令和元年8月27日最高裁判決平成30年（行ヒ）...
TRANSCRIPT
8273069 8 27 30 69
Vol. 73 No. 1 43 2020
8 27 30 69
1…… ⇒ 2 “” “” “” “ ”1 3 “” “”
8 27 30 69
2020 44 Vol. 73 No. 1
1. 2. 1 2 3 4 4
5 6 3. 1
“”
2 “” “”
3 4
5 4
6
4.
1 2011-800018 … …
2 ⇒ 1 11 3 611
be 2 1 Vol. 11No. 4603-605
1994
4 1 11 3 611 b e 2
8 27 30 69
Vol. 73 No. 1 45 2020
1 KW-4679 A
AL-4943A A … 1 4 1 KW-4679 …
5 29 10003 1 2 A … A 1 A 2
63 3
30μM 2000μM 1000μM 66.7 2 2000μM 92.6 2000μM
8 27 30 69
2020 46 Vol. 73 No. 1
2
1 A 1 1 2 A A
2
A 1 2 A 1
1
5 10
3 30 1 31
A A 8 55 24 10206
1000μM 66.72000μM 90 1 A 1 A 5 10 A
4
4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4
A
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
70 90
8 27 30 69
Vol. 73 No. 1 47 2020
2.5 10
4 4
30 4 27
8 55 24
10206 X X Y A X Y Y X would could
30 5 8 4
28 10005 27 10054 5
30 5 9 6
8 27 30 69
2020 48 Vol. 73 No. 1
1 KW-4679 1 A 1 5 10 A 5 10 A
30 11 27
7 A 1 A
5 … 8
6
3 9
8 27 30 69
Vol. 73 No. 1 49 2020
10 “ ”“ ” 2
11 KW-4679 KW-4679 A A KW-4679 …
1 KW- 4679 1 KW-4679 KW-4679 12 “obvious to try” 13 “obvious to try” 2 10118 14 20 15
8 27 30 69
2020 50 Vol. 73 No. 1
“”
16
2 1 17 1 1 A
2 1
8 27 30 69
Vol. 73 No. 1 51 2020
3
1 “ ”
29 2 29 2 2 1 19
2 “” “ ”
“” “”
“” “” “” “” “”20 “ ”21
3
8 27 30 69
2020 52 Vol. 73 No. 1
“” 22 “” 124 2007 262 2011 136 “”
2015 9 2 2 “”
4 124 2007
5 2015 9 2 2
“” 12 312 13 499 24 10415
1 “”
8 27 30 69
Vol. 73 No. 1 53 2020
24 10207
0 0 0 0
10206 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0
1… S 23 23 11 30 23 10018 24 4 24 10419
“” 24 10004 2 MOCA ETHACURE300 1 1 … 1
“ ” 22 10122 “”
3 25
26
8 27 30 69
2020 54 Vol. 73 No. 1
4
29 2 29 2 29 2 “” “” “” “”
63 10 4 4 28 46 4 245 “ ” 5 86
2
8 27 30 69
Vol. 73 No. 1 55 2020
4 27
5 4
30 4 27
30 5 8 28
27
10054 29 26 10200
30 31
30 5 9
3 2016 380
8 27 30 69
2020 56 Vol. 73 No. 1
30 11 27
1 5 10
6
3 2016 380
27 10054 26 10200 32 24 10328 33 1 28 10087 33
8 27 30 69
Vol. 73 No. 1 57 2020
34 35
4 KW-4679
“” PBP 36 “”
29 2 2 4 4 28
63 10
181 2 33 1 63 10 4 4 28 46 4 245 3 1 1 2 KW-4679 1 2 2 2 1 1 1 1 2 2 1 2 1 33 1
8 27 30 69
2020 58 Vol. 73 No. 1
3 1 9
6 4 7 7 8 55 24 10206 9 4
94 6 136 28
10005 27 10054 “” 5
6L&T No.82
33 7
273 100 8 30 4 13 28
10182 10184 9 10
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
27 9 2 2 3.2.1 11
Vol.70 No.12017.01 12
209 … 209 KW-4679
20 KW-4679 A
13“Obvious to try” 19 10269 21 10371 23 10445 … 28 10112 … 29 10171 28 10278 20 10261 20 10096 21 10308 21 10386 21 10377 22 10046 21 10353 22 10072 22 10167 21
10310 14
69 5 No.1539 https://45978612-36b0-4db6-8b39-869f08e528db.filesusr. com/ugd/324a18_0e3af17bb2dc412da006b117716f98ac.pdf
15 67 12 No.1342 https:// 45978612-36b0-4db6-8b39-869f08e528db.filesusr.com/ugd/3 24a18_9d95ef8ae72d47bc8e58059223985bc9.pdf
16 5 69
… 1 1
8 27 30 69
Vol. 73 No. 1 59 2020
17 63 263
11 65 12 72 17 10314 17 10189 17 10458 14 246 21 10096 18 24 10419
51 9 15 362 47 27
58 262 22 10163 63 148 3 14 12 297 6 215 … 5 58 24 10252 H 19
20 12 25 20
10130 21 1 28 20
10096 22 5 27 21
10361 23 11 30 23
10018
25 3 21 24 10262
25 3 6 24 10278
25 4 10 24 10328
26 7 17 25 10242
27 12 10 27 10059
28 11 16 28 10079
29 2 7 28 10068
20 69 5 1
214 3 40
22 69 5 39
23 24 10207 3 53 1 31 8 12 26 3 10 1 3 8
24 23 10018 25…
3 2016 380
26 4 4 28 63 10 27 2
8 27 30 69
2020 60 Vol. 73 No. 1
1 5 28 29 27 10054
30 26 10200
2 3 3 2
31 51 3 10 42 28 32 17 10179
… … 1 3 29 1 3 3 2 29 1 3 22 10229
33 28 10087 5 87 2 1 3 167 2 1 3
34 10 2 30 10108
2 5CaO6SiO25H2O 2002-320952 8 0028 1 1 8 1 2 2’
8 27 30 69
Vol. 73 No. 1 61 2020
2 2’ 2 2 1 2 2 1 2 2
9 9 25 9 87 2 1 1 Cf. 24 10328
30 7 19 29 10174 vs. 28 10087 29 1 17 8 8
8 8 42 28 51 3 10 30 2 79 167 8 27 10260 28 9 28 8 8 167
13 5 24 10 267 … 1 1
8 27 30 69
2020 62 Vol. 73 No. 1
1
16 12 27 13 278 …
24 7 25 23 10333 1 … 5… 1 … 5 … 6 2 7 3 1 5 7
27 1 28 26 10068 1 1 1 1 1 HCFC 141b 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 HCFC 141b,HFC 245fa HFC 365mfc 3 1
8 27 30 69
Vol. 73 No. 1 63 2020
1 1 HCFC 141b 1 1 53 2019247
31 2 26 30 10071 … 35
27 10010 50 2
30 10093 9 19 …
2 26 10195 27 10 29 2 30 36 6 2 30 36 6 2 “ ”
36 24 1204
2019.11.11
Vol. 73 No. 1 43 2020
8 27 30 69
1…… ⇒ 2 “” “” “” “ ”1 3 “” “”
8 27 30 69
2020 44 Vol. 73 No. 1
1. 2. 1 2 3 4 4
5 6 3. 1
“”
2 “” “”
3 4
5 4
6
4.
1 2011-800018 … …
2 ⇒ 1 11 3 611
be 2 1 Vol. 11No. 4603-605
1994
4 1 11 3 611 b e 2
8 27 30 69
Vol. 73 No. 1 45 2020
1 KW-4679 A
AL-4943A A … 1 4 1 KW-4679 …
5 29 10003 1 2 A … A 1 A 2
63 3
30μM 2000μM 1000μM 66.7 2 2000μM 92.6 2000μM
8 27 30 69
2020 46 Vol. 73 No. 1
2
1 A 1 1 2 A A
2
A 1 2 A 1
1
5 10
3 30 1 31
A A 8 55 24 10206
1000μM 66.72000μM 90 1 A 1 A 5 10 A
4
4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4
A
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
70 90
8 27 30 69
Vol. 73 No. 1 47 2020
2.5 10
4 4
30 4 27
8 55 24
10206 X X Y A X Y Y X would could
30 5 8 4
28 10005 27 10054 5
30 5 9 6
8 27 30 69
2020 48 Vol. 73 No. 1
1 KW-4679 1 A 1 5 10 A 5 10 A
30 11 27
7 A 1 A
5 … 8
6
3 9
8 27 30 69
Vol. 73 No. 1 49 2020
10 “ ”“ ” 2
11 KW-4679 KW-4679 A A KW-4679 …
1 KW- 4679 1 KW-4679 KW-4679 12 “obvious to try” 13 “obvious to try” 2 10118 14 20 15
8 27 30 69
2020 50 Vol. 73 No. 1
“”
16
2 1 17 1 1 A
2 1
8 27 30 69
Vol. 73 No. 1 51 2020
3
1 “ ”
29 2 29 2 2 1 19
2 “” “ ”
“” “”
“” “” “” “” “”20 “ ”21
3
8 27 30 69
2020 52 Vol. 73 No. 1
“” 22 “” 124 2007 262 2011 136 “”
2015 9 2 2 “”
4 124 2007
5 2015 9 2 2
“” 12 312 13 499 24 10415
1 “”
8 27 30 69
Vol. 73 No. 1 53 2020
24 10207
0 0 0 0
10206 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0
1… S 23 23 11 30 23 10018 24 4 24 10419
“” 24 10004 2 MOCA ETHACURE300 1 1 … 1
“ ” 22 10122 “”
3 25
26
8 27 30 69
2020 54 Vol. 73 No. 1
4
29 2 29 2 29 2 “” “” “” “”
63 10 4 4 28 46 4 245 “ ” 5 86
2
8 27 30 69
Vol. 73 No. 1 55 2020
4 27
5 4
30 4 27
30 5 8 28
27
10054 29 26 10200
30 31
30 5 9
3 2016 380
8 27 30 69
2020 56 Vol. 73 No. 1
30 11 27
1 5 10
6
3 2016 380
27 10054 26 10200 32 24 10328 33 1 28 10087 33
8 27 30 69
Vol. 73 No. 1 57 2020
34 35
4 KW-4679
“” PBP 36 “”
29 2 2 4 4 28
63 10
181 2 33 1 63 10 4 4 28 46 4 245 3 1 1 2 KW-4679 1 2 2 2 1 1 1 1 2 2 1 2 1 33 1
8 27 30 69
2020 58 Vol. 73 No. 1
3 1 9
6 4 7 7 8 55 24 10206 9 4
94 6 136 28
10005 27 10054 “” 5
6L&T No.82
33 7
273 100 8 30 4 13 28
10182 10184 9 10
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
27 9 2 2 3.2.1 11
Vol.70 No.12017.01 12
209 … 209 KW-4679
20 KW-4679 A
13“Obvious to try” 19 10269 21 10371 23 10445 … 28 10112 … 29 10171 28 10278 20 10261 20 10096 21 10308 21 10386 21 10377 22 10046 21 10353 22 10072 22 10167 21
10310 14
69 5 No.1539 https://45978612-36b0-4db6-8b39-869f08e528db.filesusr. com/ugd/324a18_0e3af17bb2dc412da006b117716f98ac.pdf
15 67 12 No.1342 https:// 45978612-36b0-4db6-8b39-869f08e528db.filesusr.com/ugd/3 24a18_9d95ef8ae72d47bc8e58059223985bc9.pdf
16 5 69
… 1 1
8 27 30 69
Vol. 73 No. 1 59 2020
17 63 263
11 65 12 72 17 10314 17 10189 17 10458 14 246 21 10096 18 24 10419
51 9 15 362 47 27
58 262 22 10163 63 148 3 14 12 297 6 215 … 5 58 24 10252 H 19
20 12 25 20
10130 21 1 28 20
10096 22 5 27 21
10361 23 11 30 23
10018
25 3 21 24 10262
25 3 6 24 10278
25 4 10 24 10328
26 7 17 25 10242
27 12 10 27 10059
28 11 16 28 10079
29 2 7 28 10068
20 69 5 1
214 3 40
22 69 5 39
23 24 10207 3 53 1 31 8 12 26 3 10 1 3 8
24 23 10018 25…
3 2016 380
26 4 4 28 63 10 27 2
8 27 30 69
2020 60 Vol. 73 No. 1
1 5 28 29 27 10054
30 26 10200
2 3 3 2
31 51 3 10 42 28 32 17 10179
… … 1 3 29 1 3 3 2 29 1 3 22 10229
33 28 10087 5 87 2 1 3 167 2 1 3
34 10 2 30 10108
2 5CaO6SiO25H2O 2002-320952 8 0028 1 1 8 1 2 2’
8 27 30 69
Vol. 73 No. 1 61 2020
2 2’ 2 2 1 2 2 1 2 2
9 9 25 9 87 2 1 1 Cf. 24 10328
30 7 19 29 10174 vs. 28 10087 29 1 17 8 8
8 8 42 28 51 3 10 30 2 79 167 8 27 10260 28 9 28 8 8 167
13 5 24 10 267 … 1 1
8 27 30 69
2020 62 Vol. 73 No. 1
1
16 12 27 13 278 …
24 7 25 23 10333 1 … 5… 1 … 5 … 6 2 7 3 1 5 7
27 1 28 26 10068 1 1 1 1 1 HCFC 141b 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 HCFC 141b,HFC 245fa HFC 365mfc 3 1
8 27 30 69
Vol. 73 No. 1 63 2020
1 1 HCFC 141b 1 1 53 2019247
31 2 26 30 10071 … 35
27 10010 50 2
30 10093 9 19 …
2 26 10195 27 10 29 2 30 36 6 2 30 36 6 2 “ ”
36 24 1204
2019.11.11