÑ Ae¤j¡e l¡a 10 V¡l ¢c−Lz l¡a fСu 11 V¡l ¢c−L ®qm¡m
L¢jne¡−ll h¡s£l f¢ÕQj ¢cL ¢c−u ®qy−V k¡h¡l pju Bp¡j£ B¢j−el h¡s£l f§hÑ
¢c−L HL¢V jVl p¡C−Lm J HL¢V p¡c¡ lw Hl fСC−iV N¡s£ ®cM−a f¡ez p¡r£
H pju Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l, j¡q¡h¤h, e¤l¦m Cpm¡j ¢cf¤, f¡è¤ plL¡l,
B¢je, BCu¤h J ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£NZ−L ®cM−a f¡ez p¡r£ A¢ik¤š² −j¡q¡Çjc
Bm£ J j¡q¡h¤h−L ®j¡Vl p¡C−Lm L−l Q−m ®k−a ®c−Mez Afl¢c−L A¢ik¤š²
f¡è¤ plL¡l®L N¡s£l ¢ia−l Hhw A¢ik¤š² e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l−L XÊ¡C¢iw ¢p−V
h−p b¡L−a ®c−Mez H pju ¢a¢e Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j ¢cf¤, BCu¤h J B¢je−L
e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡−ll p¡−b Lb¡ hm−a ®c−Mez
P.W-4 ®j¡x Bj¡e E¢Ÿe plL¡l OVe¡l ¢ce OVe¡ÙÛ−m A¡e¤j¡¢eL
10.30 ¢j¢e−V ®fy±R¡ez ¢a¢e S¡e¡e ®k, ®hm¡ 12.30 ¢j¢e−Vl ¢c−L fÐd¡e A¢a¢b
Hj, ¢f Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hl hš²hÉ ®n−o pi¡l pi¡f¢a j¢Shl lqj¡e
j¡C−L L¢j¢Vl e¡j ®O¡oZ¡ L−lez pi¡ ®n−o j−’ Ef¢ÙÛa pL−m E−W k¡h¡l SeÉ
fÐÙ¹¤¢a ¢e−m 12.35 ¢j¢e−Vl ¢c−L j−’l ¢fRe −b−L ®h¡j¡ g¡V¡l në f¡e Hhw
p¡−b p¡−b Efk¤Ñf¢l N¤¢ml BJu¡S f¡ez aMe HC p¡r£ J AeÉ¡eÉl¡ i£a p¿»Ù»
31
q−u j¡¢V−a ö−u f−sz Hj,¢f p¡−qh q¡a EyQ¤ L−l h−m “®a¡l¡ L¡l¡, ¢L
Ll¢Rpz” aMe HC p¡r£ j¡b¡ EyQ¤ L−l ®cM−a f¡e Bp¡j£ ¢cf¤, ¢nf¤, ¢Vf¤,
®M¡Le, Bm-B¢je …¢m Ll−a Ll−a Bp−Rz p¡r£ B−l¡ ®c−Me jSe¤, i¥m¤,
l¢Z, gup¡m, j¢el, c¤m¡mNZ j−’ Ef¢hø Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f Hhw
jqm−L E−ŸnÉ L−l ¢fÙ¹m J ¢limh¡l ¢c−u …¢m Ll−Rz p¡r£ B−l¡ ®cM−a f¡u
j−’l c¢rZ ¢cL ®b−L A¢ik¤š² j¡qh¤h, Be¤, L¡e¡ q¡¢gS, hs lae, ®p¡q¡N,
S¡q¡wN£l, p¡m¡j, B¢jl Hl ®R¡V i¡C S¡q¡wN£l, ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£ J Be¤l hå¥
jö ¢fÙ¹m J ¢limh¡l q¡−a Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f J jqm−L …¢m Ll−Rz
P.W-5 ®j¡x ®M¡l−nc Bmj a¡l p¡−rÉ E−õM L−le ®k, pi¡
Qm¡hÙÛ¡u ¢a¢e ú¥−ml c¢r−Zl h¡l¡¾c¡u c¡y¢s−u ®ea«hª−¾cl hš²hÉ öe¢R−mez pi¡l
fÐd¡e A¢a¢b Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f hš²ªa¡ öl¦ Ll¡l pju ¢a¢e −cM−a f¡e
jSe¤ ®j¡h¡Cm ®g¡−e Lb¡ hm−a hm−a hÉÙ¹ AhÙÛ¡u fÐd¡e ®N−Vl ¢c−L k¡−µRz
A¡h¡l O¤−l B−p Hhw H−p Bp¡j£ B¢jl, B¢j−ll i¡C S¡q¡‰£l, l¢e,
gup¡m®cl p¡−b L¡e¡L¡¢e L−l J BL¡l Cw¢N−a ¢L ®ke h−mz −hm¡ 12.30
¢j¢e−Vl ¢c−L Bk¡−el SeÉ j¡CL hå Ll¡ quz 3/4 ¢j¢e−Vl j−dÉ pi¡f¢a
hš²ªa¡ ®no L−l pi¡l pj¡¢ç ®O¡oZ¡ L−lz ¢WL HC pj®u j−’l ¢fRe ¢c−L
HL¢V ®h¡j¡ ¢h−Øg¡l−Zl j−a¡ në quz p¡−b p¡−b Efk¤Ñf¢l …¢mJ öl¦ quz
®eaªhª¾c j¡¢V−a ö−u f−sz Hj,¢f p¡−qh dj−Ll p¤−l h−m, “HC ®a¡l¡ L¡l¡, ¢L
Ll¢Rp?” p¡r£ aMe ®cM−a f¡u p¡j−el ¢cL ®b−L Bp¡j£ ¢cf¤, ¢nf¤, ¢Vf¤,
−R¡V lae, ®M¡Le, Bm-B¢je, i¥m¤, gup¡m, l¢e, c¤m¡m J j¢elNZ L¡−l¡ q¡−a
b¡L¡ ¢fÙ¹m J ¢limh¡l J ®R¡V la−el q¡−a b¡L¡ h¾c¤L ¢c−u j−’l ¢c−L
32
Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f J jqm−L qaÉ¡l E−Ÿ−nÉ …¢m Ll−a Ll−a H¢N−u
k¡−µRz p¡r£ B−l¡ ®c−M ®k, HLC pj−u j−’l ¢fRe ¢cL ®b−L Bp¡j£ j¡qh¤h,
hs lae, Be¤, L¡e¡ q¡¢gS, ®p¡q¡N, p¡m¡j, ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£, jlL¥−el S¡q¡‰£l
J Be¤l hå¥ j¢nElpq B−l¡ L−uLSe …¢m Ll−a Ll−a pi¡ÙÛ−m B−p,
H−m¡f¡b¡¢s …¢m L−l J j−’l ¢c−LJ …¢m L−lz
P.W-6 ®j¡x BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j j¡p¤j a¡l p¡−rÉ E−õM L−le ®k, HC
p¡r£ Hhw h¡c£ j¢aEl lqj¡e OVe¡l ¢ce Ae¤¢ùa p−Çjme¢V f¢lQ¡me¡ L−lez
®hm¡ Ae¤j¡e 12.35 ¢j¢e−Vl ¢c−L Ae¤ù¡e ®n−o kMe ph¡C k¡h¡l SeÉ fÐÙ¹¤¢a
¢e¢µRm aMe qW¡v j−’l ®fRe −b−L ®h¡j¡ ¢h−Øg¡l−Zl BJu¡S quz j−’l
®fRe −b−L j−’l ¢c−L Efk¤Ñf¢l …¢m q−a b¡−Lz aMe ®ea«hª¾c j¡¢V−a ö−u
f−sz p¡r£J j¡¢V−a ö−u f−sz HLC pj−u j−’l p¡j−e ®b−LJ …¢ml në
®n¡e¡ k¡uz aMe Hj,¢f p¡−qh E−W cy¡s¡e Hhw dj−Ll p¤−l hm−a b¡−Le, “HC
®a¡l¡ L¡l¡, ¢L Lla¡−R¡pz” aMe p¡r£ j¡b¡ EyQ¤ L−l ®cM−a f¡e ®k, A¢ik¤š²
¢cf¤, ¢nf¤, ¢Vf¤, ®R¡V lae, ®M¡Le, Bm B¢je, gup¡m, i¥m¤, c¤m¡m, l¢Z, j¢el
J B−l¡ 2/1 Se pq a¡−cl L¡−l¡ q¡−a ¢fÙ¹m, L¡−l¡ q¡−a ¢limh¡l ¢c−u Hj,¢f
p¡−qh J jqm−L mrÉ L−l Efk§Ñf¢l …¢m Ll−Rz p¡r£ Bp¡j£ ®R¡V lae−L a¡l
q¡−a b¡L¡ L¡V¡ h¾c¤L ¢c−u pi¡ÙÛ−m Efk¤Ñf¢l N¤¢m Ll−a ®c−Mz HC p¡r£ B−l¡
®cM−a f¡u ®k, j−’l ®fRe ®b−L j−’l p¡j−e H−p A¢ik¤š² j¡qh¤h, hs lae,
p¡m¡j, ®p¡q¡N, ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£, jlL¥−el S¡q¡wN£l, B¢jl, B¢j−ll i¡C
S¡q¡wN£l, Be¤, L¡e¡ q¡¢gS, Be¤l hå¥ jö a¡−cl L¡−l¡ q¡−a ¢fÙ¹m J L¡−l¡
q¡−a ¢limh¡l ¢c−u Hj,¢f p¡−qh J jqm−L qaÉ¡l E−Ÿ−nÉ …¢m Ll−Rz
33
P.W-7 S¡¢Ll ®q¡−pe a¡l p¡−rÉ E−õM L−le ®k, ¢a¢e OVe¡l ¢ce
®hm¡ 12.35 ¢j¢e−Vl ¢c−L Bjam£l ¢p¢Ÿ−Ll L¡−R k¡ez H pju ¢a¢e ®cM−a
f¡e Be¤, Be¤l hå¥ j¢nEl, L¡e¡ q¡¢gS, j¡qh¤h, ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£, hs lae,
p¡m¡j, ®p¡q¡N, jlL¥−el S¡q¡wN£l, jSe¤, B¢jl, B¢j−ll i¡C S¡q¡wN£lNZ
f¢ÕQj ¢c−Ll N¢m ®b−L ®R¡V ®R¡V AÙ» q¡−a c¢rZ ¢c−L H−p Bp¡j£ ®j¡q¡Çjc
Bm£l h¡s£l ¢c−L k¡uz ¢a¢e öe−a f¡e, ®e¡u¡Ny¡J ú¥m j¡−W …¢m q−u−R J
10/12 Se Bqa q−u−Rz ¢hL¡m ®hm¡ S¡e−a f¡−le ®k, Hj,¢f p¡−qh J lae
j¡l¡ ®N−Rz HC p¡r£ h¤T−a f¡−le E−õ¢Ma hÉ¢š²l¡C HC L¡S L−l−Rz
P.W-8 −j¡x Bš²¡l ®q¡−pe S¡e¡e ®k, a¡l h¡s£ A¢ik¤š² ®j¡q¡Çjc
Bm£l h¡s£l 10/12 NS f¢ÕQ−jz Cw 07/05/2004 a¡¢l−M ®hm¡ 11.00 V¡l
¢c−L ¢a¢e OVe¡ÙÛ−m k¡h¡l SeÉ ®hl qez H pju ¢a¢e ®cM−a f¡e A¢ik¤š² Be¤,
Be¤l hå¥ jö, L¡e¡ q¡¢gS, j¡qh¤h, p¡m¡j, ®p¡q¡N, hs lae Hhw jlL¥−el
S¡q¡wN£lNZ Bp¡j£ −j¡q¡Çjc Bm£l h¡s£l ¢c−L ¢Ym¡Y¡m¡ ®f¡n¡L f−l k¡−µRz
Ae¤j¡e 12.35 ¢j¢e−Vl ¢c−L p¡r£ OVe¡ÙÛ−ml j−’l ¢fRe ¢cL ®b−L ®h¡j¡
¢h−Øg¡l−Zl në öe−a f¡ez p−‰ p−‰ …¢mhoÑ−Zl në öe−a f¡ez p¡r£ i−u
C¢mu¡p f¡W¡−el h¡s£l ®N−Vl ®ia−l cy¡s¡ez H pju p¡r£ ®cM−a f¡e Bp¡j£
q¡¢gS, Be¤, jö, p¡m¡j, ®p¡q¡N, j¡qh¤h, ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£, hs lae, B¢jl,
B¢j−ll i¡C S¡q¡wN£l, jlL¥−el S¡q¡wN£l AÙ» q¡−a ®lm œ²¢pw f¡s q−u
®Ll¡e£l h¢Ù¹l ®ial Bp¡j£ ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£l h¡s£l ¢c−L Q−m k¡−µRz
P.W-9 à£−S¾cÐ plL¡l ¢eqa Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f p¡−q−hl
h¡s£l ®Lu¡l−VL¡lz ¢a¢e a¡l p¡−rÉ E−õM L−le ®k, OVe¡l pju ¢a¢e ¢j¢Vw−u
34
f¡¢e ¢c−u ¢gl¢R−mez qW¡v H pju ®cM−a f¡e Bp¡j£ Be¤, L¡e¡ q¡¢gS,
j¡qh¤hNZ ¢eqa Hj,¢f p¡−q−hl ea¥e h¡s£l p¡j−e f§hÑ f¢ÕQj l¡Ù¹¡ ¢c−u f§hÑ ¢cL
¢c−u H−p j¡−W fÐ−hn Ll−Rz p¡r£ ®c¡am¡u Q−m k¡e Hhw L¡S Ll−a b¡−Lez
qW¡v L−l Be¤j¡¢eL 12.35 ¢j¢e−V …¢ml në f¡ez ®m¡LSe ®R¡V¡R¤¢V Ll−R
®cM−a f¡ez H pju p¡r£ Bp¡j£ ¢cf¤, ¢nf¤ J B−l¡ 8/10 Se−L Hj,¢f
p¡−q−hl h¡p¡l c¢rZ ¢cL ¢c−u Q−m ®k−a ®c−Mez p¡r£ H pju f§hÑ ¢c−Ll ®NV
¢c−u Bp¡j£ Be¤, L¡e¡ q¡¢gS, lae, ®p¡q¡N, p¡m¡j, j¡qh¤h, jlL¥−el
S¡q¡wN£l, jSe¤, B¢jl, B¢j−ll i¡C S¡q¡wN£lNZ−L …¢m Ll−a Ll−a Q−m
®k−a ®c−Mez
p¡r£ HL¢V fcÑ¡ ®kM¡−e …¢ml 12 ¢V ¢Râ l−u−R, 12¢V …¢ml ®M¡p¡ J
¢eqa Hj,¢f p¡−qh ®kM¡−e ¢R−me ®pM¡eL¡l lš²j¡M¡ j¡¢V a¡l Ef¢ÙÛ¢a−a Së
Ll¡ qu j−jÑ E−õM L−lez p¡r£ Sëe¡j¡u p¡r£ ¢q−p−h cÙ¹Ma −cez p¡r£ H
pLm Bm¡ja Bc¡m−a pe¡š² L−lez
P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc 10 ew Ju¡XÑ BJu¡j£ m£−Nl pi¡f¢az
¢a¢e a¡l p¡−rÉ E−õM L−le ®k, OVe¡l ¢ce ¢a¢e p−Çjm−e hš²ªa¡ L−le Hhw
a¡l hš²hÉ ®n−o ¢a¢e j−’l Ešl f¡−n cy¡¢s−u ®ea«hª−¾cl hš²hÉ öe¢R−mez ®hm¡
Ae¤j¡e 12.30 ¢j¢e−Vl ¢c−L S¤Çj¡l Bk¡−el SeÉ j¡CL hå Ll¡ quz pi¡f¢a
3/4 ¢j¢eV hš²ªa¡ ¢c−u pi¡ pj¡¢ç ®O¡oZ¡ L−lez ph¡C p−ÇjmeÙÛm ®b−L k¡h¡l
fÐÙ¹¤¢a ®euz aMe Be¤j¡¢eL 12.35 ¢j¢e−Vl ¢c−L j−’l ®fRe ®b−L ®h¡j¡
¢h−Øg¡l−Zl BJu¡S f¡ez HLC pj−u j−’l −fRe ®b−L j−’l ¢c−L Efk¤Ñf¢l
…¢m q−a b¡−Lz ®ea«hª¾c j¡¢V−a ö−u f−sz p¡r£J i−u ú¥−ml h¡l¡¾c¡u HL¢V
35
¢fm¡−ll ¢fR−e cy¡¢s−u BnÐu ®euz H pju p¡r£ ®cM−a f¡e j−’l p¡j−e
−b−L Bp¡j£ ¢cf¤, ¢nf¤, ¢Vf¤, BEp f¡s¡l ®M¡Le, B¢lpf¤−ll Bm B¢je,
®N¡f¡mf¤−ll i¥m¤, gup¡m, l¢e, j¢el, c¤m¡mNZ ¢eqa Hj,¢f p¡−qh J jqm−L
E−ŸnÉ L−l a¡−cl q¡−a b¡L¡ ¢fÙ¹m J ¢limh¡l ¢c−u …¢m Ll−Rz p¡r£ ®R¡V
lae−L L¡V¡ h¾c¤L ¢c−u H−m¡f¡b¡¢s …¢m Ll−a ®c−Mez HC p¡r£ B−l¡ ®cM−a
f¡e, Bp¡j£ L¡e¡ q¡¢gS, j¡qh¤h, Be¤, jö, ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£, jlL¥−el S¡q¡wN£l,
jlL¥−el jSe¤, p¡m¡j, ®p¡q¡N, hs lae, B¢jl J B¢j−ll i¡C S¡q¡wN£lNZ
q¡−a b¡L¡ AÙ» Ey¢Q−u N¤¢m Ll−a Ll−a ¢eqa Hj,¢f p¡−q−hl h¡¢sl p¡j−e ¢c−u
®lm m¡Ce œ²p L−l Q−m k¡−µR z
P.W-11 −j¡x S¡j¡m a¡l S¡h¡eh¾c£−a h−me ®k, ¢a¢e ¢hNa 07-05-
04 Cw a¡¢l−M pL¡m Be¤j¡¢eL 9.45-10.00 ¢j¢eV Hl pju p¡q¡l¡ p¤f¡l
j¡−LÑ−Vl p¡j−e cy¡s¡e, OVe¡ÙÛm ®e¡u¡Ny¡J ú¥m j¡−W p−Çjm−e k¡h¡l E−Ÿ−nÉz
aMe ®c−Me Ešl ¢cL ®b−L ¢l„¡u g¢lc Bp−Rez p¡r£ g¢lc−L X¡−Lez ®p
¢l„¡ ®R−s ®cuz HC p¡r£ J g¢lc ¢j¢Vw−u k¡h¡l E−cÉ¡N ®eez aMe ®c−Me
¢h¢pL Hm¡L¡ ®b−L HL¢V p¡c¡ fСC−iV L¡l B−p J p¡q¡l¡ p¤f¡l j¡−LÑ−Vl
p¡j−e cy¡s¡uz HC p¡r£ B−l¡ ®cM−a f¡e L¡−ll ¢fR−el clS¡ M¤−m Bp¡j£
¢cf¤ J ¢nf¤ e¡−jz N¡s£l p¡j−el XÊ¡C¢iw p£−V hp¡ Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j
plL¡−ll L¡−R k¡uz aMe Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j N¡s£l Ly¡Q e¡¢j−u Bp¡j£ ¢cf¤l
‘¢fW Q¡f¢s−u’ ¢L ®ke h−mz HC p¡r£ J g¢lc f¡−u ®qy−V p−ÇjmeÙÛ−m k¡uz
Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l N¡s£ Q¡¢m−u f¢ÕQj ¢c−L Q−m k¡uz Bp¡j£ ¢cf¤ J
¢nf¤ pi¡ÙÛ−ml ¢c−L Q−m k¡uz HC p¡r£ J g¢lc ú¥−ml j¡−Wl c¢r−el h¡l¡¾c¡u
36
cy¡s¡uz pi¡ ®n−o ®ø−Sl ¢fRe ¢c−L ®b−L HL¢V ®h¡j¡l BJu¡S f¡e HC
p¡r£z a¡l fl …¢ml BJu¡S f¡ez HC p¡r£ ú¥−ml fÐd¡e ®N−Vl ¢c−L −k−a
b¡−Lez ¢fRe ¢c−L a¡¢L−u ®c−Me Bp¡j£ ¢cf¤ J ¢nf¤ Nw ®ø−Sl ¢c−L mrÉ L−l
…¢m Ll−Rz HC p¡r£ −cy±¢s−u ®lm ®øn−el fÔ¡Vg−jÑ ¢N−u cy¡s¡ez aMe S¡e−a
f¡−le Hj,¢f, p¡−qh, jqm i¡C J AeÉ¡eÉl¡ …¢m¢hÜ q−u−Rz H p¡r£ VwN£
q¡pf¡a¡−m ¢N−u ®c−Me a¡l ¢fa¡ Bh¤ q¡−nj j¢õLJ …¢m¢hÜ q−u−Rz HC p¡r£
OVe¡l 10/15 ¢ce fl OVe¡l a¡¢l−Ml pL¡−m p¡q¡l¡ j¡−LÑ−Vl OVe¡ h¡c£
j¢aEl lqj¡e−L h−mz
PW-12 −j¡x g¢lc E¢Ÿe a¡l p¡−rÉ h−me ®k, Cw 07/05/2004
a¡¢lM pL¡m ®hm¡ ¢a¢e a¡l BaÈ£u ¢fu¡l Bm£l h¡p¡u k¡e ®pM¡e ®b−L Bm¡f
®p−l pL¡m 9.30-9.45 ¢j¢e−V ¢lLp¡ ®k¡−N p¡q¡l¡ p¤f¡l j¡−LÑ−V −f±yR¡ez ¢WL
®pC pj−u ¢h¢p−Ll ¢cL ®b−L HL¢V p¡c¡ fСC−iV L¡l H®p p¡q¡l¡ p¤f¡l
j¡−LÑ−Vl p¡j−e f¢ÕQj ¢c−L j¤M L−l c¡ys¡uz N¡s£l ¢fR−el ¢pV ®b−L Bp¡j£
¢cf¤ J ¢nf¤ ®e−j XÊ¡C¢iw ¢p−V hp¡ Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡−ll L¡−R k¡uz
Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l N¡s£l NÔ¡p e¡¢j−u Bp¡j£ ¢cf¤l ‘¢fW Q¡f¢s−u’ ¢L
®ke h−mz Bp¡j£ ¢cf¤ J ¢nf¤−L Ešl ¢c−L OVe¡ÙÛ−ml ¢c−L f¡¢W−u ¢c−u Bp¡j£
e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l N¡s£ Q¡¢m−u f¢ÕQj ¢c−L Q−m k¡uz p¡r£ B−l¡ h−me ®k,
¢a¢e J S¡j¡m f¡−u ®qy−V OVe¡ÙÛm ®e¡u¡Ny¡J ú¥m j¡−W p−Çjme ÙÛ−m Ef¢ÙÛa qez
¢eqa Hj,¢f, p¡−q−hl hš²ªa¡l ®no ¢c−L ¢a¢e Q¡, f¡e ¢h¢úV M¡h¡l SeÉ ú¥−ml
®jCe ®NV ¢c−u h¡C−l k¡ez ¢LR¤rZ fl Q¡ M¡Ju¡ AhÙÛ¡u −h¡j¡ g¡V¡l J …¢ml
BJu¡S öe−a f¡ez ®m¡LSe H−m¡f¡b¡¢s i¡−h ®R¡V¡R¤¢V Ll¢R−m¡z ¢LR¤rZ fl
37
HLV¤ n¡¿¹ q−m ú¥−ml j¡−W ¢eqa Hj,¢f p¡−qh−L V‰£ ®f±lpi¡l ®Qu¡ljÉ¡e,
h¡c£ j¢aEl lqj¡e J AeÉ¡eÉl¡ ®Qu¡ljÉ¡e p¡−q−hl N¡s£−a L−l V‰£ q¡pf¡a¡−m
¢eu¡ k¡uz Bqa jqm−L a¡l N¡s£−a L−l ¢e−u k¡uz AeÉ¡eÉ−cl iÉ¡e ¢l„¡ L−l
¢h¢iæ q¡pf¡a¡−m ¢e−u k¡uz HC p¡r£ n¢g−L X¡L ¢c−u p¡r£ S¡j¡mpq
pL¡−ml p¡q¡l¡ p¤f¡l j¡−LÑ−Vl OVe¡ h−mez HC p¡r£ n¢g J AeÉ¡eÉ
®m¡LSe−cl L¡−R ®b−L S¡−ee Bp¡j£ ¢cf¤, ¢nf¤, ¢Vf¤, ®R¡V lae, j¡qh¤h,
®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£, Be¤, L¡e¡ q¡¢gS, jö, ®p¡−qm,l¢e, ®p¡q¡N, p¡m¡j, jSe¤ J
B−l¡ 10/12 Se hÉ¢š² ¢eqa Hj,¢f p¡−qh J jqm−L E−ŸnÉ L−l …¢m L−lz
HC p¡r£ Bc¡m−al L¡WNs¡u Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l−L pe¡š² L−lez
PW-13 h¡h¤m ¢ju¡ a¡l Sh¡eh¾c£−a h−m ®k, −p ®e¡u¡Ny¡J fСCj¡l£
ú¥−m 4bÑ ®nÐZ£−a f−sz HC p¡r£ ¢j¢Vw H k¡u ®hm¡ 12.00 ¢jx Hz HC p¡r£
¢j¢Vw Hl p¡j−el M¡¢m ®Qu¡−l h−p Hj, ¢f p¡−q−hl hš²ªa¡ ö−ez ¢j¢Vw ®no
qh¡l fl HC p¡r£ BJu¡S ö−e ®Qu¡l ®b−L e£−Q f−s k¡u, Bl ¢LR¤ hm−a
f¡−l e¡z HC p¡r£l X¡e e¡−Ll ¢Râ ¢c−u …¢m Y¤−L j¡b¡l ¢fR−e …¢m¢V HMeJ
BV−L l−u−Rz HC p¡r£l h¡j f¡−ul f¡a¡l ®Ny¡s¡m£−a …¢m ®m−N ®hl q−u k¡uz
PW-14 n¢lg E¢Ÿe BL¡n a¡l p¡−rÉ h−me ®k, ¢a¢e S¡e−a f¡−le
HL¢V p¡c¡ fСC−iV L¡−l L−l Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l, ¢cf¤, ¢nf¤ p¡q¡l¡
j¡−LÑ−Vl L¡−R B−pz ¢cf¤ J ¢nf¤−L e¡¢j−u ¢c−u Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l
f¢ÕQ−j Q−m k¡uz HC p¡r£ ®m¡LSe−cl L¡−R B−l¡ S¡−ee, Bp¡j£, ¢cf¤, ¢nf¤,
¢Vf¤ , Be¤ , L¡e¡ q¡¢gS, gup¡m, i¥m¤, j¡qh¤h, j¢el, L¡j¡m , p¡m¡j, l¢e, jö,
38
S¡q¡‰£l, B¢j−ll i¡C S¡q¡‰£l, hs lae , ®R¡V lae Nw a¡−cl q¡−a b¡L¡ AÙ»
¢c−u OVe¡ OV¡uz
PW-15 p¤−L¡jm ®che¡b a¡l p¡−rÉ h−me ®k, ¢a¢e ®c−Me ®m¡LSe
®cy±¢s−u H¢cL ®p¢cL k¡−µRz HC p¡r£ OVe¡ÙÛ−ml f¡−n Ah¢ÙÛa jp¢S−cl Ešl
f¡−n l¡Ù¹¡u cy¡¢s−u j¡−Wl ¢c−L mrÉ L−l ®c−M Bp¡j£ ¢cf¤, ¢nf¤, ¢Vf¤, gup¡m,
l¢e, im¤, B¢lpf¤−ll ®R¡V lae, Bm B¢je Nw fÐd¡e ®NV ¢c−u ®hl q−u AÙ»
q¡−a c¢rZ ¢c−L k¡−µR J ¢LR¤ Bp¡j£ …¢m Ll−a Ll−a ®e¡u¡Ny¡J ú¥−ml Ešl
¢c−L l¡Ù¹¡ ¢c−u f§hÑ ¢c−L k¡−µRz
P.W-16 S¡j¡m ®q¡−pe a¡l Sh¡eh¾c£−a h−me, ¢hNa Cw 07-05-04
a¡¢lM öœ²h¡l ¢a¢e ®e¡u¡Ny¡J ú¥m j¡−W Hj,¢f, p¡−q−hl ¢j¢Vw H k¡ez ¢a¢e
p−Çjme ÙÛ−m fÉ¡−ä−ml j¡TM¡−e ®Qu¡−l h−p hš²ªa¡ öe¢R−mez pi¡f¢a hš²ªa¡
L−l ¢j¢Vw ®no L−lez ®fRe ¢cL ®b−L HL¢V BJu¡S f¡ez Q¡l¢cL ®b−L …¢m
B−pz ®m¡LSe ®c±s¡−c±¢s L−lz HC p¡r£J ®c±s¡−c±¢s L−lz HL¢V …¢m HC
p¡r£l j¡b¡l X¡e ¢c−L L¡−el Efl ¢c−u ¢hÜ q−u Q¡js¡ ®ic L−l ®hl q−u
k¡uz HC p¡r£ ®cy±¢s−u f¡m¡−e¡ L¡−m h¡j ¢c−L hN−ml e£−Q …¢m¢hÜ qu Hhw
…¢m¢V HMeJ B−Rz HC p¡r£ ®cy±¢s−u ¢N−u ¢eqa Hj,¢f, p¡−q−hl i¡s¡¢Vu¡
h¡s£l L¡−R ¢N−u f−s A‘¡e q−u k¡ez flhaÑ£−a ‘¡e ¢gl−m ®c−Me ¢a¢e Y¡L¡u
hr hÉ¡¢d q¡pf¡a¡−mz Af¢l¢Qa hÉ¢š²l¡ HC p¡r£−L Y¡L¡ ®j¢X−Lm L−mS
q¡pf¡a¡−m ¢e−u k¡uz −pM¡−e HC p¡r£l ¢Q¢Lvp¡ quz HC p¡r£ ®m¡L j¤−M
ö−ee Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l, j¡qh¤h J AeÉ¡eÉ p¿»¡p£l¡ HC p¿»¡p£ L¡S
L−l−Rz
39
P.W-17 −j¡x Bh¤ p¡Dc a¡l Sh¡eh¾c£−a h−me ®k, ¢a¢e ú¥−ml c¢rZ
®NV ¢c−u Bp¡j£ ¢cf¤pq 10/12 Se −m¡L−L …¢m Ll−a Ll−a Q−m ®k−a
®c−M−Rez ¢a¢e B−l¡ h−me ®k, ¢eqa Hj,¢f p¡−q−hl ¢ejÑ¡Z¡d£e h¡¢sl ®N−Vl
p¡j−e ¢c−u …¢m Ll−a Ll−a Bp¡j£ L¡e¡ q¡¢gS, lae, ®p¡q¡N, j¢nEl,
j¡qh¤h J AeÉ¡eÉ−cl ¢a¢e Q−m −k−a ®c−Mez
P.W-18: −j¡x Bqp¡e Eõ¡q a¡l p¡−rÉ h−me ®k, ¢a¢e p−Çjm−e
pL¡m 9.45 ¢j¢e−V Ef¢ÙÛa qez p−Çjme öl¦ qu Be¤j¡¢eL 10.15 ¢j¢eV Hz
HC p¡r£ ú¥−ml ¢h¢ôw Hl f¢ÕQj j¡b¡u cy¡¢s−u ®ea«hª−¾cl hš²ªa¡ ö−eez Hj,¢f,
p¡−qh hš²ªa¡ ®cu¡l fl p−Çjm−el pi¡f¢a j¢Shl lqj¡e ea§e L¢j¢Vl e¡j
®O¡oZ¡ L−l J hš²ªa¡ ®no L−l p−Çjm−el pj¡¢ç ®O¡oZ¡ L−lz ®ea«hª¾c Q−m
k¡h¡l E−cÉ¡N ®eu, aMe pju 12.35 ¢jxz p¡r£ aMe j−’l ®fR−e ®h¡j¡
¢h−Øg¡l−Zl BJu¡S f¡uz pw−N pw−N j−’l ¢c−L EfkѤf¢l …¢ml në f¡uz
p¡r£ ®c−M j¡−Wl c¢r−Zl fÐd¡e ®N−Vl ¢cL ®b−L Bp¡j£ ¢cf¤l ®ea«−aÅ Bp¡j£
¢nf¤, ¢Vf¤, ®R¡V lae, Bm B¢je, gup¡m, ®M¡Le, i¥m¤, l¢epq B−l¡ 3/4 Se
j¡−Wl c¢rZ ¢cL ¢c−u j¡TM¡−e H−p j−’l ¢c−L ¢eqa Hj,¢f p¡−qh J jqm−L
mrÉ L−l …¢m Ll−a b¡−Lz Bp¡j£ ®R¡V lae q¡−a b¡L¡ L¡V¡ h¾c¤L ¢c−u
pi¡ÙÛ−m H−m¡f¡b¡¢s …¢m L−lz HC p¡r£ i−u ¢eqa Hj,¢f p¡−q−hl ¢ejÑ¡Z¡d£e
h¡s£l e£Qam¡u f§hÑ f¡−nl L−r Y¤−L f−sz aMe l¦−jl ®M¡m¡ S¡e¡m¡ ¢c−u
®cM−a f¡u Bp¡j£ ¢cf¤l LÉ¡X¡l h¡¢qe£ Bp¡j£ Be¤, L¡e¡ q¡¢gS, j¡qh¤h,
®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£, p¡m¡j, ®p¡q¡N, hs lae, jlL¥−el S¡q¡‰£l, Be¤l hå¥ j¢nEl,
40
¢jlf¤ClÉ¡ h¡h¤, ®R¡V S¡q¡‰£l pq B−l¡ 2/1 Se Hj,¢f p¡−q−hl h¡s£l p¡j−e
¢c−u f§hÑ ¢c−L …¢m Ll−a Ll−a Q−m k¡−µRz
P.W-19: −j¡x a¢jS E¢Ÿe p¡h-C¾p−fƒl Ah f¤¢mn a¡l Sh¡e
h¾c£−a h−me, ¢a¢e ¢hNa 07-05-04 Cw a¡¢l−M LÉ¡¾Ve−j¾V b¡e¡u Hp,BC
f−c LjÑla ¢R−mez H a¡¢l−M a¡l Sl¦l£ ®j¡h¡Cm ¢XE¢V ¢Rm pL¡m 8.00 ¢jx
®b−L l¡a 8.00¢jx fkÑ¿¹z LÉ¡¾Ve−j¾V b¡e¡l i¡lfСç LjÑLaÑ¡l ¢e−cÑ−n 16.30
¢j¢e−Vl pju ¢a¢e ¢p,Hj,HC−Q ¢N−u ¢eqa Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f’l
i¢NÀf¢a Se¡h Bh¤m ®q¡−p−el pe¡š² j−a ¢eqa Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f’l
m¡−nl p¤laq¡m ¢l−f¡VÑ fÐÙ¹¤a L−le, p¡r£−cl cÙ¹Ma NËqZ L−lez Le®øhm ew
14007 hM¢au¡−ll j¡dÉ−j m¡n jue¡ ac−¿¹l SeÉ Y¡L¡ ®j¢X−Lm L−mS
q¡pf¡a¡m j−NÑ f¡W¡e, Q¡m¡e j¡dÉ−jz ¢a¢e p¤laq¡m ¢l−f¡VÑ J Q¡m¡e fÐÙ¹¤a L−le
LÉ¡¾Ve−j¾V b¡e¡l X¡ul£ eðl 262, Cw 07-05-04 a¡¢lM j§−mz HC p¡r£ ¢eqa
Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡−ll f¢l−du hÙ» Së L−le, Sëe¡j¡ fÐÙ¹¤a L−lez
P.W-20 BSja Eõ¡q M¡e a¡l Sh¡eh¾c£−a E−õM L−le ®k, OVe¡l
a¡¢lM 07-05-04 Cw ®l¡S öœ²h¡lz h¡wm¡−cn BJu¡j£ ®üµR¡−phL m£N, V‰£
b¡e¡l 10 ew Ju¡−XÑl ¢œh¡¢oÑL p−Çjme ®e¡u¡Ny¡J Hj,H j¢Sc ¢ju¡ EµQ ¢hcÉ¡mu
j¡−W Ae¤¢ùa quz p−Çjm−e fÐd¡e A¢a¢b ¢R−me ¢eqa Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l
Hj,¢fz HC p¡r£ 10.45 ¢j¢e−Vl j−dÉ p−ÇjmeÙÛ−m Ef¢ÙÛa qez ¢eqa Hj,¢f
p¡−qh 11.00 ¢j¢eV Hl ¢LR¤ f§−hÑ p®ÇjmeÙÛ−m ®fy±R¡ez HC p¡r£l X¡e f¡−n
Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Bpe NËqZ L−lez HC p¡r£l h¡j f¡−n ¢R−me jqm, a¡l
h¡j ¢c−L ¢R−me n¡jp¤æ¡q¡l iyCu¡z Hj,¢f p¡−q−hl X¡e ¢c−L ¢R−me gSm¤m
41
qL, lSh J L−uLSez pi¡f¢a ¢R−me j¢Shl lqj¡ez j−’l Eš−l ¢R−me h¡c£
j¢aEl lqj¡ez HC p¡r£l hš²ªa¡l fl Hj,¢f p¡−qh hš²ªa¡ L−lez pi¡l
pi¡f¢a ®üµR¡−phL h¡¢qe£l L¢j¢Vl 4 S−el e¡j ®O¡oZ¡ L−lez C¢aj−dÉ
jp¢Sc ®b−L S¤Çj¡l e¡j¡−Sl Bk¡e quz pi¡l pi¡f¢a−L ¢eqa Hj, ¢f p¡−qh
pi¡ pw¢rç Ll¡l ¢e−cÑn ®cez j¡CL R¡s¡ pi¡f¢a a¡l hš²ªa¡ L−l pi¡l pj¡¢ç
®O¡oe¡ L−lez p¡r£ H pju j−’ fcÑ¡l ®fR−e ®h¡j¡ ¢h−Øg¡l−Zl BJu¡S J
p¡−b …¢ml në öe−a f¡ez HC p¡r£pq AeÉ¡eÉl¡ ph¡C j¡¢V−a ö−u f−sez
p¡j−e ®b−LJ …¢ml në f¡ez aMe Hj,¢f p¡−qh HLV¤ j¡b¡ EyQ¤ L−l cy¡¢s−u
h−me, “HC ®a¡l¡ L¡l¡, ¢L Ll¢Rpz” HC Lb¡ hm¡l p¡−b p¡−b ¢a¢e f−s k¡ez
HC p¡r£ ®cM−a f¡e Hj,¢f p¡−qh …¢m¢hÜz HC p¡r£ j¡b¡ EyQ¤ L−l ®c−Me
Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡−ll p¿»¡p£ h¡¢qe£ Bp¡j£ ¢cf¤, ¢nf¤, ¢Vf¤, ®M¡Le,
Bm B¢je, i¥m¤, j¢el, gup¡m, l¢e, ®R¡V laeNZ L¡−l¡ q¡−a ¢limh¡l J
¢fÙ¹m Hhw Bp¡j£ ®R¡V la−el q¡−a L¡V¡ h¾c¤L ¢c−u H−m¡f¡b¡¢s pi¡ÙÛ−ml
¢c−L Hhw AeÉ¡eÉl¡ AÙ» ¢c−u ¢eqa Hj,¢f p¡−qh J jqm−L E−ŸnÉ L−l …¢m
Ll−Rz ¢fRe ¢cL ®b−L p¡j−el ¢c−L H−p Bp¡j£ j¡qh¤h, ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£, L¡e¡
q¡¢gS, Be¤, ®p¡q¡N, hs lae, S¡q¡‰£l, jlL¥−el S¡q¡‰£l, B¢jl, B¢j−ll
i¡C S¡q¡‰£l, jSe¤ NZ j−’l ¢c−L …¢m L−l Hhw …¢m Ll−a Ll−a Hj,¢f
p¡−q−hl h¡s£l p¡j−el l¡Ù¹¡ ¢c−u Bjam£l ¢c−L Q−m k¡uz HC p¡r£ −c−Me
¢eqa Hj,¢f p¡−qh, jqm, n¢lg E¢Ÿe BL¡n, ú¥−ml R¡œ lae , q¡−nj j¢õL,
®p¡−qm h¡h¤m pq 10/12 Se hÉ¢š² …¢m ¢hÜ q−u Bqa q−u−Rez HC p¡r£
Hj,¢f p¡−qh−L ¢e−u V‰£ q¡pf¡a¡−m k¡ez
42
P.W-21 −j¡x BjS¡c ®q¡−pe, 3627 ew Le−ØVhm a¡l Sh¡eh¾c£−a
h−me ®k, ¢a¢e Cw 07/05/2004 a¡¢l−M lje¡ b¡e¡u Le−ØVhm ¢q−p−h LjÑla
¢R−mez H¢ce Hp,BC Bë¥m L¡−c−ll p¡−b Y¡L¡ ®j¢X−Lm L−mS j−NÑ a¡l
¢XE¢V ¢Rmz 16.45 ¢j¢e−Vl pju S¯eL Jjl g¡l¦L la−el m¡n ¢a¢e Q¡m¡−el
j¡dÉ−j h¤−T ®f−u j−NÑ h¤¢T−u ®cez
P.W-22 X¡x ®j¡x L¡jl¦m q¡p¡e plc¡l Cw 07/05/2004 a¡¢lM 5.20
¢j¢e−Vl pju Le−ØVhm ew 3627 ®j¡x BjS¡c ®q¡−p−el pe¡š² j−a Jjl
g¡l¦L la−el jªa−cq jue¡ ac¿¹ pÇfæ L−lez
P.W-23 ®j¡x hM¢au¡l E¢Ÿe 14007 ew Le−ØVhm Cw 07/05/2004
a¡¢l−M LÉ¡¾Ve−j¾V b¡e¡u Hp.BC a¢jS E¢Ÿ−el p¡−b LjÑla b¡L¡ AhÙÛ¡u
16.30 ¢j¢e−Vl pju Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f Hl m¡n Q¡m¡−el j¡dÉ−j h¤−T
f¡e Hhw Y¡L¡ −j¢X−Lm L−mS q¡pf¡a¡−ml j−NÑ h¤¢T−u ®cez
P.W-24 X¡x j¡qh¤h ®j¡l−nc Cw 07/05/2004 a¡¢lM Sl¦l£ LjÑla
A¢gp¡l ¢q−p−h VwN£l 50 nkÉ¡ ¢h¢nø q¡pf¡a¡−m LjÑla b¡L¡L¡−m 12.35
¢j¢e−V Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f, j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm J n¢lg E¢Ÿe
BL¡n−L Bqa AhÙÛ¡u fСç qez
P.W-25 Bë¥m L¡−cl i¥Cu¡ Cw 07/05/2004 a¡¢l−M lje¡ b¡e¡u
Hp.BC f−c LjÑla b¡L¡L¡−m ¢eqa la−el m¡−nl p¤laq¡m ¢l−f¡VÑ fÐÙ¹¤a
L−lez
P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm a¡l p¡−rÉ E−õM L−le ®k, Cw
07/05/2004 a¡¢lM VwN£l ®e¡u¡Ny¡J Hj,H j¢Sc ¢ju¡ EµQ ¢hcÉ¡m−ul j¡−W
43
BJu¡j£ ®üµR¡−phL m£−Nl ¢j¢Vw−u ¢a¢e j−’ Ef¢ÙÛa ¢R−mez pi¡ ®n−o j−’l
¢fRe ®b−L ®h¡j¡ g¡V¡l BJu¡S f¡ez aMe Be¤j¡¢eL 12.34 h¡ 12.35 q−hz
¢a¢e ¢f−W …¢m¢hÜ qe, j¡¢V−a m¤¢V−u f−sez HC pju Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l
Hj,¢f ¢QvL¡l L−l hm−a b¡−Le, ®a¡l¡ L¡l¡z aMeC Bp¡j£ ¢cf¤, ¢nf¤, ¢Vf¤,
juje¢pwq¡ S¡q¡‰£l, ®M¡Le, Bm B¢je, i¥m¤, p¡m¡j, jSe¤, l¢Z, c¤m¡m, j¢el
j−’l ¢c−L …¢m Ll−a b¡−Lz H pju Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f …¢m¢hÜ q−u
j¡¢V−a m¤¢V−u f−sez j−’l −fRe ®b−L Bp¡j£ j¡qh¤h, B¢jl, Be¤, L¡e¡
q¡¢gS, B¢j−ll i¡C S¡q¡wN£l, jlL¥−el S¡q¡wN£l, ®p¡q¡N, hs lae, jö,
®j¡qÇjc Bm£ J ¢jlf¤−ll h¡h¤ …¢m Ll−a b¡−Lz ®R¡V lae h¾c¤L q¡−a
H−m¡f¡b¡¢s …¢m Ll−a b¡−Lz I ¢ceC …¢m¢hÜ q−u Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f
Hhw Jjl g¡l¦L lae q¡pf¡a¡−m jªa¥ÉhlZ L−lz Cw 10/05/2004 a¡¢l−M
p¡r£ ¢h‘ jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌV hl¡hl HL jªa¤ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡ (k¡ flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl
164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) fÐc¡e L−lez ®p pju ¢a¢e ®kph
Bp¡j£l e¡j j−e Ll−a f¡l¢R−me a¡−cl e¡j ®p ®O¡oZ¡u E−õM L−lez p¡r£
S¡e¡e ®k, BnwL¡SeL AhÙÛ¡u a¡−L ¢Q¢Lvp¡l SeÉ hÉ¡wLL ¢e−u k¡Ju¡ quz
¢Q¢Lvp¡ ®n−o ¢a¢e ¢g−l B−pez a¡l ¢ejÀ¡wN haÑj¡−e Ahn, f¡uM¡e¡ J fÐpË¡h
¢eu¿»−e −eCz ¢a¢e ¢h−cn ®b−L H−p öe−a f¡e ®k, Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j
plL¡−ll ®ea«−aÅ AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£l¡ a¡−L J ¢eqa Hj,¢f p¡−qh−L qaÉ¡l
f¢lLÒfe¡ L−lz
P.W-27 H,®L,Hj, ®p¡−qm fÐbj ®nÐZ£l jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌV ¢q−p−h Cw
11/05/2004 a¡¢l−M p¡r£ p¤je Bqjc jS¤jc¡l, Bë¥m Sî¡l Hl Sh¡eh¾c£
44
L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡u ¢m¢fhÜ L−lez Cw 23/05/2004 a¡¢l−M Bp¡j£ j¡qh¤h¤l
lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤−hl ®c¡o ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL
Sh¡eh¾c£ L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡ j§−m ¢m¢fhÜ L−lez
P.W-28 k¡¢hc Bqp¡e ®p¡−qm ¢eqa Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f Hl f¤œz
¢a¢e Cw 07/05/2004 a¡¢l−M ®hm¡ 12.30 O¢VL¡l ¢c−L Bk¡−el flfl ú¥m
j¡−W ®h¡j¡ Hhw …¢ml BJu¡S f¡ez ¢a¢e mrÉ L−le Bp¡j£ Be¤ J L¡e¡ q¡¢gS
a¡−cl p¡−b 8/10 Se pq AÙ»q¡−a pi¡ÙÛ−m …¢m Ll−Rz a¡−cl j−dÉ ®j¡q¡Çjc
Bm£, j¢el, B¢jl, B¢j−ll i¡C S¡q¡wN£l, j¡qh¤h, jö …¢m Ll−a Ll−a −lm
m¡C−el ¢c−L Q−m k¡uz
P.W-29 X¡x ®j¡x nq£c¤m Cpm¡j ¢eqa Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f Hl
jªa−cq Le−ØVhm ew 14007 hM¢au¡−ll pe¡š²j−a jue¡ ac¿¹ L−lez
P.W-30 n¢gL B−e¡u¡l Cw 10/05/2004 a¡¢l−M fÐbj ®nÐZ£l jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌV
¢q−p−h LjÑla b¡L¡L¡−m j§MÉ jq¡eNl q¡¢L−jl B−cn j−a S¯eL j¡qg¥S¤l
lqj¡e jq−ml jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡ Y¡L¡l CMH q¡pf¡a¡−ml ICU-2, Bed
no. 1 H p¡r£−cl Ef¢ÙÛ¢a−a ¢m¢fhÜ L−lez
P.W-31 X¡x Al¦e¡wn l¡q¡ Bqa q¡−nj ¢ju¡l R¡sfœ fÐc¡e L−lez
P.W-32 e¤l Bqjc, pqL¡l£ f¤¢mn p¤f¡l, p¡−LÑm-H, Cw 07/05/2004
a¡¢lM VwN£ b¡e¡l i¡lfСç LjÑLaÑ¡ ¢q−p−h LjÑla ¢R−mez ¢a¢e a¡l p¡−rÉ
E−õM L−le ®k, I a¡¢lM c¤f¤l 12.50 ¢j¢e−Vl pju S¯eL hÉ¢š²l ®V¢m−g¡−e
¢a¢e S¡e−a f¡−le ®k, ®e¡u¡Ny¡J Bë¥m j¢Sc EµQ ¢hcÉ¡mu j¡−W ®üµR¡−phL
m£−Nl Ju¡XÑ L¢j¢V NWe Ll¡ pwœ²¡¿¹ p−Çjm−e ®N¡m¡…¢m q−u−R, ®pM¡−e pwpc
45
pcpÉ Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l pq B−l¡ L−uLSe hÉ¢š² Bqa q−u−Rz p¡r£ HC
pwh¡c VwN£ b¡e¡l 296 eðl ¢S¢X eð−l ¢m¢fhÜ L−le Hhw b¡e¡u Ef¢ÙÛa
A¢gp¡l J ®g¡pÑ ¢e−u OVe¡ÙÛ−m k¡ez OVe¡ÙÛ−m ¢N−u p¡r£ pi¡l ®Qu¡l…−m¡
Rs¡−e¡ ¢RV¡−e¡ AhÙÛ¡u ®cM−a f¡ez j¡¢V−a lš², hÉ¡e¡l J fcÑ¡u …¢ml ¢Qq²
®cM−a f¡ez ¢a¢e 12¢V …¢ml ®M¡p¡, 3¢V …¢ml ¢f−mV Së L−lez ¢a¢e OVe¡¢V
f¤¢mn p¤f¡lpq EÜÑae f¤¢mn A¢gp¡l−cl Ah¢qa L−lez p¡r£ S¡e¡e ®k, Hj,¢f
p¡−q−hl jªa¥Él Mhl ®fy±R¡−e¡l fl fl VwN£l BCe nª Mm¡ f¢l¢ÙÛ¢al j¡l¡aÈL
Ahe¢a O−Vz p¡r£ H pju SeNZ J plL¡l£ pÇfc lr¡l L¡−S hÉÙ¹ b¡−Lez Cw
08/05/2004 a¡¢lM l¡a 23.45 ¢j¢e−Vl pju h¡c£l V¡CfL«a HS¡q¡l ®f−u
¢a¢e VwN£ b¡e¡l j¡jm¡ ew 07 a¡¢lM 08/05/2004 cä¢h¢dl
324/326/307/302/34/109 d¡l¡u l¦S¤ L−le, FIR gjÑ f§lZ L−le Hhw
j¡jm¡l ac¿¹i¡l NËqZ J OVe¡ÙÛm f¢lcnÑe L−lez p¡r£ OVe¡ÙÛ−ml j¡e¢Qœ J
p§Q£ fÐÙ¹¤a L−le Hhw 04 Se p¡r£l Sh¡eh¾c£ L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 161 d¡l¡u ¢m¢fhÜ
L−lez p¡r£ Cw 09/05/2004 a¡w j¡q¡g¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm Hl jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡
®lL−XÑl SeÉ ¢h‘ j§MÉ jq¡eNl q¡¢Lj Y¡L¡u B−hce L−lez ¢iL¢Vj j¡qg¥S¤l
lqj¡e jqm CMH H ¢Q¢Lvp¡d£e ¢Rmz p¡r£ S¡e¡e ®k, EÜÑae LaѪf−rl
¢e−cÑ−n j¡jm¡¢V CID ®a qÙ¹¡¿¹¢la qJu¡u Cw 10/05/2004 a¡¢lM ¢a¢e ®Lp
X−LV CID ®a qÙ¹¡¿¹l L−lez
P.W-33 −j¡x M¡−mL¥‹¡j¡e, H.Hp.¢f HC j¡jm¡l flha£Ñ ac¿¹L¡l£
LjÑLaÑ¡z HC p¡r£ S¡e¡e ®k, ¢a¢e Cw 11/05/2004 a¡¢lM ®b−L ac¿¹i¡l NËqZ
L−lez ac¿¹L¡−m ¢a¢e p¡r£−cl Sh¡eh¾c£ L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 161 d¡l¡u ¢m¢fhÜ
46
L−le, HS¡q¡li¥š² Bp¡j£ j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡−el ü£L¡−l¡¢š² j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£
®g±Sc¡l£ L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡ Ae¤p¡−l ¢m¢fhÜ Ll¡−e¡l L¡kÑœ²j NËqZ L−lez
¢eqa, SMj£−cl f¢l−du hÙ»¡¢c Bm¡ja ¢q−p−h Së L−lez OVe¡ÙÛ−m HL¢V
fÉ¡−Xø¡m gÉ¡e (Q¡l¢V ¢Râ ¢Rm), j¡CL Hhw Be¤o¢‰L ¢S¢epfœ Së L−lez
p¡r£ OVe¡ÙÛm f¢lcnÑe L−le, Mps¡ j¡e¢Qœ L−le, jlL¥−el B¢j−el h¡¢sl
j¡e¢Qœ fÐÙ¹¤a L−le, ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£l h¡¢sl Mps¡ j¡e¢Qœ p§Q£ fÐÙ¹¤a L−lez
p¡r£ S¡e¡e ®k, ¢a¢e p¡r£ q¡¢gS¤l lqj¡e q¡¢hh J L¡jl¦m q¡p¡−el Sh¡eh¾c£
L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 161 d¡l¡u ®lLXÑ L−le ¢L¿º i¥mœ²−j Q¡SÑn£−Vl p¡r£ Lm¡−j a¡−cl
e¡j p¢æ−h¢na qu¢ez flha£Ñ−a ¢hQ¡l Qm¡L¡−m HC p¡r£àu−L ®j¡LŸj¡u p¡r£
¢q−p−h pwk¤š² Ll¡l SeÉ fСbÑe¡ Ll¡ quz p¡r£ S¡e¡e ®k, fСb¢jL ac−¿¹ 30
Se Bp¡j£l ¢hl¦−Ü Be£a A¢i−k¡N fСb¢jLi¡−h fÐj¡¢Za qJu¡u V‰£ b¡e¡u
cä¢h¢dl 120M/324/326/307/302/34/109 J 212 d¡l¡u 137 ew Q¡SÑn£V
fÐc¡e L−lez
P.W-34 q¡¢gS¤l lqj¡e q¡¢hh a¡l p¡−rÉ E−õM L−le ®k, Cw
07/05/2004 a¡¢l−M OVe¡l 10/12 ¢ce f§−hÑ ¢a¢e J a¡l p‰£ ¢mVe l¡a
10.00 O¢VL¡l ¢c−L jlL¥−el B¢je ®ea¡l h¡¢s−a k¡ez B¢je ®ea¡l °hWL
M¡e¡u ®N−m B¢je L¡L¡ ®hl q−u h−me BS h¡¢s−a ®jqj¡e B−R, AeÉ¢ce
®V¢m−g¡e L−l Bp−az H pju p¡r£ ®cM−a f¡e Bp¡j£ B¢j®el O−l Bp¡j£
e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l, e¤l¤m Cpm¡j ¢cf¤, j¡qh¤h, ®j¡qÇjc Bm£, Bu¤h B−Rz
c¢äa Bp¡j£ j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤−hl
L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡u ®cu ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£x
47
“Bjl¡ c¤Ci¡C c¤C−h¡ez Bj¡l h¡h¡ f¤¢m−nl Q¡L¥l£ ®b−L Ahpl NËq−Zl
fl VwN£l Bjam£−a hÉhp¡ Ll¡l pju Na 2001 p¡−ml A−ƒ¡h−ll ¢ehÑ¡Q−el
¢ae¢ce fl Bj¡l Bî¡ J S¯eL B¢je E¢Ÿe Bj¡−cl ®c¡L¡−el p¡j−e l¡¢œ
®hm¡u M¤e quz Bj¡l h¡h¡l qaÉ¡ j¡jm¡u B¢j HS¡q¡lL¡l£z VwN£l e¤l¦m
Cpm¡j plL¡l, f¡è¤ plL¡l, ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£pq a¡−cl ®m¡LSe Bj¡l h¡h¡l
qaÉ¡ j¡jm¡ f¢lQ¡me¡u Bj¡−L pq¡ua¡ L−l Hhw a¡−cl BnÐ−u VwN£−a h¡h¡l
®l−M k¡Ju¡ hÉhp¡ Q¡¢m−u ®k−a b¡¢Lz ¢hNa BJu¡j£ m£N plL¡−ll pj−u VwN£
k¤hm£−Nl fÐi¡hn¡m£ ®ea¡ jqm ¢fa¡ j¤¢Shl lqj¡e VwN£l j¡cL hÉhp¡, ¢h¢pL
Hl T¥−Vl hÉhp¡, h¡p, VÊ¡L, ®VÇf¤ ØVÉ¡äpq ph ¢LR¤C Hje¢L e¤l¦m Cpm¡j
plL¡−ll ¢p−ej¡ qm, j−cl ¢cO£ pq ¢eu¿»−e ¢e−u HLµRœ Qy¡c¡h¡¢S Ll−a¡z I
pju ¢VV¤, j¢el VwN£ L−m−Sl R¡œm£N ®ea¡ M¤e q−m jqm fÐi¡h M¡¢V−u
fÐ−aÉL¢V j¡jm¡u e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l, f¡è¤ plL¡l, n¡qS¡q¡e plL¡l, e¤¤l¦m
Cpm¡j c£f¤, a¡l i¡C ¢pf¤, ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£ J a¡−cl ®m¡LSe−L Bp¡j£ Ll¡uz
H−a a¡l¡ jq−ml Efl ¢rç quz
2001 p¡−ml A−ƒ¡h−ll ¢ehÑ¡Q−e plL¡l f¢lh¢aÑa qJu¡l p−‰ p−‰
e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡−ll ¢p−ej¡ qm EÜ¡lpq jq−ml HLµRœ ¢eu¿»e¡d£e j¡cL
hÉhp¡, T¥−Vl hÉhp¡, h¡p, VÊ¡L, ®VÇf¤pq pLm ÙÛ¡e ®b−L jqm−L ¢ha¡¢sa L−l
e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l J a¡l ®m¡LSe ph¢LR¤l ¢eu¿»e ®euz e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l
®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£−L j¡cL hÉhp¡, e¤l¦m Cpm¡j c£f¤−L ¢h¢pL Hl T¥V hÉhp¡,
L¾VÌ¡ƒl£l c¡¢uaÅ ¢c−u B¢bÑL p¤¢hd¡ Bc¡u Ll¡L¡−m jqm Eš² L¡S pj§−q h¡d¡
pª¢ø Ll−m a¡l¡ jq−ml fТa B−l¡ ¢rç quz HL fkÑ¡−u jqm VwN£ ®R−s Y¡L¡u
48
hph¡p Ll−a h¡dÉ quz L¡lZ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l J a¡l ®m¡LSe jqm−L
p¤−k¡Nja ®f−m fСZ e¡n Ll−a f¡−lz
Hj¢f p¡−qh qaÉ¡l 10/12 ¢ce B−N HL¢ce l¡−œ euV¡ p¡s euV¡l
pju ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£ Bj¡l O−ll p¡j−e H−p Bj¡−L X¡L ¢c−u ®q¡ä¡l Lb¡
¢S‘¡p¡ L−lz B¢j ®q¡ä¡ B−R hm−m, Bj¡−L pw−N ¢e−u jlL¥e jdÉf¡s¡l
B¢je (eÉ¡ne¡m gÉ¡−el nТjL ®ea¡) Hl h¡¢s−a k¡Cz B¢je Hl XÊCw l¦−j Y¤−L
®c¢M ®pM¡−e e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l, f¡è¤ plL¡l, e¤l¦m Cpm¡j c£f¤, B¢je, a¡l
i¡¢aS¡ BCu¤h hp¡z B¢j Hhw ®j¡qÇjc Bm£ ¢fa¡ jªa S¡¢jl Bm£ J h¢pz
fÐb−j e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l B¢je−L Lb¡ hm−a hm−m ®p ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£−L
E−ŸnÉ L−l h−m, ¢h¢iæ ÙÛ¡−e ®hn£ f¢lj¡−e V¡L¡ ®cJu¡ m¡−N, a¡C a¡−cl−L
V¡L¡l f¢lj¡e B−l¡ h¡¢s−u ¢c−az” f−l e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l pLm−L E−ŸnÉ
L−l h−m, “jqm Bj¡−cl−L A−eL j¡jm¡u S¢s−u−Rz AaÉ¡Q¡l L−l−R,
Bj¡−cl plL¡l rja¡u Bp¡l flJ hq¤ SÅ¡¢m−u−Rz a¡−L Bl ®hy−Q b¡L−a
®cu¡ k¡u e¡z a¡l c−ml jlL¥e ®VLf¡s¡l jSe¤, ®N¡f¡mf¤−ll B¢jl J hs
S¡q¡‰£l−L q¡a Ll¡ q−u−Rz p¡j−e BJu¡j£ −üµR¡ ®phL m£−Nl Ju¡XÑ L¢j¢Vl
p−Çjm−e jqm Bp−mC I ¢aeSe pwh¡c ®c−hz” AeÉ pL−mC HLja ®f¡oe
L−lz l¡a HN¡−l¡V¡ p¡−s HN¡−l¡V¡u fl¡jnÑ ®n−o pL−m k¡l k¡l h¡p¡u ¢g−l
k¡Cz ¢pÜ¡¿¹ qu pwh¡c f¡Ju¡ j¡œ jqm−L ®j−l ®gm¡ q−hz
OVe¡l ¢ce 07/05/2004 a¡¢lM pL¡m HN¡−l¡V¡ ®p¡u¡ HN¡−l¡V¡u
h¡S¡l L−l Bp−m ®j¡qÇjc Bm£ pwh¡c ¢c−u Bj¡−L a¡l O−l ®euz ®pM¡−e
®k−u ®c¢M (1) ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£ ¢fa¡ jªa S¡¢jl Bm£ (2) Be¤ Jl−g B−e¡u¡l
49
®q¡−pe p¡w- ®N¡f¡mf¤l (c£f¤l Q¡Q¡−a¡ ®h¡−el ®R−m) (3) L¡e¡ q¡¢gS p¡w-
®N¡f¡mf¤l (4) p¡m¡j ¢fa¡ N¢e ¢ju¡ p¡w- ®N¡f¡mf¤l (5) ®p¡q¡N p¡w ®N¡f¡mf¤l
(a¡m¤¢Vu¡u AÙ»pq dl¡ f−s) (6) hs lae p¡w ®N¡f¡mf¤l (c£f¤l h¡¢sl p¡−b)
(7) S¡q¡wN£l ¢fa¡ L¡−nj j¡chl p¡w jlL¥e ®VL¡f¡s¡ (8) j¢nEl p¡w ¢jlf¤l,
Y¡L¡ (Be¤l hå¥) Hl¡ Lb¡h¡aÑ¡ hm−Rz Lb¡ h¡aÑ¡l j¡dÉ−j S¡e−a f¡¢l Be¤l hå¥
j¢nEl HLSe ®fn¡c¡l M¤¢ez B¢j J−cl p¡−b 10/15 ¢j¢eV hp¡l f−l
®e¡u¡Ny¡J ú¥m j¡−W ®üµR¡ ®phL m£−Nl ¢j¢Vw H jqm H−p−R h−m ¢j¢Vw ÙÛm
®b−LC jSe¤ ®V¢m−g¡−e −j¡q¡Çjc Bm£−L S¡e¡−m ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£ Bj¡−cl−L
¯al£ q−a h−mz ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£ Bj¡−L .32 ¢limh¡l ¢c−u Be¤−cl p¡−b ®k−a
h−mz Bjl¡ pL−m ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£l h¡¢sl ¢ial ¢c−u hV N¡−Rl e£Q ¢c−u ú¥−ml
¢fR−el ®NCV ¢c−u ¢j¢Vw ÙÛ−ml ®ø−Sl ¢fR−el fcÑ¡l ¢fR−el h¡l¡¾c¡u ®k k¡l
j−a¡ cy¡¢s−u k¡Cz Bj¡−cl pL−ml ¢eLV ®R¡V AÙ» ¢R−m¡z Be¤ mð¡ ¢hd¡u fcÑ¡l
Efli¡N HLV¤ V¡e ¢c−u jq−ml AhÙÛ¡e mrÉ L−lz Bjl¡J HC pju a¡ mrÉ
L¢lz ¢j¢Vw H pÉ¡l (Hj¢f p¡−qh) L¢j¢Vl ¢aeS−el e¡j ®O¡oZ¡l fl pi¡f¢a
j¢Sh¤l pi¡ pj¡¢ç ®O¡oe¡ Ll¡l p¡−b p¡−b ®hm¡ Ae¤j¡e p¡−s h¡−l¡V¡l pju
Be¤ fÐb−j fcÑ¡l ¢fRe ®b−L jqm−L mrÉ L−l …¢m L−lz fl fl Bjl¡ pL−m
HLC ¢en¡e¡u …¢m L¢lz Hj¢f pÉ¡l fÐbj …¢ml fl ö−u f−s j¡¢V−a a¡lfl
Bh¡l c¡¢s−u h−m, “®a¡l¡ L¡l¡ ¢L Ll¢Rp?” HC pju Hj¢f pÉ¡−ll N¡−u …¢m
m¡−N h−m f−l ö−e¢Rz Bjl¡ c¤C HLV¡ g¡yL¡ …¢m Ll−a Ll−a f§−hÑl fb d−l
¢g−l k¡Ju¡l pju ®c¢M Hj¢f pÉ¡l Bqa Hhw j¡−Wl c¢rZ f¡n q−a ®R¡V lae
p¡w B¢lQf¤l h¡ N¡S£h¡¢s ®c¡e¡m¡ L¡V¡ h¾c¤L ¢c−u Ef¢ÙÛa −m¡LS−el ¢c−L
50
…¢m Ll−Rz Bjl¡ â¦a ®lm m¡Ce f¡l q−u hV N¡−Rl e£−Q 3/4 V¡ gy¡L¡ …¢m
R¤y−s q¡−pj j¢õ−Ll ®c¡L¡−el p¡j−e ¢c−u a¡S¤−ml h¡¢sl ¢Qf¡ ¢c−u ®j¡q¡Çjc
Bm£l O−ll ¢eLV ®fy±R¡−m −j¡q¡Çjc Bm£l q¡−al Cn¡l¡u B¢j AeÉ−cl−L
¢VHä¢V’l Ju¡−ml ¢ia−l Y¤¢L−u ®cCz Bj¡l AÙ» ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£l ¢eLV Sj¡
®cCz Hlfl ö¢e ®k, pÉ¡l j¡l¡ ®N−Re Hhw ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£l h¡¢sl HL
i¡s¡¢Vu¡l ®R−m laeJ j¡l¡ ®N−Rz f−l ö¢e Bj¡−cl V¡−NÑV jqmpq …¢m−a
BlJ L−uLSe Bqa q−u−Rz Hlfl B¢j h¡¢s−a m¤¢L−u b¡¢Lz ®j¡q¡Çjc
Bm£l ¢e−cÑ−n B¢j, j¢el, c¤m¡m ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£l hå¥, h¡—¡l h¡h¤l ¢eLV
Bp−m ®p¡jh¡l p¡l¡¢ce A−fr¡ L−l påÉ¡l f−l h¡h¤ L¢hl−L −X−L H®e
Bj¡−cl−L a¡l pw−N ®k−a h−mz Bjl¡ L¢h−ll h¡¢s−a AhÙÛ¡e Ll¡L¡−m
öœ²h¡l ¢h−L−m f¤¢mn Bj¡−cl ¢aeSe−L ®NËga¡l L−lz”
jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌV LaѪL ®lLXÑL«a j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jq−ml jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡ (k¡
flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R)x
Na 07/05/2004 a¡¢lM V‰£l eJN¡ Bx j¢Sc q¡Cú¥m fС‰−e Bj¡−cl
HL¢V L¢j¢V NWe p−Çjme quz I¢ce ¢Rm öœ²h¡lz S¤Çj¡l BS¡−el B−N
p−Çjme ®no quz ¢j¢Vw ®n−o 10 ¢j¢eV MP p¡−q−hl p¡−b S¤Çj¡l e¡j¡S fs−a
k¡h¡l ¢Q¿¹¡i¡he¡ Bjl¡ Ll¢Rm¡jz ÙÛ¡e£u AeÉ¡eÉ ®ea«hª¾c J Bj¡−cl p¡−b
¢R−mez B¢j MP p¡−q−hl f¡−nÄÑ ¢Rm¡jz I pju qW¡v L−l HLcm pnÙ»
®m¡LSe Bj¡−cl−L Bœ²je L−lz B¢j J MP p¡−qh …¢m ®M−u f−s k¡Cz
B¢j j¡¢V−a f−s k¡Cz MP p¡−qh ®Qu¡−ll Efl f−s k¡ez p¿»¡p£l¡
H−m¡f¡b¡¢s …¢m L−lz Bj¡−cl Efl q¡jm¡l fl Bj¡−cl p¡−b b¡L¡ ®m¡LSe
51
f¡¢m−u k¡uz k¡l¡ k¡l¡ Bj¡−cl−L mrÉ L−l …¢m L−l¢Rm a¡l¡ qmx- 1) e¤l
Cpm¡j c£f¤, 2) ¢nf¤, 3) ¢Vf¤, 4) L¡e¡ q¡¢gS, 5) ®p¡q¡N J 6) laez HC 6 Se
R¡s¡J BlJ p¿»¡p£ ¢Rmz a¡−cl Lb¡ HMe Memory ®a Be−a f¡l¢R e¡z HC
Bj¡l hš²hÉz
¢eqa Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f J Jjl g¡l¦L lae Hl p¤laq¡m
¢l−f¡VÑ x
P.W-19 ®j¡x a¢jS E¢Ÿe, p¡h-C¾p−fƒl, Cw 07/05/2004 a¡¢l®M
LÉ¡¾Ve−j¾V b¡e¡u Hp.BC ¢q−p−h LjÑla b¡L¡hÙÛ¡u LÉ¡¾Ve−j¾V b¡e¡l i¡lfСç
LjÑLaÑ¡l ¢e−cÑ−n I a¡¢lM 16.30 ¢j¢e−Vl pju fÐcnÑe£-9 ¢Q¢q²a jªa Bqp¡e
Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢fl p¤laq¡m ¢l−f¡VÑ fÐÙ¹¤a L−lez HC p¤laq¡m ¢l−f¡VÑ
fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, p¤laq¡m ¢l−f¡VÑ °a¢l Ll¡l pju jªa Bqp¡e Eõ¡q
j¡ø¡−ll h¤−Ll Efl X¡e f¡S−ll ¢e−Q, X¡e ®L¡j−ll Ef−l X¡e f¡−n ¢f−Wl
¢c−L, ¢f−W ®jl¦c−äl jdÉM¡−e, h¡j Ly¡−dl e£−Q hN−ml ¢fR−e, ¢f−Wl ¢c−L,
h¡j h¤−Ll e£−Q, h¡j Ly¡−d, h¡j Le¤C−a ¢Râk¤š² (g¥V¡) lš²¡š² SMj f¡Ju¡ k¡uz
fÐcnÑe£-16 ¢Q¢q²a p¤laq¡m ¢l−f¡VÑ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u Cw 07/05/2004
a¡¢lM 16.45 ¢j¢e−Vl pju P.W-25 Hp. BC. Bë¥m L¡¢cl i¥yCu¡ jªa Jjl
g¡l¦L la−el p¤laq¡m ¢l−f¡VÑ fÐÙ¹¤a L−l−Rez HC ¢l−f¡VÑ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u
®k, jª−al b¤a¢el h¡j f¡−n HL¢V ¢Râ SMjpq AeÉ¡eÉ BO¡a B−Rz
¢eqa Jjl g¡l¦L lae Hl jue¡ ac¿¹ ¢l−f¡VÑ x
P.W-22 X¡x ®j¡x L¡jl¦m q¡p¡e plc¡l, Y¡L¡ ®j¢X−Lm L−mS
q¡pf¡a¡−ml g−le¢pL ®j¢X¢pe ¢hi¡−Nl pqL¡l£ AdÉ¡fL Cw 07/05/2004
52
a¡¢lM 5.20 ¢j¢eV Hl pju Le−ØVhm ew 3627 ®j¡x BjS¡c ®q¡−p−el pe¡š²
j−a Jjl g¡l¦L la−el jue¡ac¿¹ pÇfæ L−lez k¡ ¢ejÀl¦fx-
“(1) One entry wound of bullet (1
3 "×
1
3 ") on left side of
the chin 1 1
4 " left lateral to midchin.
On dissection: Trachea, pharynx esophagus and right
cerofid vesseles were found injured. Fracture of mandiable
was found.
One deformed bullet was recovered from back of right
neck under skin 3" above 7" cervical spine and handed over to
escorting police constable.
* Death certificate of DMCH Reg/No-05/2770 is
attached herewith.
Death, in my opinion, was due to haemorrhage and
shock as a result of above mentioned fire arm injury which
was antimortem and homicidal in nature.
¢eqa Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hl jue¡ ac¿¹ ¢l−f¡VÑx
P.W-29 X¡x ®j¡x n¢qc¤m Cpm¡j, Y¡L¡ ®j¢X−Lm L−mS q¡pf¡a¡−ml
g−le¢pL ®j¢X¢pe ¢hi¡−N fÐi¡oL ¢q−p−h LjÑla b¡L¡L¡−m Cw 08/05/2004
Cw a¡¢l−M Le−ØVhm ew 14007 hM¢au¡−ll pe¡š² j−a jªa Bqp¡e Eõ¡q
j¡ø¡−ll jue¡ac¿¹ pÇfæ L−lez HC jue¡ ac¿¹ ¢l−f¡VÑ ¢ejÀl¦f:-
53
“(1) Entry wound of fire arm (3
1″ X
3
1″) present on Lt.
Shoulder 1″ lateral from acromion process of Lt. clavicle ē
corresponding exit wound of fire arm (2
1″ X
3
1″) Present on
postirior chest wall 5″ below and 7″ Lt. from C 7 spine (Not
enter the thoracie cavity)
(2) Entry wound of fire arm (3
1″X
3
1″) present on Lt. lower
chest 9″ below and 7″ Lt. from suprasternal notch ē
corresponding exit wound of fire arm (2
1″X
3
1″) present on Rt.
Post. abdominal wall 43″ above from Rt. heel and 5″ Rt. from
Post. midline.
(3) Entry wound of fire arm (3
1″X
3
1″) present on Rt. lower
chest 9″ below and 7″ Rt. from suprastarnal notch ē
corresponding exit wound of fire arm (2
1″X
3
1″) present on
Post. chest wall 10″ below and 2
1″ Rt. from C 7 spine.
(4) Bruise on both lower chest wall (5″X4″-each).
(5) Abrasions on both elbow ( 12
1″ X 1″-each).
54
Dissection note: Liver, jejunum and ileum were perforated. Rt.
Kidney was bruised. 8th
rib on Lt. side was fractured. Lt.
Shoulder joint was dislocated stomach contained semidigested
food. Death certificate of CMH, Dt. 7/5/04 enclosed here with.
On my opinion death was due to haemorrhage and shock as a
result of above mentioned fire arm injuries which was ante
mortem and homicidal in nature.
Bqa−cl CeS¤¢l ¢l−f¡VÑ Hhw ¢Q¢Lvp¡ ¢hhlZ x
P.W-24 X¡x j¡qh¤h ®j¡l−nc Cw 07/05/2004 a¡¢l−M V‰£ 50 nkÉ¡
¢h¢nø q¡pf¡a¡−m LjÑla b¡L¡hÙÛ¡u c¤f¤l 12.45 ¢j¢e−Vl pju pwpc pcpÉ
Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l, j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm, n¢lg¥¢Ÿe BL¡n−L Bqa AhÙÛ¡u
q¡pf¡a¡−m f¡ez HR¡s¡J 1.10 ¢j¢e−V ®M¡l−nc Bmj−L, 12.50 ¢j¢e−V h¡h¤m
J S¡j¡m−L Bqa AhÙÛ¡u fСç qez HC p¡r£ LaѪL fÐcš p¡¢VÑ¢g−LV
fÐcnÑe£- 19 ¢ejÀl¦fx
(1)
This is to Certify that Mr. Mahfuzur Rahman Mahal,
age about 36 years S/O. Majibur Rahman Sikder of
Aouchpara, Tongi, Gazipur was brought at emergency Deptt.
of Tongi 50 Beded Hospital, Tongi, Gazipur at 12-45 P.M. on
07.05.04 ē Bullet Injury over Front & Back of the chest wall ē
55
external bleeding. Patient was Conscious during his arrival &
stay in the Emergency Deptt. (E.Reg No. 2192/26)
Following Treatment were given in the emergency
Deptt. of Tongi 50 Beded Hospital, Tongi, Gazipur.
Cleaning, Dressing of wound.
5% DNS 1000 CC i.v. stat at a mate of 30d/m.
Oradem- 2ap i.v. stat was given
Neotack- 1ap i.v. stat was given
Immediately patient was referred to Chest Disease
Hospital, Mohakhali/ DMCH Dhaka Medical College Hospital
for Proper management.
Nature of Injury- Grievous in nature.
Cause of Injury-Bullet injury.
(2)
This to Certify that Mr. Sharifuddin, age about 35 years
of Arichpur, Tongi, was broughgt in the emergency Deptt. of
Tongi, 50 beded Hospital, Tongi, Gazipur on 07.05.04 at 12-
45 P.M. (E.Reg No. 2193/27 Date 7.5.04) ē History of Bullet
injury causing open # Humerus (E Reg. No. 2193/27)
Following Treatment were given in the emergency
Deppartment.
56
1. Cleaning, Dressing & Bandaging of wound.
2. 5% DNS 1000 CC i.v. stat was given.
Immediately patient was referred to Dhaka Medical
College Hospital/Pangu Hospital Dhaka for proper
management.
Patient was conscious & General condition was normal.
(3)
This is to Certify that Mr. Khorshed Alam age about 30
years S/O. Jahur Ali of Masimpur, Tongi, Gazipur was
brought in the emergency Deptt. of Tongi, 50 Beded Hospital
Tongi, Gazipur at 1-10 P.M. on 07.05.04 H/O Bullet injury
causing abrasion over (L) thigh. Patient was Conscious &
general Condition were normal.
following Treatment were given in the emergency
Deptt. (E Reg. No. 2196/30)
Dressing, Cleaning, Bandaging of wound.
5% DNS 1000 CC i.v. stat was given
Oradexon 2ap i.v. stat.
Nature of injury- Simple in nature.
Cause of injury-Bullet injury.
57
(4)
This is to Certify that Bablu age about 12 years S/O.
Abdur Rouf of Noagaon, Tongi, Gazipur was Brought at
emergency Deptt. of Tongi 50 Beded Hospital Tongi, Gazipur
at 12-50 P.M on 07.05.04 ē Bullet injury over head ē head
injury ē Unconsciousness. (E Reg. No. 2195/29)
Following Treatment were given in the emergency
Deptt. of Tongi, 50 Beded hospital, Tongi, Gazipur.
Cleaning, Dressing & Bandaging of wound.
5% DNS 1000 CC i.v. stat was given
Oradexon- 2ap i.v. stat.
0/2 Inhalation stat was given.
Immediately patient was refered to Dhaka Medical
College Hospital, Dhaka for proper management of head
injury.
Nature of injury-Greivious in nature.
Cause of injury-Bullet Injury.
(5)
This is to Certify that Mr. Jamal age about 30 years
S/O. A Karim of Amtali, Tongi, Gazipur was brought in the
emergency Deptt. of Tangi, 50 Beded Hospital, Tange,
58
Gazipur at 12-50 P.M on 7.5.04 e History of Bullet Injury over
Scalp ē No sign of Head Injury. Patient was conscious & his
general condition was normal.
Following Treatment were given in the emergency
Deptt. (E Reg. No. 2194/28)
Dressing, Cleaning & Bandaging of wound.
Oradexon 2ap i.v. stat was given
5% DNS 1000 CC i.v stat was given
Immediately patient was refered to DMCH Emergency
for proper management & Investigation (X-Ray skull, CT
Scan of Brain).
g−le¢pL hÉ¡−m¢øL ¢l−f¡VÑ x
P.W-33 ac¿¹L¡l£ LjÑLaÑ¡ ®j¡x M¡−mL¥‹¡j¡e LaѪL fÐcnÑe£-38
¢Q¢q²a g−le¢pL hÉ¡−m¢øL ¢l−f¡−VÑ fСç Bm¡ja pj§q J fÐcš ja¡ja ¢ejÀl¦f x
Bm¡ja pj§qx
1) Ae¤j¡e 9.10 ¢jV¡l mð¡ Hhw 2.15 ¢jV¡l fÐÙÛ HL Mä f−mø¡l
L¡f−sl fcÑ¡-k¡q¡l A−dÑL Awn p¡c¡ h¡L£ A−dÑL e£m lw, j¡T M¡−e −pm¡C Ll¡z
p¡c¡ Aw−nl fСu jdÉi¡−N Ef¢l Aw−n (30^13 ®px¢jx) Bua−el j−dÉ fl fl
12(h¡l) ¢V ¢Râ l¢qu¡−Rz ¢Râ…¢m HL−œ “L” ¢Q¢q²az
2) 4(Q¡l)¢V ph¤S lw−ul ¢ø−ml ®hÔXk¤š² HL¢V fÉ¡XØV¡m gÉ¡e-k¡q¡l
HL¢V ®hÔ−X fСu 1/3^1/2 C¢’ ¢Râ B−Rz Eš² ¢R−âl f¡−nC AeÉ HL¢V
59
BO¡−al ¢Qq² −cM¡ k¡uz gÉ¡e¢V f¡¢LÙ¹¡−el °al£, 14 C¢’, L¡S£ fÉ¡−XØV¡m
LÉ¡f¡¢pVl gÉ¡ez ®hÔ−Xl ¢Râ¢V−L “M” J BO¡−al ¢Qq²¢V−L ‘M-1’ ¢Q¢q²a Ll¡z
B¢j Ef−l¡š² Bm¡japj§q fl£r¡ L¢lu¡¢Rz Bj¡l fl£r¡ ¢i¢šL
L¡kÑœ²j ¢ejÀl¦fx-
œ²¢jL ew-1 Hl Bm¡ja¢V HL¢V fcÑ¡l L¡fsz ‘L’ ¢Q¢q²a ÙÛ¡−e 12¢V
¢R−âl fÐ−aÉL¢Vl ¢Le¡l¡, d¡l, hÔ¡−L¢ew J V¤C¢øw fl£r¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k ¢Râ …¢m
B−NÀu¡−Ù»l …¢ml à¡l¡ pªøz
œ²¢jL ew 2 Hl Bm¡ja¢V HL¢V 4 ®hÔXk¤š² ØV¡ä gÉ¡ez k¡q¡l HL¢V
®hÔ−X HL¢V ¢Râ J Afl BO¡a¢V B−NÀu¡−Ù»l …¢m à¡l¡ pªøz
œ²¢jL ew-1 Hl Bm¡j−al N¡−u B−NÀu¡Ù» pªø …¢ml ¢Râpj§q fÐ−u¡Se£u
V¡−NÑV fl£r¡ J Ae¤h£re k−¿»l p¡q¡−kÉ a¥me¡j§mL fl£r¡ L¢lz œ²¢jL ew-2 Hl
Bm¡j−al N¡−u B−NÀu¡Ù» pªø …¢ml ¢Râ J c¡N fÐ−u¡Se£u fl£r¡ L¢lz ‘L’
¢Q¢q²a ÙÛ¡−e 12¢V ¢R−âl fÐ−aÉL¢Vl ¢Le¡l¡, d¡l, hÔ¡−L¢ew J V¤C¢øw fl£r¡
®j¡a¡−hL fСç ja¡ja ¢ejÀl¦fx-
ja¡ja x
1| µwgK bs 1 Gi Avjvg‡Zi ÔKÕ wPwýZ ’v‡bi 10 (`k) wU wQ`ª
.32/7.65 GgGg K¨vj wifjevi/¢fÙ¹m nB‡Z ¢e¢rç ey‡j‡Ui AvNv‡Z m„ó|
2| µwgK bs 1 Gi Avjvg‡Zi ÔKÕ wPwýZ ’v‡bi 2 ( yB) wU wQ ª
.22 K¨vj wifjevi/¢fÙ¹m/Av‡Mœqv ¿ nB‡Z ¢e¢rç ey‡j‡Ui AvNv‡Z m„ó hvnv Avwg
ÔMÕ I ÔM-1Õ wPwýZ Kwi|
60
3| µwgK bs 2 Gi ÔLÕ I ÔL-1Õ wPwýZ wQ ª `vM .32/7.65 GgGg
K¨vj Av‡Mœqv‡ ¿i ¸wji AvNv‡Z m„ó|
4| µwgK bs 1 Gi ÔKÕ wPwýZ ’v‡bi 3wU ¸wj 0.1 wgt nB‡Z 0.5 wgt
c¤laÅ nB‡Z dvqvi Kiv nBqv‡Q| .32 K¨vj dvqvW© ey‡jUwU µwgK bs 1 Gi .32
†ev‡ii wifjfviwU nB‡Z dvqvi Kiv nBqv‡Q hvnv Avwg ÔNÕ, ÔN-1Õ I ÔN-2Õ
wPwýZ Kwi|
5| µwgK bs-1 Gi ÔKÕ wPwýZ ’v‡bi 1wU ¸wj 0.00 wgt nB‡Z 0.05 wgt
c¤laÅ nB‡Z dvqvi Kiv nBqv‡Q hvnv ÔOÕ wPwýZ Kwi|
6| µwgK b-1 Gi ÔKÕ wPwýZ ’v‡bi 8wU ¸wj 1.0 wgt nB‡Z 5.00 wgt
c¤laÅ nB‡Z dvqvi Kiv nBqv‡Q|
7| µwgK bs-2 Gi ÔLÕ wPwýZ wQ`ªwU cÖvq 0.5 wgt Gi ÔL-1Õ wPwýZ wQ ªwU
1.0 wgt Gi †ekx c¤laÅ nB‡Z dvqvi Kivi d‡j nBqv‡Q|
OVe¡ÙÛ−ml Mps¡ j¡e¢Qœ J p§Q£fœ x
P.W-32 e¤l Bq−jc OVe¡ÙÛm ®e¡u¡Ny¡J EµQ ¢hcÉ¡mu, plL¡¢l fСb¢jL
¢hcÉ¡m−ul j¡−Wl Mps¡ j¡e¢Qœ p§Q£ fÐcnÑe£-32 ¢q−p−h Hhw P.W-33 −j¡x
M¡−mL¥‹¡j¡e osk¿»ÙÛm Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m B¢j−el h¡s£l Mps¡ j¡e¢Qœp§Q£ fÐcnÑe£-
34 ¢q−p−h ¢Q¢q²a L−lez
Ef−l¡š² hÙ¹¤ fÐcnÑe£, p¤laq¡m ¢l−f¡VÑ, jue¡ac¿¹ ¢l−f¡VÑ, hÉ¡−m¢øL ¢l−f¡VÑ,
CeS¤¢l ¢l−f¡VÑ J AeÉ¡eÉ ¢hou¡¢c fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u p¤Øføi¡−h fÐj¡¢Za qu ®k, OVe¡l
¢ce OVe¡ÙÛ−m ¢e¢hÑQ¡−l …¢mhoÑZ Ll¡ qu Hhw HC …¢mhoÑ−Zl L¡l−Z …¢m¢hÜ q−u
N¡S£f¤−ll A¢hpwh¡¢ca ®ea¡ Hj,¢f Se¡h Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hhw qai¡NÉ
61
17 hRl huú al¦Z Jjl g¡l¦L lae jªa¥ÉhlZ L−lz p−hÑ¡f¢l j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e
jqm, ®j¡x ®M¡l−ncpq E−õ¢Ma hÉ¢š²NZ …¢m¢hÜ q−u Bqa quz
A¢ik¤š²−cl fr ®b−L OVe¡l a¡¢l®M OVe¡ÙÛ−m ¢e¢hÑQ¡−l …¢mhoÑ−Z
…¢m¢hÜ q−u N¡S£f¤−ll Hj,¢f Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l, Jjl g¡l¦L lae jªa¥ÉhlZ
L−l H ¢ho−u ®L¡e ¢h−l¡¢da¡ Ll¡ qu¢ez
H AhÙÛ¡u HLj¡œ ¢h−hQÉ ®k, c¢äa Bp¡j£NZ OVe¡l pj−u, ÙÛ¡−e,
h¢ZÑa fÐL¡−l ¢e¢hÑQ¡−l …¢mhoÑZ L−l HC qaÉ¡L¡ä OV¡u ¢Le¡ Hhw A¢ik¤š²NZ
HC OVe¡ OV¡−e¡l SeÉ f§hÑ f¢lL¢Òfa j−a Afl¡dj§mL osk¿» L−l¢Rm ¢Le¡?
Ef−l E¢õ¢Ma p¡rÉ fÐj¡Z¡¢c fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma ¢eqa
Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f Hhw ¢eqa Jjl g¡l¦L lae−L f¢lLÒfe¡ J
Afl¡dj§mL osk−¿»l j¡dÉ−j qaÉ¡l A¢i−k¡−N cä¢h¢dl 302/120M/34 d¡l¡u
1) e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l, 2) e¤l¦m Cpm¡j ¢cf¤, 3) ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£, 4) j¡qh¤h¤l
lqj¡e j¡qh¤h, 5) B¢jl, 6) °puc Bq−jc jSe¤, 7) S¡q¡‰£l Jl−g hs
S¡q¡‰£l, ¢fa¡- e§l ®q¡−pe NZ−L jªa¥Éc−ä c¢äa L−lez
Afl¢c−L, Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f Hhw Jjl g¡l¦L lae−L qaÉ¡
Ll¡l A¢i−k¡−N cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u ®c¡o£ p¡hÉ−Ù¹ Bp¡j£ 8) n¢qc¤m
Cpm¡j ¢nf¤, 9) q¡¢gS Jl−g L¡e¡ q¡¢gS, 10) B−e¡u¡l ®q¡−pe Jl−g Be¤,
11) gup¡m, 12) ®p¡q¡N Jl−g pl¦, 13) ®m¡Lj¡e ®q¡−pe Jl−g h¤m¤, 14)
Bm-B¢je, 15) lae ¢ju¡ Jl−g hs ¢ju¡, 16) l¢Z ¢ju¡ Jl−g l¢Z g¢Ll,
17) S¡q¡‰£l, ¢fa¡- L¡−nj j¡chl, 18) lae Jl−g ®R¡V lae, 19) Bh¤ p¡m¡j
62
Jl−g p¡m¡j, 20) j¢nEl lqj¡e Jl−g jö, 21) ®M¡Le Hhw 22) c¤m¡m
¢ju¡NZ−L jªa¥Éc−ä c¢äa L−lez
HR¡s¡J, Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f Hhw ¢eqa Jjl g¡l¦L Jl−g
lae−L qaÉ¡l Afl¡dj§mL osk−¿» ®c¡o£ p¡hÉÙ¹f§hÑL Bp¡j£ 23) l¡¢Lh E¢Ÿe
plL¡l Jl−g f¡è¤ plL¡l, 24) Bu¤h Bm£, 25) S¡q¡‰£l, ¢fa¡-®j−ql Bm£,
26) e¤l¦m B¢je NZ−L cä¢h¢dl 302/120M/34 d¡l¡u ®c¡o£ p¡hÉÙ¹œ²−j
k¡h‹£he L¡l¡cä J 50,000/-(f’¡n q¡S¡l) V¡L¡ S¢lj¡e¡ Ae¡c¡−u B−l¡
HL hvp−ll pnÐj L¡l¡c−ä c¢äa L−lez Hhw ¢eqa Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f
J lae−L qaÉ¡ Ll¡l A¢i−k¡N fÐj¡¢Za qJu¡u Bp¡j£ 27) j¢el J 28) A¢qc¤m
Cpm¡j ¢Vf¤ NZ−L cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u ®c¡o£ p¡hÉÙ¹œ²−j k¡h‹£he L¡l¡cä
J 50,000/- (f’¡n q¡S¡l) V¡L¡ S¢lj¡e¡ Ae¡c¡−u B−l¡ HL hvpl pnÐj
L¡l¡c−ä c¢äa L−lez
L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 374 d¡l¡l ¢hd¡e j−a, cä¢h¢dl 302/120M/34 d¡l¡u
jªa¥ÉcäfСç Bp¡j£ 1) e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l, 2) e¤l¦m Cpm¡j ¢cf¤, 3) ®j¡q¡Çjc
Bm£, 4) j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h, 5) B¢jl, 6) °puc Bq−jc jSe¤, 7) S¡q¡‰£l
Jl−g hs S¡q¡‰£l, ¢fa¡- e§l ®q¡−pe Hhw cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥ÉcäfСç
Bp¡j£ 8) n¢qc¤m Cpm¡j ¢nf¤, 9) q¡¢gS Jl−g L¡e¡ q¡¢gS, 10) B−e¡u¡l
®q¡−pe Jl−g Be¤, 11) gup¡m, 12) ®p¡q¡N Jl−g pl¦, 13) ®m¡Lj¡e ®q¡−pe
Jl−g h¤m¤, 14) Bm-B¢je, 15) lae ¢ju¡ Jl−g hs ¢ju¡, 16) l¢Z ¢ju¡ Jl−g
l¢Z g¢Ll, 17) S¡q¡‰£l, ¢fa¡- L¡−nj j¡chl, 18) lae Jl−g ®R¡V lae, 19)
Bh¤ p¡m¡j Jl−g p¡m¡j, 20) j¢nEl lqj¡e Jl−g jö, 21) ®M¡Le Hhw 22)
63
c¤m¡m ¢ju¡ N−Zl jªa¥Écä¡−cn Q§s¡¿¹Ll−Zl SeÉ HC ®Xb ®lg¡−l¾p¢V EfÙÛ¡¢fa
quz
Afl¢c−L c¢äa Bp¡j£ c¤m¡m ¢ju¡ Jl−g c¤m¡m ®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew
1452/2005 p¡−b ®Sm Bf£m 415/2005,
j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h ®g±Sc¡l£
Bf£m ew 1513/2005 p¡−b ®Sm Bf£m ew 410/2005,
1) BCu¤h Bm£, 2) l¡¢Lh E¢Ÿe plL¡l Jl−g f¡è¤ plL¡l Hhw 3)
e¤l¦m B¢je Jl−g B¢je ®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew 1515/2005,
®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£ ®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew 1572/2005 p¡−b ®Sm Bf£m ew
412/2005,
®p¡q¡N Jl−g pl¦ ®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew 1703/2005 p¡−b −Sm Bf£m
ew 411/2005,
e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l ®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew 1739/2005 p¡−b ®Sm
Bf£m ew 409/2005,
j¢el ®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew 1808/2005,
S¡q¡‰£l Jl−g hs S¡q¡‰£l Jl−g juje¢pwq¡ S¡q¡‰£l ®g±Sc¡l£
Bf£m ew 1813/2005 p¡−b ®Sm Bf£m ew 413/2005,
B¢jl Jl−g B¢jl ®q¡−pe ®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew 1844/2005 p¡−b
®Sm Bf£m ew 414/2005,
S¡q¡‰£l Jl−g ®j¡x S¡q¡‰£l Bmj ¢fa¡- ®j−ql Bm£ ®g±Sc¡l£
Bf£m ew 1845/2005,
64
lae Jl−g ®R¡V lae ®Sm Bf£m ew 1189/2006 ®b−L Eá¥a
®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew 2862/2007,
lae Jl−g hs lae Jl−g hs ¢ju¡ Jl−g lae ¢ju¡ ®Sm Bf£m ew
139/2010 q−a Eá¥a ®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew 8330/2010,
Bh¤ p¡m¡j Jl−g p¡m¡j ®g±Sc¡l£ ¢h¢hd ew 14222/2005 p−‰ ®Sm
Bf£m ew 1322/2005,
n¢qc¤m Cpm¡j ¢nf¤ ®g±Sc¡l£ ¢h¢hd ew 10842/2006,
®m¡Lj¡e ®q¡−pe ®g±Sc¡l£ ¢h¢hd ew 41411/2014,
q¡¢gS Jl−g L¡e¡ q¡¢gS ®Sm Bf£m ew 295/2007,
Hhw Bm-B¢je ®Sm Bf£m ew 959/2007 c¡−ul L−lz
¢eÖf¢šl p¤¢hd¡−bÑ ®Xb ®lg¡−l−¾pl p¡−b H pLm ®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m,
®Sm Bf£m, ®g±Sc¡l£ ¢h¢hd j¡jm¡…¢m HL−œ öe¡e£ J l¡u fÐc¡−el SeÉ NËqZ
Ll¡ quz
l¡øÌfr ®b−L ®Xb ®lg¡−l¾p¢V ¢h‘ ®Xf¤¢V HÉ¡VeÑ£ ®Se¡−lm ¢jp l¦e¡
e¡q¢le HÉ¡e£ EfÙÛ¡fe L−lez a¡−L pq−k¡¢Na¡ L−le ¢h‘ pqL¡l£ HÉ¡VeÑ£
®Se¡−lm Se¡h h¢nl Bq−jc, ¢h‘ pqL¡l£ HÉ¡VeÑ£ ®Se¡−lm ¢jp j”¤ e¡S¢ee,
¢h‘ pqL¡l£ HÉ¡VeÑ£ ®Se¡−lm ¢jp Cu¡p¢je ®hNj ¢h¢b z ¢h‘ −Xf¤¢V HÉ¡VeÑ£
®Se¡−lm ¢jp l¦e¡ e¡q¢le HÉ¡e£ −Xb ®lg¡−l¾p¢V EfÙÛ¡f−el pju pjNË ¢houhÙ¹¤
¢e−u HL¢V p¡l pw−rf Bc¡m−a c¡¢Mm L−lez
−Xb ®lg¡−l¾p¢V EfÙÛ¡f−el fl c¢äa Bp¡j£N−Zl fr ®b−L k¤¢š²aLÑ
öe¡e£ öl¦ quz
65
c¢äa Bp¡j£N−Zl f−r k¤¢š²a−LÑl pw¢rç ¢hhlZ ¢ejÀl¦fx
jªa¥ÉcäfСç Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l ®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew
1739/2005 Hhw ®Sm Bf£m ew 409/2005 c¡−ul L−lz HC Bp¡j£−L ¢h‘
¢ejÀ Bc¡ma cä¢h¢dl 302/120M/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥Écä¡−cn fÐc¡e L−lez
HC Bp¡j£f−r Bc¡m−al p¡j−e phÑ−SÉù ¢p¢eul ¢h‘ BCeS£h£
Se¡h ¢V.HCQ.M¡e, ¢h‘ ¢p¢eul BCeS£h£ Se¡h H. ®S ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£, ¢h‘
BCeS£h£ Se¡h M¤l¢nc Bmj M¡e Hhw ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ Se¡h ®j¡x jDe¤¢Ÿe
k¤¢š²aLÑ EfÙÛ¡fe L−lez
HC k¤¢š²a−LÑl p¡lpw−rf qmx
fÐbjax OVe¡l fСu 35 O¾V¡ fl Cw 08/05/2004 a¡¢l−M HS¡q¡lL¡l£
P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e ®k HS¡q¡l c¡−ul L−l−R ®pM¡−e 17 Se Bp¡j£l
e¡j p¤Øføi¡−h E−õM b¡L−mJ HC Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM ¢Rm e¡z HS¡q¡−ll N−iÑ
HC Bp¡j£l f§hÑ f¢lLÒfe¡ j−a HC qaÉ¡L¡ä¢V OV¡−e¡ q−u−R j−jÑ HL
L¡Òf¢eL Ae¤j¡e ¢eiÑl hš²hÉ ®cu¡ q−u−R, k¡ NËqZ −k¡NÉ euz
¢àa£uax Afl c¢äa Bp¡j£ j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡
Jl−g j¡qh¤h L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡u ®k L¢ba ü£L¡−l¡¢š² fÐc¡e L−l−R a¡
®üQR¡fÐ−Z¡¢ca, p¢WL (voluntarily and true) euz p−hÑ¡f¢l HC L¢ba
ü£L¡−l¡¢š² ®k−qa¥ AeÉ¡eÉ p¤Øfø J f¡¢lf¡¢nÑÄL p¤¢e¢cÑø p¡rÉ fÐj¡Z¡¢c à¡l¡
pj¢bÑa eu ®p−qa¥ c¢äa Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l Hl Efl HC ü£L¡−l¡¢š²
fÐ−k¡SÉ euz
66
a«a£uax c¢äa Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l ü£L«a j−a L¢ba pj−u
OVe¡ÙÛ−m Ef¢ÙÛa ¢Rme¡z
Qa¥bÑax cä¢h¢dl 120M d¡l¡l p¡−b 34 d¡l¡ pw−k¡S−e ®k cä¡−cn
fÐc¡e Ll¡ q−u−R a¡ BCe¢pÜ euz
f’jax c¢äa Bp¡j£ j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h
LaѪL L¢ba ü£L¡−l¡¢š² fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u f¡Ju¡ k¡−h ¢eqa Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l J
Jjl g¡l¦L lae−L M¤e Ll¡l −L¡e f§hÑ f¢lLÒfe¡ h¡ Afl¡dj§mL osk−¿»l
¢hou −pM¡−e E−õM ®eCz
oùax P.W-3 −j¡x Bh¤m L¡−nj, P.W-34 q¡¢gS¤l lqj¡e q¡¢hh,
P.W-11 ®j¡x S¡j¡m Hhw P.W-12 −j¡x g¢lc E¢Ÿe flha£Ñ−a pªø p¡r£
(after thought created witness.)
pçja x phÑ−SÉù ¢p¢eul ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ Se¡h ¢V.HCQ.M¡e h−me ®k,
jªa¥Éc−äl ®r−œ fТa¢V ¢ce ¢h−hQe¡−k¡NÉ, ®pM¡−e p§c£OÑ 11 hRlL¡m c¢äa
Bp¡j£ ®Xb−pm H AhÙÛ¡e Ll−Rz
phÑ−nox c¢äa Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l−L ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma ®k
jªa¥Écä¡−cn fÊc¡e L−l−Re a¡ Ef−l¡š² L¡l−Z lcl¢qa ®k¡NÉz
c¢äa Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l f−r ¢h‘ BCeS£h£NZ a¡y−cl
k¤¢š²a−LÑl pjbÑ−e ®hn¢LR¤ eS£l EfÙÛ¡fe L−lez H pLm eS£l qmx
67
Afl¡dj¤mL f¢lLÒfe¡ J osk¿» fÐp−‰ (Criminal conspiracy)
59 DLR (HC), page 345-378, para 144 The State Vs. Kajal
Ahmed Jalali j¡jm¡l eS£lx-
“Criminal conspiracy as defined in section 120A of the
Penal Code is an agreement between two or more persons to
commit a criminal offence. So, prosectution is to prove by
preponderance of evidence that there was a meeting of minds
amongst the accused persons having common programme to
work together in furtherance of such common design. It is
some sort of integrated united effort to achieve the common
offensive purpose.”
L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡u ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£ ®lLXÑ fÐp−‰ x
2 Exp (AD) Page 149-155 The State Vs. Jahedul
Islam Moulavi Banu j¡jm¡l eS£lx-
“Section 164 of the Code of Criminal Procedure:
Confessional statement under Section 164 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure not acceptable when the said confession
recorded extracted by force or under any intimidation by any
police torture.”
68
20 BLC (HC) 120-150 The State Vs. Peto Lasker alias
Liakat Ali Lasker and others j¡jm¡l eS£lx-
“Magistrate accordingly recorded his confessional
statement under Section 164 of the Code and on the other
hand, the Investigating Officer, the P.W-29 took the other
accused Peto Lasker on remand twice for six days and
thereafter produced him before the learned Magistrate for
recording his confession and the Magistrate duly recorded his
confession under Section 164 of the Code but subsequently the
Peto Lasker and Sumon Munshi retracted their confession and
filed retraction petitions before the Court concerned stating
that the Investigating Officer, the P.W-29 forced them to make
confessions by torturing them physically though the
Investigating Officer in his cross-examination denied the
suggestion of torturing the accused physically and on the other
hand the confession recording Magistrate, the P.W-30 in cross
examination also denied the suggestion of seeing any injury on
the person of the accused. The confessions made by the
accused Sumon Munshi and Peto Lasker were not voluntary.”
69
45 DLR (HC) page 142-147 Nazrul Islam and others
Vs. The State j¡jm¡l eS£lx-
“When an accused is under threat of being sent back to
the police remand he is likely to make confession out of fear.
His statement in such a position should not be considered as
voluntary.”
59 DLR (HC) page 73-97 para 74 The State Vs. Md.
Roushan Mondal alias Hashem j¡jm¡l eS£lx-
“The confessional statement could not be said to be
voluntary since it was recorded three days after the accused
was arrested and certainly after illegal detention in police
custody.”
p¡rÉ BC−el 30 d¡l¡ pÇf−LÑ x
63 DLR (HC) page 242-252 Nuru Miah and others
Vs. The State j¡jm¡l eS£lx-
“Confession of a co-accused cannot be the sole basis to
convict the other of the co-accused in absence of other
corroborative evidence.”
70
18 BLD (AD) page 43-46 para 6 Ustar Ali Vs. The
State Hl eS£lx-
“Section 30 of the Evidence Act provides that the
confession of a co-accused can be taken into consideration to
lend assurance to other substantive evidence on record but it
never says that such confession amounts to proof. In the
instant case there being no substantive evidence either direct
or circumstantial implicating the appellant in the alleged
murder or in the abatement of the same except as to some
evidence about the motive or the offence the High Court
Division was wrong in treating the confessional statement of
the co-accused as substantive evidence and treating the
evidence of P.Ws-4 and 7 as corroboration thereof.”
8 MLR (HC) 409-419, para 31 Khokon Vs. The State
j¡jm¡l eS£lx-
“Confessional statement of an accused is no evidence
and cannot be used against co-accused without independent
corroborative evidence.”
71
p¡rÉ BC−el 3 J 30 d¡l¡ fÐp−‰x
6 MLR (HC) 237-242, para 15 Abu Sayed Vs. The
State j¡jm¡l eS£lx-
“Evidentiary value of confessional statement of an
accused recorded under Section 30 of the Evidence Act, 1872
is not an evidence within the meaning of Section 3 of the
Evidence Act. Confessional statement of an accused cannot be
used against another co-accused without independent
corroborative evidence.”
L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 161 d¡l¡ pÇf−LÑx
6 BCR (AD) page 225-230 Bangladesh (State) Vs.
Paran Chandra Baroi j¡jm¡l eS£lx-
“The long delay in examining the material witnesses
cast a doubt on the whole prosecution case.”
61 DLR (HC) page 54-71 para 64 Shahabuddin Vs.
The State j¡jm¡l eS£lx-
“Investigating Officer did not assign any reason for the
long delay in examining the P.Ws. Delay in examining the
witnesses under Section 161 of the Code is fatal to prosecution
case and statements of witnesses are required to be left out of
consideration.”
72
59 DLR (HC) page 653-683 para 61 State Vs. Al-
Hasib Bin Zamal alias Hasib and five others j¡jm¡l eS£lx-
“Inordinate delay in examining the important
prosecution witnesses cast a serious doubt as to the truth of the
prosecution case and in the circumstances their evidence
cannot be relied on and are to be left out of consideration.”
p¡rÉ BC−el 114 ¢S d¡l¡ pÇf−LÑ x
57 DLR (HC) page 289-298, para 20 The State Vs.
Nazrul Islam alias Nazrul j¡jm¡l eS£lx-
“If the defence version lends support from the
prosecution witnesses in course of their cross examination or
any indication is inferred in the course of their cross
examination the accused is entitled to get the benefit of
doubt.”
57 DLR (HC) page 513-546 para 82 Kazi
Mahbubuddin Ahmed alias Mahbub Vs. The State j¡jm¡l
eS£lx-
“Witnesses, as Bentham said, are eyes and ears of
Justice. Non examination of material witnesses shall give rise
to a strong presumption against prosecution case.”
73
13 BLC (2008) page 354-364 para 56 Isahaque Ali
(Md) and others Vs. The State j¡jm¡l eS£lx-
“It was desirable for the prosecution to examine the
independent and distinterested neighbours. In the face of clear
admission that 100/150 persons reside around the alleged
place of occurrenc, none of them were made witnesses and
whereas the enemies of the accused and the relatives of the
informant were only made witnesses. There is no other
alternative but to hold that had the independent and
disinterested neighbours been examined, they would not have
supported the prosecution case and the actual facts of the case
would come out. In view of this matter the benefit of Section
114(g) of the Evidence Act shall go in favour of the defence.”
cä¢h¢dl 34 d¡l¡ pÇf−LÑx
36 DLR (1984) page 22-27 para 11 Nazimuddin and
another Vs. The State j¡jm¡l eS£lx-
“Common object as envisaged under Section 34 can
develop even at the time of occurrence-It is at the same time
essential that the acused person must be physically present
when the crime was being committed and the incriminating
74
acts and circumstances lead to the conclusion about their
common intention to commit the crime.”
29 DLR (SC) page 246-250 Md. Abdur Rahim
Mondal Vs. The State j¡jm¡l eS£lx-
“In furtherance of a common intention “indicates pre-
arranged plan-Such plan in the sense of previous distinct plan
need not be proved-A common intention may develop on the
spot between the participants. To apply S. 34 the person must
be physically present at the actual commission of the crime.”
PLD (1961) (W.P) Lah. page 348-360 Muhammad
Akbar Vs. The State j¡jm¡l eS£lx-
“Common intention can be formed on spur of moment
and can be inferred from surrounding circumstances-person
killed by one of the shots fired by gunmen simultaneously-
Each of them guilty under Section 302/34-mere presence of
person at time of commission of offence-not sufficient to
prove common intention.”
75
c¢äa Bp¡j£ j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h
f−r ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ Se¡h M¤l¢nc Bmj M¡e k¤¢š²aLÑ EfÙÛ¡fe L−lez ay¡l k¤¢š²
a−LÑl p¡l pw−rf ¢ejÀl¦fx-
fÐbjax ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ c¢äa Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l f−rl
k¤¢š²aLÑ HÉ¡−X¡ÃV L−lez
¢àa£uax Cw 14/05/2004 a¡¢l−M c¢äa Bp¡j£ ®j¡x j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e
j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h®L ®NÊga¡−ll fl Aj¡e¤¢oL ¢ekÑ¡ae
Q¡¢m−u S£hee¡−nl q§j¢L ¢c−u Cw 23/05/2004 a¡¢l−M L¢ba ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL
Sh¡eh¾c£¢V ®lLXÑ Ll¡ qu k¡ üaxfÐ−Z¡¢ca Hhw paÉ (valuntarily and
true) euz H fÐp−‰ ¢a¢e 63 DLR (AD) page 10 Hl eS£l EfÙÛ¡fe
L−lez
a«a£uax L¢ba ü£L¡−l¡¢š² j−a, L¢ba osk¿» pi¡u HC Bp¡j£l p¢œ²u
Awn NËqZ ¢Rme¡z
Qa¤bÑax L¢ba ü£L¡−l¡¢š² j−a, OVe¡l pj−u “Bjl¡ pL−m …¢m L¢l”
E−õM L−le Ab¡Ñv L¡l …¢m−a HC qaÉ¡L¡ä pwO¢Va q−u−R a¡ p¤Øfø eu, k¡l
p¤¢hd¡ (benefit) Bp¡j£ f¡−hz
phÑ−nox j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h LaѪL
fÐc¡eL«a L¢ba ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£¢V ¢a¢e flha£Ñ−a fÐaÉ¡q¡l L−le Hhw
D.W-3 ¢le¡ p¤ma¡e¡ Hl p¡rÉ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, HC ü£L¡−l¡¢š²¢V
®üµR¡fÐ−Z¡¢ca J paÉ (valuntarily and true) eu Hhw HC
76
ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£¢V ¢el−fr p¡rÉ fÐj¡Z à¡l¡ pj¢bÑa e¡ qJu¡u c¢äa
Bp¡j£l cä¡−cn lcl¢qa ®k¡NÉz
c¢äa Bp¡j£ c¤m¡m ¢ju¡ Jl−g c¤m¡m f−r ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ Se¡h
p¡Cg¥¢Ÿe j¡qj¤c ay¡l k¤¢š²aLÑ EfÙÛ¡fe L−le, k¡l p¡lpw−rf ¢ejÀl¦fx
fÐbjax c¢äa Bp¡j£ c¤m¡m ¢ju¡ Jl−g c¤m¡m Hl e¡j HS¡q¡−l E−õM
b¡L−mJ a¡l ¢hl¦−Ü HS¡q¡−l ®L¡e p¤¢e¢cÑø A¢i−k¡N Be¡ qu¢ez
¢àa£uax c¢äa Bp¡j£l ¢hl¦−Ü P.W- 4 ®j¡x Bj¡e E¢Ÿe
plL¡l,P.W-5 ®j¡x ®M¡l−nc Bmj, P.W-6 ®j¡x BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j j¡p¤j,
Hhw P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc p¡rÉ fÐc¡e L−l−R ¢L¿º ¢h‘ BCeS£h£
h−me ®k, HC pLm p¡r£NZ Bc¡m−a H−p c¤m¡m ¢fÙ¹m J ¢limh¡l ¢e−u j−’l
¢c−L Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f J jqm−L E−ŸnÉ L−l qaÉ¡l E−Ÿ−nÉ …¢m
Ll−a Ll−a H¢N−u k¡u HC dl−Zl hš²hÉ ac¿¹L¡l£ LjÑLaÑ¡ P.W-33 −j¡x
M¡−mL¥‹¡j¡e Hl ¢eLV h−m¢ez ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ h−me ®k, HC c¢äa Bp¡j£l
¢hl¦−Ü L¢ba p¡r£−cl hš²hÉ flha£Ñ ¢Q¿¹¡fÐp§a Hhw pª¢Sa (after thought
and embellishment)z
a«a£uax P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm HL¢V jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡
¢c−u¢Rm k¡ flha£Ñ−a 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a quz ®pC Sh¡eh¾c£−a
p¤¢e¢cÑøi¡−h ¢LR¤ Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM b¡L−mJ HC Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM Ll¡
qu¢ez
Qa¥bÑax HC ®j¡LŸj¡l AeÉaj p¡r£ P.W-2 ®j¡x lSh Bm£ j−’
Ef¢ÙÛa b¡L−mJ HC Bp¡j£ pÇf−LÑ ¢LR¤ h−m¢ez
77
phÑ−nox P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e HS¡q¡−l Nulq (lumb
allegation) i¡−h HC Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM L−l−R ¢L¿º H hš²hÉ¢V ®L¡e
¢el−fr p¡rÉ fÊj¡Z à¡l¡ p¤¢e¢cÑøi¡−h pj¢bÑa qu¢ez HC AhÙÛ¡u c¢äa Bp¡j£l
cä¡−cn lcl¢qa ®k¡NÉz
c¢äa Bp¡j£ BCu¤h Bm£ Hhw e¤l¦m Bj£e Jl−g B¢je f−r ¢h‘
¢p¢eul BCeS£h£ Se¡h M¾cL¡l j¡qh¤h ®q¡−pe Hhw Se¡h −nM ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£
k¤¢š²aLÑ EfÙÛ¡fe L−lez HC k¤¢š²a−LÑl p¡lpw−rf ¢ejÀl¦fx
fÐbjax cä¢h¢dl 120L d¡l¡u Afl¡dj§mL osk−¿»l pw‘¡ Bc¡m−a
EfÙÛ¡fe L−lez pw‘¡¢V ¢ejÀl¦fx
120A. Definition of criminal conspiracy-When two or
more persons agree to do, or cause to be done
(1) an illegal act, or
(2) an act which is not illegal by illegal means, such an
agreement is designated a criminal conspiracy:
Provided that no agreement except an agreement to
commit an offence shall amount to a criminal conspiracy
unless some act besides the agreement is done by one or more
parties to such agreement in pursuance thereof.
Explanation- It is immaterial whether the illegal act is the
ultimate object of such agreement, or is merely incidental to
that object.
78
¢h‘ BCeS£h£ h−me ®k, HC d¡l¡u Afl¡d pwOV−el SeÉ Ef¢ÙÛa
pcpÉ−cl j−dÉ pLm−L HLja ®f¡oe Ll−a q−h ¢L¿º L¢ba ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL
Sh¡eh¾c£−a ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, c¢äa Bp¡j£ BCu¤h Bm£ −Lhmj¡œ L¢ba
osk¿»j§mL °hW®L hp¡ ¢Rm, k¡ ®c−M P.W-3 ®j¡x Bh¤m L¡−nj Ae¤ih Ll−a
f¡−l ®k, c¢äa BCu¤h Bm£ HC osk−¿» HLja ®f¡oeL¡l£ HLSe osk¿»L¡l£z
®Lhmj¡œ HC p¡rÉ fÐj¡Z R¡s¡ c¢äa Bp¡j£l ¢hl¦−Ü Bl ®L¡e pjbÑe−k¡NÉ
p¡rÉ fÐj¡Z¡¢c e¡ b¡L¡u ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ h−me ®k, c¢äa Bp¡j£−L ®k cä¡−cn
fÐc¡e Ll¡ q−u−R a¡ lcl¢qa ®k¡NÉz
¢àa£ua x HC c¤Se Bp¡j£l e¡j HS¡q¡−l E−õM ®eCz
a«a£uax ¢h‘ BCeS£h£NZ c¢äa Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Bj£e Jl−g Bj£e
pÇf−LÑJ HLC hš²hÉ E−õ®M −Lhmj¡œ c¢äa Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Bj£e Jl−g
B¢j−el h¡¢s−a L¢ba osk¿»j§mL °hWL¢V pwO¢Va qJu¡ R¡s¡ HC c¢äa
Bp¡j£l ¢hl¦−Ü Bl ®L¡e A¢i−k¡N l¡øÌfr ®b−L fÐj¡Z Ll−a hÉbÑ qJu¡u HC
Bp¡j£l cä¡−cn lcl¢qa −k¡NÉ j−jÑ hš²hÉ EfÙÛ¡fe L−lez
c¢äa Bp¡j£ l¡¢LhE¢Ÿe plL¡l Jl−g f¡è¤ plL¡l f−r k¤¢š²aLÑ EfÙÛ¡fe
L−le ¢h‘ ¢p¢eul BCeS£h£ Se¡h jJc¤c Bqjc J ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ Se¡h
B−e¡u¡l¦m Cpm¡jz k¡l p¡lpw−rf ¢ejÀl¦fx
fÐbjax l¡¢Lh¤¢Ÿe plL¡l Jl−g f¡è¤ plL¡−ll e¡j HS¡q¡−l E−õM ®eC h¡
OVe¡ÙÛ−m HC Bp¡j£l Ef¢ÙÛ¢al Lb¡ E−õM ®eCz ®Lhmj¡œ L¢ba
ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j¤mL Sh¡eh¾c£−a j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥yCu¡ Jl−g
j¡qh¤h LaѪL L¢ba osk¿» pi¡u “HC Bp¡j£ h−p B−R” Lb¡¢V E−õM B−Rz
79
¢àa£uax P.W-3 ®j¡x Bh¤m L¡−nj a¡l Sh¡eh¾c£−a h−m−Re ®k, “HC
h−p b¡L¡” ®c−M ¢a¢e Ae¤ih L−le c¢äa Bp¡j£ L¢ba osk¿» pi¡u HLSe
p¢œ²u AwnNËqZL¡l£z ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ h−me ®k, P.W-34 q¡¢gS¤l lqj¡e q¡¢hh
HC Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM L−l¢e z HC AhÙÛ¡u ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ h−me ®k, c¢äa
Bp¡j£l cä¡−cn lcl¢qa ®k¡NÉz
c¢äa Bp¡j£ ®p¡q¡N Jl−g pl¦ f−r ¢h‘ ¢p¢eul BCeS£h£ Se¡h Hp.Hj
n¡qS¡q¡e J Se¡h Hp Hj S¡¢qc¤l lqj¡e ay¡−cl k¤¢š²aLÑ EfÙÛ¡fe L−lez k¡l
p¡l pw−rf ¢ejÀl¦f x
fÐbjax L¢ba qaÉ¡L¡ä¢V c§OÑVe¡S¢eaz Hl L¡lZ ¢q−p−h E−õM Ll¡ qu
®k, a¢LÑa HS¡q¡l, ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j¤mL Sh¡eh¾c£, jªa¥ÉL¡m£e Sh¡eh¾c£ (k¡
flha£ÑL¡−m 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u f¡Ju¡ k¡u
®k, HS¡q¡−l p¤Øføi¡−h E−õM Ll¡ B−R c¤Se AbÑ¡v ¢cf¤ J ¢nf¤ Bqp¡e Eõ¡q
j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f−L pl¡p¢l …¢m¢hÜ L−l−Rz Afl¢c−L L¢ba osk¿»j§mL °hW−L
j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e Jl−g jqm−L qaÉ¡ Ll¡l osk¿» Ll¡ qu ¢L¿º flhaÑ£−a
H−m¡f¡b¡¢s …¢m−a qai¡NÉ Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f J Jjl g¡l¦L lae
jªa¤ÉhlZ L−lz ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ h−me ®k, HC ®fÊr¡f−V cä¡−cn¢V cä¢h¢dl 304
d¡l¡u f¢lhaÑe −k¡NÉz
¢àa£uax HC c¢äa Bp¡j£l e¡j HS¡q¡−l Hhw AeÉ¡eÉ f¢lp−l p¤¢e¢cÑø J
p¤Øføi¡−h E−õM e¡ b¡L¡l L¡l−Z HC c¢äa Bp¡j£l cä¡−cn lcl¢qa ®k¡NÉz
80
c¢äa Bp¡j£ j¢el Hl f−r ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ Se¡h ®j¡x Bm¡m E¢Ÿe a¡l
k¤¢š²aLÑ EfÙÛ¡fe L−lez k¡l p¡l pw−rf ¢ejÀl¦fx
fÐbjax HC Bp¡j£l e¡j HS¡q¡−l E−õM b¡L−mJ p¤¢e¢cÑøi¡−h HS¡q¡−l
HC Bp¡j£l e¡−j ®L¡e A¢i−k¡N ®eCz
¢àa£uax P.W-4 ®j¡x Bj¡e E¢Ÿe plL¡l, P.W-5 ®j¡x ®M¡l−nc Bmj,
P.W-6 ®j¡x BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j j¡p¤j, P.W-20 BSja Eõ¡q M¡e HC
Bp¡j£−L ¢fÙ¹m J ¢limh¡l ¢e−u j−’l ¢c−L Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f J
jqm−L E−ŸnÉ L−l qaÉ¡l E−Ÿ−nÉ …¢m Ll−a Ll−a H¢N−u k¡u E−õM Ll−mJ
H pLm hš²hÉ P.W-33 ®j¡x M¡−mL¥‹¡j¡e, ac¿¹L¡l£ LjÑLaÑ¡l L¡−R h−m¢ez
k¡ flha£Ñ ¢Q¿¹¡fÐp§a Hhw pª¢Sa (after thought and embellishment)z
phÑ−nox c¢äa Bp¡j£l ¢hl¦−Ü p¤Øfø Hhw p¤¢e¢cÑø fÐj¡Z e¡ b¡L¡l L¡l−Z
a¡l cä¡−cn lcl¢qa−k¡NÉz
c¢äa Bp¡j£ ®j¡q¡Çj¡c Bm£ f−r ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ Se¡h Bh¤m L¡m¡j
f¡−V¡u¡l£ ay¡l k¤¢š²aLÑ EfÙÛ¡fe L−lez k¡l p¡l pw−rf ¢ejÀl¦f x
fÐbjax HC Bp¡j£l e¡j HS¡q¡−l ®eCz pq c¢äa Bp¡j£ j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e
j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h LaѪL ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£−a HC
Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM Ll¡ q−u−Rz
¢àa£uax P.W-5 ®j¡x ®M¡l−nc Bmj, P.W-6 ®j¡x BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j
j¡p¤j, P.W-10 −j¡x n¢g Bq−jc, P.W-20 BSja Eõ¡q M¡e Hhw P.W-
26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm OVe¡ÙÛ−m HC Bp¡j£−L ¢fÙ¹m J ¢limh¡l q¡−a j−’l
¢c−L ¢eqa Hj,¢f J jqm−L qaÉ¡l E−Ÿ−nÉ …¢m Ll−a ®c−M j−jÑ hš²hÉ
81
l¡M−mJ P.W-33 ®j¡x M¡−mL¥‹¡j¡e HC j¡jm¡l ac¿¹L¡l£ LjÑLaÑ¡ a¡l p¡−rÉ
E−õM L−le ®k, HC p¡r£NZ a¡l L¡−R ®cu Sh¡eh¾c£−a OVe¡ÙÛ−m HC
Bp¡j£−L ®c−M−R j−jÑ ®L¡e hš²hÉ l¡−M¢ez Efl¿º c¢äa Bp¡j£ −j¡q¡Çjc Bm£
OVe¡ÙÛ−m H−p¢Rm ac−¿¹ HC abÉ ac¿¹L¡l£ LjÑLaÑ¡ fСç qu¢e j−jÑ Q¡SÑn£−VJ
E−õM B−R z
a«a£uax L¢ba osk¿»¢V O−ll ¢ial q®u−Rz P.W-3 ®j¡x Bh¤m L¡−nj HC
Bp¡j£−L osk¿»ÙÛm ®b−L Q−m ®k−a ®c−M j¡œz HC AhÙÛ¡u HLb¡ fÐj¡¢Za qu
e¡ ®k, c¢äa Bp¡j£ L¢ba osk−¿» AwnNËqZ L−l¢Rmz
Qa¥bÑax c¢äa Bp¡j£−L cä¢h¢dl 120M/302/34 d¡l¡u cä¡−cn fÐc¡e
Ll¡ q−u−Rz ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ h−me ®k, 120M Hl p¡−b cä¢h¢dl 34 d¡l¡ eu,
cä¢h¢dl 149 d¡l¡ k¤š² qJu¡ E¢Qa ¢Rmz
phÑ−nox ®k−qa¥ p¡rÉ fÐj¡−Z f¡Ju¡ k¡u ®k, c¢äa Bp¡j£ OVe¡ÙÛ−m Ef¢ÙÛa
¢Rm e¡ Hhw L¢ba osk−¿» c¢äa Bp¡j£l AwnNËqZ pÇf−LÑ ®L¡e ¢hnÄ¡p−k¡NÉ
p¡rÉ fÐj¡Z Bc¡m−a EfÙÛ¡¢fa qu¢e ®p−qa¥ c¢äa Bp¡j£l cä¡−cn lcl¢qa
®k¡NÉz
S¡q¡‰£l Jl−g hs S¡q¡‰£l Jl−g juje¢pwq¡ S¡q¡‰£l f−r ¢h‘ ¢p¢eul
BCeS£h£ Se¡h Hp.Hj. n¡qS¡q¡e Hhw Se¡h ®j¡x L¢mj¤õ¡q jS¤jc¡l ay¡−cl
k¤¢š²aLÑ EfÙÛ¡fe L−lez k¡l p¡l pw−rf ¢ejÀl¦fx
fÐbjax c¢äa Bp¡j£l e¡j HS¡q¡−l ®eCz HS¡q¡lL¡l£ P.W-1 ®j¡x
j¢aEl lqj¡e HS¡q¡−l 17 S−el e¡j E−õM Ll−mJ HC Bp¡j£l e¡j HS¡q¡−l
E−õM L−l¢ez
82
¢àa£uax P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e X−L cy¡¢s−u phÑfÐbj HC Bp¡j£−L
OVe¡ÙÛ−m ¢Rm j−jÑ E−õM L−l k¢cJ OVe¡l 35 O¾V¡ fl −cu HS¡q¡−l H
Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM L−l¢e AbQ P.W-2 lSh Bm£ h−me ®k, ¢a¢e HC
Bp¡j£−L ¢eqa Hj,¢f p¡−qh J jqm−L qaÉ¡ Ll¡l E−Ÿ−nÉ …¢m Ll−a
®c−M−Rez P.W-20 BSja Eõ¡q M¡e HC Bp¡j£−L …¢m Ll−a ®c−M−R E−õM
Ll−mJ ac¿¹L¡l£ LjÑLaÑ¡l L¡−R HLb¡ h−m¢ez
a«a£uax P.W-26 j¡qg¤S¤l lqj¡e jqm a¡l jªa¥ÉL¡m£e Sh¡eh¾c£®a (k¡
flha£ÑL¡−m 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) HC Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM
L−l¢ez
Qa¥bÑax HC AhÙÛ¡u P.W-2 ®j¡x lSh Bm£ HC Bp¡j£−L L¢ba …¢m
Ll−a ®c−M−R j−jÑ ®k hš²hÉ l¡−M ®pC hš²hÉ¢V ¢hnÄ¡p−k¡NÉ ®L¡e p¡rÉ fÐj¡Z
à¡l¡ pj¢bÑa qu¢ez
f’jax j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤−hl L¢ba
ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£¢V fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, L¢ba osk¿» pi¡u HC
Bp¡j£ Ef¢ÙÛa ¢Rm e¡z ®pM¡−e ®Lhm E−õM Ll¡ q−u−R HC Bp¡j£−L “q¡a
Ll¡ q−u−Rz” ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ a¡l hš²−hÉl ®f¡oLa¡u 21 DLR(AD) 104,
44 DLR 10, 15 BLD 449 Hhw 15 BLD 281 f¡a¡l eS£l c¡¢M−m
E−õM L−le ®k, c¢äa Bp¡j£ S¡q¡‰£l Jl−g hs S¡q¡‰£l Jl−g juje¢pwq¡
S¡q¡‰£l ü£L«a j−a L¢ba osk¿» pi¡u Ef¢ÙÛa ¢Rm e¡ Hhw HC c¢äa Bp¡j£
OVe¡ÙÛ−m ¢eqa Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f Hhw Jjl g¡l¦L lae−L
83
H−m¡f¡b¡¢s …¢m L−l qaÉ¡ L−l−R j−jÑ flØfl pj¢bÑa ®L¡e p¡rÉ fÐj¡Z e¡
b¡L¡u c¢äa Bp¡j£l cä¡−cn lc l¢qa ®k¡NÉz
c¢äa Bp¡j£ B¢jl Jl−g Bj£l ®q¡−pe f−r ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ Se¡h Hp
Hj n¡qS¡q¡e Hhw Se¡h j¡p¤c Bq−jc p¡Dc ay¡−cl k¤¢š²aLÑ EfÙÛ¡fe L−lez
k¡l p¡l pw−rf ¢ejÀl¦fx
fÐbjax HS¡q¡lL¡l£ HS¡q¡−l 17 Se Bp¡j£l e¡j p¤Øføi¡−h E−õM
Ll−mJ HC Bp¡j£l e¡j HS¡q¡−l ®eCz
¢àa£uax P.W-4 ®j¡x Bj¡e E¢Ÿe plL¡l, P.W-6 ®j¡x BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j
j¡p¤j, P.W-7 S¡¢Ll ®q¡−pe, P.W-8 ®j¡x Bš²¡l ®q¡−pe, P.W-9 à£−S¾cÐ
plL¡l, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc, P.W-28 S¡¢hc Bqp¡e ®p¡−qm a¡−cl
p¡−rÉ OVe¡ÙÛ−m Hhw OVe¡l flfl HC Bp¡j£−L pÇfªš² L−l ®k Sh¡eh¾c£
fÐc¡e L−l−R ac¿¹L¡l£ LjÑLaÑ¡ P.W-33 ®j¡x M¡−mL¥‹¡j¡e Hl ®Sl¡u f¡Ju¡
k¡u ®k, E−õ¢Ma p¡r£l¡ ac¿¹L¡l£ LjÑLaÑ¡l L¡−R L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 161 d¡l¡l
Sh¡eh¾c£−a HC c¢äa Bp¡j£l OVe¡l p¡−b pÇfªš²a¡ pÇf−LÑ ®L¡e hš²hÉ
l¡−M¢ez
a«a£uax j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h LaѪL
L¢ba ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j¤mL Sh¡eh¾c£¢V fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, HC c¢äa Bp¡j£
L¢ba osk¿»pi¡u Ef¢ÙÛa ¢Rm e¡z ®pM¡−e E−õM Ll¡ q−u−R ®k, HC c¢äa
Bp¡j£−L “q¡a Ll¡ q−u−Rz” ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ H fÐp−‰ p¡rÉ BC−el 30 d¡l¡
EfÙÛ¡fe L−lez
84
Qa¥bÑax HC Bp¡j£ OVe¡ÙÛ−m Ef¢ÙÛa ¢Rm ®p Lb¡¢V pjbÑe−k¡NÉ p¡rÉ fÐj¡Z
à¡l¡ fÐj¡¢Za qu¢e, c¢äa Bp¡j£l OVe¡ÙÛ−m b¡L¡l ¢hou¢V flha£Ñ ¢Q¿º¡fÐp§a J
pª¢Sa (after thought and embellishment)z
phÑ−nox c¢äa Bp¡j£ L¢ba osk¿» pi¡u Ef¢ÙÛa ¢Rme¡ Hhw OVe¡ÙÛ−m
L¢ba …¢m Ll¡l A¢i−k¡N flØfl pj¢bÑa p¡rÉfÐj¡Z à¡l¡ fÐj¡¢Za euz HC
AhÙÛ¡u ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ c¢äa Bp¡j£l cä¡−cn lc l¢qa−k¡NÉ j−jÑ a¡l hš²hÉ
EfÙÛ¡fe L−lez
c¢äa Bp¡j£ S¡q¡‰£l Bmj, ¢fa¡-®j−ql Bm£ f−r ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ Se¡h
j¡p¤c Bq−jc p¡Dc Hhw ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ Se¡h −j¡x l¡−nc¤‹¡j¡e hp¤¢eu¡
ay¡−cl k¤¢š²aLÑ EfÙÛ¡fe L−lez k¡l p¡l pw−rf ¢ejÀl¦fx
fÐbjax HC Bp¡j£l e¡j HS¡q¡−l ®eC, L¢ba ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£−a
®eC, jqm LaѪL jªa¥ÉL¡m£e −o¡OZ¡u (k¡ flha£ÑL¡−m 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£
¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) E−õM ®eCz
¢àa£uax P.W-1 −j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e, P.W-4 ®j¡x Bj¡e E¢Ÿe plL¡l,
P.W-6 ®j¡x BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j j¡p¤j, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc, P.W-26
j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm OVe¡ÙÛ−m HC Bp¡j£−L …¢m Ll−a ®c−M−R j−jÑ E−õM
Ll−mJ Hhw P.W-7 S¡¢Ll ®q¡−pe, P.W-8 −j¡x Bš²¡l ®q¡−pe, P.W-9
à£−S¾cÐ plL¡l, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc, P.W- 28 S¡¢hc Bqp¡e ®p¡−qm
OVe¡l flfl HC Bp¡j£−L AÙ» q¡−a Q−m ®k−a ®c−M−R j−jÑ E−õM Ll−mJ
ac¿¹L¡l£ LjÑLaÑ¡ P.W-33 −j¡x M¡−mL¥‹¡j¡−el L¡−R L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 161 d¡l¡u
®cu Sh¡eh¾c£−a c¢äa Bp¡j£l ¢hl¦−Ü p¡r£l¡ H pLm hš²hÉ E−õM L−l¢ez
85
¢h‘ BCeS£h£ h−me ®k, Ef−l¡š² AhÙÛ¡u HLb¡ p¤Øfø ®k, c¢äa Bp¡j£l
cä¡−cn¢V ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma h¢ZÑa p¡r£−cl flha£Ñ ¢Q¿¹¡fÐp§a J pª¢Sa (after
thought and embellishment) hš²hÉ−L ¢hnÄ¡p L−l fÐc¡e L−l−Re k¡
lcl¢qa−k¡NÉz
lae Jl−g hs lae Jl−g hs ¢ju¡ Jl−g lae ¢ju¡ f−r ¢h‘ BCeS£h£
Se¡h −nM ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£ ay¡l k¤¢š²aLÑ EfÙÛ¡fe L−lez k¡l p¡l pw−rf
¢ejÀl¦fx
fÐbjax HC Bp¡j£l e¡j HS¡q¡−l E−õM B−Rz j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h
Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h LaѪL fÐcš ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£−a
L¢ba osk¿» pi¡u HC Bp¡j£l Ef¢ÙÛ¢al Lb¡ E−õM ®eCz
¢àa£uax j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm LaѪL jªa¥ÉL¡m£e −o¡OZ¡u (k¡ flha£ÑL¡−m
164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) HC Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM b¡L−mJ
¢h‘ BCeS£h£ h−me, c¢äa Bp¡j£l p¢œ²u AwnNËqZ pÇf−LÑ ®L¡e p¤Øfø p¡rÉ
fÐj¡Z ®eCz
a«a£uax j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm−L qaÉ¡ Ll¡l osk¿» h¡Ù¹h¡ue L¡−m Bqp¡e
Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f Hhw Jjl g¡l¦L lae jªa¥ÉhlZ L−lz HC AhÙÛ¡u ®k−qa¥
¢eqa hÉ¢š²àu−L qaÉ¡ Ll¡l ®L¡e f§hÑ f¢lLÒfe¡ ¢Rm e¡ Hhw L¢ba qaÉ¡k−‘
HC Bp¡j£l p¢œ²u AwnNËqZ ¢Rm e¡, p¡r£−cl hš²hÉ j−a, a¡l Nulq Ef¢ÙÛ¢a
f¡Ju¡ k¡u j¡œ, ®p−qa¥ HC c¢äa Bp¡j£l cä¡−cn lcl¢qa ®k¡NÉz
86
c¢äa Bp¡j£ Bh¤ p¡m¡j Jl−g p¡m¡j f−r ¢h‘ ¢p¢eul BCeS£h£ Se¡h
M¾cL¡l j¡qh¤h ®q¡−pe ay¡l k¤¢š²aLÑ EfÙÛ¡fe L−lez k¡l p¡lpw−rf ¢ejÀl¦fx
fÐbjax HS¡q¡−l 17 Se Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM b¡L−mJ HC Bp¡j£l e¡j
HS¡q¡−l ®eCz j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h LaѪL
L¢ba ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£−a HC Bp¡j£l e¡j qaÉ¡L¡−ä AwnNËqZ f−hÑ
E−õM B−R j¡œz
¢àa£uax P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e, P.W-2 ®j¡x lSh Bm£, P.W-4
®j¡x Bj¡e E¢Ÿe plL¡l, P.W-6 ®j¡x BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j j¡p¤j, P.W-10 ®j¡x
n¢g Bq−jc, P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm HC Bp¡j£−L OVe¡l pju …¢m
Ll−a ®c−M−R j−jÑ E−õM Ll−mJ P.W-1 −j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e HS¡q¡−l a¡l
e¡j E−õM L−l¢e, P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm a¡l jªa¥ÉL¡m£e Sh¡eh¾c£−a
a¡l e¡j E−õM L−l¢ez
a«a£uax Ef−l¡š² p¡r£ R¡s¡J P.W-7 S¡¢Ll ®q¡−pe, P.W-8 ®j¡x
Bš²¡l −q¡−pe OVe¡l f§−hÑ Hhw P.W-9 à£−S¾cÐ plL¡l, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g
Bq−jc OVe¡l flfl HC Bp¡j£−L ®c−M−R j−jÑ E−õM Ll−mJ HC pLm
p¡r£−cl hš²hÉ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u −cM¡ k¡u ®k, a¡l¡ “®a¡a¡ f¡¢Ml ®nM¡−e¡ h¤¢m”
(Parrot like evidence) h−m−Re j¡œz
Qa¥bÑax OVe¡l pju Hl¦f HL¢V BL¢pÈLa¡u c¢äa Bp¡j£−L p¡r£−cl
®Qe¡l ¢hou¢V pÇf−LÑ HL¢V p−¾cq ®b−L k¡uz Bl HC p−¾c−ql p¤gm¢V c¢äa
Bp¡j£ fСç q−h j−jÑ E−õM L−l c¢äa Bp¡j£l cä¡−cn lc l¢qa−k¡NÉ j−jÑ
¢h‘ BCeS£h£ a¡l hš²−hÉ E−õM L−lez
87
n¢qc¤m Cpm¡j ¢nf¤ f−r ¢h‘ ¢p¢eul BCeS£h£ Se¡h M¾cL¡l j¡qh¤h
®q¡−pe ay¡l k¤¢š²aLÑ EfÙÛ¡fe L−lez k¡l p¡lpw−rf ¢ejÀl¦fx
fÐbjax HC Bp¡j£l e¡j HS¡q¡−l Hhw −j¡x j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jq−ml
jªa¥ÉL¡m£e Sh¡eh¾c£−a(k¡ flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h
Nªq£a q−u−R) E−õM b¡L−mJ P.W-1 −j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e, P.W-2 ®j¡x lSh
Bm£, P.W- −j¡x Bj¡e E¢Ÿe plL¡l, P.W-5 ®j¡x ®M¡l−nc Bmj, P.W-6
®j¡x BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j j¡p¤j, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc, P.W-11 ®j¡x
S¡j¡m, P.W-18 ®j¡x Bqp¡e Eõ¡q, P.W-20 BSja Eõ¡q M¡e, P.W-26
j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm OVe¡l pj−u Hhw P.W-8 ®j¡x Bš²¡l ®q¡−pe, P.W-9
à£−S¾cÐ plL¡l, P.W-11 ®j¡x S¡j¡m, P.W-12 ®j¡x g¢lc E¢Ÿe, P.W-15
p¤−L¡jm ®che¡b OVe¡l flflC HC Bp¡j£l pÇfªš²a¡l Lb¡ Bc¡m−a ®ki¡−h
E−õM L−l−R a¡ “®a¡a¡ f¡¢Ml ®nM¡−e¡ h¤¢m ” (parrot like evidence)
R¡s¡ Bl ¢LR¤C euz
¢àa£uax L¢ba OVe¡l BL¢pÈLa¡u Hhw iu¡hqa¡u p¤¢e¢cÑøi¡−h p¡r£−cl
f−r ®L¡e Bp¡j£−L ®Qe¡ pñh euz
a«a£uax h¢ZÑa A¢i−k¡−N Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j ¢cf¤, A¢qc¤m Cpm¡j ¢Vf¤
Hhw HC c¢äa Bp¡j£ n¢qc¤m Cpm¡j ¢nf¤l ¢hl¦−Ü Be£a A¢i−k¡N HLC
footing i¥š² qJu¡l flJ ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma HC ¢ae p−q¡cl ï¡a¡l j−dÉ
n¢qc¤m Cpm¡j ¢nf¤ Hhw e¤l¦m Cpm¡j ¢cf¤−L jªa¥Écä¡−cn Hhw ®L¡e NËqZ−k¡NÉ
L¡lZ E−õM hÉ¢a−l−L A¢qc¤m Cpm¡j ¢Vf¤−L k¡h‹£he L¡l¡cä¡−cn fÐc¡e
L−l−Rez ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ H ¢hou¢V ®L¡e fСbÑe¡ hÉ¢a−l−L Bc¡m−al cª¢ø−N¡Ql
88
L−le j¡œz ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ phÑ−n−o HC c¢äa Bp¡j£l cä¡−cn lcl¢qa ®k¡NÉ
j−jÑ E−õM L−lez
c¢äa Bp¡j£ ®m¡Lj¡e ®q¡−pe h¤m¤ f−r ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ Se¡h H Hj
j¡qh¤h¤¢Ÿe ay¡l k¤¢š²aLÑ EfÙÛ¡fe L−lez k¡l p¡l pw−rf ¢ejÀl¦fx
fÐbjax HS¡q¡−l h¤m¤ ¢ju¡, ¢fa¡-A‘¡a, p¡w-®N¡f¡mf¤l ¢q−p−h k¡l e¡j
E−õM Ll¡ q−u−R ¢a¢e HC Bp¡j£ eez HC Bp¡j£l e¡j L¡j¡m ®q¡−pe h¤m¤,
¢fa¡- Bë¥m N¢Z Hhw ¢a¢e ®e¡u¡M¡m£l h¡¢p¾c¡z Q¡SÑn£−V ®m¡Lj¡e ®q¡−pe h¤m¤
¢ju¡, ¢fa¡- N¢Z ¢ju¡, NË¡j- ®N¡f¡mf¤l, VwN£ j−jÑ ®k Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM Ll¡
q−u−R ¢a¢e HC Bp¡j£ eez HC fÐp−‰ ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ c¢äa Bp¡j£l ®i¡V¡l
¢mø J ¢eL¡q e¡j¡ Bc¡m−a c¡¢Mm L−lez ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ h−me ®k, HC c¢äa
Bp¡j£ OVe¡l Lb¡, HS¡q¡−l a¡l e¡j b¡L¡l Lb¡ h¡ Q¡SÑn£−V a¡l e¡j b¡L¡l
Lb¡ p−hÑ¡f¢l ¢hQ¡−l a¡l L¢ba cä¡−cn qh¡l ¢hou¢V LM−e¡ ‘¡a ¢Rm e¡z Cw
07/10/2014 a¡¢lM ®e¡u¡M¡m£ ®b−L HC Bp¡j£−L i¥m f¢lQ−u ®NËga¡l Ll¡
quz
phÑ−nox ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ i¤m hÉ¢š²−L cä¡−cn fÐc¡e Ll¡l L¡l−Z
®NËga¡lL«a Bp¡j£−L j¤¢š²c¡−el fСbÑe¡ L−lez
c¢äa Bp¡j£ q¡¢gS Jl−g L¡e¡ q¡¢gS Hl f−r ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ Se¡h
®qm¡m¤¢Ÿe ®j¡õ¡ ay¡l k¤¢š²aLÑ EfÙÛ¡fe L−lez k¡l p¡l pw−rf ¢ejÀl¦fx
fÐbjax HC Bp¡j£l e¡j HS¡q¡−l, j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm LaѪL jªa¥ÉL¡m£e
Sh¡eh¾c£−a (k¡ flha£Ñ−a 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) E−õM
B−Rz
89
¢àa£uax P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e, P.W-2 ®j¡x lSh Bm£, P.W-4
®j¡x Bj¡e E¢Ÿe plL¡l, P.W-5 ®j¡x ®M¡l−nc Bmj, P.W-6 ®j¡x
BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j j¡p¤j, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc, P.W-20 BSja Eõ¡q
M¡e, P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm OVe¡ÙÛ−m Bp¡j£−L …¢m Ll−a ®cM¡
pÇf−LÑ, P.W-8 ®j¡x Bš²¡l ®q¡−pe, P.W-9 à£−S¾cÐ plL¡l OVe¡l f§−hÑ Hhw
P.W-7 S¡¢Ll ®q¡−pe, P.W-8 ®j¡x Bš²¡l ®q¡−pe, P.W-9 à£−S¾cÐ plL¡l,
P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc OVe¡l f−l HC Bp¡j£−L OVe¡ÙÛ−m Ef¢ÙÛa ®b−L
pwO¢Va OVe¡u p¢œ²u AwnNËq−Zl ®k hš²hÉ EfÙÛ¡fe L−l−R a¡ ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ
Bc¡ma p¢WLi¡−h fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u hÉbÑ qe Hhw c¢äa Bp¡j£−L ®k cä¡−cn fÐc¡e
L−l−Re a¡ lcl¢qa−k¡NÉ j−jÑ ¢a¢e E−õM L−lez
fm¡aL Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j ¢cf¤, B−e¡u¡l ®q¡−pe Jl−g Be¤, gup¡m,
l¢e ¢ju¡ Jl−g l¢e g¢Ll, °puc Bq−jc jSe¤, S¡q¡‰£l ¢fa¡- L¡−nj j¡chl,
j¢nEl lqj¡e Jl−g jö Hhw ®M¡Le f−r l¡øÌf−r ¢ek¤¢š²u ¢h‘ ®ØVV ¢X−g¾p
BCeS£h£ H.Hj. ®j¡x B¢SS¤m qL Hl k¤¢š²a−LÑl p¡l pw−rfx
L¢ba j−a, pj−u, OVe¡ÙÛ−m ®k OVe¡ pwO¢Va qu a¡ AaÉ¿¹ N¢qÑa L¡S a−h
HC Bp¡j£NZ L¢ba j−a, pj−u, fÐL¡−l OVe¡ÙÛ−m jªa Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l
Hj,¢f Hhw Jjl g¡l¦L lae−L qaÉ¡ L−l−R j−jÑ l¡øÌf−rl Be£a A¢i−k¡N
l¡øÌfr HC c¢äa Bp¡j£−cl ¢hl¦−Ü p¤Øfø, p¤¢e¢cÑø Hhw p−¾cq¡a£ai¡−h fÐj¡Z
Ll−a hÉbÑ q−u−Rz H L¡l−Z ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ Ef−l¡š² c¢äa Bp¡j£−cl cä¡−cn
lc l¢qa ®k¡NÉ j−jÑ E−õM L−l−Rez
90
Afl¢c−L l¡øÌfr ®b−L k¤¢š²aLÑ EfÙÛ¡fe L−le ¢h‘ HÉ¡VeÑ£ ®Se¡−lm
Se¡h j¡qh¤−h Bmj, ¢h‘ pqL¡l£ HÉ¡VeÑ£ ®Se¡−lm Se¡h h¢nl Bq−jc, ¢h‘
¢p¢eul BCeS£h£ Se¡h Hj. B¢jl¦m Cpm¡j, ¢h‘ ¢p¢eul BCeS£h£ Se¡h
Bë¥m j¢ae Mpl¦, ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ Se¡h gS−m e§l a¡fp, ¢h‘ BCeS£h£
Se¡h p¡−S¡u¡l −q¡−pez
l¡øÌf−rl ¢h‘ BCeS£h£N−Zl k¤¢š²a−LÑl p¡lpw−rf ¢ejÀl¦fx
fÐbjax ü£L«aj−a, OVe¡¢V O−V−R fÐL¡nÉ ¢ch¡−m¡−L HL¢V Sepi¡l
j−’ Ef¢hø−cl H−m¡f¡b¡¢s …¢mhoÑ−Zl j¡dÉ−jz
¢àa£uax HS¡q¡−ll N−iÑ p¤Øføi¡−h E−õM B−R h¡wm¡−cn S¡a£ua¡h¡c£
k¤hc−ml ®L¾cУu ®ea¡ ®j¡x e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l Hl f§hÑ f¢lLÒfe¡ ®j¡a¡−hL
a¡lC f¡¢ma pnÙ» p¿»¡p£l¡ HC qaÉ¡L¡ä O¢V−u−Rz
a«a£ua x HC OVe¡l 10/12 ¢ce f§−hÑ jlL¥−el Bp¡j£ B¢j−el h¡¢s−a
c¢äa Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡−ll ®ea«−aÅ j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm−L qaÉ¡l
E−Ÿ−nÉ HL¢V osk¿» pi¡ Ae¤¢ùa quz
Qa¥bÑax P.W-3 ®j¡x Bh¤m L¡−nj Hhw P.W-34 q¡¢gS¤l lqj¡e
q¡¢hh Hl p¡−rÉ f¡Ju¡ k¡u OVe¡l 10/12 ¢ce f§−hÑ jlL¥−el Bj£−el h¡¢s−a
c¢äa Bp¡j£pq ®hn ¢LR¤ Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡−ll ®ea«−aÅ osk¿» pi¡
L−lz k¡l pjbÑe ®j−m c¢äa Bp¡j£ j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡
Jl−g j¡qh¤h Hl ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j¤mL Sh¡eh¾c£−az I pi¡u j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e
jqm−L qaÉ¡l osk¿» R¡s¡J c¢äa Bp¡j£ e¤¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l Hl BQl−e
fÐL¡n f¡u ®k, OVe¡l ¢ce pL¡m 11.00 V¡l ¢c−L e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l Afl
91
Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j c£f¤, n¢qc¤m Cpm¡j ¢nf¤−L ‘¢fW Q¡f¢s−u’ ¢LR¤ Cw¢Na
L−l Hhw Hl flflC e¤l¦m Cpm¡j c£f¤ J n¢qc¤m Cpm¡j ¢nf¤ j−’ Ef¢hø
Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l−L pl¡p¢l …¢m L−l k¡ P.W-11 −j¡x S¡j¡m J P.W-12
®j¡x g¢lc E¢Ÿe Hl p¡−rÉ p¤Øføi¡−h f¡Ju¡ k¡uz
f’jax P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm Hl jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡u (k¡
flhaÑ£−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) p¤Øfø J
p¤¢e¢cÑøi¡−h Bp¡j£ ¢cf¤, ¢nf¤, ¢Vf¤, L¡e¡ q¡¢gS, ®p¡q¡N J lae Hl e¡j E−õM
B−R, k¡ OVe¡l p¡−b Bp¡j£−cl p¢œ²u AwnNËq−Zl HL¢V p¤Øfø J p¤¢e¢cÑø
fÐj¡Zz
phÑ−no E−õM Ll¡ qu ®k, j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡
Jl−g j¡qh¤h L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡u ®cu ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£−a j¡qg¥S¤l
lqj¡e jqm−L M¤e Ll¡l ®k Afl¡dj§mL osk¿» Ll¡ qu a¡ h¡Ù¹h¡u−el SeÉ
HL¢V Sepi¡l j’ V¡−NÑV Ll¡ Hhw ®pM¡−e H−m¡f¡b¡¢s …¢m Ll¡l Hhw
HS¡q¡l h¢ZÑa e¤l¦m Cpm¡j c£f¤ J n¢qc¤m Cpm¡j ¢nf¤ LaѪL Bqp¡e Eõ¡q
j¡ø¡l−L a¡L L−l …¢m Ll¡l p¡−b OVe¡l ¢LR¤ f§−hÑ P.W-11 ®j¡x S¡j¡m J
P.W-12 −j¡x g¢lc E¢Ÿ−el p¡rÉ Ae¤k¡u£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l LaѪL ‘¢fW
Q¡f¢s−u’ Cw¢Na h¡q£ BQlZ p¤Øføi¡−h fÐj¡Z L−l ®k, jlL¥−el B¢j−el
h¡¢s−a j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm−L qaÉ¡l f¢lLÒfe¡−L ¢i¢š L−l Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m
Cpm¡j plL¡l a¡l l¡S¯e¢aL ¢Ql fТaà¾cÄ£ Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l−L c¤¢eu¡ ®b−L
p¢l−u ®gm¡l SeÉ OVe¡l ¢LR¤ f§−hÑ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j c£f¤ J n¢qc¤m Cpm¡j ¢nf¤−L
‘¢fW Q¡f¢s−u’ ¢e−cÑne¡ ®cu k¡l gmnЦ¢a−a HS¡q¡l h¢ZÑa j−a HC c¤S−el
92
®eaª−aÅ AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£l¡ OVe¡ÙÛ−m H−m¡f¡b¡¢s N¤¢mhoÑZ L−l k¡l gmnЦ¢a−a
Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f J Jjl g¡l¦L lae ¢eqa quz
l¡øÌfr ®b−L EfÙÛ¡¢fa k¤¢š²a−LÑl pjbÑ−e ¢cõ£ q¡C−L¡VÑ Hl
VISHAL YADAV VS STATE OF U.P. ON 2 APRIL, 2014
Hl p¡−b ¢ejÀh¢ZÑa eS£l¡¢c EfÙÛ¡fe Ll¡ qux-
(1) Tapinder Singh Vs. State of Panjab (1971) SCR
599
“The telephone message was received by Hari Singh,
A.S.I., Police Station, City Kotwali at 5-35 p.m. on September
8, 1969. The person conveying the information did not
disclose his identity, nor did he give any other particulars and
all that is said to have been conveyed was that firing had taken
place at the taxi stand, Ludhiana. This was, of course,
recorded in the daily diary of the police station by the police
officer responding to the telephone call. But prima facie this
cryptic and anonymous oral message which did not in terms
clearly specify a cognizable offence cannot be treated as first
information report.”
(2) Radha Mohan Singh Vs. State of UP (2006) 2
SCC 450
93
“The details of the overt acts are not necessary to be
recorded in the inquest report. The question regarding the
details as to how the deceased was assaulted or who assaulted
him or under what circumstances he was assaulted or who are
the witnesses of the assault is foreign to the ambit and scope
of proceedings under Section 174. Neither in practice nor in
law is it necessary for the person holding the inquest to
mention all these details.”
(3) Firozuddin Basheruddin Vs. State of Kerala
(2001) 7 SCC 596
“Criminal conspiracy is not easy to prove. The
conspirators invariably deliberate, plan and act in secret over a
period of time. It is not necessary that each one of them must
have actively participated in the commission of the offence or
was involved in it from start to finish. What is important is
that they were involved in the conspiracy or in other words,
there is a ‘combination by agreement, which may be express
or implied and in part implied. The conspiracy arises and the
offence is committed as soon as the agreement is made and the
offence continues to be committed so long as the combination
persists, that is until the conspiratorial agreement is terminated
94
by completion of its performance or by abandonment or
frustration’. The court has to be satisfied that there is a
reasonable ground to believe the existence of the cinspiracy
and that is a matter for judicial inference from proved facts
and circumstances Once the existence of conspiracy is proved
or held to exist, no doubt or relevant evidence, every act,
declaration and writing of any one of the conspirators
referable to the common intention will be relevant.”
(4) Yakub A.R. Memom Vs. State of Moharashtra
(2013) 13 SCC
(Conspiracy)
125. Chapter 5-A of the Penal Code speaks about criminal
conspiracy. Section 120-A defines criminal conspiracy which
is as under.
“120-A Definition of criminal conspiracy.-
When two.........................................object.
126. Section 120-B speaks about punishment of criminal
conspiracy which is as under:
“120-B. Punishment of criminal conspiracy.-
(1) Whoever is a party to a criminal conspiracy to commit an
offence punishable with death, imprisonment for life or
95
regorous imprisonment for a term of two years or upwards,
shall, where no express provision is made in this Code for the
punishment of such a conspiracy, be punished in the same
manner as if he had abetted such offence.
(2) Whoever is a party to a criminal conspiracy other than a
criminal conspiracy to commit an offence punishable as
aforesaid shall be punished with imprisonment of either
description for a term not exceeding six months, or with fine
or with both.”
Statement of Objects and Reasons of the 1913
Amendment
127. The abovementioned sections of the Penal Code were
introduced by the amendment of 1913. It is improtant to notice
the Statement of Objects and Reasons of the said amendment
to understand that the underlying purpose of introducing
Section 120-A was to make a mere agreement to do an illegal
act or an act which is not illegal by illegal means, punishable.
The Statement of Objects and Reasons are as follows:
“The Sections of the Indian Penal Code which deal directly
with the subject of conspiracy are those contained in Chapter
V and Section 121-A of the Code. Under the latter provision,
96
it is an offence to conspire to commit any of the offences
punishable by Section 121 of the Indian Penal Code or to
conspire to deprive the king of sovereignty of British India or
any part thereof or to overawe by means of criminal force or
show of criminal force the Government of India or any Local
Government and to constitute a conspiracy under this section.
It is not necessary that any act or illegal omission should take
place in pursuance thereof. Under Section 107, abetment
includes engaging with one or more person or persons in any
conspiracy for the doing of a thing, if an act or illegal
omission takes place in pursuance of that conspiracy, and in
order to the doing of that thing. It other words, except in
respect of the offences particularised in Section 121-A
conspiracy per se is not an offence under the Indian Penal
Code.
On the other hand, by the common law of England, if
two or more persons agree together to do anything contrary to
law, or to use unlawful means in the carrying out of an object
not otherwise unlawful, the persons, who so agree, commit the
offence of conspiracy. In other words, conspiracy in England
may be defined as an agreement of two or more persons to do
97
an unlawful act or to do a lawful act by unlawful means, and
the parties to such a conspiracy are liable to indictment.”
“(6) It is not necessary that all conspirators should agree
to the common purpose at the same time. They may join with
other conspirators at any time before the consummation of the
intended objective, and all are equally responsible.......”
(5) Dhananjoy Chatterjee Vs. State of West Bengal
(1994) 2 SCC 220
“15. In our opinion, the measure of punishment in a
given case must depend upon the atrocity of the crime; the
conduct of the criminal and the defenceless and unprotected
state of the victim. Imposition of appropriate punishment is
the manner in which the courts respond to the society’s cry for
justice against the criminals. Justice demands that court should
impose punishment befitting the crime so that the courts
reflect public abhorrence of the crime. The courts must not
only keep in view the rights of the criminal but also the rights
of the victim of crime and the society at large while
considering imposition or appropriate punishment.”
98
(6) State of Punjub Vs. Bawa Singh (2015) 3 SCC
441
“16. We again reiterate in this case that undue sympathy
to impose inadequate sentence would do more harm to the
justice system to undermine the public confidence in the
efficacy of law. It is the duty of every court to award proper
sentence having regard to the nature of the offence and the
manner in which it was executed or committed. The
sentencing courts are expected to consider all relevant facts
and circumstances bearing on the question of sentence and
proceed to impose a sentence commensurate with the gravity
of the offence. The court must not only keep in view the rights
of the victim of the crime but also the society at large while
considering the imposition of appropriate punishment. Meagre
sentence imposed solely on account of lapse of time without
considering the degree of the offence will be
counterproductive in the long run and against the interest of
the society.”
99
EfÙÛ¡¢fa p¡rÉ fÐj¡Z¡¢c, eS£lpj§q J k¤¢š²a−LÑl ®fТr−a B−m¡Qe¡ J
¢pÜ¡¿¹ x
ü£L«aj−a, Cw 07/05/2004 a¡¢lM ®l¡S öœ²h¡l ®hm¡ Ae¤j¡e 12.35
¢j¢e−Vl pju ®e¡u¡Ny¡J Hj.H j¢Sc ¢ju¡ EµQ ¢hcÉ¡mu j¡−W VwN£ b¡e¡ BJu¡j£
®üµR¡−phL m£N 10 ew Ju¡−XÑl ¢œh¡¢oÑL p−Çjme −no qh¡l j¤q§−aÑ AL¥ÙÛ−m
H−m¡f¡b¡¢s …¢m−a phÑSe¢h¢ca ®ea¡ Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f Hhw 17 hRl
huú al¦Z qai¡NÉ Jjl g¡l¦L lae ¢eqa quz ü£L«aj−a, AL¥ÙÛ−m
H−m¡f¡b¡¢s …¢m−a j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm …l¦al Bqa qu Hhw a¡l p¡−b B−l¡
®hn ¢LR¤ hÉ¢š² Bqa quz l¡øÌf−rl p¡rÉ fÐj¡−Z Hhw c¢äa Bp¡j£f−r ¢h‘
BCeS£h£N−Zl k¤¢š²a−LÑJ HLb¡ p¤Øfø Hhw ü£L«a ®k, ¢eqa Bqp¡e Eõ¡q
j¡ø¡l Hm¡L¡l HLSe A¢hpwh¡¢ca ®ea¡ ¢R−mez
c¢äa Bp¡j£−cl ¢hl¦−Ü A¢i−k¡N fÐj¡−Zl SeÉ l¡øÌfr ®b−L ®k pLm p¡rÉ
fÐj¡Z¡¢c EfÙÛ¡¢fa q−u−R a¾j−dÉ 3 ¢V ¢hou j¤m Ù¹ñ (Pillar) ¢q−p−h ¢h−hQÉz
fÐbj Ù¹ñx fСb¢jL abÉ ¢hhlZ£ x
fÐb−j ®cM¡ k¡L, HC fСb¢jL abÉ ¢hhlZ£l ¢hhlZ LaV¡ NÊqZ−k¡NÉz
fСb¢jL abÉ ¢hhlZ£ fÐcnÑe£-1 ¢q−p−h ¢Q¢q²a q−u−Rz P.W-1 −j¡x j¢aEl
lqj¡e HC fСb¢jL abÉ ¢hhlZ£ OVe¡l fСu 35 O¾V¡ fl Cw 08/05/2004
a¡¢lM 23.45 ¢j¢e−V VwN£ b¡e¡u c¡¢Mm L−l−Rez HC abÉ ¢hhlZ£−a hm¡ q−u−R
p−Çjme¢V ®no qh¡l pj−u ®hm¡ Be¤j¡¢eL 12.35 ¢j¢e−V 1) e¤l¦m Cpm¡j ¢cf¤,
2) n¢qc¤m Cpm¡j ¢nf¤, 3) A¢qc¤m Cpm¡j ¢Vf¤, 4) L¡e¡ q¡¢gS, 5) B−e¡u¡l
®q¡−pe Be¤, 6) gup¡m, 7) −p¡q¡N, 8) h¤m¤ ¢ju¡, 9) Bm B¢je, (10) lae
100
¢ju¡, (11) l¢e, (12) −p¡−qm, (13) ¯puc Bq¡Çjc jSe¤, (14) j¡q¡h¤h, (15)
j¢el, (16) c¤m¡m, (17) S¡q¡‰£l pq B−l¡ A‘¡ae¡j¡ 10/12 Se ®m¡L Bp¡j£
e¤l¦m Cpm¡j ¢cf¤l ®ea«−aÅ B−NÀu¡−Ù» p¢‹a q−u …¢m Ll−a Ll−a pi¡ÙÛ−ml
¢c−L Ef¢ÙÛa quz HS¡q¡−l p¤Øføi¡−h hm¡ q−u−R e¤l¦m Cpm¡j ¢cf¤ J n¢qc¤m
Cpm¡j ¢nf¤ ¢eqa Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f ®L mrÉ L−l Efk§Ñf¢l …¢m L−l
Hhw …¢m¢hÜ q−u Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l j¡¢V−a m¤¢V−u f−sez AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£l¡
j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm, n¢lg E¢Ÿe, lae, ®M¡l−nc Bmj, h¡h¤mpq ®j¡V 10/12
Se−L …¢m¢hÜ L−lz fСb¢jL abÉ ¢hhlZ£−a B−l¡ HL¢V ¢hou p¤Øføi¡−h
E−õM Ll¡ q−u−R ®k, “h¡wm¡−cn S¡a£ua¡h¡c£ k¤hc−ml ®L¾cУu ®ea¡ ®j¡x e¤l¦m
Cpm¡j plL¡l Hl f§hÑ f¢lLÒfe¡ ®j¡a¡−hL a¡lC f¡¢ma Ef−l¡š² pnÙ»
p¿»¡p£l¡ HC qaÉ¡L¡ä O¢V−u−Rz” HS¡q¡−l B−l¡ E−õM Ll¡ q−u−R ®k, hs
i¡C−ul jªa¥Él Be¤ù¡¢eLa¡ pÇfæ Ll¡l L¡l−Z HC j¡jm¡ c¡−u−l ¢LR¤V¡ ¢hmð
q−u−Rz
HS¡q¡l fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u, HS¡q¡−l fÐbjax 17 Se Bp¡j£l e¡j
E−õM B−R, ¢àa£uax Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j ¢cf¤ J n¢qc¤m Cpm¡j ¢nf¤ Bqp¡e
Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f−L Efk§Ñf¢l …¢m L−l j−jÑ E−õM B−R, a«a£uax c¢äa
Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l Hl f§hÑ f¢lLÒfe¡ j−a a¡lC f¡¢ma Ef−l¡š² pnÙ»
p¿»¡p£l¡ HC qaÉ¡L¡ä O¢V−u−R j−jÑ E−õM B−Rz p¡¢hÑL ¢h−hQe¡u HC HS¡q¡l¢V
OVe¡ Hhw OVe¡l p¡−b c¢äa Bp¡j£−cl AhÙÛ¡e pÇf¢LÑa ¢hhl−Zl j§m ¢i¢š
¢q−p−h NËqZ−k¡NÉz
101
¢àa£u Ù¹ñx ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£
ac¿¹L¡m£e pj−u c¢äa Bp¡j£ j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡
Jl−g j¡qh¤h HL¢V ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j¤mL Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢c−u−Rz HC ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL
Sh¡eh¾c£¢V fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢q−p−h ¢Q¢q²a q−u−Rz fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a Sh¡eh¾c£¢V
NËqe L−l−Re P.W-27 H,®L, Hj ®p¡−qm, ¢h‘ fÐbj ®nÐe£l jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌVz a¡l
p¡rÉ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, ¢a¢e j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡
Jl−g j¡qh¤h Hl ®c¡o ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£¢V ®lLXÑ Ll¡l f§−hÑ j¡qh¤h¤l
lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h−L h¤¢T−u h−m−Re ®k, ¢a¢e HC
®c¡o ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£ fÐc¡−e h¡dÉ ee, HC ü£L¡−l¡¢š²l ¢i¢š−a a¡l
n¡¢Ù¹ q−a f¡−l, ®c¡o ü£L¡l e¡ Ll−mJ a¡−L Bl f¤¢mn ®qg¡S−a ®cu¡ q−h e¡,
®LE a¡−L iui£¢a, fÐ−m¡ie ®c¢M−u−R ¢Le¡ p−hÑ¡f¢l ¢a¢e f¤¢mn ee HLSe
jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌV H pÇf−LÑ a¡−L AhNa Ll¡−e¡ q−u−Rz fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a ®c¡o
ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j¤mL Sh¡eh¾c£¢V fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u B−l¡ ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, ¢h‘ jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌV
j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h−L ®c¡o ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j¤mL
Sh¡eh¾c£ fÐc¡e Ll−he ¢Le¡ ®p pÇf−LÑ je¢ÙÛl Ll¡l SeÉ 3 O¾V¡ pju
¢c−u−Rez HR¡s¡J A¢ik¤š² ¢h‘ jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌ−Vl L¡−R a¡l Efl ®L¡e f£se/
Shlc¢Ù¹l A¢i−k¡N L−l¢e Hhw j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡
Jl−g j¡qh¤h ¢h‘ jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌ−Vl ¢S‘¡p¡u h−m−Re ®k, ¢a¢e a¡l ®c¡o
ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£¢V ®üµR¡u ¢c−u−Rez ®lLXÑL«a ®c¡o ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL
Sh¡eh¾c£¢V A¢ik¤š²−L f−s öe¡−e¡ q−m A¢ik¤š² HC ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j¤mL Sh¡eh¾c£
öÜ ü£L¡−l fТa fªù¡u ü¡rl L−l−Re ®cM¡ k¡uz
102
c¢äa Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l f−r ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ E−õM L−le
®k, L¢ba 164 d¡l¡u ®cu j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g
j¡qh¤−hl ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£¢V ®üµR¡fÐ−Z¡¢ca J p¢WL (valuntarily
and true) euz H fÐp−‰ c¡¢Mm£ eS£l f§−hÑC E−õM Ll¡ q−u−Rz
c¢äa Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l J j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g
j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h f−rl ¢h‘ BCeS£h£NZ h−me ®k, ®c¡o
ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£¢V j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g
j¡qh¤h Hl L¡R ®b−L p§c£OÑ 9 ¢ce f¤¢mn ®qg¡S−a ¢ekÑ¡a−el fl Bc¡u Ll¡
q−u−R, ®k L¡l−Z HC ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£¢V flha£Ñ−a j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e
j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h fÐaÉ¡q¡l L−l−R Hhw H fÐp−‰ ¢h‘
BCeS£h£NZ j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h Hl Ù»£
¢le¡ p¤ma¡e¡ D.W-3 ¢q−p−h ®k p¡rÉ fÐc¡e L−l−R a¡ E−õM L−lez D.W-
3 ¢le¡ p¤ma¡e¡ a¡l p¡−rÉ E−õM L−le ®k, Cw 23/05/2004 a¡¢lM pL¡m
6.00 O¢VL¡l pju HC p¡r£−L CID A¢g−p ®eu¡ qu Hhw Bp¡j£ j¡qh¤h−L
a¡l p¡j−e Be¡ qu 1 O¾V¡ flz H pju p¡r£ ®c−M j¡qh¤−hl nl£l Ha M¡l¡f
®k ®p ®qy−V Bp−a f¡l¢Rm e¡z j¡qh¤h a¡−L h−m ®k, a¡l j¡b¡u L¡−l−¾Vl ¢qV
®cu¡ q−u−Rz j¡qh¤h B−l¡ S¡e¡u ®k, ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£ e¡ ¢c−m a¡−L J
a¡l h¡µQ¡−L ®j−l ®gm¡ q−hz D.W-3 ¢le¡ p¤ma¡e¡ a¡l ü¡j£l N¡−u q¡a ¢c−u
®c−M ü¡j£l SÅl H−p−Rz fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a ®c¡o ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£
fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, ¢h‘ jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌV P.W-27 H,®L,Hj, ®p¡−qm ¢h¢d
®j¡a¡−hL HC ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£ ®lLXÑ L−lez D.W-3 j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e
103
j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h Hl Ù»£ ¢le¡ p¤ma¡e¡ Cw 23/05/2004
a¡¢lM a¡l p¡rÉ j−a pL¡m 7.00 O¢VL¡u HC Bp¡j£l p¡−b Lb¡ h−m−Rez
aMe j¡qh¤h ®qy−V Bp−a f¡l¢Rme¡ h¡ SÅl ¢Rm H ¢hou…¢m I ¢ceC ¢h−L−m HC
Sh¡eh¾c£ ®lLXÑ Ll¡l pju ü¡i¡¢hLi¡−hC ¢h‘ jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌ−Vl eS−l Bp¡l Lb¡
¢Rmz ¢L¿º ¢h‘ jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌV Sh¡eh¾c£¢V ¢m¢fhÜ Ll¡l fl ¢eS q¡−a ¢m−M−Re ®k,
“A¢ik¤š² Bj¡l L¡−R a¡l Efl ®L¡e f£se/Shlc¢Ù¹l A¢i−k¡N L−l¢ez” AbÉÑ¡v
D.W-3 ¢le¡ p¤ma¡e¡ A¢ik¤š² j¡qh¤h−L pL¡−m a¡l hZÑe¡j−a ®kl¦f AhÙÛ¡u
®c−M−R, ¢h‘ jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌV ¢h−L−m a¡−L pÇf§ZÑ ¢hfl£a AbÑ¡v p¤ÙÛ AhÙÛ¡u ®c−M−Rz
HC AhÙÛ¡u p‰a L¡l−Z ¢h‘ jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌV A¢ik¤š² j¡qh¤h−L p¤ÙÛ AhÙÛ¡u h¡
ü¡i¡¢hL AhÙÛ¡u ®f−u−Re H ¢hou¢V fТZd¡e−k¡NÉz ¢h‘ jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌV A¢ik¤š²
j¡qh¤h−L ®c¡o ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£ fÐc¡−el f§−hÑ a¡−L h−m−Re ®k, ®c¡o
ü£L¡l e¡ Ll−mJ a¡−L f¤¢mn ®qg¡S−a ®cu¡ q−h e¡, Hl¦f cª¢ø BLÑo−Zl flJ
A¢ik¤š² j¡qh¤h ¢h‘ jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌ−Vl L¡−R a¡l Efl AaÉ¡Q¡l L−l h¡
i£¢a/fÐ−m¡ie ®c¢M−u f¤¢mn ®c¡o ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£ fÐc¡e Ll−a h−m−R
Hl¦f hš²hÉ l¡−M¢e h¡ ¢h‘ jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌV j¡qh¤h−L ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£
fÐc¡eL¡−m Ap¤ÙÛ h¡ i£a-¢hqhm AhÙÛ¡u f¡e¢ez H Lb¡ ü£L«a ®k, A¢ik¤š²
j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h p§c£OÑ 9 ¢ce f¤¢mn ®qg¡S−a b¡L¡l fl ¢h‘ jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌ−Vl
L¡−R ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£¢V fÐc¡e L−l−Rz eb£ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k,
Bp¡j£ j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h−L Cw 14/05/204 a¡¢l−M ®NËga¡l Ll¡ qu Hhw
a¡−L ¢h¢dNa i¡−h Bc¡m−a EfÙÛ¡fe Ll¡ qu, ¢lj¡ä Q¡Ju¡ qu Hhw ¢h¢d
Ae¤k¡u£ ac−¿¹l fl A¢ik¤š² j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h ®c¡o ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL
104
Sh¡eh¾c£ fÐc¡e Ll¡l CµR¡ ®f¡oZ Ll¡u a¡−L ¢h‘ jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌ−Vl p¡j−e
EfÙÛ¡fe Ll¡ quz AaHh, HC 9 ¢c−el ®qg¡Sa¢V ®hBC¢e f¤¢mn ®qg¡Sa
(illegal Police Custody) ¢Rm e¡z ¢h‘ jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌV A¢ik¤š² j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e
j¡qh¤h−L f§−hÑ E−õ¢Ma cª¢ø BLoÑZj§mL fÐnÀ…¢m L−le Hhw a¡−L ¢Q¿¹¡i¡he¡
Ll¡l SeÉ 3 ¢V O¾V¡ pju −cez Hlfl ¢h‘ jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌV ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL
Sh¡eh¾c£¢V ®lLXÑ L−lez A¢ik¤š² j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Cw 23/05/2004
a¡¢l−M ®cu ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£¢V flhaÑ£−a fÐaÉ¡q¡l L−lez Bp¡j£
j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h ¢h‘ jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌ−Vl L¡−R ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£ fÐc¡e
Ll¡l pju ¢h‘ jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌV LaѪL h¢ZÑa cª¢ø BLoÑZj¤mL fÐnÀ…¢m h¤−TC
ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£ fÐc¡e L−lez Cw 03/04/2005 a¡¢lM D.W-3
A¢ik¤š² j¡qh¤−hl Ù»£ ¢le¡ p¤ma¡e¡ Bc¡m−a cy¡¢s−u ®k p¡rÉ fÐc¡e L−le a¡
Ef−l¡š² B−m¡Qe¡l B−m¡−L NËqZ−k¡NÉ eu j−jÑ ¢h−h¢Qa quz
Ef−l¡š² B−m¡Qe¡l B−m¡−L ¢pÜ¡¿¹ qu ®k, A¢i−k¡N fÐj¡−Zl 3¢V j§m
Ù¹ñ ((pillar) Hl j−dÉ AeÉaj Ù¹ñ ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£¢V A¢ik¤š²
j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h ®üµR¡u Hhw p¢WLi¡−h (voluntarily and true)
¢c−u−Rez
a«a£u Ù¹ñx jªa¥ÉL¡m£e Sh¡eh¾c£ (k¡ flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l
Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R)
A¢i−k¡N fÐj¡−el SeÉ Afl j§m Ù¹ñ (pillar) P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l
lqj¡e jqm LaѪL L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡u ®cu Sh¡eh¾c£z fÐbjax fÐcnÑe£-29
¢Q¢q²a HC Sh¡eh¾c£¢V jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡ (dying diclaration) ¢q−p−h
105
P.W-30 ¢h‘ jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌV ®j¡x n¢gL B−e¡u¡l ®lLXÑ L−l−Rez fÐcnÑe£-29
¢Q¢q²a jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡¢V (k¡ flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£
¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) ®lLXÑ Ll¡l pju l¦N£l AhÙÛ¡ pÇf−LÑ −lLXÑL¡l£ ¢h‘
jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌV E−õM L−l−Re ®k, “l¦N£l AhÙÛ¡ BnwL¡SeLz hÉb¡u L¡al¡−µRz a¡l
e¡−L A¢„−Se f¡Cf ®cu¡z a¡−L ICU Bed No. 1 H Ešl ¢c−L fy¡ c¢rZ
¢c−L j¡b¡ L−l ¢Q¢Lvp¡d£e l¡M¡ q−u−Rz l¦N£ hÉ¡b¡u Hf¡n Jf¡n Ll−Rz” ¢h‘
jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌV a¡−L ¢S‘¡p¡ L−l−Re ®k, ¢a¢e jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌVz p¡r£ HC ®O¡oZ¡ ¢c−a
h¡dÉ ee, ®O¡oZ¡¢V ¢c−a ®LE fÐi¡¢ha L−l−R ¢Le¡? ®üµR¡u ®O¡oZ¡ ¢c−he ¢L e¡?
¢h‘ jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌ−Vl fÐ−nÀ ®O¡oZ¡L¡l£ h−m−Re ®k, a¡l f¢lZ¢al SeÉ k¡l¡ c¡u£
¢a¢e a¡−cl Lb¡ hm−hez ¢h‘ jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌV HC ®O¡oZ¡¢V ¢m¢fhÜ Ll¡l fl ®O¡oZ¡
fÐc¡eL¡l£−L hš²hÉ f−s öe¡−e¡ J h¤T¡−e¡ q−m ®O¡oZ¡L¡l£ paÉ ü£L¡−l ü¡rl
L−lez ¢h‘ jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌV l¦N£ ®üµR¡u HC hš²hÉ ®ce E−õ−M a¡l cÙ¹Ma fÐc¡e
L−lez
P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm OVe¡l pju j¡l¡aÁi¡−h Bqa qe Hhw
a¡l AhÙÛ¡ BnwL¡SeL qJu¡u ¢h‘ jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌ−Vl L¡−R OVe¡l flflC Ab¡Ñv Cw
10/05/2004 a¡¢l−M HC jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡ (k¡ flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164
d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) fÐc¡e L−lez ®k−qa¥ j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm
¢h‘ jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌV LaѪL ®lLXÑL«a jªa¤ÉL¡m£e −O¡oZ¡ fÐc¡−el fl jªa¥ÉhlZ L−l¢e
®p−qa¥ BC−el ¢hd¡e Ae¤k¡u£ p¢WLi¡−h HC jªa¥ÉL¡m£e Sh¡eh¾c£¢V L¡kÑ¢h¢dl
164 d¡l¡u ®cu Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h flha£Ñ−a Nªq£a q−u−Rz ®k−qa¥ p¡r£ j¡qg¥S¤l
lqj¡e jqm OVe¡l flflC jªa¥Épj AhÙÛ¡u b¡L¡L¡−m ¢h‘ jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌ−Vl L¡−R
106
HC Sh¡eh¾c£ fÐc¡e L−l ®p−qa¥ p‰a L¡l−ZC HC Sh¡eh¾c£¢V AaÉ¿¹ …l¦aÅf§ZÑ,
¢hnÄ¡p−k¡NÉ Hhw A¢ik¤š²−cl ¢hl¦−Ü Be£a A¢i−k¡N fÐj¡−Zl SeÉ 3¢V j§m
Ù¹®ñl(pillar) j−dÉ AeÉaj HL¢V Ù¹ñ(pillar)z
Ef−ll B−m¡Qe¡l B−m¡−L ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, HS¡q¡l, Bp¡j£ j¡qh¤h¤l
lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h La«ÑL ®cu ®c¡o ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL
Sh¡eh¾c£ Hhw P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jq−ml ®cu jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡¢V (k¡
flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) flØfl
pÇf¢LÑa Hhw H−L Af−ll f¢lf§lLz ®k−qa¥ Ef−ll B−m¡Qe¡u HS¡q¡l h¢ZÑa
¢hhlZ¢V NËqZ−k¡NÉ, j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h LaѪL ®cu ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL
Sh¡eh¾c£¢V ®üµR¡fÐ−Z¡¢ca J p¢WL (valuntarily and true), p−h¡Ñf¢l
P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jq−ml jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡¢V (k¡ flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl
164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) fТed¡e−k¡NÉ j−jÑ Bc¡m−al L¡−R
fÐa£uj¡e q−u−R, ®p−qa¤ H AhÙÛ¡u Bp¡j£−cl ¢hl¦−Ü ®cu p¡r£−cl hš²hÉ
fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡L ®k, HC ¢ae¢V j§m Ù¹−ñl (pillar) p¡−b p¡r£−cl
pjbÑe−k¡NÉ hš²−hÉl ®fТr−a c¢äa Bp¡j£N−Zl cä¡−cn hq¡m ®k¡NÉ ¢Le¡?
cä¢h¢dl 302/120M/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥ÉcäfСç Bp¡j£ B¢jl pÇf−LÑ B−m¡Qe¡
J ¢pÜ¡¿¹ x
−Xb ®lg¡−l¾p Hl p¡−b HC Bp¡j£l c¡−ul Ll¡ 1844/2005 ew ®g±Sc¡l£
Bf£m J ®Sm Bf£m ew 414/2005 HL−œ B−m¡Qe¡ Ll¡ q−m¡z
jªa¥ÉcäfСç Bp¡j£ B¢j−ll e¡j HS¡q¡−l ®eCz fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a j¡qh¤h¤l
lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h LaѪa ®cu ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL
107
Sh¡eh¾c£¢V fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, c¢äa B¢jl osk¿»pi¡u Ef¢ÙÛa ¢Rme¡z
ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£−a hm¡ q−u−R ®k, “a¡l c−ml jlL¥e, ®VLf¡s¡l
jSe¤, ®N¡f¡mf¤−ll B¢jl J hs S¡q¡‰£l−L q¡a Ll¡ q−u−R”z Ab¡Ñv
ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£−aC ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, A¡p¡j£ B¢jl osk¿» pi¡u Ef¢ÙÛa
¢Rme¡z P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e, P.W-4 ®j¡x Bj¡e E¢Ÿe plL¡l, P.W-
5 ®j¡x ®M¡l−nc Bmj, P.W-6 ®j¡x BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j j¡p¤j, P.W-10 ®j¡x
n¢g Bq−jc, P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm OVe¡l pj−u c¢äa B¢jl−L
j−’l ¢fRe ¢cL ®b−L ¢fÙ¹m J ¢limh¡l q¡−a j−’l ¢c−L ¢eqa Hj,¢f p¡−qh
J ®j¡x j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm−L qaÉ¡l E−Ÿ−nÉ …¢m Ll−a ®c−M j−jÑ ®k hš²hÉ
®l−M−R P.W-33 −j¡x M¡−mL¥‹¡j¡−el (j¡jm¡l ac¿¹L¡l£ LjÑLaÑ¡) L¡−R
L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 161 d¡l¡u fÐcš Sh¡eh¾c£−a p¡r£l¡ Hl¦f hš²hÉ l¡−M¢e ®cM¡ k¡uz
Afl¢c−L P.W-8 ®j¡x Bš²¡l ®q¡−pe, P.W-9 à£−S¾cÐ plL¡l, P.W-10 ®j¡x
n¢g Bq−jc, P.W-28 S¡¢hc Bqp¡e ®p¡−qm a¡−cl Sh¡eh¾c£−a h−m−R ®k,
a¡l¡ ®cM−a f¡u c¢äa Bp¡j£ B¢jlpq AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£l¡ OVe¡l fl AÙ» q¡−a
®lmœ²¢pw f¡l q−u k¡−µRz ac¿¹L¡l£ LjÑLaÑ¡ P.W-33 M¡−mL¥‹¡j¡−el p¡−rÉ
®cM¡ k¡u ®k, HC p¡r£l¡ L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 161 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£−a Bj£l pÇf−LÑ
HLb¡ h−m¢ez P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm a¡l jªa¥ÉL¡m£e Sh¡eh¾c£−a (k¡
flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢qp¡−h Nªq£a q−u−R) OVe¡l flflC
OVe¡l p¡−b pÇfªš² 6 Se Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM Ll−mJ c¢äa B¢j−ll e¡j
E−õM L−l¢ez Ab¡Ñv ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, HC ®j¡LŸj¡u f§−hÑ E−õ¢Ma 3 ¢V j¤m
Ù¹−ñl(pillar) j−dÉ x-
108
fÐbjax p¤¢e¢cÑøi¡−h 17 S−el e¡j HS¡q¡−l b¡L−mJ HC Bp¡j£l e¡j
P.W-1 −j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e HS¡q¡−l E−õM L−l¢e,
¢àa£uax j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¤Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤−hl
ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, osk¿»pi¡u HC c¢äa
Bp¡j£ Ef¢ÙÛa ¢Rme¡z HC Bp¡j£−L “q¡a Ll¡ q−u−R” E−õM Ll¡ qu ¢L¿º HC
“q¡a” Ll¡ pÇf−LÑ ®L¡e p¡rÉ h¡ f¡¢lf¡¢nÄÑL fÐj¡Z Bc¡m−al p¡j−e EfÙÛ¡¢fa
qu¢e,
a«a£uax P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm LaѪL jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®o¡Oe¡u (k¡
flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) HC Bp¡j£l
e¡j E−õM Ll¡ qu¢e k¢cJ ®pM¡−e p¤Øføi¡−h ®hn ¢LR¤ Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM Ll¡
q−u−R,
Qa¥bÑax P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e, P.W-4 ®j¡x Bj¡e E¢Ÿe plL¡l,
P.W-6 ®j¡x BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j j¡p¤j, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc, P.W-5
®j¡x ®M¡l−nc Bmj, P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm, P.W-7 S¡¢Ll ®q¡−pe,
P.W-8 ®j¡x Bš²¡l ®q¡−pe, P.W-9 à£−S¾cÐ plL¡l, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g
Bq−jc, P.W-28 S¡¢hc Bqp¡e ®p¡−qm Bc¡m−a HC Bp¡j£ pÇf−LÑ ®k
hš²hÉ fÐc¡e L−l−R a¡ ac¿¹L¡l£ LjÑLaÑ¡ P.W-33 −j¡x M¡−mL¥S¡j¡−el L¡−R
L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 161 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£−a h−m¢ez
p‰aL¡l−Z AaÉ¿¹ p¤Øføi¡−h ¢pÜ¡−¿¹ B¢p ®k, A¢ik¤š²−cl ¢hl¦−Ü A¢i−k¡N
fÐj¡−Zl SeÉ l¡øÌfr ®b−L ®p pLm p¡rÉ fÐj¡Z¡¢c EfÙÛ¡¢fa q−u−R a¾j−dÉ j§m
Ù¹ñ ¢q−p−h ¢h−hQÉ fСb¢jL abÉ ¢hhlZ£, ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£ Hhw P.W-
109
26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm LaѪL jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡u (k¡ flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl
164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢qp¡−h Nªq£a q−u−R) HC Bp¡j£l e¡j ®eCz HR¡s¡J
h¢ZÑa p¡r£NZ Bc¡m−a H−p HC Bp¡j£l ¢hl¦−Ü ®k hš²hÉ −l−M−R ®p pLm
hš²hÉ L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 161 d¡l¡u ac¿¹L¡l£ LjÑLaÑ¡ P.W-33 ®j¡x M¡−mL¥‹¡j¡−el
L¡−R e¡ l¡M¡u ¢pÜ¡−¿¹ B¢p ®k H pLm hš²hÉ flha£Ñ ¢Q¿¹¡fÐp§a J pª¢Sa
(after thought and embellishment)z H AhÙÛ¡u ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma
c¢äa Bp¡j£ B¢jl−L Be£a A¢i−k¡−N ®k jªa¥Écä fÐc¡e L−l−R a¡ lcl¢qa
®k¡NÉz
cä¢h¢dl 302/120M/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥ÉcäfСç Bp¡j£ S¡q¡‰£l Jl−g hs
S¡q¡‰£l Jl−g juje¢pwq¡ S¡q¡‰£l ¢fa¡-e¤l ®q¡−pe pÇf−LÑ B−m¡Qe¡ J
¢pÜ¡¿¹ x
−Xb ®lg¡−l−¾pl p¡−b HC Bp¡j£l c¡−ul Ll¡ ®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew
1813/2005 J ®Sm Bf£m ew 413/2005 HL−œ B−m¡Qe¡ Ll¡ q−m¡z
cä¢h¢dl 302/120M/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥ÉcäfСç Bp¡j£ S¡q¡‰£l Jl−g hs
S¡q¡‰£l Jl−g juje¢pwq¡ S¡q¡‰£l ¢fa¡-e¤l ®q¡−pe Hl e¡j HS¡q¡−l −eCz
j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h LaѪL ®cu ®c¡o
ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£−a f¡Ju¡ k¡u ®k, “a¡l c−ml jlL¥e, ®VLf¡s¡l
jSe¤, ®N¡f¡mf¤−ll B¢jl J hs S¡q¡‰£l−L q¡a Ll¡ q−u−R” Ab¡Ñv
ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£−aC ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, A¡p¡j£ S¡q¡‰£l HC osk¿» pi¡u
Ef¢ÙÛa ¢Rme¡z “q¡a” Ll¡ pÇf−LÑ ®L¡e p¡rÉ h¡ AhÙÛ¡Na fÐj¡Z EfÙÛ¡¢fa
qu¢ez P.W-26 ®j¡x j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jq−ml jªa¥ÉL¡m£e −O¡oZ¡u (k¡ flha£Ñ−a
110
L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢qp¡−h Nªq£a q−u−R) HC Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM
®eCz P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e, P.W-2 ®j¡x lSh Bm£, P.W-20 BSja
Eõ¡q M¡e, P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm HC Bp¡j£−L OVe¡l pju …¢m
Ll−a ®c−M−R j−jÑ E−õM Ll−mJ P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e 17 Se Bp¡j£l
e¡j E−õ−M HS¡q¡l c¡−ul L−l AbQ HC Bp¡j£l e¡j HS¡q¡−l E−õM L−l¢ez
P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm LaѪL fÐcš jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡−aJ (k¡
flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢qp¡−h Nªq£a q−u−R) HC Bp¡j£l
e¡j E−õM −eCz P.W-20 BSja Eõ¡q M¡e Hhw P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e
jqm ac¿¹L¡l£ LjÑLaÑ¡ P.W-33 ®j¡x M¡−mL¥‹¡j¡−el L¡−R L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 161
d¡l¡u ®cu Sh¡eh¾c£−a HC Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM L−l¢ez P.W-2 ®j¡x lSh Bm£
a¡l −Sl¡u E−õM L−l®R ®k, Bp¡j£ hs S¡q¡‰£l OVe¡l f§−hÑ ®ØV−S a¡l ¢fR−e
hp¡ ¢Rmz ¢a¢e B−l¡ E−õM L−le, p−Çjme öl¦ qJu¡ ®b−L ®no fkÑ¿¹ Bp¡j£
hs S¡q¡‰£l pi¡ÙÛ−m b¡L−a f¡−lz Ab¡Ñv ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, HC j¡jm¡u f§−hÑ
E−õ¢Ma 3 ¢V j¤m Ù¹−ñl(pillar) j−dÉ x-
fÐbjax HS¡q¡−l p¤¢e¢cÑøi¡−h 17 S−el e¡j E−õM b¡L−mJ hs S¡q¡‰£−ll
e¡j E−õM ®eCz flha£Ñ−a HS¡q¡l L¡l£ P.W-1 −j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e Bc¡m−a
H−p HC Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM L−l−R j¡œ,
¢àa£uax ®c¡o ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£¢V fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k,
osk¿»pi¡u HC Bp¡j£ Ef¢ÙÛa ¢Rm e¡ Hhw a¡−L L¢ba “q¡a Ll¡ q−u−R”
hš²hÉ¢V fÐj¡¢Za qu¢e,
111
a«a£uax OVe¡l flflC P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm LaѪL −cu
jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡u (k¡ flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a
q−u−R) −hn ¢LR¤ Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM b¡L−mJ HC Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM ®eC,
Qa¥bÑax P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm, P.W-20 BSja Eõ¡q M¡e
L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 161 d¡l¡u ®cu Sh¡eh¾c£−a P.W-33 ac¿¹L¡l£ LjÑLaÑ¡ ®j¡x
M¡−mL¥‹¡j¡−el L¡−R HC Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM L−l¢e,
p−hÑ¡f¢l, P.W-2 −j¡x lSh Bm£l p¡−rÉ f¡Ju¡ k¡u ®k, HC Bp¡j£ pi¡l
öl¦ ®b−LC j−’ P.W-2 −j¡x lSh Bm£l ¢fR−e hp¡ AhÙÛ¡u ¢Rmz
p‰a L¡l−ZC Ef−l¡š² p¡rÉ fÐj¡Z¡¢c fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ¢pÜ¡−¿¹ B¢p ®k, ¢h‘
¢ejÀ Bc¡ma S¡q¡‰£l Jl−g hs S¡q¡‰£l ¢fa¡-e¤l ®q¡−pe−L cä¢h¢dl
302/120M/34 d¡l¡u ®k jªa¥Écä¡−cn fÐc¡e L−l−R a¡ lcl¢qa−k¡NÉz
cä¢h¢dl 302/120M/34 d¡l¡u k¡h‹£he L¡l¡cäfСç Bp¡j£ l¡¢Lh¤¢Ÿe
plL¡l Jl−g f¡è¤ plL¡l pÇf−LÑ B−m¡Qe¡ J ¢pÜ¡¿¹x
HC Bp¡j£l c¡−ul Ll¡ ®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew 1515/2005 pÇf−LÑ ¢pÜ¡¿¹z
k¡h‹£he L¡l¡cäfСç Bp¡j£ l¡¢Lh¤¢Ÿe plL¡l Jl−g f¡è¤ plL¡−ll e¡j
HS¡q¡−l ®eCz Bp¡j£ j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h LaѪL ®c¡o ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL
Sh¡eh¾c£ fÐcnÑe£-27 fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, HC Sh¡eh¾c£−a hm¡ q−u−R,
“B¢je Hl XÊCw l¦−j Y¤−L ®c¢M ®pM¡−e e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l, f¡è¤ plL¡l,
e¤l¦m Cpm¡j c£f¤, B¢je, a¡l i¡¢aS¡ BCu¤h hp¡z” ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL
Sh¡eh¾c£−a f¡è¤ plL¡l pÇf−LÑ Bl ®L¡e hš²hÉ ®eCz AbÑ¡v osk¿»j§mL pi¡u
f¡è¤ plL¡−ll p¢œ²u AwnNËq−Zl ®L¡e ¢hhlZ ®eCz P.W-3 ®j¡x Bh¤m L¡−nj
112
OVe¡l 10/12 ¢ce f§−hÑ Bp¡j£ B¢j−ll h¡¢sl f§hÑ ¢c−L 1¢V p¡c¡ fСC−iV
N¡s£l ¢ial XÊ¡C¢iw ¢p−V Afl Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡−ll f¡−n f¡è¤
plL¡l−L h−p b¡L−a ®c−Mz ¢L¿º P.W-33 ac¿¹L¡l£ LjÑLaÑ¡ ®j¡x
M¡−mL¥‹¡j¡e a¡l p¡−rÉ E−õM L−le ®k, P.W-3 −j¡x Bh¤m L¡−nj L¡kÑ¢h¢dl
161 d¡l¡u ®cu Sh¡eh¾c£−a a¡l L¡−R h−m e¡C ®k, Bp¡j£ f¡è¤ plL¡l N¡s£l
¢ia−l h−p, XÊ¡C¢iw ¢p−V Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l, Bp¡j£ e¤l Cpm¡j c£f¤,
Bu§h J B¢je N¡s£l clS¡ M¤−m Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡−ll p¡−b Lb¡
h−m−R ®cM−a f¡uz P.W-34 q¡¢gS¤l lqj¡e q¡¢hh OVe¡l 10/12 ¢ce f§−hÑ
l¡a 10.00 V¡l ¢c−L jlL¥−el B¢je ®ea¡l h¡¢s−a a¡l ¯hWLM¡e¡l ¢ia−l
AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£NZ−L ®cM−a −f−mJ HC Bp¡j£−L ®c−M−R a¡ E−õM L−l¢ez
HC Bp¡j£ OVe¡l pju OVe¡ÙÛ−m Ef¢ÙÛa ¢Rm HLb¡ ®L¡e p¡r£ E−õM
L−l¢ez p¡¢hÑL ¢h−hQe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k,
fÐbjax HS¡q¡−l HC Bp¡j£l e¡j ®eC,
¢àa£uax j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Hl ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£−a HC
Bp¡j£ ®Lhm “hp¡” E−õM B−Rz Afl¢c−L P.W-34 q¡¢gS¤l lqj¡e q¡¢hh
AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl jlL¥−el B¢j−el h¡s£−a osk¿»j§mL pi¡u ®cM−a −f−mJ
HC Bp¡j£−L ®c−M¢ez Efl¿º P.W-3 ®j¡x Bh¤m L¡−nj HC Bp¡j£−L
jlL¥−el B¢j−el h¡s£l p¡j−el p¡c¡ fСC−iV L¡−l Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j
plL¡−ll XÊ¡C¢iw p£−Vl f¡−n H Bp¡j£−L h−p b¡L−a ®cM−mJ P.W-33
ac¿¹L¡l£ LjÑLaÑ¡ −j¡x M¡−mL¥‹¡j¡−el L¡−R L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 161 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£−a
HLb¡ E−õM L−l¢e,
113
H AhÙÛ¡u AaÉ¿¹ p¤Øføi¡−h ¢pÜ¡−¿¹ B¢p ®k, k¡h‹£he L¡l¡c−ä c¢äa
l¡¢Lh¤¢Ÿe plL¡l Jl−g f¡è¤ plL¡l−L ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma cä¢h¢dl
302/120M/34 d¡l¡u ®k cä¡−cn fÐc¡e L−l−Re a¡ lcl¢qa −k¡NÉz
cä¢h¢dl 302/120M/34 d¡l¡u k¡h‹£he L¡l¡cäfСç Bp¡j£ BCu¤h Bm£
pÇf−LÑ B−m¡Qe¡ J ¢pÜ¡¿¹x
HC Bp¡j£l c¡−ul Ll¡ ®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew 1515/2005
B−m¡Qe¡œ²−j ¢pÜ¡¿¹z
cä¢h¢dl 302/120M/34 d¡l¡u k¡h‹£he L¡l¡cäfÊ¡ç Bp¡j£ BCu¤h
Bm£l cä¡−cn fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k,
fÐbjax BCu¤h Bm£l e¡j HS¡q¡−l ®eCz
¢àa£uax j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h LaѪL ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£−a E−õM
B−R ®k, “B¢je Hl XÊCw l¦−j Y¤−L ®c¢M ®pM¡−e e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l, f¡è¤
plL¡l, e¤l¦m Cpm¡j c£f¤, B¢je, a¡l i¡¢aS¡ BCu¤h hp¡z”
a«a£uax P.W-3 −j¡x Bh¤m L¡−nj a¡l Sh¡eh¾c£−a h−m ®k, OVe¡l
10/12 ¢ce f§−hÑ B¢j−el h¡s£l f¡−n e¤l¦m Cpm¡j ¢cf¤, BCu¤h J B¢je N¡s£l
clS¡ M¤−m Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡−ll p¡−b Lb¡ hm−R ®cM−a f¡uz 10/12
¢ce fl OVe¡ OV¡u ¢a¢e “Ae¤ih” L−le Hl¡C OVe¡ O¢V−u−Rz P.W-34
q¡¢gS¤l lqj¡e q¡¢hh OVe¡l 10/12 ¢ce B−N l¡a 10.00 V¡l ¢c−L jlL¥−el
B¢je ®ea¡l h¡¢s−a HC Bp¡j£ BCu¤h−L ®cM−a f¡ez HC ®cM¡l ¢hou¢V paÉ
eu j−jÑ p¡−Sne ®cu¡ quz
114
AbÑ¡v ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤−hl ®c¡o ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£
j−a, osk¿» pi¡u HC c¢äa Bp¡j£ BCu¤−hl ®L¡e p¢œ²u AwnNËqZ −eC, ®p
a¡l Q¡Q¡ B¢j−el h¡¢s−a Ef¢ÙÛa ¢Rm j¡œz P.W-3 ®j¡x Bh¤m L¡−nj OVe¡l
10/12 ¢ce f§−hÑ HC Bp¡j£−L AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b Lb¡ hm−a ®c−M Hhw
P.W-34 q¡¢gS¤l lqj¡e q¡¢hh OVe¡l 10/12 ¢ce f§−hÑ osk¿»pi¡u HC
Bp¡j£−L Ef¢ÙÛa b¡L−a ®c−Mz
−k−qa¥ HC Bp¡j£ OVe¡l pj−u Ef¢ÙÛa ¢Rme¡, OVe¡l 10/12 ¢ce f§−hÑ HC
Bp¡j£−L P.W-3 ®j¡x Bh¤m L¡−nj jlL¥−el B¢j−el h¡¢sl f¡−n AeÉ¡eÉ
Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b ®c−M, P.W-34 q¡¢gS¤l lqj¡e q¡¢hh HC B¡p¡j£−L osk¿»
pi¡u ®c−M, p−hÑ¡f¢l j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤−hl ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£−a
−cM¡ k¡u ®k, HC Bp¡j£ osk¿»pi¡u ®Lhmj¡œ “hp¡” AhÙÛ¡u ¢Rm, a¡l ®L¡e
p¢œ²u AwnNËq−Zl ®L¡e ¢Qœ p¡¢hÑL fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u f¡Ju¡ k¡u e¡, ®p−qa¥ ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ
Bc¡ma La«ÑL h¢ZÑa d¡l¡u c¢äa Bp¡j£−L ®cu k¡h‹£he L¡l¡cä¡−cn¢V
p−¾c−ql AhL¡−n (benefit of doubt) lcl¢qa ®k¡NÉ j−jÑ ¢pÜ¡−¿¹ B¢pz
cä¢h¢dl 302/120M/34 d¡l¡u k¡h‹£he cäfСç Bp¡j£ S¡q¡‰£l Jl−g
−j¡x S¡q¡‰£l Bmj ¢fa¡- ®j−ql Bm£ pÇf−LÑ B−m¡Qe¡ J ¢pÜ¡¿¹x
H Bp¡j£l c¡−ul Ll¡ 1845/2005 ew ®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m¢V B−m¡Qe¡œ²−j
¢pÜ¡¿¹z
¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma cä¢h¢dl 302/120M/34 d¡l¡u Bp¡j£ S¡q¡‰£l Jl−g
−j¡x S¡q¡‰£l Bmj ¢fa¡ ®j−ql Bm£−L k¡h‹£he L¡l¡cä¡−cn fÐc¡e L−l−Rez
e¢b fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u −k,
115
fÐbjax HC Bp¡j£l e¡j HS¡q¡−l ®eCz
¢àa£uax fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡
Jl−g j¡qh¤h La«ÑL ®cu ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£−a HC Bp¡j£l e¡j ®eCz
a«a£uax fÐcnÑe£- 23 ¢Q¢q²a P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm LaѪL ®cu
jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡u (k¡ flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a
q−u−R) HC Bp¡j£l e¡j ®eCz
P.W- 1 −j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e, P.W-4 −j¡x B¢je E¢Ÿe plL¡l, P.W-6
®j¡x BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j j¡p¤j, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc Hhw P.W-26
j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm OVe¡l pju HC Bp¡j£−L …¢m Ll−a ®c−M−R j−jÑ ®k
p¡rÉ fÐc¡e L−l P.W- 33 ac¿¹L¡l£ LjÑLaÑ¡ ®j¡x M¡−mL¥‹¡j¡−el p¡rÉ
fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, h¢ZÑa p¡r£l¡ L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 161 d¡l¡u HC Bp¡j£−L
h¢ZÑa j−a OVe¡ÙÛ−m AwnNËq−Zl Lb¡ ac¿¹L¡l£ LjÑLaÑ¡l L¡−R h−m¢ez
P.W-7 S¡¢Ll ®q¡−pe, P.W-8 −j¡x Bš²¡l ®q¡−pe, P.W-9 à£−S¾cÐ
plL¡l, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc Hhw P.W-28 S¡¢hc Bqp¡e l¡−pm HC
Bp¡j£−L AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b OVe¡l pju f¢ÕQj ¢c−Ll N¢m ®b−L ®R¡V
®R¡V AÙ» q¡−a c¢rZ ¢c−L H−p Bp¡j£ ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£l h¡¢sl ¢c−L Q−m ®k−a
®c−M j−jÑ ®k hš²hÉ l¡−M P.W-33 ac¿¹ LjÑLaÑ¡ ®j¡x M¡−mL¥‹¡j¡−el p¡rÉ
fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 161 d¡l¡u h¢ZÑa p¡r£NZ ac¿¹ LjÑLaÑ¡l
L¡−R HLb¡ E−õM L−l¢ez
¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma c¢äa Bp¡j£ S¡q¡‰£l Jl−g ®j¡x S¡q¡‰£l Bmj ¢fa¡-
®j−ql Bm£-®L cä¢h¢dl 302/120M/34 d¡l¡u ®c¡o£ p¡hÉÙ¹ f§hÑL k¡h‹£he
116
L¡l¡c−ä c¢äa L−l−Rez ¢L¿º Ef−ll B−m¡Qe¡l B−m¡−L ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, c¢äa
Bp¡j£ S¡q¡‰£l Jl−g ®j¡x S¡q¡‰£l Bmj ¢fa¡- ®j−ql Bm£l e¡j HS¡q¡−l
®eC, j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h LaѪL fÐcš
ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£−a ®eC, P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jq−ml jªa¥ÉL¡m£e
®O¡oZ¡®a (k¡ flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R)
−eC, p−hÑ¡f¢l ®k pLm p¡r£l¡ HC Bp¡j£−L OVe¡l pj−u OVe¡ÙÛ−m h¡ OVe¡ÙÛm
®b−L Q−m ®k−a ®c−M−R ®p pLm p¡r£NZ ac¿¹ LjÑLaÑ¡l L¡−R L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 161
d¡l¡u ®cu Sh¡eh¾c£ fÐc¡−el pju a¡ E−õM L−l¢ez p‰a L¡l−ZC L¡kÑ¢h¢dl
161 d¡l¡u ®cu Sh¡eh¾c£ h¢qÑia flha£ÑL¡−m Bc¡m−a H−p HC Bp¡j£l
¢hl¦−Ü ®cu hš²hÉ flha£Ñ ¢Q¿¹¡fÐp§a Hhw pª¢Sa (after thought and
embellishment) j−jÑ Bc¡ma ¢hnÄ¡p L−lz H AhÙÛ¡u h¢ZÑa p¡r£NZ
flha£Ñ−a Bc¡m−a H−p −k hš²hÉ ®l−M−R ®p pÇf−LÑ ®L¡e f¢lf¤lL h¡
¢hnÄ¡p−k¡NÉ AhÙÛ¡Na fÐj¡Z Bc¡m−al p¡j−e e¡ b¡L¡u ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma LaѪL
®cu H Bp¡j£−L k¡h‹£he L¡l¡cä¡−cn¢V lcl¢qa ®k¡NÉ j−jÑ ¢pÜ¡−¿¹ B¢pz
cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥ÉcäfСç Bp¡j£ c¤m¡m ¢ju¡ pÇf−LÑ B−m¡Qe¡
J ¢pÜ¡¿¹ x
−Xb ®lg¡−l−¾pl p¡−b H Bp¡j£l c¡−ul Ll¡ ®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew
1452/2005 J ®Sm Bf£m ew 415/2005 HLp¡−b B−m¡Qe¡u ®eu¡ q−m¡z
¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma HC Bp¡j£−L cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u ®c¡o£ p¡hÉÙ¹f§hÑL
jªa¥Écä¡−cn fÐc¡e L−l−Rz e¢b fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k,
fÐbjax HC Bp¡j£l e¡j HS¡q¡−l B−R,
117
¢àa£uax j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h LaѪL ®cu
fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a ®c¡o ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£−a HC Bp¡j£l e¡j ®eC,
a«a£uax P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm LaѪL fÐcš jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡u
(k¡ flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) HC
Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM ®eC,
Qa¥bÑax P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e, P.W-4 ®j¡x Bj¡e E¢Ÿe plL¡l,
P.W-5 ®j¡x ®M¡l−nc Bmj, P.W-6 ®j¡x BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j j¡p¤j, P.W-10
®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc Hhw P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm a¡−cl p¡−rÉ E−õM
L−l−R ®k, OVe¡l ¢ce c¤m¡m ¢ju¡pq AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£®cl j−’ Ef¢hø Hj,¢f
p¡−qh−L J jqm−L E−ŸnÉ L−l ¢fÙ¹m J ¢limh¡l ¢c−u …¢m Ll−a ®c−M−R ¢L¿º
P.W-4 ®j¡x Bj¡e E¢Ÿe plL¡l, P.W-5 ®j¡x ®M¡l−nc Bmj, P.W-6 ®j¡x
BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j j¡p¤j Hhw P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc P.W-33 ac¿¹L¡l£
LjÑLaÑ¡ −j¡x M¡−mL¥‹¡j¡−el L¡−R L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 161 d¡l¡u ®cu Sh¡eh¾c£−a HC
hš²hÉ ®cu¢ez P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm Bc¡m−a H−p Bp¡j£ c¤m¡m
¢ju¡−L …¢m Ll−a ®c−M j−jÑ E−õM Ll−mJ a¡l ®cu fÐcnÑe£-23 ¢Q¢q²a
jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡u (k¡ flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a
q−u−R) HC Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM L−l¢ez ac¤f¢l ac¿¹ LjÑLaÑ¡l L¡−R L¡kÑ¢h¢dl
161 d¡l¡u ®cu Sh¡eh¾c£−aJ HC Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM L−l¢ez j−’ Ef¢hø
P.W-1 HS¡q¡lL¡l£ −j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e HS¡q¡−l HC Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM
Ll−mJ j−’ Ef¢hø P.W-2 ®j¡x lSh Bm£ h¡ j−’ Ef¢hø AeÉ¡eÉ p¡r£l¡
HC Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM L−l¢ez Ab¡Ñv ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, ®Lhmj¡œ HS¡q¡−l H
118
Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM hÉ¢aa HC Bp¡j£l ¢hl¦−Ü l¡øÌfr A¢i−k¡N fÐj¡−Zl SeÉ
Bl ®L¡e NËqZ−k¡NÉ pj¢bÑa p¡rÉ fÐj¡Z h¡ AhÙÛ¡Na fÐj¡Z¡¢c Bc¡m−al p¡j−e
EfÙÛ¡fe Ll−a pÇf§ZÑi¡−h hÉbÑ q−u−Rz p‰a L¡l−Z ¢pÜ¡−¿¹ B¢p ®k, ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ
Bc¡ma LaѪL jªa¥ÉcäfСç Bp¡j£ c¤m¡m ¢ju¡l jªa¥Écä¡−cn lcl¢qa ®k¡NÉz
cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥Écä fСç Bp¡j£ ®m¡Lj¡e ®q¡−pe Jl−g h¤m¤
pÇf−LÑ B−m¡Qe¡ J ¢pÜ¡¿¹ x
−Xb ®lg¡−l¾p R¡s¡J HC Bp¡j£l c¡−ul Ll¡ −g±Sc¡l£ ¢h¢hd ew
41411/2014 B−m¡Qe¡u ®eu¡ q−m¡z
c¢äa Bp¡j£ −m¡Lj¡e ®q¡−pe Jl−g h¤m¤ pÇf−LÑ ¢ek¤¢š²u ¢h‘ BCeS£h£
H,Hj, j¡qh¤h E¢Ÿe h−me ®k, HS¡q¡−l E−õ¢Ma h¤m¤ ¢ju¡, ¢fa¡-A‘¡a,
phÑp¡w-®N¡f¡mf¤l, HC c¢äa Bp¡j£ ®m¡Lj¡e ®q¡−pe h¤m¤ euz e¢b fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u
®cM¡ k¡u ®k, L¢ba ®m¡Lj¡e ®q¡−pe h¤m¤ HC j¡jm¡u phÑfÐbj Cw 07/10/2014
a¡¢l−M ®e¡u¡M¡m£ ®b−L ®NËga¡l quz ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ ®m¡Lj¡e ®q¡−pe h¤m¤l
®i¡V¡l ¢mø Hhw ¢eL¡qe¡j¡ Bc¡m−a c¡¢Mm L−lez ®pM¡−e ®cM¡ k¡u ®k,
®m¡Lj¡e ®q¡−pe h¤m¤l e¡j Ab¡Ñv Ef¢ÙÛa Bp¡j£l e¡j L¡j¡m ®q¡−pe h¤m¤, ¢fa¡-
Bx N¢Z E−õM B−Rz HS¡q¡l fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, HS¡q¡−l h¤m¤ ¢ju¡,
¢fa¡-A‘¡a, phÑp¡w-®N¡f¡mf¤l Hhw Q¡SÑn£−V ®m¡Lj¡e ®q¡−pe h¤m¤ ¢ju¡, ¢fa¡-
N¢Z ¢ju¡, VwN£ E−õM B−Rz ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ h−me ®k, Ef¢ÙÛa Bp¡j£−L
i¥mœ²−j Cw 07/10/2014 a¡¢l−M ®e¡u¡M¡m£ ®b−L ®NËga¡l L−l HC j¡jm¡u
c¢äa Bp¡j£ ®m¡Lj¡e ®q¡−pe h¤m¤ ¢q®p−h ®cM¡−e¡ q−u−Rz ¢h‘ BCeS£h£l
hš²−hÉl ®fТr−a HC ®i¡V¡l ¢mø h¡ ¢eL¡qe¡j¡ p¢WL eu h¡ c¢äa Bp¡j£
119
®m¡Lj¡e ®q¡−pe h¤m¤ Cw 07/10/2014 a¡¢l−M ®e¡u¡M¡m£ ®b−L ®NËga¡lL«a
Ef¢ÙÛa L¡j¡m ®q¡−pe h¤m¤, ¢fa¡- Bx N¢Z HLC hÉ¢š² h¡ ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ LaѪL
E›¡¢fa “wrong identification” pÇf−LÑ l¡øÌfr ®b−L ®L¡e ¢h−l¡¢da¡ Ll¡
qu¢ez
P.W-1 −j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e, P.W-4 ®j¡x Bj¡e E¢Ÿe plL¡l, P.W-5
®j¡x ®M¡l−nc Bmj, P.W-6 ®j¡x BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j j¡p¤j, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g
Bq−jc, P.W-18 ®j¡x Bqp¡e Eõ¡q, P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm H
Bp¡j£−L AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b OVe¡ÙÛ−m …¢m Ll−a ®c−M−R j−jÑ −k hš²hÉ
®l−M−R a¡ Ef−l¡š² B−m¡Qe¡l B−m¡−L “wrong identification” Hl
p−¾c−ql AhL¡−n NËqZ−k¡NÉ eu j−jÑ ¢pÜ¡−¿¹ B¢pz
HC AhÙÛ¡u ®k−qa¥ HC Bp¡j£l e¡j HS¡q¡−l B−R (d−l ¢e−mJ) ¢L¿º
j¡qh¤¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤−hl fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a
ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£−a h¡ P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jq−ml jªa¥ÉL¡m£e
−O¡oZ¡u (k¡ flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) HC
Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM ®eC, p−hÑ¡f¢l p¡r£−cl hš²−hÉ HC Bp¡j£l ¢hl¦−Ü p¤Øfø
J p¤¢e¢cÑøi¡−h ®L¡e p¢œ²u AwnNËq−Zl Lb¡ ®eC Hhw Bp¡j£f−r ¢h‘
BCeS£h£l wrong identification pÇf−LÑ l¡øÌf−r ®L¡e ¢h−l¡¢da¡ −eC
®p−qa¥ p−¾c−ql AhL¡−n (benefit of doubt) HC Bp¡j£−L ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ
Bc¡ma La«ÑL ®cu jªa¥Écä¡−cn lcl¢qc ®k¡NÉ j−jÑ ¢pÜ¡−¿¹ B¢pz
120
cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥ÉcäfСç Bp¡j£ gup¡m J l¢e ¢ju¡ Jl−g l¢e
g¢Ll pÇf−LÑ B−m¡Qe¡ J ¢pÜ¡¿¹ x
HC Bp¡j£àu HLC g¥¢Vwi§š² (footing) Hhw ®Lhmj¡œ ®Xb ®lg¡−l¾p
b¡L¡u HLp¡−b B−m¡Qe¡u ®eu¡ q−m¡z
¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma HC Bp¡j£−cl−L cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u ®c¡o£
p¡hÉÙ¹f§hÑL jªa¥Écä¡−cn fÐc¡e L−l−Rez e¢b fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k,
fÐbja x HC Bp¡j£−cl e¡j HS¡q¡−l E−õM B−R,
¢àa£uax fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡
Jl−g j¡qh¤−hl ®cu ®c¡o ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£−a HC Bp¡j£®cl e¡j ®eC,
a«a£uax P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm LaѪL jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡u (k¡
flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) HC Bp¡j£−cl
e¡j E−õM ®eC,
Qa¥bÑax P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e, P.W-4 ®j¡x Bj¡e E¢Ÿe
plL¡l, P.W-5 ®j¡x ®M¡l−nc Bmj, P.W-6 ®j¡x BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j j¡p¤j,
P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc, P.W-18 −j¡x Bqp¡e Eõ¡q, Hhw P.W-20
BSja Eõ¡q M¡e Hl p¡rÉ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, HC Bp¡j£−cl pÇf−LÑ
hm¡ q−u−R AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b HC Bp¡j£l¡ H−m¡f¡b¡¢s …¢mhoÑZ L−l−Rz
ac¿¹L¡l£ LjÑLaÑ¡ P.W-33 ®j¡x L¡jl¦‹¡j¡e Hl p¡rÉ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u
®k, HC Bp¡j£−cl f−r ®ØVV ¢X−g¾p ¢e−u¡¢Sa ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ ®Sl¡ adopt
L−l−Re j¡œz p¤¢e¢cÑøi¡−h HC Bp¡j£−cl f−r ®L¡e ®Sl¡ Ll¡ qu¢ez ®ØVV
¢X−g¾p LaѪL ¢e−u¡¢Sa ¢h‘ BCeS£h£l Hl¦f ¢e¢mÑça¡ h¡’e£u euz
121
HC Bc¡m−a ®Xg ®lg¡−l¾p öe¡e£L¡−m HC Bp¡j£−cl f−r ®ØVV
¢X−g¾p ¢e−u¡¢Sa ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ Se¡h H. Hj. ®j¡x B¢SS¤m qL h−me ®k,
¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma HC Bp¡j£−cl−L ®k jªa¥Écä¡−cn fÐc¡e L−l−Re a¡ p¢WL
euz
HS¡q¡l, Ef−l h¢ZÑa p¡r£−cl hš²hÉ, ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡m−al ®ØVV ¢X−g¾p
¢e−u¡¢Sa ¢h‘ BCeS£h£l ®Sl¡l dlZ, p−hÑ¡f¢l HC Bc¡m−a ®ØVV ¢X−g¾p
¢e−u¡¢Sa ¢h‘ BCeS£h£l hš²hÉ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, jªa¥ÉcäfСç Bp¡j£
gup¡m J l¢e ¢ju¡ Jl−g l¢e g¢L−ll ¢hl¦−Ü HS¡q¡−l p¤¢e¢cÑø A¢i−k¡N e¡
b¡L−mJ AeÉ¡eÉ 17 Se Bp¡j£l p¡−b ®Lhmj¡œ a¡−cl e¡j¢V ®ki¡−h E−õ¢Ma
q−u−R ¢WL ®pi¡−hC Ef−l E−õ¢Ma p¡r£NZ AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b a¡−cl
e¡j¢V EµQ¡lZ L−l−R j¡œz HLCi¡−h ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma LaѪL ®ØVV ¢X−g¾p
¢e−u¡¢Sa ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ Hhw HC Bc¡m−a ®ØVV ¢X−g¾p ¢ek¤¢š²u ¢h‘
BCeS£h£ HC Bp¡j£−cl ¢hl¦−Ü HL¢V ‘Nulq’ BQl−Z a¡−cl hš²hÉ EfÙÛ¡fe
L−le Hhw Be£a A¢i−k¡N plL¡l fr p¤Øfø J p¤¢e¢cÑøi¡−h LaV¡ fÐj¡Z
Ll−a −f−l−R ®p pÇf−LÑ Bc¡ma−L p¡q¡kÉ Ll¡ ®b−L Ec¡p£e b¡−Lez H ®r−œ
HC Bc¡ma A¢ija ®f¡oZ L−l ®k, ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma Hhw p¢m¢pVl ECw ®ØVV
¢X−g¾p BCeS£h£ ¢e−u¡−N flha£Ñ−a AaÉ¿¹ p−Qae q−h ®ke ®L¡e Bp¡j£
fm¡aL b¡L−m h¡ BCeS£h£ ¢e−u¡−N hÉbÑ q−m H pLm Bp¡j£NZ p¢WL,
B¿¹¢lL Hhw kb¡kb BCe£ pq¡ua¡ fСç quz
f§−hÑC E−õM Ll¡ q−u−R ®k, HC Bp¡j£−cl e¡j HS¡q¡−l b¡L−mJ
fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h
122
LaѪL ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£−a f¡Ju¡ k¡u ®k, osk¿» pi¡ h¡ OVe¡l ¢ce
Afl Bp¡j£ ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£l h¡¢s−a AeÉ¡eÉ ®hn ¢LR¤ Bp¡j£−cl HL¢œa qh¡l
pjuJ HC Bp¡j£l¡ Ef¢ÙÛa ¢Rme¡z P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm a¡l
jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡u (k¡ flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a
q−u−R) HC Bp¡j£−cl e¡j E−õM L−l¢ez HC jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡u (k¡ flha£Ñ−a
L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e
jqm 6 Se Bp¡j£l e¡j p¤Øføi¡−h E−õM f§hÑL h−m−Re ®k, “HC 6 Se
R¡s¡J BlJ p¿»¡p£ ¢Rmz a¡−cl Lb¡ HMe Memory-®a Be−a f¡l¢R e¡z”
HC P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm Bc¡m−a H−p a¡l Sh¡eh¾c£−a ®k 6 Se
Bp¡j£l e¡j p¤Øføi¡−h E−õM L−l−Re a¡l h¡C−l B−l¡ −hn¢LR¤ Bp¡j£l e¡j
E−õM Ll−mJ HC Bp¡j£®cl e¡j E−õM L−l¢ez P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e
Hhw P.W-2 ®j¡x lSh Bm£ HLC j−’ OVe¡l pju Ef¢ÙÛa b¡L¡ AhÙÛ¡u,
P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e HC Bp¡j£−cl−L OVe¡ÙÛ−m …¢m Ll−a ®c−M−R j−jÑ
E−õM L®l, AbQ P.W-2 ®j¡x lSh Bm£ HC Bp¡j£−cl ¢hl¦−Ü ¢LR¤C h−m e¡z
p−hÑ¡f¢l HC j¡jm¡l AeÉaj p¡r£ P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm HC
Bp¡j£−cl Ef¢ÙÛ¢al Lb¡ h−m e¡z
p¡¢hÑL fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, HS¡q¡−l HC Bp¡j£−cl e¡j E−õM
b¡L−mJ a¡−cl ¢hl¦−Ü p¤Øfø J p¤¢e¢cÑøi¡−h ¢LR¤ hm¡ qu¢ez h¢ZÑa p¡r£l¡ HC
Bp¡j£−cl e¡j¢V Bl 15/20 Se Bp¡j£l p¡−b EµQ¡lZ L−l−R j¡œz p−hÑ¡f¢l
P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm ¢k¢e HC j¡jm¡l AeÉaj p¡r£ ¢a¢e HC
Bp¡j£−cl e¡j E−õM L−le ¢e Hhw j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡
123
Jl−g j¡qh¤h LaѪL ®cu fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£ j−a
OVe¡l ¢ce ®kM¡−e ®hn ¢LR¤ Bp¡j£ HL¢œa q−u¢Rm ®pM¡−eJ HC Bp¡j£®cl
e¡j ®eCz AbÑ¡v ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, HC Bp¡j£−cl e¡j HS¡q¡−l Hhw ¢LR¤ ¢LR¤ p¡r£l
hš²−hÉ ®ki¡−h H−p−R a¡ p¤Øfø J p¤¢e¢cÑø euz p−hÑ¡f¢l OVe¡ÙÛ−ml AeÉaj
p¡r£l¡ HC Bp¡j£−cl e¡j E−õM L−l¢ez −kje P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e
jqm, P.W-2 ®j¡x lSh Bm£z f§−hÑ E−õ¢Ma Bp¡j£−cl ¢hl¦−Ü Be£a
A¢i−k¡N fÐj¡−Zl ¢i¢š ¢q−p−h 3¢V j§m Ù¹−ñl (pillar) j−dÉ j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e
j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤l LaѪL fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a
ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£−a Hhw P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm LaѪL
jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡u (k¡ flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a
q−u−R) HC Bp¡j£−cl e¡j E−õM ®eCz ®Lhmj¡œ HS¡q¡−l AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl
p¡−b HC Bp¡j£−cl e¡j¢V E−õM B−R j¡œz HC AhÙÛ¡u HC Bp¡j£−cl ¢hl¦−Ü
Be£a ‘A¢e¢cÑø’ A¢i−k¡N¢V p¤Øfø J p¤¢e¢cÑøi¡−h l¡øÌfr fÐj¡Z Ll−a pjbÑ
q−u−R h−m Bj¡−cl L¡−R ¢h−h¢Qa qu¢ez
Ef−l¡š² B−m¡Qe¡l B−m¡−L ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma LaѪL cä¢h¢dl
302/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥ÉcäfСç Bp¡j£ gup¡m Hhw l¢e ¢ju¡ Jl−g l¢e g¢Ll−L
®k jªa¥Écä¡−cn fÐc¡e Ll¡ qu a¡ lcl¢qa ®k¡NÉ j−jÑ ¢pÜ¡−¿¹ B¢pz
cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥ÉcäfСç Bp¡j£ ®M¡Le pÇf−LÑ B−m¡Qe¡ J
¢pÜ¡¿¹ x
HC Bp¡j£l ¢hl¦−Ü ®Lhmj¡œ ®Xb ®lg¡−l¾p öe¡e£l SeÉ ®eu¡ quz
124
¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma HC Bp¡j£−L cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u ®c¡o£ p¡hÉÙ¹f§hÑL
jªa¥Écä¡−cn fÐc¡e L−l−Rez e¢b fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k,
fÐbja x HC Bp¡j£l e¡j HS¡q¡−l E−õM −eC,
¢àa£uax fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡
Jl−g j¡qh¤−hl ®cu ®c¡o ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£−a HC Bp¡j£l e¡j ®eC,
a«a£uax P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm LaѪL jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡u (k¡
flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) HC Bp¡j£l
e¡j E−õM ®eC,
Qa¥bÑax P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e, P.W-2 ®j¡x lSh Bm£, P.W-4
®j¡x Bj¡e E¢Ÿe plL¡l, P.W-5 ®j¡x ®M¡l−nc Bmj, P.W-6 ®j¡x
BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j j¡p¤j, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc, P.W-18 −j¡x Bqp¡e
Eõ¡q, Hhw P.W-20 BSja Eõ¡q M¡e, P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm
a¡−cl p¡−rÉ E−õM L−l−R ®k, AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b HC Bp¡j£®L OVe¡l
pju OVe¡ÙÛ−m AÙ»q¡−a …¢mhoÑZ Ll−a ®c−M−Rz
P.W-1 −j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e HS¡q¡lL¡l£ ¢q−p−h 17 S−el e¡j
HS¡q¡−l E−õM Ll−mJ HC Bp¡j£l e¡j HS¡q¡−l E−õM L−l¢ez OVe¡l 35
O¾V¡ f−l c¡−ulL«a HS¡q¡−l ®kM¡−e 17 Se Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM Ll¡ q−u−R
k¡−cl−L ¢a¢e OVe¡ÙÛ−m ®c−M¢R−me, ®pM¡−e HC Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM e¡ b¡L¡u
p‰a L¡l−ZC P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e Bc¡m−a H−p kMe HC Bp¡j£l e¡j
OVe¡ÙÛ−m Ef¢ÙÛa ¢Rm j−jÑ E−õM L−l ®p ¢hou¢V p¡¢hÑL ®fÐr¡fV ¢h−hQe¡u
NËqZ−k¡NÉ euz P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm a¡l jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡u (k¡
125
flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) HC Bp¡j£l
e¡j h−m¢ez
f§−hÑC E−õM Ll¡ q−u−R ®k, Bp¡j£−cl ¢hl¦−Ü A¢i−k¡N fÐj¡−Zl j§m
¢i¢š ¢qp¡−h 3¢V Ù¹ñ−L (pillar) ¢h−hQe¡u Be¡ q−u−Rz fÐbjax HS¡q¡l,
¢àa£uax j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h LaѪL ®cu
fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£, a«a£uax P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l
lqj¡e jqm La«ÑL jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oe¡ (k¡ flhaÑ£−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l
Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R)z HC ¢ae¢V j§m Ù¹−ñl HL¢V−aJ HC Bp¡j£l
e¡j E−õM ®eCz E−õ¢Ma p¡r£l¡ flha£Ñ−a Bc¡m−a H−p AeÉ¡eÉ pLm
Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b HC Bp¡j£l e¡j¢V ‘A¢e¢cÑøi¡−h’ E−õM L−l−R j¡œz
Afl Bp¡j£ gup¡m J l¢e ¢ju¡ Jl−g l¢e g¢Ll Hl eÉ¡u HC
Bp¡j£l f−rJ ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma ®b−L ®ØVV ¢X−g¾p ¢e−u¡N ®cu¡ qu Hhw
haÑj¡e Bc¡m−aJ HC Bp¡j£l f−r ®ØVV ¢X−g¾p BCeS£h£ ¢e−u¡N ®cu¡ quz
AaÉ¿¹ c¤xMSeL i¡−h mrZ£u ®k, HC ®ØVV ¢X−g¾p ¢e−u¡¢Sa ¢h‘ BCeS£h£NZ
a¡−cl c¡¢uaÅ kb¡kbi¡−h f¡m−e pÇf§ZÑi¡−h hÉbÑ q−u−Rez Bc¡ma j−e L−l,
®ØVV ¢X−g¾p ¢e−u¡¢Sa ¢h‘ BCeS£h£NZ k¢c p¢WLi¡−h HC Bp¡j£l f−r
a¡−cl c¡¢uaÅ f¡me Ll−ae a¡q−m ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡m−al L¡−R HLb¡ p¤Øføi¡−h
EfÙÛ¡¢fa qa ®k, ®kM¡−e HS¡q¡−l 17 Se Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM b¡L¡ p−šÆJ HC
Bp¡j£l e¡j ®eC, j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h
La«ÑL fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£−a HC Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM
L−l¢e, P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm LaѪL jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡u (k¡ flha£Ñ−a
126
L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) HC Bp¡j£l e¡j e¡
b¡L¡l flJ p¡r£NZ Bc¡m−a H−p HC Bp¡j£l ¢hl¦−Ü AeÉ¡eÉ pLm
Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b S¢s−u A¢e¢cÑøi¡−h ®k hš²hÉ ®l−M−R a¡ pÇf§ZÑC HC Bp¡j£l
¢hl¦−Ü flha£Ñ ¢Q¿¹¡fÐp§a J pª¢Sa (after thought and
embellishment)z
f§−hÑl B−m¡Qe¡l B−m¡−L Bh¡lJ E−õM Ll¡ q−µR ®k, ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ
Bc¡ma Hhw p¢m¢pVl ECw ®ØVV ¢X−g¾p BCeS£h£ ¢e−u¡NL¡−m flhaÑ£−a
B−l¡ paLÑ q−hez
p¡¢hÑL fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ¢pÜ¡−¿¹ B¢p ®k, ®k−qa¥ HC Bp¡j£l e¡j HS¡q¡−l
¢Rm e¡, ®k−qa¥ j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h La«ÑL fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL
Sh¡eh¾c£−aJ HC Bp¡j£l e¡j ¢Rm e¡, ®k−qa¥ P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm
La«ÑL ®cu jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡u (k¡ flhaÑ£−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£
¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) HC Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM Ll¡ qu¢e, ®Lhmj¡œ flha£Ñ−a
AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b ‘A¢e¢cÑøi¡−h’ ¢LR¤ hš²−hÉl ¢i¢š−a ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma
HC Bp¡j£−L jªa¥Écä¡−cn fÐc¡e L−l−Re ®p−qa¥ a¡ p¢WL euz
Ef−l¡š² B−m¡Qe¡l B−m¡−L ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma LaѪL cä¢h¢dl
302/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥ÉcäfСç Bp¡j£ −M¡Le−L ®k jªa¥Écä¡−cn fÐc¡e Ll¡ qu a¡
lcl¢qa ®k¡NÉ j−jÑ ¢pÜ¡−¿¹ B¢pz
127
cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u k¡h‹£he L¡l¡cäfСç Bp¡j£ j¢el pÇf−LÑ
B−m¡Qe¡ J ¢pÜ¡¿¹ x
HC Bp¡j£l c¡−ul Ll¡ 1808/2005 ew ®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m pÇf¢LÑa
B−m¡Qe¡z
cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u k¡h‹£he L¡l¡cäfСç Bp¡j£ j¢e−ll cä¡−cn
fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k,
fÐbjax Bp¡j£ j¢e−ll e¡j HS¡q¡−l B−R,
¢àa£ua x j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h LaѪL
®cu ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£−a HC Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM −eC,
a«a£ua x P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jq−ml jªa¥ÉL¡m£e −O¡oZ¡u (k¡
flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢qp¡−h Nªq£a q−u−R) HC Bp¡j£l
e¡j E−õM ®eCz
P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e, P.W-4 ®j¡x Bj¡e E¢Ÿe plL¡l, P.W-5
®j¡x ®M¡l−nc Bmj, P.W-6 ®j¡x BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j j¡p¤j, P.W-20 BSja
Eõ¡q M¡e Hhw P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm a¡−cl p¡−rÉ E−õM L−le ®k,
Bp¡j£ j¢el OVe¡l pju OVe¡ÙÛ−m ¢fÙ¹m, ¢limh¡l ¢c−u AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl
p¡−b ¢eqa Hj,¢f Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hhw jqm−L mrÉ L−l Efk§Ñf¢l …¢mhoÑZ
L−lz H fÐp−‰ ac¿¹L¡l£ LjÑLaÑ¡ P.W-33 ®j¡x M¡−mL¥‹¡j¡−el p¡rÉ
fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u, L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 161 d¡l¡u ac¿¹ LjÑLaÑ¡l L¡−R ®cu
Sh¡eh¾c£−a P.W-4 ®j¡x Bj¡e E¢Ÿe plL¡l, P.W-5 ®j¡x ®M¡l−nc Bmj,
128
P.W-6 ®j¡x BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j j¡p¤j Hhw P.W-20 BSja Eõ¡q M¡e h−m¢e
®k, OVe¡l pju a¡l¡ Bp¡j£ j¢el−L OVe¡ÙÛ−m …¢m Ll−a ®c−M−Rz
P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm Bc¡m−a H−p Bp¡j£ j¢el−L OVe¡ÙÛ−m
…¢m Ll−a ®c−M j−jÑ E−õM Ll−mJ fÐcnÑe£-23 ¢Q¢q²a jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡ (k¡
flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u
®cM¡ k¡u ®k, ®pM¡−e HC Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM ®eCz ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma HC
Bp¡j£l ¢hl¦−Ü ®Lhmj¡œ HS¡q¡−l Bp¡j£l e¡j Hhw P.W-1 HS¡q¡lL¡l£
®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡−el p¡−rÉl Efl ¢eiÑl L−l k¡h‹£he L¡l¡cä¡−cn fÐc¡e
L−l−Re z ®k−qa¥ P.W-1 HS¡q¡lL¡l£ ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡−el hš²hÉ Bl ®L¡e
p¡r£l hš²hÉ à¡l¡ pj¢bÑa eu Hhw f¡¢lf¡¢nÑÄL OVe¡ fÐh¡q Abh¡ A¢ik¤š²−cl
¢hl¦−Ü Be£a A¢i−k¡®Nl Afl c¤C j§m Ù¹ñ (pillar) j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h
Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤−hl ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j¤mL Sh¡eh¾c£ Hhw j¡qg¥S¤l
lqj¡e jq−ml jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oe¡u HC Bp¡j£l e¡j −eC, ®p−qa¥ ¢pÜ¡−¿¹ B¢p
®k, ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma LaѪL Bp¡j£ j¢el−L ®cu k¡h‹£he L¡l¡cä¡−cn lc
l¢qc ®k¡NÉz
cä¢h¢dl 302/120M/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥ÉcäfСç Bp¡j£ °puc Bq−jc jSe¤
pÇf−LÑ B−m¡Qe¡ J ¢pÜ¡¿¹ x
HC Bp¡j£l ®Lhmj¡œ ®Xb ®lg¡−l¾p öe¡e£ quz
¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma HC Bp¡j£−L cä¢h¢dl 302/120M/34 d¡l¡u
jªa¥Écä¡−cn fÐc¡e L−l−Rez e¢b fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k,
fÐbjax HC Bp¡j£l e¡j HS¡q¡−l E−õM B−R,
129
¢àa£uax j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h LaѪL ®cu
ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£ fÐcnÑe£-27 fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡ −cM¡ k¡u ®k, osk¿» pi¡u HC
c¢äa Bp¡j£ Ef¢ÙÛa ¢Rm e¡z HC Bp¡j£−L “q¡a” Ll¡ q−u−R E−õM Ll¡ qu
j¡œ,
a«a£uax P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm LaѪL ®cu jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡u (k¡
flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) HC Bp¡j£l
e¡j E−õM Ll¡ qu¢e, k¢cJ ®pM¡−e p¤Øføi¡−h ®hn ¢LR¤ Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM
B−R,
Qa¥bÑax P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e, P.W-4 ®j¡x Bj¡e E¢Ÿe plL¡l,
P.W-7 S¡¢Ll ®q¡−pe, P.W-9 à£−S¾cÐ plL¡l, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc
Hhw P.W-20 ®j¡x BSja Eõ¡q M¡e a¡−cl p¡−rÉ E−õM L−l−R ®k, Bp¡j£
jSe¤−L OVe¡l pju OVe¡ÙÛ−m ¢fÙ¹m J ¢limh¡l ¢e−u j−’ Ef¢ÙÛa Hj,¢f
Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hhw jqm−L …¢m Ll−a ®c−M−R Hhw P.W-7 S¡¢Ll
®q¡−pe, P.W-9 à£−S¾cÐ plL¡l, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc a¡−cl−L OVe¡ÙÛm
®b−L ¢fÙ¹m q¡−a Q−m ®k−a ®c−M−Rz ac¿¹L¡l£ LjÑLaÑ¡ P.W-33 ®j¡x
M¡−mL¥‹¡j¡−el p¡rÉ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, P.W-7 S¡¢Ll ®q¡−pe, P.W-
10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc Hhw P.W-20 BSja Eõ¡q M¡e L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 161 d¡l¡u
®cu Sh¡eh¾c£−a Bp¡j£ ¯puc Bq−jc jSe¤−L ¢fÙ¹m h¡ ¢limh¡l q¡−a
OVe¡ÙÛ−m Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f, jqm h¡ L¡E−L …¢m Ll−a ®c−M−R j−jÑ
h¡ Q−m ®k−a ®c−M−R j−jÑ E−õM L−l¢ez
130
−k−qa¥ HC Bp¡j£l e¡j HS¡q¡−l E−õM B−R, HS¡q¡lL¡l£ P.W-1 −j¡x
j¢aEl lqj¡e HS¡q¡−l h¢ZÑa OVe¡ p¢hÙ¹¡−l Bc¡m−a EfÙÛ¡fe L−l−R Hhw HC
Bp¡j£−L OVe¡ÙÛ−m ¢fÙ¹m, ¢limh¡l q¡−a …¢m Ll−a ®c−M−R Hhw P.W-4 ®j¡x
Bj¡e E¢Ÿe plL¡l, P.W-9 à£−S¾cÐ plL¡l, HS¡q¡lL¡l£ P.W-1 ®j¡x
j¢aEl lqj¡−el hš²hÉ−L pjbÑe L−l−R ®p−qa¥ Ef−l E−õ¢Ma AhÙÛ¡l ®fТr−a
HC Bp¡j£l OVe¡l p¡−b pÇfªš²a¡l ¢hou Hhw pj¢bÑa p¡rÉ fÐj¡Z¡¢c ¢h−hQe¡u
Bp¡j£ ¯puc Bq−jc jSe¤−L ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma LaѪL ®cu jªa¥Écä¡−c−nl
f¢lh−aÑ k¡h‹£he L¡l¡cä¡−cn fÐc¡e pj£Q£e h−m Bjl¡ j−e L¢lz
AaHh, cä¢h¢dl 302/120M/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥Écä fСç Bp¡j£ ¯puc
Bq−jc jSe¤−L jªa¥Éc−äl f¢lh−aÑ k¡h‹£he L¡l¡c−ä c¢äa Ll¡l ¢pÜ¡¿¹ quz
cä¢h¢dl 302/120M/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥ÉcäfСç Bp¡j£ −j¡q¡Çjc Bm£ pÇf−LÑ
B−m¡Qe¡ J ¢pÜ¡¿¹ x
−Xb ®lg¡−l−¾pl p¡−b 1572/2005 ew ®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m J 412/2005 ew
®Sm Bf£m HL−œ B−m¡Qe¡u ®eu¡ q−m¡z
¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma HC Bp¡j£−L cä¢h¢dl 302/120M/34 d¡l¡u
jªa¥Écä¡−cn fÐc¡e L−l−Rez e¢b fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k,
fÐbjax HC Bp¡j£l e¡j HS¡q¡−l ®eC,
¢àa£uax j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h LaѪL ®cu
ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£ fÐcnÑe£-27 fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, osk¿» pi¡u
HC ®j¡qÇjc Bm£ Ef¢ÙÛa ¢Rm Hhw HC osk−¿» a¡l p¢œ²u AwnNËqZ ¢Rmz HC
ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£−a B−l¡ f¡Ju¡ k¡u OVe¡l ¢ce Cw 07/05/2004
131
a¡¢lM pL¡m 11.00 V¡l ¢c−L Bp¡j£l h¡pih−e AeÉ¡eÉ ®hn ¢LR¤ Bp¡j£−L
HC Bp¡j£ °al£ q−a h−m,
a«a£uax P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm LaѪL fÐcš jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡u
(k¡ flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) HC
Bp¡j£l e¡j ®eC,
P.W-3 −j¡x Bh¤m L¡−nj Hl p¡−rÉ f¡Ju¡ k¡u ®k, OVe¡l 10/12 ¢ce
f§−hÑ A¡e¤j¡¢eL l¡a 11.00 O¢VL¡l ¢c−L Bp¡j£ B¢j−el h¡¢sl f§hÑ ¢c−L HL¢V
jVl p¡C−Lm J HL¢V p¡c¡ lw−ul fСC−iV N¡s£ ¢a¢e ®cM−a f¡ez p¡r£ B−l¡
S¡e¡e ®k, Bp¡j£ ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£ J j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡
Jl−g j¡qh¤h−L jVl p¡C−Lm L−l Q−m ®k−a ®c−Mez P.W-34 q¡¢gS¤l lqj¡e
q¡¢hh S¡e¡e ®k, OVe¡l 10/12 ¢ce f§−hÑ ¢a¢e jlL¥−el B¢je ®ea¡l h¡¢s−a k¡e
Hhw ®pM¡−e l¡a 10.00 V¡l ¢c−L HL¢V fСC−iV L¡l J jVl p¡C−Lm cy¡s¡−e¡
®cM−a f¡ez H pju p¡r£ Bp¡j£ B¢j−el O−ll ¢ial ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£ pq
AeÉ¡eÉ−cl h−p b¡L−a ®c−Mez j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡
Jl−g j¡qh¤−hl fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡
k¡u ®k, OVe¡l 10/12 ¢ce f§−hÑC Bp¡j£ ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£, Bp¡j£ j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e
j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h−L ®q¡ä¡u L−l jlL¥−el B¢j−el
h¡s£−a k¡u Hhw ®pM¡−e f§−hÑ E−õ¢Ma osk¿» °hWL¢V quz fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a
j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤−hl ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL
Sh¡eh¾c£l pjbÑe −j−m P.W-3 ®j¡x Bh¤m L¡−nj Hhw P.W-34 q¡¢gS¤l
lqj¡e q¡¢hh Hl p¡−rÉz fr¡¿¹−l hm¡ k¡u, P.W-3 −j¡x Bh¤m L¡−nj Hhw
132
P.W-34 q¡¢gS¤l lqj¡e q¡¢hh Hl fÐcš p¡r£−L pjbÑe L−l fÐcnÑe£-27
¢Q¢q²a j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤−hl
ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£l Ef−l¡š² hš²hÉz
P.W-4 −j¡x Bj¡e E¢Ÿe plL¡l, P.W-5 ®j¡x ®M¡l−nc Bmj, P.W-6
®j¡x BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j j¡p¤j, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc, P.W-20 BSja
Eõ¡q M¡e, P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm OVe¡l pju Bp¡j£ ®j¡q¡Çjc
Bm£−L OVe¡ÙÛ−m ¢fÙ¹m, ¢limh¡l ¢c−u …¢m Ll−a ®c−M j−jÑ ®k hš²hÉ
Bc¡m−a EfÙÛ¡fe L−l P.W-33 ac¿¹L¡l£ LjÑLaÑ¡ ®j¡x M¡−mL¥‹¡j¡−el p¡rÉ
fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 161 d¡l¡u Nªq£a Sh¡eh¾c£−a HC p¡r£NZ
®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£−L OVe¡ÙÛ−m ®c−M−R j−jÑ E−õM L−l¢ez
P.W-4 −j¡x Bj¡e E¢Ÿe plL¡l, P.W-5 ®j¡x ®M¡l−nc Bmj, P.W-6
®j¡x BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j j¡p¤j, P.W-7 S¡¢Ll ®q¡−pe, P.W-8 ®j¡x Bš²¡l
®q¡−pe, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc, P.W-20 BSja Eõ¡q M¡e, P.W-26
j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm Hhw P.W-28 S¡¢hc Bqp¡e ®p¡−qm Bc¡m−a H−p
a¡−cl p¡−rÉ E−õM L−l ®k, OVe¡l f§−hÑ, OVe¡l pju Hhw OVe¡l fl fl HC
Bp¡j£−L AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b AÙ»pq …¢m Ll−a ®c−M−R Hhw f¡¢m−u ®k−a
®c−M−R ¢L¿º ac¿¹L¡l£ LjÑLaÑ¡ P.W-33 ®j¡x M¡−mL¥‹¡j¡−el p¡rÉ
fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u, L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 161 d¡l¡u ac¿¹ LjÑLaÑ¡l L¡−R ®cu
Sh¡eh¾c£−a a¡l¡ HLb¡ h−m¢ez Efl¿º ac¿¹L¡l£ LjÑLaÑ¡ LaѪL c¡¢Mm£ Q¡SÑn£V
fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, ac¿¹L¡l£ LjÑLaÑ¡ p¤Øføi¡−h h−m−Re ®k, ®j¡q¡Çjc
Bm£ OVe¡ÙÛ−m H−p¢Rm a¡ ¢a¢e ac−¿¹ fСç qe¢ez
133
Ef−l¡š² B−m¡Qe¡l B−m¡−L p¤Øføi¡−h fÐa£uj¡e qu ®k, pwO¢Va OVe¡l
f§−hÑC ®k f¢lLÒfe¡ J Afl¡dj§mL osk¿» pi¡ q−u¢Rm ®pM¡−e c¢äa Bp¡j£
®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£l p¢œ²u AwnNËqZ ¢Rm, k¢cJ OVe¡ÙÛ−m HC Bp¡j£ Ef¢ÙÛa ¢Rm
e¡z e¢b fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, c¢äa Bp¡j£ ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£ OVe¡l fl fl
®NËga¡l qu Hhw Cw 16/04/2005 a¡¢l−M ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma LaѪL fÐcš
B−c−nl ¢ce ®b−L AcÉ¡h¢d AbÑ¡v p§c£OÑ 11 hR−ll EÜÑL¡m Ah¢d Le−Xj ®p−m
BhÜ B−Rz
Ef−l¡š² B−m¡Qe¡l B−m¡−L ®k−qa¥ HC c¢äa Bp¡j£l e¡j HS¡q¡−l ®eC,
ac¿¹ fТa−hc−e ac¿¹L¡l£ LjÑLaÑ¡ P.W-33 ®j¡x L¡jl¦‹¡j¡e a¡l fÐcš
A¢i−k¡Nf−œ Bp¡j£l Ef¢ÙÛ¢a OVe¡ÙÛ−m f¡e¢e, Bc¡m−a H−p ®k pLm p¡r£l¡
HC Bp¡j£ OVe¡ÙÛ−m Ef¢ÙÛa ¢Rm j−jÑ hš²hÉ ®l−M−R ac¿¹L¡l£ LjÑLaÑ¡ P.W-
33 ®j¡x L¡jl¦‹¡j¡−el L¡−R L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 161 d¡l¡u fÐcš Sh¡eh¾c£−a a¡l¡
Bp¡j£l Ef¢ÙÛ¢al Lb¡ E−õM L−l¢e, P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm LaѪL
fÐcš jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡u (k¡ flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h
Bc¡m−a Nªq£a q−u−R) HC Bp¡j£l e¡j ®eC, a−h HC Bp¡j£ osk¿»pi¡u
p¢œ²ui¡−h AwnNËqZ L−l−R j−jÑ pq Bp¡j£ j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h
i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h LaѪL fÐcš ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£−a p¤Øføi¡−h f¡Ju¡
k¡u Hhw P.W-3 ®j¡x Bh¤m L¡−nj, P.W-34 q¡¢gS¤l lqj¡e q¡¢hh Hl p¡rÉ
à¡l¡ HC hš²hÉ pj¢bÑa qu, ®p−qa¥ Ef−l¡š² p¡¢hÑL AhÙÛ¡ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ
Bc¡ma LaѪL −j¡qÇjc Bm£−L ®k jªa¥Écä¡−cn fÐc¡e Ll¡ q−u−R ®pC
134
jªa¥Écä¡−c−nl f¢lh−aÑ k¡h‹£he L¡l¡cä fÐc¡e Ll¡ pj£Q£e h−m Bjl¡ j−e
L¢lz
AaHh, cä¢h¢dl 302/120M/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥Écä fСç Bp¡j£ ®j¡q¡Çjc
Bm£−L jªa¥Éc−äl f¢lh−aÑ k¡h‹£he L¡l¡c−ä c¢äa Ll¡l ¢pÜ¡¿¹ quz
cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥ÉcäfСç Bp¡j£ B−e¡u¡l ®q¡−pe Be¤ pÇf−LÑ
B−m¡Qe¡ J ¢pÜ¡¿¹ x
HC Bp¡j£l ®Lhmj¡œ ®Xb ®lg¡−l¾p öe¡e£ quz
¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma HC Bp¡j£ B−e¡u¡l ®q¡−pe Be¤−L cä¢h¢dl
302/34 d¡l¡u ®c¡o£ p¡hÉÙ¹f§hÑL jªa¥Écä¡−cn fÐc¡e L−l−Rez e¢bÑ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u
−cM¡ k¡u ®k,
fÐbjax HC Bp¡j£l e¡j HS¡q¡−l E−õM B−R,
¢àa£uax j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h La«ÑL
fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£−a HC Bp¡j£ osk¿» pi¡u
Ef¢ÙÛa e¡ b¡L−mJ OVe¡l ¢ce ®j¡qÇjc Bm£l O−l HC Bp¡j£ Ef¢ÙÛa ¢Rm
Hhw HC Bp¡j£ mð¡ ¢hd¡u OVe¡ÙÛ−m ®p fcÑ¡l Efli¡N HLV¤ V¡e ¢c−u j¡qg¥S¤l
lqj¡e jq−ml AhÙÛ¡e mrÉ L−l Hhw HC Bp¡j£ j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm−L mrÉ
L−l …¢m L−l j−jÑ E−õM B−R,
a«a£uax P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm La«ÑL ®cu jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡u
(k¡ flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) HC
Bp¡j£l e¡j ®eC,
135
Qa¥bÑax P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e, P.W-2 ®j¡x lSh Bm£, P.W-
4 ®j¡x Bj¡e E¢Ÿe plL¡l, P.W-5 ®j¡x ®M¡l−nc Bmj, P.W-6 ®j¡x
BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j j¡p¤j, P.W-10 −j¡x n¢g Bq−jc, P.W-20 BSja Eõ¡q
M¡e, P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm a¡−cl p¡−rÉ E−õM L−l ®k, Bp¡j£
B−e¡u¡l ®q¡−pe Be¤pq AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£l¡ j−’l ¢fRe ¢cL ®b−L ¢fÙ¹m J
¢limh¡l ¢e−u ¢eqa Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f J −j¡x j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm−L
E−ŸnÉ L−l …¢m Ll−a b¡−Lz P.W-7 S¡¢Ll ®q¡−pe, P.W-8 ®j¡x Bš²¡l
®q¡−pe, P.W-9 à£−S¾cÐ plL¡l, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc a¡−cl p¡−rÉ
E−õM L−l ®k, HC Bp¡j£pq AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl AÙ» q¡−a ®lm œ²¢pw f¡l q−u
Bp¡j£ ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£l h¡¢sl ¢c−L Q−m ®k−a ®c−Mz f§−hÑC B−m¡Qe¡ Ll¡
q−u−R ®k, haÑj¡e OVe¡l p¡−b c¢äa Bp¡j£−cl pÇfªš²a¡l ¢hou¢V pÇf−LÑ
p¤Øfø Hhw p¤¢e¢cÑø ¢pÜ¡¿¹ NËq−Zl SeÉ 3 ¢V j§m Ù¹ñ (pillar) ¢h−hQe¡u ®eu¡
q−u−Rz a¾j−dÉ HS¡q¡l, j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g
j¡qh¤−hl ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£, P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jq−ml
jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡ (k¡ flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a
q−u−R)z
c¢äa Bp¡j£ B−e¡u¡l ®q¡−pe Be¤ pÇf−LÑ HS¡q¡−l AeÉ¡eÉ pLm
Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b a¡l e¡j E−õM B−R ®cM¡ k¡uz j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g
j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h La«ÑL ®cu fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL
Sh¡eh¾c£ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u −cM¡ k¡u ®k, HC Bp¡j£ j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm−L E−ŸnÉ
L−l …¢m L−l¢Rm, ®kC j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm OVe¡ÙÛ−m j¡l¡aÁL Bqa q−u HL¢V
136
jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡ (k¡ flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h
Bc¡m−a Nªq£a q−u−R) ¢c−u¢Rm Hhw flha£Ñ−a ¢a¢e ®hy−Q k¡ez HC jªa¥ÉL¡m£e
®O¡oZ¡u (k¡ flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R)
j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm p¤Øføi¡−h 6 S−el e¡j E−õM Ll−mJ HC Bp¡j£l e¡j
E−õM L−l¢ez P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e, P.W-2 ®j¡x lSh Bm£, P.W-4
®j¡x Bj¡e E¢Ÿe plL¡l, P.W-5 ®j¡x ®M¡l−nc Bmj, P.W-6 ®j¡x
BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j j¡p¤j, P.W-7 S¡¢Ll ®q¡−pe, P.W-8 ®j¡x Bš²¡l ®q¡−pe,
P.W-9 à£−S¾cÐ plL¡l, P.W-10 −j¡x n¢g Bq−jc, P.W-20 BSja Eõ¡q
M¡e, P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm OVe¡ÙÛ−m HC Bp¡j£l Ef¢Øq¢al ¢hou¢V
E−õM L−l−Rz
HM¡−e E−õMÉ ®k, HS¡q¡−l Bp¡j£ e§l¦m Cpm¡j c£f¤ J n¢qc¤m Cpm¡j
¢nf¤ HS¡q¡lL¡l£l hs i¡C Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f−L mrÉ L−l …¢m L−l
Hhw AeÉ¡eÉl¡J pi¡ÙÛ−m …¢m L−l j−jÑ E−õM B−Rz Afl¢c−L j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e
j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤−hl ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£−a f¡Ju¡
k¡u ®k, Bp¡j£ B−e¡u¡l ®q¡−pe Be¤ jqm−L E−ŸnÉ L−l …¢m L−l, k¢cJ jqm
¢eqa qu¢ez HR¡s¡J Ef−l E−õ¢Ma p¡r£−cl p¡rÉ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k,
Bp¡j£ B−e¡u¡l ®q¡−pe Be¤ OVe¡l pju OVe¡ÙÛ−m Ef¢ÙÛa −b−L …¢m L−l¢Rmz
HC AhÙÛ¡u Ef−l¡š² p¡rÉ fÐj¡Z¡¢c fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u Hhw h¢ZÑa OVe¡l p¡−b
Bp¡j£l pÇfªš²a¡l ¢hou¢V ¢h−hQe¡u H−e Bp¡j£ B−e¡u¡l ®q¡−pe Be¤−L ¢h‘
¢ejÀ Bc¡ma LaѪL ®cu jªa¥Écä¡−c−nl f¢lh−aÑ k¡h‹£he L¡l¡cä fÐc¡e pj£Q£e
h−m Bjl¡ j−e L¢lz
137
AaHh, cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥Écä fСç Bp¡j£ B−e¡u¡l ®q¡−pe
Be¤−L jªa¥Éc−äl f¢lh−aÑ k¡h‹£he L¡l¡c−ä c¢äa Ll¡l ¢pÜ¡¿¹ quz
cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥ÉcäfСç Bp¡j£ lae ¢ju¡ Jl−g hs ¢ju¡
Jl−g lae Jl−g hs lae pÇf−LÑ B−m¡Qe¡ J ¢pÜ¡¿¹ x
−Xb ®lg¡−l¾p Hl p¡−b HC Bp¡j£l c¡−ul Ll¡ 8330/2010 ew ®g±Sc¡l£
Bf£m¢V B−m¡Qe¡ Ll¡ q−m¡z
cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u ®c¡o£ p¡hÉÙ¹f§hÑL jªa¥Écä¡−cn fСç Bp¡j£ lae
¢ju¡ Jl−g hs ¢ju¡ Jl−g lae Jl−g hs la−el cä¡−cn fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡
k¡u ®k,
fÐbjax HC Bp¡j£l e¡j HS¡q¡−l B−R,
¢àa£uax j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h LaѪL
fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, osk¿»
pi¡u HC Bp¡j£l Ef¢ÙÛ¢al Lb¡ hm¡ e¡ q−mJ Afl Bp¡j£ ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£l
h¡pih−e OVe¡l ¢ce Ef¢ÙÛ¢al Lb¡ hm¡ B−R,
a«a£uax P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm La«ÑL fÐcš jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡u
(k¡ flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) HC
Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM B−R,
Qa¥bÑax P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e, P.W-2 ®j¡x lSh Bm£, P.W-4
®j¡x Bj¡e E¢Ÿe plL¡l, P.W-5 ®j¡x ®M¡l−nc Bmj, P.W-6 ®j¡x
BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j j¡p¤j, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc, P.W- 20 BSja Eõ¡q
M¡e, P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm OVe¡l ¢ce Hhw P.W-7 S¡¢Ll ®q¡−pe,
138
P.W-8, −j¡x Bš²¡l ®q¡−pe, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc OVe¡l flflC HC
Bp¡j£−L OVe¡ÙÛ−m AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b HC Bp¡j£−L H−m¡f¡b¡¢s …¢m
Ll−a Hhw Q−m ®k−a ®c−M−R j−jÑ E−õM L−l−Rz
f§−hÑC E−õM Ll¡ q−u−R ®k, Bp¡j£−cl ¢hl¦−Ü Be£a A¢i−k¡N fÐj¡−Zl j§m
¢i¢š ¢q−p−h 3¢V Ù¹ñ−L (pillar) ¢h−hQe¡u Be¡ q−u−Rz H AhÙÛ¡u HS¡q¡l
fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, HS¡q¡−l Bp¡j£l e¡j HS¡q¡lL¡l£ lae ¢ju¡, ¢fa¡-
A‘¡a, p¡w-®N¡f¡mf¤l ¢q−p−h ¢m¢fhÜ L−l−Rz Afl¢c−L j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h
Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h La«ÑL ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£−a hs lae,
p¡w-®N¡f¡mf¤l E−õM Ll¡ q−mJ Q¡SÑn£−V ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, Q¡SÑn£−V HC Bp¡j£l
e¡j hs lae Jl−g lae ¢ju¡, p¡w-p¢gf¤l ¢q−p−h E−õM Ll¡ q−u−Rz
HS¡q¡−l Afl jªa¥ÉcäfСç Bp¡j£ ®R¡V lae (®k haÑj¡−e jªa) Hl e¡j
E−õM e¡ b¡L−mJ P.W-1 HS¡q¡lL¡l£ ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e pq pLm p¡r£NZ
p¤¢e¢cÑøi¡−h E−õM L−l−R ®k, Bp¡j£ ®R¡V la−el q¡−a HL¢V L¡V¡ h¾c¤L ¢Rmz
Afl¢c−L AeÉ¡eÉ p¡r£l¡ c¢äa Bp¡j£ lae ¢ju¡ Jl−g hs lae pÇf−LÑ
AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b ¢fÙ¹m q¡−a ®c−M−R j−jÑ E−õM L−l−Rz H AhÙÛ¡u
P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm La«ÑL fÐcš jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡ (k¡ flha£Ñ−a
L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k,
®pM¡−e j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm a¡l Sh¡eh¾c£−a ®k 6 Se Bp¡j£l e¡j p¤Øfø J
p¤¢e¢cÑØVi¡−h E−õM L−l−R ®pM¡−e “lae” e¡j¢V E−õM B−Rz ®k−qa¥ Afl
Bp¡j£ ®R¡V lae−L HL¢V L¡V¡ h¾c¤L q¡−a OVe¡ÙÛ−m …¢m Ll−a −c−M−R j−jÑ
p¤Øfø J p¤¢e¢cÑøi¡−h pLm p¡r£ E−õM L−l−R ®p−qa¥ P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l
139
lqj¡e jqm La«ÑL jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡u (k¡ flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l
Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) E−õ¢Ma lae Afl Bp¡j£ “®R¡V lae” e¡ HC
c¢äa Bp¡j£ lae ¢ju¡ ®p pÇf−LÑ HL¢V p−¾c−ql AhL¡n B−Rz a−h HC
p−¾c−ql AhL¡n hÉ¢a−l−L HS¡q¡l, ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£ Hhw p¡r£−cl
hš²hÉ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u HLb¡ fÐj¡¢Za ®k OVe¡l ¢ce OVe¡ÙÛ−m c¢äa Bp¡j£ “lae
¢ju¡” Jl−g hs lae AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b OVe¡ÙÛ−m AÙ» pq Ef¢ÙÛa ¢Rmz
HS¡q¡−l E−õM B−R ®k, HS¡q¡lL¡l£ e§l¦m Cpm¡j ¢cf¤ J n¢qc¤m Cpm¡j
¢nf¤−L ¢eqa Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f−L mrÉ L−l …¢m Ll−a ®c−M−Rz
AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl …¢m−a pi¡ÙÛ−m ®j¡x j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqmpq AeÉ¡eÉl¡
Bqa qu (flha£Ñ−a Bqa Jjl g¡l¦L lae jªa¥ÉhlZ L−l)z p¡j¢NËL
fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm La«ÑL fÐcš
jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡u (k¢cJ flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h
Nªq£a q−u−R) E−õ¢Ma ‘lae’ HC c¢äa Bp¡j£ ‘lae’ ¢Le¡ ®p pÇf−LÑ HL¢V
p−¾cq l−u−R Hhw HS¡q¡−l E−õ¢Ma j−a P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e HC
Bp¡j£−L pl¡p¢l ¢eqa Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f ®L …¢m Ll−a ®c−M−Re
j−jÑ E−õM ®eC, a−h AeÉ¡eÉ Bqa−cl AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b …¢m Ll−a
®c−M−R Hhw p¡r£l¡ HC hš²hÉ−L pjbÑe L−l−Rz HC AhÙÛ¡u jªa¥ÉcäfСç Bp¡j£
lae ¢ju¡ Jl−g hs lae−L E−õ¢Ma AhÙÛ¡l ®fТr−a OVe¡l p¡−b pÇfªš²a¡l
¢hou¢V ¢h−hQe¡u H−e jªa¥Écä¡−c−nl f¢lh−aÑ k¡h‹£he L¡l¡cä fÐc¡e pj£Q£e
h−m Bjl¡ j−e L¢lz
140
AaHh, cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥Écä fСç Bp¡j£ lae ¢ju¡ Jl−g
hs ¢ju¡ Jl−g lae Jl−g hs lae−L jªa¥Éc−äl f¢lh−aÑ k¡h‹£he L¡l¡c−ä
c¢äa Ll¡l ¢pÜ¡¿¹ quz
cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥ÉcäfСç Bp¡j£ S¡q¡‰£l ¢fa¡-L¡−nj j¡chl
pÇf−LÑ B−m¡Qe¡ J ¢pÜ¡¿¹ x
HC Bp¡j£l ®Lhmj¡œ ®Xb ®lg¡−l¾p¢V öe¡e£l SeÉ ®eu¡ quz
cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u ®c¡o£ p¡hÉÙ¹f§hÑL jªa¥Écä¡−cn fСç Bp¡j£
S¡q¡‰£l ¢fa¡-L¡−nj j¡ahl Hl cä¡−cn fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k,
fÐbjax HC Bp¡j£l e¡j HS¡q¡−l B−R,
¢àa£uax j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h LaѪL
fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, osk¿»
pi¡u HC Bp¡j£l Ef¢ÙÛ¢al Lb¡ hm¡ e¡ q−mJ flha£Ñ−a OVe¡l ¢ce Afl
Bp¡j£ ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£l h¡¢s−a AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b HC Bp¡j£l Ef¢ÙÛ¢al
Lb¡ hm¡ B−R,
a«a£uax P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm La«ÑL fÐcš jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡u
(k¡ flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) 6 Se
Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM b¡L−mJ HC Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM ®eC,
P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e, P.W-4 ®j¡x Bj¡e E¢Ÿe plL¡l, P.W-5
®j¡x ®M¡l−nc Bmj, P.W-6 ®j¡x BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j j¡p¤j, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g
Bq−jc, P.W- 20 BSja Eõ¡q M¡e OVe¡l ¢ce HC Bp¡j£−L OVe¡ÙÛ−m
AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b H−m¡f¡b¡¢s …¢m Ll−a ®c−M−R Hhw P.W-9 à£−S¾cÐ
141
plL¡l, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc OVe¡l flfl HC Bp¡j£−L ¢fÙ¹m q¡−a
AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b Q−m ®k−a ®c−M−Rz
¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma HC Bp¡j£−L jªa¥Écä fÐc¡e L−lez ¢L¿º fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡
k¡u ®k, P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e HS¡q¡−l p¤Øføi¡−h E−õM L−l−R ®k,
Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j ¢cf¤ J n¢qc¤m Cpm¡j ¢nf¤−L ¢a¢e ¢eqa Bqp¡e Eõ¡q
j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f−L …¢m Ll−a ®c−M−Rez Afl¢c−L P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e
jqm LaѪL fÐcš jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡u (k¡ flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l
Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) 6 Se Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM Ll−mJ HC Bp¡j£l
e¡j E−õM L−l¢ez a−h HS¡q¡−l AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b HC Bp¡j£l e¡j
OVe¡ÙÛ−m OVe¡l pju H−m¡f¡b¡¢s …¢m Ll−a ®c−M−R j−jÑ HS¡q¡lL¡l£ E−õM
L−l−R Hhw HS¡q¡l h¢ZÑa HC OVe¡¢V OVe¡ÙÛ−m Ef¢ÙÛa p¡r£ P.W-1
HS¡q¡lL¡l£ −j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e, P.W-4 −j¡x Bj¡e E¢Ÿe plL¡l, P.W-5
®j¡x ®M¡l−nc Bmj, P.W-6 ®j¡x BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j j¡p¤j, P.W-9 à£−S¾cÐ
plL¡l, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc, P.W- 20 BSja Eõ¡q M¡e a¡−cl
p¡−rÉ E−õM L−l−Rz
H AhÙÛ¡u Bp¡j£ OVe¡ÙÛ−m OVe¡l ¢ce HS¡q¡l h¢ZÑa j−a AeÉ¡eÉ pLm
Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b H−m¡f¡b¡¢s …¢m−a AwnNËqZ L−l¢Rm Hhw ®p¢ce OVe¡ÙÛ−m
Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f J Jjl g¡l¦L lae ¢eqa qu a−h HS¡q¡−l
p¤Øføi¡−h e¤l¦m Cpm¡j ¢cf¤ J n¢qc¤m Cpm¡j ¢nf¤−L P.W-1 HS¡q¡L¡l£ ®j¡x
j¢aEl lqj¡e Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ØV¡l Hj,¢f ®L …¢m Ll−a ®c−M−R j−jÑ E−õM
Ll¡u Hhw P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm a¡l jªa¤ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡u (k¡
142
flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) 6 Se Bp¡j£l
e¡j E−õM Ll−mJ HC Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM e¡ Ll¡u, fr¡¿¹−l Ef−l E−õ¢Ma
p¡r£−cl hš²hÉ, HS¡q¡l h¢ZÑa OVe¡l ¢hhlZ J j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g
j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h LaѪL ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡
k¡u ®k, Bp¡j£ S¡q¡‰£l, ¢fa¡- L¡−nj j¡chl OVe¡l pju OVe¡ÙÛ−m Ef¢ÙÛa
®b−L H−m¡f¡b¡¢s …¢m−a p¢œ²u AwnNËqZ L−l¢Rm k¡l gmnЦ¢a−a Bqp¡e Eõ¡q
j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f Hhw Jjl g¡l¦L lae ¢eqa qu Hhw j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqmpq
A−e−L Bqa quz HC AhÙÛ¡u Ef−l¡š² p¡rÉ fÐj¡Z¡¢c fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u Hhw h¢ZÑa
OVe¡l p¡−b HC Bp¡j£l pÇfªš²a¡l ¢hou¢V ¢h−hQe¡u H−e jªa¥Écä¡−c−nl
f¢lh−aÑ k¡h‹£he L¡l¡cä fÐc¡e pj£Q£e h−m Bjl¡ j−e L¢lz
AaHh, cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥Écä¡−cn fСç Bp¡j£ S¡q¡‰£l
¢fa¡- L¡−nj j¡chl−L jªa¥Éc−äl f¢lh−aÑ k¡h‹£he L¡l¡c−ä c¢äa Ll¡l
¢pÜ¡¿¹ quz
cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥ÉcäfСç Bp¡j£ Bh¤ p¡m¡j Jl−g p¡m¡j
pÇf−LÑ B−m¡Qe¡ J ¢pÜ¡¿¹ x
−Xb ®lg¡−l−¾pl p¡−b H Bp¡j£l c¡−ul Ll¡ ®g±Sc¡l£ ¢h¢hd ew
14222/2005 J ®Sm Bf£m ew 1322/2005 öe¡e£l SeÉ ®eu¡ quz
cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u ®c¡o£ p¡hÉÙ¹f§hÑL jªa¥Écä¡−cn fСç Bp¡j£
Bh¤ p¡m¡j Jl−g p¡m¡j Hl cä¡−cn fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k,
fÐbjax HS¡q¡−l HC Bp¡j£l e¡j −eC,
143
¢àa£uax j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h LaѪL
fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, osk¿»
pi¡u HC Bp¡j£l Ef¢ÙÛ¢al Lb¡ hm¡ e¡ q−mJ flha£Ñ−a OVe¡l ¢ce Bp¡j£
®j¡qÇjc Bm£l h¡¢s−a AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£pq HC Bp¡j£ Ef¢ÙÛa ¢Rm,
a«a£uax P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm La«ÑL fÐcš jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡u
(k¡ flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) 6 Se
Bp¡j£l e¡j p¤Øføi¡−h E−õM Ll¡ q−mJ HC Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM ®eC,
Qa¥bÑax P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e, P.W-2 ®j¡x lSh Bm£, P.W-4
®j¡x Bj¡e E¢Ÿe plL¡l, P.W-6 ®j¡x BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j j¡p¤j, P.W-10 ®j¡x
n¢g Bq−jc, P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm OVe¡ÙÛ−m HC Bp¡j£−L
H−m¡f¡b¡¢s …¢m Ll−a ®c−M−R j−jÑ E−õM L−l−R k¢cJ P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl
lqj¡e HS¡q¡−l HC Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM L−l¢e Hhw P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e
jqm a¡l fÐcš jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡u (k¡ flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l
Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) HC Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM L−l¢ez P.W-7 S¡¢Ll
®q¡−pe, P.W-8 ®j¡x Bš²¡l ®q¡−pe OVe¡l f§hha£Ñ pj−u HC Bp¡j£−L AÙ»
q¡−a AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b ®k−a ®c−M−R Hhw P.W-9 à£−S¾cÐ plL¡l,
P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc HC Bp¡j£−L AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b AÙ» q¡−a
Q−m ®k−a ®c−M−R j−jÑ E−õM B−Rz
f§−hÑC E−õM Ll¡ q−u−R ®k, Bp¡j£−cl ¢hl¦−Ü Be£a A¢i−k¡N fÐj¡−Zl j§m
¢i¢š ¢q®p−h 3¢V Ù¹ñ−L (pillar) ¢h−hQe¡u Be¡ q−u−Rz H AhÙÛ¡u HS¡q¡l
fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, HS¡q¡−l Bp¡j£l e¡j e¡ b¡L−mJ P.W-2 ®j¡x lSh
144
Bm£, P.W- 4 ®j¡x Bj¡e E¢Ÿe plL¡l, P.W-6 ®j¡x BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j
j¡p¤j, P.W-7 S¡¢Ll ®q¡−pe, P.W-8 ®j¡x Bš²¡l ®q¡−pe, P.W-9 à£−S¾cÐ
plL¡l, P.W- 10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc OVe¡ÙÛ−m Bp¡l f§−hÑC, OVe¡l pju,
OVe¡l flflC HC Bp¡j£−L AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b AÙ»pq Bp−a ®c−M−R,
AÙ»pq H−m¡f¡b¡¢s …¢m Ll−a Hhw AÙ»pq Q−m ®k−a ®c−M−Rz HC p¡r£−cl
hš²hÉ−L pjbÑe L−l j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h
LaѪL fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£, ®kM¡−e ®cM¡ k¡u HC
Bp¡j£ Afl Bp¡j£ ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£l h¡¢s−a OVe¡l ¢ce AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl
p¡−b S−s¡ qu J AÙ»q¡−a HLp¡−b OVe¡ÙÛ−m lJu¡e¡ quz
p¡¢hÑL ¢h−hQe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, HS¡q¡−l Hhw P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e
jqm LaѪL fÐcš jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡u (k¡ flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l
Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) HC Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM e¡ b¡L−mJ Ef−l¡š²
p¡r£−cl hš²hÉ Hhw j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h
LaѪL fÐcš fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a ®c¡o ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£l hš²hÉ
fk¡Ñ−m¡Qe¡u p¤Øføi¡−h fÐa£uj¡e qu ®k, HC Bp¡j£ OVe¡l ¢ce OVe¡ÙÛ−m
Ef¢ÙÛa ®b−L EfkѤf¢l H−m¡f¡b¡¢s N¤¢m−a AwnNËqZ L−l¢Rm k¡l ®fТr−a
flha£Ñ−a Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f J Jjl g¡l¦L lae ¢eqa qu Hhw
j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqmpq A−e−L Bqa quz HC AhÙÛ¡u jªa¥Écä¡−cn fСç Bp¡j£
Bh¤ p¡m¡j Jl−g p¡m¡j−L E−õ¢Ma AhÙÛ¡l ®fТr−a OVe¡l p¡−b pÇfªš²a¡l
¢hou¢V ¢h−hQe¡u H−e jªa¥Écä¡−c−nl f¢lh−aÑ k¡h‹£he L¡l¡cä fÐc¡e pj£Q£e
h−m Bjl¡ j−e L¢lz
145
AaHh, cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥Écä fСç Bp¡j£ Bh¤ p¡m¡j Jl−g
p¡m¡j®L jªa¥Éc−äl f¢lh−aÑ k¡h‹£he L¡l¡c−ä c¢äa Ll¡l ¢pÜ¡¿¹ quz
cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥ÉcäfСç Bp¡j£ j¢nEl lqj¡e jö pÇf−LÑ
B−m¡Qe¡ J ¢pÜ¡¿¹ x
HC Bp¡j£l ®Lhmj¡œ ®Xb ®lg¡−l¾p öe¡e£l SeÉ ®eu¡ quz
cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u ®c¡o£ p¡hÉÙ¹f§hÑL jªa¥Écä¡−cn fСç Bp¡j£
j¢nEl lqj¡e jö Hl cä¡−cn fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k,
fÐbjax HS¡q¡−l HC Bp¡j£l e¡j −eC,
¢àa£uax j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h LaѪL
fÐcnÑe£- 27 ¢Q¢q²a ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, osk¿»
pi¡u HC Bp¡j£ Ef¢ÙÛa ¢Rm e¡z a−h, OVe¡l ¢ce OVe¡ÙÛ−m k¡h¡l f§−hÑ Afl
Bp¡j£ ®j¡qÇjc Bm£l h¡pih−e AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b HC Bp¡j£−L ®cM¡
k¡u Hhw ü£L¡−l¡¢š² fÐc¡eL¡l£ Bp¡j£ j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h a¡l
ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£−a h−m ®k, Lb¡h¡aÑ¡l j¡dÉ−j S¡e¡ k¡u Be¤l hå¥
j¢nEl lqj¡e jö HLSe ®fn¡c¡l M¤e£,
a«a£uax P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm La«ÑL fÐcš jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡u
(k¡ flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) HC
Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM ®eC,
Qa¥bÑa x P.W-1 HS¡q¡lL¡l£ ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e HC Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM
e¡ Ll−mJ Bc¡m−a cy¡¢s−u HC Bp¡j£l ¢hl¦−Ü p¡rÉ fÐc¡e L−lz P.W-2
®j¡x lSh Bm£, P.W-4 ®j¡x Bj¡e E¢Ÿe plL¡l, P.W-6 ®j¡x BSq¡l¦m
146
Cpm¡j j¡p¤j, P.W-8 ®j¡x Bš²¡l ®q¡−pe, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc,
P.W- 17 ®j¡x Bh¤ p¡Dc, P.W- 26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm, P.W-28 S¡¢hc
Bqp¡e ®p¡−qm a¡−cl p¡−rÉ E−õM L−le ®k, j¢nEl lqj¡e jöpq AeÉ¡eÉ
Bp¡j£−cl OVe¡ÙÛ−m OVe¡l ¢ce a¡l¡ H−m¡f¡b¡¢s …¢m Ll−a Ll−a Hhw OVe¡l
flfl AÙ» q¡−a Q−m ®k−a ®c−M−R k¡l gmnЦ¢a−a Bqa Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l
Hj,¢f J Jjl g¡l¦L lae ¢eqa q−u−R Hhw j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqmpq ®hn ¢LR¤
hÉ¢š² Bqa q−u−Rz
f§−hÑ E−õ¢Ma j−a, Bp¡j£−cl ¢hl¦−Ü Be£a A¢i−k¡N fÐj¡−Zl j§m ¢i¢š
¢q®p−h 3¢V Ù¹ñ−L (pillar) ¢h−hQe¡u Be¡ q−u−Rz a¾j−dÉ HS¡q¡l fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u
®cM¡ k¡u ®k, HS¡q¡−l p¤Øføi¡−h 17 Se Bp¡j£l e¡j b¡L−mJ HC Bp¡j£l
e¡j ®eC, P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm LaѪL fÐcš jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡u (k¡
flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) HC Bp¡j£l
e¡j E−õM −eC a−h fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h
i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤−hl ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£−a ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, HC Bp¡j£
OVe¡l f§−hÑ AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b Afl Bp¡j£ ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£l h¡phih−e
¢j¢ma qu Hhw P.W-2 ®j¡x lSh Bm£, P.W-4 ®j¡x Bj¡e E¢Ÿe plL¡l,
P.W-5 ®j¡x ®M¡l−nc Bmj, P.W-6 ®j¡x BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j j¡p¤j, P.W-8
®j¡x Bš²¡l ®q¡−pe, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc P.W-17 ®j¡x Bh¤ p¡Dc Hhw
P.W-28 S¡¢hc Bqp¡e l¡−p−ml p¡−rÉ f¡Ju¡ k¡u ®k, HC Bp¡j£ AeÉ¡eÉ
Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b OVe¡ÙÛ−m Ef¢ÙÛa ®b−L H−m¡f¡b¡¢s …¢m L−l−Rz
147
p¡¢hÑL ¢h−hQe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, HS¡q¡l Hhw jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡u HC Bp¡j£l
e¡j e¡ b¡L−mJ Ef−l¡š² p¡r£N−Zl hš²hÉ Hhw j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g
j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h LaѪL fÐcš fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a ®c¡o ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL
Sh¡eh¾c£l hš²hÉ fk¡Ñ−m¡Qe¡u p¤Øføi¡−h fÐa£uj¡e qu ®k, HC Bp¡j£ OVe¡l
¢ce OVe¡ÙÛ−m Ef¢ÙÛa ®b−L EfkѤf¢l H−m¡f¡b¡¢s N¤¢m−a AwnNËqZ L−l¢Rm k¡l
gmnЦ¢a−a flha£Ñ−a Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f J Jjl g¡l¦L lae ¢eqa qu
Hhw ®j¡x j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqmpq A−e−L Bqa quz HC AhÙÛ¡u jªa¥Écä¡−cn
fСç Bp¡j£ j¢nEl lqj¡e jö−L E−õ¢Ma AhÙÛ¡l ®fТr−a OVe¡l p¡−b
pÇfªš²a¡l ¢hou¢V ¢h−hQe¡u H−e jªa¥Écä¡−c−nl f¢lh−aÑ k¡h‹£he L¡l¡cä
fÐc¡e pj£Q£e h−m Bjl¡ j−e L¢lz
AaHh, cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥Écä fСç Bp¡j£ j¢nEl lqj¡e
jö®L jªa¥Éc−äl f¢lh−aÑ k¡h‹£he L¡l¡c−ä c¢äa Ll¡l ¢pÜ¡¿¹ quz
cä¢h¢dl 302/120M/34 d¡l¡u k¡h‹£he L¡l¡cä fСç Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m B¢je
Jl−g B¢je pÇf−LÑ B−m¡Qe¡ J ¢pÜ¡¿¹ x
HC Bp¡j£l c¡−ul Ll¡ 1515/2005 ew ®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m¢V öe¡e£l SeÉ
®eu¡ quz
¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma HC Bp¡j£−L cä¢h¢dl 302/120M/34 d¡l¡u k¡h‹£he
L¡l¡cä¡−cn fÐc¡e L−l−Rez e¢b fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k,
fÐbjax HC Bp¡j£l e¡j HS¡q¡−l ®eC,
148
¢àa£uax j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h LaѪL ®cu
ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£ fÐcnÑe£-27 fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, osk¿» pi¡¢V
HC Bp¡j£ e§l¦m B¢j−el h¡¢s−a h−p q−u−R,
a«a£uax OVe¡ÙÛ−m OVe¡l pju HC Bp¡j£l ®L¡e AwnNËqZ ¢Rm e¡,
Qa¥bÑax P.W-3 −j¡x Bh¤m L¡−nj a¡l p¡−rÉ E−õM L−l−R ®k, OVe¡l
10/12 ¢ce f§−hÑ A¡e¤j¡¢eL l¡a 10.00 V¡l ¢c−L ®p Hhw a¡l c¤Se hå¤ ®qm¡m
L¢jne¡−ll h¡¢s−a k¡u, ®pM¡e ®b−L ¢g−l Bp¡l f−b l¡a 11.00 V¡l ¢c−L
Bp¡j£ B¢j−el h¡¢sl f§hÑ ¢c−L HL¢V p¡c¡ lw−ul jVl p¡C−Lm J HL¢V p¡c¡
lw−ul fСC−iV N¡s£ ®cM−a f¡uz H pju p¡r£ ®cM−a f¡u e¤l¦m Cpm¡j c£f¤,
BCu¤h Hhw Bp¡j£ e§l¦m B¢je N¡s£l clS¡ M¤−m Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j
plL¡−ll p¡−b Lb¡ hm−Rz H fÐp−‰ P.W-34 q¡¢gS¤l lqj¡e q¡¢hh a¡l p¡−rÉ
E−õM L−l ®k, OVe¡l 10/12 ¢ce f§−hÑ ®p L¡jl¦m q¡p¡e−L p¡−b ¢e−u jlL¥−el
B¢j−el h¡¢s−a k¡uz Bp¡j£ B¢je ®hl q−u H−p h−m, HMe ®jqj¡e l−u−R,
f−l ®V¢m−g¡e L−l Bp−az H pju p¡r£ Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l, e¤l¦m
Cpm¡j ¢cf¤pq ®hn L−uLSe Bp¡j£−L B¢j−el h¡¢sl ¢ia−l l¦−j h−p b¡L−a
®c−Mz Bp¡j£f−rl ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ h−me ®k, HC Bp¡j£l e¡j HS¡q¡−l ®eC,
j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h LaѪL ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL
Sh¡eh¾c£−a HC Bp¡j£l p¢œ²u AwnNËqZ ®eC Hhw ü£L«aj−a, HC Bp¡j£
OVe¡ÙÛ−m Ef¢ÙÛa ¢Rm e¡z ®Lhmj¡œ P.W- 3 ®j¡x Bh¤m L¡−nj, P.W-34
q¡¢gS¤l lqj¡e q¡¢hh OVe¡l 10/12 ¢ce B−N HC Bp¡j£l h¡¢s−a ®hn ¢LR¤
Bp¡j£−L ®cM−a f¡uz ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ B−l¡ h−me ®k, P.W-34 q¡¢gS¤l
149
lqj¡e q¡¢hh Q¡SÑn£V i¥š² p¡r£ ¢Rm e¡ flha£Ñ−a a¡−L p¡rÉ j¡eÉ Ll¡ quz e¢b
fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u f¡Ju¡ k¡u P.W-34 q¡¢gS¤l lqj¡e q¡¢hh Q¡SÑn£Vi¥š² p¡r£ e¡
b¡L−mJ ac¿¹L¡l£ LjÑLaÑ¡ a¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 161 d¡l¡u ¢m¢fhÜ
L−l¢R−mez ®p−r−œ ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma l¡øÌ f−rl fСbÑe¡u HC p¡r£−L p¡r£
¢q−p−h Bc¡m−a p¡rÉ fÐc¡−el SeÉ ®k B−cn ¢c−u−Re a¡ p¢WL ¢Rmz Efl¿º
eb£ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u f¡Ju¡ k¡u, Bp¡j£fr ®b−LJ Hl ¢h−l¡¢da¡ Ll¡ qu¢ez
Bp¡j£f−rl ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ B−l¡ h−me ®k, P.W-3 ®j¡x Bh¤m L¡−nj,
P.W-34 q¡¢hh¤l lqj¡e q¡¢h−hl p¡rÉ fÐb−j ¢hnÄ¡p Ll−a q−h Hhw flha£Ñ−a
HC p¡−rÉl Efl ¢i¢š L−l j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g
j¡qh¤−hl exculpatory confession ®L ¢h−hQe¡u Be−a q−hz
l¡øÌf−r ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ h−me ®k, Afl¡d j§mL osk−¿»l (criminal
conspiracy) ®L¡e fÐaÉr p¡rÉ fÐj¡Z f¡Ju¡ L¢Wez AhÙÛ¡Na fÐj¡Z¡¢c Hhw
HC fÐj¡Z¡¢cl d¡l¡h¡¢qLa¡u pwO¢Va OVe¡ Afl¡dj§mL osk¿» fÐj¡−Zl HLj¡œ
fbz ¢a¢e B−l¡ h−me ®k, P.W-3 ®j¡x Bh¤m L¡−nj OVe¡l 10/12 ¢ce f§−hÑ
c¢äa Bm-B¢je Hl p¡j−e AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b HC Bp¡j£−L Lb¡ hm−a
®c−M−R Hhw P.W-34 q¡¢gS¤l lqj¡e q¡¢hh HC Bp¡j£−L OVe¡l 10/12 ¢ce
f§−hÑ P.W-3 E−õ¢Ma pj−u AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b HC Bp¡j£l h¡¢s−a
°hWLla AhÙÛ¡u ®c−M−Rz
f§−hÑC B−m¡Qe¡l j¡dÉ−j ¢pÜ¡¿¹ NËqZ Ll¡ q−u−R ®k, Bp¡j£ j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e
j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h LaѪL fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a Sh¡eh¾c£¢V
üaxfÐ−Z¡¢ca J p¢WL (valuntary and true) ¢Rmz H AhÙÛ¡u P.W-3 ®j¡x
150
Bh¤m L¡−nj J P.W-34 q¡¢gS¤l lqj¡e q¡¢h−hl p¡rÉ A¢hnÄ¡p Ll¡l j−a¡
®L¡e NËqZ−k¡NÉ L¡lZ Bc¡m−al p¡j−e EfÙÛ¡¢fa qu¢ez HC p¡r£NZ L¡kÑ¢h¢dl
161 d¡l¡u ac¿¹L¡l£ LjÑLaÑ¡l L¡−R ®ki¡−h p¡rÉ fÐc¡e L−l−R ¢WL −pi¡−h
Bc¡m−a cy¡¢s−u HLC hš²hÉ ®l−M−Rz HC p¡r£−cl hš²hÉ à¡l¡ HLb¡¢V
p¤Øføi¡−h J p¤¢e¢cÑøi¡−h fÐj¡¢Za qu ®k, OVe¡l 10/12 ¢ce f§−hÑ ®k
osk¿»j§mL °hWL¢V q−u¢Rm a¡ HC Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m B¢j−el h¡¢s−a q−u¢Rmz
p−hÑ¡f¢l, fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡uJ ®cM¡ k¡u
®k, ü£L¡−l¡¢š²L¡l£ j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h
h−m−R ®k, osk¿»j§mL pi¡¢V HC Bp¡j£ B¢j®el h¡¢s−a q−u¢Rmz AaHh,
®cM¡ k¡u ®k, osk¿»j§mL °hWL¢V HC Bp¡j£l h¡¢s−a pwO¢Va qJu¡u Hhw a¡l
d¡l¡h¡¢qLa¡u OVe¡ÙÛ−m pq-Bp¡j£−cl H−m¡f¡b¡¢s …¢mhoÑ−Z Bqp¡e Eõ¡q
j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f J Jjl g¡l¦L lae Hl ¢eqa qJu¡ J jqmpq AeÉ¡eÉ−cl Bqa
qh¡l c¡u ®b−L H Bp¡j£ AhÉ¡q¢a ®f−a f¡−le¡z
Ef−l¡š² B−m¡Qe¡l B−m¡−L ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma c¢äa Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m B¢je
Jl−g B¢je−L ®k k¡h‹£he L¡l¡c®äl B−cn fÐc¡e L−l−Re a¡ p¢WLi¡−hC
fÐc¡e L−l−Re j−jÑ ¢pÜ¡−¿¹ B¢pz
AaHh, cä¢h¢dl 302/120M/34 d¡l¡u k¡h‹£he cäfСç Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m
B¢je Jl−g B¢j−el k¡h‹£he cä¡−cn¢V hq¡m b¡−L j−jÑ ¢pÜ¡¿¹ quz
151
cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥ÉcäfСç Bp¡j£ n¢qc¤m Cpm¡j ¢nf¤
pÇf−LÑ B−m¡Qe¡ J ¢pÜ¡¿¹ x
HC Bp¡j£l ®Lhmj¡œ ®Xb ®lg¡−l¾p¢V öe¡e£ qu z
¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma HC Bp¡j£−L cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u −c¡o£ p¡hÉÙ¹f§hÑL
jªa¥Écä¡−cn fÐc¡e L−l−Rez e¢b fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k,
fÐbjax HC Bp¡j£l e¡j HS¡q¡−l E−õM B−Rz fÐcnÑe£-1 ¢Q¢q²a HS¡q¡l
fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, HS¡q¡lL¡l£ P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e a¡l
HS¡q¡−l E−õM L−l−R ®k, e¤l¦m Cpm¡j ¢cf¤ J n¢qc¤m Cpm¡j ¢nf¤ a¡l hs i¡C
Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f−L mrÉ L−l Efk¤Ñf¢l N¤¢m L−l,
¢àa£uax P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jq−ml jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡u (k¡
flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) −k 6 Se
Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM L−l−R a¾j−dÉ HC n¢qc¤m Cpm¡j ¢nf¤l e¡j E−õM B−R,
a«a£uax P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e, P.W-2 −j¡x lSh Bm£, P.W-4
®j¡x Bj¡e E¢Ÿe plL¡l, P.W-5 ®j¡x ®M¡l−nc Bmj, P.W-6 ®j¡x
BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j j¡p¤j, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc, P.W-11 ®j¡x S¡j¡m,
P.W-18 −j¡x Bqp¡e Eõ¡q, P.W-20 BSja Eõ¡q M¡e, P.W-26
j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm fÐ−aÉ−Ll p¡rÉ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u f¡Ju¡ k¡u ®k, HC Bp¡j£
OVe¡l pju OVe¡ÙÛ−m Ef¢ÙÛa ®b−L Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f Hhw j¡qg¥S¤l
lqj¡e jqm−L qaÉ¡ Ll¡l E−Ÿ−nÉ j−’l p¡j−el ¢cL ®b−L AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£pq
…¢m L−lz P.W-11 ®j¡x S¡j¡m, P.W-12 ®j¡x g¢lc E¢Ÿe P.W-15
152
p¤−L¡jm −che¡b OVe¡l flfl HC Bp¡j£−L AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£pq ¢fÙ¹m J
¢limh¡l pq Q−m ®k−a ®c−Mz
l¡øÌf−r −ØVV ¢X−g¾p ¢e−u¡¢Sa ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ Se¡h H. Hj. ®j¡x
B¢SS¤m qL E−õM L−le ®k, ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma HC Bp¡j£−L p¢WLi¡−h
jªa¥Écä fÐc¡e L−le ¢ez
f§−hÑC B−m¡Qe¡ Ll¡ q−u−R ®k, Bp¡j£−cl ¢hl¦−Ü Be£a A¢i−k¡N fÐj¡−Zl
SeÉ j§m ¢i¢š ¢q−p−h 3¢V Ù¹ñ−L (pillar) ¢h−hQe¡u Be¡ q−u−Rz HM¡−e fÐbj
Ù¹ñ ‘HS¡q¡−l’ phÑ−j¡V 17 Se Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM b¡L−mJ HC Bp¡j£l
¢hl¦−Ü p¤Øfø J p¤¢e¢cÑøi¡−h A¢i−k¡N Be¡ q−u−R ®k, Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j ¢cf¤
J n¢qc¤m Cpm¡j ¢nf¤ HS¡q¡L¡l£l i¡C Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f−L Efk¤Ñf¢l
…¢m L−l Hhw …¢m¢hÜ q−u HS¡q¡lL¡l£l i¡C j¡¢V−a m¤¢V−u f−sz Bjl¡
®cM−a f¡C ®k,flha£Ñ−a Bqa Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f q¡pf¡a¡−m jªa¥ÉhlZ
L−lez HC OVe¡l AeÉaj ü¡r£ OVe¡ÙÛ−m Bqa P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm
jªa¥Épj Bqa AhÙÛ¡u ¢h‘ jÉ¡¢S−ØVÊ−Vl p¡j−e HL¢V Sh¡eh¾c£ fÐc¡e L−l−R k¡
fÐcnÑe£-23 ¢qp¡−h ¢Q¢q²a q−u−Rz ¢h‘ jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌV HC Sh¡eh¾c£¢V jªa¥ÉL¡m£e
−O¡oZ¡ ¢q−p−h ®lLXÑ Ll−mJ flha£Ñ−a P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm p¤ÙÛ q−u
EW¡u ü¡i¡¢hL i¡−hC HC jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡¢V L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£
¢q−p−h ¢h−h¢Qa q−u−Rz
fr¡¿¹−l P.W-30 ¢h‘ jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌV n¢gL B−e¡u¡l Hl p¡rÉ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u
fÐcnÑe£-23 ¢Q¢q²a h¢ZÑa Sh¡eh¾c£¢V fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u HC Sh¡eh¾c£¢V A¢hnÄ¡p Ll¡l
153
−L¡e L¡lZ h¡ AhÙÛ¡ Bc¡m−al p¡j−e EfÙÛ¡¢fa qu¢e ®cM¡ k¡uz f§−hÑC ¢pÜ¡¿¹
q−u−R ®k, fÐcnÑe£-23 ¢Q¢q²a Sh¡eh¾c£¢V ¢hnÄ¡p−k¡NÉz
p‰a L¡l−ZC ¢pÜ¡−¿¹ B¢p ®k, HS¡q¡−l ®k−qa¤ p¤Øfø J p¤¢e¢cÑøi¡−h E−õM
B−R ®k, HC Bp¡j£ OVe¡ÙÛ−m Afl Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j ¢cf¤pq Bqp¡e Eõ¡q
j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f−L …¢m L−l−R, ¢a¢e j¡¢V−a m¤¢V−u f−s−Re Hhw flha£Ñ−a ¢a¢e
jªa¥ÉhlZ L−l−Re, p−hÑ¡¢fl HC ¢hou¢V P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm a¡l
jªa¥Épj Bqa AhÙÛ¡u ¢h‘ jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌ−Vl p¡j−e HC Bp¡j£l e¡j h−m ®N−R Hhw
P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e, P.W-2 ®j¡x lSh Bm£, P.W-4 ®j¡x Bj¡e
E¢Ÿe plL¡l, P.W-5 ®j¡x ®M¡l−nc Bmj, P.W-6 ®j¡x BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j
j¡p¤j, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc, P.W-11 ®j¡x S¡j¡m, P.W-18 ®j¡x
Bqp¡e Eõ¡q, P.W-20 BSja Eõ¡q M¡e, P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm
pL−m HLh¡−LÉ E−õM L−l−R ®k, HC Bp¡j£ OVe¡ÙÛ−m pl¡p¢l …¢m L−l−R
Hhw P.W-9 à£−S¾cÐ plL¡l, P.W-11 ®j¡x S¡j¡m, P.W-12 ®j¡x g¢lc
E¢Ÿe, P.W-15 p¤−L¡jm ®che¡b h−m−R ®k, a¡l¡ HC Bp¡j£−L AeÉ¡eÉ
Bp¡j£pq ¢fÙ¹m J ¢limh¡lpq f¡¢m−u ®k−a ®c−M−R ®p−qa¥, ¢pÜ¡−¿¹ B¢p ®k,
¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma p¢WLi¡−hC HC Bp¡j£−L VwN£l A¢hpwh¡¢ca ®ea¡ Bqp¡e
Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f Hhw qai¡NÉ Jjl g¡l¦L lae−L qaÉ¡l SeÉ jªa¥Écä fÐc¡e
L−l−Re Hhw HC jªa¥Écä¡−cn hq¡m−k¡NÉz
AaHh, cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥ÉcäfСç Bp¡j£ n¢qc¤m Cpm¡j
¢nf¤l jªa¥Écä¡−cn¢V hq¡m b¡−L j−jÑ ¢pÜ¡¿¹ quz
154
cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥ÉcäfСç Bp¡j£ q¡¢gS Jl−g L¡e¡ q¡¢gS
pÇf−LÑ B−m¡Qe¡ J ¢pÜ¡¿¹ x
−Xb ®lg¡−l¾p Hl p¡−b HC Bp¡j£l c¡−ul Ll¡ 295/2007 ew ®Sm
Bf£m HLp¡−b ¢h−hQe¡l SeÉ ®eu¡ q−m¡z
¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma HC Bp¡j£−L cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u −c¡o£ p¡hÉÙ¹f§hÑL
jªa¥Écä¡−cn fÐc¡e L−l−Rez e¢b fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k,
fÐbjax HC Bp¡j£l e¡j HS¡q¡−l E−õM B−R,
¢àa£uax j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h LaªÑL
fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£−a E−õM B−R ®k, HC Bp¡j£
OVe¡l ¢ce Afl Bp¡j£ ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£l h¡¢s−a AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b
OVe¡ÙÛ−m k¡h¡l SeÉ HL¢œa q−u¢Rm Hhw ®pM¡e ®b−L AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b
AÙ»pq OVe¡ÙÛ−m lJu¡e¡ qu,
a«a£uax P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jq−ml jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡u (k¡
flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) −k 6 Se
Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM Ll¡ q−u−R a¾j−dÉ HC Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM B−R,
Qa¥bÑax P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e, P.W-2 −j¡x lSh Bm£, P.W-4
®j¡x Bj¡e E¢Ÿe plL¡l, P.W-5 ®j¡x ®M¡l−nc Bmj, P.W-6 ®j¡x
BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j j¡p¤j, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc, P.W-20 BSja Eõ¡q
M¡e, P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm a¡−cl p¡−rÉ E−õM L−l ®k, HC Bp¡j£
OVe¡ÙÛ−m AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b ¢eqa Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f Hhw
j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm−L E−ŸnÉ L−l j−’l ¢c−L J pi¡ÙÛ−ml ¢c−L H−m¡f¡b¡¢s
155
…¢m L−l Hhw P.W-7 S¡¢Ll ®q¡−pe Hhw P.W-8 ®j¡x Bš²¡l ®q¡−pe HC
Bp¡j£−L OVe¡l f§−hÑ J OVe¡l flfl AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b AÙ» q¡−a
®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£l h¡¢sl ¢c−L ®k−a ®c−M−Rz
Bp¡j£f−rl ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ h−me ®k, ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma p¡r£−cl ®Sl¡l
hš²hÉ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡ L−le¢ez H fÐp−‰ c¢äa Bp¡j£ q¡¢gS Jl−g L¡e¡ q¡¢g−Sl
®Sl¡ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, ®Sl¡u Hje ®L¡e hš²hÉ B−p¢e ®k, k¡ à¡l¡
fÐa£uj¡e qu ®k, h¢ZÑa p¡r£NZ ®k hš²hÉ a¡−cl Sh¡eh¾c£−a ®l−M−R a¡
¢hnÄ¡p−k¡NÉ euz
AaHh, Ef−ll B−m¡Qe¡l B−m¡−L ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, HC Bp¡j£l e¡j
HS¡q¡−l B−R, HC Bp¡j£l e¡j j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡
Jl−g j¡qh¤h La«ÑL ®cu ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£−a E−õM B−R, HC Bp¡j£l
e¡j j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm La«ÑL ®cu jªaɤL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡u (k¡ flha£Ñ−a
L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) E−õM B−R, p−hÑ¡f¢l
P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e, P.W-2 ®j¡x lSh Bm£, P.W-5 ®j¡x ®M¡l−nc
Bmj, P.W-6 ®j¡x BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j j¡p¤j, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc,
P.W-20 BSja Eõ¡q M¡e p¤Øføi¡−h a¡−cl p¡−rÉ E−õM L−l−R a¡l¡ HC
Bp¡j£pq AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl−L ¢eqa Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l J jqm−L pl¡p¢l
OVe¡ÙÛ−m …¢m Ll−a ®c−M−R Hhw P.W-7 S¡¢Ll ®q¡−pe, P.W-8 ®j¡x Bš²¡l
®q¡−pe, P.W-9 à£−S¾cÐ plL¡l, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc OVe¡l flflC
HC Bp¡j£−L AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£pq Q−m ®k−a ®c−M−Rz
156
f§−hÑC ¢pÜ¡¿¹ q−u−R ®k, P.W-1 −j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e LaѪL c¡¢MmL«a
HS¡q¡l¢V ¢h−hQe¡−k¡NÉ, j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g
j¡qh¤h La«ÑL fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£¢V üaxfÐ−Z¡¢ca J
p¢WL (valuntarily and true), P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm LaѪL
jªa¥Épj k¿»Z¡u L¡al AhÙÛ¡u ¢h‘ jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌ−Vl L¡−R ®cu jªa¥ÉL¡m£e −O¡oZ¡ (k¡
flhaÑ£−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) NËqZ−k¡NÉz
®k−qa¥ Be£a A¢i−k¡N¢V fÐj¡−Zl j§m ¢i¢š ¢q®p−h HC ¢ae¢V j§m Ù¹−ñl j−dÉ
fÐ−aÉL¢V−aC p¤Øfø J p¤¢e¢cÑøi¡−h HC Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM B−R, p−hÑ¡f¢l
OVe¡ÙÛ−m Ef−l¡š² p¡r£NZ HC Bp¡j£−L AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b Bqp¡e
Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f J AeÉ¡eÉ−cl N¤¢m Ll−a ®c−M−R k¡l gmnЦ¢a−a Bqp¡e
Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f Hhw Jjl g¡l¦L lae ¢eqa q−u−R Hhw j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e
jqmpq A−e−L Bqa q−u−R, ®p−qa¥, ¢pÜ¡−¿¹ B¢p ®k, ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma q¡¢gS
Jl−g L¡e¡ q¡¢gS−L ®k jªa¥Écä¡−cn fÐc¡e L−l−Re a¡ hq¡m−k¡NÉz
AaHh, cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥ÉcäfСç Bp¡j£ q¡¢gS Jl−g L¡e¡
q¡¢gS Hl jªa¥Écä¡−cn¢V hq¡m b¡−L j−jÑ ¢pÜ¡¿¹ quz
cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥ÉcäfСç Bp¡j£ −p¡q¡N Jl−g pl¦ pÇf−LÑ
B−m¡Qe¡ J ¢pÜ¡¿¹ x
−Xb ®lg¡−l¾p Hl p¡−b Bp¡j£l c¡−ul Ll¡ 1703/2005 ew ®g±Sc¡l£
Bf£m Hhw 411/2005 ew ®Sm Bf£m¢V ¢h−hQe¡l SeÉ ®eu¡ q−m¡z
¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma HC Bp¡j£−L cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u −c¡o£ p¡hÉÙ¹f§hÑL
jªa¥Écä¡−cn fÐc¡e L−l−Rez e¢b fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k,
157
fÐbjax HC Bp¡j£l e¡j HS¡q¡−l E−õM B−R,
¢àa£uax j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h LaªÑL
fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡ Ll−m ®cM¡ k¡u ®k,
osk¿» pi¡u HC Bp¡j£l Ef¢ÙÛ¢al Lb¡ hm¡ e¡ q−mJ flha£Ñ−a OVe¡l ¢ce
Afl Bp¡j£ ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£l h¡¢s−a OVe¡l f§−hÑ Ef¢ÙÛa Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b HC
Bp¡j£ Ef¢ÙÛa ¢Rm Hhw ®pM¡e ®b−L AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£pq HC Bp¡j£ AÙ»pq
OVe¡ÙÛ−m k¡u j−jÑ E−õM B−R,
a«a£uax P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jq−ml jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡u (k¡
flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) HC Bp¡j£l
e¡j E−õM B−R,
Qa¥bÑax P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e, P.W-2 −j¡x lSh Bm£, P.W-4
®j¡x Bj¡e E¢Ÿe plL¡l, P.W-5 ®j¡x ®M¡l−nc Bmj, P.W-6 ®j¡x
BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j j¡p¤j, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc, P.W-20 BSja Eõ¡q
M¡e OVe¡l ¢ce OVe¡ÙÛ−m HC Bp¡j£−L AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b ¢eqa Bqp¡e
Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f®L mrÉ L−l …¢m Ll−a ®c−M−R Hhw P.W-7 S¡¢Ll ®q¡−pe
Hhw P.W-8 ®j¡x Bš²¡l ®q¡−pe, P.W-9 à£−S¾cÐ plL¡l, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g
Bq−jc OVe¡l flflC HC Bp¡j£−L AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b AÙ» pq Q−m
®k−a ®c−M−Rz
Bp¡j£f−rl ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ h−me ®k, HC Bp¡j£ Cw 29/03/2005
a¡¢l−M ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡m−a BaÈpjfÑe L−l Hhw Cw 16/04/2005 a¡¢l−M j§m
j¡jm¡l l¡u ®O¡¢oa quz ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ h−me ®k, HC Bp¡j£l hup OVe¡l
158
pju 26 hRl ¢Rm Hhw −ØVV ¢X−g¾p ¢e−u¡¢Sa ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ p¢WLi¡−h HC
Bp¡j£l f−r ®Sl¡ Ll−a hÉbÑ q−u−Rez ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ B−l¡ h−me ®k,
HS¡q¡−l p¤Øføi¡−h E−õM B−R ®k, Afl Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j ¢cf¤ J n¢qc¤m
Cpm¡j ¢nf¤ ¢eqa Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f−L mrÉ L−l …¢m L−l−R Hhw
AeÉ¡eÉl¡ H−m¡f¡b¡¢s …¢m L−l−Rz ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ B−l¡ h−me ®k, ®k−qa¥ HC
Bp¡j£l ¢hl¦−Ü p¤Øfø Hhw p¤¢e¢cÑø A¢i−k¡N ®eC ®p−qa¥ HC Bp¡j£l
jªa¥Écä¡−cn lcl¢qa ®k¡NÉz
Ef−ll B−m¡Qe¡l B−m¡−L HC Bc¡m−al A¢ija HC ®k, f§−hÑl
B−m¡Qe¡l B−m¡−L E−õM Ll¡ q−u−R ®k, Bp¡j£−cl ¢hl¦−Ü Be£a A¢i−k¡−Nl
¢i¢š ¢q−p−h 3¢V j§m Ù¹ñ−L (pillar) ¢h−hQe¡u Be¡ q−u−Rz HC Bp¡j£l ®r−œ
®cM¡ k¡u ®k, fÐbj Ù¹ñ HS¡q¡−l HC Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM B−Rz ¢àa£u Ù¹−ñ
j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h LaѪL fÐcnÑe£-27
¢Q¢q²a ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£−a OVe¡l ¢ce OVe¡l f§−hÑ HC Bp¡j£ AeÉ¡eÉ
−hn ¢LR¤ Bp¡j£l p¡−b ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£l h¡¢s−a HL¢œa q−u¢Rm Hhw ®pM¡e
®b−L ®hn ¢LR¤ Bp¡j£ AÙ»pq OVe¡ÙÛ−m k¡u j−jÑ E−õM B−Rz a«a£u Ù¹ñ,
jªa¥ÉnkÉ¡u P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm ¢h‘ jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌ−Vl L¡−R ®k 6 Se
Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM L−l ®N−R a¡l j−dÉ HC Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM B−Rz HC
¢ae¢V j§m Ù¹ñ−L (pillar) p¡r£ P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e, P.W-2 ®j¡x
lSh Bm£, P.W-4 ®j¡x Bj¡e E¢Ÿe plL¡l, P.W-5 ®j¡x ®M¡l−nc Bmj,
P.W-6 ®j¡x BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j j¡p¤j, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc, P.W-20
159
BSja Eõ¡q M¡e Hhw P.W-7 S¡¢Ll ®q¡−pe, P.W-8 ®j¡x Bš²¡l ®q¡−pe,
P.W-9 à£−S¾cÐ plL¡l pjbÑe L−l ®N−Rz
AaHh, pwNa L¡l−ZC VwN£l A¢hpwh¡¢ca ®ea¡ Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l
Hj,¢f Hhw Jjl g¡l¦L la−el qaÉ¡l OVe¡u ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma HC c¢äa
Bp¡j£ ®p¡q¡N Jl−g pl¦−L ®k jªa¥Écä¡−cn fÐc¡e L−l−Re, hup h¡ AeÉ¡eÉ
AhÙÛ¡¢c fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u HC Bp¡j£ ®L¡e Ae¤LÇf¡ ®f−a A¢dL¡l£ eu j−jÑ ¢pÜ¡−¿¹
B¢pz
AaHh, cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥ÉcäfСç Bp¡j£ ®p¡q¡N Jl−g pl¦ Hl
jªa¥Écä¡−cn¢V hq¡m b¡−L j−jÑ ¢pÜ¡¿¹ quz
cä¢h¢dl 302/120M/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥ÉcäfСç Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j ¢cf¤
pÇf−LÑ B−m¡Qe¡ J ¢pÜ¡¿¹ x
HC Bp¡j£l ®Lhmj¡œ ®Xb ®lg¡−l¾p¢V ¢h−hQe¡l SeÉ ®eu¡ q−m¡z
¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma HC Bp¡j£−L cä¢h¢dl 302/120M/34 d¡l¡u −c¡o£
p¡hÉÙ¹f§hÑL jªa¥Écä¡−cn fÐc¡e L−l−Rez e¢b fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k,
fÐbjax HC Bp¡j£l e¡j HS¡q¡−l p¤Øfø Hhw p¤¢e¢cÑøi¡−h E−õM B−Rz
HS¡q¡−l hm¡ q−u−R ®k, Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j ¢cf¤ J n¢qc¤m Cpm¡j ¢nf¤
HS¡q¡lL¡l£ P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e Hl hs i¡C Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l
Hj,¢f−L mrÉ L−l Efk¤Ñf¢l …¢m L−l Hhw …¢m¢hÜ q−u ¢a¢e j¡¢V−a m¤¢V−u
f−se,
¢àa£uax j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h LaªÑL
fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡ Ll−m ®cM¡ k¡u ®k,
160
OVe¡l 10/12 ¢ce f§−hÑ Bp¡j£ B¢j−el O−l HC Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j ¢cf¤pq
AeÉ¡eÉl¡ j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm−L BJu¡j£ ®üµR¡−phL m£−Nl Ju¡XÑ L¢j¢Vl
p−Çjm−e ®j−l ®gm¡ q−h j−jÑ HL osk¿»j§mL °hWL L−l,
a«a£uax P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jq−ml jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡u (k¡
flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) −k 6 S−el e¡j
E−õM Ll¡ q−u−R a¾j−dÉ HC Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j ¢cf¤l e¡j E−õM B−R,
Qa¥bÑax P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e, P.W-2 −j¡x lSh Bm£, P.W-4
®j¡x Bj¡e E¢Ÿe plL¡l, P.W-5 ®j¡x ®M¡l−nc Bmj, P.W-6 ®j¡x
BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j j¡p¤j, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc, P.W-11 ®j¡x S¡j¡m,
P.W-18 ®j¡x Bqp¡e Eõ¡q, P.W-20 BSja Eõ¡q M¡e, P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l
lqj¡e jqm OVe¡ÙÛ−m HC Bp¡j£−L AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£pq Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l
Hj,¢f−L mrÉ L−l N¤¢m Ll−a ®c−M−Rz P.W-3 ®j¡x Bh¤m L¡−nj, P.W-34
q¡¢gS¤l lqj¡e q¡¢hh OVe¡l 10/12 ¢ce f§−hÑ jlL¥−el e§l¦m B¢j−el h¡s£−a
osk¿»j§mL pi¡u HC Bp¡j£−L Ef¢ÙÛa b¡L−a −c−M−R Hhw e¤¤l¦m B¢j−el
h¡¢sl f¡−n b¡L¡ p¡c¡ lw−ul ®j¡Vl N¡s£ J ®j¡Vl p¡C−L−m HC Bp¡j£pq
AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−L ®cM−a −f−u−Rz P.W-11 ®j¡x S¡j¡m, P.W-12 ®j¡x g¢lc
E¢Ÿe OVe¡l ¢ce ®hm¡ Ae¤j¡e 9.45/10.00 V¡l pju ®cM−a f¡u ®k, p¡q¡l¡
p¤f¡l j¡−LÑ−Vl p¡j−e ¢h¢pL Hm¡L¡ ®b−L HL¢V p¡c¡ fСC−iV L¡l B−p Hhw
p¡q¡l¡ p¤f¡l j¡−LÑ−Vl p¡j−e cy¡s¡uz p¡r£l¡ B−l¡ ®cM−a f¡u ®k, N¡s£l
¢fR−el clS¡ M¤−m Bp¡j£ ¢cf¤ J ¢nf¤ e¡−j J N¡¢sl p¡j−el XÊ¡C¢iw ¢p−V hp¡
Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡−ll L¡−R k¡uzaMe Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l
161
N¡s£l Ly¡Q e¡¢j−u Bp¡j£ ¢cf¤l ‘¢fW Q¡f¢s−u’ ¢L ®ke h−mz Bp¡j£ ¢cf¤ J ¢nf¤
pi¡ÙÛ−ml ¢c−L Q−m k¡uz OVe¡ÙÛ−m pi¡−n−o HC p¡r£àu ®ØV−Sl ¢fRe ¢cL
®b−L ®h¡j¡l BJu¡S f¡u Hhw ®cM−a f¡u ¢cf¤ J ¢nf¤NZ ®ØV−Sl ¢c−L mrÉ
L−l …¢m Ll−Rz
HC Bp¡j£ f−r ¢ek¤¢š²u ¢h‘ ®ØVV ¢X−g¾p BCeS£h£ h−me ®k, HC
Bp¡j£ ¢e−cÑ¡o, a¡l ¢hl¦−Ü AeÉ¡ui¡−h HC A¢i−k¡N Be¡ q−u−R Hhw HC
Bp¡j£l jªa¥Écä¡−cn lc l¢qa ®k¡NÉz
Ef−ll B−m¡Qe¡l B−m¡−L ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, Bp¡j£−cl ¢hl¦−Ü Be£a
A¢i−k¡N fÐj¡−Zl j§m ¢i¢š ¢q−p−h 3¢V j§m Ù¹ñ−L (pillar) ¢h−hQe¡u Be¡
q−u−R a¡l phL¢V Ù¹ñ−aC Bp¡j£l e¡j p¤Øfø J p¤¢e¢cÑøi¡−h Hhw p¢œ²ui¡−h
AwnNËq−Zl E−õM l−u−Rz
−k−qa¥ f§−hÑl B−m¡Qe¡u fÐcnÑe£-1 ¢Q¢q²a HS¡q¡l¢V ¢h−hQe¡u Be¡ q−u−R,
P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm LaѪL fÐcnÑe£-23 ¢Q¢q²a jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡¢V−L
(k¡ flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) ¢hnÄ¡p−k¡NÉ
j−jÑ ¢pÜ¡¿¹ q−u−R, p−h¡Ñf¢l fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤−hl
ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£¢V üaxfÐ−e¡¢ca J p¢WL (valuntary and true)
j−jÑ ¢h−h¢Qa q−u−R ®p−qa¥ HC ¢ae¢V fkÑ¡−u Hhw Ef−l¡š² p¡r£−cl hš²−hÉ
p¤Øfø Hhw p¤¢e¢cÑøi¡−h fÐa£uj¡Z qu ®k, HC Bp¡j£l p¢œ²u AwnNËq−Z OVe¡l
10/12 ¢ce f§−hÑ jlL¥−el B¢j−el h¡¢s−a HL Afl¡dj§mL osk¿» qu Hhw
a¡lC d¡l¡h¡¢qLa¡u HC Bp¡j£l ®ea«−aÅ OVe¡ÙÛ−m AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£pq HC
162
Bp¡j£l …¢m−a VwN£l A¢hpwh¡¢ca ®ea¡ Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f J 17
hRl huú al¦Z qai¡NÉ Jjl g¡l¦L lae ¢eqa quz
AaHh, ¢pÜ¡−¿¹ B¢p ®k, ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma p¢WLi¡−hC HC Bp¡j£−L h¢ZÑa
d¡l¡u jªa¥Écä¡−cn fÐc¡e L−l−Rez
AaHh, cä¢h¢dl 302/120M/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥ÉcäfСç Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j
¢cf¤l jªa¥Écä¡−cn¢V hq¡m b¡−L j−jÑ ¢pÜ¡¿¹ quz
cä¢h¢dl 302/120M/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥ÉcäfСç Bp¡j£ j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h
Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h pÇf−LÑ B−m¡Qe¡ J ¢pÜ¡¿¹ x
−Xb ®lg¡−l−¾pl p¡−b HC Bp¡j£l c¡−ul Ll¡ 1513/2005 ew ®g±Sc¡l£
Bf£m Hhw 410/2005 ew ®Sm Bf£m¢V ¢h−hQe¡l SeÉ ®eu¡ q−m¡z
¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma HC Bp¡j£−L cä¢h¢dl 302/120M/34 d¡l¡u −c¡o£
p¡hÉÙ¹f§hÑL jªa¥Écä¡−cn fÐc¡e L−l−Rez e¢b fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k,
fÐbjax HC Bp¡j£l e¡j HS¡q¡−l E−õM B−R,
¢àa£uax HC Bp¡j£ OVe¡l p¡−b Hhw OVe¡l f§hÑha£Ñ osk−¿»l p¡−b ¢e−S−L
S¢s−u HL¢V ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢h‘ jÉ¡¢S−ØVÌ−Vl L¡−R fÐc¡e L−l−Rz
f§−hÑl B−m¡Qe¡u ¢pÜ¡¿¹ q−u−R ®k, c¢äa Bp¡j£ j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g
j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h LaѪL fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£¢V
®üµR¡ fÐ−Z¡¢ca J p¢WL (valuntarily and true)z HC ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL
Sh¡eh¾c£−a j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h p¤Øfø
Hhw p¤¢e¢cÑøi¡−h E−õM L−l−R ®k, OVe¡l 10/12 ¢ce f§−hÑ Afl Bp¡j£
®j¡qÇjc Bm£l p¡−b HC Bp¡j£ jlL¥−el B¢j−el h¡¢s−a k¡u Hhw ®pM¡−e
163
e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡lpq AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b jqm−L BJu¡j£ ®üµR¡−phL
m£−Nl Ju¡XÑ L¢j¢Vl p−Çjm−e ®no L−l ®ch¡l SeÉ HL osk¿» L−lz OVe¡l ¢ce
AbÑ¡v 07/05/2004 a¡¢l−M HC Bp¡j£ −hm¡ 10.00 V¡l ¢c−L Afl Bp¡j£
®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£l O−l AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£pq k¡u Hhw ®pM¡e ®b−L AÙ» ¢e−u OVe¡ÙÛ−m
®f±yR¡uz HC Bp¡j£pq AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£l¡ jqm−L mrÉ L−l …¢m L−lz flha£Ñ−a
a¡l¡ f§−hÑl fb d−l gy¡L¡ …¢m Ll−a Ll−a Q−m k¡u,
a«a£uax P.W-3 ®j¡x Bh¤m L¡−nj a¡l p¡−rÉ E−õM L−l−R ®k, OVe¡l
10/12 ¢ce f§−hÑ Afl Bp¡j£ e§l¦m B¢j−el h¡¢sl f¡−n l¡a 11.00 V¡l ¢c−L
HL¢V jVl p¡C−Lm Hhw HL¢V p¡c¡ fСC−iV N¡s£−a Bp¡j£ j¡qh¤hpq AeÉ¡eÉ
Bp¡j£−cl−L h−p b¡L−a ®c−M−Rz P.W-34 q¡¢gS¤l lqj¡e q¡¢hh a¡l p¡−rÉ
E−õM L−l−R ®k, OVe¡l 10/12 ¢ce f§−hÑ l¡a 10.00 V¡l ¢c−L jlL¥−el Bp¡j£
B¢j−el h¡¢s−a ¢N−u ®p Bp¡j£ B¢j−el p¡−b ®cM¡ Ll−a Q¡C−m B¢je
h−m−R, B−lL¢ce ®V¢m−g¡e L−l Bp−az H pju B¢j−el O−ll ¢ia−l Bp¡j£
j¡qh¤hpq AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl HC p¡r£ ®c−M−Rz
P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e, P.W-4 ®j¡x Bj¡e E¢Ÿe plL¡l, P.W-5
®j¡x ®M¡l−nc Bmj, P.W-6 ®j¡x BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j j¡p¤j, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g
Bq−jc, P.W-20 BSja Eõ¡q M¡e, P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm
OVe¡ÙÛ−m HC Bp¡j£−L AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£®cl p¡−b Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f−L
mrÉ L−l N¤¢m Ll−a ®c−M−R j−jÑ p¡−rÉ E−õM L−l−Rz k¢cJ P.W-26
j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm a¡l jªa¥ÉL¡m£e ®O¡oZ¡u (k¡ flha£Ñ−a L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 164
d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ ¢q−p−h Nªq£a q−u−R) p¤Øføi¡−h 6 Se Bp¡j£l j−dÉ HC
164
Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM L−l¢ez P.W-7 S¡¢Ll ®q¡−pe, P.W-8 ®j¡x Bš²¡l
®q¡−pe OVe¡l f§hha£Ñ pj−u HC Bp¡j£pq AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl−L Afl Bp¡j£
®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£l h¡¢sl ¢c−L ®k−a ®c−M−Rz P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc Hhw
P.W-28 S¡¢hc Bqp¡e ®p¡−qm HC Bp¡j£pq AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl−L OVe¡l
flfl AÙ»pq Q−m ®k−a ®c−M−Rz HC p¡r£l¡ Sh¡eh¾c£−a ®k hš²hÉ ®l−M−R
®Sl¡ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u a¡l −L¡e hÉaÉu f¡Ju¡ k¡u e¡z
Bp¡j£f−rl ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ h−me ®k, HC Bp¡j£ osk¿»pi¡u Ef¢ÙÛa
b¡L−mJ a¡l ®L¡e p¢œ²u AwnNËqZ ¢Rm e¡z ü£L«aj−a, “Bjl¡ pL−m …¢m
L−l¢R” E−õM L−l−R Ab¡Ñv L¡l …¢m−a Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f J Jjl
g¡l¦L lae ¢eqa q−u−R a¡ p¤Øfø euz ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ B−l¡ E−õM L−le ®k,
Cw 14/05/2004 a¡¢l−M HC Bp¡j£−L ®NËga¡l Ll¡l fl ALbÉ ¢ekÑ¡ae L−l
Cw 23/05/2004 a¡¢l−M L¢ba ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£¢V Bc¡u Ll¡ q−u−Rz
¢h‘ BCeS£h£ B−l¡ h−m−Re ®k, Bp¡j£ j¡qh¤−hl Ù»£ D.W-3 ¢le¡ p¤ma¡e¡
a¡l p¡−rÉ E−õM L−l−R ®k, ALbÉ ¢ekÑ¡a−el fl Ù»£ p¿¹¡e−L qaÉ¡ Ll¡ q−h H
q§jL£ ¢c−u a¡l L¡R ®b−L ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£¢V Bc¡u Ll¡ q−u−Rz
j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h LaѪL fÐcnÑe£-27
¢Q¢q²a ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£¢V üaxfÐ−Z¡¢ca J paÉ (valuntarily and
true) j−jÑ f§−hÑC ¢hnc B−m¡Qe¡u ¢pÜ¡¿¹ q−u−R, ®p−qa¥ H pÇf−LÑ Bl
B−m¡Qe¡ Ll¡ q−m¡ e¡z
Ef−ll B−m¡Qe¡u f¡Ju¡ k¡u ®k, cäfСç Bp¡j£ j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h
Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤−hl e¡j HS¡q¡−l E−õM B−R, j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e
165
j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h ¢e−S−L S¢s−u osk¿»j§mL pi¡u
Ef¢ÙÛa b¡L¡l Lb¡ Hhw OVe¡ÙÛ−m p¢œ²u AwnNËq−Zl Lb¡ ü£L¡l L−l−R k¡
üaxfÐ−Z¡¢ca J p¢WL (valuntarily and true)z HC ü£L¡−l¡¢šj§mL
Sh¡eh¾c£l osk¿» ¢ho−u P.W-3 ®j¡x Bh¤m L¡−nj Hhw P.W-34 q¡¢hh¤l
lqj¡e q¡¢hh Hl p¡rÉ NËqZ−k¡NÉ H L¡l−Z ®k, OVe¡l 10/12 ¢ce f§−hÑ HC
osk¿»j§mL pi¡¢V q−u−R k¡ ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£−a fÐL¡n ®f−u−Rz HC
osk¿»j§mL pi¡l pj−u P.W-34 q¡¢gS¤l lqj¡e q¡¢hh Afl Bp¡j£ B¢j−el
h¡¢s−a Bp¡j£−L ®cM−a ®f−u¢Rm J P.W-3 −j¡x Bh¤m L¡−nj HC osk¿»
pi¡−n−o a¡−cl−L HL−œ jVl p¡C−Lm J HL¢V p¡c¡ lw−ul N¡s£−k¡−N Q−m
®k−a ®c−M−Rz p¡r£−cl ®Sl¡u HC p¡r£−cl hš²hÉ−L A¢hnÄ¡p Ll¡l ja ®L¡e
AhÙÛ¡ f¢lm¢ra qu¢ez Afl ¢c−L P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e, P.W-4 ®j¡x
Bj¡e E¢Ÿe plL¡l, P.W-5 ®j¡x ®M¡l−nc Bmj, P.W-6 ®j¡x BSq¡l¦m
Cpm¡j j¡p¤j, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc, P.W-20 BSja Eõ¡q M¡e,
P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm OVe¡l pju AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−clpq HC
Bp¡j£−L Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f−L pq AeÉ¡eÉ−cl …¢m Ll−a ®c−M−R j−jÑ
E−õM L−l−Rz ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ “Bjl¡ pL−m …¢m L¢l” Eàªa L−l hm−a
®Q−u−Re L¡l …¢m−a Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f h¡ Jjl g¡l¦L lae ¢eqa
q−u−R ®p ¢hou¢V ¢e¢ÕQa e¡ qJu¡u Bp¡j£ j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h
i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h Hl p¤¢hd¡ (benefit) −f−a f¡−lz
Ef−ll B−m¡Qe¡l B−m¡−L ¢pÜ¡−¿¹ B¢p ®k, HC Bp¡j£l e¡j HS¡q¡−l
¢Rm, HC Bp¡j£ ¢e−S−L S¢s−u osk¿»j§mL pi¡ Hhw OVe¡l pju OVe¡ÙÛ−m
166
…¢m L−l−R j−jÑ üaxfÐ−Z¡¢ca Hhw p¢WL (valuntarily and true)
ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£ fÐc¡e L−l−R, P.W-3 ®j¡x Bh¤m L¡−nj Hhw P.W-
34 q¡¢gS¤l lqj¡e q¡¢hh osk¿» pi¡ pÇf−LÑ p¡rÉ fÐc¡e L−l−R Hhw P.W-1
®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e, P.W-4 ®j¡x Bj¡e E¢Ÿe plL¡l, P.W-5 ®j¡x ®M¡l−nc
Bmj, P.W-6 ®j¡x BSq¡l¦m Cpm¡j j¡p¤j, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc,
P.W-20 BSja Eõ¡q M¡e, P.W-26 j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm OVe¡l pju
AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−clpq HC Bp¡j£−L Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f−L pq
AeÉ¡eÉ−cl …¢m Ll−a ®c−M−R, P.W- 7 S¡¢Ll ®q¡−pe Hhw P.W-8 ®j¡x
Bš²¡l ®q¡−pe OVe¡l f§hÑha£Ñ pj−u HC Bp¡j£pq AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl−L Afl
Bp¡j£ ®j¡qÇjc Bm£l h¡¢sl ¢c−L ®k−a ®c−M−R Hhw P.W- 7 S¡¢Ll ®q¡−pe
Hhw P.W-8 ®j¡x Bš²¡l ®q¡−pe, P.W-10 ®j¡x n¢g Bq−jc, P.W-17
−j¡x Bh¤ p¡Dc, P.W-28 S¡¢hc Bqp¡e ®p¡−qm OVe¡l fl fl HC Bp¡j£pq
AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl−L AÙ»q¡−a Q−m ®k−a ®c−M−R, p−hÑ¡f¢l HC p¡r£−cl
Sh¡eh¾c£, ®Sl¡ Hhw P.W-33 ac¿¹ LjÑLaÑ¡ ®j¡x M¡−mL¥‹¡j¡−el L¡−R ®cu
L¡kÑ¢h¢dl 161 d¡l¡l Sh¡eh¾c£ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, l¡øÌfr AaÉ¿¹ p¤Øfø
J p¤¢e¢cÑøi¡−h fÐj¡Z Ll−a pjbÑ q−u−R ®k HC Bp¡j£ osk¿»pi¡u Hhw
OVe¡ÙÛ−m p¢œ²ui¡−h AwnNËqZ L−l−Rz
AaHh, ¢pÜ¡−¿¹ B¢p ®k, ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma p¢WLi¡−hC HC Bp¡j£−L h¢ZÑa
d¡l¡u jªa¥Écä¡−cn fÐc¡e L−l−Rez
167
AaHh, cä¢h¢dl 302/120M/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥ÉcäfСç Bp¡j£ j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e
j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤−hl jªa¥Écä¡−cn¢V hq¡m b¡−L j−jÑ ¢pÜ¡¿¹
quz
cä¢h¢dl 302/120M/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥ÉcäfСç Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l
pÇf−LÑ B−m¡Qe¡ J ¢pÜ¡¿¹ x
−Xb ®lg¡−l−¾pl p¡−b HC Bp¡j£l c¡−ul Ll¡ ®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew
1739/2005 Hhw 409/2005 ew ®Sm Bf£m¢V ¢h−hQe¡l SeÉ ®eu¡ q−m¡z
¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma HC Bp¡j£−L cä¢h¢dl 302/120M/34 d¡l¡u −c¡o£
p¡hÉÙ¹f§hÑL jªa¥Écä¡−cn fÐc¡e L−l−Rez e¢b fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k,
fÐbjax HC Bp¡j£l e¡j HS¡q¡−ll Lm¡−j E−õM −eC a−h HS¡q¡−ll
¢hhl−Z E−õM Ll¡ q−u−R ®k, “h¡wm¡−cn S¡a£ua¡h¡c£ k¤hc−ml ®L¾cУu ®ea¡
®j¡x e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l .......... Hl f§hÑ f¢lLÒfe¡ ®j¡a¡−hL a¡q¡lC f¡¢ma
Ef−l¡š² pnÙ» p¿»¡p£NZ à¡l¡ Eš² qaÉ¡L¡ä OV¡−e¡ qCu¡−Rz Bj¡l i¡C−ul
Se¢fÐua¡l L¡l−Z c£OÑ¢ce k¡ha h¡wm¡−cn S¡a£ua¡h¡c£ c−ml EµQ jq−ml
V¡−NÑ−V f¢lZa qCu¡¢Rm, a‹eÉ C¢af§−hÑJ a¡−L Y¡L¡l l¡S f−b B−¾c¡me
pwNÊ¡−jl pju qaÉ¡ Ll¡l ®Qø¡ Ll¡ qCu¡¢Rmz”
¢àa£uax j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h LaѪL
fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, ®pM¡−e
4¢V fkÑ¡u l−u−Rz HC ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£l 2u fkÑ¡−u hm¡ q−u−R ®k,
2001 p¡−ml A−ƒ¡h−ll ¢ehÑ¡Q−e plL¡l f¢lh¢aÑa qJu¡l p¡−b p¡−b e¤l¦m
Cpm¡j plL¡l, jqm LaѪL A¯hd hÉhp¡l f¢lQ¡me¡l ¢eu¿»e a¡l q¡−a ¢e−u
168
®euz H fkÑ¡−u jqm VwN£ ®R−s Y¡L¡u hph¡p Ll−a h¡dÉ quz L¡lZ e¤l¦m
Cpm¡j plL¡l J a¡l −m¡LSe jqm−L p¤−k¡Nja ®f−m fСZ e¡n Ll−a f¡−lz
HC ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£l 3u fkÑ¡u fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u f¡Ju¡ k¡u, OVe¡l
10/12 ¢ce f§−hÑ jlL¥−el B¢j−el h¡¢s−a HL¢V osk¿»j§mL pi¡u BJu¡j£
®üµR¡−phL m£−Nl Ju¡XÑ L¢j¢Vl p−Çjm−e jqm−L ®j−l ®gm¡l osk¿» qu Hhw
HC osk¿»pi¡u Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j pLm−L E−ŸnÉ L−l h−m ®k, jqm
a¡−cl−L A−eL SÅ¡¢m−u−R a¡−L Bl ®hy−Q b¡L−a ®cu¡ k¡u e¡z H pju pL−m
HLja ®f¡oZ L−lz P.W-3 −j¡x Bh¤m L¡−nj J P.W-34 q¡¢gS¤l lqj¡e
q¡¢hh H¢ce jlL¥−el B¢j−el h¡¢s−a J h¡¢sl f¡−n p¡c¡ N¡s£ J jVl
p¡C−L−m Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡lpq AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl ®cM−a f¡uz HC
ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£l ®no fkÑ¡−u E−õM B−R, OVe¡l ¢ce AbÑ¡v Cw
07/05/2004 a¡¢l−M Bp¡j£ ®j¡qÇjc Bm£l h¡¢s−a OVe¡ OV¡−e¡l SeÉ
AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£l¡ S¢sa quz ¢L¿º Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l ®pM¡−e Ef¢ÙÛa
¢Rm e¡z P.W-11 ®j¡x S¡j¡m Hl p¡rÉ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u f¡Ju¡ k¡u ®k, OVe¡l ¢ce
pL¡m 10.00 V¡l ¢c−L p¡q¡l¡ p¤f¡l j¡−LÑ−Vl p¡j−e P.W-12 ®jx g¢lc
E¢Ÿepq a¡l¡ cy¡s¡u Hhw P.W-11 ®j¡x S¡j¡m, P.W-12 ®j¡x g¢lc E¢Ÿe
®cM−a f¡u ®k, ¢h¢pL Hm¡L¡ ®b−L HL¢V p¡c¡ fСC−iV L¡l B−p J p¡q¡l¡
j¡−LÑ−Vl p¡j−e cy¡s¡uz Hpju N¡s£l ¢fR−el clS¡ M¤−m Bp¡j£ ¢cf¤ J ¢nf¤
e¡−j, N¡s£l p¡j−el XÊ¡C¢iw p£−V hp¡ Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡−ll L¡−R k¡uz
aMe Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j N¡s£l Ly¡Q e¡¢j−u Bp¡j£ ¢cf¤l “¢fW Q¡f¢s−u” ¢L
®ke h−mz P.W-11 ®j¡x S¡j¡m ®q¡−pe Hhw P.W-12 ®j¡x g¢lc E¢Ÿe
169
pi¡ÙÛ−m k¡u, pi¡−n−o ®ØV−Sl ¢fRe ®b−L HL¢V ®h¡j¡l BJu¡S f¡u, ¢fRe
¢g−l ®c−M Bp¡j£ ¢cf¤ J ¢nf¤ Nw ®ØV−Sl ¢c−L mrÉ L−l …¢m R¤s−Rz P.W-33
ac¿¹ LjÑLaÑ¡ ®j¡x M¡−mL¥‹¡j¡−el ®Sl¡ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m
Cpm¡j plL¡l f−r HC p¡r£−L ®k ®Sl¡ Ll¡ q−u−R ®pM¡−e P.W-3 ®j¡x
Bh¤m L¡−nj, P.W-34 ®j¡x q¡¢gS¤l lqj¡e q¡¢hh Hhw P.W-11 ®j¡x S¡j¡m
J P.W-12 ®j¡x g¢lc E¢Ÿe Ef−l¡š² ®k p¡rÉ Bc¡m−a H−p h−m−R a¡l
¢h−l¡d£a¡u HC p¡r£−L ®L¡e p¤¢e¢cÑø p¡−Sne −cu¡ qu¢ez AbÑ¡v ®cM¡ k¡u ®k,
P.W-3 ®j¡x Bh¤m L¡−nj, P.W-34 q¡¢gS¤l lqj¡e q¡¢hh OVe¡l 10/12 ¢ce
f§−hÑ j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h La«ÑL fÐcnÑe£-27
¢Q¢q²a ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£−a jlL¥−el B¢j−el h¡¢s−a osk¿»pi¡
pÇf¢LÑa ®k p¡rÉ fÐc¡e L−l−R Hhw P.W-11 ®j¡x S¡j¡m, P.W-12 ®j¡x
g¢lc E¢Ÿe OVe¡l f§hÑ j¤q§−aÑ p¡q¡l¡ j¡−L−VÑ Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l−L a¡l
N¡s£−a L−l ¢e−u Bp¡ Bp¡j£ ¢cf¤, ¢nf¤−L ‘¢fW Q¡f¢s−u’ ¢LR¤ HLV¡ h−m−R
j−jÑ p¡r£l¡ a¡−cl p¡−rÉ k¡ E−õM L−l−R a¡ A¢hnÄ¡p Ll¡l ja ®L¡e AhÙÛ¡,
¢hnÄ¡p−k¡NÉ fÐj¡Z¡¢c h¡ ¢hnÄ¡p®k¡NÉ p¡−Sne Bc¡m−al p¡j−e EfÙÛ¡¢fa qu¢ez
ü£L«a j−a, e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l OVe¡l pju OVe¡ÙÛ−m Ef¢ÙÛa ¢Rm e¡z
¢L¿º fÐcnÑe£-1 ¢Q¢q²a HS¡q¡l fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, ®pM¡−e HS¡q¡l Lm¡−j
HC Bp¡j£l e¡j E−õM e¡ b¡L−mJ p¤Øføi¡−h hm¡ q−u−R ®k, h¡wm¡−cn
S¡a£ua¡h¡c£ k¤hc−ml ®L¾cУu ®ea¡ ®j¡x e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l Hl f§hÑ f¢lLÒfe¡
®j¡a¡−hL a¡lC f¡¢ma pnÙ» p¿»¡p£−cl à¡l¡ HC qaÉ¡L¡ä OV¡−e¡ q−u−Rz f§−hÑC
B−m¡Qe¡œ²−j ¢pÜ¡¿¹ q−u−R ®k, OVe¡l 35 O¾V¡ fl P.W-1 ®j¡x j¢aEl lqj¡e
170
®k HS¡q¡l¢V c¡¢Mm L−l−R a¡ NËqZ−k¡NÉz f§−hÑ B−l¡ ¢pÜ¡¿¹ q−u−R pq-Bp¡j£
j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h LaѪL fÐcnÑe£-27
¢Q¢q²a ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£¢V üaxfÐ−Z¡¢ca J p¢WL (valuntarily and
true)z HS¡q¡−l Ef−l E−õ¢Ma hZÑe¡l ®fÐr¡f−V P.W-3 ®j¡x Bh¤m L¡−nj J
P.W-34 ®j¡x q¡¢gS¤l lqj¡e q¡¢hh Hl p¡rÉ p−h¡Ñf¢l P.W-11 ®j¡x S¡j¡m
J P.W-12 ®j¡x g¢lc E¢Ÿe Hl Ef−l E−õ¢Ma p¡−rÉl p¡−b fÐcnÑe£ -27
¢Q¢q²a j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤−hl
ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£¢V HL−œ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u −k, Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m
Cpm¡j plL¡l h¡wm¡−cn S¡a£ua¡h¡c£ k¤hc−ml HLSe ®L¾cУu ®ea¡ ¢R−mez
Afl¢c−L ü£L«a j−a, VwN£l A¢hpwh¡¢ca ®ea¡ Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f
BN¡j£ S¡a£u pwpc ¢ehÑ¡Q−el pñ¡hÉ fСbÑ£ ¢R−mez fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a
ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, ®pM¡−e jqm−L A¯hd
hÉhp¡l i¡N h¡−V¡u¡l¡ ¢e−u ¢e−S−cl j−dÉ ¢h−l¡−dl ®Sl ¢q−p−h BJu¡j£
®üµR¡−phL m£−Nl Ju¡XÑ L¢j¢Vl p−Çjm−e jqm−L M¤e Ll¡l osk¿» q−u¢Rmz
Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l HC osk¿»j§mL pi¡l j§m f¢lQ¡me¡L¡l£ ¢q®p−h
p¢œ²ui¡−h AwnNËqZ Ll¡l flJ P.W-11 ®j¡x S¡j¡m, P.W-12 −j¡x g¢lc
E¢Ÿe Hl p¡rÉ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u fÐa£uj¡e qu ®k, e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l Bp¡j£ ¢cf¤
J ¢nf¤−L OVe¡l f§hÑha£Ñ pj−u ‘¢fW Q¡f¢s−u’ a¡−cl−L ®k Lb¡ h−m−R a¡l
gmnЦ¢a−aC osk¿» pi¡l ¢pÜ¡¿¹ j−a jqm−L qaÉ¡ Ll¡l f§−hÑC B¡p¡j£ ¢cf¤ J
¢nf¤ OVe¡ÙÛ−m ¢N−u ¢eqa Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l−L pl¡p¢l …¢m L−l−Rz
171
Afl¡dj§mL osk¿» fÐj¡Z Ll¡ pqS ¢hou euz HLb¡ hm¡l A−fr¡ l¡−M e¡
®k, ®L¡e Afl¡dj§mL osk¿» osk¿»L¡l£l¡ fÐL¡−nÉ Ll−hz a−h osk¿» Hhw
osk−¿»l ®fТr−a pwO¢Va L¡kÑLm¡−fl j¡−T ¢LR¤ BQlZ à¡l¡ p¤Øfø qu ®k,
pwO¢Va OVe¡l f§−hÑ ®L¡e Afl¡dj§mL osk¿» q−u¢Rm ¢L e¡z
P.W-3 −j¡x Bh¤m L¡−nj OVe¡l 10/12 ¢ce f§−hÑ l¡a 11.00 V¡l ¢c−L
jlL¥−el B¢j−el h¡s£l p¡j−e Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡lpq f§−hÑ E−õ¢Ma
AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£−cl−L HL¢V jVl p¡C−Lm J HL¢V N¡s£pq ®cM−a f¡uz P.W-
3 ®j¡x Bh¤m L¡−nj Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j−L HC fСC−iV L¡−ll XÊ¡C¢iw p£−V
®cM−a f¡uz P.W-3 −j¡x Bh¤m L¡−nj Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l−L Bp¡j£
¢cf¤pq AeÉ¡eÉ Ef¢ÙÛa Bp¡j£−cl p¡−b Lb¡ hm−a ®c−Mz P.W-34 q¡¢gS¤l
lqj¡e q¡¢hh HC ¢ce l¡a 10.00 V¡l ¢c−L jlL¥−el B¢j−el h¡¢s−a Bp¡j£
e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡lpq f§−hÑ E−õ¢Ma ®hn ¢LR¤ Bp¡j£−L ®cM−a f¡uz fÐcnÑe£
27 ¢Q¢q²a j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h Hl
ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£¢V üaxfÐ−Z¡¢ca Hhw p¢WL (valuntarily and
true) j−jÑ f§−hÑC ¢pÜ¡¿¹ ®eu¡ q−u−Rz HC ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£
fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, OVe¡l 10/12 ¢ce f§−hÑ AbÑ¡v P.W-3 ®j¡x Bh¤m
L¡−nj, P.W-34 q¡¢gS¤l lqj¡e q¡¢hh ®k OVe¡ ®c−M−R a¡l pjbÑ−e
ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u f¡Ju¡ k¡u ®k, ®p¢ce jlL¥−el Bp¡j£
B¢j−el h¡¢s−a jqm−L BJu¡j£ ®üµR¡−phL m£−Nl Ju¡XÑ L¢j¢Vl p−Çjm−e
®j−l ®gm¡l SeÉ HL¢V osk¿» q−u¢Rm Hhw Ef¢ÙÛa Bp¡j£l¡ HC osk−¿»
HLja ®f¡oZ L−l¢Rmz p−hÑ¡f¢l, HC osk¿»pi¡¢V Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l
172
à¡l¡ f¢lQ¡¢ma q−u¢Rmz fÐcnÑe£-1 ¢Q¢q²a HS¡q¡−l Øføa E−õM B−R ®k,
Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l f§hÑ f¢lLÒfe¡ j−a a¡lC f¡¢ma HS¡q¡l h¢ZÑa
pnÙ» p¿»¡p£−cl ¢c−u HC qaÉ¡L¡ä O¢V−u−Rz Afl¢c−L ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL
Sh¡eh¾c£ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u ®k, Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡lC BJu¡j£
®üµR¡−phL m£−Nl Ju¡XÑ L¢j¢Vl p−ÇjmeÙÛm¢V OVe¡ OV¡−e¡l SeÉ ¢ehÑ¡Qe L−lz
HS¡q¡−l p¤Øføi¡−h E−õM B−R ®k, OVe¡l pju Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j ¢cf¤ Hhw
n¢qc¤m Cpm¡j ¢nf¤ HS¡q¡L¡l£l hs i¡C Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f−L mrÉ
L−l Efk¤Ñf¢l N¤¢m L−l Hhw AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£l¡ pi¡ÙÛ−m BeÉ¡eÉ−cl …¢m L−lz
HS¡q¡−l E−õ¢Ma ¢cf¤, ¢nf¤l ®ea«−aÅ …¢m hoÑ−Zl ¢hou¢Vl p¡−b P.W-11 ®j¡x
S¡j¡m Hhw P.W-12 ®j¡x g¢lc E¢Ÿe p¡q¡l¡ j¡−LÑ−V HC Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j
plL¡l LaѪL HC ¢cf¤ J ¢nf¤−L ‘¢fW Q¡f¢s−u’ ¢LR¤ hm¡l ¢hou¢Vl HL¢V
®k¡Np§œa¡ f¡Ju¡ k¡uz fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡
Jl−g j¡qh¤h Hl ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£ fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u −k, OVe¡l
¢ce Afl Bp¡j£ ®j¡qÇjc Bm£l h¡¢s−a ®hn ¢LR¤ Bp¡j£ AÙ»pq OVe¡ÙÛ−m
k¡h¡l SeÉ −hm¡ 10.00 V¡l ¢c−L fÐÙ¹¤a qu Hhw lJe¡ quz ¢L¿º HS¡q¡−l
E−õ¢Ma Bp¡j£ ¢cf¤ J ¢nf¤ ®pM¡−e ¢Rm e¡z P.W-11 ®j¡x S¡j¡m Hhw P.W-
12 ®j¡x g¢lc E¢Ÿe Hl p¡−rÉ f¡Ju¡ k¡u ®k, ®pC pj−u Bp¡j£ ¢cf¤ J ¢nf¤−L
p¡q¡l¡ j¡−LÑVÙÛ−m Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l a¡l N¡¢s−a L−l e¡¢j−u ®cu
Hhw ‘¢fW Q¡f¢s−u’ ¢LR¤ h−mz f§−hÑC E−õM Ll¡ q−u−R ®k, Afl¡dj§mL
osk−¿»l ¢hou¢V pl¡p¢l fÐj¡Z Ll¡ Løp¡dÉLlz ¢L¿º haÑj¡e AhÙÛ¡u P.W-3
®j¡x Bh¤m L¡−nj, P.W-34 q¡¢gS¤l lqj¡e q¡¢hh, P.W-11 −j¡x S¡j¡m Hhw
173
P.W-12 ®j¡x g¢lc E¢Ÿe Hl p¡−rÉl p¡−b fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e
j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h Hl ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL Sh¡eh¾c£
fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u p¤Øfø Hhw p¤¢e¢cÑøi¡−h ¢pÜ¡−¿¹ Bp¡ pñh ®k, Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j
plL¡l 2001 p−e l¡S¯e¢aL rja¡ hc−ml fl fl j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jq−ml
pLm A¯hd, °hd hÉhp¡¢cl ¢eu¿»e NËqZ L−l Hhw a¡−L ®j−l ®gm¡l ¢pÜ¡¿¹ NËqZ
L−lz Hl flJ a¡l l¡S¯e¢aL ¢Ql-fТaà¾cÄ£ Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l−L ®k−L¡e
Ef¡−u p¢l−u ®ch¡l j¡e¢pLa¡u OVe¡ÙÛm BJu¡j£ ®üµR¡−phL m£−Nl Ju¡XÑ
L¢j¢Vl pi¡¢V−L ¢ehÑ¡Qe L−l J OVe¡l ¢ce P.W-11 −j¡x S¡j¡m Hhw P.W-
12 −j¡x g¢lc E¢Ÿ−el p¡rÉ j−a AeÉ¡eÉ ®hn¢LR¤ Bp¡j£ ®j¡q¡Çjc Bm£l h¡¢s
®b−L fÐÙ¹¤a q−u OVe¡ÙÛ−m ®N−mJ Bp¡j£ ¢cf¤ J ¢nf¤−L HC e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l
N¡¢s−a L−l p¡q¡l¡ j¡−LÑ−V e¡¢j−u ¢c−u a¡−cl−L ‘¢fW Q¡f¢s−u’ ®k
Evp¡qhÉ”L Lb¡ h−m a¡lC gmnЦ¢a−a HS¡q¡lh¢ZÑa j−a, ¢cf¤, ¢nf¤ pl¡p¢l
Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l−L OVe¡l pju …¢m¢hÜ L−l Hhw a¡l p¡−b AeÉ¡eÉ
Bp¡j£l¡ OVe¡ÙÛ−m H−m¡f¡b¡¢s …¢mhoÑZ L−lz
Bp¡j£f−rl ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ h−me ®k, HC Bp¡j£−L cä¢h¢dl 34 d¡l¡u
®k cä¡−cn −cu¡ q−u−R a¡ kb¡kb d¡l¡ euz HM¡−e cä¢h¢dl 302/120M d¡l¡l
p¡−b 109 d¡l¡ pw−k¡¢Sa q−hz H fÐp−‰ Bc¡m−al A¢ija HC ®k, cä¢h¢dl
109 d¡l¡l ÙÛ−m cä¢h¢dl 34 d¡l¡ ¢m¢fhÜ qJu¡l ¢hou¢V j§m ¢hQ¡kÑ ¢hou J
cä¡−cn−L ¢h¢OÀa L−l¢e ¢hd¡u HC cä¡−cn¢V haÑj¡e fkÑ¡−u a¢LÑa q−a f¡−l
e¡z
174
plL¡l f−r ¢h‘ HÉ¡Ve£Ñ ®Se¡−lm Se¡h j¡qh¤−h Bmj h−me ®k, Bp¡j£
e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l HC OVe¡l j§m ‘®q¡a¡’ Hhw a¡−L ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma p¢WL
cä¡−cn fÐc¡e L−l−Rez l¡øÌf−rl ¢h‘ pqL¡l£ HÉ¡Ve£Ñ ®Se¡−lm Se¡h h¢nl
Bq−jc, ¢h‘ BCeS£h£ Se¡h p¡−S¡u¡l −q¡−pe ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma p¢WL cä
fÐc¡e L−le j−jÑ E−õM L−le Hhw ¢h‘ pqL¡l£ HÉ¡Ve£Ñ ®Se¡−lm Se¡h h¢nl
Bq−jc H pÇf¢LÑa eS£l c¡¢Mm L−le, k¡ f§−hÑC E−õM Ll¡ q−u−Rz
l¡øÌf−r ¢h‘ ¢p¢eul BCeS£h£ Se¡h Hj. B¢jl¦m Cpm¡j Hhw ¢h‘
¢p¢eul BCeS£h£ Se¡h Bë¥m j¢ae Mpl¦ a¡−cl hš²−hÉ j§ma HL¢V ¢h−no
AhÙÛ¡l Lb¡ E−õM L−lez a¡−cl hš²−hÉl j§m ¢houhÙ¹¤ qm fÐcnÑe£-27 ¢Q¢q²a
j¡qh¤h¤l lqj¡e j¡qh¤h Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h Hl ü£L¡−l¡¢š²j§mL
Sh¡eh¾c£ j−a ®Lhmj¡œ jqm−L M¤e Ll¡l E−ŸnÉ b¡L−mJ osk¿»pi¡u
BJu¡j£ ®üµR¡−phL m£−Nl Ju¡XÑ L¢j¢Vl p−ÇjmeÙÛm−L HC M¤e L¡kÑLl Ll¡l
ÙÛm ¢q®p−h ¢ehÑ¡Qe Ll¡l L¡lZ¢V ¢h−hQe¡−k¡NÉz Ef−ll fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u ®cM¡ k¡u
®k, HL¢V E¾j¤š² Sepi¡u Bp¡j£NZ E¾j¤š² j−’ fÐL¡nÉ ¢ch¡−m¡−L ¢e¢hÑQ¡−l
…¢mhoÑZ L−l−Rz HC …¢mhoÑ−Z VwN£l A¢hpwh¡¢ca ®ea¡ Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l
Hj,¢f Hhw 17 hRl huú al¦e qai¡NÉ Jjl g¡l¦L lae ¢eqa q−u−R Hhw
jqmpq A−e−L Bqa q−u−Rz hÙ¹¤ fÐcnÑe£, hÉ¡−m¢øL ¢l−f¡VÑpj§q fkÑ¡−m¡Qe¡u
®cM¡ k¡u ®k, ®pM¡−e ApwMÉ …¢ml ¢Qq² f¡Ju¡ −N−R AbÑ¡v i¡NÉœ²−j OVe¡l ¢ce
B−l¡ qaÉ¡L¡ä ®b−L SeNe lr¡ ®f−u−Rz ¢h‘ BCeS£h£àu osk¿» h¡Ù¹h¡ue
Ll¡l SeÉ ¢ehÑ¡¢Qa ÙÛ¡e¢V−L Hhw OVe¡ OV¡−e¡l fТœ²u¡¢V−L HL¢V “j¡p L£¢mw”
Abh¡ “¢j¢e ®S−e¡p¡CX” ¢q−p−h ¢Q¢q²a L−l−Rez ay¡l¡ h−m−Re ®k, HC−k
175
Sepj¡−h−n ¢e¢hÑQ¡−l …¢ml fÐhZa¡ ®kM¡−e ¢e¢cÑø hÉ¢š²pq ApwMÉ hÉ¢š²l ¢eqa
qh¡l pñ¡he¡ b¡−L Hl¦f fÐhZa¡ ¢elp−e Bc¡m−al L¡R ®b−L HL¢V ¢h−no
¢e−cÑne¡ SeNZ Bn¡ L−lz HC fÐp−‰ ¢h‘ BCeS£h£NZ k−n¡−l E¢cQ£l
p−Çjm−e …¢m hoÑZ, HL¥−n BNØV h‰hå¥ HÉ¢i¢eE−a fÐL¡nÉ ¢ch¡−m¡−L
¢e¢hÑQ¡−l ®NË−eX q¡jm¡, lje¡l hVj§−m f−qm¡ °hn¡−M ®kM¡−e pjNË h¡P¡m£ S¡¢a
HL¢œa q−u−R ®pM¡−e ¢e¢hÑQ¡−l ®h¡j¡ ¢h−Øg¡lZ, p−hÑ¡f¢l VwN£l A¢hpwh¡¢ca
®ea¡ Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f Hhw qai¡NÉ Jjl g¡l¦L la−el fÐL¡nÉ
Sepi¡u Hl¦f H−m¡f¡b¡¢s …¢ml L¡l−Z ¢eq−al OVe¡u Bl cn¢V M¤−el ¢hQ¡l
eu, H¢V−L HL¢V “NZqaÉ¡” ‘j¡p L£¢mw’ h¡ ‘¢j¢e ®S−e¡p¡CX’ ¢q®p−h
¢h−hQe¡u H−e HC fÐL¡l L¡S ®b−L ®ke i¢hoÉ−a osk¿»L¡l£ J h¡Ù¹h¡ueL¡l£l¡
fÐL¡nÉ Sepi¡u h¡ Sepj¡N−j ¢e¢hÑQ¡l …¢mhoÑ−Z, ®h¡j¡ hoÑ−Z, ®NË−eX hoÑ−Z ®k
qaÉ¡L¡ä pwO¢Va L−l, k¡−L HL¢V ‘¢j¢e ®S−e¡p¡CX’ ¢q−p−h E−õM Ll¡ ®k−a
f¡−l, ®p ph ®r−œ A¢ik¤š²l¡ ®ke ®L¡e Ae¤LÇf¡ ®f−a e¡ f¡−l ®p pÇf−LÑ ¢cL
¢e−cÑne¡ fСbÑe¡ L−lez
Ef−l¡š² B−m¡Qe¡l B−m¡−L HLb¡ p¤¢e¢cÑø J p¤Øfø ®k, Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m
Cpm¡j plL¡−ll l¡S¯e¢aL fТaà¾cÄ£ ¢eqa Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hhw A¯hd
hÉhp¡l fÊ¢aà¾cÄ£ j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqmz HC j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqm−L c¤¢eu¡ ®b−L
p¢l−u ®ch¡l osk−¿»l ÙÛ¡e¢V Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l ¢ehÑ¡Qe L−le Hhw
ü£L«aj−a, H¢V HL¢V E¾j¤š² Sepi¡ ¢Rmz jlL¥−el Bp¡j£ B¢j−el h¡¢sl
osk¿»pi¡l p¡−b B¡p¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l a¡l l¡S¯e¢aL fТaà¾cÄ£ Bqp¡e
Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l−LJ HLC f¿Û¡u p¢l−u ®gm¡l j¡e¢pLa¡−a P.W-11 ®j¡x S¡j¡m
176
Hhw P.W-12 ®j¡x g¢lc E¢Ÿe Hl p¡rÉj−a e¤l¦m Cpm¡j ¢cf¤ J n¢qc¤m
Cpm¡j ¢nf¤−L ‘¢fW Q¡f¢s−u’ Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l−L mrÉ L−l …¢mhoÑZ Ll¡l
SeÉ Evp¡¢qa L−l Hhw HS¡q¡l h¢ZÑa j−a, Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j ¢cf¤ J n¢qc¤m
Cpm¡j ¢nf¤ OVe¡ÙÛ−m pl¡p¢l Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l−L mrÉ L−l …¢m L−lz
B−m¡Qe¡u B−l¡ f¡Ju¡ k¡u ®k, jlL¥−el B¢j−el h¡¢s−a osk−¿»l gmnЦ¢a−a
AeÉ¡eÉ Bp¡j£l¡ jqmpq AeÉ¡eÉ−cl Efl H−m¡f¡b¡¢s …¢mhoÑZ L−l, k¡l
gmnЦ¢a−a Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l J Jjl g¡l¦L lae OVe¡l pju ¢eqa qu Hhw
j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e jqmpq A−e−LC Bqa quz
¢h‘ ¢p¢eul BCeS£h£ Se¡h Hj. B¢jl¦m Cpm¡j Hhw ¢h‘ ¢p¢eul
BCeS£h£ Se¡h Bë¥m j¢ae Mpl¦l Ef−l E−õ¢Ma hš²hÉ Bc¡m−al L¡−R
¢h−hQe¡−k¡NÉz HL¢c−L l¡S¯e¢aL fТa¢qwp¡, Afl¢c−L l¡S¯e¢aL rja¡
hc−ml p¡−b p¡−b °hd, A¯hd hÉhp¡l B¢dfaÉ NËq−Zl fТa−k¡¢Na¡l Afpwúª¢a
®b−L ®hl q−u Bp¡l m−rÉ, fcÑ¡l A¿¹l¡−m ®b−L ®kph osk¿»L¡l£l¡ osk−¿»l
j§m ®q¡a¡ Hhw ¢e−cÑnc¡a¡ ¢q−p−h fÐL¡nÉ Sepi¡−L OVe¡ÙÛm ¢q−p−h ¢ehÑ¡¢Qa
L−l, qaÉ¡l osk¿» h¡Ù¹h¡ue L®l, Hph ®r−œ fÐj¡Z p¡−f−r, HC pLm
osk¿»L¡l£l¡ LM−e¡C Bc¡m−al ®L¡e Ae¤LÇf¡ ®f−a A¢dL¡l£ eu j−jÑ ¢pÜ¡−¿¹
B¢pz
p‰a L¡l−ZC Ef−l¡š² B−m¡Qe¡l B−m¡−L ¢pÜ¡−¿¹ B¢p ®k, B¡p¡j£ e¤l¦m
Cpm¡j plL¡−ll p¢œ²u AwnNËqZ Hhw ®ea«−aÅ jqm−L c¤¢eu¡ ®b−L p¢l−u ®ch¡l
SeÉ ®k osk¿» pi¡¢V q−u¢Rm, ®pM¡−e HC osk¿» L¡kÑLl Ll¡l SeÉ OVe¡ÙÛm¢V
¢ehÑ¡Qe Ll¡ q−u¢Rm HC c¤l¢ip¢å−aC ®k, ®p¢ce ®pM¡−e pi¡ÙÛ−m, j−’ ¢eqa
177
Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡lpq pi¡j−’l Ef−l J j−’l h¡C−l fÐQ¤l ®m¡L ¢eqa qh¡l
pñ¡he¡ ¢Rmz Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j plL¡l HLSe l¡Se£¢a¢hc q−u Hhw HC
pj¡−Sl HLSe fТa¢ùa h¤¢ÜpÇfæ hÉ¢š² q−u f§hÑ¡fl pLm AhÙÛ¡ Efm¢ì−a
H−eC pÇf§ZÑ p−Qaei¡−hC OVe¡ÙÛm¢V ¢ehÑ¡Qe L−l¢R−me, ®ke a¡l l¡S¯e¢aL
fТaà¾cÄ£ Hhw A¯hd hÉhp¡l fТaà¾cÄ£ c¤Se−LC c¤¢eu¡ ®b−L p¢l−u ®cu¡ k¡uz
¢L¿º i¡−NÉl ¢ejÑj f¢lq¡p, l¡S¯e¢aL EµQ¡¢im¡p J A¯hd hÉhp¡l V¡e¡−f¡s−e
qai¡NÉ 17 hRl huú al¦Z Jjl g¡l¦L lae ¢eqa qu, ¢eqa qu VwN£l
A¢hpwh¡¢ca ®ea¡ Bqp¡e Eõ¡q j¡ø¡l Hj,¢f, f‰¥aÅ hlZ L−l j¡qg¥S¤l lqj¡e
jqm, Bqa qu ®hn¢LR¤ hÉ¢š² Bl i¡NÉœ²−j ®hy−Q k¡u ®p¢ceL¡l j−’ J j−’l
h¡C−l b¡L¡ hq§ i¡NÉh¡ez
AaHh, Ef−l¡š² B−m¡Qe¡l B−m¡−L ¢pÜ¡−¿¹ B¢p ®k, OVe¡l ¢ce,
OVe¡ÙÛ−m ®k OVe¡ O−V−R a¡l j§m f¢lLÒfe¡L¡l£ OVe¡ÙÛ−m Ef¢ÙÛa e¡ ®b−LJ
fcÑ¡l A¿¹l¡−m pjNË L¡kÑœ²j O¢V−u−R Hhw fcÑ¡l A¿¹l¡−m ®b−L osk¿»
h¡Ù¹h¡u−el Hl¦f ÙÛ¡e ¢ehÑ¡Q−el ¢hou¢V (®kM¡−e hq§ SeN−Zl S£h−el q§jL£
b¡−L) LM−e¡C …l¦aÅq£e q−a f¡−l e¡z HC Afpwúª¢a ®b−L ®hl q−u Bp¡l
m−rÉC HC A¢i−k¡−Nl j§m osk¿»L¡l£, ¢k¢e fcÑ¡l A¿¹l¡−m ®b−L HC qaÉ¡L¡ä
O¢V−u−Re ¢a¢e ®L¡e Ae¤LÇf¡ ®f−a f¡−le e¡ Hhw ü£L«a j−aC OVe¡ÙÛ−m
Ef¢ÙÛa e¡ b¡L−mJ cªø¡¿¹j§mL n¡¢Ù¹ f¡h¡l ®k¡NÉ, ®ke i¢hoÉ−a osk¿»L¡l£l¡ H
dl−el Afl¡d pwOV−e ¢e−S−cl ¢hla l¡−Mz
AaHh, ¢pÜ¡−¿¹ B¢p ®k, ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡ma p¢WLi¡−hC HC Bp¡j£−L h¢ZÑa
d¡l¡u jªa¤Écä¡−cn fÐc¡e L−l−Rez
178
AaHh, cä¢h¢dl 302/120M/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥ÉcäfСç Bp¡j£ e¤l¦m Cpm¡j
plL¡−ll jªa¥Écä¡−cn¢V hq¡m b¡−L j−jÑ ¢pÜ¡¿¹ quz
cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥ÉcäfСç Bp¡j£ Bm-B¢je Hhw lae Jl−g
®R¡V lae pÇf−LÑ B−m¡Qe¡ J ¢pÜ¡¿¹ x
`Ûwewai 302/34 d¡l¡u jªa¥Écä fСç Bp¡j£ Bm-B¢je J lae Jl−g
®R¡V lae †W_ †idv‡iÝ PjvKvjxb mg‡q g„Zz eiZ K‡i‡Q g‡g© †Rj LaѪfr
HC Bc¡ma−L AhNa L−lz HC AhÙÛ¡u jªa¥ÉcäfСç Bp¡j£ Avj Avwgb I iZb
Ii‡d †QvU la−el ®Xb ®lg¡−l¾p¢V J a¡−cl c¡−ulL«a −Sm Bf£m ew
1189/2006 q−a Eá¥a ®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew 2862/2007 J ®Sm Bf£m ew
959/2007 ¢eÖf¢š j−jÑ NeÉ quz
B−l¡ E−õMÉ ®k, cä¢h¢dl 302/34 d¡l¡u k¡h‹£he L¡l¡c−ä c¢äa
Bp¡j£ A¢qc¤m Cpm¡j ¢Vf¤l ®L¡e Bf£m e¡ b¡L¡u H Bp¡j£ pÇf−LÑ ®L¡e
B−cn ®cu¡ q−m¡ e¡z
AÎ Av‡`k nq †h,
GB †W_ †idv‡iÝwU AvswkK M„nxZ (accepted in part) nq|
`Ûwewai 302/120L/34 avivq g„Zz `ÛcÖvß Avmvgx- (1) e¤l¦m Bmjvg
miKvi, (2) e¤l¦m Bmjvg ¢cf¤ Hhw (3) gvneyeyi ingvb gvneye Jl−g j¡qh¤h
i¥Cu¡ Jl−g j¡qh¤h Gi −Xb ®lg¡−l¾p M„nxZ (accepted) nq| Avmvgx e¤l¦m
Bmjvg miKvi J Bp¡j£ gvneyeyi ingvb gvneye Jl−g j¡qh¤h i¥Cu¡ Jl−g
j¡qh¤h LaѪL c¡−ulL«a kb¡œ²−j ®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew 1739/2005 J ®Sm
179
Bf£m ew 409/2005, −g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew 1513/2005 J ®Sm Bf£m ew
410/2005 e¡-j”¤l quz
`Ûwewai 302/120L/34 avivq g„Zz `ÛcÖvß (4) ‰mq` Avn‡g` gRby‡K
g„Zz `‡Ûi cwie‡Z© (Commute) hve¾xeb Kviv`Û I 50,000/- nvRvi UvKv
Rwigvbv Abv`v‡q Av‡iv 01(HL) eQ‡ii mkÖg Kviv`‡Û `wÛZ Kiv nq|
`Ûwewai 302/120L/34 avivq g„Zz `ÛcÖvß Bp¡j£ (5) †gvn¡¤§`
Avjx‡K `Ûwewai 120L/34 avivq hve¾xeb Kviv`Û I 50,000/- (f’¡n
nvRvi) UvKv Rwigvbv Abv`v‡q Av‡iv 01(HL) eQ‡ii mkÖg Kviv`‡Û `wÛZ
Kiv nq| HC Bp¡j£ LaѪL c¡−ulL«a ®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew 1572/2005 J ®Sm
Bf£m ew 412/2005 e¡-j”¤l œ²−j Ef−l¡š² cä¡−cn ®cu¡ quz
`Ûwewai 302/120L/34 avivq g„Zz `Û cÖvß Avmvgx (6) Avwgi Jl−g
B¢jl ®q¡−pe I (7) Rvnv½xi Ii‡d eo Rvnv½xi Jl−g juje¢pwq¡ S¡q¡‰£l
wcZv b~i †nv‡mb Gi g„Zy `Ûv‡`k i`iwn‡Z †eKmyi Lvjvp †`qv nq| Ab¨ ‡Kvb
gvgjvq cÖ‡qvRb bv n‡j Avmvgx Avwgi Jl−g B¢jl ®q¡−pe I Bp¡j£ Rvnv½xi
Ii‡d eo Rvnv½xi Jl−g juje¢pwq¡ S¡q¡‰£l wcZv b~i ‡nv‡mbÕ‡K Awej‡¤
gyw³ †`qv ‡nvK| HC Bp¡j£−cl c¡−ulL«a kb¡œ²−j ®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew
1844/2005 J ®Sm Bf£m ew 414/2005, ®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew 1813/2005
J ®Sm Bf£m ew 413/2005 j”¤l quz
`Ûwewai 302/120L/34 avivq hve¾xeb `ÛcÖvß (8) l¡¢Lh E¢Ÿe
plL¡l Ii‡d cvày miKvi, (9) AvBqye Avjx J (10) Rvnv½xi Jl−g ®j¡x
180
S¡q¡‰£l Bmj wcZv †g‡ni Avjxi `Ûv‡`k i`iwn‡Z †eKmyi Lvjvm †`qv nq|
Ab¨ †Kvb gvgjvq cÖ‡qvRb bv n‡j Avmvgx l¡¢Lh¤¢Ÿe plL¡l Ii‡d cvày
miKvi, AvBqye Avjx, Rvnv½xi Jl−g ®j¡x S¡q¡‰£l Bmj wcZv †g‡ni Avjx’†K
Awej‡¤ gyw³ †`qv †nvK| Avmvgx l¡¢Lh¤¢Ÿe plL¡l Ii‡d cvày miKvi J
Bp¡j£ AvBqye Avjx LaѪL c¡−ulL«a ®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew 1515/2005 Hhw
Bp¡j£ S¡q¡‰£l Jl−g ®j¡x S¡q¡‰£l Bmj ¢fa¡ ®j−ql Bm£ LaѪL c¡−ulL«a
®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew 1845/2005 j”¤l quz
`Ûwewai 302/ 120L/34 avivq hve¾xeb `ÛcÖvß Avmvgx (11) e¤l¦m
Avwgb Jl−g B¢je Gi hve¾xeb Kviv`Û 120L/ 34 avivq envj _v‡K| HC
Bp¡j£ LaѪL c¡−ulL«a ®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew 1515/2005 e¡-j”¤l quz
`Ûwewai 302/34 avivq g„Zz `ÛcÖvß Avmvgx (12) kwn yj Bmjvg wkcy,
(13) nvwdR Ii‡d Kvbv nvwdR J (14) †mvnvM Ii‡d pl¦ Gi −Xb ®lg¡−l¾p
M„nxZ (accepted) nq| HC Bp¡j£−cl c¡−ulL«a kb¡œ²−j ®g±Sc¡l£ ¢h¢hd
j¡jm¡ ew 10842/2006, −Sm Bf£m ew 295/2007 J ®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew
1703/2005 p¡−b ®Sm Bf£m ew 411/2005 e¡-j”¤l quz
`Ûwewai 302/34 avivq g„Zz `ÛcÖvß Avmvgx (15) Av‡bvqvi †nv‡mb
Avby, (16) iZb ¢ju¡ Jl−g hs ¢ju¡ Jl−g lae Ii‡d eo iZb, (17)
Rvnv½xi wcZv Kv‡kg j¡chl, (18) Avey mvjvg Ii‡d mvjvg Hhw (19) gwkDi
ingvb gï‡K g„Zz `‡Ûi cwie‡Z© (Commute) hve¾xeb Kviv`Û I
50,000/- (f’¡n nvRvi) UvKv Rwigvbv Abv`v‡q Av‡iv 01 (HL) eQ‡ii mkÖg
181
Kviv`‡Û `wÛZ Kiv nq| Bp¡j£ iZb ¢ju¡ Jl−g hs ¢ju¡ Jl−g lae Ii‡d
eo iZb J Bp¡j£ Avey mvjvg Ii‡d mvjvg LaѪL c¡−ulL«a kb¡œ²−j ®Sm
Bf£m ew 139/2010 q−a Eá¥a ®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew 8330/2010 J
®g±Sc¡l£ ¢h¢hd j¡jm¡ ew 14222/2015, ®Sm Bf£m ew 1322/2005 e¡-j”¤l
quz
`Ûwewal 302/34 avivq g„Zz `ÛcÖvß Avmvgx (20) dqmvj, (21)
†jvKgvb †nv‡mb Ii‡d h¤m¤ ¢ju¡, (22) iwb ¢ju¡ Ii‡d iwb g¢Ll, (23) †LvKb
Hhw (24) yjvj wgu¡’l g„Zz `Ûv‡`k i`iwn‡Z †eKmyi Lvjvm †`qv nq| Ab¨
‡Kvb gvgjvq cÖ‡qvRb bv n‡j Avmvgx gup¡m, †jvKgvb †nv‡mb Jl−g h¤m¤, iwb
wguv Jl−g l¢e g¢Ll, †LvKb Hhw yjvj wguv‡K Awej‡¤ gyw³ †`qv ‡nvK|
Bp¡j£ ®m¡Lj¡e ®q¡−pe Jl−g h¤m¤ J Bp¡j£ c¤m¡m ¢ju¡ LaѪL c¡−ulL«a
kb¡œ²−j ®g±Sc¡l£ ¢h¢hd j¡jm¡ ew 41411/2014 J ®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew
1452/2005, ®Sm Bf£m ew 415/2005 j”¤l quz
`Ûwewai 302/34 avivq hve¾xeb L¡l¡cä cÖvß Avmvgx (25) gwbi‡K
hve¾xeb Kviv`‡Ûi Av‡`k i`iwn‡Z †eKmyi Lvjvm †`qv nq| Ab¨ †Kvb
gvgjvq cÖ‡qvRb bv n‡j Avmvgx gwbi‡K Awej‡¤ gyw³ †`qv †nvK| HC Bp¡j£
LaѪL c¡−ulL«a ®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew 1808/2005 j”¤l quz
`Ûwewai 302/34 avivq g„Zz `Û cÖvß Avmvgx (26) Avj Avwgb I
(27) iZb Ii‡d †QvU iZb †W_ †idv‡iÝ PjvKvjxb mg‡q g„Zz eiZ K‡i‡Q
g‡g© †Rj LaѪfr AeMZ Kivq Bp¡j£ Avj Avwgb I Bp¡j£ iZb Ii‡d †QvU
182
iZb Gi †W_ †idv‡iÝwU wb®úwË g‡g© Mb¨ nq| HC Bp¡j£NZ jªa¥ÉhlZ Ll¡u
c¡−ulL«a kb¡œ²−j ®Sm Bf£m ew 959/2007 J ®Sm Bf£m ew 1189/2006
q−a Eá¥a ®g±Sc¡l£ Bf£m ew 2862/2007 ¢eÖf¢š j−jÑ NeÉ quz
`Ûwewai 302/34 avivq hve¾xeb Kviv`‡Û `wÛZ Avmvgx (28)
Awn yj Bmjvg wUcyi †Kvb Avcxj bv _vKvq D³ Avmvgx m¤ú‡K© †Kvb Av‡`k
†`qv n‡jv bv|
HC l¡−ul Ae¤¢m¢f L.C.R pq ¢h‘ ¢ejÀ Bc¡m−a Hr¥¢e ®fËlZ Ll¡
−q¡L z
¢hQ¡lf¢a Jh¡uc¤m q¡p¡e.
B¢j HLja z
−j¡x B¢lg¤m Cpm¡j M¡e pqL¡l£ ®h’ A¢gp¡l