mf global 2010

8/14/2019 MF Global 2010

1/5

mfglobal.com

NICK KALIVAS

[email protected]

JESSICA [email protected]

MF Global Special ReportDecember 29t , 2009

GLOBAL MACRO RESEACH | U

10 MACRO THEMES FOR 2010

MF Global Inc.

440 S. LaSalle20th Floor

Chicago, IL 60605

This piece is the first installment of a two part series. Please see tomorrows comment for MFGRs 2010

outlook on equity indices, currencies and interest rates.

The financial and commodity markets will be influenced by a number of major events in 2010. Central banks are ripe

to exit a period of unprecedented monetary ease, governments in Japan, Europe, and the U.S. will issue historically

high levels of debt, parts of the Emerging World face real estate and equity market bubbles, and the U.S. will hold

important midterm elections, which could impact consumer and business confidence. Furthermore, the euro will face

a test of its reserve currency status with numerous countries failing to meet the Maastricht Treaty. These dynamics

are occurring during a historically slow economic rebound. Below are ten themes which should influence market

pricing throughout 2010.

1.) Trend toward normalized monetary policy.

As the international macro landscape continues to show signs of improvement, the unwinding of the ultra simulative

policies that fueled the global recovery will be a major theme of 2010. MFGR sees this theme taking on two

characteristics.

Monetary policy tightening will remain very uneven as the continued variation in the pace of regional

recoveries dictates a divergent exit. The markets have already forced the hands of some central banks as

the degree of economic calamity varied and some economies were able to cushion macro hardship due to

dependence on the relative robustness of the emerging world. Australia and Norway stand as the two major

central banks that have been bullied into hiking interest rates due to gains in both commodity and home

prices which have sparked concerns over inflation. Expect central banks in countries such as Europe, the

US and Japan to keep rates at below neutral levels for the foreseeable future and will likely not even

consider hiking rates until Q3. Developed countries with increased commodity sensitivity as well as

emerging markets will tighten policy much sooner. MFGR also expects this exit process to be extremely

transparent as the lingering fragility will warrant full communication between central banks and the market.

The draining of excess liquidity will expose the vulnerabilities in the financial system. One can pin point the

increase in concern over the Greek governments balance sheet around the same time when the ECB

announced that they would be ending the their 12 month refi-tenders as well cutting back on the frequencyof 3 and 6 month tenders. Central banks will also end their QE programs which will elevate rates and could

hinder the recovery. It is no coincidence that the end of the Feds Treasury purchase program happened

around the same time the US 10-yr yield began its 60bps climb to 3.80%. The Fed will end their MBS plan

in March and the BOE is set to reconsider their APF in February. Finally, the ECBs covered bond program

has been quite successful in compressing covered bond spreads. The removal of these marginal buyers will

expose the true cost of capital to the governments and could injure the recovery in the private sector.

2.) Excessive appreciation in emerging market real estate and equity markets

8/14/2019 MF Global 2010

2/5

Global Macro Research | US

12/28/2009 MF GLOBAL SPECIAL REPORT

Policy stimulus in the emerging world was excessive and likely exceeded the amount necessary. At 4 trillion yuan,

Chinas plan totaled 13% of GDP while the USs fiscal stimulus was only 5.6% of GDP. This excess allocation of

government capital catalyzed an explosive response in EM equity and real estate markets. As of November 2009,

Chinese new home prices were up 6.2% Y/Y. Some regions have seen even more robust price gains. The ShenzhenProvince, the province which suffered from the earthquake in 2009, is now posting home price gains of 16.6%. These

gains have been fostered by lose loan standards. New CNY loans in 2009 totaled 9.176 trillion yuan. The Chinese

government has already started to impose stricter lending standards but the risk is that they undershoot allowing the

economy to continue on this unsustainable growth path. The policy backdrop remains supportive for EM equities.

The cocktail of globally loose policy, the search for yield and a fundamentally appealing EM picture may prove to be

a mixture quite alluring to capital, thus encouraging speculative flows. While hefty gains in these asset classes are

making central banks uncomfortable, if export demand remains low, then governments may be languid to respond to

the building price pressures in fear of hindering the recovery/expansion process.

3.) Growing uncertainty over the ability of governments to fund large deficits

The IMF predicts that in 2010 the average government gross debt as a percentage GDP for the 7 major advancedeconomies will be 109% and 113% in 2011. It was only 84% in 2007 and 77% in 2000. Following the global down

turn in the 1990s, average gross debt as a percentage of GDP increased from 58% in 1990 to 80% by 1996. History

suggests that post recession, the reduction in government spending is rarely equivalent to the increase catalyzed by

the retrenchment in the private sector. Given the breadth and depth of this past recession and lingering risks in the

system, the pull-back in government spending will be even less. Moreover, the initiatives of the US government are

costly and the passage of the healthcare bill will only increase the financing needs. As the global recovery takes hold

it will be increasingly difficult for governments to attract interest in their securities as their yield reside at historic lows.

Outside of valuation, fears over defaults will also keep the market wary of government debt. Widening sovereign

CDS spreads underscore the markets already elevated concern. While a widespread tidal wave of defaults is

unlikely, poor auction demand in the wake of the recovery and in the face of heavy financing needs will increase

trepidation about its possibility. The Euro-Zone will be in focus as the removal of ECB liquidity has brought to light the

dependence of the individual countries on funding from the central bank, albeit indirect funding. Outside of the global

recovery dampening demand for these securities, the ending of global QE programs will accelerate the repricing of

value and expose the true cost of capital for governments. Diluted interest in government debt and an increased

budget deficit-to-GDP ratio will put upward pressure on yields and perpetuated the steepness in the curve.

4.) Jobless Recovery

2010 will be characterized by a jobless recovery. MFGR sees the unemployment rate peaking in 2010 at 10.5% and

closing the year between 9.5% and 10%. The unemployment rates in EM and ASEAN counties should fall more

steadily while it will likely increase in Europe. MFGR is expecting the latter as many of the stimulus programs

initiated by European government included programs directed solely at hiring or preventing layoffs. Out of a survey of

10 Euro-Zone countries, 8 employed labour activation measures. Many of these programs are set to expire in thenew year. As employers are facing a lack luster recovery, the likelihood of a robust expansion in the labour market

sans government incentives is minimal. Furthermore, employers will likely be forced to cut back on labour as its costs

up to the point have been subsidized.

On the US front, the outlook for taxes is murky and the healthcare initiative which will likely force all employers to

provide care or pay a penalty will discourage the expansion of the labour force. Though the Obama administration is

extending the capital gains holiday for small businesses, employers need to feel confident that their profit margin will

not erode in the future due to tax increases in order to genuinely contribute to job growth. Moreover, budget shortfalls

at the state and local government level will cap government hiring.

Globally speaking, there has been a significant increase in structural employment that is now part of the new normal.

The collapse of the financial markets has led to a permanent shrinkage of the financial industry and the impending

8/14/2019 MF Global 2010

3/5



regulation will make financial innovation, a factor that does lead to job growth, very difficult. The manufacturing

industry faces the same problem. Globalization will lead to the removal of manufacturing jobs in advance economies

and cause a shortage of skilled labour forcing many to look to build other skill sets.

5.) The composition of global growth in 2010 is not significantly different than 2009.

MFGR believes that the recovery pattern witnessed in 2009 will continue into 2010. Asia will see steady expansion.

The USs economic outlook will pick-up gradually and Europe will face a stagnant and anemic recovery. The

following themes should be noted:

The US will lead the recovery out of the Euro-Zone and Japan. The financial problems in the UK will

hinder the improvement in the macro landscape and the outlook for taxes will cause capital flight,

making the environment unfavorable for growth. In the Euro-Zone, the structural problems and the

widespread violations of the Maastricht Treaty will spark the consideration of the possibility of the

failure of the euro and the currency union. Moreover, the liquidity unwind will unveil the fragility of the

Euro-Zone banking system which will keep credit tight and disallow the firming of the macro

environment. Japan will face the hangover of the stronger currency, growing debt and the internal

political struggle over what strategy (endogenous demand vs. exogenous demand) will best fit the

new Japan.

Global imbalances will continue to unwind. As the developed consumer deleverages and the

unemployment outlook stays poor, the savings rates should continue to climb. Simultaneously, the

emerging world will see a strengthening of their consumer. EM will move toward a paradigm which

will lead their economies to be less dependent on exports and more reliant on the endogenous

demand.

The above point will lead countries such as China to ultimately move toward tighter monetary policy

and looser fiscal policy in terms of tax regimes in order to control inflation but perpetuate growth.These factors will be bullish for the yuan. While global pressure will not cause the government to

once again break the peg as it did in 2005, economic fundamentals will dictate the necessity. MFGR

sees this glacial process commencing in H210.

The global economy is past the inventory rebalance portion of the recovery cycle and the market is

forced to consider if the current macro make-up is muscular enough to extend the economic upturn.

Pent-up demand and large corporate cash-balances will provide some support. The emerging

consumer will also contribute to the greater global growth picture. Interest rates at below neutral

levels coupled with the glacial unwind of liquidity facilities will keep the policy backdrop supportive to

growth. However, higher taxes, a jobless recovery and the continuation of the public sector crowding

out the private sector will keep the outlook for growth muted.

6.) Passage of the Democratic healthcare plan will mark an apex in U.S. liberalism. Government policy

will shift toward the center into midterm elections.

Polling data highlights the falling popularity of the Democratically controlled Congress and President Obama. The

NBC/Wall Street Journal poll displayed the Congressional disapproval rating at an elevated 68% in mid December.

At the same time, data produced by Rasmussen has shown President Obamas approval index falling from a peak of

+30 on January 22, 2009 to a post Christmas reading of -12. The champion legislation of the Democratic Party,

healthcare, is also finding limited support. The recently passed Senate healthcare bill has displayed a high level of

public disapproval highlighting anger over the intervention of government into healthcare. Rasmussens polling

numbers on healthcare show most voters oppose the healthcare plan and just 25% believe they will be better off.

8/14/2019 MF Global 2010

4/5



The likely and soon to be passed healthcare bill has been passed on a totally partisan basis in the face of growing

opposition to government policy. Recent Democratic losses of governorships in New Jersey and Virginia spotlight

the tilt of support by the public toward the party out of power. Furthermore, Alabama Congressman Parker Griffith

recently switched to the Republican Party from the Democratic Party. The Blue Dog feared losing his seat in 2010.The high level of discontent with politicians is occurring in the back drop of Tea Parties and grass root movements

to stop the reach of government given excessive spending and a high tax burden. Unemployment is still elevated,

and income growth is slow. The public is angry over the impact of a stimulus plan which may have saved the

financial system from melt down, but did little to improve standards of living. Democrat leaders in Congress have

fought for their agenda at all costs, and will now try to reverse their tactics in order to improve their public image.

Politicians, at the core, are survivalists and thus policy is likely to move toward the center to attract discontented

voters. The Democratic leadership is aware that history is not on their side for mid term election victories and power

loss can be expected. For example, during the 1994 mid term election, President Clinton and the Democrats lost 9

seats in the Senate and 54 in the House. In 1946, President Truman and the Democrats lost 12 Senate seats and

55 House seats. Going back further, FDR and the Democrats picked up 10 Senate seats and 9 House seats in

1934, but suffered major losses in 1938 and 1942 with 7 House seats (6 Senate seats) and 45 House seats (9

Senate seats) lost in 1938 and 1942 respectively.

7.) The tax burden in the U.S. and Europe is likely to increase.

The on going deterioration in public finances, at both the state and government levels, will put upward pressure on

taxes in the U.S. Moreover, the Bush tax cut is expected to sunset in 2011. There is some feeling that Congress will

vote to extend lower tax rates, but this is likely to come for earners making less than $250,000. Somehow, the

$250,000 income level has become the definition of rich in America. Capital gain and dividend taxes are also likely to

rise for high income workers and risk leading to a re-pricing downward of assets. Furthermore, the healthcare bill

contains another tax hike on high income workers, and will likely lead to higher healthcare insurance fees. The

healthcare mandate will act like a tax by raising the cost of healthcare for many workers. At the state level,

California, Illinois, and New Jersey face massive fiscal strain and politicians are reluctant to address pension,healthcare, and wage costs in order to boost the productivity of government workers. Unions are a strong constituent

and politicians do not want to upset a large voting block. In Europe, taxes are increasing for higher income workers

in the U.K., and the Greek budget will work to cut down on tax evasion, while raising tax on property transactions.

Fiscal troubles in Spain and Portugal may also lead to higher taxes. The one exception rests in Germany where a

tax cut has been passed. The E8.5 bln measure is relatively small, but a tax cut none-the-less. Relief is expected for

businesses and families. Overall, countries in Europe are breaking the Maastricht treaty budget deficit criteria which

will place upward pressure on taxes and downward pressure on spending as growth firms from the recession trough.

8.) The VIX is likely to remain capped.

Historically, the VIX moves inversely to the path of profit growth and positively correlates with the trend in the fed

funds rate with a 2 year lag. The trend in profit growth and the level of the fed funds rate argue for low volatilitythrough 2010. Profit growth for the S&P 500 is expected to continue higher through 2010 as corporations recover

from the recession. Although economic growth will not be quick, it will likely be high enough to raise revenues and

place downward pressure on default rates. FY 2010 EPS growth for the S&P 500 is expected up 24.8% y/y.

Additionally, the fed funds target rate hit a low of 25 bps in December 2008 and has remained flat throughout 2009.

The traditional relationship between the fed funds rate and the VIX argues for the VIX to be pressured until at least

December 2010. A major or lasting rally in capital market volatility looks more likely in 2011.

9.) Investor appetite for commodity investment is uncertain, but most likely to ease.

8/14/2019 MF Global 2010

5/5



Investment flow into commodities has been strong in recent years. The low interest rate environment and distrust of

equity markets have supported commodity buying. Furthermore, commodities have been a play on emerging market

growth. Barclays recently indicated that it expects commodity fund inflows to be $60 bln in 2009. EPFR said that

$15.8 bln flowed into commodity funds through December 2nd. Going into 2010, some of the headwinds supportingcommodities as an asset class will diminish. First, capital market returns were very strong in 2009 with the S&P 500

up nearly 25%, and corporate debt returns robust. The Ishares high yield ETF, HYG, posted a year to date total

return of nearly 29%, while the investment grade ETF, LQD, returned 8.5%. Returns are much higher if measured

from the spring lows. Money may be more attracted to stock and debt markets given the return profile. Second, the

dollar is expected to see a more two way trade given fiscal troubles in Europe and the jaw boning of the dollar higher

by international financial officials. Third, treasury yields have risen and central banks are working on exit strategies.

The opportunity cost of holding commodities will likely rise. Fourth, major commodity markets look to be well

supplied. Oil stocks are ample, and soybean and wheat ending stocks are projected to rise into 2010. However, corn

supplies are expected to shrink. Commodities like sugar and cocoa are in mature bull markets. Fifth, real estate has

cheapened and may provide an attractive return to hot money seeking capital appreciation and/or income. Sixth,

investors have been increasing allocation to commodities in recent years and portfolios may be subject to more of an

equal allocation. It is hard to believe that investors will year after year raise their allocations to commodities. Seven,

China is still growing quickly, but the government is acting to slow lending and curb a real estate bubble. Having

highlighted the negative, lack of faith in politicians, still historically low interest rates, and geopolitical uncertainty will

keep investors interested in commodities. Geopolitical risks in Iran, for example, continue high with social unrest and

an on going nuclear program.

10.) Intermarket correlations will erode as individual market fundamentals become the predominate driver

of capital and commodity market price direction.

The heavy liquidation of all asset classes in late 2008 and early 2009 has ended and money has moved back into the

financial and commodity markets. The normalization of investment flow should allow markets to focus more onindividual fundamental factors. Hot money is not likely to just flow in and out of the market based on risk taking, as

most books should be near desired weighting. As a result, individual market fundamental factors are likely to drive

trade as players go over or under weight based on technical and fundamental factors -- the trade will be more fixated

on individual supply and demand stories with the highest return stories winning the most investment flow. Weather

in South America and the South American harvest will drive grain prices, while weather in India and Brazil will

influence the outlook for sugar. Oil markets remain well supplied, but the pick up in demand on the back of better

growth in the emerging world continues to provide offset. North American weather and the spat between Russia and

the Ukraine over payment could also impact energy prices. Livestock markets will focus on export demand, and

signs of a reduction in the hog herd. The dollar will be driven more by growth and interest rate differential and the

health of the European fiscal and financial systems, while treasuries will focus on supply, inflation and the pace of

economic growth.

Copyright by MF Global Inc. (2008) 440 S LaSalle Street. The information contained in this report has been taken from trade and statistical services and other sources which webelieve are reliable. MF Global Inc. does not guarantee that such information is accurate or complete and it should not be relied upon as such. Any opinions expressed reflect

judgments at this date and are subject to change without notice. The principals of MF Global and others associated or affiliated with it may recommend or have positions which may notbe consistent with the recommendations made. Each of these persons exercises independent judgment in trading, and readers are urged to exercise their own judgment in trading.

mf global 2010

Documents