terminologie utilisateur, terminologie...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface,cispclub.org/cispclub/docs/14/000288/0000705.pdf · Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface, Terminologies de référence,](https://reader030.vdocuments.fr/reader030/viewer/2022013104/5b9636b509d3f2d0248b709d/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface, Terminologies de référence, et Terminologie d’ agrégation le projet MERITERM
CISP Club , Rouen, 16 octobre, 2015 Robert Vander Stichele, Département d’ Informatique médicale, EuroRec,
Université de Gand, Belgique
![Page 2: Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface,cispclub.org/cispclub/docs/14/000288/0000705.pdf · Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface, Terminologies de référence,](https://reader030.vdocuments.fr/reader030/viewer/2022013104/5b9636b509d3f2d0248b709d/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Déclaration de conflit d’ interêt Je suis médecin généraliste, pratiquant dans la ville de Gand, Belgique Je suis pharmacologue clinique, professeur à l’ Université de Gand Je travaille sur des projets Européens (FP7 et H2020), dans le cadre :
• un service universitaire d’ informatique médicale (RAMIT) • une association Européenne de marchands de logiciels médicaux (EuroRec)
![Page 3: Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface,cispclub.org/cispclub/docs/14/000288/0000705.pdf · Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface, Terminologies de référence,](https://reader030.vdocuments.fr/reader030/viewer/2022013104/5b9636b509d3f2d0248b709d/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
![Page 4: Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface,cispclub.org/cispclub/docs/14/000288/0000705.pdf · Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface, Terminologies de référence,](https://reader030.vdocuments.fr/reader030/viewer/2022013104/5b9636b509d3f2d0248b709d/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Acknowledgements of co-workers Elena Cardillo Joseph Roumier Marc Jamoulle Maxime Warnier Dirk Van Nimwegen
![Page 5: Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface,cispclub.org/cispclub/docs/14/000288/0000705.pdf · Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface, Terminologies de référence,](https://reader030.vdocuments.fr/reader030/viewer/2022013104/5b9636b509d3f2d0248b709d/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
“Investigation starts with a problem” Karl Popper International reference terminologies are in English. Health care worker have the fundamental right to work, document, practice continuing education, search for point of care EBM information IN THEIR MOTHER TONGUE LANGUAGE. Evidence shows that it provides a more efficient information flow. Many E-health engineers and medical informaticians speak of semantic interoperability, as if English is the only language in the world.
![Page 6: Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface,cispclub.org/cispclub/docs/14/000288/0000705.pdf · Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface, Terminologies de référence,](https://reader030.vdocuments.fr/reader030/viewer/2022013104/5b9636b509d3f2d0248b709d/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Objective
Provide a hybrid healthcare interface terminology capable of automatically linking patients’ and physicians’ medical words to the corresponding concept(s) in international classifications
That includes:
1. A conceptual reference terminology
– Multidisciplinary, multilingual – Restricted to reference concepts – Linked to international nomenclatures, thesauri, classifications, ontologies
2. A series of specific end-user lexicons
– One for each language – Bridged to the reference terminology – Connected to rich linguistic corpora for NLP
‘‘Systematic collection of healthcare-related phrases (terms) to support clinicians’ entries of patient-related information into computer programs …”
Rosembloom et al, 2006
6
![Page 7: Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface,cispclub.org/cispclub/docs/14/000288/0000705.pdf · Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface, Terminologies de référence,](https://reader030.vdocuments.fr/reader030/viewer/2022013104/5b9636b509d3f2d0248b709d/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Terminology : What’s in a name ?
End-user Terminology in language X
Reference Terminology in language X
Interface Terminology In language X
Reference Terminologies
in English
SNOMED-CT UMLS MeSH
Aggregate Terminologies
in English
ICD ICPC ATC ICF
Nomenclatures Thesauri
Classifications
![Page 8: Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface,cispclub.org/cispclub/docs/14/000288/0000705.pdf · Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface, Terminologies de référence,](https://reader030.vdocuments.fr/reader030/viewer/2022013104/5b9636b509d3f2d0248b709d/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Word
Sense 1
Sense 2
Concept
(n = 1)
Term
![Page 9: Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface,cispclub.org/cispclub/docs/14/000288/0000705.pdf · Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface, Terminologies de référence,](https://reader030.vdocuments.fr/reader030/viewer/2022013104/5b9636b509d3f2d0248b709d/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Approach
Interface Terminology
End-user Lexicons Reference Terminology
18/10/2015 9 Terminologie et Intelligence Artificielle - TIA
2013, Paris
Word
Sense 1
Sense 2
Concept
(n = 1)
Term
![Page 10: Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface,cispclub.org/cispclub/docs/14/000288/0000705.pdf · Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface, Terminologies de référence,](https://reader030.vdocuments.fr/reader030/viewer/2022013104/5b9636b509d3f2d0248b709d/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
The Lemon core structure of a lexical terminology
The ISO-Norm LMF : Lexical Markup Framework (ISO 24613)
![Page 11: Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface,cispclub.org/cispclub/docs/14/000288/0000705.pdf · Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface, Terminologies de référence,](https://reader030.vdocuments.fr/reader030/viewer/2022013104/5b9636b509d3f2d0248b709d/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
The ISO-Norm TMF : Terminological Markup Framework (ISO 16642)
![Page 12: Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface,cispclub.org/cispclub/docs/14/000288/0000705.pdf · Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface, Terminologies de référence,](https://reader030.vdocuments.fr/reader030/viewer/2022013104/5b9636b509d3f2d0248b709d/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Lemon/LMF-based End-user Lexicons • ISO 24613 - Language Markup Framework (LMF)
as a Requirement for the Lexicon • Use of the Lemon model (LExicon Model for
ONtologies) because: – Based on LMF – RDF-native model – Easy to link to data category registries (ISOcat) – The sense of a lexical entry can be defined by a reference to an
external resource (E.g. our TMF-based resource) – More powerful and less verbose than the LMF model – http://lemon-model.net/ (McCrae et al.)
The Lemon core
18/10/2015 12 Terminologie et Intelligence Artificielle - TIA
2013, Paris
![Page 13: Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface,cispclub.org/cispclub/docs/14/000288/0000705.pdf · Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface, Terminologies de référence,](https://reader030.vdocuments.fr/reader030/viewer/2022013104/5b9636b509d3f2d0248b709d/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
TMF-based Reference Terminology
• ISO 16642: Terminological Markup Framework
Resource
Concept
Language
Term
Term components
• ISO 12620 and ISOcat Data categories registry
10/18/2015 13 Terminologies et Intelligence Artificielle -
TIA 2013, Paris
![Page 14: Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface,cispclub.org/cispclub/docs/14/000288/0000705.pdf · Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface, Terminologies de référence,](https://reader030.vdocuments.fr/reader030/viewer/2022013104/5b9636b509d3f2d0248b709d/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
TMF-based Reference Terminology
![Page 15: Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface,cispclub.org/cispclub/docs/14/000288/0000705.pdf · Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface, Terminologies de référence,](https://reader030.vdocuments.fr/reader030/viewer/2022013104/5b9636b509d3f2d0248b709d/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Architecture
Nomenclatures
Thesauri &
Metathesauri
Ontologies
Multilingual Reference
Terminology
Classifications
Interface Terminology Service External Reference
Sources
End-user Lexicon L1
End-user Lexicon L2
End-user Lexicon L3
External Reference Sources
Linguistic Corpus in L3
Linguistic Corpus in L1
Linguistic Corpus in L2
LMF/Lemon – TMF Connection NLP Connection Conceptual linking
TMF (ISO 16642) LMF (ISO 24613)
18/10/2015 15 Terminologie et Intelligence Artificielle - TIA
2013, Paris
![Page 16: Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface,cispclub.org/cispclub/docs/14/000288/0000705.pdf · Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface, Terminologies de référence,](https://reader030.vdocuments.fr/reader030/viewer/2022013104/5b9636b509d3f2d0248b709d/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Architecture
Nomenclatures
Thesauri &
Metathesauri
Ontologies
Multilingual Reference
Terminology
Classifications
Interface Terminology Service External Reference
Sources
End-user Lexicon L1
End-user Lexicon L2
End-user Lexicon L3
External Reference Sources
Linguistic Corpus in L3
Linguistic Corpus in L1
Linguistic Corpus in L2
LMF/Lemon – TMF Connection NLP Connection Conceptual linking
TMF (ISO 16642) LMF (ISO 24613)
18/10/2015 16 Terminologie et Intelligence Artificielle - TIA
2013, Paris
BABELNET
![Page 17: Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface,cispclub.org/cispclub/docs/14/000288/0000705.pdf · Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface, Terminologies de référence,](https://reader030.vdocuments.fr/reader030/viewer/2022013104/5b9636b509d3f2d0248b709d/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Lexical terminologies
ISO – Standard LMF (ISO 24613) Lexicons Dictonaries, Glossaries, Vocabularies Babelnet (www.babelnet.org)
Conceptual terminologies ISO – Standard TMF (ISO 16642)
Controlled Vocabularies Nomenclatures Classifications
International standards for multilingual terminologies
![Page 18: Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface,cispclub.org/cispclub/docs/14/000288/0000705.pdf · Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface, Terminologies de référence,](https://reader030.vdocuments.fr/reader030/viewer/2022013104/5b9636b509d3f2d0248b709d/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Fig 5. Resources and tools
![Page 19: Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface,cispclub.org/cispclub/docs/14/000288/0000705.pdf · Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface, Terminologies de référence,](https://reader030.vdocuments.fr/reader030/viewer/2022013104/5b9636b509d3f2d0248b709d/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Site manager Concept manager Concept committee Lexical managers Language 1 team Language 2 team Language 3 team … … Language n team
Publication platform
Edition platform
CSV, EXCEL, SQL, RDF
Dissemination and Translation Website for a multilingual interface terminology
End-user (Human consultation) Web services (SQL, OWL)
![Page 20: Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface,cispclub.org/cispclub/docs/14/000288/0000705.pdf · Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface, Terminologies de référence,](https://reader030.vdocuments.fr/reader030/viewer/2022013104/5b9636b509d3f2d0248b709d/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Existing end-user terminologies in General Practice ICPC-PLUS (Australia) 3BT (Belgique) Belgian, Bilingual, Bicoded 300.000 words and phrases, of which 45.000 double coded to ICD and ICPC
![Page 21: Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface,cispclub.org/cispclub/docs/14/000288/0000705.pdf · Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface, Terminologies de référence,](https://reader030.vdocuments.fr/reader030/viewer/2022013104/5b9636b509d3f2d0248b709d/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Woord
ICD
ICPC
Mot
3BT Belgian Bicoded Bilingual Thesaurus
IBUI
![Page 22: Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface,cispclub.org/cispclub/docs/14/000288/0000705.pdf · Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface, Terminologies de référence,](https://reader030.vdocuments.fr/reader030/viewer/2022013104/5b9636b509d3f2d0248b709d/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Woord
ICD
ICPC
Mot
3BT Belgian Bicoded Bilingual Thesaurus
IBUI International Reference Terminology SNOMED-CT
![Page 23: Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface,cispclub.org/cispclub/docs/14/000288/0000705.pdf · Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface, Terminologies de référence,](https://reader030.vdocuments.fr/reader030/viewer/2022013104/5b9636b509d3f2d0248b709d/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Woord
ICD
ICPC
Mot
3BT Belgian Bicoded Bilingual Thesaurus
IBUI International Reference Terminology SNOMED-CT
![Page 24: Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface,cispclub.org/cispclub/docs/14/000288/0000705.pdf · Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface, Terminologies de référence,](https://reader030.vdocuments.fr/reader030/viewer/2022013104/5b9636b509d3f2d0248b709d/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Woord
ICD
ICPC
Mot
3BT Belgian Bicoded Bilingual Thesaurus + Belgian Core Set
IBUI Belgian Core set
SNOMED-CT
International Reference Terminology SNOMED-CT
![Page 25: Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface,cispclub.org/cispclub/docs/14/000288/0000705.pdf · Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface, Terminologies de référence,](https://reader030.vdocuments.fr/reader030/viewer/2022013104/5b9636b509d3f2d0248b709d/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Woord
ICD
ICPC
Mot
Medical Enduser Reference Interface Terminology (Meriterm)
IBUI Belgian Core set
SNOMED-CT
International Reference Terminology SNOMED-CT
Belgian Reference Terminology TMF
![Page 26: Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface,cispclub.org/cispclub/docs/14/000288/0000705.pdf · Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface, Terminologies de référence,](https://reader030.vdocuments.fr/reader030/viewer/2022013104/5b9636b509d3f2d0248b709d/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Woord
ICD
ICPC
Mot
Medical Enduser Reference Interface Terminology (Meriterm)
IBUI Belgian Core set
SNOMED-CT
International Reference Terminology SNOMED-CT
Belgian Reference Terminology TMF Concept Definition
Core Set Criteria Post coordination Ontological hooks
![Page 27: Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface,cispclub.org/cispclub/docs/14/000288/0000705.pdf · Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface, Terminologies de référence,](https://reader030.vdocuments.fr/reader030/viewer/2022013104/5b9636b509d3f2d0248b709d/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Woord
ICD
ICPC
Mot
Belgian Reference Terminology TMF Concept Definition
Core Set Criteria Post coordination Ontological hooks
International Classifications
Medical Enduser Reference Interface Terminology (Meriterm)
Belgian Core set
SNOMED-CT
International Reference Terminology SNOMED-CT
ICF
Loinc, ATC
…
…
…
IBUI
![Page 28: Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface,cispclub.org/cispclub/docs/14/000288/0000705.pdf · Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface, Terminologies de référence,](https://reader030.vdocuments.fr/reader030/viewer/2022013104/5b9636b509d3f2d0248b709d/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Woord
ICD
ICPC
Mot
Belgian Reference Terminology TMF Concept Definition
Core Set Criteria Post coordination Ontological hooks
Unilingual (NL) End User Terminology LMF
Unilingual (Fr) End User Terminology LMF
Sense disambiguation
Synonymy
Sense disambiguation Synonymy
International Classifications
Medical Enduser Reference Interface Terminology (Meriterm)
Belgian Core set
SNOMED-CT
International Reference Terminology SNOMED-CT
ICF
Loinc, ATC
…
…
…
IBUI
![Page 29: Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface,cispclub.org/cispclub/docs/14/000288/0000705.pdf · Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface, Terminologies de référence,](https://reader030.vdocuments.fr/reader030/viewer/2022013104/5b9636b509d3f2d0248b709d/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
For the end-user approach The choice between:
• An end-user thesaurus with translated SNOMED-CT Terms
• An end-user thesaurus linked to a
standardized Interface Terminology
![Page 30: Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface,cispclub.org/cispclub/docs/14/000288/0000705.pdf · Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface, Terminologies de référence,](https://reader030.vdocuments.fr/reader030/viewer/2022013104/5b9636b509d3f2d0248b709d/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
The context of the terminology problem In the Electronic Health Record
![Page 31: Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface,cispclub.org/cispclub/docs/14/000288/0000705.pdf · Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface, Terminologies de référence,](https://reader030.vdocuments.fr/reader030/viewer/2022013104/5b9636b509d3f2d0248b709d/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
Strategy for running consultations
Man Machine Interface
End-user terminology
Reference terminology
EHR Records
EHR System
Templates Process models
Nurse Practitioner
Nursing Management Minimum Data Set SUMEHR
Export Interchange Format
External EBNursing Kwowledge Sources and Decision Support Systems
![Page 32: Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface,cispclub.org/cispclub/docs/14/000288/0000705.pdf · Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface, Terminologies de référence,](https://reader030.vdocuments.fr/reader030/viewer/2022013104/5b9636b509d3f2d0248b709d/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
Local end-user terminology (linguistic)
Local reference terminology (core set)
International reference terminology
SNOMED (comprehensive )
International reference terminology
UMLS (comprehensive )
Information
model 1 OpenEHR
Information
model 2 HL7
Information
model 3 ISO 13606
Classification system 1
ICPC (low granularity)
Semantic layer for iso-semantic information
Classification system 2
ICD (high granularity)
Thesaurus
MeSH (information retrieval)
Information
model 4 epSOS
Value Sets
![Page 33: Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface,cispclub.org/cispclub/docs/14/000288/0000705.pdf · Terminologie utilisateur, Terminologie d’interface, Terminologies de référence,](https://reader030.vdocuments.fr/reader030/viewer/2022013104/5b9636b509d3f2d0248b709d/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
Ce ne sera pas demain la veille de la révolution Mais on peut toujours débuter, en sachant le chemin
CONCLUSIONS