the association of carbonate minerals to acidic ... · of carbonates below a ph of ~4.5. however,...

2
THE ASSOCIATION OF CARBONATE MINERALS TO ACIDIC ENVIRONMENTS: A POSSIBLE BIOSIGNATURE FOR MARS. D. C. Fernández-Remolar 1 , M. Sánchez-Román 2 , N. Rodríguez, R. Amils 1 and C. Romanek 2 , 1 Centro de Astrobiología (INTA-CSIC), Torrejón de Ardoz, 28850 Spain, [email protected], 2 Department of Geology, University of Georgia, Athens GA, 30602: [email protected] and [email protected]. Introduction: Carbonate production is thermodynamically inhibited under low-pH conditions. More specifically, in most terrestrial environments, neither abiotic or biotic pathways favor the production of carbonates below a pH of ~4.5. However, carbonate minerals have been recognized associated to extremely acidic environments of Río Tinto, Spain. The mineralogical similarity of these deposits at Rio Tinto and those in the Meridiani region of Mars suggest that carbonates may be more widespread on Mars than originally thought. Carbonates in the subsurface of Rio Tinto: (1) Carbonates occur in subsurface deposits associated with hydrothermal sulfides (primarily pyrite) in two boreholes (4 and 8) that feed the acidic headwaters of Peña de Hierro [1]. At these locations, highly-fractured Carboniferous volcanosedimentary deposits (sedimentary shale and hydrothermal silica) host platy-like rounded carbonate structures covered in some cases by spheroidal objects, as well as rhomboidal cements. EDS microanalyses of these materials show that they are composed of phosphorus- bearing Fe-carbonate. (2) Carbonates of ankerite-like composition (Fe- Ca-Mg carbonates) have been found associated with fractured shales (borehole 1) that cover the hydrothermal complex sourcing of the microbially dominated acidic waters of Río Tinto [1]. In some cases, the fractures are filled by carbonate-bearing aggregates having fibrous microtextures, but isolated rombohedral carbonate crystals composed of Fe, Mg and Ca (Fig. 1) and infilling microcavities have also been observed. (3) Carbonate structures have been recognized in the 2 Ma old terrace deposits of the Río Tinto fluvial system. They are comprised of rhombohedral crystals that fill the porous regions of biological remains. Microscope observations show that filamentous structures are occluded in the crystals and that these are sub-perpendicular to crystal faces. The occurrence of carbonates in the three different subsurface settings suggests mildly acidic to neutral pH (~ 5-7) and somewhat reducing (Eh < 0) conditions. Water samples obtained in the Peña de Hierro aquifers support the existence of mildly acidic to neutral ferrous solutions that have seasonally high concentrations of carbon dioxide, which favor the precipitation of Fe-bearing carbonates. In addition, the diagenetical history of the ancient terrace indicates that mildly to neutral conditions are reached through the input of meteoric water leading to Fe +2 -carbonates precipitation. Microbial mediation of Río Tinto subsurface carbonates: Although the carbon source for dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC) is not well known, several biogeochemical pathways can be suggested to explain its high concentration in the subsurfaces. In the aquifer hosted by volcanosedimentary deposits, the concentration of aqueous CO2 can seasonally reach 100-150 ppm during the wet seasons [1, 2] when rainfall carries O2-rich meteoric fluids into the subsuface. Iron and sulfur oxidation by microbial activity decreases the pH and shifts the equilibrium concentration of DIC to the aqueous CO2 field. Based on all the exponded above, bicarbonate is the most predominant DIC specie during the dry season. Thus, the geochemical conditions that prevail in this area, at least sesasonally [2], favor the precipitation of Fe-rich carbonates at Río Tinto system. The presence of sulfate reducing bacteria (SRB) that oxidize organic matter (or compounds) [1, 3] would induce the precipitation of carbonate minerals in the subsurface by increasing the DIC in the aquifer. This bacterial oxidation of organic matter may also explain the presence of phosphorous associated with the platy-like microstructures found in the Peña de Hierro boreholes 4 and 8 [1]. Furthermore, the occurrence of rombohedral crystals and abundant carbonate infillings of fractured shale and the pH (~6.5) lead us to conclude that microbial activity may play an important role in the precipitation of these ankerite-like composition carbonates. Indeed, the neutralization of subsurface solutions is promoted by microorganisms (iron and sulfate reducers), thus, the potential exists that those carbonates were microbiologically mediated. On the other hand, there is an absence of sulfate in the ancient iron-rich terraces of Río Tinto. In this case, methane and organic matter oxidation though the ferric reduction (e.g., by Acidiphilium sp.) [4] are possible processes that introduce DIC into subsurface fluids. Carbonates in materials derived from acidic environments as posible biosignatures: The occurrence of Ca-Mg carbonates in Earth’s surface environments may be interpreted within the context of mineral biosignatures [4] to search for life in other 1214.pdf 40th Lunar and Planetary Science Conference (2009)

Upload: others

Post on 07-Oct-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: THE ASSOCIATION OF CARBONATE MINERALS TO ACIDIC ... · of carbonates below a pH of ~4.5. However, carbonate minerals have been recognized associated to extremely acidic environments

THE ASSOCIATION OF CARBONATE MINERALS TO ACIDIC ENVIRONMENTS: A POSSIBLE BIOSIGNATURE FOR MARS. D. C. Fernández-Remolar1, M. Sánchez-Román2, N. Rodríguez, R. Amils1 and C. Romanek2, 1Centro de Astrobiología (INTA-CSIC), Torrejón de Ardoz, 28850 Spain, [email protected], 2Department of Geology, University of Georgia, Athens GA, 30602: [email protected] and [email protected].

Introduction: Carbonate production is thermodynamically inhibited under low-pH conditions. More specifically, in most terrestrial environments, neither abiotic or biotic pathways favor the production of carbonates below a pH of ~4.5. However, carbonate minerals have been recognized associated to extremely acidic environments of Río Tinto, Spain. The mineralogical similarity of these deposits at Rio Tinto and those in the Meridiani region of Mars suggest that carbonates may be more widespread on Mars than originally thought.

Carbonates in the subsurface of Rio Tinto: (1) Carbonates occur in subsurface deposits

associated with hydrothermal sulfides (primarily pyrite) in two boreholes (4 and 8) that feed the acidic headwaters of Peña de Hierro [1]. At these locations, highly-fractured Carboniferous volcanosedimentary deposits (sedimentary shale and hydrothermal silica) host platy-like rounded carbonate structures covered in some cases by spheroidal objects, as well as rhomboidal cements. EDS microanalyses of these materials show that they are composed of phosphorus-bearing Fe-carbonate.

(2) Carbonates of ankerite-like composition (Fe-Ca-Mg carbonates) have been found associated with fractured shales (borehole 1) that cover the hydrothermal complex sourcing of the microbially dominated acidic waters of Río Tinto [1]. In some cases, the fractures are filled by carbonate-bearing aggregates having fibrous microtextures, but isolated rombohedral carbonate crystals composed of Fe, Mg and Ca (Fig. 1) and infilling microcavities have also been observed.

(3) Carbonate structures have been recognized in the 2 Ma old terrace deposits of the Río Tinto fluvial system. They are comprised of rhombohedral crystals that fill the porous regions of biological remains. Microscope observations show that filamentous structures are occluded in the crystals and that these are sub-perpendicular to crystal faces.

The occurrence of carbonates in the three different subsurface settings suggests mildly acidic to neutral pH (~ 5-7) and somewhat reducing (Eh < 0) conditions. Water samples obtained in the Peña de Hierro aquifers support the existence of mildly acidic to neutral ferrous solutions that have seasonally high concentrations of carbon dioxide, which favor the precipitation of Fe-bearing carbonates. In addition, the

diagenetical history of the ancient terrace indicates that mildly to neutral conditions are reached through the input of meteoric water leading to Fe+2-carbonates precipitation.

Microbial mediation of Río Tinto subsurface carbonates: Although the carbon source for dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC) is not well known, several biogeochemical pathways can be suggested to explain its high concentration in the subsurfaces. In the aquifer hosted by volcanosedimentary deposits, the concentration of aqueous CO2 can seasonally reach 100-150 ppm during the wet seasons [1, 2] when rainfall carries O2-rich meteoric fluids into the subsuface. Iron and sulfur oxidation by microbial activity decreases the pH and shifts the equilibrium concentration of DIC to the aqueous CO2 field. Based on all the exponded above, bicarbonate is the most predominant DIC specie during the dry season. Thus, the geochemical conditions that prevail in this area, at least sesasonally [2], favor the precipitation of Fe-rich carbonates at Río Tinto system.

The presence of sulfate reducing bacteria (SRB) that oxidize organic matter (or compounds) [1, 3] would induce the precipitation of carbonate minerals in the subsurface by increasing the DIC in the aquifer. This bacterial oxidation of organic matter may also explain the presence of phosphorous associated with the platy-like microstructures found in the Peña de Hierro boreholes 4 and 8 [1]. Furthermore, the occurrence of rombohedral crystals and abundant carbonate infillings of fractured shale and the pH (~6.5) lead us to conclude that microbial activity may play an important role in the precipitation of these ankerite-like composition carbonates. Indeed, the neutralization of subsurface solutions is promoted by microorganisms (iron and sulfate reducers), thus, the potential exists that those carbonates were microbiologically mediated.

On the other hand, there is an absence of sulfate in the ancient iron-rich terraces of Río Tinto. In this case, methane and organic matter oxidation though the ferric reduction (e.g., by Acidiphilium sp.) [4] are possible processes that introduce DIC into subsurface fluids.

Carbonates in materials derived from acidic environments as posible biosignatures: The occurrence of Ca-Mg carbonates in Earth’s surface environments may be interpreted within the context of mineral biosignatures [4] to search for life in other

1214.pdf40th Lunar and Planetary Science Conference (2009)

Page 2: THE ASSOCIATION OF CARBONATE MINERALS TO ACIDIC ... · of carbonates below a pH of ~4.5. However, carbonate minerals have been recognized associated to extremely acidic environments

planets whether used with other traces as organics, structures or isotopic. The occurrence of Fe-Ca-Mg carbonates in subsurface regions of the late Noachian-Hesperian materials in Mars formed under acidic conditions [5], should not be overlooked that can be a first-step exploration procedure to look for right in the investigation and exploration of biomarkers that can support the presence of extant or extinct life on Mars.

Acknowledgements: This paper was supported by the Project ESP2006-09487 funded by the Ministry of Science and Education of Spain.

References: [1] Fernández-Remolar D. C. et al. (2008) Astrobiology, 8(5), 1151–1154. [2] Fernández-Remolar et al (2003) JGR, 108(E7), 5080. [3] van Lith Y. et al. Geobiology, 1, 71-79. [4] Sánchez-Román M. et al. (2008) Geology, 32, 879-882. [5] Squyres S. W. et al. (2004) Science, 306, 1709-1714.

Figure 1. SEM image and EDS microanalysis of a rhombohedralcrystal found in Borehole 1 [1].

1214.pdf40th Lunar and Planetary Science Conference (2009)