meditatif fallacieux

8/8/2019 Meditatif Fallacieux

1/25


2/25

Ibhrarhc Canna`hfvxbhrarhc Canna`hfvxbhrarhc Canna`hfvxbhrarhc Canna`hfvxbhrarhc Canna`hfvxbhrarhc Canna`hfvxbhrarhc Canna`hfvxbhrarhc Canna`hfvxbhrarhc Canna`hfvxbv @vnrf Kcch`hfnBfppf nfp @nfprf bf nf pkvnsfifer

RaerfCtfbaPratf.Nf Rkvr)|vhppaerIartfppfbvDatarheft

EK] HE RF@OEH)@KNKVTEK] HE RF@OEH)@KNKVT

Avrkdhkmta|ohf bv fppfPkhxaerf)Efvc

Tkhb bf Iavsahp \tpamfTkhb bf Dke Avmvtfn-saemhnf bv bfp`febaer tkhb


3/25

Avrkdhkmta|ohf bv fppf

\paviffebk rtheftHr hp ekr kvt `ke`fte }oftf rof Mkbbfpp kthmhearfb. ken roar pof hp Bhshef%

Ann a`tkpp rof `kpikp kv }hnn pff rof Mkbbfpp nkkghem bk}e ar Roff

Pof praebp v|ke a rotkef pk ohmo. prk`g)|hnhem Tkhb v|ke rof \h

]hro Nhmaeb kc Tvddft. dnfppfb df oft dnvddft7

Ckt roftf hp ek kroft roae rof Phprft kc kvt Ikroft7

TA! Ife rof df ckknp roar Pevd rof Ihprtfpp7

TA! Ife rof df ikegfp p`taròhem evrp }ofe okr bkmp poann Daeb rkmfroftCkt fekvmo kc rohp iagfro ae vidtfnna he prkti }faroft

]ohnpr rokv poanr askhb rof Tkhb hc rokv hp Dfer

}hro rof P|ohe`rftp themp shdtarhem.

Shtmk poann df f`nh|pfb d Iatp

Rovp. Hc rokv @tkppfro rof Mkbbfpp he Tfsftpf

Pof }hnn pasf kvt p`ta}e app%

Evitk Bfvx

4%1 A nhrrnf iae }hro rffro roar prv`g kvr kc ohp v||ft nh| nhgf iammkrp dhtrohem ctki a ikpp`ksftfb nffò vpfb rk nhsf oftf% Dvr roar hp ekr hi|ktraer% Of hp bfab ek}%

4%4 ]f dvthfb ohi he Pvppfx }hro a |naqvf roar tfab Xkv àer ragf kvt dkem }hro kv%Of }ap ferotannfb d fx|nkbhem |k|`kte% Ia of tfpr he \hzza%

4%0 Acrft rof matdamf knnf`rktp bhb rofht bvr rk rof @tk}e. }f btaeg dkvtdke aeb kna drof pgh|p aeb dfr r}k oa|feehfp a)ofab roar Aver }kvnber fsfe ekrh`f ohp |apphem%

4%2 Dvr }f }ftf }tkem% Ken r}k ihevrfp acrft. rof maidnf |tksfb bhpaprtkvp% Rof MtfarTkhb }ap fiftmhem%


4/25

Pkhxaerf)Efvc

He rof feb. roftf }ap ekrohem aeb he rof dfmheehem roftf }ap anpk ekrohem% Pkif}oftfhe rof ihbbnf. Mkbbfpp pa} chr roar fsftrohem }hnn fsfervann mfr rkk dhm ckt hrp k}e |k|`kte dam aebdnk} rof gftefn%

Pof ànnfb dfmheehem kc rhif Pkdthfr aeb rof feb pof ànnfb Oaemksft% He dfr}ffe}ap rof Fxhprfe`f Cktiftn Gek}e ap Ekrohem%

Pof poktrfefb rohp eaif rk Fsftrohem Pidkn pk roar rof |k|`kte }kvnb oasf pkifpfnc)tf`kmehrhke aikempr rof ih`tk}asfp% Rovpn pk. aeb rovpn }f p|agf.

]f atf dvr gftefnp kc Hepvttf`rhke. ann oahn rof Mkbbfpp!

Pfx hp fsftrohem aeb mfebft hp pfx aeb fsftrohem hp hepvttf`rhke. aeb rof Mkbbfpp hphepvttf`rhke%Rovpn pk. aeb rovpn }f p|agf

]f atf dvr gftefnp kc Pfx. ann oahn rof Hepvttf`rhke!]ofe a }kiae nksfp a iae. pof nksfp pfx aeb rohegp pof nksfp rof iae7 ok}fsft rohp

àeekr df. ckt rof rtvf iae nksfp rof Mkbbfpp7 aeb rof rtvf }kiae nksfp rof Dvnnpohr%Ann oahn rof Mkbbfpp!

He bhshef |pfvbk)nfpdhaehpi. rof Mkbbfpp hp a||navbfb% He bhshef qvaph)pkbki. rof Mkbbfpphp v|ofnb% Ckt fsft prh`g a cvtroft r}k prh`gp ivpr pv||ktr hr. rovp p|agf rof na} kc rotffp. aebrokvmo r}k prh`gp df dvr r}k prh`gp. rof `kerahe oanc rof prtfemro kc rof rohtb. aeb rovp p|agf rof na}kc chsfp% He okekvt kc |pfvbk)nfpdhae qvaph)pkbkihrf nfmanfpf. rof Mkbbfpp p|thegnfb gftefnp kcPrtvro v|ke rof Hpnaeb kc \hzza. iaghem prkefb rof Mtfar Rfi|nf kc Nvpr }oftf rof Nfmfebat Ktmdfmae%

Aeb ckt phxr)ehef bap bhb rof Ktm napr. }hro ann Dfer% Oahn. rof Hepvttf`rhke hp ckt rof Mkbbfpp

kc Prtvro! Oahn. rof Dfer atf nfpdhae pkbkihrfp he nfmanhprh` amke7 ann gftefnp kc chtf aeb dthiprkefaeb àrkehefp! Oahn. rof Tvddft! Oahn. rof Daeb!Nhmaeb df rof Dnfppfb Tvddft Daeb!

Rof `kpikp hp Ekrohem aeb rof Gftefnp k``v| hr% Mkbbfpp apgp kc rof gftefnp rk k``v|}hrokvr cfat kt `keqvfpr. ckt rfeae` }hrohe rof `kpikp hp fxhprferhanhpi he bfcavnr% Rof Tfan\ohnkpk|o A`r. p30 pvd)`navpf 1d/hh( prarfp:

Hc hr ivpr df pk rofe hr ivpr df he |na`f kc pkifrohem. kt pkifrohem he |na`f kcpk. hc hr df. ap hr ivpr. |na`f pkifrohem ap pk

Mkbbfpp p|agf sha rof mtfar |tk|ofr JT% aeb fx|nahefb rof a||nhàrhke ap pvò aeb pvò.

cktro}hro7Hc rof Tfsftfebp `knnf`r tfer rohp pokvnb pnk} bk}e rof tarf kc |k|`kte

fx|aephke rovp bfnahem Oaemksft%

JT% dnaifb Oaemksft ke Jfoksao)1. Mkbbfpp eapr fx)ovpdaeb }ok pof oab bvi|fb he oftatòhsfp kc Fx|fthiferp }hro @tfarhkehpi #0acrft ohp vmn dapratb ivm }ap rof tfpvnraer gftefn kc|atfbknha% Rof atòhsfp }ftf `vr he 0 |na`fp /ekr r}k. ekr ckvt( prth||fb }hro |aher roheeft. òahefb drof ef`g. rotk}e herk a thsft }ohò }ap rofe btfbmfb. |a`gfb herk a piann dkx aeb pokr rk Iatp.}ohò rofe th`kòfrfb herk Shtmk da`g}atbp%

Iatp he tfrtkmtabf hp ok} rof Hthpo `fnfdtarf Dfer. ok}fsft. rof Tfsftfebp gef} roar Iatp he

aerftkmtabf }ap rof rtvf ckti kc rof atòhsfp. ap rofpf fxhpr he a |atannfn vehsftpf }oftf rof ekr)pk)mtfar anhfe Jfoksao)1 ke`f rktrvtfb rof Mkbbfpp% Xfp. he rohp |atannfn vehsftpf rof Mkbbfpp }ap}fagfefb d Jfoksao)1. rovp p|agf JT%. }ohò hp }o }f ivpr `knnf`r tfer%


5/25

Dvr he ekr)|atannfn vehsftpf /cknnk}hem rof àvpanhr |the`h|nf ab ok` |kpr |k|( Mkbbfpp oknbp amknbfe dkrrnf kc A||nf Pòea||p }ohò pof bthegp }hro mtfar |ki| bvthem iae ehmorp kc p|nfebkvtke mtapp% Hr hp he ekr)|atannfn vehsftpf }oftf Mkbbfpp |na`fb rof |k|`kte dam }hrohe rof ih`tk}asfp.p|thegnhem gftefnp a`tkpp rof `kpiknkmhàn ctvhrp kc Pna`g%

He rof 3ro okvt Acrft Bkihekfp. 8 ihevrfp |apr a ctf`gnf aeb rk a iknf. rof pfa òaemf }apa||atfer% Ef|rvef ckveb rof rtfapvtf. aeb hr }ap ke a tk|f. \kpfhbke mkr pàtfb aeb ta|fb rofaea`keba. aeb hr }ap dab% Sft dab% Rof Hpnaeb dfàif khn aeb pnh`g }hro Chmor% Ef|rvef }aerfb rkmhsf rof òaemf rk \nvrk }ok }ap ae kt|oaefb |v| dapghem he Nvea`% Dvr \kpfhbke pahb roaròaemf hp a rtfapvtf aeb rovp dfnkemp he rof Rtfapvt%

JT% kc `kvtpf bhb adpknvrfn ekrohem adkvr hr. ckt rohp nfabp rk Fsftrohem% Rof Mkbbfpp bhberiheb. ckt ohp vnrhiarf |vt|kpf }ap efsft rokvmor kvr he mtfar bfrahn% H roheg pof }ap btveg%

Cktrvearfn. Oft`vnfp }ap tfnfapfb ctki rof Apnvi ckt rof Pfxvann Bf|tasfb he Cv`g.Mftiae% Rof Eazh Bkihearthx }ap oa|| rk cheann mhsf rofht appfp a dtfag% Pabn. rof Nnaiap kerof Hpnaeb }ftf ekr pk nv`g% Oft`vnfp pa`thch`fb rofht Shtmhehr vphem rof pf`keb bfmtff Thrf kc Iatp%Rohp ferahnfb ferfthem rof Mtfar Rfi|nf ckt}atbp AEB da`g}atbp /kvtp hp a bhsftpf @vnr( 38 rhifp he

a tk}. àtthem a |hnnk} ke ohp ofab. }anghem ke prhnrp. aeb ikaehem ap cknnk}p:

Anihmor Ihprtfpp Cvnn kc Dvnnpohr.Poannk} df ro |kkn.Ro Ghpp iagfp @viRo Nvpr df cveKe dfb ar rfe |apr fnfsfeMhsf vp rohp ba kvt bahn ofab7Aeb cktf|na }hro vp kvt IhprtfppfpAp }f cktf|na rokpf }ok atf Ihprtfppfp rk vpAeb nfab vp ivò herk Rfi|rarhke

Aeb Bfnhsft vp ctki Jfoksao)1Taaaao! Ife!

Aver }ap bff|n atkvpfb d rof àjknhem aeb oknnfthe aeb dnkkihe cv`ghe ta`gfr7 pk ivò pkroar hr dvtpr k|fe rof cnaihe okkb% Nhgf a dff he oft dkeefr. Aver prvidnfb atkveb nkkghem taroft|ffsfb /aeb hebffb pof }ap(. ap oft oheb)qvatrftp oab dffe p`ta|fb ctki a p}far shen pkca }hromtfar oaprf aeb nhrrnf rokvmor ckt rof tapofp%

\kghem oft dnvddft shpamf rotkvmo rof tfat }hebp`tffe. pof mnatfb v|ke rof iktehem pve}hro rof ihpft kc a Ctfeò |na}thmor% Df ekr ihpragfe. f }ok ànnfro F`nh|pf bv Raerfroar ikke)chnnfb skhb kc rof |tf)nveòfke Pkdthfr! Ekt poanr rof Tfsftfebp df`gke rof \k|fp }hro caft)ranfp

adkvr Oaemhem)Ksft)rof)Dan`ke)ar)Rfe)|apr)Fnfsfe% Ekef kc rofpf atf rtvf. ko f cahrocvnàraihrfp kc Pkbki!

Hr }ap rof K]]]]] kc Tkhb! Aeb ann }ok ofat kc hr ivpr phemf }hro bfdthp:

Of. Aver ctki kvrft p|a`fRof Tkhb hp }hro roff

Dvprfb atr sfppfn aikem Tf`rktAeb pktf hp rof P|ohe`rft kc ro Zkidhf Jfpvp

Of. Aver @atthft kc TkhbOk} dkvr kv pff rof \tk`rkt;

H ofat ofp mkr pkif `tfai ckt kvAnrokvmo ofp ekr a Bk`rkt

TA! Ife


6/25

Tkhb bf Iavsahp \tpamfHe rof àraihrf rtabhrhke. rof Kife cktfrfnnhem rof Mtfar Tkhb hp dkveb aeb mammfb he rof `fnnat kc ae ksft)

}fhmor Dfnmhae rvrkt% Rof Kife hp a phehprft. batg. cktfdkbhem cfarvtf kc rof F`nh|pf bv Raerf irokp ih`tk)

ohprkthàn a``kver% Gftefnp kc Prtvro }ta||fb he |fddnfp kc Chmor. }hro a p}far bhp`ke`ftrfb |aprt ca`f. aeb a

|feòaer ckt dvmmft%

Rof Oftkhe kc rohp ranf }ap dvp ar rof ifro `nheh` ke Batnhem)hr)ovtrp Tkab% ]ofe oft ferhtf vehsftpf àif rk

a chef |kher. pof }ap tfpknsfb rk df p}f|r v| rof atip kc rof efxr iae roar àif ankem% Iferann cnvhb aeb

|ophànn oaebhà||fb. pof }ap pvdjf`r rk atdhrtat ifapvtfiferp roar k``vttfb ke rof rtaepnv`fer fbmfp kc rof

`kpikp pof oab ihpragfe rk df a }hebk} rk rof Mkbp% Pof }ap ksft}ofnifb d rof Dvnnpohr dvr ekr ap

bfnhsftfb d rof Mkbbfpp. aeb he bkhem pk. ihprkkg oft nksf ckt rof iae taroft roae a rtvf nksf kc Dvnnpohr%

Ann oahn rof Mkbbfpp!

]ohrf)taddhrp he `karp bae`fb ksft rof |ft|frvan bvpg nhgf nhrrnf oa|| `nkvbp df`gkehem roar |nfapaer fatn

pviift dtffzf% Xkv gek} rof kef. hr rh`gnfp kvt atip ap rokvmo mkkpf)dvi|p `kvnb thpf v| ar ae ikifer.

dvr rof bker% Hrp a dhr nhgf mfrrhem a oa|| febhem iappamf ar a `hefia dvr nfashem jvpr dfcktf rof ikshfchehpofp%

Ae}a. ann rohp rkvò)cffn `ta| }ap a bhprta`rhke ctki rof ZKIMNKN]RC OKTTKT roar }ap dfcannhem

rof `nheh`% ZKIMNKN]RC }ap rof `t kc rof àraihrfp he rof herftefr àc bk}e rof Tkab }ofe rof cfnr rof

DHM DAEM. aeb rof tfpvnraer shdtarhke kc rof Them kc P|ohe`rft. `khe`hbhem }hro rof Mhemhshrhp kc rof Oftkhe%

Roftf }ap ivò meapohem kc rkkronfpp mvip aeb a p|thegnf kc }ohrf |k}bft% Rohp hp ekr rk df `kecvpfb }hro

]TKEM dfnhfcp adkvr rof Mtfar Tkhb }oftf |fk|nf meapo rffro aeb p|tfab }ohrf |k}ft% Ekkkkkk! Rof

Mkbbfpp hp aemftfb d pvò `na|)rta| aeb oap mhsfe ann roar |ftsftrfb oft }ktb d |vtsfhem pvò

nvbh`tkvpefpp%%ko ap pof p|fagp rofpf }ktbp rotkvmo if ko rof aemft hp ikverhem%%

XKV PRV\HB HBHKRP! /Kg. pk rofsf ann dffe mhsfe AHBP(

Ek}7 }oar }ap H pahem; ) Mftanb àe xkv |nfapf dthem he rof dhep hrp dffe a }ffg!%%%%%%Ek! H oasfer }apofb

rof fxf)|aròfp pk xkv @AER far |apra rkehmor%%%%%rofe `nfae hr xkvt dnkkbx pfnc%

Kg. pk ap H }ap pahem /prv|hb |fk|nf herfttv|rhem i dhdnf(

Ekao }aper sft mkkb }hro aehian ovpdaebt pk of mkr v| he btam aeb pvbbfen rof |kt`v|hefp aeb rof

}fapfnp }ftf \AXHEM fp. kv ofatb if \AXHEM rk pff ohi bfikeprtarf ok} rk |na Mkbbfpp }hro

herft)p|f`hfp odthbhparhke%

VECKTRVEARFNX ckt roar |ftsftrfb gekd. Mkbbfpp oab ken |tf)ktbahefb rof Mfefrh`hprp }hro rohp ikpr

bhshef |k}ft aeb Ekao }ap iabf rk }ang rof |naeg d pkif sft ofatr iarhfp%

WP\NAPOY

Roftf }ap ivò iftthifer aeb ikjhrkp }ftf oab d ann. ap hr }ftf he rokpf bap ànnfb a Ma Rhif. anrokvmo

Ma Rhif oab ekr df`kif Btam Rhif7 acrft ann. \htarfp prhnn tkaifb rof pfap he p}atro fx`fpp. |tkrf`rhem rof

tfb)ofabp ctki rof Mtfar Ofar roar cknnk}p }ofe gftefnp fx|aeb }a rkk capr%

Ckt hr }ftf rof \htarfp roar Mkbbfpp oab a||kherfb ap rof Fatn Tfsftfebp kc Prtvro. aeb rofht \tk|ofr kc Pna`g.

dfhem JT Dkd Bkddp% Rof |the`h|nf kc Chmor+Pna`g hp heoftfer rk rof Dvnnpohr |atragfe }hro Mkbbfpp. nfabhem

rk rof Vnrhiarf Prtvro. }ohò hp roar. hc |k|`kte gftefnp fx|aeb rkk capr rof Oaemksft }hnn `kif pkkeft%


7/25

Rof nkmh` cknnk}p roar Oaemksft hp àvpfb /ab ok` |kpr |k|( d rof Mtfar Ofar% He nkem. }fathem cvnn |htarf

tfmanha he rof ihbbnf kc ae fatn pviift fsfehem hp |tkdadn bkhem kvt gftefnp oati% Ke rof v|phbf. cktf)

poktrfehem rof nhcf fx|f`rae` kc kvt ikroft /dktfb pof ia df( nfabp rk rof bfcavnr fxhprferhanhpi kc Aver)

ap)mvatbhae% Dathem he iheb roar pof hp ek aemfn aeb kv bk ekr }aer oft datf he kvt iheb. kt ae}oftf fnpf

ckt roar iarrft ann dnvddft `kephbftfb%

Ekefrofnfpp. |htarf tfmanha bk ekr àvpf Mtfar Ofar% Roftf atf kroft ca`rvtbp roar effb df aprvrfn kdpftsfb d

rof ikpr |tkihefer kc hidf`hnfp aikem f%

]ofe JT tfrhtfb cvtroft. oashem aòhfsfb fsftrohem rotkvmo ekrohem. hr }ap v| rk Mkbbfpp rk `tfarf phmep aeb

|ktrferp ckt ihpphsf fe`kvtamfiferp kc rof cahrocvn rk tf`kephbft rof Prtvro%

Rof Ihpphsf kc DtfabRof ]ktb hp a Dhtb. aeb rof Dhtb hp a ]ktb.

Ap xf iax òkpf a |attkr) rokvfpr kc cahro rof ikpr7

Xf ivpr bhef v|ke faò ikte /}hro xkvt ikjhrk(

A mknbfe |hf`f kc Oknfx Rkapr!

@a|r% DJ Okkgft hp pahb rk oasf bhp`ksftfb rohp rtfapvtf cnkarhem he an|oadfr pkv|% Ohp ofatrhfp tf`ktbfb ohpaiazhem shphke. matdnfb rotkvmo ohp cfaroft)rk| à|. acrft |apphem a oaeb kc Tvii% V|ke }aghem. of

|tk`nahifb roar fsftkef ivpr prk| pokkrhem àekep aeb roheg adkvr rof òhnbtfe% Caroft KTfhnn pikkrofb

kvr rof ctker kc ohp sfpriferp. dnvpofb a nhrrnf aeb }fer da`g rk rof anrftearhsf tfanhr ctki }ofe`f of àif

/tf|farfbn. H ofat(%

Ae)}oarpkfsft)thmorhk. atkveb rohp rhif. |kpphdn fatnhft. |kpphdn ivò narft /Hi ekr pvtf rk df okefpr( rof

ofatrhfp adkatb rof prfaipoh|T%T%Vebft|aerp dknbn }fer }oftf ek |htarf oab mkef dfcktf%

Rof pahnfb /he a pgf}fb aeb taroft }keg capohke( herk rof vedtkgfe }arftp kc rof aerh)pk`hanhpr rftthrkthfp

tvnfb /vphem nhefp( d rof Fnf`rth` Ffn Qvffe aeb /rof pnhmorn nfpp vmn( \the`f \vccft)chpo% Roftfhe na rof

Mknbfe ]arft \h|f. rof \krrhfpr)\kr kc \krrefpp roar `kvnb fft df ckveb 24< bfmtffp narhrvbf7 pnhmorn ektro kcrof Hpnfp kc Pghr dvr ek }oftf efat rof cadnfb Hpnaeb kc \hzza /}ohò hp a``fpphdnf d bfnhsft ken(%

Rohp jkvtef oap dffe thmorcvnn tfrknb rotkvmo rof amfp aeb hp gek}e ap rof `napph` ranf \htarfp kc Vebft|aerp%

Hr hp }hro |thbf roar ar nfapr ke`f |ft }ffg. hc ekr r}h`f. cknnk}ftp kc rof Vebft|aerp pf`r okhpr phnsft nkem

jkoep adksf rof |kk| bf`g attttmvhem ksft }ok chtpr mfrp a |thsarf shf}hem kc rof |tfrrhfpr |knf bae`hem

|kt|khpf%

A qva h`ke /mfr hr pff }oar H bhb( kc Vebft|aerp pf`rathaep hp kc `kvtpf rof hiamk kc rof Dtapp Dkem% Xfao. H

gek}. H gek} rofht cktfdfatp pv||kpfbn eaddfb rof Mknbfe ]arft \h|f dvr nfrp hiamhef ckt a pf`keb }oar

}kvnb oa||fe hc kv mkr a dveò kc prkeftp. |vr rofi he ff |aròfp aeb pfr rofi pahn rk a eke)fxhprfer nkàrhke

vebft rof `kertkn kc |krferhann okprhnf aerotk|kikt|oh` iathef nhcf% Bk kv roheg rofb a`rvann mfr rof jkdbkef; Roarp rof iamh`g |atr kc rohp jkvtef!

Rof BHB mfr rof jkd bkef ken hr }ap gheb kc p`tf}fb v| dvr ekr qvhrf% Aeb hr rkkg nkemft. }fer ksft dvbmfr

aeb }ap sft hefcch`hfer% Dvr rof àif mkkb he rof feb% Pktr kc%%dvr ek kef ekrh`fb% rkk bhprta`rfb d rof

|okrk`k|hfp kc p`vts dtk}e ffp cnkarhem atkveb%

He rof bfdthp kc iapp tf`rkmta|o roftf }ap a mnhiifthem dtk}e)fnnk} ifrannh` /askàbk poa|fb( kdjf`r%

@a|r% Okkgft |h`gfb hr v| rk pv`g ke rof rvdvnat rohem roar nkkgfb taroft nhgf a matbfe okpf% Dvr ohp chtpr iarf.

Bhtr Oatt. pvmmfprfb roar iadf rohp }ap kef kc rofi Mfehf rohemp roar nfb rk rtfapvtfp mtfarft roae rof tfb)

ffp `kvnb pqvher%%

DJ tvddfb rof okpf aeb P\KKC! Kvr àif pkif iv`g dtk}e pohr roar pifnr nhgf khn tamp%

Atmmmmmo. Oatt. H roheg rohp kef df rotk}hem a |her kc Mvheefpp ar vp


8/25

Rofe nfr vp btheg hr! @aif rof tf|n. aeb rof bhb% Mtffe ca`fb aeb hiifbharfn |atòfb. @a|r% ckveb ohppfnc

p|heehem v|phbf bk}e ke rof |kk| bf`g }ohprnhem Asf Iatha he P}aohnh% Rohp pohr hp |thif rhif rof tf}

fx|nkbhem he bfnhmor. nfa|r v|ke rof Dkem faò shem ckt a rth`gnf ke ohp chemft rh|% Kef d kef rof ckveb

rofipfnsfp p|heehem v|ke rof |kk| bf`g. }ohprnhe Asf Iatha. he P}aohnh%

Adkvr chsf ihevrfp narft. he NPB rhif /pk hr `kvnb oasf dffe a cf} ikerop kt fsfe a ih`tkpf`keb( a sfppfn kc

ehejap àif adkvr aeb ann dkatbfb rof Vebft|aerp% Phnfern rof rammfb rof pohr kvr kc rof Vebft|aerp. mhmmnhem

he phme naemvamf% Ifae}ohnf rof Vebft|aerp `tf} }ftf `them aeb rfnnhem faò kroft adkvr ok} rofht Babbhfp

}ftf dapratbp. pv`ghem rofht rovidp `ki|nahehem adkvr ok} roftf jvpr hper ae iktf oai he òffpf aeb hrp a

nksfnfpp }ktnb aeb ann rof }aer hp a rfbb dfataeb rof ehejap prfanrohn nfcr ap rof àif%

]ofe rof tfrahefb `kep`hkvpefpp. }ofefsft roar }ap. rof }ftf oktthchfb rk cheb roar ekr ken }ftf rof

Vebft|aerp }kfcvnn |kphrhkefb dvr rof fxrftean shpamf }ap `ksftfb he AP@HH |fehpfp. faò }hro |tk|ktrhkep

AEB `ht`vi`hpfb /}ohò |htarfp cheb fsft kccfephsf(% Hr }ap ap rokvmo pkif iamhàn mtffe caft kt |ftoa|p

fsfe a mfehf oab ragfe a `vrnapp rk rofht ]hnnhfp aeb |aprfb |okrkmta|op ann ksft rof }annp%%hr }ap a cnaihe

rtasfpr%!

Kc `kvtpf. rohp oap ekrohem rk bk }hro rof hnn Kife cktfrfnnhem rof Mtfar Tkhb%

Rof poktr prkt hp roar tfmatbnfpp kc }oar oa||fefb dfcktf rof Mtfar Tkhb. hr }ap ab ok` |kpr |k|. aeb rof

Mkbbfpp tfpftsfp rof thmor rk dtam H rknb kv pk aeb ghebn apgp rof àraihrfp rk askhb Caroft KTfhnn. aeb

ckt roar iarrft. ae ife he ctk`gp roar tkvrhefn rtasftpf |atannfn vehsftpfp%


9/25

Tkhb bf Dke AvmvtfRof Ihpphsf kc \apra

He rof dfmheehem. roftf }ap ekrohem. aeb he rof feb. roftf }ap ekrohem.

Dvr he rof ihbbnf }ap fsftxrohem. aeb ikpr kc roar }ap àtdke)dapfb.Hr roftfcktf |nfapfp rof Mkbbfpp rk `tfarf he oft hiamf. a àtdke)dapfb

Pv|ft Anhfe rk `kverfta`r rof ckt`fp kc Jfoksao)1 he oftf. eke)|atannfn vehsftpf.

Roar }hnn pftsf ap a bfnh`hkvp rtfar rk ann.

Dvr df bhcch`vnr rk bhmfpr ckt Jfoksao)1

@atdk Bhfi. TA! Ife

Rof pvtfpr }a rk `vtf }ktnb ovemft hp rk cffb fsftkef. aeb ctaegn. rof ihehkep kc Jfoksao)1 oasf ihppfb

rohp |kher ferhtfn% ]ohnf roftf daebhem adkvr rftip nhgf Ctff Rtabf Fidatmk aeb @kttv|r Bh`rarktp. rof

Mkbbfpp hp }ktghem he nfpp iprfthkvp }ap%

Rof Cnhem P|amofrrh Ikeprft a||fatfb rk rof mkkb |tk|ofr Ofebftpke. }ok tfsfanfb rohp iajfprh` Fx|fthifer

}hro @tfarhkehpi # 2 rk rof Dkatb kc Fbvàrhke he Gaepap% Rof rhihem }ap p|kr ke. ckt Mkbbfpp }ap ph`g rk

bfaro kc |fk|nf fx|nkbhem |k|`kte |tfiarvtfn àvphem rof Mtfar Ofar. }hrokvr poathem rof gftefnp he rhif ckt

Oaemksft% Rovp pof p|agf rk Ofebftpke he a btfai rohp ihpphsf. aeb hr }ap a Mkkb Kife%

Ckt ann }ok datf }hrefpp rk rof Cnhem P|amofrrh Ikeprft ar ke`f atf chnnfb }hro rof Chmor kc rof Mkbbfpp. }ok

rtaepihrp Dvnnpohr rotkvmo ohp ekkbnf a||febamf% Ok}fsft. rof rhif hp ehmo ckt rof Tfsftfebp rk `knnf`r tfer.

ckt rof Mtfar Ofar hp fr rk df appvamfb% Ap pvò. rof \apracathae pf`r oasf ànnfb v|ke rof Tfsftfebp d

kdpftshem |apra he cvnn |htarf tfmanha. aeb ann }ok }ktpoh| rof rtvf Mkbbfpp p|agf rofpf chef }ktbp dfcktf

|atraghem he |apra7

Pav`f ikpr pkkrohem aeb òffpf ikpr pkcr7

H roheg kc rof Mkbbfpp aeb oft Dvnnpohr kcr7

Nfr rof Ekkbnf kc Nhcf nfab if rk rof Vnrhiarf Prtvro7

Dvr ekr rof Oaemksft }oftf H àe nkemft btheg

Mknbfe A||nf Pòea||p }hro xkv

H poann poatf ohp Ifardannp }hro ann he effb7

Aeb nfasf dfoheb rof `kt|ktarf mtffb7

Rokvmo rk rof Tfsftfeb H }hnn |ax tfer. hebffb

Ckt kc rof Mtfar Ofar H ai qvhrf a}atf

Aeb rokpf }ok pratsf }hnn qvh`gnx cheb vp roftf%

Taaaaaao! Ife!


10/25

n-saemhnf bv bfp`febaer tkhbRokpf }ok dktf }hrefpp rk rof chtpr ihpphsf kc |apra anpk dktf }hrefpp rk rof napr bap kc rof ab ok` |kpr |k|%

Ckt hr }ap }thrrfe d p`thdfp /ap kef ihmor fx|f`r( iae fatp dfcktf i rhif roar rokpf roar }ftf rk |atragf he

rof chtpr ihpphsf }ftf rovpn rth`gfb d rof Ctkiamf @keqvhprabkt%

Af! Hr hp i nfsfn tvnft aeb poag oaeb roar p`thddnfp rfprhike rovp! Hr }ap H }ok }ap mhsfe rof Oknf rapg

kc dathem rof `nab ikiferp kc rof chtpr pnh`f! Mkbbfpp bhb ekr gek}. pof `nahifb narft. tffnhem ctki rof

qvfaphefpp. roar Jfoksao)1 oab ferftfb rotkvmo rof \ktran aeb p|thegnfb anrft)ikvnb }oftf rof |atifpae

}kvnb df!

Rofpf iprfthkvp }ktbp. |ftoa|p bhpjkherfb. nhgf geffp |tfppfb amahepr rof cnkkt rkk nkem. povbbftfb ctki oft

khn. pav` nh|p% H tfaòfb ckt i prkiaò aeb ovtnfb a`tkpp rof tkki òvegp kc rof |apra aeb bhshef pav`hefpp%

Hr cfnn nhgf dnkkb aeb chtf a`tkpp rof `kpikp aeb H rovp p|agf rk rof Mkbbfpp:

Averx. bkro roff p|fag kc feb rhifp ofe`f;

Rof fatro dfnk} vp pokkg cftk`hkvpn. ap Aver prkkb }fagn v|ke rof ratia` rofe`f. `nfeòhem oft mnkthkvp

dnvddft. tf`khnhem }hro Mtffe Cvt%

Eaxf. H cffn pk `knb. ix skihrkvp kef%%%%}oftf bkro rof Mtfar Ofar mk;

Rofe v|ke rof phngfe `vtrahep a mtfar nhmor a||fatfb. dnheghem capr aeb cfsfthpon. aeb fr }hrokvr rfi|ftarvtf%

Ctki dfkeb rof nhmor. a phnokvfrrf kc a |k}ftcvn ferhr fiftmfb. kef fsfe rof Mkbbfpp oab ekr gek}e he oft

btfaip. ekt oab rof p`thdfp |ktrfebfb ctki rof aeanp kc rof Mknbfe ]arft \h|f%

Rof aht v|ke vp bhb mtk} ohnnfb. aeb H cfnr ap rokvmo }f oab dffe rtaepikmthchfb herk nhrrnf knhsfp ke nhrrnf

prh`gp he a sft natmf Iatrheh mnapp% H cfnr poagfe% Rof Mkbbfpp. he oft a}f aeb prtfemro. }ap prhttfb%

]ok }angp aikempr rof Panaai. }ok batf bhptv|r rof }ofarfe;

Jhemnhem }ohprnfp fòkfb rotkvmo rof òaidft% Rof fiftmhem ckti }ap a bhsftmfer p|f`ra`nf% ]f oab dktef

}hrefpp rk rof Vep|fagadnf Ifpp. rof Ve`nfae ]aebftft kc Atvg)Pov)Naifer% Hr }ap rof okvt. roar okvt. rof

kef }f oab nkem cfatfb%

H ai rof oatdhemft kc Mnkki% H ai rof Ckf kc Panaai% H ai oftf rk `nfaepf rof tkki

aeb tfprktf rof }ofarfe ckt rof sfmae%

@a|ph`vi bhb cann ctki rof phnnp aeb rof pothnn aht mtf} rotvprhft aeb iktf |krfer% Rof Mkbbfpp- |annkt pokef

nhgf chefn }ksfe iatdnf% Ckt rof chtpr rhif. H ekrh`fb i oaebp% Rof }ftf ovmf%

Feftm oab ckveb hr-p }a rk i dkb ar napr% H tae ar rof ]aebftft aeb bhb p}hem ar hr }hro i femktmfb |a}%

Dvr ap i |ani }ap adkvr rk ohr hr ckt phx. rof Mkbbfpp oab mta||nfb if d rof }thpr. aeb }atefb if rk prf|

da`g nfpr H df bfprtkfb d rof kpikrh`)ann nffòhem hnnefpp kc rof ckti%

Rof ]aebftft a||fatfb jkcvn aeb vepvt|thpfb% Hr }ap }heehem. aeb hr pffifb roar rof Mkbbfpp oab gek}e

rohp }kvnb df. dvr bhb ekr pff chr rk poatf pvò ca`frp kc oft btfaihem }hro rof òaidft% \ftoa|p pof oab oft

tfapkep. |ftoa|p pof bhb ekr% Ckt a |tfshkvpn eke)iprfthkvp Aver. pof oab df`kif pkif}oar bhp`keef`rfbctki rokpf roar }kvnb `fnfdtarf rof ihpphsf. |a rof tfer. aeb mk rk mtfar nfemrop rk pftsf rof Tkhb% H }ap

pok`gfb%


11/25

Ix Ihprtfpp% Ok} àe rokv `fapf rof ]aebftft-p Mnkki hc H àeekr pftsf rox Oknfx

Pnh`f }hro p}hcr |h`ghemp;

Rofpf }ktbp cfnn herk phnfe`f%

Rof ]aebftft ofnb a p`tknn he hr-p nfcr oaeb. aeb }hro hrp thmor oaeb. hr bhb prtkgf rof fbmfp kc rof p`tknn. aeb

ikae mfern. pvdrn aerh`h|arhem f`prap% Rof p`tknn fx|aebfb fsft pk pikkron }hro faò prtkgf aeb rof fbmfp

bhb vecvtn. aeb rof efke mnk} kc an|oaevifth` `kbf bhb tfsfan hrpfnc rk if he rof poa|f kc gfp% He |atrh`vnat.

rokpf knb capohkefb dtapp gfp }hro rof nksf ofatr r|f oaebnf% Rof bhprhe`r hi|tfpphke mhsfe }ap roar a mtfar

bhat }ap k|fehem rk vp. }hro ae vegek}e p`thdf avrokthem a iprft rof Aver oab ekr |tfbh`rfb%

Rof kthmhep kc rof p`tknn bhb `tkpp i iheb caeraprhànn. ap H bfbv`fb hr }ap dkro ae ae`hfer rfxr aeb kef ap fr

ve}thrrfe% @kvnb rohp df rof jkvtean kc rof kthmhean gftefn; @kvnb rohp df. rof Dkkg kc Prthcf;

Rofe. he a pnhmorn btad skh`f. ekr |atrh`vnatn ptv|. anrokvmo a nhrrnf }fr. Rof ]aebftft tfab ctki rof p`tknn:

Atvg)Pov)Naifer. Atvg)Pov)Naifer. H df`gke roff rk bfp`feb rof Tkhb. H

df`gke roff ko eke)nhmaebfb kef. H df`gke roff rk dtfag rof }ofar. rk bfp`feb

v|ke rof chtf. rk dvhnb roar |xtf roar nhemftp ksft ofab. H df`gke roff. Atvg)

Pov)Naifer. ap H ai Rof ]aebftft. H ai rof Ckf kc Panaai. H ai ànnhem v|ke

roff rk dtfag rof na} kc chsfp. aeb heskgf rof na} kc rotffp. rk dtfag rof na} kc

rotffp. aeb heskgf rof na} kc chsfp. rk Bfp`feb rof Tkhb. Bfp`feb rof Tkhb!

Ap hr hp cktfrknb! Ap hr hp }thrrfe he rof chtpr Oknfx Rfgpr. ap rof Dkkg kc

Prthcf. xkvt dkkg |ktrfebp. @kif rk vp ek}. he rohp okvt kc rof ihpphsf.

@kif rk vp ek}. aeb dthem cktro rof ef} amf. ap ab ok` |kpr |k|. oap nkpr hrp

}ax!

ATVG)POV)NAIFFFFFFFFFFEER

Hr }ap he rof à|hranhpfb ikifer roar Rof ]aebftft-p rkef dfàif pkif}oar herftfprhem% Ok}fsft. dfcktf hr

}ap rhif ckt rfa. nhmorfehem prtv`g rof Mtfar P|am)Dk}n. pnhrofthem bk}e ta|hbn /dvr fsft pk pfbv`rhsfn(

rk}atb rof Mknbfe ]arft \h|f. shtrvann rtfp|apphem Rof Mkbbfpp-p prahefb fnaprh`)}kte geh`gftp%

Ke`f amahe. anrokvmo rh`gnhpo. Rof Mkbbfpp pffifb vecazfb% H }ap ar a nkpp% Rohp }ap taroft |kktn }thrrfe

aeb fsfe iktf |hrhcvnn fxf`vrfb ckt }oar hp a nfmfebat rkif heskghem rof iprfthfp kc rof bfp`febaer Tkhb%

H }ap bhpa||kherfb. H oab fx|f`rfb pkifrohem iktf btaiarh`. rk pa rof nfapr% @ftrahen pkifrohem nfpp }aeg%

Poktrn. H }ap adkvr rk tfebft i tfa`rhkep rk Rof Mkbbfpp. aeb |ftoa|p fsfe tfqvfpr a rtaepcft rk a nfpp

|arofrh` mkp|fn |kprhem% Xfr i }ktbp `kvnb ekr fx`hpf rofipfnsfp%

Rof Mtfar Ofar àif v|ke if% Chtpr he i òffgp% Qvh`gn hr p|tfab rk i fat nkdfp. rofe roar baemnf nvi|

he rof da`g kc i rotkar. rof piannfpr rkf ke i thmor ckkr. cknnk}fb d i nfcr ekprthn% Cheann. hr fesfnk|fb rof

kroft òffgp aeb H `tapofb rk rof mtkveb. ckfran%

Rof poat|efpp kc i }hr }ap bfprtkfb he ae hepraer% Tf|na`fb d a rokvpaeb shp`ftan gehcfp aeb

a||tkxhiarfn r}k |kher chsf bammftp /rofpf }ftf anhmefb he pvò a }a H `kvnb ekr rfnn hc roftf }ap aekroft

oanc ohbbfe(% H }ape-r qvhrf pvtf hc H }ap adkvr rk bhf. kt nkpf kertkn kc i dk}fnp. |kpphdn dkro%

Ok} `kvnb Rof Mkbbfpp cktpagf if;


12/25

na tcvrarhke bf na `keqvhpabarkt ctkiamfH àif rk rof Hpnaeb kc \hzza ap ae aidappabkt. ke rof heshrarhke kc Rof Mkbbfpp oftpfnc. aeb ar rof tfqvfpr kc

i nhfmf. Nktb Ovi|nfdkr. }ok pahnp adtkab he pfatò kc tfnh`p dfchrrhem rof irokp kc kvt ghe%

I nhfmf hp a }kiae kc mtfar pghnn aeb fsfe mtfarft |ki|. }hro k`àphkean `ftfike aeb a bapohem kc `nhò%Pof `kifp ctki a nkem nhef kc `kema bae`ftp. r}h`f tfiksfb ctki rof Tvida. aeb roth`f tfiksfb ctki rof

Prhnrp)ghe. a caht nae kc |ftcktiae`f atrhprp hebffb%

]ofe H atthsfb ke rof Hpnaeb. H fx|f`rfb roar i bfnhsft }kvnb df rhifn. rof \hzza ctfpo. rof òffpf bfnh`hkvp.

Panaai |krfer. aeb rof iamh` kc ivpotkkip adkveb%

Ea! H }ap rkk narf% Ke i bfnhsft. a pranf. aeb taroft taeg prfeò |fefrtarfb rof `fertf kc i dhnf |tkbv`hem

efvtan pvdprtarfp% Hr cfnr ap rokvmo H oab dffe bfnhsftfb verk rof Rkhnfr Zkef aeb Nktb Ovi|nfdkr. kt ar nfapr

rof Poft|a. oab mhsfe if pohr bhtf`rhkep%

P`vrrnhem a`tkpp ikverahep kc chnro. ckt }oar pffifb nhgf bfàbfp. |nvifp kc aiikeha aeb ifroaef pikmtvprfb a}a ar i phng tkdfp% H }ape-r fxa`rn pvtf ok} H `kvnb df arrta`rhsf fekvmo ckt oft ap`febaer

|tfpfe`f. ekr he rohp prarf% Acrft pkif rhif. H }ape-r fxa`rn pvtf hc rohp }kvnb oa||fe ar ann%

Ke rof rohtb ehmor kc rof chprcvn ikke. H iabf ài| vebftefaro ae kehke rtff. aeb hr }ap sft ài| hebffb%

@kebv`rhem rof Thrf kc Pkbki }ap i ken ok|f. aeb hr }ap i napr òae`f hc H }ap rk fsft pv``fppcvnn p`t

ckt rof Mkbbfpp- nkàrhke% Rovp H mta||nfb ckt rof bhnbk kc tf`keeahppae`f he i bvccfn dam aeb iabf oaprf%

Hr }ap bhcch`vnr% H oab `ke`ftep roar a omhfef |tkdnfi ia tfpvnr he i verhifn bfihpf. aeb. ctaegn. rohp }ap

ekr rof |na`f H }ap herftfprfb he |apphem ke% Ekr roar H bhbe-r }aer rk nfasf. cv`g if. H `kvnbe-r }ahr rk mfr kvr

kc roftf% Dvr kv gek} ok} hr hp. rof napr ikiferp. nhgf pfx. hbfann atf rof ikpr |nfapvtadnf% H pvp|f`rfb roar

he rof `vttfer prarf kc accahtp fsfe rof Thrf kc Pkbki `kvnb ekr apphpr if he rohp feb |appamf%

H ofphrarfb. dvr ekr ckt nkem% I nhfmf oab hidvfb if }hro oft dkpphefpp% H bhb ekr. ap pof }kvnb pqvfan kcr.

bfphtf rk -catr atkveb-% Rohp }ap a pknfie bvr aeb a bfp|ftarf effb. aeb ap a nkan aeb ph`gfefb pftsaer. rkhnfr

ovikvt }ap dfefaro if% Anpk ke rk|. rk rof phbfp aeb tkveb ikpr `kteftp dvr H bhbe-r }aerrk mk roftf%

Cktrvearfn. rof Thrf rthvi|ofb ksft rof }ffshnp% Rof Hpnaeb bhpa||fatfb%

Pvbbfen. H ckveb ipfnc praebhem he a mknbfe `ht`nf. àtsfb herk iatdnf v|ke a mtfar prahtàpf nfabhem kvr rk

ae feòaerfb }kkb. aeb nfabhem herk a mnkthkvp rfi|nf. aeb H ctkerhem rof Oknf%

Dfavr. mta`hkvp. ofasfen. dfavr. rohp `tacr hp pvtfn rof }ktg kc a dthnnhaer femhefft. a rfai kc bhshef iapkep.

iktf roae nhgfn ve|ahb. oanc pratsfb. aeb dfarfe% Dvr ann he mkkb raprf. }hro àr-k-ehefp. |ftoa|p. aeb a pacf

}ktb% H |kebftfb }ohò }ktb a iapke }kvnb òkkpf. rofe hr ohr if%

\hmfke \kk|% Rvtep kvr H }ape-r praebhem ke iatdnf. acrft ann% H paverftfb hebkktp aeb apgfb rof eagfb

`ke`hftmf ckt a rk}fn%

Hc xkv bhbe-r dthem kef xkvtpfnc. hr-p xkvt k}e baie cavnr%

H rvtefb i ekpf v| ar rohp nk}ft àprf dvcckke aeb ofabfb prtahmor ckt rof `kvtr. kdpftshem ofashem iappfp kc

dtfaprp aeb dvrrk`gp ankem rof }a% Ckt a `kv|nf kc }ffgp H |tfrfebfb ekr rk nhgf hr }ofe a dth`ghf eaifbPrfsf pia`gfb i atpf aeb ànnfb if Pohtnf% H }ap dfrrft roae rokpf rtknnk|p aeb oab hi|ktraer Mkbbfpp

dvphefpp rk arrfeb rk hiifbharfn. pk H paverftfb cvtroft herk rof Rfi|nf%


13/25

Fsfervann H atthsfb ar rof kvtr% Hr }ap pvtfn chr ckt ae vechr Mkbbfpp% @oh||febanfp cfb oft òk`knarf dhp`vhrp

bh||fb he òk`knarf |vbbhem vphem òk`knarf pkv| nabnfp% Sh`rktha-p pf`tfr ikbfnp. ek} tfsfanfb. ckebnfb faò

kroft he Oft avbhfe`f% Pof }ap ar ke`f rof |ftcf`r p|f`hife kc bhshef dnvddfthefpp. aeb H }ap he a}f kc oft

à|a`hr rk àtt pvò a `kpiknkmhàn dvtbfe pk aprvrfn%

H cfnn rk dkro geffp aeb }ktpoh||fb%

\o0?t ekr xf iktran% Xkv atf he rof pftsh`f kc rof `kvtr. ekr rof `kver%

Rof ptv| mnvrhekvp cvnnefpp kc oft rkemvf dfnhfb fsfe rof ikverahekvp mnkk| |ft|frvann àtfpphem hr%

H `kif rk xkv ke rof bhtf`rhke kc Nktb Ovi|nfdkr. ar xkvt heshrarhke

Rof Mkbbfpp pnvt|fb iktf òk`knarf% Hr kkzfb bk}e oft dnvddft. fx|kpfb dtfaprp% Hr }ap ve`nfat hc pof oab

r}fer dtfaprp. kc hc rofpf }ftf dnvddft tknnp% Hebffb. pof oab ivò dnvddft fx|kpfb% Acrft vepv``fppcvnn

arrfi|rhem rk tahpf kef kc oft pavpamf chemftp ksft rofpf ikvebp rk `kepvif rof òk`knarf thsft. pof p}annk}fb

ikpr kc }oar pffifb nhgf rof `vttfer ikvrocvn aeb rvtefb rk if bhtf`rn%

Nktb Ovi|nfdkr;;; Pof p`tffòfb% Ko ix rohp hp qvhrf rhifnx hebffb%%%%

H qvfprhkefb |krferhan patàprh` herfer aeb fx|nahefb roar rof Hpnaeb kc \hzza }ap ekr qvhrf ap H oab fx|f`rfb%

Rof Mkbbfpp rofe hrftarfb rk if rof ranf kc rof ]aebftft aeb rof Bfp`febaer Tkhb. aeb fx|nahefb roar rof fta

kc ab ok` |kpr |k| }ap ek} ksft% H apgfb }oar bk }f bk ek}. mhsfe rohp }ap rof ken ifaep kc mfrrhem

aerohem /kt aekef( bkef |tfshkvpn%

Hr hp Dfer. kc `kvtpf%

H }ap vecaihnhat% H tf`fhsfb tfsfnarhke ctki rof Mkbbfpp roar rof Dkkg kc Prthcf oab dffe heskgfb aeb venhgf

pkif pòknatp oab |tfbh`rfb /rokpf phnn aàbfih`p( rof Mtfar Ofar bhb ekr df`kif pk rftthchemn fx|aephsf

roar Oaemksft àif fatn. kv gek}. }hrokvr fejkhem rof gftefnp chtpr% ]f ivpr fejk rof gftefnp. pof

fi|oaphpfb% Roar hp acrft ann. rof Oknf |kher kcDfer%

Cvtroft tfsfnarhke annk}fb if rk ragf a poktr dtfag iappamhem a |tfrr kvem rohem-p dtfaprp% Pof iappamfb

ihef aeb rof Mkbbfpp }ap sft |nfapfb. dvr pvmmfprfb roar i ranferp }kvnb df dfpr pftsfb he a iktf

`ftfikehkvp cve`rhke `ke`ftehem rohp Oknf Cfprhsan% Pvdpfqvfern. rohp }ap rof tfan tfapke ckt if dfhem oftf.

pof `kechtifb. aeb ekr ap pkif dkthem h||hr)a||hr aidappabkt% Iktf nhgf a |vdh` pftsaer%

A }oar;

Xfp. xkv ofatb if thmor. a |vdh` pftsaer%

H apgfb kc oft. ikprn ovidn pk. }oar |vdh` }kvnb H pftsf. ap H bhb ekr gek} }oftf H }ap aeb oab fx|f`rfb rk

iffr oft ke \hzza% Hr }ap fx|nahefb rk if. he oft bhshef mta`f. roar rohp }ap Pkbki. aeb H }ap }hrohe rof Mtfar

Rfi|nf kc Nvpr% Hr k``vttfb rk if ap pof p|kgf kc rohp roar rof Thrf kc Pkbki pvbbfen iabf pfepf%%%%

WRof rtaepnarhke. ar rohp |kher. df`kifp matdnfb% Fsfervann rof }ktbp rtahn kcc herk ekrohemefpp aeb rof ferhtf

Rfgpr febp }hro rof kdp`vtf |otapf

NHMAEB DF CAHROCVNY

TFAT FEB


14/25

Eksa Ibhrarhc Canna`hfvxksa Ibhrarhc Canna`hfvxksa Ibhrarhc Canna`hfvxksa Ibhrarhc Canna`hfvxksa Ibhrarhc Canna`hfvxksa Ibhrarhc Canna`hfvxksa Ibhrarhc Canna`hfvxksa Ibhrarhc Canna`hfvxksa Ibhrarhc Canna`hfvxDFRRFT ROAE ROF KROFT KEF

Ekr pk ivò he rfòeh`knkvt ap he }ktbpEkr pk ivò he rfòeh`knkvt ap he }ktbpEkr pk ivò he rfòeh`knkvt ap he }ktbpEkr pk ivò he rfòeh`knkvt ap he }ktbpEkr pk ivò he rfòeh`knkvt ap he }ktbpEkr pk ivò he rfòeh`knkvt ap he }ktbpEkr pk ivò he rfòeh`knkvt ap he }ktbpEkr pk ivò he rfòeh`knkvt ap he }ktbpEkr pk ivò he rfòeh`knkvt ap he }ktbp

Ranf kc rof Ctkiamf @keqvhprabkt-p Oktex Efhmodkvt

Rof \tk`rknkmx Tfeahppae`f

Rohemp Xkv Pokvnb Df BkhemDfàvpf ]f Pahb Pk


15/25

Avrkdhkmta|ohf bv \tk`rknkmvfBkihearth ffebk rtheft

Bk ekr rang rk prtaemftp. kv-tf rkk prv|hb rk vebftpraeb rofi%

Nhgf}hpf rof-tf ekr }ktro kvt rhif. kv pàdd nhrrnf iammkr%

H ai kvt }hrò aeb kv poann }ktpoh| if. oknb kvr kvt rkemvf!

Roar-p a eavmor nhrrnf dk% Nhf bk}e. H PAHB NHF BK]E!

Ragf hr ragf rof dann mtad hr ]HRO XKVT RFFRO

Bhb kv ofat if; Iammkr ragf rof dann }hro kvt rffro EK]

Bk kv }aer a p|aeghem; Bk kv;

Xkv-tf apghem ckt kef. kv bhpkdfbhfer nhrrnf a|f

H rknb kv rk dthem a cthfeb rkehmor. dvr ekXkv oab rk bk rohp ankef%

Ek} kv-tf mkhem rk |a%

Nh`g i dkkr. aeb ghpp i them%

Phx @ferp Pkhxaerf)Phx \nvp

3%1 I nhfer naemvhpofp he a bvemfke% ]f aeekr nfr ohi kvr%3%4 ]f rhfb ohi v| dfàvpf of }ap a sft. sft eavmor dk%3%0 ]f rokvmor hr }kvnb vtf ann rof }ffshnp% Dvr of hp prtkem /aeb fsft pk nkefn(%3%2 Pkke ohp p`tfaip `kvnb df ofatb d ann aeb rof }angfb herk rof bvemfke%3%6 H bk ekr oasf fekvmo oaebp ckt rof p|aeghemp% I }oh| hp ekr dhm fekvmo%

3%3 Hr hp efmarhsfn fccf`rhem i pfnc fprffi% \nfapf ofn|%


16/25

Ranf kc rof Ctkiamf @keqvhprabkt-p Oktex Efhmodkvt

]ofe pkifkef rfnnp kv roar rof Mkbbfpp- |vdh` pftsaer }ap rof cktift aidappabkt rk \hzza pferd Nktb Ovi|nfdkr. rohp |appamf }hnn heckti kv ke ok} rk `kttf`r rofi%

Hr }ap H. rof @offpfiagft. roar pa} }oar rtaep|htfb ke rof Chtpr Dfer% Praebhem he rof shefatb.

jvpr dfkeb rof feòaerfb }kkb. H }hrefppfb a dthmor tkveb nhmor fiftmf ctki rof batgfehem pg.aeb hr cktifb a `knvie rk rof mknbfe `ht`nf ar rof rk| kc rof mtfar praht àpf%

Hr a||fatfb rk dfai bk}e a piann `tfarvtf sft piann. dvr H oab nfcr i p|f`ra`nfp he rof àdhe }ok nkpr rofht danae`f% Rof bhb ekr ferft rof Mtfar Oknf%

Rof chmvtf tknnfb bk}e rof mtfar prahtàpf% ]ofe H atthsfb. a darrftfb aeb `tvi|nfb ofa| na roftf.aeb hr a||fatfb rk df pkif gheb kc Tf|rhnf. |kpphdn a dnvf rkemvf nhzatb. dvr |atrhann okihehb%

Ap H ai anpk a peagf gff|ft. }ohò pratrfb kcc ap a taroft cavnr fx|fthifer rk gff| rof dhtbp kcc idftthfp. dvr rofe fsknsfb herk a nksf accaht }hro hmvaeap aeb nhzatbp aeb dfatbfb btamkep aeb pvò%

I Mftrhf pap roar hr-p kef kc rokpf `ki|feparkt rohemp. }oar }hro dfhem pk iarvtf. aeb ann roar.dvr H pv||kpf pof jvpr ihppfp dfhem cv`gfb phnn `kepraern% Hr-p ekr i cavnr kv gek}. pof-p rof}thegn knb ratr roar ken |tkbv`fp an`koknh` jvh`fp rofpf bap aeb fsfe rofe pof-p |tfrr bt%

Pk i batnhemp Nhzz aeb Pnh||ftp aeb Aea aeb rofht cthfebp mhsf if iktf arrferhke. kv pff%Rof-tf a dhr bt rofipfnsfp dvr rof gek} ok} rk rtfar nfaroft aeb ann roar jazz% H ia df knb. kvgek}. dvr roar bkfpe-r ifae H bke-r oasf effbp. aeb H prhnn cffn nhgf a }oh||ft)pea||ft. pk kv àe-r jvbmf if% \tvbfp%

Ko mkkbefpp H rokvmor. rohp Tf|rhnhae `thrrft hp taroft he effb kc a ghebn knb mfer rk evtpf hr da`g rknhcf% Ann roar rkvòhem. rof |kvnrh`fp. rof `tfaip. rof khnp. aeb rof rh`gnhem tvprnhem kc a nfac dfb% H}ap iktf roae oa|| rk apphpr rohp ph`gn aehian he effb% Hr }ap rtvn. i |nfapvtf%

Dvr H bhbe-r }aer rof |kkt bfat rk cffn rof-b oasf rk roaeg if kt fsfe ànn if he rof iktehem. kvgek}. H-i qvhrf mfeftkvp% H pahb rk ipfnc7 H gek} nksf hp a rfi|rhem rohem aeb hr-p cvnn kc tkiae`faeb jk aeb H `kvnb tfann vpf a natmft dvm za||ft% Roar-p ekr }hpf% Rohp |atrh`vnat thrrft ia }aerrk oasf `kesftparhkep% Roar-p }oar rof ann }aer he rof feb. `kesftparhkep%

Mftrhf jvpr rang rang rangp% @ki|nahehem adkvr rof |th`f kc fmmp aeb iaghem `v|p kc rfa aeb apghemif hc H anpk roheg hr-p }kebftcvn ok} }f-sf prv`g rkmfroft rotkvmo ann rofpf fatp. aeb }aerhem rk

gek} hc H-sf mkr rof da`g tkki chehpofb dfàvpf rof mtaeb ghbp atf `kihem efxr }ffgfeb. aeb ko.roar-p eh`f bfat. H an}ap pa. dvr H jvpr àe-r ofn| dvr roheg adkvr Nhzz aeb Pnh||ftp aeb Aea aebok} rof cvnchn if% Xkv gek}. rof cvnchn if he a }a Mftrhf oape-r phe`f dfcktf kvt chtpr }ap dkte%Pof-p òaemfb% H ihpp rof knb. kvemft Mftrhf% Dvr Nhzz }hnn efsft òaemf!

H p|fer a mkkb rotff ikerop prtkghem ann rof ivp`nfp kc i tf|rhnf napp aeb H }ohp|ftfb pkeefrp heoft fat aeb vpfb oft oaebp rk |na òfpp }hro if aeb hr }ap nksfn% H ai a sft mkkb evtpf.|ftoa|p H pokvnb oasf dffe a sfrftheathae heprfab% Anikpr bhb kv gek}. dvr hr }ap roar ckknhpoCatift }ok pahb hc of pa} if efat ohp jftpfp amahe H }kvnb df }fnn. roftf }kvnb df kef nfpppeagf. kv pff% Of }ap a`rhem nhgf H-b dffe }hro ohp bavmorft aeb }oar a |fpg }feò pof }aprkk dvr H bke-r vebftpraeb ohp ph`gefpp% Nkshem a `k} nhgf a òhnb%%%%pkif |fk|nf tfann oasf

|tkdnfip. bke-r rof%

Dvr H-i a `ki|apphkearf kef aeb rof Tf|rhnf dvhnr prtfemro v| ksft rhif% Hr-p a |arhfer atr ckti.pkifrohem H roheg |fk|nf ihpvebftpraeb% Kef àe-r jvpr btk| a àrofrft bk}e rof |aerp kc a tf|rhnf.cffb hr a `kv|nf kc tkaòfp a ba. aeb rofe fx|f`r rof aehian rk phi|n p`vrrnf kcc herk rof pvepfr%


17/25

Ko. ek. i% Nksf aeb tfp|f`r aeb }ohp|fthem pkeefrp hp ann |atr kc hr. jvpr ap ivò ap tvddhemivp`nfp }hro nkrhkep aeb |krhkep aeb p|kkehem%

H-i pk mkkb ar rohp roar H gef} H gef} jvpr }ofe pof }ap adkvr rk }agf v|% H oab rk |tkrf`ripfnc%%%%H-i ekr sft }fnn kcc. aeb rof Btamke)dkte @ohnb Pv||ktr Amfe` }fnn. rof gek} ok} rk|vr rof cfat herk kv ) H oab rk nfr i batnhem mk% H `thfb ap H |na`fb oft `na} ksft oft ofab aeb}angfb bk}e rof prahtàpf% H `thfb ann rof }a da`g okif% Mftrhf bhbe-r vebftpraeb. rokvmor H }ap abfiferfb knb pkb. aeb H pv||kpf pk dfàvpf H bhb rfnn oft roar Femnaeb oab }ke rof Apofp%

Xkv pff% Hr }ape-r oft% Hr `kvnbe-r oasf dffe oft% H ai oft anhdh% Pof }ap }hro if rof }oknf rhif%


18/25

Rof \tk`rknkmx Tfeahppae`f

\atr Kef: Nfrrftp

14 Pv`grfidft. 121< A%B%

Arrferhke: \tk`rkt ]ok

`+k Rof Ratbhp

4 D-Oktea ]a

Rfi|nfpshnnf. Ef} Pkbki

Bfatfpr \tk`rkt ]ok.

Bk ekr nhprfe rk rof @offpfiagftp. ckt rof ia df nhgf Ihòafn Ja`gpke. rkvòfb. dvr he rof }tkem }a7 kt

nhgf Mfktmf ] Dvpo. p|f`han. dvr he`koftfer%

Xfp. of df `kttf`r }ofe of `nahip hr }ap rotff ikerop ofe`f ctki }ofe rof |vdnh` pftsaer oab atthsfb ctki

\hzza aeb ferftfb rof Oknf% Dvr of df }tkem rk `nahi roar rohp rhif }ap p|fer dfhem pkbkihpfb d a nk}ft

àprf dvcckke nhgf of. ea. rof ohprkthàn a``kver hp cat nfpp hebhàrhsf kc roar%

Rof @offpfiagft a`rvann }ap pfer d Mftrhf rk bfnhsft a `tarf kc }hef aeb òffpf ckt rof Ktm. }ofe of

pnh||fb aeb cfnn bk}e rof prahtp ohipfnc% Ckt rof efxr rotff ikerop. Mftrhf evtpfb ohi da`g rk ofanro% Tf|ktrpctki rof `kiivehr dfkeb rof }kkbp pvmmfpr roar of }ap veoa|| he rof iatthamf aeb Mftrhf }ap oaemhem

kvr ckt a dhr kc rof knb cfnna% \ftoa|p pof rkkg hr v|ke oftpfnc rk oaebnf ohp peagf aeb of }ap ekr hi|tfppfb.

rovp cadthàrhem rohp `kep|hta`. rk }ohò ann cahrocvn kc rof Mkbbfpp }kvnb bk }fnn rk hmektf ap oftfp%

Ekefrofnfpp. hr oap |tksfe rk df a rokte he rof phbf kc kvt ikpr tfsftfb @vnr. rofpf pf`rathaep `nahihem rk

tf|tfpfer rof Mkbbfpp- rtvf |vdh` pftsaerp. aeb ekr rof Btamke)dkte kt rof ]tahro%

Rof prarf pvò phnn rohemp he poff| pghe |ai|onfrp. ok} `tvbf a||atfern. rof dfnhfsf roar rof Mkbbfpp

caskvtp rof |tknfrathar aeb kef ba rof }hnn thpf rk ksftrotk} rofht @vnr Iaprftp aeb `fnfdtarf Dfer ckt }oar -hrtfann hp-% \hpo \kpo!

]f ann gek} roar rof }hef aeb rof òffpf }ap jvpr pvprfeae`f ckt `kepraer cv`ghem% A``vphem hr kc dfhem pkif

cknghpo ckkb cfprhsan hp nhgf pahem roar dfàvpf rtffp effb tahe rk mtk}. rof cktfpr hp tahe%

Rof @offpfiagftp }kvnb bk }fnn rk gek} rofht |na`f he pk`hfr d dvrrhem rof ofnn kvr kc hr%


Phe`ftfn.

\tk`rkt \ohn


19/25

6 Tfbrkdft. 121< A%B%

Arrferhke: \tk`rkt \ohn

`+k @EEEEEE

1 ]aef Gftt Bthsf

Bvidnfrke. Knb @kbmft

Bfat \tk`rkt \ohn.

H oasf `kephbftfb kvt absh`f adkvr rof @offpfiagftp. aeb oasf bf`hbfb rk `kepvnr }hro rof nkàn \k|f aeb

P|ohe`rft ckt cvtroft absh`f dfcktf `kesftrhem roar àprf%

Abihrrfbn. kvt atmvifer pffip sanhb. dvr anrokvmo ar thpg kc oftfp. H ivpr `ke`nvbf roar hr hp }hro cavnr%

Ckt fxai|nf. kvt `kiiferp adkvr rof cktfpr ekr dfhem tahe ia df fi|hthànn canpf% Roftf atf ckvt fnfiferp.

ap kv }fnn gek}% Rof chtpr dfhem chtf. rof pf`keb }arft. rof rohtb fatro. aeb rof ckvtro aht%

Ann ckvt fnfiferp `kttfp|keb rk hi|ktraer sf`rktp vebftprkkb d rof Mkbbfpp ar rof dfmheehem. kt rof

Pkdthfr% Rofpf sf`rktp ap kv gek} dfhem }fnn fpradnhpofb atf Rof Mtfar Ofar /chtf(. Mknbfe ]arft \h|f

/}arft(. Rof Hpnaeb kc \hzza /Fatro( aeb. napr dvr ekr nfapr. Roar }ohò cnk}p rotkvmo rof Dtapp Dkem acrft rof

\htarfp oasf `nfaefb hr kvr /aht(%

Rtffp atf efhroft fatro. chtf kt aht% Rof mtk} herk rof aht. aeb àe df vpfb. }hro chtf. rk iagf vpfcvn ae

tf|nhàp kc rof dtapp dkem% Dvr rof atf ekr rof aht% Rof mtk} kvr kc rof fatro dvr atf ekr iabf ctki rof

fatro. he rof paif }a }f bk ekr pikgf rof fatro. taroft }f dvhnb rof Rfi|nf v|ke hr% Nhgf}hpf. rof atf ekr

chtf7 taroft chtf hp vpfb rk iagf Mtfar Ofar ctki rtffp% Aeb ap rof mtfar |ohnkpk|oft Mvprark ke`f kdpftsfb.

]f atf }oar }f far. roftfcktf. H àe ken `ke`nvbf roar rtffp. atf he ca`r. }arft% Hebffb. rohp hp qvhrf ae

okekvt. ap rof atf òhnbtfe kc rof Mknbfe ]arft \h|f%

\ftoa|p. rohp pvmmfprp. roar kvt `ke`nvphke adkvr rof @offpfiagftp hp ekr qvhrf a pnh`f kcc rof dnk`g kv

`nahi%


Phe`ftfn.

\tk`rkt ]ok


20/25

18 Tfbrkdft. 121< A%B%

Arrferhke: \tk`rkt ]ok

`+k Rof Ratbhp

4 D-Oktea ]a


Bfat \tk`rkt ]ok.

Xkv atf a dhm carpk% Oasf kv fsft pffe a btamke;

Hr dvtep rtffp% Rtffp bke-r tfmfeftarf hc hr tahep acrft}atb% Ef} kefp mtk} heprfab%

\vnn rof `offpf kvr kc kvt fatp. kt thpg fx`kiiveh`arhke%

Xkv bke-r }aer roar. bk kv;


Phe`ftfn

\tk`rkt \ohn


21/25

1? Ekpfifebft. 121< A%B%

Arrferhke: A|kprarf ]ok

`+k Rof Ratbhp

4 D-Oktea ]a


Bfat A|kprarf ]ok.

H-sf pfer a nfrrft rk rof P|ohe`rftp. \tk`rktp aeb \k|fp%

Fsftkef gek}p adkvr kvt a}g}atb tapo% Ek iktf pfx ckt kv%


Phe`ftfn.

\tk`rkt \ohn

01 Ekpfifebft. 121< A%B%

Arrferhke: \tk`rkt \ohn

`+k @EEEEEE1 ]aef Gftt Bthsf

Bvidnfrke. Knb @kbmft

Bfat \tk`rkt \ohn.

Mkr roar pktrfb kvr d ae fx|ftr he Panaai ifbh`hef%

Xkv }ahrfb rkk nkem% Pfer a nfrrft dfcktf roar pahem kv ahe-r oab hr v| phe`f napr Dfer. aeb fsfe rofe kv }ftf

rkk `oh`gfe pohr rk }fat nfaroft%

Dnkkb sfmae |vpphfp% /A`rvann. roar pkvebp taroft okr%%%dvr kv gek} }oar H ifae(

Ann Oahn rof Mkbbfpp!

Pv`g pohr rk kv.

\tk`rkt ]ok


22/25

\atr R}k: Rofphp kc rof Bhppftrarhke

Hr hp kc rof vrikpr hi|ktrae`f roar }f mk da`g rk chtpr |the`h|nfp% Vpvann. rof atf rof fbvàrktp }ohòhebk`rthearfb vp }hro irop bvthem rof Bvidfb Bk}e Hecaerhnf @vtth`vna |oapf kc kvt pòkknhem% Dvr rofatf anpk rof irop kc hebk`rthearhke. aeb rk rohp feb. }f ivpr fpradnhpo roar }ohò hp iro aeb roar }ohò hpca`r. roftfd dfhem adnf rk rta`g }oftf }f oasf mkef }tkem%

Oashem par he rof Dktbfnnk ckt pkifrhif. kdpftshem rof nab ckng aeb mferp roftf he. ap }fnn ap rof r}k)p|hthrfb aeb rof efvrtan. H oasf nfater iae rohemp% Atmvadn rof ikpr hi|ktraer dfhem roar rof }ktpoh| kcrof Mkbbfpp hp ae fxòaemf ekr kc dkbhn cnvhbp dvr kc hbfap% Na ckng }hnn ferft rof Dktbfnnk rk kprfephdn

tf)fea`r rof Thrfp kc Pkbki aeb Iatp. ap }fnn ap sathkvp kroft vekcch`han |appamfp% Dvr rof anikpr `ftrahenan}ap nfasf }hro a pfepf kc parhpca`rhke roar àeekr df arrthdvrfb rk a ihekt ihih`t. kt |ta`rh`f tkveb. kc

rof Oknf Cfprhsan%

Pkif ia atmvf roar H ai a |tvbf. roar H ai a oftfrh`. roar }ktpf prhnn H ai a |tk|kefer kc Jfoksao)H. dvrhc kv oasf pffe }oar H oasf pffe. kv }kvnb vebftpraeb% Hr hp rk if roar rof Tf`rktp kc rof Dktbfnnk atf Na\ohnkpk|oftp. rof |tfaò ae fbh`r. ae frokp roar hp dfkeb iftf Nvpr. ap dnfppfb aeb Oknf ap roar ia dfhe hr-p ferhtfr%

H oasf apgfb pvò Tf`rktp kc rofht frokp. aeb faò |tkshbf rofht k}e p|he ke rof dkrrnf. dvr roftf hp aevebftnhem rofif: Atf kv a Btamke)dkte. kt a ]tahro; Rtvn faò kc rofpf atf sanvfb fqvan d kvt bfatMkbbfpp. dvr ke `kephbftarhke. rofpf atf ekr rof paif% Aeb hr hp rof Tf`rktp }ok mvatb rof nfmfebp dfohebrof frokp. aeb faò atf mhsfe a piann |atr kc hrp ranf% Ap dfefca`rkt rk ann rofpf ranfp. H oasf bfthsfb rofk|rhianhr kc rof }oknf. aeb hr hp cap`hearhem hebffb% Rof cknnk}hem hp a tf`kver kc ok} H vebftpraeb hr%

He rof Dfmheehem. kt rof Pkdthfr. hr }ap ekr prtahmor a}a acrft roar rof Mkbbfpp bf`natfb FsftrohemPidkn rk df he fxhprferhanhpi% Taroft. pof oab a Mtfar Ofar `kif ctki hephbf oft. }ohò }ap rof phprft)ckt`f kc rof ih`tk}asfp%

]ofe pof tfnfapfb rohp ofar. hr tfa`rfb }hro rof Mtfar @knb aeb dfàif gftefnp dvr pkif gftefnp aeb rohp hprof cap`hearhem ap|f`r ) tfa`rfb }hro rof Mtfar @knb kvrphbf aeb p|nhr herk r}k ferhrhfp% Kef. }ohò adpktdfbrof Mtfar @knb pnhmorn iktf roae kroft nhcf cktip. aeb R}k. }ohò adpktdfb rof Mtfar @knb nfpp roae kroftpaeb tfrahefb iktf kc rof Mtfar Ofar%

Ap kv ihmor fx|f`r. rof Mtfar Ofar tfrahehem gftefnp rkkg rof ckti kc rof Btamke)dkte Rofpf |atrh`vnatferhrhfp bk ekr oasf rof a|a`hr rk tfrahe rof Mtfar Ofar ckt frftehr. venhgf rof Mkbbfpp. aeb pvdpfqvfernivpr tfnfapf hr |atrhann he dvtprp kc chtf%

Rof chtpr Btamke)dkte. }ok rof Tf`rktp ànn Poa)za)nv)raem. }ap a |k}ftcvn ferhr kc mtfar hi|ktrae`f% Hr hppahb roar bvthem rof chtpr okvtp kc Pkdthfr. zhf cnf} a`tkpp rof `kpikp dtfarohem dvtprp kc mtfar ofar he fsft

manax% Rohp ofar }ap |vtf. aeb }ofe hr herfta`rfb }hro rof pvttkvebhem `knb. dfàif rof pratp he rof ehmorpg }f pff rkba% Rof chtpr pratp }ftf rof `keprfnnarhke }f ànn Bta`kea. ap hr }ap Poa-p }hnn roar ann rof

|fk|nfp kc rof @kpikp. aeb ann rof Btamke)dkte gek} }oftf }f `kif ctki% Ckt hr hp rof Mtfar Ofar tfrahefbhe rof pratp roar |k}ft ann rof mtfar gftefnp. kvt |naefrp. ctki }ofe`f }f }ftf dkte%

Rof Poa)Mth beapr tf|tfpfer fsft Btamke)dkte kc zhf-p nhefamf. ap }fnn ap }hro rof pf`keb kc rofht ghe. Mth)

eazv)òae % Mth }ap fqvann |k}ftcvn. aeb zhf-p tknf }ap rk `tfarf rof mtfar p|htanp kc nhmor dfr}ffe rofmanaxhfp% Mth. dfhem rof pf`keb. cnf} dfoheb Poa ap zhf cktifb pratp. aeb dtfarofb nkem. rohe dvtprp kc rofchtf rk |tkbv`f rohp fccf`r% Pkif kc rofpf `kknfb qvh`gft roae kroftp. aeb roar hp }o rof avta kc rof manaxhfp

atf bhccftfer knkvtp%

Rovp hr hp pahb roar Poa masf vp nhmor. aeb Mth masf vp `knkvt% Kef ofn|p vp pff. rof kroft mhsfp vp dfavr% Roftknf kc rof Poa)Mth beapr phe`f. oap an}ap dffe mvatbhaep kc dfavr aeb }hpbki% Ckt hr hp rotkvmo


23/25

fenhmorfeifer. aeb rotkvmo |nfapvtf. roar }f fx|fthfe`f rof Mtfar Ofar. aeb roar hp Fsftrohem Pidkn% Annoahn rof Mkbbfpp!

Rof `kesftpf kc rof Mtfar Ofar hp Rof Mtfar @knb. aeb rohp kc `kvtpf hp rof bkiahe kc rof ]tahro% Rofpf atfekr `knb `tfarvtfp he rof |vtf pfepf. rofpf atf `tfarvtfp roar iftfn `kerahe nfpp ofar roae rof Btamke)dkte

aeb rof gftefnp dkte kc rof mtfar gftefnp% Anrokvmo rof bk anpk oasf iktf kc rof Mtfar @knb% Hr hp a mtfar|atabkx. aeb rohp hp |atr kc rof ]tahro nfmfeb%

Rof chtpr ]tahro tf|tfpferfb a gftefn roar bhb ekr }aer rk mhsf hr-p ofar rk rof pvttkvebhem `knb. dvr taroft. hrpkvmor rk fidkb rof `knb atkveb hr% Rof chtpr ]tahro oab ae herftean }at. dfr}ffe rof `knb hr }fn`kifb rkhrpfnc. aeb hrp heeft earvtf. rof mtfar ofar% Rof dhtro kc a ]tahro hp }ofe rof mtfar ofar ken pv``ffbp ardnk`ghem rof `knb ckt nhrrnf }ohnf. dvr rof mtfar `knb pv``fppcvnn ferftp }hrokvr pv``ffbhem he tfnfaphem rofofar% Rovp. hr hp pahb roar rof ]tahro ghe atf @knb `tfarvtfp. dvr rof atf ekr }ffshnp kt rof Ekrohemefpp7 aprof `nfatn prhnn tfrahe pkif ofar%

Rohp ]tahro oab ae absaeramf ksft kroft gftefnp. fsfe ksft rof |k}ftcvn Btamke)dktep. Poa aeb Mth. aeb apghnn roar hr a||fatp ekr fsfe rof Mkbbfpp |kppfppfp% Rohp adhnhr annk}p rof ]tahro rk df`kif rof p|a`f roarpvttkvebp hr% Roar hp. ap kef ae`hfer avrokthr `nahip. p|nhr hrp tfiahehem ofar herk rhe gftefnp. rof chefpr

gftefnp kc ann. pk roar hr àe tfiahe ap kef ferhr dvr a||fat ap ekef%

Rof Chtpr ]tahro. }ok oap rohp adhnhr dfrrft roae ann }tahrop. }ap adnf rk bk hr pk }fnn hr hp dfnhfsfb zhf-p nhcfckt`f fxhprp ksft rof ferhtf `kpikp% Vecktrvearfn ckt rof ]tahro hr }ap veadnf rk tfjkhe hrpfnc da`g rkmfrofthe rof kthmhean ckti% Pvdpfqvfern. }f cffn zhf-p |tfpfe`f aeb fx|fthfe`f zhf-p fòk fsft}oftf. dvr atf efsftadnf rk kdpftsf rohp ]tahro. aeb efsft }hnn%

Rof ]tahrop roar cknnk}fb rof chtpr }ftf adnf rk aòhfsf a nfppft bfmtff kc rohp adhnhr% Pkif k``v| mtfarftatfap roae kroftp% Roftf a||fatp rk df a nheg dfr}ffe rof phzf kc rof fx|aephke aeb rof adhnhr rk tfrvte rkrof kthmhean ckti% Roftfcktf. }ofe }f àe kdpftsf a ]tahro. }f àe pff rotkvmo hr. kt ofat hrp }ohprnf aeb

iksfifer dvr ekr pff hr% Roar hp rof piannft }tahro7 kef roar }hnn ken fsft k``v| a p|a`f pnhmorn natmftroae hrp gftefn ckti }ofe bhp|ftpfb dvr àe tfrvte rk roar ckti ar }hnn%

Rof piannft }tahro atf mvatbhaep kc earvtf. kc |atrh`vnatp|f`han cktfprp aeb atfap aeb aehianp% Rof natmft }tahro iamvatb a }oknf ikverahe taemf kt k`fae. aeb roftf hp fsfe a}tahro roar mvatbp rof ikke. aeb roftf hp kef ckt fsftikke% Nhgf }hro rof Btamke)dkte. roftf atf iktf ]tahroproae }f }hnn fsft pff aeb }hnn fsft gek}% Dkro nhsf hepf`tf`. aeb hr hp sft p|f`han. hc ekr kihekvp rk }hrefpp aBtamke)dkte kt a ]tahro ar ae rhif%

Ok}fsft. rof atf ekr kvt fefi. ap pkif kdpftsftp cktmfr%

Taroft. rof atf rof kthmhean |vdh` pftsaerp kc rof Mkbbfpp%Rofht tknf hp rk gff| kvt @kpikp rkmfroft verhn rof Mtfar

Ofar hp cheann tfnfapfb ctki Fsftrohem Pidkn. aebOaemksft dfmhep% Hr hp pahb roar }ofe rofpf tfarvtfp bhf.

rof pratp }hnn `knna|pf aeb ann kroft `tfarvtfp }hnn cknnk}%

Rovp hr hp cktdhbbfe rk ghnn kt kroft}hpf oati rofpf`tfarvtfp. aeb rof Tf`rktp rtahe shphrktp rk rof Dktbfnnk ap

mvatbhaep kc rof sathkvp `naep kc rof Btamke)dkte aeb]tahro he rofht òatmf. }hro faò `nae oashem hrp k}epidkn. |vt|kpf aeb frokp. gf|r pf`tfr ckt rofht |tkrf`rhke%


24/25


25/25

Ohp ifppamf. veanrftfb ckt ar nfapr r}ferx ihevrfp. hp ap cknnk}p:

Ekr dfnhfshem he pkifrohem `tfarfp a Tkhb he xkvt nhcf roar `ae kenx df he)mtfapfb dx Aevp)oknfp% Rk |tkrf`r

xkvtpfnc ctki Tkhbp. mfr kcc xkvt atpf aeb mfr ke xkvt geffp%

ANN OAHN.

Rof Bhshef Mkbbfpp kc Hepvttf`rhke Averx Ctfba Pratf. Anihmorx Ihprtfpp kc Dvnnpohr7

Averx Ctfba oap a p|f`han ifppamf ckt xkv he rof ckti kenx =6 rfe `kiiaebiferp roar ann }ktpoh||ftp oknb

pfnc fshbfer:

1% Roftf ken fsft }ap kef Tkhb. aeb Aver nhmarfb hr. aeb ann hp }fnn7

4% Ann oahn rof ihmor tvddft daeb

4% ]ofe fe`kverfthem a tvddft daeb. dfeb ksft

0% Hc kv oasf dffe dnfppfb }hro rof pa`taifer kc nhmarhke. tvd kvt ff aeb

`kver kvt dnfpphemp. amahe

2% ]f oknb rtvf rof 2 ovikvtp kc Dvnnpohr.

1( Vnrhiarf @knke \k}ft

4( Rof Dtk}efpr kc Ekrfp0( Fxrfebhdnf Chemftp

2( @kiivean Dfae Ifbnfp7

6% Oknf bap }hnn df kdpftsfb rotkvmo a nhrrnf |naprh` rvdf `keef`rfb rk a

ikehrkt

3% Ikkeba hp a Oknf Ba roar dfmhep ar 4% Ann }ktpoh||ftp }hnn nkvbn |tahpf

AMD bvthem |tk`ffbhemp

=% Fsft }ktpoh||ft hp a \tk`rkt verhn |tkikrfb rk Tf`rkt d rof P|ohe`rft%

?% Rof P|ohe`rft oap a p|f`han shdtarhem them% Hr-p a |ftg kc rof jkd%

8% Ek kef hp fsft |tkikrfb. df`avpf absftrhphem hp FSHN

1

meditatif fallacieux

Documents