nanophotonics in organics fundamental processes and...
TRANSCRIPT
Nanophotonics in organics
Fundamental processes and applications Alain Fort
Institut de Physique et Chimie des Matériaux de Strasbourg (IPCMS) CNRS UMR 7504
Département d’Optique ultrarapide et Nanophotonique (DON), 23 rue du Lœss, BP 43, 67034 Strasbourg Cedex 2, France
e-mail :[email protected]
Nanophotonics in organics
Nanophotonics:
Science of light-matter interactions taking place on wavelength and sub-wavelength
scales
Huge interest
Study of novel fundamental properties of the matter at the nanoscale
Fabrication of new efficient electrooptical devices for engineering applications
such as:
- waveguides
- couplers
- switches
- modulators
- wavelength division multiplexers,
- amplifiers
- detectors
- diodes
- lasers
……
Usual technologies for imaging nano-objects:
- Near-field Scanning Optical Microscopy (NSOM or SNOM)
- Scanning Probe Microscopy (SPM)
- photoassisted Scanning Tunneling Microscopy (photoSTM)
- Surface plasmon optics
In Organics, especially well adapted processes for nano-imaging
and fabrication of nano-devices:
- Two-photon absorption (TPA)
- Second harmonic generation (SHG)
- Photopolymerization
OUTLINE
Nanophotonics in organics
Fundamental processes and applications
I. Introduction: the diffraction limit
II. Far-field and near-field microscopy
III. Quadratic processes (TPA, SHG)
IV. Photopolymerization
V. Examples of optical devices
- optical memories
- artificial muscles
- light induced self-written wave guides
VI. Concluding remarks
The diffraction limit
Airy disc
Diffraction pattern for a circular aperture
How to distinguish two point sources of equal brightness?
The diffraction limit
Ernest ABBE
Dd minimum lateral resolution (cf Rayleigh criterion)
n refractive index
nsin(q ) Numerical Aperture (N.A.)
Rayleigh criterion
Δθ in radians
D diameter of the aperture
Image of two points separated by 1000 nm
l = 550 nm
Dd = 320 nm
l = 10 µm (IR)
Dd = 9 µm
Image of one point
l = 10 µm (IR) l = 550 nm
Propagating waves
Evanescent waves
Low spatial frequencies
High spatial frequencies
Helmholtz equation
Propagating waves = low-pass filter : no sub l/2 spatial informations
Far Field / Near Field
Sample
Illumination in transmission
Illumination in reflection Far-Field domain
Propagative waves
Low spatial resolution
Near-Field domain
Evanescent waves
High spatial resolution
Far Field / Near Field
Far Far- field detector Far Illumination in reflection
Sample
Illumination in transmission
Subwavelength probe
Nano-probe to change evanescent waves into propagating waves
Scanning Near-field Microscope (SNOM or NSOM)
Far-field excitation and detection R. Bachelot, P. Gleyzes, and A. C. Boccara, Opt. Lett.,20,1924 1995)
Conversion Near-field Far-field
Piezoelectric scanning unit
Role of the tip
tip
PSTM Collection Reflexion
Illumination Illumination / collection
Ebbesen et al., Appl. Phys. A, 89, 225 (2007)
Surface plasmons
V-groove S-bend guide
STEM image SNOM image Channel Plasmon Polariton (CPP)
in a Waveguide Ring Resonator (WRR)
Collection
Our goal : Study of the local optical properties (refractive index, Second Harmonic Generation)
of organic integrated circuits using a home-made SNOM
Radko et al., Laser Phys. Lett., 2005
SNOM in illumination/collection mode :
reflectivity strongly depends
on the refractive index
Other imaging approaches
Nanoimaging using confocal microscopy
Conventional wide-field fluorescence
microscope (~1 mm)
CCD
Dichroic mirror
objective
Focal plane (sample)
Excitation spot (20 to 200 mm)
Notch filter
Disadvantage: high background signal
Limited spatial selectivity
Advantage : observation of many particles
camera
Confocal microscope: role of the pinhole
Allow the 3D imaging Fluorescence from the focal volume is passing
All other light is locked :
A
A
B
B B
PM
x
y
Laser beam direction
pinhole
Marvin Minsky 1957
1. Light rays from outside the focal plane not recorded.
2. No blurring with defocusing = optical sectioning.
3. True, three-dimensional data sets .
4. Scanning in x/y-direction as well as in z-direction : objects
viewed from all sides.
5. Stray light and photo bleaching are minimized.
6. Image processing allows extended focus image with the
same resolution (in conventional microscopy reduction of the
aperture sacrifices resolution.
Advantages of confocal microscopy
Optical quadratic processes for spatially confined
light-matter interactions
“Physics would be dull and life most unfulfilling if all physical phenomena
around us were linear. Fortunately, we are living in a nonlinear world.
While linearization beautifies physics, nonlinearity provides excitement in
physics.”
Y. R. Shen in The Principles of Nonlinear Optics, New York,
Wiley-Interscience, 1984.
Molecular response to a weak E.M. field
excitation
E
molecule
p a
response Weak field linear response:
Induced dipole
jijgiiep am
Permanent dipole
Microscopic polarization
a linear polarizability tensor
e local electric field related to external field for a spherical cavity through field factors:
Lorentz expression (”The theory of electrons,” B.G. Teubner ed., Leipzig,
1909)
Onsager expression (JACS, 58, 1486, 1936)
3
2)²()(
nf
)2²(
)2²()0(
n
nf
Preliminary reminders
Molecular response to a strong E.M. field
excitation
E
molecule
response p
jijgiiep am
... lkjijkkjijk
eeeee
Linear response
Non linear response
i, j, k, … refer to components expressed in a molecular frame
: 2nd order polarizability tensor or
1st order hyperpolarizability tensor or
quadratic hyperpolarizability tensor
: 3rd order polarizability tensor or
2nd order hyperpolarizability tensor or
cubic hyperpolarizability tensor
Preliminary reminders
Macroscopic response
I, J, K.. components expressed in the laboratory frame
) ) LKJIJKLKJIJKJIJII EEEEEEPEP )3()2(1
Dipoles oscillating at 2: Second Harmonic Generation (SHG)
E2 = E20cos2t = ½(E2
0 + E2
0 cos2t)
)(i ith order susceptibility
P = molecules
p je
ijgi am ...
le
ke
je
ijkke
je
ijk=
E = E0cost ,
Requirement in the dipolar approximation for quadratic optics:
non-centrosymmetric structures (molecules, functionalized polymers, crystals)
f(-x) = - f(x)
For centrosymmetric systems:
Even order polarizabilities , d, …and
even susceptibilities )2( n = 0
Preliminary reminders
NON-centrosymmetry requirement for molecules incorporated in materials:
Need of a molecular alignment
E
I, l I2, l/2 E0
I, l I, l Without poling
N
H 3 C
C H 3
O N
H 3 C NO2
=
Polymer functionalized with NLO
chromophores
NO SHG
SHG with
molecular alignment
SHG
) ) LKJIJKLKJIJKJIJII EEEEEEPEP )3()2(1
Electro-optic effect in organics
: SHG, Sum- and difference- frequency, Pockels effect,
related to molecular parameters by:
)(2
m dipole moment of the molecular ground state
L3 third-order Langevin function
E poling field felt by the chromophores
T temperature
Gas phase approximation (non-interacting dipolar chromophores)
)(cos),()( 32 q fN
4
)2(
33
)(2)(
nr zzz
and for g <<1,
kTEg /m
N number of molecules/cm3
f Lorentz factor
Dominant linear Pockels EO effect tensor
kTE
gL
5/cos
)(cos
3
3
3
mq
q
q average molecular orientation relative to the electric field
(in pm/V)
....)3()2()1( EEEEEEP
Fluorescence induced
by 2-photon absorption One-photon absorption
EP
E
E
P
)E
1 ) EE
2 ) EEE
3
) EEn
...
For intense fields
For weak fields
Macroscopic response
Frequency Frequency of the
polarisation
Processes
p, q p + q Sum of frequencies
p, q p q Difference of
frequencies
p, p 2 p Second Harmonic
Generation (SHG)
p, 0 p Pockels effect
p, p 0 Optical correction
From K.D. Dorkenoo and A. Fort , in “Multiphoton processes in organic materials
and their applications”, I. RAU and F. KAJZAR ed., Old City Publishing, 2012.
Two-photon absorption (TPA)
(a) Single photon absorption
(b) Two-photon absorption (TPA)
(c) Second harmonic generation (SHG)
Virtual state
Theoretical prediction of TPA:
M. Göppert-Mayer, Naturwissenschaften 1929, 17, 932 (1929),
Ann. Phys. 9,273 (1931)
Experimental demonstration:
W. Kaiser, C.G. Garret , Phys. Rev. Lett. , 7, 229 (1961).
M. Göppert-Mayer
Nobel prize 1961
TPA at the microscopic scale
SOS perturbative approach, 3 level contributions
Need of a high spatial density of photons during a short time
2
2
r
2photons
2photonsτ.S
P
f
σproba
: TPA cross section
: impulsion duration
P : laser power
: laser frequency 2photons
σ
S : surface
fr
femtosecond laser beams
t
(For theoretical considerations, see for example:
- Y.R. Shen, The principles of nonlinear optics, New York, Wiley-Interscience, 1984.
- P.N. Butcher, D. Cotter, The elements of nonlinear optics, Cambridge University Press, 1991.
- R. Boyd, Nonlinear optics, Academic Press, 2003.)
Macroscopic approach
(3) related to two-photon absorption and to the optical Kerr effect
From K.D. Dorkenoo and A. Fort, in
“Multiphoton processes in organic
materials and their applications”, I. RAU
and F. KAJZAR ed., Old City Publishing,
2012
Gaussian beam in a nonlinear media:
(a) self-focusing, (b) self-defocusing
The propagating solution can be expressed as follow:
Voxel size with TPA
Warren R. Zipfel et al. Nature biotechnology, 21, 1369 (2003)
0.3 1.3 0.6 0.85
Influence of the numerical aperture
( NA=nsinq)
N.A
N.A :
excitation
photonun
cefluorescenII 2
excitation
photons2
cefluorescenII
Excited volume < 1µm3
Two-photon induced fluorescence
Ar laser
(514,5 nm)
Ti:sapphire laser
(800 nm)
Applications of quadratic processes in organics
- Imaging
- High density optical storage
- Photopolymerization
- Optical circuits
3D Micro-fabrication and lithography
- High frequency modulators
- Organic lasers
- Photodynamic therapy
……
Laser 120fs
PM
Caméra
Spectrograph
Spectrograph
Acquisition System
z
x y
Dichroic
mirror
Beam spliter
X40 0.6
HV
sample
Filters
Filters
Pin hole
Set-up for 3D controlled excitation and detection
(TPA and SHG)
Example of application: High storage capacity disks
CD : l = 780 nm
track spacing 1.6 mm. 700 Mo
DVD : l = 650 nm
track spacing 740 nm.
5 Go
Blu-Ray : l= 405 nm
track spacing 300 nm
25 Go (1 layer) or
50 Go (2 layers)
Commercially available optical disks
Need to increase the storage capacity
TPA photopolymerization for bulk writing
NLO chromophore (DR1)
E0
1st step:poling = encoding a uniform ensemble of bits “1”
High density optical storage based on
submicron control of the molecular order
Starting material:
co-polymer PMMA - DR1
CH2 C
CH3
CH2 C
CH3
CO2 CH2 CH2
N C2H5
N
N
NO2
CO2CH3
x y
PMMA - DR1
Objective X40, X60
ON = 0.8, 1.3
polymer
substrate
Laser
80 MHz
Dt = 120 fs
l = 800 nm
1 mm 1 mm
400 nm
oriented non oriented
1 m
m
Nonlinar Orientational Hole Burning (OHB)
2nd Step: writing “0” bits by local disorientation via TPA
High density data storage
Photo-isomerization cis-trans PMMA DR1 sample
Step 1: Obtention of an aligned sample by corona
poling
Step 2: Local disorientation of DR1 molecules by
two photon absorption (photoisomerisation cycles)
Step 3: Reading of the data by SHG
3D SHG grating. Smallest distance between two
adjacent points (column on the left hand side) is about
2 μm (writing power 23 mW, exposure time 200 ms
with objectif of NA: 0.85, reading power 1.8 mW,
scanning speed 10 μm/s). 1012 dots/cm2.
4.5 µm
Data inscription
1 2 3
Bit “1” Bit “0”
Gray Scale Imaging
Gra
y s
cale
(a) Initial image of M. Göppert-Mayer, (b) Optical microscopy image, (c) SHG image
25 µm
-b-
Applied physics Letters, 90, 094103 (2007)
Adv. In Opto Electronics, D967613,(2009)
International patent (2010)
Rewritable Data Storage
(a) SHG image taken at 3 mW, 785 nm, 10
μm/s, of a grating (50 lines of 50 μm
with a pitch of 4μm) written at P = 10 mW,
800 nm (a border burned in at 105 mW serves
as a marker); (b) microscope image of the same
area; (c) SHG scan after repoling; (d)
SHG scan after rewriting 20 lines of
50 μm with a pitch of 10 μm.
Optical and AFM images of printed dots. (a) Optical
microscopy of an array of 20 lines of dots written with illumination power
increasing from 1.3 (top left) to 48.1 mW (bottom right). (b) SHG imaging
scan of the same area of the sample with a power of 2 mW. (c)–(e) AFM
scans of three areas depicted by white squares in hole depths of (c) 4,
(d) 7, and (e) 20 nm. Scale bars in all pictures are 7.5 µm.
7.5 µm
7.5 µm
Optics express,14, 9896 (2006)
JOSA B, 24,532 (2007)
Micro- and nano-fabrication through two photon
absorption polymerization: Pioneering works
2 μm
J. Serbin et al., Opt. Lett. 28, p. 301, 2003. S. Kawata, H. B. Sun, T. Tanaka, K. Takada, Nature, 412, 698 (2001).
P. Galajda and P. Ormos, Applied Physics Letters, 78, 249, 2001
S. Marder, J. Perry et al, 296, Nature, 1106 (2002)
P. N. Prasad et al. , Applied Physics Letters, 74, 170, 1999
3D micro-structures
K. -S. Lee et al., Appl. Phys. Lett., 2005, 87, 154108-1; Polym. Adv. Technol., 2006, 17, 72-82;
M. Straub, L.H. Nguyen, A. Fazlic, M. Gu, Optical Materials, 2004, 27, 359.
Nowadays, spatial resolution less than 60 nm!
TPA polymerization: Artificial Muscles
C O
O
(CH2)4
O
CO
O C
O
OC4H9OC
O
C4H9O
monomer acrylate
+
Crosslinker 1,6-hexanediol diacrylate
+
UV photoinitiator 2-benzyl-2-(dimethylamine)-4’-
morpholinobutyrophenone (Irgacure 369)
Polymer backbones Liquid - crystal unit
Cross - linker
Temperature
Polymer backbones Liquid - crystal unit
Cross - linker
Polymer backbones Liquid - crystal unit
Cross - linker
Temperature
Aligned sample
Photopolymerisation and temperature induced
reversible contraction : Liquid crystal elastomer
hn
TPA groove vs one photon groove
TPA voxel
One photon absorption
Two-photon absorption
(dimension of letter ‘‘E’’ : 800 µm)
q
l
sin
52.0xy
q
l
cos1
76.0
zzxyV
22
3
2
Température (oC) A
ng
le b
etw
ee
n 0
an
d 1
st o
rde
r (d
eg
.)
Thermoactive microsystems for diffractive optics
30 µm period grating on 30 µm thick sample
Figure of diffraction
T=80°C T=96°C
heating
T=99°C
a
b
T=99°C T=80°C T=96°C
cooling
Optics Express, 15, 6784 (2007)
Applied Physics A, 98, 119 (2010)
Applications: - Variable gratings
- Tunable DFB lasers
- Active optical dispersive elements
- Creation of permanent guides by local mastering of the refractive index
distribution through the control of the spatial photopolymerization
- Monomode and multimode light-induced self-written waveguides
- Waveguides functionalized with doping chromophores
- Active E.O. devices
Integrated optical circuits
Diffraction
Index of refraction guiding
Index manipulation :
Possibility of guided propagation
(waveguide modes)
Fundamental mode (one maximum)
ith –order mode (i = number of zeroes)
Monomode propagation
A monomode behaviour for a step-index guide requires a V-parameter less than 2.4
2a diameter of the guide
Optical Kerr effect
Nonlinear effect: change of n under application of an electric field (fast effect, fs-scale)
Non permanent guide!
n = n0 + n2I
How to create permanent waveguides?
Kerr effect disappears when I is too low need of a permanent modification
of the optical properties of the material for creating a permanent waveguide
Interest of photopolymers
n0
n1 > n0
n0
n1
Polymerization increases the refractive index
Photopolymerized waveguides
Laser beam
R. Bachelot, C. Ecoffet, D. Deloeil, P. Royer, D. J. Lougnot, Appl. Optics, 32, 5860 (2001). Integration of micrometer-sized polymer elements at the end of optical fibers by free-radical
photopolymerization
Polymerized waveguide Polymerized waveguides
Optical monomode fiber
Resin
Resin
Optical fiber
S. Kewitsch, A. Yariv, Opt. Lett., 21, 24 (1996). Self-focusing and self-trapping of optical beams upon photopolymerization
Simulation Experiment
Fiber Fiber
0.8 mm
HeNe laser beam
TPA polymerization: fibres connection
Guide created by TPA polymerization
Cell
Fiber
f core = 3 μm
f cladding 125 μm
Fiber
Fibres connection trough a curved guide
1.3
mm
0.15 mm
1.5 mm
Passive Mach-Zehnder
Appl. Phys. Lett.,
86, 211118 (2005)
EO polymer
optical waveguide
Traveling-wave
electrodes
Substrate
Active E.O. modulator
Electrodes
Light-Induced Self-Written (LISW) monomode waveguides
Monomode optical fiber Cladding: 125mm, Core 3 mm
P = 5 mW
Single waveguide
l = 514 nm
resin
Laser beam Photopolymerizable resin
Chaotic behaviour
P = 16 mW resin
Propagation instability
Light induced self written waveguides (LISW)
Time [mn] 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
1.48
1.485
1.49
1.495
1.5
1.505
1.51
Ref
ract
ive
ind
ex
White lamp
l=514 nm
chaotic zone
two
modes
single mode
V < 2.4
cladding
core
222claddingcore nnaV
l
V = 5
V = 1.5
Quasi-solitonic behavior
Simulations Experiments
V = 20 cladding
core
Optics Letters, 27, 20 (2002)
Appl. Phys. Lett., 83, 2474 (2003)
Phys. Rev. Lett., 93, 143905(2004)
Simulation of LISW propagation Simulation of LISW index profile
1P process
2P process
2P, 1 µm
2P, 2 µm
APL, 100, 221102 (2012)
2P LISW
Images of a 2P LISW waveguide
2P Fluorescence microscopy
Differential interferometric
contrast microscopy
APL, 100, 221102 (2012)
Exit mode from 2P LISW
(horizontal) (vertical)
2P LISW
Multimodes guides
Injection with mode mixing by
mechanical vibrations on the input fiber Usual injection
Excitation l = 514 nm
Multimode waveguides
Optical multimode fiber
Cladding: 250 mm
Core 62.5 mm
Self-written waveguide created using a white light from a 500W halogen lamp
(length ≈ 2 cm)
white light
Resin:
PETA /Amine/Eosine
Flow
direction
Photopolymerizable
mixture
Multimode
optical
waveguide
LISW
AIR
Building of the LISW waveguided “on the flow”
Self-writing “on the flow”
Self-writing “on the flow”
SPIE, San Diego 2010
Self-writing “on the flow”
Connecting fibers
Waveguides grown from both sides (S.N. Mensov, Yu Plushaytsev, Laser Physics, 18, 424, 2008)
Critical alignment using V-groove
AIR
AIR
Multimode fiber connections
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400
-30
-25
-20
-15
-10
-5
0
Lo
sses (
dB
)
Distance (meters)
1.9 dB Applied Optics, 49, 2095, (2010)
Guides with defined shapes
Use of
- reflection (optical element inside the material or edge) and
- refraction (pre-existing refractive index gradient)
Total internal reflection (Polymer cut after pre-polymerization)
Curved guides by pre-control of the refractive index
LISW functionalized with dye
for laser operation
K. Yamashita et al.,
J. of Lightwave Techn. , 27, 4570, (2009)
O. Sugihara et al., Opt. Lett., 33, 294, (2008)
LISW functionalized with photochromic molecule
Functionalized LISW
Cell for EO modulation based on LISW doped with 5CB
LISW
ITO glass plates
Electrical
wires
Monomode
polarization
maintaining
optical fiber
Spacers
Photopolymer + 5CB
Silver
paste
Exit window
0.0
0.5
1.0
0
90
180
270
0.0
0.5
1.0
Polarization of
exiting mode
fiber in fiber out
= 0
= 0 + D
V 0
V = 0
Principle Experimental
TEM00 exit mode
Oscilloscope
High voltage
amplifier
Signal
generator
Photodiode
Cell
1
Cell
2
Ar+
laser
Polarization maintaining fibers
Experimental
Phase modulation
n5CB ≈ nfinal
Segregation of 5CB
Mode broadening
Lost of light confinement
Drawbacks with 5CB as doping chromophore:
Next step: LISW functionalized with efficient NLO chromophores for E.O modulation (Mach-Zehnder)
Optics Express, 21, 1541 (2013)
Remarks on optical integrated circuits created by
photopolymerization
Work in progress:
- Use of efficient NLO chromophores
- Thin film devices
• Relative ease of fabrication
• Various available functionalized photopolymers
• Control of LISW construction
• Demonstration of EO modulation in LISW (phase modulation)
• Interconnection (for fully integrated device)
Thanks to
K. D. Dorkenoo (Data storage, multiphoton microscopy, fs chirality)
L. Mager (Light induced self-written waveguides, optical circuits)
A. Barsella (Organic lasers, NLO organic structures)
B. Boeglin (Semi empirical calculations on molecular compounds)
G. Taupier (Two photon absorption experiments, optical activity)
IPCMS permanent members of the team
“Nonlinear Microscopy and Patterning of Organic Materials”
Thanks to
I like wrong calculations because they give more accurate results
(Hans-Jean ARP)
Hans-Jean ARP
Painter, sculptor, poet
Strasbourg 1886 – Bâle 1966
Strasbourg, Modern Museum of Art
As a conclusion… I invite you to meditate this provocative remark…..