8/3/2019 TURRUBIATES et al v. RUSTGO CO et al Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/turrubiates-et-al-v-rustgo-co-et-al-complaint 1/5
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
EASTERN DISTRICT OF W ISCONSIN
GREEN BAY DIVISION
JEREMY TURRUBIATESP.O. Box 123Kimberly, WI 54136
Plaintiff,
ACE AMERICAN INSURANCE CO.426 Walnut StreetP.O. Box 1000Philadelphia, PA 19105
Involuntary Plaintiff,
RUSTGO CO.48926 State Highway 12Spencer, NE 68777-3567
and
ABC INSURANCE CO MPANY
Defendants.
Case No. 1-12-CV-25
COMPLAINT
NOW COMES the plaintiff, Jeremy Turrubiates, by his attorneys, Menn L aw Firm, Ltd.,
and as and for a claim for relief against the above-named defendants, allege and show to the
Court as follows:
JURISDICTION
1. That the plaintiff, Jeremy Turrubiates, is an adult residing in Kimberly,
Outagamie County, Wisconsin.
Case l:12-cv-00025-WCG Filed 01/09/12 Page 1 of 5 Document 1
8/3/2019 TURRUBIATES et al v. RUSTGO CO et al Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/turrubiates-et-al-v-rustgo-co-et-al-complaint 2/5
2. That the involuntary plaintiff, ACE American Insurance Company (hereinafter,
"ACE"), is, upon information and belief, a foreign insurance provider, authorized to do business
in the State of Wisconsin, with its principal office located at 426 Walnut Street, P.O. Box 1000,
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19105; upon information and belief, ACE, at all times referenced
herein, was the workers' compensation insurance provider for the employer of the plaintiff,
Jeremy Turrubiates; that upon information and belief ACE may have made payments for
workers' compensation benefits, including medical expenses incurred by the plaintiff, Jeremy
Turrubiates, as a result of injuries he sustained in an accident referred to herein; that by virtue of
said payments, ACE may be subrogated to the extent of those payments and is, therefore, a
necessary party to this action pursuant to Wis. Stats., § 803.03(2)2.
3. That the defendant, Rustgo Co. (hereinafter "Rustgo"), is a foreign corporation
with its home office and principal place of business located at 48926 State Highway 12, Spencer,
NE 68777-3567, and at all times material, was in the business of designing, manufacturing and
selling scaffolding equipmen t, including scaffold wa gon s. The registered agent for Rustgo is
Willard M. Rust, 48926 State Highway 12, Spencer, NE 68777.
4. That upon information and belief at all times material hereto, defendant, ABC
Insurance Company, was a corporation, the name, address, registered agent, and state of
incorporation of which are presently unknown, and that in place of the actual name of the
defendant insurance company , a fictitious name is being used for the defendant. Upon
information and belief, the defendant, ABC Insurance Company, at all times material herein, had
in full force and effect a policy of liability insurance providing liability insurance coverage for
the defendant, Rustgo, and that by reason of said policy of insurance and the liability of
defendant, Rustgo, said ABC Insurance Company is a proper party hereto and is directly liable to
Case l:12-cv-00 025-W CG Filed 01/09/12 Page 2 of 5 Document 1
8/3/2019 TURRUBIATES et al v. RUSTGO CO et al Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/turrubiates-et-al-v-rustgo-co-et-al-complaint 3/5
the plaintiff for his injuries and dam ages. Upon discovery of the correct nam e of said insurer,
said insurance company will be substituted in place of ABC Insurance Company and said
pleading relates back to the date of this Com plaint pursuant to Fed. R. C iv. P. 15(c).
5. The Court has jurisdiction pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1332 based on diversity of
citizenship of the parties and the amount in controversy (exclusive of costs and interest)
exceeding $75,000.00.
6. Venue is proper in this judicial district pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1391.
FIRST CLAIM BASED ON STRICT LIABILITY
7. That prior to July 12, 2009, the defendant, Rustgo, designed and manufactured a
Rustgo manually propelled work platform, model 195, in a defective condition; that said work
platform was ultimately distributed and sold to Consolidated Construction Company, Inc.,
located in App leton, Wisconsin. That on July 12, 2009, the plaintiff, Jeremy Turrubiates, was
climbing up the side ladder of the manually propelled work platform when the extension on the
ladder became dislodged, causing him to fall to the ground.
8. That the manually propelled work platform designed and manufactured by the
defendant, Rustgo, was in a defective condition when it left the possession and control of
Rustgo; that because of said defective condition, the work platform was unreasonably dangerous
to the ultimate user and consumer, the plaintiff, Jeremy Turrubiates.
9. That the work platform was a produc t which the defendant, Rustgo, intended to,
and expected to, and which did, in fact, reach the ultimate user and consumer, Jeremy
Turrubiates, without substantial change in the condition it was in when it was manufactured and
subsequently sold.
Case l:12-cv-00 025-W CG Filed 01/09/12 Page 3 of 5 Document 1
8/3/2019 TURRUBIATES et al v. RUSTGO CO et al Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/turrubiates-et-al-v-rustgo-co-et-al-complaint 4/5
10. That the defendant, Rustgo, was engaged in the business of designing,
manufacturing and selling the aforesaid manually propelled work platform, and the sale of said
work platform was not an isolated nor infrequent transaction not related to the principal business
of said defendant.
11. That the defective and unreasonably dangerous condition of the manually
propelled work platform was the direct and proximate cause of the accident referred to herein.
12. That as a direct and proximate result of the defective and unreasonably dangerous
condition of the manually propelled work platform, the plaintiff, Jeremy Turrubiates, sustained
severe and permanent injuries which necessitated extensive treatment by health care providers,
and which he is informed, will continue to require treatment in the future, and which have, and
will permanently in the future, result in pain and suffering, loss of enjoyment of life, loss of
earning capacity, and other damages.
SECOND CLAIM BASED ON NEGLIGEN CE
13. That as and for a claim for relief based upon negligence, the plaintiff realleges
and incorporates by reference as though fully set forth herein each and every allegation contained
in Paragraphs 1-12, above.
14. That the defendant, Rustgo, was negligent in designing, manufacturing and selling
the manually propelled work platform in a defective condition, in failing to properly inspect and
test the work platform, in failing to provide adequate warnings and instructions regarding the
setup, assembly, inspection, servicing, maintenance and use of the manually propelled work
platform, and in other respects.
15. That the negligence of the defendant, Rustgo, was a substantial factor in causing
the accident and the injuries and damages sustained by the plaintiff as alleged herein.
Case l:12-cv-00 025-W CG Filed 01/09/12 Page 4 of 5 Document 1
8/3/2019 TURRUBIATES et al v. RUSTGO CO et al Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/turrubiates-et-al-v-rustgo-co-et-al-complaint 5/5
WHEREFORE, the plaintiff demands judgment as follows:
A. For the amount of damages found to be appropriate, together with costs and
disbursements of this action;
B. For an adjudication of any subrogation claim which the involuntary plaintiff, ACE
American Insurance Company, may have; and,
C. For such other relief as the Court may deem just.
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE THAT THE PLAINTIFF HEREBY D EMAND S TRIAL
BY A 6- PERSON JURY.
Dated this 9m day of January, 2012.
P.O. ADDRESS:2501 East Enterprise Avenu eP.O. Box 785Appleton, WI 54912-0785
PHONE: 920.731.6631FAX: 920.734.0981EMAIL: mark-feldmann(5)mennlaw.com
MENN LAW FIRM, LTD.Attorneys for the Plaintiff
BY: /S/MARK R. FELDMANN
Mark R. FeldmannState Bar No. 1017847
Case l:12-cv-00 025-W CG Filed 01/09/12 Page 5 of 5 Document 1