- ii> - 0mechanism.ucsd.edu/teaching/philsci/churchland.realism.pdf · po>a:=: ~, 5' g....

7
~.1 I ;i- ;' =' .s ~ c. ~ ~~~ ~ 00 ~ '~N 0 .' W .~ ~ t:d 'G ..,' j!::r- ~t'D'" ~(jOO "'::r? V\~"'3 ~.:J ~ NO"'" ,~~ ~ 0 §' , ""'" ~'S; t'D <'> ~.... ~' S1 8~ ,. ... rrJ' .,,0 ::n' X ~O' :; a. 0 ,. O'n IJQ - n" ~ ~ t'D -::I- ,...0. 8 0 ." = =:-.'" g ~ cr !" = '" 0 .... g: ~ ~ ... ~'tI 1; ::r-a~ ~'e g ~ ~g~~~. ~,:tPo"g ::r~<i$(1!!!. m ~ 'tI ~,,< ii!n:S'tl S. '< .. -$; g. Po ~ e." ir' ;;""""::r g: ~ 6' ~ 2- p..~ ? ~ ::i' ' ~ _v~ ~ ;) i"~;. '8-::I~O S""'2i; ::r:" ... ~..~~ o ~'.. ~ ?~s:g "'TJ~IJ: 5.1;'~ = "d E: 2' ;! ~- -r> ~. ~IQ ~ 6;' g. I!J &. 9~~:1a !; r.')~ I!t n ... O\~' 2:~ = ~ ""~m Po ~'c'S!. 0""'-<; ;.: -3 "">CE. 06"= ~o 2"TJ':-f~ Q:i!Ng, r;;'~ ~< g ~ I ~ t:Jv ~'TJ o' C'). .. = S'~:! g,~'1"r ~~~~§"dJ~~~~~a~ ~~~~en~~~R~~~ ~Qq~~~~~~~Q.~naS~~ o Rgg~~~~a~~; nen~-~nn n o-'O~ ~~ Q.~n"d~V~n en n ::I '"1 . '"1'" 0 Q. ~ ~ ::I :.-- -, Qq =' '0 - - 0 0 en ... 0 -, 0 < ~n n ~n::l ~ "'~~~--- eno ~'"1n :::. ~ ~ ~ ~ a 8 '0 rn n' ~ ~ ('j' s' - =' 0 0 ... ~ g ::'. ~ ::r ~ ... En' g ~ 0 '< ~ '0 _::!, g- 0.. 0 g: ~ ~ ::r n (i (i ... ::1 < 2: ~ "' ~ rn ~ * 0> !"! =t' ~ a c: ~ q9, 0 ~ 0 0 ::::- g =' en ~',< ~ ~ '0 c: 0 rn ~.~,;;i "" ~ -,... n S . Q. e: 0 0 '" ::r:-' ~ ~ v 0 0 - n ;;i a nn n ... Q. _. ~ n '" ~ <: .. - 0 _. '-::IQq '"1~"'~ ='- ~ rn~~~~-nrn5O~= ::r enV'" en ~ ~ 0 '< 2" n n '0 c: ::r> 0 - - =' ::I ~ 0 . ~ =:-. ~ ...' ~ '< < ,.::: 0 ~ '"1 '"1 ::r ,. Q. rn =' - n '" v, '" a gj ~ "d e- 0 ~ 0 g' ~ :4 n ~ j;3 g g ~'o ~ ~ ~ ~ Q."" 5' it:lQ ~n:<~ ~gj~n~"1~t=':4~a"'3g- - (II ~ 0... ~ ~ ;;i ..' - 0 '< -- rn"" -.. ~ -- ::r ~"'::r 0 ~... =' =' On-' n rn ~.. - '" 0 - n .. ~ ~ 0 ~"'0"'8~0 ~"""'~o '~"'vr;n-::r:::""nn::r'"1 , fi ~ a ~ ('j' ~ ~ ::I ~ ~ ~ e. a = go =' ~ ~ (i ~, ~ goo Qj - < ' ~ 0 n' ~ 0 ~ 0 n ::s = '< n ::. s, ~ '< Qq n = ~ < c:, ~ C:o"'l~ '"1~='::S~Q.o~<Q.::S"'I\)O 8 -,~('j'a-' - o_«~",-~ ~-~ on- ~"'-o= - 0 Qq '< =t' t:j' ~ 0 ~ <: 0 ~ n ::::' Q '" ~ I\) if '0, n ~ Qq ::rao ---::so::r~Qq o;;irn=_t:i ",°""0 ~ '0 0 Q ~ c: n ",v Qq ~ I\) e!,.g a ~ g ... - (I) n' ~ -< ~ n - 0 t:j.Q.~' '" n 0 ~ ('j'..., =::1 -, ~ ~ en::r n ~ -, ~ 0 ... 0 < ""... ('j' - "'::I ~ ~ '" '< ~ ~ 5' = c: ~ < n ~ =-: c: 0 8 gj @ IJ. n ~ t:j.,-.. 8 ~ - ~ ... ::r n... o:::! ~ ~ ~ - ~ '" '0 ~en~-"'I~_"'nl:l::r""a~ '.0"'-""" oC:-~ "' 0 a ~ - ~ a ' 0 :::, 0 Q. n '" -, =r eo", 0 g ::. 0 Q.'" ~ "1 - ::ro Qq~a oC/>() """"'()~n~~~«I)1I) ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 'E. :;), ~ 8 !-< R < e- 0'!::1. n n ~ c: ~ :;r Q. ~ '" '=" <: ... rn '" ... 0"" ~ - ~ '0 0 0 0::1 n,..., '" Q. ~ 0 (I) ::'. D, ~ ~ a' ~ ~ ::I ~... ~ '< :::. Qq -, '0 Q < ~ iii 0 ..' '"1 ~ :;d = '0 :::s -, (I) Q. c: 0 ...' ~ < t:!. - n - e! ~ =. -= 8 '.0-Q.-(I)'" (I)~ n (',I =-"1::r~",~J'" 0 :-' ... ...' ::I 1:1 ~ !2. ~ en ~ g I'D n en 0 "rj n ~ ~ ... ~ ~ en =- 8 ~ ~,~ 0 ::r!, 8 ~ n'" ~ g Q ; Q ~ 0 rn Q. -, D 0 ::r!, a' - e. 8 0 < 0 ~ Ii v '< ~ t n § ~ c: ::I(I)'~I'DI:I C")::r- ::I~ :3(1)-(1),...0 C/>I:TII)- "d ~ Qq ::I - :! '" , c: '< Qq:::, !"! ~ 0 < '" ::I "d '" 5' ... .... '0 c: ..' - s' ~ - =' ..' a ~ ~ ° 0 ;;i c: ::s (I) - en 0 0 Qq n S~~~~Ri~[~ie~i i~R:~a~:Q~r ...8 0- <Cj"'-<Q. ~"' O~~-C:'"1~::s::;.en~ ::r ::r ~ 0 (I) 8 0 ... g '" ~ ::S::l... So :::;' :i o' Q. ,5' if Q. 0 S' 0 ~ ~ ~ 0 .., ~ 0 _. 0 R ~ Q. if n ~'=, =' c: ~ .... '" - Q. ...' ~ '0 <: ~ ~. rn - =' ~ - ..,'" ;;i =- v <J:I 0 ~ " t:r ~. e go j;) 0 = 0 ::r S 0 rr ;. ;- 0 0 ~ '< I\) ... U Q. ~ ..g 0 ~ 0::S ~ ~ ~:;! 0 s..g::l ~ - go g' 0 Q. ::s == ~ e c: n~Q.O~"""o~-' II)n -O(l)/1)",oQ. -""- ('j' ~ o' 0 ~ 0 ~ Q. g: e: ~ - (I) ~::s < < ~ t2'> < g- ~ ~ Q. e!. <f ::I ~ ",v ~ iii -:='j" ~ 9 ~ g ~ ~ ~v, , ~ ~ ~ c: ~ X' ~~ \J.J \J\ ~ ~ (I) .... (I) ~ (I) '" 1 ~~ I ~ I ~i E;. > I:~ .ON..."'::a ~w - O J. ~'O~~ ~".... CO=-e-co:4-..JI~ ~ '< n' :-' g :" - ;;j ~g,o.~:.< :~'. OCl)~WUJ~ ~ ::s (") _. V\ ~ tI> ... _. "'d rD C7\ ... ~ ::rg. ::;I~ _. 0 n '=' _. ~ ::r en (jtl>. i'r°o 3 c»?O... w ::a",,~ c::: ti!..,cno,,= ::s ooc:~1"o. 0. ... D.::;. ~. 8 -3 ('II CI) ~. =- a g" ::r a- So 1" _. no ~ ",p::s..p.o Ii 5;. p.[~~ '" g, ?d z c; 9 ~. go z~l'>p:o II> rD . = 8::s 1:. ~ g2.[~ g 1;! ~~. p.: I" rD rD::' (]<I ::s 0 ~o\'1l= p. C7\mc!::" I'> W w'9. 2. ~ Q -. I '" < - = g ~n~~ ~ ::. .!3 _.~ - ~ m~~::t .!'"J ::a ~~::r~ if rD "<:<:rD~ 0 ~ t"'" = ~ 0..:1 ~ -. ~ 3 ~::s ~ g, . w 5' ... ~ m . (]<I ~ ::t ;S. ~~~~ 0. * ~... rD g ... -. \() 0. n ;: So oa ::-" tI> ~ :.:> B. ': ~ .... ('] ::I:: > ~ ::;j Z ttI 0 -< 0 N '\:J ~ - ~ n g g. ~ p.. (1)0..., ~cr'0'" ~eno Q~o 0<1:1 e~r-t "!:S - ~ 1-"0 0 ""'. en 0C1 .. ..... g ~~ -1:1~ <~CI) 1=;'101 , ,. e e:. ~ oen~ ~ 0 ~ ~~ e- ('1)

Upload: others

Post on 25-May-2021

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: - II> - 0mechanism.ucsd.edu/teaching/philsci/churchland.realism.pdf · Po>a:=: ~, 5' g. So t: 8 So g-""::b';:J ~(1'~",('I)g ('I) ~ g. 0 '2. '2. ;i 1:; ... aq ~ Er 0- e-. ~ ::2

~.1

I;i-

;'

='

.s

~c.

~

~~

~~

00

~

'~N

0

.' W

.~

~

t:d'G

..,

'j!:

:r-

~t'D

'"~

(jOO

"'::r

?V

\~"'3

~.:J

~

NO

"'"

,~~

~

0 §'

, ""

'"~

'S;

t'D

<'>

~...

.~

' S

1

8~ ,. ...

rrJ'

.,,0

::n'

X

~O

':;

a.0

,.

O'n

IJQ

-n"

~

~

t'D-:

:I-,..

.0.

8 0

."

=

=:-

.'"

g ~

cr

!"= '" 0 ...

. g: ~

~

...

~'tI

1;

::r-a

~~

'e

g ~

~g~

~~

.~

,:tP

o"g

::r~

<i$

(1!!!

.m

~

'tI

~,,<

ii!n:

S'tl

S.

'<

.. -$

; g.

Po

~

e."

ir'

;;"""

"::r

g:

~

6'

~

2-

p..~

?

~

::i'

' ~

_v

~

~

;)

i"~;.

'8-:

:I~O

S""

'2i;

::r:"

...

~..~

~o

~'..

~

?~s:

g"'T

J~IJ

:5.

1;'~

=

"d

E:

2'

;!

~-

-r>

~.

~IQ

~6;

' g.

I!J

&

.

9~~

:1a

!; r.

')~

I!t

n ...

O

\~'

2:~

=

~

""~

mP

o ~

'c'S

!.

0""'-

<;

;.:

-3""

>C

E.

06"=

~

o

2"T

J':-

f~

Q:i!

Ng,

r;;'~

~

<g

~ I

~

t:Jv

~'T

Jo'

C').

..

= S

'~:!

g,~

'1"r

~~

~~

§"dJ

~~

~~

~a~

~

~~

~en

~~

~R

~~

~

~Q

q~~

~~

~~

~Q

.~na

S~

~o

Rgg

~~

~~

a~~

;ne

n~-~

nn

n o-

'O~

~

~

Q.~

n"d~

V~

nen

n

::I

'"1

. '"1

'" 0

Q. ~

~ ::I

:.--

-,

Qq

='

'0

- -

00

en

...0

-,

0 <

~n

n ~

n::l

~

"'~~

~--

- en

o ~

'"1n

:::.

~

~

~

~

a 8

'0

rn

n'

~

~

('j'

s'

- =

' 0

0 ...

~

g

::'.

~

::r

~

...

En'

g

~

0 '<

~

'0

_:

:!,

g-

0..

0 g:

~

~

::r

n

(i (i

...

::1

<

2:

~

"' ~

rn

~ *

0>

!"

! =

t' ~

a c:

~

q9,

0 ~

0

0 :::

:-

g =

' en

~',<

~

~

'0

c:

0 rn

~

.~,;;

i ""

~

-,

...

nS

. Q

. e:

0

0 '"

::r:-

' ~

~

v

00

- n

;;ia

nn

n ...

Q

. _.

~

n

'" ~

<

: ..

- 0

_.

'-::IQ

q '"1

~"'~

=

'- ~

rn

~~

~~

-nrn

5O~

=::r

en

V'"

en

~

~

0 '<

2"

n

n'0

c:

::r

>

0 -

- =

' ::I

~

0

. ~

=:-.

~

...'

~

'<

<

,.:::

0 ~

'"1

'"1

::r

,.

Q.

rn

='

- n

'" v,

'" a

gj

~ "d

e-

0

~ 0

g'

~

:4

n

~

j;3

g g

~'o

~

~

~ ~

Q.""

5'

it:lQ

~

n:<

~

~gj

~n~

"1~

t=':4

~a"

'3g-

- (I

I ~

0.

.. ~

~

;;i

..'

-

0 '<

--

rn

""

-..

~

--

::r~

"'::r

0

~...

=

' =

' O

n-'

n rn

~

.. -

'" 0

- n

.. ~

~

0

~"'0

"'8~

0 ~

"""'~

o '~

"'vr;

n-::r

:::""

nn::r

'"1,

fi ~

a

~

('j'

~

~

::I

~

~

~

e.

a =

go

t::!

='

~

~

(i ~

, ~

go

o

Qj

-<'

~

0 n'

~

0

~

0 n

::s

=

'<

n ::.

s,

~

'<

Q

q n

=

~

<

c:,

~C

:o"'l

~

'"1~

='::

S~

Q.o

~<

Q.::

S"'I

\)O

8-,

~('j

'a-'

- o_

«~",

-~

~-~

on

- ~

"'-o=

- 0

Qq

'<

=t'

t:j'

~

0 ~

<:

0 ~

n

::::'

Q '"

~

I\)

if

'0,

n ~

Q

q::r

ao

---:

:so:

:r~

Qq

o;;ir

n=_t

:i ",

°""0

~ '0

0 Q

~

c:

n ",

v Q

q ~

I\)

e!

,.g

a ~

g

...

- (I

) n'

~

-< ~

n

-0

t:j.Q

.~'

'" n

0 ~

('j

'...,

=::1

-,

~

~

en:

:r

n ~

-,

~

0

...

0 <

""...

('j

' -

"'::I

~

~

'" '<

~

~ 5

' =

c:

~

<

n ~

=

-:

c:

0 8

gj

@ IJ.

n ~

t:j

.,-..

8 ~

-

~

...

::r

n...

o:::!

~

~

~ -

~

'" '0

~en

~-"

'I~_"

'nl:l

::r""

a~

'.0"'-

"""

oC:-

~"'0

a ~

-

~a

' 0

:::,

0 Q

. n

'" -,

=

r eo

",

0 g

::.

0 Q

.'"

~

"1

- ::r

o Q

q~a

oC/>

()

""""

'()~

n~~

~«I

)1I)

~ ~

~

~

~

'E

. :;)

, ~

8!-

<

R <

e-

0'

!::1.

n

n ~

c: ~

:;r

Q

. ~

'" '=

" <

: ...

rn

'"

...

0""

~

- ~

'0

0

0 0:

:1

n,...

, '"

Q.

~

0 (I

) ::'

. D

, ~

~

a' ~

~ ::I

~

...

~ '<

:::.

Qq

-,

'0

Q <

...'

~

iii

0 ..'

'"1

~

:;d

=

'0

:::

s -,

(I

) Q

. c:

0

...'

~ <

t:!

. -

n -

e!

~

=.

-=8

'.0-Q

.-(I

)'"

(I)~

n

(',I

=-"

1::r

~",

~J'

"0

:-'

...

...'

::I

1:1

~

!2. ~

en

~ g

I'D n

en 0

"r

j n

~ ~

...

~ ~

en

=-

8 ~

~,~

0

::r!,

8 ~

n'

" ~

g

Q ;

Q

~

0

rn

Q.

-,

D

0 ::r

!, a'

-

e.

8 0

<

0 ~

Ii

v '<

f!!,

~

t n

§ ~

c:

::I(I

)'~I'D

I:I

C")

::r-

::I~

:3

(1)-

(1),

...0

C/>

I:TII)

-"d

~

Q

q ::I

-

:! '"

, c:

'<

Q

q:::,

!"

! ~

0

<

'" ::I

"d

'"

5'

...

....

'0

c:

..'

- s'

~

-

='

..'

a ~

~

°

0 ;;i

c:

::s

(I

) -

en 0

0

Qq

n

S~

~~

~R

i~[~

ie~

i i~

R:~

a~:Q

~r

...8

0-

<C

j"'-<

Q.

~"'

O~

~-C

:'"1~

::s::;

.en~

::r

::r ~

0 (I

) 8

0 ...

g

'" ~

::S

::l...

S

o :::

;' :i

o'

Q.

,5'

if Q

.0

S'

0 ~

~

~

0 ..,

~

0

_.

0 R

~

Q.

if n

~'=

, =

' c:

~

....'"

- Q

. ...

' ~

'0

<

: ~

~

. rn

-

='

~

- ..,

'" ;;i

=

- v

<J:

I 0

~"

t:r

~.

e go

j;)

0

= 0

::r

S

0

rr

;. ;-

0

0 ~

'<

I\)

...

U

Q

. ~

..g

0 ~

0:

:S

~

~

~:;!

0

s..g

::l

~

- go

g'

0

Q.

::s

==

~

e

c:

n~Q

.O~

"""o

~-'

II)n

-O(l)

/1)"

,oQ

. -"

"-('j

' ~

o'

0

~

0 ~

Q

. g:

e: ~

-

(I)

~::s

<

<

~

t2

'> <

g- ~

~

Q

.e!

. <f

::I ~

",

v ~

iii -

:= 'j"

~

9 ~

g

~

~ ~

v,

, ~

~

~ c

: ~

X

' ~~

\J.J

\J\

~

~(I

)...

.

(I)

~ (I)

'"

1~

~I

~I~

iE

;. >

I:~

.ON

..."':

:a ~w

-O

J.~

'O~

~

~".

...C

O=

-e-c

o:4-

..JI~

~ '

<

n' :

-' g

:" -

;;j

~g,

o.~

:.<

:~'.

OC

l)~W

UJ~

~

::s

(")

_.

V\

~

tI>...

_.

"'d

rD

C

7\ .

.. ~

::rg.

::;

I~

_.0

n '=

' _.

~

::r

en(jt

l>.

i'r°o

3

c»?O

...

w

::a",

,~

c:::

ti!..,

cno,

,=

::soo

c:~

1"o.

0.

...

D.::

;. ~

. 8

-3

('II

CI)

~

. =

- a

g"

::r

a-S

o 1"

_.

no

~",

p::s

..p.o

Ii

5;.

p.[~

~

'"

g,

?d z c;

9 ~

.go

z~

l'>p:

o II>

rD

. =

8:

:s

1:.

~

g2.[~

g

1;!

~~

. p.

: I"

rD

rD::'

(]

<I

::s0

~o\

'1l=

p.

C7\

mc!

::"

I'>

W

w'9

. 2. ~

Q

-.

I '"

< -

=g

~n~

~

~::.

.!3

_. ~

-

~

m~

~::t

.!'

"J

::a

~~

::r~

if

rD

"<:<

:rD

~

0~

t"

'" =

~

0..:1

~

-.

~3

~::s

~

g,

. w

5'

...

~

m.

(]<

I ~

::t

;S

.~

~~

~

0.*

~...

rD

g

...

-.

\()

0.

n;:

So

oa

::-"

tI>~

:.:

>

B.

':

~ ....

('] ::I::

> ~ ::;j

Z ttI 0 -< 0

N

'\:J

~ - ~ n g g. ~ p..(1

)0...

,~

cr'0

'"~

eno

Q~

o0<

1:1

e~r-

t"!

:S

- ~

1-"0

0

""'.

en

0C1

.. ...

..

g ~

~-1

:1~

<~

CI)

1=;'1

01

, ,.

e e:

. ~

oen~

~

0 ~

~~

e- ('1)

Page 2: - II> - 0mechanism.ucsd.edu/teaching/philsci/churchland.realism.pdf · Po>a:=: ~, 5' g. So t: 8 So g-""::b';:J ~(1'~",('I)g ('I) ~ g. 0 '2. '2. ;i 1:; ... aq ~ Er 0- e-. ~ ::2

~,

~,~

P

o>a:=

: ~

, 5' g.

So t:

8

So

g-""

::b';:

J ~

(1'~

",('I

)g

('I)

~g.

0'2

. '2. ;

i 1:;

... a

q ~

Er

0-

e-. ~

::2

~('I

) t:

t'> !1

...,;,)

S

::!,

<

~ ~

'<

i: ~

::I1~

o"'{1

' ~

a~

::!,'

""

=,~

('I)"

""ig

snoo'

::!,Q

'3!3

~{I

'Q

. ir

t:T:;I

::!

, ""

a-

::; ~

~ 2

: 5'

~

0S

- "1 ~

-, ~

=

' 0

::r - 0

('I)

I\)

~

8('I

)"""

('I)~

§Q

.oo

,!";;:

t"

;)a

I\)~

o""~

o ,"

",

=-<

~ag

-~oo

-g-o

i=:i

,~g~

=!o

Q.::

SE

.fIr!

8g.g

g~iu

'<

'<

=:0

0

0. ::!

u 0

~

n° '<

0

g::

...",

""Ig

::s

='

1\)0

('I

) "'S

-°;:J

.~"0

0

Po>

8

0 =

, c

"S1.

~

aq

...,::

s =

-.t:T

::S"'-

,...o

"1{1

'('I)

('I):

:S""

"'"~

§: c

S- ~

fir! ~

g. !ii

' '2' ~

~, i

g; ~

.('I

) 0

::s

o' (

'I) - :1

1 -,

'" "1

'"

-

aq""

I\):;I

°nc"

"!.o

S'I\

)"'I

;,<0-

g<

~~

-<o

",g

,...1

o-

o~oQ

>;,)

'

a~Q

""0-

~

0 ""

0

=, '

" =

'"'..,

"0

::!. g

g:;

t: !ii

,:3 '

g aq

g

8 S

t:T :

3 -<

=,

C/'.

::s",

,=,"

,s-.

':<=

$I)=

"'1a~

::n

~(I

"'"

-,'"

,<

;:JO

oo$I

) (;

"0

,..

.s5'

0

s'.!-

!ii'

-,

...,

"1a"

=

'"'

aq

::Saq

$l)V

flr

!o~

0='"'

0('1

).

"'('I)

c.oc

.a"S

I)~

C~

aqg

o$2

..::s

('l)-

' :n

=-'o

""('1

)-""

0-

::s..,

0-0"

,"O

C

$I)

~

-,

c::

aq

0 I\)

~

'<

<

:;j =

,",

-O°=

,""

'<=

"';:1

,...1

\)

n'"

='

='"'

-,

..,

t:T

0-

I::

I:j

-,

;rou

'C'!i

i' ~

='"'

::S~

'!)!o

R"'

3-=

:=,"

,nO

('I

)('I)

'<~

(1)"

,1\)

,:<=

~~

S-g

::S

5'~

aqo$

l)~'~

-' 0

g '<

~

::r

(1)

0 ::s

(1)

-,0

-,

go n

.,

~ (

'I)

::s

=

Q

S-

ir Q

t'

!j 0

~ "

1 ;;!

~

f!!,

t:T'"

en

I\)

;:J

='

- ::t' v

;,)

Q.

='"'

(1

) "'I

(1)-

,=,~

,; ...

'<I»

=O

(1)f

Ir!~

;; g

Q.

=,..

., >

<

0 ::s

'<

i3

-,

""

"0

!";!

~-.

o.~

~=

,gn!

:(0

- -"

"rJl

V'O

('I)

1\

)"n

"' "1

~

t:T-,

...,=

""""

""""

0-

('I

).,

('I)

...

(1)

::s

::s

'" u'

"' 0

....

:::.;,

)~gl

\)

I:I

QQ

v::!,

=o

(1)=

""

- ",

=-"

"-,..

.,,,

9""3

('1)0

s:

('I

)...o

'<

$I

)IA

~

-,

~

~

~

0

::r

=:

-.

0 e1

:::

:u-

...

I

I I

. I

(1)

"1

'" ,

: '<

~

~ 'E

, S

' ~

g ~

~ ~

'E, g

s ~

~ E

r ~

'g

~ g

, S

' ~ 0

' 5'

~

e: ~

g, 2'

2' 'E

, ~ ~

~;;>

~

~ 0

' ~ g

o ~n

~,g

.:r: ~

-<' ti

'< ~

~':.

~' 0

. ;

~ ~

II)

~

;:~ Q

;' §- g

, ~ S

o '"C

0. ~

ti ~

...

0 ~

'o

~ ~

ri ;

> ~

~ i

g ;,

ri8

I\)

0.

0 '<

-,

0

So .

.. P

>

-,

111

0 _.

(1

) (I

) 1I

t1 ~

'-'

S

I'")

=

(I) n

~ 0

-<

' 0.

=-

I\)

II)

~,g

I'"

) C

T = '

< ~

'

~-n

~-,

""""

"oC

T-~

;':

:1

en "

1 '

:;J',I

\)""

'!'>

::rC

T

...p>

"'::::

1-~

~""

I'"

) S

' <

n I\)

~: !

§ ~ ~

~ ~

~. §8

~'~

~ ~

g ~' i §

, ~ $

I ~

- a§-!'

~ ~

~ §

' ~ ~ [

~ ~ ~

f g

~ ~

~ ~

'i !'~

~=

= 0

v en

'<

...

(1)

::I

o c.

. :-

(1

) I\)

go

"'t °

CT

S c

:!' (1)

0.

~

(I

) '0

;:I

'.,

0 C

JO 0

P

> =

~ "'t

en

~ ~

~ ~

P>

g., S

2' a

!:'

[~

~ ~

~ ~

e: g

;- (I)

~ s

' ~ ~

8 n

o@ ~

p.::I

~

~. ~

c:

~ e

: '?:.

8.:g

~ ~

~

0.g

~ ~

gr ~

~ ~

~ ~

~ ~

i'

1r ~

~ [~

~;i

'<

!2. 'v

~

~ ~

;.

~ C

o g-

~ ~ ~

~ 8

g ~

,~,

~ ~

:. 8 ~

z

:r S

' ~

cn

~ ~

""

.., -<

' g. ';

<: =

~ ~

s ~

~ ~

g- ~

g, ~

- "1

1 a ;;

:.f'

g.

g ::1

, P

> ~

a

0' g

g

5' Co

Q

g, (

I)~

o.

j

.Rr~

~~

2e:~

~~

~R

f~~

g.S

i~t[i

i~g-

r~~

if~I:[

~

~~

o.i~

~

::::IP

>

""I,<

cn

P>

cn

CT

'" :!p

>l\)

o-'

s0.

-""-

""'"

~'O

"'0

""""

..,

"',

"""'"

-'

'<

en :

:r - C

JO -,

I\)

en

I\)

N'

...

QC

I "0:

:1

..':!

!!.

'" -'

' -,

C

T

en

"1

CT

8'" - (I

) (1

) 0

0 's

'<

0 '~

"'"

"1'")

0

I'DS

S-n

::r"1

o"'n

""

I\)~

::r~

o~

::In

,<0

-,'-'

",

<=

0

;> r

i I\)

~

0

~ ~

~

I\)

"0

~ ~

~ ~

.0

~'

5: a

S'::

r (1

) ~

::I

So

~ ;

i 0'

'"

~ "1

~

g g

, i @

Q

;° ""

I 0'

E =

~

§ ~

I ~

~ s i

~ R<

' [~

g:~

, ~ ~

'i 8

~ ~ ~

,~ ~ ~ o

:: ~

'ffi ~

~ ~

~ ~

8 ~

a 'R

° ~

g.! '

~l

~ >"'p

>

::::I-

' ""

'::1-

,,<

=

"<::I

,...v

' vn

(1):

::-:<

II::I.

v =

"O

-"'°

"""l~

-"'I\

) V

(D""

'",

t~:~

g.~

~~

I\)~

~g~

,?:~

g.

0.::I

~~

8S~

s~

:-<

,o~

g.::r

8~~

::r

~fg

.(I)

~

QC

I -

~ ~

g ~

II)

0 ~

&. ~

§ c::

. -;

;:;

::r

~

~ ~

t::.; !!?

::I

§

~;-

0@

3 0

f; g o

I\)

~

!!?

a ;-

S

! ~

!!?

~...

5'

~

U

>-<

'o:=

: ""

'~

s!!'

""""

""'o

n o"

"l~

~'::

!'::I'

I::I

;:s

-"

""""

'3

-"'"

00'

~Q

.. o.

j~

<!9,

g q

I\)

~ ~

'1::1, :;r

8

i; =

' ~

5!

Q

.. ~

ri

~ 0

~ ~

g 0.

<

II a

S'

;:I

"0 ~

~ S

o ~ ~

' Q

;' 6:

<

::I

~ ~

~

>

::rR

=S

So~

~5'

~3"

"1::4

-,::J

~0

~O

s'.f'

-~~

o'

p>g.

t'I),

-;<

::~oj

;;'S

Il)(',

I ~

~I\)

~n

o.j

~,

-<':<

~

2 ,..

, '<

~

5' ~

8 s

' ~

en

'"

~

g ~

~ ~

if 8

0 '"

::I

~ ~

a.

..,

=:I

0'

@ Q

&.

~

S ='

~ o

:i c:

g,

s' 5

~ e:

<

n'

;;!T

Q

~ 3

0 0

~

~

0'

en

~ ~

n

p. 3

~ 5

<

n'

;:0' ~

::r

0'

8"'" ...

~

o'

q

Co

::4 e

; ~

f'JJ

I'D

p.1\

) ~

::Iop

.t:S

...,,=

, ""

""'1

(',1'

" 0.

<:'0

<1)

0::1

(1)=

=

::1

I\)

CT

o.,

0""

::::I

oQ91

\)

..':!

8 I'D

::I

en

~ S

(I)

0 Q

g"

S 5

!! .f'

O S

~

0 c:

:. (I

) n

~'-

~

::I""

C

T '<

-'.

.. ~

CT

0 ;-

<

n ::I

S

qs

P.

~

0!:j

8""'<

""

.0""

--

;.!,

" "'0

1\)(

13""

"""

-,s.

;n-:

:I=-.

c:

""P

>

I'")(

I)""

'~

'11

~ '1

::1 ft

So g

!ii' 5

: ~ §

- ~' ~

. ~ 9

~ ~

.g

~ ~

= ~

5 ~

; ff

g' (',I

0

~?f

[ ~

;; §

~,§

: r

~ ~

~ '<..

0

!!?~

n::r

I'"

)I'")

CJO

-~

I'")-

~~

~

::I~

""::I

~

3"'::

1 nc

..,C

TC

T::I

==

""

-0~

cr

~ ~

. 2

e?.

'<

I'; ~

'< i1

!D

~ 5'

Q

, '2

.::r

ft \;;

! ~

;i

~

~ 8

.?:

::I

' 3

~ ~

0 R

~

~ g

=

CT

bj

o an~

'<

~-<

,~;"

Og.

i~!!'

QC

l8

~f

3""ri~

io~

~

~~

.g(',

l~o~

~;~

p.

8"~

~

~::I

~

p>

p>

.. ~

p>

n

en -

, I'D

I\)

I'D

'<

"

""I

QC

I ...

~

::r ~

P>

C

T

Q)

I\)

:;r0

<

,o,

I'D

So

1'D

::r

t'l:I

0.

~::I

""

o' :

:r p

> 0

"""

=

_.

<I)

I\)

0

::r:::

, =

' (ii

' ~

r a

0 a"

;

en

CT

;-

> ..

.' Q

;' n

:>0:

1

38p.

~

~!'~

~g.

t:S~

f~~

§r

~g~

8.~

l §~

(I)e

?.S

So~

n~~

~

3~S

Q~

<

'Eo

::!. C

T

C'tI

-,

=

= E

::; ~

0

~<

J)

I'D

0 -.

0

CT

n

<

en

0 ...

I\)

'<

C

T '<

c;

;' (',

I '"

I'D .p

0

0 ~

(',I

=: (I)

~

~ 0

:>

~. a

~o g

~

, ;

cr ~

'< .5

g- 0=

.p ~

-:

Q ~

~ 0

' ~ ~

~ ~

Q

5 ::I

g ?i

~ S

o § g

g: ~

~

~ :.

~::I

bjD

:ln"'

I\)

n'l::

l,-,

_"'t

I'D

""I

-(11

_0

(1)(

',1'<

--00

" ..,

1\

) ...

-\1:

1(1)

0 --

, °o

O~

~b;

j-tb

<C

/>"r

I",o

OS

'I::I

<Q

;"""

'O,..

.'.O

_V

-,

~~

c;:

,E

. ~

8' ~

~

~ ~

~

,~

~ a' 5'

~

~

~

, ~

~

g

~

@::!

, ~

g:

:1,

g a

~

ft ~

0

tO~

, q§

, g.

&

. 3

~

0 ~

~

:

oe?.

(J

q (',

I::II\

)""~

"'.

.,"-:

:1"1

(',

I;;J~

'I::I(

',I~

,..,~

O

-,::I

~-C

T8<

J)or

D-.

o 1\

)-::1

-

,-,,<

,o

.,::r

~

,o,~

Q'q

,<

",n,

,

e?.,

r;>

- ""

",

'co,

. ",

,<7'

'<

'<'1

1)'<

w '"~ 0 a- en ~ ... <

:C

I)a. 0 0 C

I)::s Q

.

0 = ....

0 - 0 q9.

(') ~ (")

0 3 e. ....

3 ~ 0 ....

I»nn

""~

~

~~

::s>

~

"~~

~~

~

1»~

~S

g::s

0

0 ::r

>

! n

0 C

'D::s

::r

c:

~

'<

~

s ..,

::s

0 c:

...

'~,

Q.:3

~

~

'2.

~

tI1

~ a

~

Q

. 2

'"':I

~ ;!I

'g,

~ 0

)0

E

r o.

::s

e,

='

I:1:'J

"0;::

:1

oo<

::so(

;>

"1::r

,<Q

n~::s

c...~

~_,

:r~

nC'D

0.-0

""

...,::

s0

""(;

>""

:::'::

:'-'

""'~

oO

Q"'-

C'D

(iJ<

;:::IO

"="

oon

-<:"

'" ""

'(1)"

""."

,01:

\-

-""

11>

1:1

c:

~ ~

~

5'

~,=

- "g

...

"0

ra

,!f'

'" 1:

1 ":

) '<

cf

J ii

='

2 II>

n

~ - <

~

~ -<

'

C'D

0Q

II>

=, "

0 15

..., "

'I ::!

, ~

8

;;:' "1

::r

~ 0'

~

~ g

~ ~

n' "

0'<

g

'" =

-' ~

(1

) ...

::s

n

OQ

,g

j8

t! g.

,7

t::".

~

'

n ::;

" =

:=

!, c:

-'-o"

"::r

..'"

0 II>

C

:::r

~

n""~

~

On

(;:1

0"1

S3-

<~

~~

~cr

-==

"O~

:::'~

"OC

'D"1

R~

-<

~~

~O

::S'"

...'

n n

"1

"1

'<

'<

OQ

"1

0

'<

-,

~ <

;:

~

'" ~

Er

rn

;:

~o~

~S

~n

::ro:

:s-,

g:"'C

'DO

n"""

"""

~o.

""'I»

~S

'n

C'D

0.

II>

n 0

~

cr-

c:

;:::I

II>

='

"1

~,

0.

0 oo

,::r

~

C'D

0Q

E.

;-

II>

~

g,

::r

a ;:

::s

~

~

~

~'

==

~

r;

s :-

0

~

==

a,

~

::r

(;

>

0o_

wo=

'<-o

.o.-

nC'D

II>

_-~

::s'"

=

o::r

c:c:

~

5'

"1

,

0 0.

II>

-,

'<

n 0.

g-

::s

Si>

' 0

0 ::r

n

~

..'

~ "

'I'"

OQ

~

C'D

::S=

'OC

'Dn"

1c...

::r

=...

=-

~"'o

go~

-,(;

>'

<:"

"_:::

!-<

n="'~

"'--c

r-..,

o 0'

~

""

c:",

,::;

"'o."

""""

OO

=""

"""n

~

"'I».

.. ...

..:::

:! :::

,...

0 _,

.A<

a._O

Q

- "I

(;

>O

Q _

0 -

==

00Q

- <

~""

'-"'..

c:

o""'.

.o"1

'."'"

""",

"'-'<

~

..."'I

I>"

::r ,.

. ..'

E

r "1

='

00

...

<J1

rn

==

1:

1> 0

II>

~,

0 ;:S

' 0

;:::I

0 "1

::I

@

('!) J6

~ =

' 0

00' '"

~

~

<J1

~

C'D

:4 :

:s =

' II>

t::"

. < ~

cr

- 0

~

::s...

0

.. (J

: "'

- - II>

:::.

::1 .

"::i"

."::i

" 0...

0 <

t1I -

, ~

:::.

...

'" ~

n

~

0 =

= - r

i -,

- '--'

::S

""""

" -"

"""

n ,

"1

0

~"'-

<:

~~

~

o.°~

~~

oo.o

~~

~

o;E

r~",

011>

Q

.o

ir"=

,,o

"'::s

~~

o;:(

iJ""

"ErI

l>

I»::s

""or

n"::!

,::I

cr-

~

c:

0 n

=,

0 ::r

::rS

n

=

<:

II>

...

S

=,

0 ...

~

~

::;

'0

0.

0 "1

"1

0

.0

0 "'.

..'

n ...

0

II>

0 =

::r

..,

..'"

=00

""=

=

C:o

o II>

~""

""'I"

'::S

=

::s_o

11

1"

<:

2'::t

~

...

0

=

0 cr

- <

""::r

00

II>

,<

::r

'<

::r

0 (;

>

-,

t::~

=

' ..

...

n'

0 '"

0 <

0

S ..

.' ~

==

n

Er

~ C

'D c

r- t:

:". f.n

-

I'D

0.

i:f

;; '"

zr.!2

. 0'

=

0

~

S

0 S

~

0

~

=

~

'" ~

~

"0

II>II>

"'~~

=I»

...

c:cr

-~

Slo

~c:

...

::s

~oo

"'l@

dn

3;::

n O

Q::r

'<

'"

n ;-

_.

=

~

!l. 3

~

CIC

I ::s

:=!. <

~ II>

<

R 0

5"

C'D<

@ ~

C'D

'g

, ~

;;:

<

g

(i,'

"'"

'" ::r o

::-

!:!

Q ~

~

Q.

0_:

:ss:

:: "'0

0 n

'.n-'=

:-,..

o::s

'v

_'"

'<...

""'-"

"'0""

0-

II>n"

1 ...

' ""

o ~

n ,"

'--nl

l>~

"0"

"!!."

'E"'~

8Er

-g'=

"'>~

,=

t:n

~o

~E

r--=

(iJ~

;>

n =

.00

OQ

'<

@

<

° g

~

0.

g, g

. 3

c: ~

0

0 c:

0.

Q

~

::;

0 ::r

0

=

=

'" II>

n

::I

0 ~

n"

" I»

"1

~

-,

S

I :5

::r

0' -

nQ!;c

=,"

"""'W

t::"

.~Q

...~'"

.. "'n

cr-°

::l-

0.

='a

~II> ~

£:

!, 0

<I>

~

~ ~

..0

' 5'

::r

e:

; sr

3

ti! -

<I>

n

=,

0...

Ft'

- ::s

"0

-..

0. 0

;:::I

~

0 ~

'0

0.

n'

0

0

0...,

00

I»C

ICI:=

!, ...

g~<

:=!

o""~

n;'..

. 0

00"':

:S

FrC

'D<

=o"

'~

n ::r

_""n

. ~

-<

I>~

""

11I-

<n

3"1

n

...

=

~ '

" 00

' *

0 0

0.

~

~:T

Q

, '"

g 3

0. ~

0 @

"0

~ :

-.

~ <

=

:3

a

0 c:

Os

...

~

0 n

n S

'"

1»'"

- 0.

I» ::r

t1)

3 '"

=;'

0.

::!,

' !f'

3

0;:::

1 c:

3

~ c

: n

~

~,

n a

~

~~

Ft-

~ e

0 3::I

<

I> n

cr

- ~ §

i5

: I»

n <

J1 0

'<

=

0:...

- N

'II>

""

"""

OQ

"'"

t1)

'<

c:

'<

'" '"

a - n

00

::r

...,

0...

:::,

S~

vC:

o'...

~

OO

Scr

- I»

n=

15O

~O

~II>

S

';;:J

~

'g

(iJ=

coS

o.

o'S

'sg.

R",

i%~

~::S

::l1l

>

::rO

::rn<

l>

=o(

;>l1

>~

~

::InA

,_";

Iov

n~o.

o.::I

M

I"10

, '

~

,.....

...... > c: t""

~ (")

::c c::

~ (")

::c t""

> Z t:' \JJ

'I

Page 3: - II> - 0mechanism.ucsd.edu/teaching/philsci/churchland.realism.pdf · Po>a:=: ~, 5' g. So t: 8 So g-""::b';:J ~(1'~",('I)g ('I) ~ g. 0 '2. '2. ;i 1:; ... aq ~ Er 0- e-. ~ ::2

... -

~

~

~...

'...

- Ii"

Q.

.d

<

!n'

0 ~

~

0 a"

0

-,

~

~ 0

~

~

.0

~

=

D:I

n ~

'0

'T

j ~

'0

::"

.09

2 0

OJ

~

=

=

r;'::

T::s

0

<:I

'-0

S'

CI'

-,;::

a ~

-.

g.,

a"

-,

Q.

c:

::T

=

~::T

~

0

...

a-

~

::T

c:~

0

a"~

'.8

l" Q

. g ~

8 .~

!;

~ ~

~ ~

So S

o < ~

~ S

o ~

8

e; S

o ~ S

o.8

~ ~

~ ~

~ ;

~ 9

~ ~

::" g

, ~

~:::

I0

Q.

c:

~ S

o Q

. ::T

::I,

~

~

51

u.

~~

, 0

~

::" Q

9 0

::I,

"~

"-'

~ ::

:! E

'<

0 ~

0

0 S

' n'

~

fA

~ '<

_.

'<-

0 ~

-

~O

O""

"~

-"":

:T.,:

:T.'o

";

;J

-'~'._

Q..

-'"

""

n...

c:-

!n'

~

9 a"

n

~

~

...

- ""

-,

,

- -

~

0 0

o'

0 a"

'<

0

'<

a"

a'

""

n 0

0 0

'<

n ::T

0

'<

=

...'

~

en

0-

~

'<

'<

~

0 0

...'

~

-.8

n ~

::T

;;J

Q..

n c:

'0

=

en

'

9 <

£:

~

'<

0

=

~

..,

n c:

Ii"

~

~

ii

=

- ...

.

~o1

2,~

o-,

~,=

:!~c:

:::T

~~

O-,

-",o

s:!~

::::'O

-""'~

n~"'o

"'<:=

~

n~""

"Q.C

'::!

::'C

""'I:

I ~

""Q

.CI"

'<:~

~,;:

;.."'~

!::b~

-~-<

: -'O

ny

-"":

:s

9::T

~;;J

",

(I)~

",

0::;'

n""

(;"<

'O

D:lo

o~0.

..'!=

' 0~

"""<

-,

~~

::I'~

300

0...,

o~§g

~:::

: ~

~::T

(I)

~

~

'0

""a

Q.'"

(I

) ""

::T

'i'"

..;;J

C

" =

(I

) n

U

0 0

(Jq

=

"" -

0 n

...

Q.

0 -

0..,-

(1)=

",9

- ,..

=--

~

,...'"

(I

)-,.,

.,...,

~

'O

::;:

C"

'<00

__,-

0-"

0",=

"'<-<

0

(l)0-

n'<

o~""

::T~

09°0

0~-:

:T-'.

=

c:

CI'

~=

-~=

-"

"'0ii

~ '<

j5

.; '<

~

~

'0 ..,

8..

0 ..,

:-' ~

-,

(I)

,D' -.

'0 ::>

g =

:::

0<' n

::I,

;::a

= 0...0<

' =

!n

' -,

§

(I)

;; ~

:::t

Q.

= =

- ~ !n

' ~"'~

n-n

...<

: ~

;s,

<!:j

O""

C:-

-;;J

""O

...n

Q.

",,-

--,o

O"'o

:on

~~

Q.=

::T::T

::T::T

~_O

J_=

-o~

'" =

,<-~

(I)

9n"

'~~

C'=

nn"'0

;;J-C

::<:"

",,0

_0~

,. 0

nO'"

..'

-..

0 '0

::T

'" '0

0

~

,..

U

c:

...::s

.0

0

- -,

""

""

.,

0 ...

-

0 0

00

0 C

I' 0

=

'0

0 -.

c 0

0 ~

,..

., "'..

. ~

!n

' '()

'...

~.

=

~n

>;.

-0' ...

'0

c: ~

,o<

' ::::

(I) .!:

:" Q

. ""

..,

0

=

!4

~

S =

'0

=

'0

-'::T

...

;;J

~

...'

n -~

,""

0 n

Q.'.

0

0""

"'0

... ~

n

;;J C

(Jq

""

~

- =

00

0'<

0

- =

' ~

. n

'<

'<

..=

en

<:

::T

C"

::T

<

::T

<

a.

0 t:I

=

...

<

: t:I

t'I

~

<

: ..'

'0

-

'<

...'

~

-' Q

. 0.

.. n

f3::T

""

-

0 -

0 ~

C

I' -,

0

- 0

g,

~

n ...

'0

=

::T

n 0

00

""

.0

- II)

Q

. (I

) ::T

::I

9

t: Q

. ~

,'O

- ...

o~

0 =

""

'C'(I

) ~

~ 0

°'

0 =

'!='

'" ~

...

~

~

n ~

n

n Ii"

0

C ~

g:

a g

~'

S'

'" ""

"""

n 0

~ ~

n U

un

_,

-,

<:

- ""

",

,::T

0

0 ~

0

<n,

><

=

:e

' II>

n

::.

OJ

n ,-

.. n

::T

n ~

'0

p,

0

=.

~

'00

5'

~

a,...

~

0

8"

g ~

::T

0

~

~;;J

(I

) "g

g

...

::I,

~

::.

'0

~

: 0:

0 ~

~

...

' 5'

0<

' ~

C

!n

' n

...

0 "'

~

~

n ::;

>...

a ::T

~

~

~

.,g:"

" ...

t:

8 g:

';-

' ~

~

::.

'" 2,

;::

&1j

::"

n

~

~

n Ii"

C

" '-'

&

n

0 Q

. ~

~

ro

~

,;=(

; ,:-

t 0

&1j

0 ::T

~

C

' 0

n =

n

~

::I.

g =

r:

ro

::T

&1j

=

-:

y::T

g

~

~

9 ::I

ro

0-

1,

:=":

:;>

<n

n .

o 9~

' n

:0;-

=' n

9

~C

l'n

-CI':

:I~oo

~nO

J::Io

""~

~

~

'O~

""(I

)'O""

::T

~""

o::T

"'(Jq

<

0:00

"'...

~.

:=,"

<o"

"""'~

=(1

)""

OC

l'::Ig

""""

~o=

:.;n

-""'9

~.-

-,

no=

=

'00"

" O

'-'~

'O0:

1 '0

~

~

...

0

un

0 '0

:0

;-

Q.

0 <

: 0

""

""

00

0 ::I

, 0

0:0

...

::T

...

=...

~

..'

n

~

;; - -

-~fG

<;;J

'<=

::Tl'\

>no

-'~I'\

>(I

)O:O

oo=

1'\>

""

,-..

~n"

"::I-

,==

o~o"':

:I ::I

,o~

"'I'\>

O

:=::;

. -

'<

~,(

I)

t::h

- 0

'0

0 !:I

::T

;:!

n <

:' U

(J

q -,

0

So

~

e;.

r' '<

:!'

""

-

-.

- 0

n =

=

n

=

..':=

., 0

u ':.

., '"

;-

So"

" 0

~

~,g

;

0 n'

~

!n'~

e,

<

:: =

:.; n

g:

I'\

> I'\

> 0

:0

'=">

<

?:

=

=

~ e

e;

. n

I'\>

::T

:i 0:

0 :5

=f!!

, =

~

C'

_. ~

C

' (I

) 0=

(I)

-,

~

cn_'

::1

Q. 0

0 -

ii (I

) n

0 :3

Q..

~ 0

~

-,

::I

0 (I

)..,

~

n =

~

~

::I

""::I

C

' - ::I

I'\

> <

)<

=

- ::

T <

=

Q

. ~

=

~

ro

n

::T

::I

=

0 t1

, "" <

:""

Q

. '0

~

~

~

- 00

...'

n-o(

l)(Jq

'O

(l)o.

..<II:

:T~

~I!.

~'"

/111

\)=

--""

-.0

ro~

C

'n

- c:

! =

",

=:,-

::1"

~ =

-

- 9,

<

='

u ...

n

,:-t '

!='

'< a ~

'T1 t

::h ib

Z ~

<II

'<

=

...::1

~

So

~ I

'\>

~::T

.8

0 '0

~

n

~ .

...

~

-.""

~

::T

=

9,

(I>

~

&

1j

~ \I>

00

""'"

n'

~

~ :

:I A

. ""

0"

=

- ~

""

'<

~

~

""

=- n

I'\>

=

:;,~

, §

~ :

:T =

:- ~

::S::S

o...~

~,n

_'::T

'O"'O

""""

"o

~~

I'\>

-(I)

-,~

..."

=

<...

~

o'"

=

..'<

Q

. a'

(I

> -

=

~

.::s

~

I'\>

~'

n" ::T

u

=

I'\>

fA

Q

. <

- -'::1

0

'<..

n::T

~

n

~

~

::'

0..

n -.

I'\

> ...

,. 9

~

I'\>

(1)\

1>'

""(J

Q-n

-n<

: -',

,.~

...,"

'v

~""

'n"d

""

~

tT(1

)(I)

~C

"Y'

~

,<""

=

,>

<~

t::h

.1'\>

::0

'" .

I'\>

::T

~'

I'\>

e;

. e. ~

- "d

'<

a.

0

~ 0

::;

' ~ 0

:0

0 1:

1 ~

-,

::;

' ;'

~

n.

So

(;"

"I1

(Jq

~ ~

...

=

...

I'\>

...

0

""'" -

~

"

'<

::T ~

""

,'"

_. -

::s...

, =

' =

-.,.

v ~

C

I'::I

""

OJ

.. n

~

...

0::T

ro

=...

'<no

o=

::T--

o'.<

~-'n

u",-

"1.I'

\>"-

'n

,..

""<

"".~

""

"-I'\

>

""n

9-~

-

I'\>

~'<

Q

.. ;::

J<n~

:e".

-(

JqO

~=

"'"

(I)

..,-

...I'\

>,..

.~...

...

e;. I

'\> C

' e;

. e-

;::J.

."

~0

- -,

~

::t

I '<

0...

=' - 0

-,

0 '"-

:!...

::! -

,::T

~

::T

...

n =

= n

t: tT

::I,

0--

"'"9

~a'

cl'\>

""

'-'

~

""

"1

-"""

'n;;J

~

0(1)

...

~

::>"

...

n tT

=

~

~

9c

~ 0

""

""

I -

0 =

I'\

> n

-.

<II

-,

-,

'" C

I' '0

,...

::T

<

I'\>

::I

00<

tD ~

~...

::T

e;.o

:o

00 "

,n-.

"J

'"1=

::I(J

Q(I

)o<

' Q

.°on

t';

)i:lp

'::T

n-

.u

o~ro

Cl'!

E.I'

\>::I

,n-Z

"'oo-

- -

:O;-

""O

"'~I'\

>'-"

'::I-

=

=0

""::t

I-,

1'\>

00::1

-,

<II"

"...u

l'\>

~

""I\)

...

e:

,:'

'<

- ~

Q

(J

Q

~::;

. ~

n

u ::T

~

-,

0

Q.~

, r;

""

(J

Q

5'

~

~

~

:3

~

n'::I

~

~

...

f!!

,o<

' ...

<

II ~

"g

JD

~

'=">

c:

~

:. 1:

1 a

C';:

;' ~

g-

C

I' ~

n

CI'

;=(

~,S

' g

0 g

nO""

Q

. 12

, 0

e;

!n'

1:1

~

=

y 8.

. =

p,

""~

,,,~

g.o

<IIo

=~

~(I

)'O~

~=

,o§O

'::T

~-'r

; oQ

..:O

;-I'\

>::I

.-'~

~

;-S

::::I:

;)<

II=B

-oo

~

1:'

!3

~

n!3

8 g"

=

,..

;; =

.

g <

: :3

""

...

~

S

' go

..,

8

~

.g

8 Q

I\)

Ii-

n

n fi

'<

~

R

~

~~

~ £;:

=-

a.

'0:3

~

Q. ~

.0

g- ~

~

E :5'

~

'i ~

9

e1, -

=

!!.

'i a:

~,

"5!,

So.

o ~

g,

:.!

Q.

~

<II

~

<II

<II

1'\>

=<

11-'"

<""

O=

CI'V

-'-

=".

.. ~

-t1)

cr'~

""

n...

00 I'

\>t:v

. .."

"...

<II-

.Q

. _0

1'\>

_""

'O

~::T

M

~n

o'A

=_,

::T-~

""

"'-'-"

"0

.'1'\>

""

...~

n<,.,

;'=-

0 -,

-.

. I'\

> -

<

::I -

~.

v'

(I)

C' -

, -,

C

" ~

-.

-,

cr

"'"

<II

n -

- -,

~

~

~

::T

::I

~~

~Q

~~

~

~9~

~~

~§9

~~

1i"g

.§~

~~

~

n99~

~Q

~~

~

~""

=::I

I'\>

'~

~

ti S

:J.

a

ti a

~. g

. R

. ~

~

0" 'i

~

~

~.

g. e

- ~

~

~

S g

. ~

~

'g

s §

n g.

er

8 D

~

g.

iiJ

~

3 ~

g ~

j" C§.

tz

, g

(1.

~ (

i' ~

~

'~'..

,~.

~ g

~

..,

«'

~ a

~

s' 't

:I 0

" ~

,...

iiJ

a

0 8

.., ~

tt'

~

~

<."

~

e-

. g.

5'

Srs

- ~

;;

~ rs-

~ ~

.§ i g

~ ~

Pi g,

~ g

a: ~

~

e ~

~. ~ 3:

~ 2

. ~ :;;

g, ~

5: ~

s. g

a. ~

~ .g

~ Pi

51;- g

. ~."

E

rg

"'::r

:ti!

0"":

'" ti!

~ :

:ra'

<::-

'::8

!."

r.1,

;'~a:

;rs

~ ~

~ ~

~C

§.R

~::!

~R

'g:c

::v

~...

.g

~ g"

~ ~

~ ~

g, if

~ ~

&;. g

§ ~

~ ~

~

~ 0

' ~ ~

rb

~ ~

D ~

~f ~

2. 1

S ~

~ 6

~ ~

~ &; 51

' ~

a.

~ 'E1

:;r

('t)

~ Q

.. v

_. '

t:I,..

. ~

a.

... ~

'<

8

...

a""

~

~ ""

6)' ;;

;:t

0

a" a

~

~

('t)

~

en

~

~ Q

.. 0

5'~

:i ~

~: ~

~

ga

g'

~

5'- ~

~

6 ~

3

=-

[ ~

a ~

61

~ 8

;"

,111

~,

:., ~

'<

('t

) ~

g.

§ ~

.:;.

g t.;

. a.

fi' g

. ~

~

. 0

a :

~

~

I g-

§' ~

a

g- ~

-<

~.

g' ~

'g

~

g, ~

0

.g §

~

~ ~

[

fi' ;

- ~

~

g,

R ~

g.

(i'

::h g

. 8

5'- (

i' ~

a~

. ~

g g,

~

~ g

. ~ g

('t) o

a. ~

~ ~

1Sa!.

~<s.

2. ~

.a: g

~ ;

. ;-

~ ~

g.

~,

5' '< a

11 ::1

~ In'

~ ~

~ ~

er ~

~ §,

~ g

~.

~,,~

<:=

""

<::r

'=

'>

-('t)

~..~

."...

=no

-<

~.,

1\)0

'<

-,:0

;-'.-

'=0-

'"

~ ~

~ :;r

:;r ~

s g

9 a

~.:

~ g

. £ ~ ~

:: ~

~ ; Q

..~'

:. ~

~ ~

~ ~

v~ e:

~ ~

~ g

,.§ ::

~ ~

!.~

, ~

~ ~

~a~

ig;~

~~

~~

~~

~~

~ri~

a~~

88rb

~>

[~~

rrig

~~

r~tg

;~~

~

5' ~

~ g

g g.

~ a.

~ g 1

~.?'

:. ~

~ B.

~ g

. ~ ~

:- ~

~ .g

~ ~

:, ~

'< ag

g' ~

§: ~

~.~

. g

~ ~

~';'

. ;:;

=. Q

.. ri

=::

~ '"

::r

e- o

;!.

'II)

('t)

~

v 0

:g ~

::r ('t)

S

~ ~

0

=

~

II) .,"

C

I> ~

V>

~ '

" II)

c

~ "'!

nO>

;:' ej

R if

<: : ~

9 ~

~ ~

'8

~ 5

. a g

- ~

~

?- ~

~ ~

~ ~

~ g.

~'<

~ ~

~ .

'g

8 ~

g

~ 9

e- '

t:I

r-2.

g- ~

::f

a- if

Ii-

-~ ~

In' 't

:I S

' ~

. ~

a~.

v~ 2

g. 5

1gB

. ~

!.

e- ;;

6 ~ g

~ ~

g' g

. cfJ

§'

~ ~.

g. ~ ~

~

9 (i

;a (

I) ~

=

~ '

<

0 g

g:.

:J' g

g &;

. Q

.. '"

~ ~

::.

~ ~

(Jq

't:I

S c:

: en

'=

'> -.

::: n

(i '8

~

Q..

'" g.

: :>

6) .;

~ [~

, ~

e. ~

~ -<

e. ~

~

'g .,

0-

~ ~

a j;;

'> 8

~H

~

~ ~

'R o'

~ ~ ~

fr

~ 51 1

~ ~

~

~ ~

~ i

f H

.~

::r

9: '<

-<

~ '"

~ ~

~ 'g

:; v;

. ~ ~

~

:=,' 'g

. ~

t:.;

't:I

;' g'

... ~

., ;

~ '<

~

g...

, ~

. ~

a ~ ~

a.

c::!.

§=

~ 5

'g.

~ IS

a ~

~ ~

. D

2: ~

~ g

~

g. j;;'>

S

~ f--

:" ;

~ ~:J

~

9 s

';; ~

~ ::r

~

~ >

g' a~

' ~

V

>"':

-S"'o

~

~.e

nac§

- en

0

::r.:?

't:.;:

:rn

,'t:I(

't)I\)

~(I

):::(

Jq=

...

::r;.;

't:

jgl('

t)::r

0

g. 't:I

g

g':::

':3 ~

. 5'- 0

~

:=

,' g:

~

2 ~

~

g, II)

8 ~

g.. fr

::r 'i

8

~ :

g ~

~: 8

Q.. g

~ §

' ~

~

0 if

Q..

~

..,a

if %

~ ~

. S ~

. ~ r

i g" ~

(Jq

:J

::!

~::r

~

: ~

: -

'< ~ g

8. ()"

a (I

) '"

~ ~

R g

., a

...

e.. a.

~ ~

0

~...

<

=(1

)'<

II)

O!"

'l'>

""",

"'<

:(I)

::I""

aa

cv

'I:j't

:j n

0-';:

;: -~

.0

=

Cc:

: ::I

Q

.. B

. 0

Q..

0 :;.

~ ::

r ~

~

... e.

~ 0

~

:=" a.

0

I\)

'" '"

(I)

:!. ~

...

fi' -.

8 ('t

) s~

R

=:I

Qq

g. ~

~

t1;j

"'lI)

ia

~~

"'(

1);:!

(1)Q

..~

(1)-

"(;)

""

'::r

.~'t:

I,<II)

~

::r:!.

II)(I

>'t:

I...~

. 1I

)-('t

)(1)

('t)

CI>

~ ~

~ ~

~ ~

~

~ ~

~ ~: if

~ ~

g gg

;. g

~ :g o"

a ~

g. ~

'<a" $.

: ~

~O~

. ~ e

g, ~

a

'i .,;'~

. ~ ~

:1\

)-.

Q..

::r'.-

o""';

:t ~

-"

,~.(

't)

CI>

., 1:

- '<

't:

I(I)

(1)

--'-'

11)<

; "

'":J

-;

' ~

...

~

('t)

~,;a

< g

. g. g

: e

0.: ~

. ~

g

-.!

'g

",,'

0' 8

~ ~

~.

&;"

~ ~

~ ~

.;; t

::: ~

~

g a

In' 5

<

II)

~

::r ~

('t)

2

0 ~

Qq

'" <

.I>

(1)

(I)

...

('t)

S ('t)

s';;

('t)

0 =

:: (I

) 6)

tz,

~ ~

0

."

g.;

~

~

~:!,

c

In'

Q..

>

g. ~

~ ~

'6 ;1

;:;- Q

:;.

g ~

~

11. ~

e. [

~ g

; g

Ii ~

~. a

6 ~

~ ;;

;a a

==

~ So

S' !

? g.

"s' ~

~

=r=

g

~it~

og~

§;:~

&~

rb

g'<

f ~

~;~

~,<

~g§

!~O

'~~

~~

~i:

~~

~~

t ~

~ ~.a-

~ ~.

~ ~.

~. '2

~ ~

~ §

a ~.§.

g0

§ ~

!n'

~ 0 ..,

;g' g

. n a

~ O'Q o

~

~ ~

"" 0~ o

j;;'>.,

O,...

~ ~

~. ~ I

V>

""

'-"-"

".,"

""~

~

t...~

" ""

,. ""

'yo-

" ,.,

. -.

~,

.!

I,.IJ

oc -..

> c: - . ~ ~ ::c c: :z:

C"J

::c t""

> Z 0 v..

\D

Page 4: - II> - 0mechanism.ucsd.edu/teaching/philsci/churchland.realism.pdf · Po>a:=: ~, 5' g. So t: 8 So g-""::b';:J ~(1'~",('I)g ('I) ~ g. 0 '2. '2. ;i 1:; ... aq ~ Er 0- e-. ~ ::2

~

>'0

t:

-::r

~ Q

q "'I

-.

0:

0V

> ~

0' "

'I S

o ~

-< 'g

t:;.'O

ootR

nol»

n::I

.

II)

~06

',...,

.,::I -.

'E.

~.

-~'T

Ig'<

::r

t;:an

'O

"'I

°

6 ~

~e-

~to

::r

~

_. ~

Eo ~

~

o 11

0':.

° ~

~

.-

::I

CII

::I -.

...~

~

1I)(

't)~

~

~

<'O

SIl)

~~

§

:!.~

~

:3

~

'TI

~

110'

<:

'g<

::f'

"'I

_.

~

::.

CII

n t'E

.",,'

<'"

:::-.

~

n

~ <

::f' o

~

~o=

='<

SC

II t:I

""'::

ron

-,

CII~

~

I\>

<::f

' n

a -<

1,9:

:1

CII

;;51

~

",

.qq

n t:

51

...

~ <

n~

c"

::rO

E

r::r

~.

'0 ~

: qq

~ -

<

51 0

C

II °

n '0

::1

::r~

::I

::j'

n ~

~ ;

:;.~

;:'

)'a.g

::CII

...

-I»

,::,.1

»!i;

. ;-

'<' ~

_. g

-I»

C

II

g,

~"'8

't:lg

n .0

=6,

",0-

0 ;a

.~;~

5i

n - 0:

0 ::I

...

~

:::";

3n~

-'::1

c"

'0

CII

6 ~

. Qq

~ tn

. ~c"

~

O'-;

::;i

n ""

"'I~

3c"

n ~

o:o~

e.~

~

o;.~

o

t:I»

e-

n

'-I

qg.

c"~

n

n ~

~

.c

.,

"'I

'0

. -'

~

""

,.. ~

.-

_.

,

...' r

.:r Q

..""

... "

d ::r

-"0'

<

: 0

~;:;

>

~

:;r 1

::' =

?i

j rn

C

-Go o

' 0'

-

~

Pi'

~~

n"'~

~'~

o~~

~C

~~

-::S

=~

"'=O

-~O

o-=

:;r~

~~

=Q

..O~

~~

",~

:<

0 ~

'"i

(J

Q C

JQ...

('D

::r

0 0

ti! ~

- -

_. ... "

%j

~

'"I

~. 8

~

::r

~

=

(11

:;r ~

=

=

Q

.. 0

0 a"

- OJ

8 0

=

-.0

~

a.~

°"

d 0

~

0 n

~.=

=

n

0 ~

"0

8'

CJQ

~

!.

~

'"i

:::;.

&!!

0 (J

Q

::r

-.

0 ~

.'"

:3

~

~- (;J

~

Q

.. "0

rn

en

...

!:r

ti! (

'D

!"!

-. =

~ -

-. ..

. I'b

un

='::

S

'"10"0

"d

~

0

...

~

Q..

8 ::s

0

.S1

.S1

:::;-

en

=...

...

~

~

. u"

"o""

""",

0

~~

~ a

~ g

:~.

S' ~

;.

g" ~

;'

~

'E.

o' '

<

';<: ~

8 .;

~°"

Ooo

~_o

o~o

~"'=

:3Z

~oo

E g

=--

;.

8 0

~ 8

n =

dO

' g

=:

~ a

" ,

0 0

_. f

!!-- ~

('D

~'.9

...

0 e:

! ::r

-< 8

B

~

'd

0 e.

~,

en

0_.'"

'o

JO"'1

",::r

""

0"'-"

"'-'

0"'0

N'

'"I

<

0 ...

0

!"!

0 ...

<

::s

0 <

: ~

~

~;':

:s

o~or

n:;r

'"l;:;

>~

o"'::

ro"'~

o -

. ~

_.

- 0

II> "

0'

=

~

>;

a 0

'<

- ~=

""'t;

>-0

...0"

"",<

Ci>

~."

'::S

...

.~O

~!~

~II>

O~

::ro.

..<

, no

~~

cc

""'"I

~O

O::r

~'=

'>::r

CN

' c-

8 ~

ti!

~ ~

0

0: ~

-. ~

=

R

~ ~

';'

<: ;

. B

. f!!.

Q..

08=

0_.=

_,

o..."

%jr.

:r

...~

n...a

"°~

"O°'

='>

o=

o"'~

=:;r

~~

~::r

~=

-o~

:<-

0 0"

""

... 0

11>

"" ... 0

-

~

_.0

"d-~

~!.-

.~~

~~

~_o

,

"%jo

o"'~

~~

<:

=

-o"'~

Q..~

W'"l

"':<

';<:~

0 _.

:;r

~

0 t:r

Q

(J

Q!1

1 "':

:!,

-,

0 '-'

~

0

n ~

r.:r

<o:

::,~

o..o

...;.o

=",

v

~=

-t:;C

_.

no=

-",~

~co

=

o~~

D>

="'i

cQ""

5'

:::;':

3 ~

;:;

>

0 =

0

=0"0

oS

' =

Q

.. Q

.. n

Q

o'"

'-';:;

>

.. D

>

!"!

0~

C

- 0

::r"'o

=

=

::r

1I>

:=t'r

.:r~

II>~

;:;>

C'"

"'r:!~

~o

'II>

~""

'~(J

Q-,

~=

"':

:!O!"

!""

Crn

"O

~'-

<--

C

C

i>0

Q..g

~::r

~~

~O

OR

°D>

::So~

~",

g"dB

<n(

JQo--

>; <

~-=

=~

C"'r

n~"'O

o"'0

° -"

"I;1

:I-~

D>

_""O

(;J-

'_.o

::r",

- ",

~D

>°c

-.""

'-"'-'

" 0'

" _.

c.=

~

D

> <

t:!.

'" ...

Q

.. 0

0 '

. -,

~ ~

::s

c5' =

Q ~

. ...

'TJ

::r C

JQ ~

ia

t ~

~

~

'"I

'"

R

0 ~

::I

;.

'-'

0 O

JO

J ~

~

=

-,

"0

::r

'<

0

=:,I

~

=

"d

~

~

~

1:

1 =

:,I ~

,D

>

- =

'" 0

C

Q..

0 :;r

...

oC

) ...

-,

;! ~

0rn

""O

""""

"""r

n <

O

~

C=

!:>.

O=

"'...

"'<o.

..:;r

"0

--

-0""

"-.

.,o~

-'~'"I

::ro'

='>

~-

-'-'~

I:I

::s~

C-

=

'"I

"'D>

0

0'"!

°::S

"O

'<~

<:~

~(J

QN

~~

rn" _

. "g

~

~

'"I 0

"S

o::s

~

c ...

'-'

=

"O~

~go

ir~~

o ~

Q..Q

..oco

~=

...'"'

Oil>

~

"'~

""'-"

"""'-

""10

000"

'-0-0

""

,On

~w

::r::r

ri°8"

'o~

~Q

..§~

~'a

~B

.c

~oo

",~

~

CJQ

n (J

Q e

n' _

. C

0'

"0

t!;

1:1

C

0 8

::::!

D>

;:!

. S

0

~""

~""

" -"

~

~

~=

- -

O"~

;:;>

"0

~

~

=:,I

:::.'"

Q

-

0-

... 0

~

Q

.. ~

...

>

; ...

..,

0 =

:::.Q

..~°;

;r.~

o °o

""'()

'::!.,

",'"I

~::r

0 0

:i -,

~

0

a'

a,

. c

"'...,

::r ~

~

II>

~

-"

"'i"

'.:""

,<:"

O...

::...

0 0-

""""

'"

~

° ...

, 8

a 8

S- n

~

~

ti!

~ ~

S- t

;' 8

"S. °

a a

:::

:a-

~

1»0

1»_°

8"'1

1»-

~n

-OC

1»;"

1--

.(I

) 'A

o A

o ..

::3""

" ~

>

; or

8~

...

8

.. U

'; ~

~'g

.C1)

t:lC

1)t:I

'O~

:;rti!

~p.

.gtr

' m

~C

1)~

"'C1)

t;I

:j<

t::

8 "'C

1)~

C1)

~'<

-::3

t::-~

->;C

1)t::

- ("

)

~'°

t::~

tr'~

<~

::3...

,tr""

8tr'0

~~

::3n

a=

-.,..

.::3n

C

1)i:I

~Q

:I"'C

1)C

1)o~

~

Ao,

<t::

tr'

C1)

Otr

'...tr

'noa

o (l)

5'~

:::;'-

'i:lC

1)00

""S

'I»C

1)

~::3

C1)

tr""

0'1j

ot

::aoo

~C

1)

~-'~

~C

1)rn

i:l

~'r-

0 C

1)

(;

8 ~

,a

::s a

~

::3 9

: ~

~

a-

~

&;

~ .:;

r ~, °

gC

1)a-

n::s

'O...

ol»'

1j",

_,-'1

jC1)

o:::"

n~S

~

,...

<"'O

C1)

I»C

1)A

o",~

tr'rn

--~

S'~

'<~

""

tr'

-.0

8v

""8

C1)

nO

O

.o~

.~

o~

~0'

1jC

:! ...

.p.

.""

...

'" rn

i:l

v'ao

o --

"...

C1)

~

'0

..:.a

~

.o

~ a

o st::

' ~

~

...

n

~ °

R. ~

~"<

r;

;=

~

tr

'v,"

, C

1)~

t::

I -.

tr'1

» v"

" I»

-.

- en

(")

:::0'

>;

C1)

...

(")

-,

rn

"0

'1j

S. °

C1)

'"

CI>

0

::J, =

-<' 0

<

J>f1

' ~

C1)

tr'tr

'no:

:S-';

::;:C

1)t:I

'<"'"

,<""

,,~

~

r'!.g

-'8

C1)

e.O

nAo:

:!'IJ

,~...

"'~::!

Q:a

...nA

o ::s

;:r-<

C

1)n=

O(l)

n...,

tr

'~C

I>::;

C1)

C1)

oop.

. ,..

,~

A. C

1) "S

. >:

C1)

~8

~ '<

C

:!. '1

j t:r

t:I

C

I> .

.. t:r

"1

...

.C

1)<

ao""

"'"

_.::s

_.

""

~t::

vnvt

r'C1)

~

,...

-, -

~

. g a

- <

'1j

(")

~

< '<

...

...

C

1)

~

C1)

ti!

(I)

tr'

9~0~

~

=rt

i!C1)

~~

~

. ~

t:ro(

l)fJ:

t:I...

C

1)-;

:;: ::

s g'

~

...

~ Q

q tr

' ~

"':

::;:;

::s I;

:j '<

C

1) -,

~

t:.

~ ~

C

I)_.

(")-

~0C

1)

C1)

C1)

v.

"I

j°'O

°o::s

av

t::

~f1

'<~

~C

1)~

~~

S-C

I)

>;"

'""s-

a ~

~~

'1

j0.

..ti."

,<:t:

:It:r

-'~~

5'

~'E

'~O

'1j~

t::

It::

0ti!

::r

...

. v e

: ...

~ ~

- -

0 (I

) fir

ClQ 8

...

-.

~

C1)

p..

0 ...

t:I

~

t::

n tr

' 0

_.

0 C

I>

<

0 ~

°

0 ~

C

1)

0 C

1) ;':

:r

C1)

:::

"'"

0 '"

C1)

0

~

_.

0'

'" -,

~

8

.:;r-

'" ~

~~

nn~

::S

~~

~~

~~

'1j§

'1

j~

9

° '"

::r

... ~

° C

1)

'0'"

0 t::

::S

... -

-,~

o"""

~~

aoC

1)!3

~o'

a""

""~

'<fJ

:~t::

~~

o ::!

.o§

-tr'

~

o::l'

g.:

~i:I

~_o

"'o~

-' n

::s <n

t:r

~

~

a-

'1j

C

1) rn

n

...

_. ~

~

.., 0

~

~

"' C

1)

"'~-

a=

'" p.

. t::

::St::

'.~..,

::r:::

2...n

o-O

't::'<

~t:I

~

~~

"'~~

(I)v

~C

1)

-<~

0

~

~

~ ~

~

~

("

) '<

°

v '0

v

g, ~

::x

= :::

'1j s-

::;

.Q

.AoO

C1)

n:"'-

o_

,~

"""C

1)-e

;v

-.t::

°C1)

...

..'"

"'~

o~~

i:I=

~

...,_

0 ~

CI>

...~

'" t::

.., ~

qg.

s-

t:: g

~ ~

::;>

~

'< C

1) g:

a- ~

(I

) S

,.?' ~

ET

~

tr'~

~o~

~~

og'O

o 8Q

qC1)

-,...

C1)

~~

0~

t::~

no~

~

-C1)

-' 1»

.,...,

<tr

'~~

(1).

..,-

:. C

I> - tr'

00

sr °

S!

n 5'

0

e:. ~

0"0

:::

C

1)

tr'

(1)

]1»0

m

:.!..

ot:r

-O

ClO

t::

"11»

""C

'bv

""--

'CI>

O

'rnnC

1)t:I

-"

"n~

::SO

Ao~

O

-.'"

-!:.1

on.

..,oO

::lo

t:lt::

,..,>

;.':;"

!:!

>;

...

. C

1)

,. I»

n

..,'"

n n

>;

- C

1)

~

~

...

~

C1)

!3 "S

l a a

9::s

a-

no"

" t::

~

0

p..

Qq

0 0'

t'>

C

.t::

;i

~ t

:: C

1) ::s

~ C1

) ~~

. -,5<

. ~

° 2

.. ~

. 0

(b

t:I ~

. ~""

_",,n

O

~C

I>

Ao-

,,<...

="'C

I>"'-

_"'<

"'o-~

o-'O

ao

-t::O

I»«

a- ~

~ a

-!3

a"- ~

0 ~

~ °

0

S- 0

' ~ 5

' a ~

~

. ti.

0 ,

'" 0

, 0

v ::s

J

,..,

,0

""

0 'v

,

I

~ 0:;.

~

:>0'

a.g.

~~

~

...::!

. ::;

"(i!

<:

~

(II

(II

Q.

~(;

> -

i~ ::!.

0-~

""I

"C

I»0

::If!!

.'<::!

. Q

.0

-.::I

~

g,~

-0

n::I

t:I

n ...

<Jt

::;"

fj:;O

:t:I

0

~

~... '<

()

~

I»'0

t:I

. "51

er

~"5

I~

S

'(;

>

()0

if.-

-

;:rn

~

.~i n~ n'

(;>

t:I

(')

g.

;-'<

t:I

-.

(Jq

'" n

'" ~ "0 ... ....

(') ,....

'" 9 (') 0 = n ... '"I = ... = OQ ... if '" "0 !!? "° ~ ==

'< < ... ... '< ~ 1:;-

~ ;:s ... ... =-

... ... ... (So

'" "0 0 '" 2 SO

~ ... 0- cr"

'< ::r ....

'"

......

......

......

......

u.>

1'

-.1

.....

'-"

'-"

'-"

...

....

::r::r

::r:r

s'

s'

0000

00(;

:I '"

'"

=

0o:

:ra-c:

'"0

<J)

(I

>

a- 0

::!

<J)

a-

n~

~p.

.<

~a-

~<

'<9:

~",

I'D - C

a- n

:I

'<

a- (I>

::r

'<

::rc:

::r

t:

:I t:

:II»

:3

~=

~

=

(;:I

=...

.....

~.?

'~.

; a-

~'

-c:::

r:-

"'c=

=

0 ~ ..'

...

0-=

I'D

~p.

.~

<

J)(')

I'D =

C

'"a-

n~

?~ < ('D 0- ~ = p.

.

-'0""

'6r~

=:s

c:r

So

~..,

=

:s

'0

~n

>:-

30

=:s

~ ::

!. "'i

~

0 =

:s ::

:: "'i

::I

<

G'

(';

n a

'<

D. 2

-t:

an-

' II)

'0

..

P.

I\)

6r'O

n-

ot:

'g.::

s c:

:!. '0

=

:s"'i

I\)

...

0

~ ~

nn

'" ""

::1

, n

0 _.

~ ~

t::

~ I\

)

-'~nO

Cl>

,<::I

a"'-

::S"'C

I>!)

q::r

5'

C

I> 0

n 0

'<n

t::"':

:r...

0 -.

II)

n

::r

I\)

0a:

a :::

:::r

~

::s ::

;.n'

O

~'O

...~

.no

~-:

:r

t::\:j

...

"'i -.

II)

n ...

t::

o' 6

r S

~.

n ~

...

::s :

:s n

r;

::I

"'i

n

~ ~

. ~

. g. a

..g"'i

O

~'<

~I\)

n c:

r _.

=:r

=

=

CJS

o g~

n~0

a "' 0

c:r~

0'

::s n

~ I

\)

...

6: 8

~

~

;.

~n

=

~ ~

-'<

"'i

VI

-..,!

::!...

Q

: 0.

, rq

';::>

~ n

?J

"'C

...

r;'

0.;

"'~~

~-.

_.

'0

~

('J)

~

0 ::r

...

f'>

n~

. =

'<

£

C;)

0

~ :f

' f!!

. - -s,

"S-

n -~

n

c::!'

n II)

~

;:

n0.

.. -.

c:-':

:I=

:s

3 ;-

..'

a

=-

g' n

~

a s.

~t::

-"

O;:t

~

~ a

. 8'

~ g

, g~

n

-. n

n

"' ...

C

I>

0""

",

::rn:

:ln8

0 ~

n~

~

(;!

'i!,

('J)

'" > c. t""

3::

(")

= C :::cI

(")

=s: t""

.> Z t::1

.$>

....

.Q

'g

2

0-1

~

g"

~

~

~

@

[ 5

~

$'

g-

a.

ri°

- s:

: ::r

0

=--

-

~

g:

~

-,

...

-0

- ::I

-,

=

e-.

::r

~

~

s::

0 °

.r>

-

t;'

~

l . "0

s:

: ::r

0.

::3

:::IJ

' ~ -

...

~ -

, ::r

0

...

~

~ ~

-

o "1

J:

) =

:;:::

0>

~s:

:-

::I

...~

<

I)

"i<l)j

»OS

::o

::;'~

:.:

. "'t

=

0>

-

9 if

(1>

, 0

8 !!!

, s:

: IJ'

0.

t;'

s::

,<~

~00

1J'::

r~

5-0~

O<

l)~::r

Vl

, ~

~

IJ

' 0

&;)

' /1

1 =

0

-,

;;>::r

o~

. ~

1J',~

o<l)S

:: <

oo"'(

I>°o

=-~

1J'

s::,<

~0"

'8~

=...

S::C

::=1J

':i°-

s::

- -,

n

"1

0 00

~

"'t::r

"0

=

:I ~

-,

~

0...

0

"'...<

0

8O

OR

'=

...

_OO

w_-

~O

- n~

~

- ~

::r 0

. '<

IJ'

(I>

°

...

-"

...

~

o~ .

.. "'-

0..,

_O"1

o>...

,@o~

(1

>(1

>;;>

",...

.0

::1\ ~

~

:;!

u

:, ~

00

0' ::

1.

0> 0

.r

' IJ

' <

I)

..,::3

~

rn.

o>

~,'"

~

.=--

"1

~

=

8 ~

(1

)::3

0

0 /1

1 0.

1'

;0 !Z

::3

t;'

i;:

~

rtI.-

0.

0

::3 =

-- ~

t'"

'::I

s::

.. 0

0 ::r

0'

" 0.

(1

)O

"'_!::

(I>

O'"1

rn&

;)'..

,=

0 ~

::3

0O

q w

~

n.

.. ~

<I)

-"

0 w

°

'<

.-;;;

- 0'

...

' -,

go

~

(I

>

~

OJ

o~

~

o V

I 0

C)

::rs:

:::3"

'(1)=

o...,

u ~

C

l>0>

"1~

0 ...

.g.

.IJ

<I)

S

' S

' '<

'<

::3

~ g

. ::3

1J'::

3;-

~ ~

n

0-

<1)

"'0;;>

0 °-

'0

00'<

~

~

g (

I>

c::

;:: 0

CIQ

- "I

1 =

- n

en S

o::l,

~

"'t

0 "0

":

:3

-.,

"1

.. "0

~

-

"00"

'=8

-=--

00>

~

-o~

'<

t'"'

ri ::r

...

W

0 0

~

00

'" 0'

"...

oo~

,(1)

~=

i:!.r

o~~

~

~::3

0

..."

c::

n ...

' '1

o

"i =

:<

...

°

g-

=:I

° ~

IJ

' ..,

'O~

"'~~

...~

CIQ

~~

=

c::-

~or

o ~

'B

!!!,

5 ...

'<

;

=--

a'

=

0

<II

...

n g

s::

0>

..,

(l>8=

~(1

>"'~

~0.

~~

~

e-.-

~"O

~

°oo,

.c...

rno'

a-(I

><

II ::r

::l\o

. 'g

. '-<

n 0.

a- a

'0

::r ~

~

0

8""

no...

.g

", ~

rn

.2.

~

n' ~

n

::r ~

~ 0'

" "'1

@

::r

R c:

:oc

r...

-,n

0-'

s::

o=g.

..o.

0~

'«~

~~

o>g.

cro~

.g

",n

(I>

~

~I»

~c:

: rn

'"l-'n

Oq

oocr

~,

=

g -,

0>

0

~

n =

'<

s:

: 0>

g

cr (

1) °

0 0

0 =

r 8

~'..

. 8

a'

0 s:

. &

. .r

' ~

~

Q

q' =

' ~

"0

::;'

00

0 ::r

""~

';-!::

! a'

-

""

(Jq

::r n

(I

>::1

,,< - =

0>

n =

... -

- I»

::r

~ ~

.<

-"

""'C

IQ

r-o.

.°<

l) p'

og;;>

=

t!j~

""8<

1)

::;.

0..,

",

...=

-(Jq

S::,

~

° ::3

s::

=

g, s::

g. g

° :

:r :

:r

_.

-< n

(JqC

IQ"'(

I>O

00

(1);

;>00

00

(1>

0 tn

::r

::r .

.. ...

0

=,

P'

a' =

'0

=

(I

>

tn'"

~oo

=(I

>t:o

S-(

I>

::3

n~~

0.

"1

~c"

1::3

o~~

&-

"1<

1)~

~~

w

'" <

I)

"1

"1

<

"10>

0"0

(D

J

"0

a'

0 n1

<

(D

c:

: t1

I cr

'. ::3

""

t'"'

(D~

~~

~-'

<1)

0>=

8 ~

~~

Q

. ~

C.

0 if

o'

0'

0 ~

s:

: !Z

0

° ::;

' o'

s:

: t:t

> (

D

(A

~.:;

J ::j

':-<

~

E

i .,.

11?

uro

=?

t;'

~

~.r

>

~

g

~~

Page 5: - II> - 0mechanism.ucsd.edu/teaching/philsci/churchland.realism.pdf · Po>a:=: ~, 5' g. So t: 8 So g-""::b';:J ~(1'~",('I)g ('I) ~ g. 0 '2. '2. ;i 1:; ... aq ~ Er 0- e-. ~ ::2

'-':::

.9°:

::,"'(

")'"

'O~

'O:::

,~~

n:::.

s'n

'0--

-' ,

0 0

t1I

::I n

~ 0

i=f

ti" ('I

I (D

' S 0

::I

e.

~ aq

~

n if

e:::I

3.

0 ~

g

So g

. r;

' ~

~

n

::I 3

5'

. fa

n ::I

::I

,..

u ,<

::I

~ t

o> n

...

"1

:::

. ti"

'<

-, - ;J>

ti -

t:! n

~ :

e e-

- t1I:J

'"

o 0

~ 0

_.

~

M

~ ~

~~

~ o

~ ~

~ ~

i

~ ~

~ ~

~ ~

,~ §

- ~ :

.~, ~

~ ~

; a ~

~ ~ ~

~ ~

~ ~

~ [Q

8 i

fi,..

'<0

""'1

('11

oC

n 1\

);':

n"'('

IIn

""'0

(1

>"1

~

rnn~

~

E.r

n ::1

11:1

A

orn,

«'II~

"'B

Ii:-,

('I

I rn

~

S

o ;;-

:!

c-

='

o -

0 0

=-

- <

a

., ~

~

,('II

=

-::1

o

('II

c..

Q..

- "0

:J

('I

I ~

::r

...

n "t

1 ... 0

=

~

(11

=-

('II

- 11

:1

,. "1

~

=

- I\)

::s

::I

0

'<

n I\)

'<

,.

II>

9 =

- -

c..

c-

n g

-,

...

...

('II

a-:J

11

0>

:r

::I

..

::r""

"::I-

"'1~

'9aS

'n('l

l::S

0~('I

I""=

=

~'IM

o'O

°~

~6o

-,""

"~~

~8n

o."'~

""=

.:;!

-,

::;

~,

en (

I> I

ii'

I\)

'0

OQ

o

"1

Q..

a""

'9

;r

0'

'8

~

~

=1'

'0

Q..

So.

, (I

>

~

go

So

C

S

::I'

S

no

~

_.

g,

~

C!::

I ...

en('l

l""..-

'::S

('ll

C

'.9::S

I\)

...,o

('1

1<0-

-""(

'11

"'Oto

:>::I

('II"

'to:>

n:J

"'0-

<""

'=

",o'

o::l:

:lB;,<

n'O

,<o-

<

=-:

:In<

,l\

)o..!

t::::"

::Ir.

n~!:"

I c.

."'n

!n'-:

:I-'

II)n

cr.n

=-.

".,n

OQ

n

,t;;t:

i'n"'l

no

Q..I

\)I'D

\O""

a--I

\)('I

I"""

'r;"'O

'I'D

""o

~

-<~

I')

==

0 I\)

0

~I'D

~

I'D

(I

>

""

o.""

Q)

('II

8"""

'::1

.-.~

"1

~(I

) ti"

C;

t;;S

"",c

v~

=

=0

~

C Q

)",

if'n

..<"1

-"

'1\)

"'::1

n:

:l-"'1

I\)~

tr

' -<

\OI'D

(I>

...

nc..-

o '<

::Ic.

.~rn

g ~

;3

I\) ~

I'D ~

:::

, ff

o'

::s ~

~

~ ~

0

C

c..

Ii <

~

~ 0

v

if v

~

:e '?

Q)

t::".

=-

I'D

a-:e

::I

...

...

('I

I "1

~

"',

'" ~

9 ~

~

:r

~ "

1 g

Q..

~

A -

QJ"

<:

::s

~""

~

I'l

l 0.

-.

~ =

, '"

OJ

.~

.:! ~

~ Q

, ('I

I ...

:e

0 ~

e, C

Oo'

S S

o 0.

...

' "0

I'D

0

C

9 '

~,u

~

=- n

~

e

0 C

8"

... <

: no

S'::

I ~

-

~.

I')

=- g

o '"

~

-,

i:!.

Q.

~ ~

~ a

s,;;

: ; ~

'<

!! ~

~ ~

rr ~

~ ~

'~ ~

Ii &

" ~

~ J'

R >'

lj ~

[;

[~ ~

~ :; a ~

g ~ f

""'1

('11n

('llc

c-a-

'O

::::..

0.

c o=

=

(1>

::11'

) u

p;v'

" A

I"

D

~l\)

l\)n'

.C-~

....

: g

~

g ~

a'

;! '"

'<

a r;

' 0

~

~

::I

~

...

!n'

g,

~

~

0'

~

~

!;;'

Q)

~

"a

: ~

I\)

~

;'.:!

::s

...

::r

~

S

8,

;::>

I'D

_.

e

::;'::

1 0.

~

=

- =

- "1

Q

) ?

en

~

Q)

('II

-<

""

Qq

==

'T

j =

- s:

: :e

...

A

o.

~

.., '0

0

~

C

~

R

'<

I"D

5'

R

~

<

S

' tr

I\)

:;

I"D

~

~

~

('I

I O

Q

n ~

('I

I ...

' '<

0.

""

~

('II

~

=-

~~

c

i=f

~

...,

~

0' '

<

a,

5'

~

Ii:'

Qq

0.

(II

~

Qq

~

'" ~

:;

~

~

..,

I"D

::s

S

g

't1 I

i .?

'O

~

R

t ,Q

~

::I

S

o <

:0

a- n

...

~

-<

0 ~

,..

, a ~

S' -

S!iS

...'

... 0

:r

g ::

I~::I

i=f =

- ~

~

~

"1 a

::;';

r;;' g

j ~

"0

n t;'

~

~

(II

0 ::1

1 '<

~::s

~

n

::r

('II

0 S

" S

o ::t

' '"

g,

e!.

S

"1

tr

'" 0.

(I

> Q

) ::I

~

'..,

t S

' r.

n O

Q 0

' S

r.

n ~

0

=-

(l>°a

"",..

.rnC

:lSoo

('l

lrA::l

.=l"D

o...o

=~

oa..!

tn

I"D

~-'v

~",

~,R

a::s

=

""1a

~('I

I-,

"'1

0'

_.

=

=:

;;.

0::s

:e

0

0.

...

'<

n :;r

'" (I

) 0'

('I

I I"

D

..,

0 t;'

C

n

('II

'" '"

a n

0 @

j '0

Q

)

~ ~

~ 0.

5..9

Si' ~ o

R

9 ~

Q.. 5'

~

sa ~

~ a

~,~

ti"

<:~

,v ~

~ ~

,sa

~ S

S (I>

~'e

F.

~

n ~ ...

[:g""

"~o'

-"

oq

"'1

":;r

"'"

('II'"

"'0

"'"

S»~

I"D

('II'"

tI...=

v...~

".

..v,

(11

'-tD

;- ;

Q C

"rI

s..

==

::I

s: Q)

ii1

e- =

: R !n

' 0'

(I

>

~

"'t. ~

- <:;;

(II

::I

'<

~,'"

:=

:'"

Q)

I\)v

R "O

~ 6

" (I)~

~

'< to

>"'1

0'

t;'

,..

0 u

en ~

rA Q

):::

a I'D

0.

'0

(IIA

::S ;

~.

"'t. e:

::t Ii

U

Q)

~.!D

,...

~

: t;"

'..

"1

0.

_:

~ ~

;[

~ n

~

'2 ~

g. 5'

~

8. ~ ::!

~!5

,' ~

a =t>

~,

s'

~~

, ~

K'E

i g.

;! S

' ~ ~

g ~

~. cfij

':., ~

Pr I

i ~

ii'

",,°

g

=-:

3 ~

('I

I'~, c

'-'

0 ...

':

to>

- 'E

, o sn

'g.

:3::1

~

< ~

~ 0

' n

~ "

1 ::I

S

' Qq,

3 -':

r ~

~

~ .

~

~

='

Q)

~

::r <

... C

:! tr

::l

~ "0

0'

=t>

' 0,

n r;

' 0.

~

.. - I'D

aa,

C

:! I"

D :

:I =

P

;::b

~ ~

"

':'1 "

'...:

CI>

.,(',I

-n

onoQ

)::r

o I'D

g=-1

i) Q

)n::l

""'"

"""o

'OI"

DI\)

«I>

-I\)

~r.

nI\)

:e._

'n::l

1 =

(;:1

Q)

t! ~

OJ

-< :

:r a

- g a

- a"

I"

D n

15 a

~ °

::;' ~

~

::I

-. ~

a,

!!.'

Ii:'

"0

~ ~

a, if

n~ =

- ~ 5

";"

-g'

'-' I')

"1

v

Q)

ti" Q

q ~

0

'<

,:-s

~

~ (

'II

I\)

!n' ~

v 0'

S

o I"

D n

'<

~

'<

- ""

~

('II

0 ,..

OQ

OQ

,..

, ~'

0C

5'

0.

0'

::r

en

, =

- "1

(/

I:e

00

:e 0

. ~

;.

no"1

~

...,::

I n

...

r.n

n 0. 0

I"D

0

; ...

0...

_0"0

..'

Q

) G

...

(',I::

S""

"",<

"'=

-::1

."

,on

",-(

I>o.

o('ll

oQ)

M'O

...tr

-~

~...

'" o

'<

:;r 0

t::

: ('II

Q)

Q).

..,

('II

=

c: "1

,Q

;J

> 0

' =

- -:

e =

:"'

= e

. U C

:! ~

n:

('II

'<

0 c:

a- ~

y;

::>

g:=

- c: =

- 0 Q

)-<- >c

C-

::I

n no

n,...

C

...

"1

~

=

- (11

- 0.

(I

>

_. =

- a-

"'1

::1

::I e

. 0

... =

- a-

t;' g.

-, '"

-,

0 '0

ti"

0.

=- 0

",

y:;r

,.,...

~

0.

I"D

~

no

C

,.. Q

: (I)

0

I'D =

::1

a C

:I Q

.. 0.

' =

- I"

D

...'

o~:l"

Da~

~~

: e-

~ao

Q)~

~

~~

;=

~a~

~~

o.~

~g~

~~

('11~

~~

:::n

'" en

~

0 e;

.. -,

_3'

C

:! I"

D

0.

('II ~

=t>

"1

v

0 I"

D

Ii S

" I\)

...

s» .

.. <

R

Ii '"

"1

~

"'I

=- Q

, =

- 0.

'0

if~

~ 1

S ..'

§

u '"

Q..

en r.

n ~

~ Q)

.g

~,S

o OQ

~ n

n: a

p,::;'

(I

I ..'

OQ

i: ~

=- ~

('II ~

,~

I'D 0

9,<

na,

~(1

1 ""

""0<

:S'"'

I::I

s'2

.1\)

~

oJ'l"

Doc

:,:-s

o.l\)

l"Dl"D

'<Q

-::S

O('l

ln:S

'S

~j;)

'::I(

',I~

::Ig8

" a=

-_,I\

)I"D

I"D

Q_N

~

c..,

::S::l

2--,

~::!

r;ne

nen:

::-..,

e~,..

"..~

ICI>

"o."

,"1

,0...

",..,

..,-

1 C

I>""

","',

'

, 1,

,"'v

.y.ll

w,

~

CT

I')t:r

::r-

""""

""""

"-'<

na""

"""

..,..'

t:n""

" ,L

"',,:'

~-o

""

"::r

<n"

"""I

1-'"

1')"

0<0

r.

(;)

t: S

' -.

::r

t: ::I

t:

I') - ;S

o ::r

::1

::1 0

(I

) '"I

t::

:r

'" ::r

t:::I

VI

~

~

::; '"

::I

I-t

::r '"

0

0 ::;

''"I

c:

.,

...

0 ~

(;

>

'" '"

0.

0..

0 '<

...

g

'" ~

i5

:: ~

0

""

0 ::I

'"

1::,

n ~

~

0.

. b)

t:

0 p.

. '"

8 '"

"I1

"0

(JI

0::I

r

g.

!:!

?-

~

~::I

;-

0.

~

~

a:

:r

'" ~

a

0 g.

~

:,

ii ~

"I

1 ~

g

~

t: 0

'"'

...

!4

Q,

'" ~

'"I

::I

0

a ~

::I

~

?' C

'? 5

~

"0

g.

~

0 ;>

(I

) 0

;:;

;s, _

. '"

-.

(I)

n (I

) ...

(;

) ""

': '"

- ::r

0

Q.

0 0

0 :\J

'<

0

...

'" ::r

S...

' ""

'n...

"'o

o~...

,.,

-'"1_

,on

--"'-

0 -

.o::~

!:1

<n-

~'~

...C

I)~

",'J

o-,

o --

=

n (1

> ,-

,. ::;

0

I::!::

:'"

'" ~

"':

:'.'"

0'_""

0 >

'.--;

:J

=

CT

;:J

'::;"

::r

;:Joo

n

0"'_

_""'0

0 ~

'~

<

~'..

o ..

0..

<:

""'0

..,0

~"O

...t:

::I'2

rr

0::I

::I

:-

:" ~

a«'

"' 0

8 0

CT

"00!::

: :::

'"

~ ;

:J

51

~

~ .

..,;::

. -

-"II

~

0 - '0:.

0 "

-;:-

. Q

. 0.

. ...

...

"';;"

1-."

,°5'

"' t:.

..n=

o -:

.1a"

"'!>

0 "'0

""""

.'"

::re:

"'",

0'

"1'<

""oc

::r'

::I

...:,

0 ..'

is

: a-;

:J

g tj'

j;>

g, 0

.. 0

...

0 -

g oc

::I - E

. ...

0 0'

::1

tj'

Pi,.

::1 "0

'0

" n'

=

1:

:, a

!1' ~

'" II)

3t1

I ...

,n

~

~

...

n 0.

.'" -

~

0.

...

...

::r '"

51

II)

0 - 0

::I

0 u

'"I:::

" -

~

!!; - "0

~

0 0 -

'<::r

-f10

' "1

""""

'ri;:J

g.g.

a"°(

JIo:

:lo-"

'~~

nr::r

II)

n"

'~"

::I

o'-,

,t;

;' ",

0"

0 n

0R

~

::l

. g'

13

Jg

8

; ~

=

: 0

'" ~

S

o R

::n

g

g :\J

0'

51

g

0 g,

~

~

g.

~

::I

"I

1 "0

~

g

~

~,o

g'

~

~

a

~

z::;

~

0. "

0 :;I

...

a"

0

0 e:

~

a

~

0 ::r

~

t: -,

~

g

rn

13

~

-,

'" Ii"

8

S'

~

::1,

0 <

:I> "g

'"

51

Ii ~

0

"0

<:..

" --

!

g",g

,~o~

n~::I

~~

i~~

o:"'~

oS-~

iS:"

,-~

-!4

qR

g,a"

~g-

O~

"1iS

:~

0.g

:i, :\J

0'

t: "0

12

, ~ ::;.

C. ;;

! ::;

~ ~

0

~'

~ -<

ro

g q

g- [

2-. 8

B. ~

g: ~

'6' 9

- S- n

§. 'g

. 0

ri ~

~ 0

[

t'"'

e,'O

~

g::lQ

q::r

::l~

",

::;-~

",~

""LO

'(1)-

~:;;

'n~

a"::I

"'(1)

O'(1

);'(1

)o<

nt;;'

::;""

'..,..

,iS:g

:ii'

0no

t: ::r

"'...

'" Q

q u

... (

!Q

n ~

::r

(1

) ~

3(1

) t: - 0.

. ::r

3

-. -

, 0

..'

n ::I

~

~

""

,,:::

a en

'"

0 0

51

na

~ .

.."

0 ~

n

'" E

. '"

::r 0:

.0 ~

0.

0 no

?'

e:.

~

a"

0 -,

'"

5'

~

:;-. ~

~ 0

~

~ ~

t:

~

::I

...

t: a

~(I

) '"

"g

51 ':

:r

><

is:

'"

ri!

(1)

c,

0 t:

II)

"0

g ...

, E

)' 0.

. '<

g.

0

eT

(1)

~

II)

0 if

f1

<;;'

~'

!4

a"

go",

'"

~

'" ...

.8

",01

iro""

'::s5

l05l

Q,

~::I

""""

::r...

o-_.

~~

t:::I(

I)::r

,-\C

)...

,',

1:'t:

~;:J

,L""

::;

'- ~

"0

'" C

-,

a"

0 "1

'"

~'o

(1

) g

'" ::I

§

"2' ~

.r'

0 0

~ ff

~ '

0 g

c-,:"

" §

::r $

0

~

~

n ;:;

~ '

S.

t: ~

::r

S'

:>n

::J

!i-

0'

a" s'

8' 0

.. ...

~

tj'

8 Q

q 0

'" n

n ::;

' a ::!

,::: c

-' ::I

a"

~

6" '"

!!;

':-

' !;;

'..!t

.; ~

~

R

::!,

~ r

t"

a z

t'"'

ic(l)

"'0

~0<

:~~

~~

~51

~~

::rg~

~i~

e Q

.~«o

."'~

::s

~~

g,

::Ig=

Q

t:~"1

"""u

'1

::1(D

60""

II)j»

00Q

""-a

"~p.

.::I"

"~'"

(1).

.. O

"'l...

~

",-0

n_

. '"

~::T

""O

<:"

"~

(1)~

::I...

"O~

"1

::Ip

~'u

~

- t:"

:O::;

'~ro

..,

(1)(

1)",

eoC

\>=

O

::re

--!

p V

_O",

...,::

I.'I)

I:I

-"'..

:..:

0-

-::r

~

<

: (1

) "'r

J>"'-

~

-

C\>

:::

Z ~

~

0:.0

""'"

I')

::r;;

t: '"

'" 0

(I)

(1)

0..

t: '"

8 C

T

!;;'

::r

Qq

~

(1)

0 °

0 a

Po

(;)

go

CI>

>

::I 3

(D

I:'

'" ::;

'"

0 S

' 0

~

"',

a" =

a"

5[

~

:::.

!!i n..

- _0

n S

- ~

0'

'"' 0S

::s

~ 0

(D

~

Er ~

n

".~

~

ro~

""""

'o

"'0~

'"'51

5-

~

"'::s

"'Y'

' ,.,

a"

0"

" -'0

-(1)

" ...

......

.~

~

'"

~ .

.. 8

t: -.

~.....

. (1

) ~

oc

(1)~

"I

1 R

::s

0.. (

1) 'E

,.a ::r o

119,

0

~ s

-:;\

'" ::I

0.

~

--

' ...

0"

S

:!::

r ~

;:;

c:...

0 .

.. "

- ~

'"

0 n

n ...

-

a'

. 0

... ",

. 0

::I ..

., ..'

- -

-' -

-,

::r '"

'. "0

!:!

-<-'Q

J",0

;>-t

:II)~

S"':

""S

'!!"'o

'(1)n

~03

:\J

rJ>

~,:\

J::IE

;..:

::T=

"!"if

(1)t

1)~

O'(1

) ;:J

::I

(/')

_c.=

o.~

"Oa"

...cP

'""

"",

::r

, '--

"1",

--,

0'

::1,<

""""

y.

..""

00::s

' n

0.

0 i;"

n

...

'" °

::r

...,

::;

1::,

~

~

8 !,

~

::r

n ~

(/

) ~

"':

'" Q

q ~

~

2'

-0

::r

~

~

(I

j (;

>

..'

...

0

"0

~

.r'

51

g,

a 'g

Q

J ~

~

t;;

' ::r

~

g.

g

~;

~

; ~

a

~

~:.

~

~

E:,

~

8 Z

~

&

J g

CT

~

~

§

g,

5'

.."

S-~

"""E

r!!..

.::I~

",:::

.(1)

;:J"'~

C(1

)o-~

8n

~rJ

>~

~Q

.,",

t:;:;-

::I~

i;"n"

"'~

g~

0n

t:::I:

:;'(1

)"""

""'

0"""

rn

0'"

...0.

.::In

-3

- ~

-,

-(1)

0 -"

;'-'.~

~

t::::

1'11

""0.

""

""",

Q

ooo

"Ot:S

::s"'~

(1

)"'::

:;'"

'" ::1

(1)

o.."

,"O

t:S(I

)(1)

"':r:

:r

;:J-'

~n

.. ~

...

-,

t:

'" 0

0 ...

' c.

. 0

n0

'0

0 ...

::I

:r

tr

'00

<:a

~

'" - -

~

G"

c:r.

s-o<

:op.

.(')~

"'(i!:

:I"'-O

"""'-

O't:

t:-

' ~

go~

,"'o

!2.

::S°:

:s0

"';J~

,'.

=,i;

" '"

~ 0

~ .

.. ~

go

(D

q -,

g:

c-,

Ej n

"0

!4 ~

(1

) O

'Q a

'" ~

go

rn

.., C

-. -

n a

S ~

- g

8. Ei

n ...

g.

. 0

y tT

."1

~

(1)

3 s:

(1) :r

.!-

~

n n

::I

~ a

:;;' (1

) <

!9,

'<

'" ~

...

(1

) e

'" ~

go

0 "0

- po

'~

(1

) ~

~ 1

]..

=

r::r

"

-- '"

° ",

o::r

"'o

'.-

...u

-~'"

n.

-::s

- (1

)::S

--

"1

""""

...

t:",

-"O

O

..."~

""

"0(')

...,(

1)0

"""

-'"

,..'"

1.':,

-'"

~8

(1)!

:::(I

)O""

"'"

t:r...

..:

t;;-"

"I--

-O-;

:J:r

..:-0

0

a""

" to

;>

",

-"'--

"'1-,

n ...

O

,.,--

,-.

N-(

;,!~

o'<

"'~~

(1

)0

-' t:'

11-t

'" ""

'000

0(

1)"=

1 ::I

-' ""

, 0'

(1

)t:~

"'-

>

--'

"',.

~

,",o

",o.

..~""

"on

t:...

0 00

"""

""

-o."

'~

"'0(1

)",,~

a.::I

~,'"

0'

n"

,::Iii

't1)n

n~°'

El-:

:;-

rn-

,::1=

':;<

:: "'~

~!i)

't::t!

::r

1::.-

0'

" tI'

~ <

; '

0 C

'"

::j1

OQ

n

~

'" '0

(')

'<

'0

IU 0

C

. -

0 S

... :3

(I

j C

T a"

'"

coo"

~

.. C

t:

~g:

:SrJ

>~

~~

~':=

;,§a'

::IS

...=

.n'

~=

"On~

5-

'<

e.1)

I:I 8

!"

to!!.

. '-'

~'«

Jq~

"1

r1:1

t'"

0a

a0

0 0

(1)

::I

'" n

C

Qq

-,

(D

n "0

v.

0

O:r

...

~

-,

0

0 ;:J

t:"

,

n II>

0

0 '0

'"

r:!

'<

0.. P

o. t:

==

c.. -

0

s- E.

Q - !;

;' ...

on

-

E)'

t: -"

...

<

: ~

O'Q

..:

~

t: (1

) 0

0 t:

.. <

: e?

.. (1

) C

cr

.~

v ;n

' ~

8 $J

'('

?' g-

'9 ~

!:J

9

~'5

I.F'

B. ~

~ g

g.

7~'

'" :;<

:: 9 '

jI g.

¥' ¥

' If

g. s

: ~ ~

s:

';'

'9

'

e A-

n 0 a .g ~ ~ q" ..-;.

~ - !JC

I

a = ::s Q.

'" '" = 0 ::s-

II) '" "1 0 ~ ~"

0 0 ::s-

o "1 0 ::s 0 0 v '" s" '2. ;:;"

~"

::c ~ ::s Q.

~ ..... ." :>-

c: t"" is:

(")

::c c::

~ (j ::c ~ :> Z t;J ~ .....

Page 6: - II> - 0mechanism.ucsd.edu/teaching/philsci/churchland.realism.pdf · Po>a:=: ~, 5' g. So t: 8 So g-""::b';:J ~(1'~",('I)g ('I) ~ g. 0 '2. '2. ;i 1:; ... aq ~ Er 0- e-. ~ ::2

......

......

...... ~ ~ D

)

>-s

p. D)

i:: 0 ~ ~ ~ ....

0 ::s D)

- ~ D)

- ~.

S-R

S-O

't:::I

~C

lJtD

...Q

;!o...

(;

:I '<

tD

(I

) ...

..

CI>

;?

t: ("

) ::s

,..

, ::s

(")-

::1-"

"00

..,.

..,::-

.. tD

~

tD

,<=

...=

=""

g~...

-g;

tDg,

~~

eL!:i

(")

'" '"

~

tD

::s

~

~

Q.

e::;!

~

t:j

>

p..'1

' tD

(I

) S

' ~ 0

..'

e ~

UQ

;::I !'I

<:

::~,

-,

tD;::

I~

. W

::l

g,

e ~

'<

t: -,

..,

.. <

I>

...

~.

~

8 ~

~

~

r R

'

or

~°S

-::r

o=

..-

tD

...

,'~tD

tD

~

,~

...

CI>

~

S,

! §

° ~

~o

::s

-,

.. ~

<:

tD "r

:I

Oo~

~tD

~~

...

-::s

...0

Q)

::s

..'

~

<:1

"0

en

Q)

f4

(ii

n!!l

~ (;:I

2 ~

S-S

-;::I

S

~

,..

n tD

tD

g

'" ::s

"

...

° ro

o ,(

;:I-':

:S

<:

..,

. "'.

...0

(;:I

::;'

a.

0 ;:s

::s

::::-

...

~

!"

'! C

i)"'1

t:

t: c.

C

I>

;;I

..'

~

n tD

0

::r

tD

c'.

So

t1,

0 ::s

tD

-

StD

<:1

~ot

Do.

.."1

tD

.,...

~ 0-'

0'...

...

::r

...

-

n> . ~

;-

0 ~

g-

Q

),

=e

.' ~

::s

...

n 0

5 n

<:

~

=

t: ~

(;:I

, =

~

;;'

e-.

=0

...

5 S

~nI

Jg:O

"'"ot

...

~.

...

.

<

tD

~

~

=.

~.r

0

~!!I

::ro:

:s~

::s,<

;::ItD

::l."

""'tD

.. '<

::s

po

a

B.

0O

~<

I>R

'~.'-

nOt:"

t:

"""

::S~

()::S

n=::r

1<:1

~I~

tD

~

,...

::r ,..

. <

cr

' ~

, ~

~

0.

t:r

I c:

.,...,

<

I>

:: t:1

CIQ

-!

j oq

~

'1

:1

~

!j (I

I ~

II>

::r

(D::r

I"

) en

5' ~

-

n en

::r ~

c: 0

' "'t

;::

r - CI>

0 t:I

I"

) ~

:;'

n (D

'"$

~

OJ

II> rl:

:r

o::r

O

J '<

"d

<

I> ~

t:1

(D

...

' (D

j;;

"'::r

0-

~

(i ~

t:

~

A""

(D

~,-

~

(D -

.,...,

t:

0 I"

) 9

oq ~

t:!

!i;'

~C

I> 0

0<

t:I

"d

,...

<I>

::t.

" J

"g

::s

;S,::

I °

J -<

2

",~

qll>

cr'~

::r

~O

"'tn:

:S~

~o

ClQ

I")

~C

: n=

::r...

"'t""

'~-~

- ",

~o-

,...

::r~

- n

::r",

"'t-o

""

""'

O,..

.<I>

O'"

O-O

"d::r

...,-

O""

l"o"'o

"'t::r

/.:

0-0:

:r'"'

;.4"'t

::r""

::r

11>

'<'"

""""

"::r

",-,

J:::'

..-

<0.

~

" O

_lI>

o<

~C

I>-"

"-'<

-'

0

::r °

~ -

...' ~

00

::: -::r

!j 0

"'t

'<::I

" c;

; ~

(D..,

::t,

!!:.

'<

~

,..

...'

n "'t

~

,.

0j»

C

I>

0 ~

::s

-'"

O

J =

' t:

'" j»

'"

(D

::S t

:1 C

I>9

~

n ~

-,

9...

"'t

o

c: ~

~

...

0 ...

'" cr

"'"

&r~

""::r

.:::!

::S""

o n

::s-"

"-o.

tD

t:!,

~j»

I:;!j

n<l>

aq-c

nCl>

II>"'"

1 ,..

° ..

,~

° ~

...

' <

I>

~..

n tD

en

- ~ -

(D

" tD

::r

'" -

~

nOli>

,..

o0

!"!'>

::rt:

'-'

~::S

0;

00

t:!o.

""o

rll:l

~tD

P>

~0.

1I)"

"::1

-'~-

8(D

ClQ

41

~

<'<

--0

",,"

't 0"

-<

I>no

.:;'..

....

,...

f:!!.:

:s

-;E

"'t

::S

"'I

n<o.

°o::s

~

(D

""tD

'<

'<

<",

,0

lI>°o

o..,~

~ ~

n

fO'

9- ~

'<

~ ~

""9-'

tD ~

::t.

§'

""

::s::

~

!)!.

'" E

. ~ 9

- ~ n

~

S. :;

'>0

~ :

I. ~

2. ~

9 ~

g,!:

! ~ ::

I o

g, S

o 9

C'~

o::s

o°S

--C

I)

~

<...

0 o~

onl

°to)

o-a

oqC

IQ"',

c ,-

,en-

n'"1

"'t::s

0

0ei

::s ~

n "

CI g

°

~ Q

Q "

't ::r

E

,~' ~

g :r

0.

<I>

;'

a ~

n

CI)

~

S

o 8

"'t

~ 8

. c: ~

~ ~

~ ::

r g

~"g

e. g

~

z,..

. 0,9

. 9

~ t

:r::l

n

8 0,

°

~ :

:s .

::r::s

CIQ

=' ~

0 (I

) 0.

~

a-

is.:

9 °

,... ~

~

t: :::

'::r"

"""

::r °

n

n 0

<

=!i>

--

I-,

::r

no'

=:.

:;!!.

0 0

5 ~

::r!i;

':;O

~

~

5"

" II)

c:

~ 1

3' en

CIQ

o

° E

-.::r

~

Q n

On

So e:

c: ~

!!,

~ '

0 ~

'n

,..l:I

o~'"1

oo.g

o.C

lQcr

'q:;'

II),..

.'"1"

"""'d

""lo

<l>

~en

'"1~

'"1°o

o-""

"n-<

I>t:1

o<_~

~q:

:r

0g

!i>'"

"d ~

o

tD. ~

,..

. -

~

So:

:! ~

,... if

C', g

1:1

,...

° ~

...

II)

°8

0.'"

0 ~

'"1

t:I "

d ...

' <

I> 0

::r

""

~

::s ~

r-

-..0

0'"1

""

,:I,n

~

o'<

~Q

,o:::

,...o

n"

,0.9

~t:I

::r:=

:go

",,"

"""'_

:::""

'~~

01l).

..,a,

o='

a0

~..,

O

~::S

""O

:O

Ocr

'o"'t

::r""

o.

n °

0.°

en_,

--

n"-'-

::I'

9 <

1>0"

""'"

R'

;. "C

I ::t

. C

IQ

o'::S

:r

~

"1

::s

~

,

...'

g ~

o

8 ~

::I

~

0

oq

9 g

ti!

08if

° g

Q,

::r...

, "d

S

o 0

::I

::r

aq

t: c;

')",

og~

nn::l

o.

::r~

o:::<

I>..

o,<

t:lI»

::S~

nn"'t

. Q

Q c

:en 8

°8

::;'O

<O

:OS

;:So~

...

° ti!

CIQ

:::' .

.. 0

!i;'

So

1S c

: =

:I'

rn

1],

cr'

9 C

: ~

0. ~

°

8 ~

l'

g,;

~,g

- g, C

IQ

a -

;:;' ~

q 1

:1 9

°

n!:!

~

,O

;~

0""'"

""

:=>

-0

"dnO

.. ::s

t:1"d

"'o""

'-'::S

l»...

,::r-

o~

1»'<

_0

2';;;

>

~,o

°

~::s

...

~

::r :

:r'"

::r -

::r

~

,... -

, t:r

I<

_v

<

...

<

' 0

<

- -<

... =

:I ...

,.

>cr

' ~

t:!o' e

~ -

' 0

"CI

~

~ °

=

:II"

)(D

::r

Qq'

S

...0'::

S

a. =

- CIQ"

I»a

a tD

0

0. °

CI)

""

tD

ti!

0:

0 ::r

- ::1 0I'>

t'"

~.

""...

'"1

n '"$

"'~

-"

"""S

;:cr"

'1

~

I'>"d

-<:

n 0.

<1>

:=:0

" 0.

~ ~

t:I

~ ~

(i

CIQ

,g 0

.g 0

~ g

, r-

t c:

~ a.

~ S

o g:

°

OJ-

~

~

' tD

;1

0' . ~

n

~ e:

; 0

° 0:

0 ::s

('J

g ~

°

CfI

o u

5.

° '"

0,'"

~

"'t

"'t o

q =

:I ir:

:s

'<

en

(D o

q ti!

"",

rn

.':t

0 ~

"'t 8

e 0.

Q

, Q

, n

r»::1

,c

""

Q

Q

0 ~

°

09

--'

o.n

0:0"

, nS

..,::I

0-

n",::

s o~

o~

;-:::

<

t:rI::

r,<

n C

:(D

~C

IQ~

:;!'"

..,cr

' ::r

n

~

=r

=.

QQ

~

~

0.

~

e,

~

'E

i =

, "C

I j;!

0.

~

<

I> '

0 ::I

~

O

cr"'"

t:

g.::s

:::

' n

~.g

~

,...

so'

e,

tD

~

~

>'<

~

:;!

...

$2

=

:i ...

'<

=

, ~

!:!

<

1>80

_9' e

'0

::I -

('J

s' e

-, 0

0 ;:;

&r ~

~

~ e

. II)

"'to-

'<

9.. =

, a,.e

- a".

°

--I

~'.:

:r...

,...'o

oo"-

c:

...

"'tC

IQ::r

O

"'::s

-n"1

n-

_

8..'

--

'n<

v"...

.....

.."..,

0'

r»_.

!=:"

,<

::st:!

.(I)

~

- r»

°tD

o::l-

<I>

"d

or»1

»"""

't~""

"<9

08

O°t

DO

c:

- VI 8'

=

cr'

<

...

'" 0.

~

- "d

I0.

::r

n

~

::r a

q ;

... °

<

: en

1""'.

" ,

::s

j;!

CIQ

..,

:: -

, "'t

aq

::I

5'

0 g.

cr

' !:L

0

~

'" ~

S:I.

~

~ °

"d ;.

S'::

s .

if ~

~ -

--:

~::s

,..

- 8.

5. =

:i. ~

::r

'"°

... °

- ~

tD

o '<

~

...

"d

~

0.

r» =

- - ..,

0

-,

en:::

' ..,

--

=' 5

..,

c.. ir

::I

;r °

CI)

""

::r

- °0

'~\O

<I>

O,..

.~-,

o~

1I)~

"d""

;_

OoO

-('J

v..,

oO""

-~""

0.

'._

°"""

,\0-

~O

QQ

Qso

O'ri

",~

r»"'t

~09

~'

a~

'~~

::;-r

»<

;.-""

~",

,,(D

::s::r

- "'r

n~~

_OO

:r

"Z1

n-oo

""-n

~~

~o.

~r»

"'t

::r

o-"':

:So

,o~

r»o~

::r

g 0

"'°0

::r ~

::s

~ =

r ~ "

S ::I

~

...

0'

"'t

~ c

: ..,

<: (

i g

::s s

'::r

0. -<

::s

~ .

., 8

° ~

0. e:

° II>

j;!

"1 g

,::r

u::s

0

~ :::

' ~ -

< ~

;:;'

so'

,...

=:I

2 :"

' 8

... g

ir ~

r» ;

: ~

!i>

a, :

:r to

) 5'

~

. ::I"

tD

9

,... s

o' a

: ~

::I

S

o e:

<I> ~

~ O S

i;Ij

O_,

r»8

::r;o

Z-t

r..."

't::?

0c:

n ::s

~o:

o,..o

...o=

- c:

!o",

t:...

'"C

IQ"'~

="'-

°

wo"

'O

O"1

n cr

'~~

--

""""

",,::

rt:1

,. "0

; n

°'<

::r

'<

,..

. S

O' 0

(I

)~ ~

~

cr' ~

(D

"d

! '

"Z1

"0 r

» ;-

""""

6>

<

~

&; ...

g:

~

°

r» I

» ~

g

tD s::r

::;'

::I

:!1

~ Oij'

;...

~ ~""

t cr

' ~

. g

g.., g

S

o :I,

' ~

~

::r

~

~ S

'~,

t:I

tD

0.

n ~

:;'

ti!

g

~ ;:;-

=:r

E

:;-

'0

t: S

. ~

"

~

==

!:!

~

~ ~

g.

So

en ~

e. (D

~

~::s

~ '6

~

g ca

. ~ ~

Q

:;'

ti!

::;;~

, n

~ ~

g

~

II)::S

::;'

g,

n ~

<

:0

'<

tD9

.,...,

~0:

0 I-

h cr

' ~

"'.

..,..

e: tD

o nO

~

Or»

.., - 0

-',

n,...

en

II)

;:;

. <I>

0

0.

::-"'t

-'-""

<

C-

<I>

~"d

::r""-:

:Io

o."'.

..'"1

::1""

g:

=:<

:,<::I

o.-o

o r-

t<l>

,q

g ...

...'.

0"'~

'.(I)

O..t

o)

,. ~

O

~""

,..

.",

_""o

oen

tD'.'

_-

::r

"'<I>

'" ...

-

="~

Q.o

0.

O

;;l::T

o-"1

-nV

lI;/J

-c"'o

o--

o~

,"1w

",

nO:O

~

...,'"

S=

u oS

'

~~

~

"du.

.,<I>

p.

o.a.

s;:o

~:i!

::I

::SII)

"1~

,...~

~,o

, ~

;;I'1

'O,

g t'"

0.

,...

0:0

::I0

5 <

I> ;::

i, 0"

0,

8 ...

-,

I"

) fO

' n

:I, g

0;

~ - (I)

0..

ri j5

: "1

"1

en e!

2,

~ ~

' c:

0

" 1'

<1

0 o

(I)

~

~

0 ~

°

0 0

- 0.

., 0

0..,'

" 0

"""'"

t:

en

en

-,

~

-::1

~

'"

~

~

_. c

r' -

c: o

"'t

.. ::!

0.

-,

::I

53::I

""n

' °

::1 0

:0 t1

~

... 0

° ,..

.' c:. a

""!3

t:1 o

~

::r...

, ",

'"'-

-"~

I'-

""""

"'~""

"""'"

1

""""

-"""

,0

:00

ICI>

""

0

1~

S !

~ 5

' ~

,...,

:::

;. ~

~ ~

0' S

So 8

So

! ~

~ '0

0'

S

o ~

0 0'0

~

II)

,..

.,0

0 =

r II)

n

cr-

t:r

=

0 0

s::

II)

~'

...

n n

~ - aq

t:rn~

s::t:

r~n=

_~~

o;'n

s::c

n ,..

.,~~

~~

<~

_~s~

~~

nnn-

-' ""

"""1

""",

aq

- =

r<:S

'" nO

)s::"

1O)

,o-'o

~<

Co"

'arC

os::~

~~

o~=

rne:

na~

~'O

=""

,o~

""'a

~::s

::s~

g: ~

8 8

~ 8

~ ~

-< n

~

§ ~

""

8 en

Co

~

~,

~ g

"Ij

~ :

; u

~ ~

= ~

0' .g

B- g

o ~

a, 8

, ~ ~

'~ ~

~ ~

!:J

' if

[ ~

~ §

i~.

~ ~

~ i

; ~

~ g

. '0 !i

!:i ~

~

,~

~ n

~

~

51,

-, s:

Co C

o ~

'~

...'

0;

~ ~

'a ~

'?

s ~

~ s

:: ~ s

:. ~

z [

0 r c

n~

~

-. ~;

1 II)

;.

t:r 0

ft

~ n

0'

::t

~ ~

... '

0 S

8,

Q. ~

> ~

~ a

g:-~

,<a~

en:::

=~

~@

~a~

~=

'<a~

~~

~~

cr-~

",S

::?II)

~i'

U

Co

~ n

i!:

s::8

Q.;:

;,a

'" p.

j:)'

~ §i

@::>

,...

;:c

~

~ '0

<

I)

~, - ~

~

:;' ~

""'1

1)""

°=r°

II)

~

1i1l

)~

~.c

"";:=

-'-

~S

::°8

s::n

~1I

) ~

....

~,t3

~::J

's::'

gS~

~~

0=:-

'8~

S::<

"'~Q

~~

,1I)

"'S

Q.=

' '<

~08

Q.

"'t

!..8

"'"

0 -

Po

...,

::s

...

=S

' ~

i!" S

' t;

.d

:::, '<

~ "'

" '"

Q.

PO

t::

~n

1I)0

en'O

s::'O

t:r

::Snn

"""(

')"'~

0::s

""

""u

'<s:

: =

o::s

~~

n=o""

ot:r

nn'O

en"I

j;!"'S

!n::S

O

~i~

on

cnS

o w

nt)

I C

o n=

r°""

"""1

~"'(

'>

~,..

-"

,=~

""

0!'"

s::

n ...

' en

en 1

').2

n '0

S

o::r

s::

:::, ~

::r

~

~

;:=

8 ~

,-'

...'

Co

~

5'::s

~

5' =

i!:

~,e

: s:

: g ft

n s:

: 8

~

n8~

~ s

. ~ Ql

~

=

i=J

=

0'8

"' J'

~

oen:

:S""

P~

~

II)'"

en~

'<

0-

"""

..'

-,C

o""

n '0

aq

'0

0 ~

8

p ::s

en

~

0

~

Q

n s:

: 0_

0 -

~ Z

0 ir

0 0

g -,

"0

t:!

. 0

...'

~ 0

0- 0

=r

=w

~

... = 0

Co

"1::r

~

...

' ...

0 ~

, t:r

Q

,::S

0

< 8

0

...

...,

s:: e

n ..

~ -

t:r 0

n

0 =

r ro

o 0

==

: =

9

cn

.,.,

Co

II)

cr- 8

!;)

' C

o -

~8

'0

"t...

t)

'"

aq::r

~ ~

=

r Co

=

"1

r;'<

: ""

'0

=r"

""'1

""

..,

=r:

:: 0

Q~

""'<

S::

1I)S

::::r

-~

onll)

oSgS

::!II)

<:~

",n~

~",

~

e.~

lI)o

[8

n<

t:r-

"""'-

"'0;:;

18

' oO

'."1"

"s::=

~,

~_"

1t:r

..,

"1~

n~

o'O

_~'n

~

o~-9

rD<

:Coo

...'

1;j"<

->S

::(1)

n ::s

II)

0=

"'$

111.

..,

-II)

""'"

",

cOfil

""O

=

.c"

...

-=

t)S

::no

cr-e

n""o

'=6J

II)r-

-""S

::"1c

nCot

:l ~

~n:

:S'"

u""o

cr-"

Ij ""

"8:

::"10

0=

0;'"

@-'C

:: u

..~

Ot:!

, ""

""'-n

'" ""

",cr

- <'

~ ~

, =

=: -

@ tI

:' C

o @

g ~

t::.;

~

Q

en

"":

;:1,

::r ~

0

~

0 s:

::::

! 0

n'

~

~

5"~

::r

!..

S

0C

o ~

~ C

o 1-

1 ~

g ~

g. ~

o a

Q.;r

~

:::

g-o

",no

""'_

.o

_,,;0

...

::tt:T

"'...,

n

on

-"R

='

=

"10

=0

"'-cr

-°-8

,1I)

6

I::o~

0=

;0

"'"",

=

n;,g

~~

g

R a

c::.

t:.

=

B- e

: t",J

CT

S

o "'0

Co

;s!:t

a

~o

0 :=

1. Q

0

""

t:j'

n--

' II)

"'",-

~",

O

n-

n ~

i::;:;

;oS

:: 0<

: 'u

~ 0

C

o g

:::, a

, rD

'<

a

~ II)

::j,::

r.g

0 "t

...

~

~'

cr- ..

. -,

cr

- 8.0

::s

II)

~,o

..'

0

"1 ~

C

o e:

"1

n

n ~

~

'...~

' ~

0

::s!

'0

s:.

2 =

"Oo=

=::S

"tI::

o""o

en~

(lj°

o§'O

) .<

:::1"

"'",::

S

~"I

I)Q

Q

.II)

n~

r:

!.""'1

I)

~

-.;;(

'>

- P

-,

=--

oo~o

ril..S

a"'-

-=

..:c:

=1

"'...,

~...o

OJ"

,~

0...

- 0-

1::0

'. ",

-"",

_0

~...

=

'- -"

-aq

"00

8 "1 8

Q.

~

-@no

@

~

...'

...

t::,..

., lo

t C

:! ;.

0 s:

:::r sr

"1 t:r

'0~

~

on

~=

_~;o

~

0'O

""

~::t

O

~

~O

no

'<8

"0a9

n ~

C

o :::

,~,

Q °

g ~

~, :

::'O~

"0

8 ~

".!:i

g

~

5' =

- C

o JP

~

. 0'

t:T

"""'.

<-,

.;z'.c

r-

""""

""'t°

'" ~

.. "1

~

aq""

"'-

00'<

~.

~ O

~ ::

s n

::t' c

r- I'D

cr-,

=

r ~

- C

o "1

...~

' ° ~

0

8 9:

::r

0' ..

..8

t:r...

_.

.~

o-"'n

~_n

~

~::S

"'O

""11

)(1)

11)

-'"o

,<o=

-:::o

o...:

:r""

'o(lj

><

~"'~

"'~

r-t=

0 ::T

::s::s

'" ~

~'

-'0

oenl

l)-,~

oq'~

' riI

'OnS

::-

..",O

!!!,"

1 gO

(;1<

'"

'" :;,

g.

Co

aq

5'

"'"

~

::r n

" ~

0

<

8 ~

1:

:0 ~ 0

' Q

. e:

O

J s:

o'::j'

'0

...,

~. ;

r E

. ~ n

'"

;r ~

t;:"

~ ~

0

::!, a

~

! ~

aq

~

.a

:::' '"

= s

:: ~

8'~

w'_

",

~

, en

'<

_u'<

"'~

~<

I>

II

.;,.

.;,.

'" > C t""

$: (")

:::c

c:::

::a (")

:::c

t""

> Z 0

~ VI

Page 7: - II> - 0mechanism.ucsd.edu/teaching/philsci/churchland.realism.pdf · Po>a:=: ~, 5' g. So t: 8 So g-""::b';:J ~(1'~",('I)g ('I) ~ g. 0 '2. '2. ;i 1:; ... aq ~ Er 0- e-. ~ ::2

~

~'

~

;! 5r

~

~

~~

, ~

~,

~

n ""

'0

0;0

;:D""

=

- ==

~ ~

"::;

' ~

~

=

= ..

: aq

(")

~

~""

'::r

r::,

a- ,

.. ,..

Ii"

~::r

fJ

";:

,..'"

'0

~

S <

...'

!'! - g

1:

1 0

"" °

::r 0

'<

;:D ~

0

., 0

'0

0 C

0

0;0

0 ~

::r

::r

~

'0-,

""

0 ~

g.

Ii"

'e.

~

'I1 '0

~

'==

'"'

,!'D

...

, 0

~

~ - ~

c "

~ .

.., -

.."

., s:

: !.~

' c

0 a-

<

en

==

f!J

, ~

~

., ~

'

g. ~

S :

=- a

o ""

, ~

r;

'..,"

" =

;' ~

, ::n

r;

~,

::r ~

~

~

~

~ -

~ a

q :r

'<

f!J

, 3

g.::,

;:;

- a.

"' ~

c

u 0

~

~,

~=

= 0

~

::t

,... ~

~

r.o ;

...'

n t:I

n

--i q

n

::' -.

0' ao

< Q

... a

q n

~ ~

~ u

~

3~

~

::I

0 ~

s:

: ;:s

:r

S

3~

0

0'

n '<

.."

a:

"'

=

j;3

...'

0..

0,

:r

~

~

~

S

"1

~

Q

CT

~

~

::I

~

-

=2'

g'

...

' .."

0

::I

~

R

&,::

1,

~

ti!

ao

0

~~

~=

o;~

~~

~-~

g.~

~on

:r;:s

~'"

PS

~o=

o~~

n~

~~

3~.,~

~~

n-0

Q

, ""3

' -,

!.

0 ~

::3

g-

::; ~

.,

0' ii

0

~

:::. ~

'0 ~

=

' en

g, '<

aq

- n

==

~

ao

n ...3

' ~

0

nor;

' g

~ ~

g :.,

Q

3 g.

~

',",

0 3

; e.

c

;:; ~

'.,

_.

5!

;: §

... ~

e;

~

:::,

::;

::I

==

r;

' ~

n

~

~

'g,

r::.

-,

g ,..

., ~

en

::I

'<

~

5.

g:

8 n

0'

~

-,

0 ...

t:I

S

o_.

S

::3

c:

n.

::r~

: IU

a

e!.

° ;:'

0

~;.

- ~

'"' ~

0

~

1"".

:1

g ,..

., 5'

ti!

'1

n n

t:I:I

<I>

"'"

ti!

n

CT

n

==

<I> E

. ==

n

~

8 <

~

.fj

s:: (

II:; -

, "'"

D>

:I,

u

0 ~

fJ"

n

-,

n =

- R a

o ("

) 0

"0s:

: '0

~

::; 0

e:

. g ;

.."

~

'n

~ R

D

> :r

0;

n

-'.,

n n

...,

3 go

:;' n

::s

~

...'

c: n

c:

9

~

0 <

I>

=. ~

0'

go "

'"g

n c:

=

-,

r.o

~

~

QQ

~

"0

:r

0'

. !!;

("

) ~

'<

...

' n

~ ~

IU

c:

n

0..

<I>

-:

:s

'"'

...'

1:1

<I>

:;:

~

::I

na

111:

1 C

IJ ...

0

~.

1:1

n en

=

non

...'

0 <

: ::I

<

I> t'

: =

=

;;-

'""

0'

Co

n n

'" 0

,. -'.

.., n

nti!

~

2 :r

::3

~ ~

~ "

0 .g

c: gj

' 0'

0

= ::

r g c

: : ~

; g.

8 g

. IU

:r

!'D

==

0'

c: O

'! ~

~ ~

.2 :4

~. g

0'.:

:;' ~

::I

~ . g

~ n

s.

, Q :

:r o

' ~

. 11 ~

,",~

::I

S !

2. g.

'" 0:

~ !

!; ~

n

r;o

n ~

~'

~ ~

::: ~

~ j;3

. ~ !'

D ~

0 : ~

;i.

;!"

f;n"

""""

'O

..,,(

").t:

I~

Q)~

S

O""

'..n

Co.

., "1

<

l>o;

n ""

:r'"

~

ern

C:C

o =

1:I-

."'~

"1

0

~s.

,~~

§~;:D

o=~

!~<

~~

::I~

~~

~~

~&

~(,

,)~

=

in5!

~~

~~

R

:4~

a~~

~S

o-

;:D g.

~

"1

~ r

;r ::3

5""

" ~

0-:

8- g,:

:3

a :r

~

8 F

. n 2

, g

1i

~ 'r

3 R

a::4

~

a-""

!"

;

~ a

~,~

!!;

D>

~

5i ti

! 30

u "0

:3

i:!

t:I 'g

(Jq

0

5 Q

) ~

=

:, Q)

~ .;

'1

II)

1:1

0. F

. r:

:, g

"0

5' S

(D

::r

n

~

~ -'

0.

. ~

n

~

!'1

!"!I

~..'

3

-""

0 ~

...

<

u 0

~J

ao

""

n ~

...

'<

(")

D>

0

n - "1

'<::r

D

> n

;:?

n

'" g.

~ =

' 0;

c:

~°D

>o:

rf!J

,\\i:r

D>

MD

>

II)

OO

n=

:r-(

")~

~

::IO

no

~o"

",~

<I>

Q)C

:"""

'",,"

"D.~

:!...

0

...' Q

Q n

~

u

= 0

1:1

II) D

> 0

-,

D

> 0

::I

"

'" 0

"""

1:1

... (

Jq

-,

:r

~

<

c: .

.. ("

) 0

::s :r

0;0

'"'

M

!'! ~

::s

r;' ~

=

r :::

--~.

~

"Ij

~

Q...

g.

~

~::s

...

. -

, ~

0;

~ -,

::r

s.

,"O

n

~

a. g

. Po>

D

>

CI>

:r ::

I, 3

QQ

~

- ~

...

.n~

""""

:r

("

),,(

")o;

n"'_

("):

r<l>

"o--

,=

0 nn

::s~

::sn

"On

nO<

::r0"'"

'"'

0

-"'

~

I\)

n <

: ::s

'..O

n =

0 "1

n

"".,

= - -

, .,

0;

::I

"'"

~

""""

~

..

D>

0'

0

"'"

"'t

0 n

... o'~

-(I>

-"

I\)_n

_""~

"O

...::s

c:

<I>

::;n"

"l\):

rn

n 0"

"'",

t;,"I

j<:

"'<':r

'"'o

.,"1

::s

..

'<

Q)

()

~

(")

.." -<

::r

" en

-,

0'.

::r ~

...

8

~

::r ~

=

=" -

,,;;?

n

"0 =

~

"1

n

n n

; 0;

et

,... 0

'<

u

0 I\)

0'

t::

~

~

Q

)'"

~

~

0 '0

o;

:r

..,:r

1\

)""

~

'<

"0

::s

0 ~

~

-

c:

- --

,e

., n

r.o

...'

II)Q

) ~

::so~

-='.e

n«:'"

""~

-=""

~<

:n

""J9

an

""..,

,::ro

-~o;

n~

u n"

'L-<

!J. ~

0..

r:::

~

~

~'

::s~

; n

n 8.

~: u

~ A

g ~

~ .

.. =

;. 2

g n

D>

"0

S'

f!J,'

c ~

~

~ ~

0

;. =

= .

'0

nn

-~'"'

""

~'O

~("

)n~

",

D>

",n~

t':n~

""

-~

O'

g ::s

-g.~

n~~

"Oi

:r

~

3 E

;

~ ~

g i

r (D

==

.. 3

2- ~

~

!.!

~

I\)

~',E

' ~

CI>

'2.~

~

n

D>

(D

~

f!J

. en

~ 0'

=- ~

n

~

S .

., :4

~~

...

n

... .

. ,..

. 0'

1:

1 ::s

=

0 .c

~

... 0

::s

::s

C

'<

n n:

r ..

~

n 1:

1 Q

Q

~ '

<

Q)

... D

>

<:

0 D

>

'0

e:~

;;'

g.g:

.: ~

Ren

~'!?

~oc

: fJ

"g

R

-'n

0 ~

g;

;'ti

.~

5 ~

~.~

:;g

.~

(")

0 ;.;

'<:

;'.8

.~~

;~~

;;,~

i3~

00..§

~~

~l:I

o~

t~~

~1g

~~

ao

8-~

~::,

~!g

-<~

",r;

rti!n

o' ~

'0...

'<

"=-'.

n...,

O-'-

.1-!

\' ~

CI>

oCl>

nQ.1

\)

~Q

Q

n::l_

'" 0

n<

no"

,:;::'

f!J.<

","'O

::s

?":::

:, ~

~<

I>~

fJ""

"'1-'n

-

::<=

oI:lO

::3'a

oa,::

r-::;

::In~

a~~

<:_

(")I

\)~

(i!

QQ

~

J:)(

")

°:r"

,nnn

...,<

O'",

aq

::r

-,

n...

(")C

:<O

=;:D

""n~

<I>

n

IJ

p:I

0';;1

~

...

..

=

<

0..

_.

0',::

1 ...

:r

' ;-

. ~

! a

(").

.,..,

Co

n <

: "0

...

"1

n

::s

::I

0 0;

..

0u

S'

=

(D'

~

~:r

:"!'D

-,

n

0 ~

~

~

nO

n n o

, C

IJ i?

, =

ti! ~

n

: , n

= =::

- '"

0..

'"'

::r

(')

:! ...

0

0.....

~...

""::<

=C

I>~

n:

::..

(")~

::3-~

"::I-

""'1

F

==

-=

~<

I>'""

':I-~

n-'~

.

nC.!)

o::S

::;. ~

;-

II)

::r::r

"2

;! ti!

0'.

z:: o

' 0

e., '<

e., ~

~ g

. ';':

i!!. g

' g. -

! C

o ~

Q

if ~

= n

~ S

~

0 0

= ~

~:r

I\)

:

en

~

~ -

~ (D

S

';'

:::s:

0

0..

(")

'v:-

n

~...

"1

::'

I\)

~

-a'

::s s

:::;.

a f;

QQ

' =

.., ~

= 5!

e.

<A

:r...

nno~

<~

~

o::r

r:::~

o "0

"'=::I

Q)~

1I)

"O3~

o~o'

O

:r0:

'O

ntn~

I\)

po n

::r

_. r

i 0

==

~ n

r:

::. -,

S

' 0;

-,

aq

r:

:: ~

a

::r 0

-'

::I

"0

Q)

<

... n

-,

tj'

~ ..

. a

=:r

., ..

. 0

"'t

::I

ti! g

~ .

.. g

'v

n -<

...

'T:i

~

n ~

2.

nul\)

n

::r ,

'<J

a::l

n 0'

C

I> ~

('j

' 0.

. 0

=--

"0

n

~

:r

::s'<

. Q

. n

...

...

roo

"rI

n 0

~

0',

r::,

~

~

'<

~

2:

g if

~

'0

0',

I\)

::s

=

o~.

~

~

0 0

I\)

g I\)

0 ~

~

'~

::r

~

0 o.

§ ::r

f!J

. ~

;n

' <

<

I:I

:=!

0'

,e

.. 0

~

~.

&1

::!

0 C

o a

~

;;1

~

g.

f!J,

r:::

::!..'

:I :=

!u,

,-,'

<h.

..n

,..,-

.. n,

n,nn

,-

n",u

",<

" ,~

n.

..,

1'"1

_...-

~

.....

~ "tI

> c: too

~ n ~ c: " n :J:

too

> Z tI .j:>

.'-J

~ (II

(t>

""I

(II

::;I

() (II

en

~()

-,

...

.

'.:;,

!ii'

t>;~

~gE

._¥

n

S:::

:T-

()

c::

\C~

.,..O

Q~

~&

-~I-

EO

n:-

' ~

5. :a

,::I

Q.

-.?

': C

"} !.

.j:»-

i§=

. :T

~

0

.n>

~

...

0 i:!

-;::;

-c:

r::tn

~~

s.,

~ §

~go

e:

. ~

o

[~~

...

3=:::

;:;,

.E'

Q-

a

~

.g

~

~~

i!'"

I:>'"

-;t

s.,.:

-~cn

=i-

0 ?

'"

~!"

~

..,

~~

~

:~

~

~o

~°:

1S

:

~

:so

Ii:

~..

~;:!

c:

r~

'<

:Ft"

"';p

II()

:J

~~

~~

~

~

g-[

~~

g.~

;;:!"

~

6;

;::t~

.:'g:

;r

~-;

!".'

~e:

~ 5

X' t"""

::I

;P

::o ~

::0 -

. ~

~::I

Q>

Nc

ooC

oo()

c.::s

0

:::

!'I

~

.::..

N"O

II>

u

~.~

",

!';"~

-8."

=

II>

~'<

::O

'e»

Q>

'""

c::

~

J-..!

""""

,~

~

- ~

~

00

...

_.

~00

-. 0

" v

[0.

- ()

"S

"n

OQ

'>

.'"

-",

=.n

..,'~

~

6'"9

::sc:

::'

~

:>

~ :

:. :;:

. !'J ~

. =. :

:0?

()

:o2:

:d

;i<

J0

-n

~:O

~

:!,

~

10

~

==

~

. c.

.,'"

c n!

i1~

g~

"c.

., s

ni'

:::;

!I~'

" ...

::I

- trI

_.

::r

;!

~.

o'

Fj ,;

t '8.

~ ~

.,a

.~

::I

~

~

~

~

~'S

; 0

~cr

-t1)

8-

" ::;

' ~

8 '"

~()

0"

_0

::I

~:1

1 0

0 c.

-

I:'S

::I

S

?~

t;:~

~

_N

~

5-

;!.

., ,.,

. 0

n

O~

~

...,."

§

~

~

~

~

a ~

0'

-.::1

't:

I ...

.."

a "I

1&:

~P

: ~

!i

;;:

::;.

,.,

:::

. II)

o'

~

~

<II

~

<II

::I

Q'

to>

a

~

~

II>

~~

.

. '=

>

::I

- ~

.::s

.

I'!

~v

>

-.c.

~:l

...

Q0

~

1:1

..,

~.

::I

~

- if

a ~

::r~

.?

,~~

~

~

~

"c

~.

~v

-.'"

~~

;: ~

E

-.

~

[ $

~

n

V)

.g

...

-;

139.

~

~

l

,

'" 51

C

" 5'

~~

. 0

'<

(Jq

::I

g~g(

Jq~

§;;"

1~~

n 0

go "C

:I g.

...g,

~O

::l0

"1

...,~

e!.~

; ~

...

-.

0 ::1

"::1

gJ

:5

0 0

I:).

:;:J

::I

"1

""I

'".

~

fD'

0 <

:

;-~

e!.S

:::I

C'>

~'

<S

- en

~-°

-"1

oC"~

'<~

e!

.""

5'.

0 ::I

" (J

q

>x!

!.en

b n

p.

c::

p.~

-R-

0 0

0

::1":

:10;

(1)

~

R

~

~::I

"oP

=t"

'"~

::'

~.

~~

::1

"::1

-

is-:

C:

.~"=

-o'<

'<°c

en

"'I

"1

"1

C"(

tI°C

"(9

!=

! "C

:I 0

0 fi;

..

en::I

_.

~

...-

-::I

0 ~

=-"

'::1:

:1

0__1

:).

(')

=-

~0

0 c!

, 51

:;~g~

"1

::I

en

...!.

I:).

"C:I

"C:I

(')

e "1

(I

I=

:I 0

::Ie:

!.o

;S,J

'.E

!SQ

.~0

~

~-

...,..

......

.

0 z >oj

0 I'"'

0 C)

- n ~ I'"'

'" >-j

~ >oj

c: Ct'I

0 "" 0 = Ct'I

~ ~ < ~ 1;1:

1

I'"'

t'I1

'"

~~