فصلنامه آموزش و توسعه منابع...

24
2 1393 24 - 1 Quarterly Journal of Training & Development of Human Resources Vol.1, No 2, 2014, 1-24 !" ! #$%&) ( " 1 ! "# 2 % &’( 3 * ) : 23 / 01 / 1393 : ! 14 / 04 / 1393 ( ,-. #$ %&’ ( )* +’, -. /012$ /012$ 345 && 61’ 71) /012$ 82/1 2&19 7&( :; & /<$ -. :( &4( 0=.2 6’ 71) -1/02$ 5 1>? 1@ 2&19 /012$ 134 &2 ABC -( :( D :B*2 & :49 6’ :B*2 2 7 -EF0 &2 -*G :( D0 7 &1. :B*2 .&I D&J KL(M4C 0=.2 :( 5 -5 N2 / -5 :=5 - 6’ ;1 O10 6P5/1() #1. ; O0 6P5/() N2F (8I&..; &12 -1*G) R1E B(J (8I&..; 81SSL42 O10 -.(/1( ; &5 T)0) U (8I&..; ’, ? .& U4 (; :1=5 -1U; V05 / )* + -1.M2 +’, OW2 :; 0( A2 (:N2F) 2 -2 0X* :.2/ :3( ( 8BN 61’ 71) -1/02$ 2&19 VYG .0( 8 A2 5 (:505) 23 9 841 81BN2 / U5 :1505 Z1( :1;0( 601) 81 61I &CJ &.&’ 6=5 VM :M*1S2 +’,1 ( .&5& [L45 :15 \1C 61’ 91 :1] &.24 BW A ; Z4 6E.K ’ && 6* ^45 .0( 7(0 60W2 " /02$ 345 " " 6I " :.2/ A20C / _‘42 :; 0( 6 _a2 /02$ &5I) 6I 812/ -1/02$ bE] b5?2 04W2 &.’ 1; &150( 5 6’&2 A2 && 7 .&50( (09/( -(/ /02$ 8?2 :41 :1( : 61( &12 8BN2 -( -U.2 &) 2&9 7) :( M>5 -IP5 ; Tc +’; J %Y ’ &2 (d& U +5 6( -() 8/02$ E( ZY; -<0B -=5 / 6&.2 :1KB; 61’ 6 1E( D&1C 61? / 6&1.2 #ec2 / .&5& R>3 (-I2/ -I2 ,/ ! 0 : /02$ 345 7) -/02$ 6’ -U; +’, /02$ 8BN2 2&9 . 1 - & Z.; D0BC +I -4( :25( 6 - D0BC I D0BC &?K5 -4( 8 -4( -. 8 8E -2/09 PK5 2 - 4 D0BC :25( +I -4( - 6 D0BC I D0BC &?K5 -4( 8 -4( 8 8E -2/09 PK5 -. 3 * - 4 D0BC :25( +I -4( - 6 D0BC I D0BC &?K5 -4( 8 -4( 8E PK5 -. 8 8E 0g>2 :bM?2 [email protected]

Upload: others

Post on 17-Jul-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: فصلنامه آموزش و توسعه منابع انسانیistd.saminatech.ir/WebUsers/istd/UploadFiles/OK/... · 1-24 1393 2 Quarterly Journal of Training & Development of Human

������ ��� �� �� � ���� �����

����� �� ���2 ���� �1393 �24-1 Quarterly Journal of Training & Development of

Human Resources Vol.1, No 2, 2014, 1-24

��������� � ����� � ���� ����� �� ����� � � � �� � ���

�!"� ! ����� � ��� ���� #$% &�)(��� � ��"

���� ������ �� 1

��! �"#2

�%� �&�'( ��� 3*

) :������ �����23/01/1393 :��� � ����� !14/04/1393(

,��-.

#��$ %&' �( �)�* +',� -��.� �/012$ �� �/012$ ��345 �&�&� 6�1' 7�1) �/012$ 8�2/�1� �2&19

7�&( :; &� /�<$ ���� ��� -����.� :( &4( �0=.2 6�' 7�1) -1�/02$ 5 �1>?� ��1@� �2&19 �/012$ ��134

&2��� ABC -���( :( D� :B*�2 �� &� :49��� 6�' :B*�2 �� ��2 7� � -E�F0� �&2 -*�G :( D0� 7 &1.���

:B*�2 �� .&���I D&J KL(��M4C �0=.2 :( �5 -5�������N2 / -5���� :��=5 - 6�' �;�1� O1�0� 6�P5/�1() #1��.�

�;�� O�0� 6�P5/�() ��N2�F �(8�I&..; &12 -1*�G) R1E� ��B(�J �(8�I&..; 8�1SSL42 O1�0� -.�(/�1( �

�;�� &5� T�)0�) ����U� �(8�I&..;',� ��?�� .&� ���U4� (��; :1��=5 �� -1U�; V05 / �)�* + -��1.M2

+',� O�W2 :; �0( � A2�� (:N2�F)2 -2����� �� �0X* :.�2/ �� :3(�� �( 8��BN 6�1' 7�1) -1�/02$ �2&19

VYG .�0( ���8 �' A2�� �5 (:50�5) 23 �9 8�41� 8�1�BN2 / �U5 :150�5 �� Z�1��( :1;�0( 601)� 8�1� 6�1�I

�&C�J &.��&' 6�=5 V�M� :M*�1S2 �+',1� � ( .&5&� [�L45 :1��5 \1��C 6�1' 9�1� :1� ]� �� &.2��4

BW���� A� ; Z�4� 6��E.K�� �� ��'�&�&� � 6�* ^��45 .�0( 7�(�0 6�0W2"�/02$ ��345" "6��I���"

:.�2/ A20C / �_`42 :; �0( 6�_a2 �/02$ ��&5��I���) 6��I��� 8�12/ �-1�/02$ b �E]� b�5�?2 �04W2 ��&.'�

1; &15�0( �5 6�'&2��� A2�� �&�&� � 7� .&5�0( (��09/�( -(���/� ��/02$ 8�?2 :41�� � :1( : 6�1( &12���

8��BN2 -( -U.2 &��) �2&9 7�) ���� :( �M>5 -I �P5 �; Tc� +'�; ��J %Y� ��' &2��� (d��&� ��U

+5� 6�( -() 8/02$ ��E( �ZY; �� -<0B� -�=5 �� / 6&.2 :1K�B; 6�1' 6 ��1E( D&1C �6��1?� / 6&1.2

#e�c2 �� �/� .&5&� R�>3� (-I�2/� -I��2

,/�� ����! ��0: ��/02$ ��345 ���7�) -�/02$ 6�' -U�; +',� ����� �/02$ �8��BN2 ��2&9.

1- &�� Z�.���; D0BC +��I �-4�(�� :2�5�( 6 �� �-��� D0BC ��I D0BC �&?K5� �-4�(�� 8� -4�(�� �-��.� 8�� �8�E� �-2/�09 ��PK5� 2- �����4� D0BC :2�5�( +��I �-4�(�� �-��� 6 �� D0BC ��I D0BC �&?K5� �-4�(�� 8� -4�(�� 8�� �8�E� �-2/�09 ��PK5� �-��.� 3*- �����4� D0BC :2�5�( +��I �-4�(�� �-��� 6 �� D0BC ��I D0BC �&?K5� �-4�(�� 8� -4�(�� 8�E� ��PK5� �-��.� ��8�� �8�E� �0g>2

:b�M��[email protected]

Page 2: فصلنامه آموزش و توسعه منابع انسانیistd.saminatech.ir/WebUsers/istd/UploadFiles/OK/... · 1-24 1393 2 Quarterly Journal of Training & Development of Human

-5�>5 h(�.2 :N�0� �/02$ :2�.BS� ����� �� ��� �2 ���� �1393 2

1 - ��� ��� �0

�' / i�8�2/�� �' ( :F0� �(-2 �Y� �/02$ ���' : �j�� &..;' &�� 6�( � -��

6�XC -I&.e�( ���K�� .&..; R'�� �09 D�P.E(�5 bk0W� 6l0e0.?� RBC h��� 6�'

'������� 6��S4J -C��4F �-P.'-2 [�]� 8�2/�� ��m42 %&' � 6��5 :; &.;

�2/�� �� A<�� -5�>58- RE2 80.C :( :N�0� A2�C 7���8�2/��- ��J �/02$ n�N2 ��

�/02$ .&5��I A�E>� �&.��� :.�2/ �� 6��I���o�4M>5 ���m� ��]� 6�( :; �� -��' �� �&���

2 :( ����3�� �0=.6 ��; D�]5 ��B(�J8$ �' -2 b�0j -2 �/02$ .���I ���m� �( &50� �+5�

� ���P5b��E2 ��4�:4>5� �� &��( ���' ��� 6�' ��; D�]5 �0W5 �8�.;��; 6�'8$ �' �

��P58$ �' A2�N� �� ��; :( �M>58$ �' &.; ��]� ���m� 8�4����� �� 8��?�' �( �-B�()

1389.(

�=.2 /�].��; .�0I$1 )2009( /�� i� �� �/02$D�=5 [�>4; �8�2 2EF �� &. �

��_`�-KL(�_ �0ME( �0=.2 :( ��� ��P5 b��E2 �+5� �( 6� I .�� 8�2/�� ��I ����

�/02$ � �� �' :U>B� 8�2/ :( :F0� �( 8�2/��>3� :4�� � :( 6� I�(-2 R&50� -W4�)

���I��F1390 :( �� / AMJ :; -�/02$ V05 8$ / �� b��MC :; �2&9 AMJ �/02$ -?�

��� ��� D&L4�-2 :q� 6 :( 8�2/�� � ��]� �� +� � �/02$ V05 7� -Bj %&' .�0�

6&.�50� -2 A.��� �� D/k 6�' -P4>��� &��(K2 6&S� 6�( � ��� � P'� 7� / �� A<�

�/02$ 7� .&���5 ���2$ �,� o��&�C �' Aq�>2 Z���( �F -*�G -5�2/�� bY?K2

-�5 ��0� �0S32 :?B(:q� / -Bj 8$ �' -5�>5 6��5 ��(�� 8�2/�� rB4L2 A<�K2 /��5 ��02

-2 &��( >*) ��0� 7�13827�) �/02$ 6�P�� (8�F �=.2 / :; �2&9 % -22 �� b��MC

&2 �&2�=5 �0ME( /b��E2 �+5� �=5 / 7�2&L4>2 D��4�� �':; -��' 8�5$ ���� :(

8�2/��AW2 �2&9�5 i�; 8��7�) �/02$ %&' #���� 7� :( .&�� -��50� ��]� �2&9

( O��� #>; -BN� Am� �� -���; +� � �&�e0� �4K�(-2 ��k�( b�2�32 /�* 6�( �4E&��(

) �-Wc(1383( +',� �� :; �/02$ 7� D� :4�� -5�� :( :F0� �( �)�* ��� �0G �� �'

b&2 6��;8�2/ ��; �2&9 �4K�( ��(8$ �':4��I ��J :F0� ;�2 � .&5 / 8�2/�� �P�� %�G

:q� ��MJ ���/02$ / :4�� 7�:.� ' %�j �' ��(��; 6��I��� ��=45 ��'8$ �' O�W2 �� �

��� :U�s ��; :j�C �� �&�&� 7� / :; �&� ��� �/02$ ��345 80.C �W� ����&2 RBC

.�� :( �/02$ ��345&.��� ; :(b��E2 �+5� 6��I�� �'-��50�6�' / -��5 �&� :4��I���

1-Aguini & Kraiger 2-Jan. F. May

Page 3: فصلنامه آموزش و توسعه منابع انسانیistd.saminatech.ir/WebUsers/istd/UploadFiles/OK/... · 1-24 1393 2 Quarterly Journal of Training & Development of Human

3 #��$ �� �/02$ ��345 �&�&� -��.�&*02 -��Uj &�N� �8��; 8�F�2 �6��]� -3�&�� /...

:2�5�(��NJ02 �� -�/02$ 6�'5� 6�'b��E2 �+5� 7� tU* -NJ 6��-��50� �' �0G �� �'

��� ���� ��; O�W2 �� 8�2/ (Schmitz & Maag, 2009).

��I&�� / 6&�(0�1 )2004( -5 �2 80.C :( �/02$ ��345 �b�CYG ��(��; tU* /

b��E2��P5 �'W2 / �'-2 r��N� 6��; O�W2 :( -�/02$ O�( .�0� ��345 ��P�� b��MC :

:F�� �/02$��; :; �� 6���( / 6��I��� �8/02$ :( � -�/02$ :( -Bm� ���( �� �_a2 �0G

-2 ��; .&5�(

:.� ' :5k�� 6�':2�5�( %�j -4UP.''�/02$ -�/02$ 6�7�) 6�' �� �2&9

8�2/�� �' -2 �0�(Dorji, 2005). �]5 �� I Z�� �( ��u2 6�(�?��2$ 6/�>E( �/02$ 72 �

:.� ' / ��� �' 6�( �/02$1298 ��� �� �k�2003 :(1434 ��� �� �k�2006

/ �5 8�.;��; / i� �' �/02$ b�C�� �&N� 7�P5��242 ��� �� �C��2002 :(45 �C��

��� ��2006 Z�MC) �� :4��� +� � �8��&�* �0�1390 -(��/� 6�( :; ( ��(��; 8 �2

�/02$ 7� ��345:( �' -2 �&.>( -�; +].� -(��/� i� -(��/� 7� :?.� / A��< �0�

D&C ��345 xYcj �� �� ��(��; D&C ��(��; O3� �-�; +].� ��J +].� ��02 � ��345

-2&2��� ABC &'� � 8$ 6�':K�� -���( ��02 -�5 ��J -(��.&'�

�W2 �� �0X* �( �0�5 -N� �)�* +',����� �/02$ O - :; -5�2/�� 80.C :(

�03e�( -5�>5 6��5 �B2 i� 6����� 8$ 8�4�� �� �0K; i�- :c�* :4��� � A?K2 7�

� ABC &2��.&'� ��J ��?.; :Ne�c2 ��02 � 8$ 6�'

+L( ��09 -�����mF �N� :( :F0� �( :; -5�4� 80.C :( �5 60)� 8���9 8�4�

-�=C� �&.�$ ��; 6��5 ���� �/02$ 8�2/�� -5�>5 6��5 /- 8/02$ +5� - �� �

.�� A�?K� � +',� 7� O�W2 �0�5 %0cN2 �09 :( � �)�* +',� :F0� ���� 6�F �09

�M2 :( :F0� �(+��� �y0� b�W�)0� �&� 8��( -5:<&<� �' b��MC �)�* +',� 6�'

:/ �0( &.'09

1. �/02$7�) 6�'�/02$ ��345 �>?� ��@� :; -42&9 z&.2&; &5

2. ��/02$ �� �/02$ ��345 �>?� A�k7�) 6�'z�>�@ �2&9

1-Subedi 2-American Society for Training & Development

Page 4: فصلنامه آموزش و توسعه منابع انسانیistd.saminatech.ir/WebUsers/istd/UploadFiles/OK/... · 1-24 1393 2 Quarterly Journal of Training & Development of Human

-5�>5 h(�.2 :N�0� �/02$ :2�.BS� ����� �� ��� �2 ���� �1393 4

3. �>?� 6�'&2����/02$ �� �/02$ ��3457�) 6�'z�>�@ �2&9

4. �/02$ �� �/02$ ��345 �>?� �&27�) 6�'z�� :50P@ �2&9

2- 4�� 5����

',�:4�� �� ��?�� {�We :( �)�* + +',�-U�; 6�'1 �� 8��2 / ��� ��J 6�'

�� �-U�;:��=5 �� ���'�2 {�We :( #��.2 -��.M22 :��=5 �� �9�(��� / :4��' .�0(

:N2�F�� �)�* +',���� �� �;�� :3(�� :; �0( -5��BN2 -2��� A27�) 6�' �2&9

:; &.4�� �0M�; A�e� :(���&W2 b�5�?2 -2��� A2�� :4��� +'�; �' 8���9 8��BN2

��� �� �;�� :3(�� :; &� 60)�7�) 6�' A2�� �5 +',� :50�5 .&.4�� �2&923 RBN2

6�'&; �( #���� :( :; �0( :��&�* �(�� ��(�.I �8�4>]( �8�E� 6�'�E� /TT3 �BT4 �

GT5 THT6 D�5� .&5&� 6� I0�5 �:5 :50�5 �� �+',� 6��I ��&' 6��I / :; �0( &.

�� �8$ V05 8��2:50�5 :6�' AE� 6��I :50�5 �8�E� �� �0j0e &.��&' -���S� 6��I 6�(

:50�5 �8�4��E� &.@ [�L45 �I�;�� [�L45 6�( [0Bc2 ��02 6� �' �� �>L5 �&..;

:50�5 �8�4��E� ���]5/ 6��I -��( :e0BI �� 6:50�5 -.< b�CYG #>; 6�( i��0g� 6��I

�&N� .&� ���U4� |0(�2�;�� �&C�J Z�� �( �5 8�I&..; �� :; &5&� [�L45 6�=5 V�M�

#���� :( :��&�* �(�� ��(�.I �8�4>]( �8�E� 6�'�E�2 �6 �9 6 .&5�0( ���&F )1 (

SLK2��&� }LK2 �5 :50�5 b :��

1-Qualitative Research 2-Grounded Theory Method 3-Tehran Teacher 4-Bajestan Teacher 5-Gonabad Teacher 6-Torbat-e Heydarieh Teacher

Page 5: فصلنامه آموزش و توسعه منابع انسانیistd.saminatech.ir/WebUsers/istd/UploadFiles/OK/... · 1-24 1393 2 Quarterly Journal of Training & Development of Human

5 #��$ �� �/02$ ��345 �&�&� -��.�&*02 -��Uj &�N� �8��; 8�F�2 �6��]� -3�&�� /...

6��"1- ��789:;� < 4� �0

r��� &; ��>.F -B�SW� ~�&2 :4��

-B�SW�

��; :3(��

(���)

Z�&2

(���) ���

1 TT1 ��2 &�� -��.���; -4�(�� D0BC 10 -

2 TT2 8/ -��.���; [�C b��(� 14 -

3 BT1 ��2 -��.���; ->�BP5 8�(/ 28 -

4 BT2 ��2 -��.���; ->�BP5 8�(/ 21 -

5 BT3 ��2 &�� -��.���; ����� 19 *

6 BT4 ��2 -��.���; -��� 20 -

7 BT5 ��2 -��.���; -)��� 23 -

8 BT6 ��2 &�� -��.���; -C��4F D0BC 26 *

9 GT1 ��2 -��.���; -C��4F D0BC 22 -

10 GT2 ��2 -��.���; -)��� 22 -

11 GT3 ��2 -��.���; �>�/ 20 -

12 GT4 ��2 -��.���; b��Ee 21 -

13 GT5 8/ -��.���; ->�BP5 8�(/ 12 -

14 GT6 ��2 -��.���; -4�(�� D0BC 27 -

15 GT7 ��2 &�� -��.���; b��Ee 27 *

16 GT8 ��2 -��.���; -��� 28 -

17 GT9 ��2 -��.���; �>�/ 20 -

18 THT1 ��2 &�� -��.���; -���� b��(� 15 *

19 THT2 ��2 -��.���;&�� -��� 21 -

20 THT3 8/ -��.���; ->�BP5 8�(/ 18 -

21 THT4 ��2 -��.���; -)��� 25 -

22 THT5 ��2 &�� -��.���; i� �� 13 -

23 THT6 ��2 -��.���; -C��4F D0BC 22 -

( �>��4�?� <�@ ��):�@

Page 6: فصلنامه آموزش و توسعه منابع انسانیistd.saminatech.ir/WebUsers/istd/UploadFiles/OK/... · 1-24 1393 2 Quarterly Journal of Training & Development of Human

-5�>5 h(�.2 :N�0� �/02$ :2�.BS� ����� �� ��� �2 ���� �1393 6

,� � (:M*�S2 +' :��5 \��C 6�' :B�� :( :; �0( &.2��49�� ��P4�� �M_ b0j OM)

��� A�BW� .&5&�7�(�0; Z�4� 6��E.K�� �� Z���( �'1 :A*�2 A2�� �/�( 6� I&;

&; �6�0W2 6� I&;��=5 -KL( ��M4C �0=.2 :( .&� D�]5 -(�L45 6� I / � �5 -5���� :

���N2 :6�' #��.� ��N2�F �(8�I&..; �;�� O�0� 6�P5/�() �;�� O�0� 6�P5/�() �(8�I&..;

RE� ��B(�J &2 -*�G)�;�� 8�SSL42 O�0� -.�(/�( � ����U� �(8�I&..; &5� T�)0�)

.&� ���U4� (��;

3- �A��&�0B0�CD �

Fh�:4��� 6&.(�� �)�* +',� 6�' ) A?�1-2 }LK2 ( &��( 7� . A�e� :( +',�

:3B* 8�0( �03U2 6��I��� �&�&� � 6�� ���; 6&4( �� .�� 6�0W2

E-F1- ,4�� 4� ���� 6��A�� G�-F �H�"�� 6� G�I J�K ��0

:�@ ( �>��4�?� <��L�M)

1-Straos & Korbbin

�_02 A20C \3W� D&C

:6��I���

�&5��I��� rN) (re

�/02$ rN) ([

�&.'�

04W2 rN) (�

b�5�?2 rN) (b

-�/02$ b �E]�

8�2/ 8�?2 rN) (�

-(���/� rN) (�

��09/�(

\3W� D&C

6��I���

�0���D

8��BN2 6�( &2��� (re

+5� 6�( &2��� ([

8/02$

,�&�D

�4��1

,�&�D

�4��2

��345 D&C

6��I���

(�/02$)

��N O&�#F

Page 7: فصلنامه آموزش و توسعه منابع انسانیistd.saminatech.ir/WebUsers/istd/UploadFiles/OK/... · 1-24 1393 2 Quarterly Journal of Training & Development of Human

7 #��$ �� �/02$ ��345 �&�&� -��.�&*02 -��Uj &�N� �8��; 8�F�2 �6��]� -3�&�� /...

+��� :2� �� :4��� �' ��4UI :B��0( +',� 6�'�;�� ��02 6�=5 -5�M2 8�I&..;

��J ��.4� -2 �' 6�( �742 8�0( �S4L2 �0=.2 :( :; ���I:Uea2 2 �&� :q� ��4UI :50�5

.509 .��-2 742 ASU2 A?� 6�( D�4W2 8�I& 8���� :( &.50� 7� ASU2 �� I �� :2�5

.&.���5 :NF�2 +',�

��/ -K',� bk0� y0� #e�c2 :( :F0��( -2 x�c2 :�0�

:B0�CD 6�� B #D���� J�K ��0 ���� 6��A�� G�-F 4�.� �! �A�I ���P

Q���!

:c�* :; �0( 7� �0�5 �09 :( %0cN2 � �)�* +',� 7'� �2 6&4( �� :; -K���

z�� D&; �>?� 6��

�;�� ��4UI -���( :; �� 8�K5 8�I&..; �/02$ / :4�� 8$ A2�� :c�* 7� ��' �� -

:��� -20�C :M.F �4K�( :;

»:M*�S2 ��� :@ :�&..; -2 -(��/� \�02�5 � -��' z&�.;

GT2: ��� 7�( / ��� ok0�N2 �-20�C -SSL� 6�' o�4M>5 -20�C 6�' ��0( ��&2$��;�5

D�( .«

THT2��� : ��� �2 �0( [09 -SSL� 6�' 6��(��; 80@ �0M5 #e�F -20�C 6�'

.&.4�&5

�6�=5 -5�M2 \MG �/02$ �/02$ / :4�� 8$ -20�C 6�' ��]� �0=.2 :( :; �� �'

�.;��; 7�( �� �?U� /�G ��P5 �+.�( b&* :N�0� �� ��]� �5 8�2/�� 8��E2 -9�(b 6�'

-2 :q� 8�.;��; :( -20�C �0� ���I��F -W4�)1390&��( .( ��4UI \MG �( :; ��� :F0�

�;�� 8�I&..; ��� 7� :M.F 8&.@ �' ���E2:c�* :( |0(�2 �4K�( :4�&5 - ��P5 �+.�(

��0( �?U� /�G :B*�2 �� .�� )�* +',� D��/02$ 7� �>?� A�k� �0�5 -N� � � �'

.�0� ��0F

���� 4� ���� 6��A�� G�-F E&R� :B0�CD S�� B #D J�K ��0 QG��. G�I

�;�� ��4UI -���( 8�I&..;k� 6�* :(05 :( D&; �' :; �0( ��/ A� 6��02 A2�� �09

:�0(

Page 8: فصلنامه آموزش و توسعه منابع انسانیistd.saminatech.ir/WebUsers/istd/UploadFiles/OK/... · 1-24 1393 2 Quarterly Journal of Training & Development of Human

-5�>5 h(�.2 :N�0� �/02$ :2�.BS� ����� �� ��� �2 ���� �1393 8

,��#�>��& T�K(TL�

- ���,U�?�� JAF �&�D E-8 :���4�

TT1RBN2 : �'-2 �0I O3� -e0J :( 8��I�� 8 �I &.'� -2 �0I R' oYj &.'�

�>* -B�9 ��02 :� R4UI &5�&5 :JYC :; :.� RE2 -B�9 ��02 :� ZRBN2 ZY; 7� :( �' �'

:JYC oYj C A�k� / -?� &5�&5 -5�.�5$:M.F 80�' R4UI 80K4;�� 80KJY -e�2 6�'

8 �G�L( �� -5��( �4K�( -.N� �>�5 -5�� �� �.� 6/��42 \�0K� +�/��42 +��'

-2 �;�� � �P5 &..;-.N� &5�&5 -NJ �� ��Y; 7� 0� �� :� /-�5 �; .&..;

BT4 ��� 7� :( 6�0F i� R4>�� &��( -.N� �0K5 ���/ 8��BN2 6�( :JYC � �P5 �� :

.�� :��; 7��' �$ 7��' &��M5 :JYC � �P5 :; -2��2 ....&.; ���/ � :JYC :; ��(

��0� &e�(7�1 )1988( / � /02$��; -��50� � �P5 ��09 �/02$ ��345 �&2 �� �5

A20C-2 -��N2 6��I��� �( �_a2 &..;(Neo, 2010).

:B�F» : �-�/02$ -'��� D/k b�5�?2 8�0�5 R'�� ��/02$ :( 60J /��5 Z�>*

:4��� ��(��; -Bm� rB4L2 6�� 2 / 6���09�( ��NJ02 �� -�/02$ 6�' B�C 6�' / �Am� -

~�W2 :B�F -2 :; &.4>' 60J 6�' � �P5 &.50� �;�� 6�( � D/k 6�' �/02$ �� 8�I&..; �'

6��I��� 8$ �' �-B;0�) &5�$ R'�� 1388(«�/02$ �� � �P5 :Uea2 ���' �&.'� 8�K5 . �'

.��

�;�� ��4UI �4K�( ��?.; -���( � A?K2 i� A?K2 7� :; �� 8�K5 8�I&..; :��

.&� &'0L5 A* �5 bY?K2 ���� ���P5 hU��2 :; -5�2/ �� �� ��0( 6���.(

���� T�K(V ,�0� (W4�)

- ��4�8��! X&4�� ��0 6��� #�Y � ��

»M*�S2��� 7� 0� ��� �=5 :( :�&50� :zZ�&2 �� :e�N� RBN2 �4K�( �'

TT1 &.4>�5 ��N� :F ��' :( 8��BN2 �Z�&2 O3� :�&5 �;��K2 �� :��G i� &5

ZY; 7� 8���F-2 -5�.L� Z�&2 .�' 8��BN2 &.; �0I O3� -e0J :( 8��I�� 8

-2 &.'�.«

THT2�; �J� :-2 ���U4� �� i� / 8���u; D� �MWj O3� .-5�.L� oYu2 &..;

-2 &..; -�5 :F0� ��BN2 �2 -PBj0* -( :(. ...&..;

1-Ford & Baldwin

Page 9: فصلنامه آموزش و توسعه منابع انسانیistd.saminatech.ir/WebUsers/istd/UploadFiles/OK/... · 1-24 1393 2 Quarterly Journal of Training & Development of Human

9 #��$ �� �/02$ ��345 �&�&� -��.�&*02 -��Uj &�N� �8��; 8�F�2 �6��]� -3�&�� /...

:b��MC»-2 ��� [09 -5�2/ �8�I&5��I��� �/02$ -���.'� b��=5 �( :; &5��I �&.'�

�� (Z�&2) &5��I ��; :( 6��I��� 8���F �� � #��.2 6�'��M'� �' 5�;�02 d��) -

�-.�>*1392 .«(�&.'� 8�K5 I��� �/02$ / :B*�2 �' �� :; �� 7� [��]� / &��( 6��

�� 6��I�����&� 6�' r�e�� ��P�� %�G / �0� ���U4� 8$ �( #��.42 d 80.� #4;

�� / 60���$ �( d��&�6�' -P5�E( #5�F / V0.42 d��&�)1390) -5�MN� �(1392 (

) 60Uj1389�� 7� ���' / -;�* ���< ( 6��I��; :( V0.� �'8$ �' ��&.��� d��&�

.��

- J�&�D Z�7� � [4�

THT5�u; : ��:(�]� �� �� 7���� 8�K;�&2 &�� 8�2�09 8��?�' -4* �� �� R; 8��

.&.4>'

THT6o�4��E5 8��2 :; -���4� : �u; &5�� �2 8��BN2 8k :; �� 7� #e�F &5�� &��

.R�4>' Tc� R' -��0F i� d� &5��I -2 � 8��&��

�;�� ��4UI -���( Z�>* �I :; �� 8�K5 8�I&..;&2 ~�&2 &..; �/02$ �� Z�

�09 Tc� R' �&.'�8$ �' -2 :F0� �4�; ��4UI :( �� -9�( / 6 ~�&2 :; �>( :@ .&..;

�� 7���� 8�I&5��I���ZY; 7� 0F �( -���MC :( .&��(~�&2 �' �( O3� :; �� R;�* -��I

.�� -�0PL��� A(�J k�( ~�&2 �( 8���&2 �0X*

::B�F ��»� }SL� -K35 �5 8�I&5��I��� :( #e�c2 R�EU� :q� �� 8���&2 -��50

��� 8�I&5��I��� 6��I��� 8 �2 �� ��?5 A(�J��< �-.�>* -5�;�02 d��)1392 .«( �( �5

Z�&2 ~�&2 }SL� ���'&�;`� .�� �&�

- � \! <���� ��&�]

BT3[09 � #Bc2 &504( :; �>�5 -Wc� �� +��&2 8 : }J�5 +��CYG &.; R�EU�

...��

GT3: ��M'� / -?� R.; n�C ��� �2&9��?'� �'-2 �4K�( :; -��' ��_`� &50� � I

�� 7� 60� &��(� -(09 [�>* i� :( [��]� 6�� :; �� -5 � C &���� / ���U4� ��'

�) &.4>' 6/�( b�20BN2 6�� &.4>'( b�20BN2 ��09�: /� 8�K5 �&.'� 8�0( -��&J

�/02$ b�20BN2 .(�� 8�I&.'�

8�I&5��I��� :K��'-2 :F0� -5�I&.'� �/02$ ��4UI :( &�&F #e�c2 :; &..;

�P5�(�&.5 -2 :q� 6 :(05 :( &�&F #Bc2 :q� .&.'� ��4UI �� :; ��0( �&.5 �P5�( -C05 �09

Page 10: فصلنامه آموزش و توسعه منابع انسانیistd.saminatech.ir/WebUsers/istd/UploadFiles/OK/... · 1-24 1393 2 Quarterly Journal of Training & Development of Human

-5�>5 h(�.2 :N�0� �/02$ :2�.BS� ����� �� ��� �2 ���� �1393 10

�;�� :c�* 7� �� 8$ rN) :( 8�I&..;&�;`� �� 6�=5 -5�M2 �� +L( 7� :( .�� �&�

.�0( �&K5 � M2 -EF0� �5 Z�4��

(^ ��A� T�K

- ,4�� ��� ��@� Z78�0

BT3��� �� : :; 6�0X* 6�'o�SL� D&?��' 0� D��; d��&� -4* D��; �;�� 72

8$ �' :�' -.N� D&�&5 -SLK2 hM.2 728$ �'-� -2 �;�� 8�2�09 �2 ��* �' :( :; R���;

-2 ���U4� ��Y; /( -e �0( �0� 72 6�( 7��' &N( �0( � F �4K�( R���; D&2$ :; &N

-2 Z�&2 D�32 �� D�09; d��&� R4�09o�.�C R. -2�AS� �� �� :; R�&� �'- �� O3�

AS� &5��; 80.C � �'- .�>�5 }LK2 -NM.2

THT5 �u; �� :��� D�� VYG D��; �;�� (-20�C) :.�2/ 7� �� :; 6�0X* 6�'

.2�MWj O3� �&K5 DYC �2 :( -NM 6�'o�u; R' 8$ :; ��4� -�5 ������.&..;

:(05 :( 04W2 8�0( }LK2 8�K5 �09 �&.'� 8�I&5��I��� 6�( 6��I��� ��; A*�2

��;�� ��4UI -���( �P�� %�G / .��I&..; �/02$ O�W2 �� �2 8�I&5��I��� :; �� 8�K5 8

I��� ���� :4>( -5�I&5��-2 T�F�� :; &5 &.'�&.��� 6�( ��;8$ �' AMJ / }LK2

�/02$ b��(� �� :; &.4>�5 �/02$ 6��I��� �2 �� A34>2 6��� &��( �&� r��N�

.�� �&K5 :F0� +L( 7� :( 6��I���

- S�N�� ����

GT1 h(�.2 : ZY; �� �&� ���( ��; :( 604W2/��5 �( #��.42 -�/02$ 6�' -�/02$ 6�'

0M5 8��?�'-2 ���U4� -N(�.2 / hJ �� ��YG Tc� ���/ :; �&� � 8��?�' +5� b�C

-�5 k�( .���(

THT3� ��02 � 8��BN2 6�'/��5 �@ : �@ :@ R��EU( :; R�'&5 ��J +]. 8����&( -��'

z&5�� D/k ��0L�2

:b��MC �6�=5 -5�M2 \MG» �� -�BC 6�'���N2 h(�� ok �/02$ �� 04W2 [�L45 �0j

-2 -].�/��5 Am� A�BW� :� ]� / Aj�* b�3�3W� ^��45 Z�� �( o��5�_ 604W2 .&��(

��� %&' Z�� �( -�/02$ 6�' �/02$ 6�'/��5 7��N� / :; -��' �&� ^4.2 R�=.� :�E� &5

-2 �;�� �� ��9 ��4�� �� b��E2 �+5� ��]� 6�( �� 7?�2 :; �0� .&��( 8�I&..;

�;�� ��� �� 8�I&..; ��� 604W2 &.504( &��( -�/02$ 6�' �09 -Bm� 6�'/��5 �( � �'

�� 6��I��� 6�( -5&.@ � �P5 �b�0j 7� ��< �� .&.'� \�Mc�8$ �' L5 &� &'0

Page 11: فصلنامه آموزش و توسعه منابع انسانیistd.saminatech.ir/WebUsers/istd/UploadFiles/OK/... · 1-24 1393 2 Quarterly Journal of Training & Development of Human

11 #��$ �� �/02$ ��345 �&�&� -��.�&*02 -��Uj &�N� �8��; 8�F�2 �6��]� -3�&�� /...

� 6���&.U�) ���/�)1390 .«(:Uea2 ���' �( -].�/��5&�;`� ��4UI \MG �( :; ���

� �( 7�.��' b��MC 7� .�� ��0M5 R'�� �)�* +',� O�W2 �� 8�I&50� :M*�S2 :4?5 7

-2 -].�/��5 :Uea2 \3W� :; ��� :F0�:Uea2 &50� .�/�� ���$�( �5 � � �P5

- ���A�_�0 ���

THT1��� ok0�N2 :; �� 7� +4BC :-( �'-�5 ��M5� � -�&' ��� 04W2 &..;

ok0�N2 ��;�5 &.4>'.

THT2��� 7� : ' 8&( �'-2 � I�( -�&' ����� 7� &50� %&' :( /��5 �' �� 6� I &5

T�Wj �0K( -4* �� -(���/� ��.��; 8��

MC :b��» 6��I��� %&' ��2�� AS� &4( �� �/02$ �� :K35 �') ��; -5�;�02 d��

�-.�>* 1392 «( »��� 604W2 %&' Z�� �( -�/02$ 6�' 6�'/��5 7��N� / :; -��'

�&� ^4.2 �/02$ -2 R�=.� :�E� &5 ���/�)� 6���&.U�) �0�1390 «( ���' �( ��

%&' �� 6� I&.��� � �/02$ 04W2 7��N}LK2 %&' .�� :K35 �&..; �� :; �� ��

.�� �&���I 8�I&5��I��� -�I���� #F02 :4��P5 ��J :F0� ��02 �)�* +',� O�W2

- ,��#�>��& ��#� ��A� �8� ��"��

THT3-�5 o�SL� 72 : 604W2 �( ��� 8Y� �� &��( �@ R5�X zR.; �;��

THT4-�5 D��� : ��� &�$ ��� 7� / 6 ���; �;�� %&' �( �&� :�F0� � -20�C 6�'

.R��(

\��G 8$ / �� ��� :c�* 8$ �� 8&� :�F0� :( /��5 -MBc2 �� ��; 74��� � 6�( ��� �'

A?� :( -MBc2 �� 6��; �J�' ��/ &�$�� ��34C A?� :( #Bc2 8$ :( :F0� �� ��; 8$ D�]5

�� A�C �F :( -4*� :( &�$�� ��34C 8&� :�F0� :; ��� :F0� &��( 7�.��' .&2$ &'09

:.�2/ �5 b��(� �� �)�* +',� O�W2 �� :; .�� �02 D�]5 6�( � �P5 8��; R'�� /��

.�� �&K5 :F0� 8$ :( Z�4�� �� 6��I��� �/02$

(< �F��� <�U�H�� � <���-� T�K

- W:! <�U�H�� � <���-� ��� \!

THT3cj :6/�]2 xY �� O3� �&2$ ��� 80.C D�5 �� �E.� ��0��2�; / ���U4� 6/��

VYG �� ��� ��(��; D�5 �M_ -5��� ��(��; Z�� ZY;-5&.@ -2 �&�� �4�; ��&5 .�0�

Page 12: فصلنامه آموزش و توسعه منابع انسانیistd.saminatech.ir/WebUsers/istd/UploadFiles/OK/... · 1-24 1393 2 Quarterly Journal of Training & Development of Human

-5�>5 h(�.2 :N�0� �/02$ :2�.BS� ����� �� ��� �2 ���� �1393 12

THT6�>�5 �04;l�� �� ��0��2�; / R' -����� ZY; 7� 0� :- 8�� Z�� 8�2/ �� :4Me-

( &��� k�*: ( �� :F�0( 74�&5 �G�9 :.8��BN2 �u; 74�&5 ��� �G�9

:b��MC »���K�� �( #��.42 -�/02$ i�; -�/02$ b �E]� A��� / ���U4� RBC

04W2 �6l0e0.?�#��.42 7�.��' -�/02$ �;�� �&N� �( ��� �� 8�I&..; �-�/02$

-2 �0� �].2 8�I&5��I��� 6��I��� Tc� �0ME( :( &50� �-*04�)1388 .«( ���' �( ��

\MG �( �)�* +',� O�W2 �� :; .�� 6��I��� �/02$ �2 �� b �E]� b�5�?2 ���;

.�� ��0( �0M�; 8�S35 ��@� :4��P5 ��J :F0� ��02 8�I&..; �;�� ��4UI

- � ��@� V��MW:! <�U�H�� � <���-

TT2-2 RBN2 -.N� : 80�' �� &�$-2 -4?��5 +5� :; &.�K5 -2 /02$ &��� -.N� &.�K5

+5� �?��5 7� 6� &5�0M]2 RBN2 :� ...8��BN2 �2 &..�K.( �U5 � �?��5 8$ 6� 8/02$

o�NJ -.N� ...&..�K.( RBN2 72-2 �?��5 6� �C�� � �� �C�� i� 4J R.�K5-2 &.B( - D0�

8 0� 74>K5 .72 6�( �� �&..; :4>9 �NJ 7� D�� ��; ��� 0� &�&� ��� Z�>*

�$�F/ -4* ZY; .��

GT2-2 �J �' 6��0��2�; R4>�� : �� �/�� :=We 8$ ��0� ���U4� &'09-2 7 �0�

-2 [�>* :( -2 �� &..�M( &.'09 -�5 i@ oYMJ -.N� z:5 �� &4� 7�) ;�2 �2/...�0� -42&9

60� R�4���e 80@ :; 8�2�09 8�4��E� +e�@ :( ZY; :; &� �C�( �0( R'��' ���

$ ��� / :; 6��0��2�; k ��0L5-�5 /�( oYj ��� 2� &5�0( ��� . ...&�

�� D/k �>�5 -��; b �E]� b�5�?2 %�j �0X* :; ��� :F0� &��( �J &.@ �'

M?���� b�0j :( �� D/k ��U�; / �� &5��I ��J -.�(/�( ��02 �&���I i@ A��� 7� 6

.�� �&K5 :F0� 8$ :( Z�4�� �� 6��I��� �/02$ b��(� �� :; &.��( ���09�(

- W:! �#�� �0��4 <���-� ��@� \0�#�

BT34* :�J -'�I ���4� y�U� - ��� �' 4��E� �� :; -��'�8 '�R�4�� %�G 6-

8�4� ;�2 �� :5 8�4��E� - � ��E5 &��( k�* #9 R��0( 8��I�� R' � O� �C�� � 8

.R�50L( �]; � /��5 R��0L( �];

THT3��� 6�( : �� �' -�5 ���2$ 6 �@ R' ZY; / ���9 .&..;

/��5 / -9�( O�W2 �� -�/02$ 6�' -2 A?� -5�EI�5 b�0j :( �/02$ &.5�2 ���I

��NJ02 :; -'��� b �E]� b�5�?2 �/02$ O��� 8$ �' -2 [�]� � ��u2 80.C :( .&.;

��� / -9�( �8�2/ {�We :( -5k0G -�/02$ 6�'-2 [�]� � :� m� ��P(09 �0F �� &..;

Page 13: فصلنامه آموزش و توسعه منابع انسانیistd.saminatech.ir/WebUsers/istd/UploadFiles/OK/... · 1-24 1393 2 Quarterly Journal of Training & Development of Human

13 #��$ �� �/02$ ��345 �&�&� -��.�&*02 -��Uj &�N� �8��; 8�F�2 �6��]� -3�&�� /...

>; ��@� �&5��I��� :M.F 80@ :; .���P5 b09� �e� :( :4>( -5�EI�5 6�0� ��NJ02

&5�� :( 6��I��� �/02$ b��(� ��8$ �' .�� �&K5 :F0�

(` ���� �� � �- T�K

- a.�! ��b� Z��7�

TT2 :ok0�N2 ?�-�5 � 8k R.;50-40 2$ +5�ZY; 8k &..�K.( ZY; i� 0� /0 �'

F ���-2 & �0�30 -20 -2 6�U5 7�) ZY; -e �&50� RBN2 72 6�( :; -42&9-2 &5� I

&5�0( :4� I AMJ ��2 i� &��� �3�J�40 R��0( :4>K5 ���K� ZY; i� 0� RBN2....

THT3-2 :; ��� 6� I�( /� : -2 �0� RBN2 :�e�C i� &�.�(0� ���K� b�0j :( i�

-2 i@0; ZY; .&���( ��4� &5�=4.2 &..�K5

�� -��2&32 A20C 6�>?� :( /��5 -�/02$ 6��I��� �' �&5��I��� ����P5 R'�� �� :; �

�5 6��I��� �/02$ 8�?2 �� �X� &� &'0L5 ���2$ &�&F #Bc2 6��I��� �/02$ 6�( �5

2 .�� -��2&32 A20C 7� / -?�-2 �/02$ 8�? A�E>� &50� �&..; �2 AL2 �� 6��I���

.&��( 8$ R* 2-.�>* -5�;�02 d�� )13922 :; &.4�� ��Es ( / -4>��( �/02$ 8�?

��0( #��.2 �ZY; 8�2&�@ :�0E� ��N� ��05 ��2� ��U�; �6� I�( AW2 �E� {�We

:F0� �5 �X� �� 8�?2 �N� �( :B�F 7� .&��( 6��I��� 6�( �&5 �P5�( #e�F -c�W2

� � M2i@0; �)�* +',� O�W2 �� :; :4� 0M5 [0Bc2 8�I&5��I��� �&N� �( �(�.( ��

.��

- ,4�� ���� �>�#8� �0

BT3��� : 42 6�0X* 6�'`�0� � I�( ���K� -B�9 :; �� ��J 80@ :5�U�- :; -��F ��

��� D&5� I D�09 72 � �' - -2 V�� TMj .[�< �� �0�

THT5-2 oYu2 : &.�0I24 �� &��( ��� �C��3 -2 �0� D��� /� 9-8 /� �� ZY; �C��

�L� o�NJ �Y2 .�� �$

( -��; 8�2/ :( /��5 �6��I��� 6�( #��.2 8�?2 �( �YC 8�I&5��I��� :( �� &5�� 8$ 6�

8$ ���(�� A2`� :( :@8$ �' ( xYcj �� �� -P4>9 h�� �&� :4902$ -.'� �*�4� :

7� / .&5/���( �=5 \MG �:4� I �'r�� )1389( -2 R�>3� :4�� � :( 8�I&5��I��� :&50�

8�I&5��I��� -K5�?� 8�I&5��I���B2`� 8�2/ :( 6��I��� 6�( -K5�?� 8�I&5��I��� :; .-

8�I&5��I��� �2 &5�&5 /��5 6���/B2`� �� �� &5�� 6���/ 8�2/ :( /��5 �09 6��I��� �2 6�( -

V0)02 #Bc2A2`� �/02$ ��345 :; ��� :F0� &��( .&.���5 :q� [0F ���; :B�F /

Page 14: فصلنامه آموزش و توسعه منابع انسانیistd.saminatech.ir/WebUsers/istd/UploadFiles/OK/... · 1-24 1393 2 Quarterly Journal of Training & Development of Human

-5�>5 h(�.2 :N�0� �/02$ :2�.BS� ����� �� ��� �2 ���� �1393 14

' [0Bc2 �0G :( �&5��I��� �� ��P5 �� b��E2 #Bc2 �� :; �� 6�02 ���P5 [ F RX

���I &'0L5 b�0j 7� :;&.��� 8�2/ :( /��5 �09 :(05 :( �5A2`� .���

- ,�F J���� ���� ,��� G&�N4 S�N

»:M*�S2��� -5�2/ �/�( :�&..; -2 ���C� �' z�0�

GT4L5 +43�3* : n�C ...���J -'�I oYu2 ��� �0X* :(-2 �' &.�0I &��( Z�� 8Y� :;

30 7�) ��� �C�� 7� &��( :4�� �2&930 hJ �� +4C�� �' Z�� �C��60 :3�J�

� -e �� �.45 -2 ��P5 :; ��9$ �� :3�J� -2 -.; �C�� 7��' -.�( 6�'45 :3�J�oYu2

�&�35 ���E5 �� .:3�J�30 �C��oYu2 R� :(30 hJ �� -e �&� D��� �C��20 �C��

&.4��5 ZY; �4K�( 8��?�'.«

GT8-�5 ���C� -5�2/ �/�( : �� ��� �0( ��J �I...&�30 6�( ��4� �0� ��� �C��20

��&5 #Bc2 �4K�( �C��10 C��-�5 A�?K� ZY; Y�C �� �P�� � A�?K� R' �I �� &�

-2 �J &�5� I.�0( -

-2 7��N� -5�2/ �/�( -�/02$ ��� �' 6�( 8�I&5��I��� :BmK2 :( :F0� �( :; �0�

:.� ' 8$ 6�'���&W2 -9�( 8�2/�� 6�( ��� �� �� R; hJ02 �u; �� b�U42 �/�( 7� �'

AJ&* �e�*�/�( 7� �I ��* .�� � AJ&* �� R;-2 :50P@ &(�� +'�; ���P5 ���C 80� /

2 �� z��� -NJ ��NJ02 :( � 8$ ��345 6��I��� ��=45 8�I&5��I��� �)�* +',� O�W

�;�� b��Es �5 ��0( 6��I��� 8�2/ +'�; :]�45 �� �/�( 7� ���C� D&C / -;�* 8�I&..;

.��

- �'�c� � EdF �� EI���

BT1-2 D��� : &�$ -2 Z�� -'�PK5� +�� #9 8�2/ 8$ D��7� 6�Es / &N( :� &���

-2 A�cN� � R4>� ZY; �0( ZY; D��; -2 ��� / � �]5$ 6�� 2 :4��� ZY; -e D��

-2 A�cN� � R4>� �2&9 7�) ZY; D�( :; D��;176 .R.; A2�; � R4C��

THT3 -'�PEI :ZY; R' ZY; �( 8�K��' �'-2 ��09�( �2 6 -2�0M]2 �2 &.; -?� R�0�

Y; /Z 5 � �'ZY; ��� 2 �G�L( �u; :; R�� 7�) 6�' -2 T�F�� � �2&9 .R�'�

��� 7� -*�G 6�( 8�2/�� -Bj :<&<� 8�.;��; :U�s Am� %&' -�/02$ 6�'

� 7� �� �;�� 6�( 8�.;��; -Bj�� ��� 7� �I ��* .�� ��0( �' :U�s Am� �( �'

&��( :4�� A9&� 8�.;��;�4� ��* 2 /�� :.�2/ � ��/�( +'�; ���E5 �� -Bm� Z8$ �'

G :; ����4UI \M �;�� 8�I&..; �/02$ 7� :4�� A9&� �'8$ �' ��NJ02 �� �

R��S� +��I 6��I- / Am� :( +��I %�G i� / .�� :4� I +��I +��I �P�� %�G

Page 15: فصلنامه آموزش و توسعه منابع انسانیistd.saminatech.ir/WebUsers/istd/UploadFiles/OK/... · 1-24 1393 2 Quarterly Journal of Training & Development of Human

15 #��$ �� �/02$ ��345 �&�&� -��.�&*02 -��Uj &�N� �8��; 8�F�2 �6��]� -3�&�� /...

:.�2/ :; -�/02$ ��� �� �0X* :( Z�4� /��8$ �' �C�( A9&� 7� :4� I 7� / .�� ��0(

��@�5 ��� ��NJ02 7� �� ��/ �� Am� �� �/02$ O�W2 �� 8�2/�� -e�2 h(�.2 74�� �&' :(

.�� [�L45 :(

(e �4�I��� � ����F�4� T�K

- f��� ,�&�D ��#� � 5�]� <4�g� ��@�

TT1-(���/� �j0SL2 : ��F RBN2 i� �� r�N) -B�9 8-2 [0 ( ��� 7� &'� :

-2 ��� -2 [0F 8$ / :�' &9�@ -2 -MB3� &.'� ...�� ��� � ~� -���MC :( �0�

GT4 ��� �� :; ��� �0X* :( n�C :9 :; -M4; � F [�4; 8��?�' ok0�N2 #

-2 ��(�2 :>BF �� &5�$ R')9 / (Z�&2-�5 :F0� R' -B�9 �� 8��?�' �0 8��?�' &.;

R'�4; �( �YC-2 R' :>BF A�?K� R' �( � F [ � �' &.'5-4 R' R' �( 6�U5 6�?�

-2 -2 b�0K2 &..; -2 � bk0� [0F &..; R' 6/�]2 \��G / &.'� i� A?� 8��' :(

-2 &�� 6��9 �U5 ( �0� 6�F :( ��9k�5 -4 -2 8�W42 �U5 -2 &'� .8����; ��M5� &5�

�� :?.� :( :F0��( 8�I&5��I�-( :��� A?K2 ��@� �)�* +',� O�W2 ���J &.4>' -I �P5

-(���/� :(:(05 :( 7� ��0M5 b��=5 8&( :.�2/ �09 #B3� �&�&� /�( /�� d� ��

��� �/02$ 7� 8��;�&5 -2 �' D�]5 ��e�N� � &.50�� �( � � �P5 A?K2 �� &.'�� ��; 6�'

.&.���5 -(���/� 6��I��� O�W2 �� � b��=5 �� &..; A* -5����

- �4�I��� ��"� S�N

:3B* 7��9$ -(���/� :.�2/ �� �_a2 A20C / ��09/�(&.��� �I��� 7� ��/ �� 6�

&.��� :(05 :( b��MC .�� 8$ T�WS� 6��I��� -C05 ��09» :2�5�( &5���J �&2$��; 8��(�2

$ &..; -(��/� �/02$ -G D&2 �0G :( � -�/02Yj&.���5 ���C � /��5 ��02 b�*« �( �

�� �&�&� 7� ���'&.��� 6��I��� -(���/�&�;`� .���

-(���/� :; 7� :( :F0� �( -�5 D�]5 -4��� :( �' ��' �� �&� T�Wj ��09/�( :50I

/ -B2�;8$ �' :( 8�I&5��I��� :]�45 �� �� �&K5 ��L4� �)�* +',� O�W2 �� b0J |�35

�&���P5 ��I$ �09 rN) .&5 �;�� / i� ��' ��4UI -G 7�.��' �( �� -�Y�F 8�I&..;

.�>�5 ��09/�( �0F

- E��N 5��� S�N#hi��� j 6��A�� G�-F ��

-.�>* -5�;�02 �=.2 / )1392 ( A20C ���_a2 \3W� 6��I��� &(��5 \3W� 6��I���

02$ ��345 &(��5 \3W� 6��I��� �I 8$ hM4e�( ���� &'0L5 d� .&���I &'0L5 \3W2 �5 �/

Page 16: فصلنامه آموزش و توسعه منابع انسانیistd.saminatech.ir/WebUsers/istd/UploadFiles/OK/... · 1-24 1393 2 Quarterly Journal of Training & Development of Human

-5�>5 h(�.2 :N�0� �/02$ :2�.BS� ����� �� ��� �2 ���� �1393 16

-2 A20C :( R�34>2��< b�0j :( �/02$ ��345 :; ��; ��4.4� � :4��� 7� 80��_a2

6��I��� / �� :4>(8$ �' -2 ��_`� �� � 7� A*�2 R�'0L( �I .�&.��� :( R�.; �0S2 �

:�0( &'09 ��/ A?�

�;�� ��4UI A20C \3W� D&C �( �� -��'�U2 6�* �)�* +',� 8�I&..;�_a2

:; �0( 6��I���8�K5 �09 V05 �� :4��� 7� -?� 8�0( �03U2 �&.'�:3B* / 7� RE2 6�'&.���

��I��� -.N�-2 :; �� 6 D&C /�� :.�2/ &� �; 42 80� O�W2 7� �� �/02$ ��345

��� -2 �' -2 d� �0� 7� 80�&.��� ��� �� �� 7� ���� �/02$ O�W2 -20�C 6�'

:�0�5 �0S2 7�.@

:B0�CD S� B #D ,4�� 4� �#�>��& 6��A�� G�-F ��0���D J�K ��0 G�I

QG��.

(TL� ���� ��#� ���D

- ' �&�J�K #&� �� G@�� �>U�?�� �� � � G�I�0

TT1ZY; 6�( -4* : SL� 6�'-( -S ZY; 8$ / 80@ D&� � �P5 i� -20�C 6�'

...�&2$ +�� 72 6�( 6&( ��.'�

#hi E��N

�#�>��& #�

�#�>��& 6��A��

����

5��� S�N

#hi E��N

�#�>��& #�

5��� S�N

�#�>��&

5��� S�N

6��A��

����

Page 17: فصلنامه آموزش و توسعه منابع انسانیistd.saminatech.ir/WebUsers/istd/UploadFiles/OK/... · 1-24 1393 2 Quarterly Journal of Training & Development of Human

17 #��$ �� �/02$ ��345 �&�&� -��.�&*02 -��Uj &�N� �8��; 8�F�2 �6��]� -3�&�� /...

BT2��� -4J : -2 �;�� 6 ��9k�( 6�� ��� 8$ / 6&( b�G�9 �� \�02�5 -.;

�M<�:2� 6�( � �P5 ��� �� �;�� 6 -2 ��� / � �' ...-'�

i� :( �M>5 �&5��I��� �� ��� :; -2�P.':Uea2 -U.2 &�� �� Z�>* �/02$ O�W2 ��

��( :4��-2 �� ~�W2 i� A?� :( :Uea2 8$ & � :.�2/ b&2&.B( �� :; &�$ -U.2 &�� ��]� /�

:Uea2 ���� �� E5 �� �'O�W2 :( �M>5 ��� -2 �/02$ .�0� :Uea2 �5 �)�* +',� O�W2 ��

��� O��� -20�C 6�'8$ �' �:.�2/ ��� :( �M>5 -U.2 &�� /�� ��� -j�S49 6�' 6�'

I�( -20�C .�� �&K5 �

-G]� _:��

TT1: -2 8$ 6�'&2��� �0P( R50�-2 i� 8k :; -.; rB� �J O3� R R4�� 72 R.;24

...D��; rB� � R4J O3� �C��

»&2��� :�&..; :M*�S2 ��� 7� 6�' z��0( :@ ��� 6�( �'

GT4; rB� �&2��� : 8��30-20 ��E( -.N� ��C / �C�� {�We / R�4�&5 6 -�BC

��E(.�&K5 �2 #�S5 6

:Uea2 A20C / 8�2/ :�' :F0� ��02 RE2 6�'8�2/�� �' =.2 i� / �� / %&' �

��� � I�( �� -�/02$ 6�'8�2/�� �'�; O�W2 �� �J %Y� / 6��I0BF � ��* .�� :U�s �

��� 7� �I P@ &��( �J %Y� -C05 �09 �'-2 :50 / -���; ��=45 80�8$ �' .��� �

-2 5 �� �J %Y� :; �0�5 8�K5 �G�9 80�-( -C05 ��]� /�� :.�2/ ��09 V0 -I �P5

.�� �&5��I��� �� �e�>;

- X&4�� G�'�! � kM B0�!

GT8&2��� : ��� 7� 6�' �-20�C 6�' :( 8��(� 8&� b�U� -(&.��� �0( �/02$

/ 6��I0Pe 7�&.��� ZY; �� -XN( �0( Z�� 6�'-2 ��; :( � �' 8$ -4* 8��BN2 / .&.4��I

THT2� AMJ �( :>��32 �� 72 d��&� :-�5 -4��K� �� R4�� :; 6&�2�5 �(�( -4* ��;

.�� :4�� R'

-2 ��� -MBc2 �/02$ O�W2 �� ��� :; -2�P.' :; �9��� V0)02 7� :( :50I 7� 80�

�� ���P5 ; �E.� :5 �� �&� rB� �J &.; Z�>*-2 /�( �� -I �P5 -( �e�> &.;

:]�45 �� :?B(� �-I �P5 -( �e�>; 7�-2 +'�; �5 6 d��&� ��U�; Tc .&(��

Page 18: فصلنامه آموزش و توسعه منابع انسانیistd.saminatech.ir/WebUsers/istd/UploadFiles/OK/... · 1-24 1393 2 Quarterly Journal of Training & Development of Human

-5�>5 h(�.2 :N�0� �/02$ :2�.BS� ����� �� ��� �2 ���� �1393 18

���� B��� ��#� ���D(V

- W:! 4� �Y��F � ��g� ��

GT9+5� :Bj0* :�� /02$ K�2 ZY; �� -<0B� �C�( ���2...:.?�2 ��]� -�=5 -( :

THT2?�( ZY; �� -4J /02$ +5� :-2 �0B� �0K5 ZY; [ F &��( �� 7� �0�

&N( � �e�*ZY; / -2 R�Y; �� -20�C 6�' .D&��

+5�&F #Bc2 -��� �WM2 ZY; �� &..; Z�>* :; -2�P.' 8/02$ �� &�

�&.5 �P5�( -�5 :q� 6 -( :( ��� ��0� -�=5 -2 Z�� ZY; �� -<0B� -4* :; .&.5/

-2 C� 80�:M.F �( �YC -<0B� 7� �0�5 � 9�( �� 8$ -�� / :4��9�( �8/02$ +5� / -

-( .�� Z�&2 �� RBN2 -I �P5

- ,#H���4 �� ���8��! ��0�4�#-� � ��

THT27�) ZY; �� 72 -4J : 5� D��P5 ��� 6&�&F �� �2&9+ 8/02$ R'

�� 8��' / &5�0M]2 ��E( �90.?� -��&J 6�'.&50� &.2

THT3ZY; 7� �� -4J 72 : -2 �' � i� �( O3� R.�K5-2 ��09�( d��&� � 8$ R.;

Y; �� hM4( d� -5�.L� R'-2 ���U4� 8��' / O3� R���� Z .R.;

-2�P.'� �P5 RBN2 d��&� �� Tc� :; 2 �&(�� +'�; 6�� 8�? -C05 :( 6 �

:K�B; d��&� 6oYu2 -5�.L�- :4�09�5 A?� :(- +5� b&2 /�� �� :; .��$ 6� � 8/02$

-C05 ��@� :4>9 6�?� A?�� -2 �&..; .&.;

- ,#H� S�N ��4 �� fL�M �� ��

BT6�( :; -5/02$ +5� : ��� �� :; &.4>' �(� -5��BN2 -�5 �;�� �' ��� �� &..; �' �

-2 \�02�5 -�5 &.5� I .&..; &�� 6/�( b�CYG &.50�

THT4 6��I��� �W� :; -��CYG :8$ �' ZY; 7� �� R' �2 d� �>�5 /�( R�4>' �'

�CYG+5� :( -��&J b-2 A34.2 8/02$ .R�.;

2 �( RBN2 :; -2�P.':( ��< �� -��&J #e�c �� �� /� :K�B; d��&� 6�' 6 -( �� � �P5

-2 �C�( �0� ZY; +5� :; �0� /� :( #e�c2 / �5 8/02$ hM.2 -C05 &50K5 &.2�E(

���9� .&5��I &2$��;�5 �� 6��?� b�CYG

Page 19: فصلنامه آموزش و توسعه منابع انسانیistd.saminatech.ir/WebUsers/istd/UploadFiles/OK/... · 1-24 1393 2 Quarterly Journal of Training & Development of Human

19 #��$ �� �/02$ ��345 �&�&� -��.�&*02 -��Uj &�N� �8��; 8�F�2 �6��]� -3�&�� /...

- ��4 � �>�# 6� �>#

BT6 �*� -B�9 e... :8$ �' �� ��(��; �_ �� -��&J 6�' ��@� �8��BN2 -I�2/�

-2 -I�2/� &50�-2 ZY; :( O3� -2 &.�$ y�U� 8�K�.'� ��49�� �� 6���m� &5�

-�5 .&4�

THT2ZY; 7� / &N( : +5� �'�-P4>9 �0F i�...&5�0( 6�P�� �0F i� 8/02$ ��e�>;

z��0( �2 ��09�( +B�e� &��� .-I��2 ��

��/� -I��2 7� &2��� 7��9$ -I�2&.��� V05 �� :; �� �)�* +',� O�W2 ��

( �09-( / :4��9 � �� �RBN2 -I �P5 :K�B; d��&� 6�' 6 :q� D&C � :( #e�c2 ���< /�

�� &2 /�� �� :;+5� b :B�� -C05 :( � 8/02$ %�j -?�5�?2 -2 A�&M� b�(� �� :; &.;

%&'8$ �' .�� r�B?� h�� -C05 ZY; �� �0X* /

�� ���:B*�2 7� 8� - :� ]� :M*�S2 A�BW� R�'�U2 ��L4� �' - :4��� +',� 6�'

2�=5 :I�( A?� :( 8$ / :Bj�* R�'�U ���49 �� 6��09/�( -].��;�� ���I ��J 8�I&..;

:�' 8$ �' :4��� :; &.4�� �=5 y�U� �' &��3C ��4UI �P5��( R�'�U28$ �' i� ��' ��

J�.�.&.4�&5 ��Es � -X

4 - � m�����A� �#�>

+',� ��2 �/02$ �/02$ ��345 :c�* �� �&� D�]5 6�' 7�) 6�' �� 8�K5 �2&9

:; -U]5 )1391�( 8��?�' �k1 )200774� �(2 )2000(� � �P5 :c�* :( �09 ��; ��

:49��� -5�� :c�* �� :; &5 .�� ��0( rN) ��@� �)�* +',�-<�� 6��5 �6�(

R�'�( �0�)1387( �k � ) 8��?�'2007 �(&e�5� i23 )2000(� -�W� �0I4 )2002 �(

72�Me5 )1999( :e032 :( �09 +',� �� b�0j :( d��&� �� R�34>2��< R�34>2

:49��� � :; &5:K�B; b�0j :( �)�* +',� O�W2 � .�� �&� :q� ��N���< 6

-U]5)1391( -<�� R�'�( 6��5 �6�( �0�)1387( � d;�� b�0?B(6 )2006 -�W� (

) �0I2002 (+',� �� :4�� &�;`� -].�/��5 :c�* ���' �( �09 �)�* +',� �� :; &5

.�� :4���5 \3W� -U]5)1391) b�0?B( d;�� (2007 :c�* ���' �( �09 +',� �� �(

1-Velada et al 2-Aytin 3-McDonald 4-Yagya& Goh 5-Leberman 6-Saks & Belcourt

Page 20: فصلنامه آموزش و توسعه منابع انسانیistd.saminatech.ir/WebUsers/istd/UploadFiles/OK/... · 1-24 1393 2 Quarterly Journal of Training & Development of Human

-5�>5 h(�.2 :N�0� �/02$ :2�.BS� ����� �� ��� �2 ���� �1393 20

%&' :4�� &�;`� 6� I j �)�* +',� O�W2 �� :; &5 .�� :4��� �5 b�0 b�0?B( d;��

)2006�( ,� �� ���' �( �09 +' :Uea2W2 8&� :�F0� b�0j :( ��&5��I��� 6�( 04

��<34>2:49��� R� �* +',� O�W2 �� :; &5-<�� .�� �&K5 R'�� 8�I&5��I��� 6�( �)

�0� R�'�( 6��5 �6�( )1387( ���; &�;`� 8$ ���' b��=5 :c�* �( �09 +',� �� &5

:.�2/ 8$ 8&3� �)�* +',� �� :; �( /��-(���/� -���; D&C #B3� /.�� �&� �'

-U]5 )1391( -I,� +L( ���09 +',� -�/02$ 6�' �� ��09/�( :Uea2 �(

-(���/� ���� ��4>2 -5���� 6�'$ 8�2/�� #5�F / �)�* +',� �� :; �� ���; �/02

�/02$ ���� 8�I&.'�8$ �' �02 .�� �&� hJ �BU< �8��?�' ����0(1 )2008 ( ��

:4��� �&.�$ b�3�3W� �� 6��I��� �&�&� :( :F0� �( �09 +',� 6�'&�;`� ���; +',� &5

��� ��J ��?.; ��02 � 8$ A�k� ���( -� +',� O�W2 �� �&�&� 7� 8&3� :( �5 �)�*

.��

h�F+',� 6&.( :; �� 8�K5 �&� D�]5 6�':Uea2�� �-5�� � �P5 74�&5 :6�'6�'

:K�B; d��&�04W2 �-].�/��5 D&C ���N���< 6 \�J� b��=5 8�0M5 �%&' 8&( /�(

�< R�34>2 b�0j :( 6��I��� �&�&� ��09/�( �0F D&C �#B3� �&�&�� :Ne�c2 ��02 R�34>2

:4��I ��J ���' �( &58$ �' :Uea2 �2 �� �&� &�;`� -��&J R; b�20BN2 :6�'

�/02$ 2 8�0M5 }LK2 �7���� }SL� ~�&2 ��&.'���� h(�. �ZY; b�5�?2 8�0( R; ��'

[0Bc2 SL� �ZY; 8��( -'��� b�5�?2 8�0M5 R'�� �ZY; b�5�?2 8�0M5 6�X� }�

��� -5�2/ -I��K� �i@0; �:U�s Am� �( A9&� ��&� 7��N� -5�2/ �/�( ���C� D&C ��'

6��I��� ��345 D&C ( -U.2 &�� �6��I��� \3W� D&C / -��5 (�/02$)- :( �M>5 -I �P5

7�) ���� �2&9Y� ��'d��&� ��U�; Tc� +'�; ��J %-( � �ZY; �� -<0B� -�=5

��E( �� / 6&.2:K�B; 6�'��E( D&C �6��?� 6 6&.2�� /� :( #e�c2 / -I��2

/� c2 -���( ��02 -I�2:4��P5 ��J :Ne� :4��� / &5.�� �)�* +',� �/�� 05 6�'

:4��� / �P�� -?� +',� 6�':��� +35 ��)�* 7� �� � �P5 6&.��� �' &.���

:.�2/ 8$ 8&3� :; �� -�/02$ ���4>I bY?K2 /�( /�� �/02$ ��345 6��I��� �� 6

-2 A20C 7�( R�34>2 |�M�� :( +',� 7� :; �0�5 8�K5 �G�9 &��( 7�.��' .���I�_a2

�� %�G / �� ���( -� �'&2��� 6��I���5 �P&2��� 7�( -5�� |�M�� &��M �02�� �5 � �'

;��< A?� :( �'&2��� -2��� 80@ ���( -'�PEI &.4>' |�M�� �� R' �( R�34>2 &2��� i� /

:.�2/&2��� /�( /�� d��&� ��U�; Tc� +'�; &2��� /�( ��u2 80.C :( �� �P�� 6�'

1-Bossard et al

Page 21: فصلنامه آموزش و توسعه منابع انسانیistd.saminatech.ir/WebUsers/istd/UploadFiles/OK/... · 1-24 1393 2 Quarterly Journal of Training & Development of Human

21 #��$ �� �/02$ ��345 �&�&� -��.�&*02 -��Uj &�N� �8��; 8�F�2 �6��]� -3�&�� /...

�E( #F02� +5� 6&.2�� / 8/02$ d��&� 6�':K�B;+5� �� -I�2/� -I��2 �� 6

-2 ���< 8/02$ :�' :; �0�8$ �' ( �09 V05 ��.�� :4>( -5�� � �P5 :Uea2 :

( �0�5 -N� �)�* +',� ��4UI 6�=5 -5�M2 -���( ��;��8�I&..; 6�'��?'� :q� :(

-���; �'��?'� 7� :; �� &�2 �/���( :c�* 7� �� 6��(��; hU��2 � bY?K2 :4��

.&5/��

�&5��I��� rN) 6�( 6��(��; 6�'��E.K�� �'��?'� (re :(RBN2)

- �&5��I��� :�F0�

- [ F��� 8��; ���'

- ���� 8��:��� �( �'�e&C D�=5 i� 6 �0W2

- &�� A�&N�RBC RBC :( �M>5 �&5��I��� ��I 6/02$

�� �'��?'� ([ 6�'��E.K�/02$ rN) 6�( 6��(��;�&.'� :(Z�&2)

- �� / ���U4� V0.42 d��&� 6�'�/02$ #5�F / V0)02 �( #��.42 .8�I&.'�

- �/02$ :F0� �/02$ 6��I��� 8���F �� 8�I&5��I��� ��N� +35 :( 8�I&.'�

- �/02$ / ���U4�.[�]2 }SL42 8�I&.'�

- �/02$ / ���U4�( 8�I&.'� : :.�2/ �� /�.-�� -K5�

:04W2 rN) 6�( 6��(��; 6�'��E.K�� �'��?'� (�

- 8�2/�� #5�F / R=.2 -N(�.2 8042 :q�

- /��58�I&5��I��� / -].�

- �04W2 :( �M>5 8�I&5��I��� :�F0 �' 6&4( �� �&� :q� .���

- ��� 6� I�(�/02$ / -].��=5 6�' :( 8�I&.'���� 74��� �0=.2 D/k 6�'

.6��(��;

- %&' I��� 6&4( �� %&' 8��( 6�.�'

��?'� (b :-�/02$ b �E]� b�5�?2 rN) 6�( 6��(��; 6�'��E.K�� �'

- ���< -e&.j � �2 ��04;l�� 0�&� �:5��� A2�� ZY; -�/02$ b�5�?2 ���; +� �

- � -.�(/�( b�5�?2 ��U�; +� 8$ �' �/�( �� ��32 -5�2/ 6�'

- 4��E� ���9 6�( -'��� b�5�?2 8��; R'���8 �' .��P(09 :� m� &.5�2

:�/02$ 8�2/ 8�?2 rN) 6�( 6��(��; 6�'��E.K�� �'��?'� (�

Page 22: فصلنامه آموزش و توسعه منابع انسانیistd.saminatech.ir/WebUsers/istd/UploadFiles/OK/... · 1-24 1393 2 Quarterly Journal of Training & Development of Human

-5�>5 h(�.2 :N�0� �/02$ :2�.BS� ����� �� ��� �2 ���� �1393 22

- ��� 6� I�(?2 �� �'�8 �'o�W�F�� �4I� ( 6 Z�&2 / ���9

- ��� 6� I�(#cJ A?� :( �'�E� �� �'

- ��� 6� I�(4>(�� �,�0( A�cN� D�� �� �'8Ĥ �'

- �/�( �� 7�N2 ��� i� 6� I�(5 8 �2 +� � �0=.2 :( b�U42 -5�2/ 6�'[�L4 6�'

.8�I&5��I���

- .-��� -5�2/ �/�( ���C� �0=.2 :( -���=5 ��(&� -*�G

'��E.K�� �'��?'� (�:��09/�( -(���/� rN) 6�( 6��(��; 6�

- -(���/� �� bk0� V05 / ���U4��'

- -(���/� �� b��=5 :c�* ��03��� / �':��/ 6�'

• +5� / ���U4�7��s�5 80.C :( 8/02$

• ��< ��� / ���U4�-(���/� �� -20(�'

• /� �� �&5��I��� :( �0MC 2� :��.� :q���9 ;�2 �� 8$ 6� I�( -(���/�

- �G���5 D�=5 �� :5k��C ��(&� -*-'�

- -(���/� �;�* -���E2 -B�C ��� :( %�j 6�=5 �e�* / �'

- -(���/� / ���U4� -5���� -(���/� % *ZY; �� ��4>2 6�'

- ��� 6� I�(:N�0� 6�( -�/02$ -E�F0� 6�' 6/�]2 �.'�� �/02$ �� 6/��

-(���/�

5- ���

���&9 �-B�(. )1389 .(-5�>5 h(�.2 ����&2 �()&�;`� (7�015 6�1' ��1?�� �( :8�1E� . b��1K45 ����&12 8�2/�1�

.-4N.j

�-Wc( &�� 7�>*. )1383 .(�/02$ 6/�>E( :��2�� 6�' -5�>5 .8�E�: b��1K45 8�2/�1� ��41>I 6/�1�05

h��.j 8��.

!7�>* �6���&.U� �.�2 ���/ �)�. )1390 .(��?'� 6�'�_a2 #��$ +���' 7�4>L5 .-5�2/�� �/02$ �� -��.�

-5�2/�� �/02$ �8�E� �7- 6 .��2 &.U�

d�0F !Z�( �A�����2 �! 80Ee�;-B�2 � )1390.( d��&� 6�'0Pe2004� b��1K45 �-1P5�E( �1)� &�W2 :RF�42

.��E(

:.2�_ �-B;0�. )1388 .(��� -(���/� b��) 7�1) -1�/02$ 6�1' :15�L(�4; �� �2&19 �� +L(�1_ 6��1?�� :�1'

-5�>5 h(�.2 ����&24?e :��K5 .:5�L(�4; 8�2/�� -?�5��/02 .�' �60)� Z&J 8�4�$ ��.� ;�2 �'1)4.(

Page 23: فصلنامه آموزش و توسعه منابع انسانیistd.saminatech.ir/WebUsers/istd/UploadFiles/OK/... · 1-24 1393 2 Quarterly Journal of Training & Development of Human

23 #��$ �� �/02$ ��345 �&�&� -��.�&*02 -��Uj &�N� �8��; 8�F�2 �6��]� -3�&�� /...

7�>* ��0� Y�E�. )1382 .(-���( b�=5 8��BN2 ��� :c�042 ���(�� #��.� 604W2 -1�/02$ ��� 6�1' 7�1)

�2&9 ���0; b&2 �( 6�'/��5 -�/02$ 8�5$� 8����:2�5 -��.���; &�� �-2/�09 ��PK5� 8�E�.

�M; -BC �r��. )1389 .(�/02$ 6��I��� -��.K5� :7�05 -���� -��.K5� :8�E� . b��K45.8��

7>* �-5�MN�. )1392 .(b��E2-���� -�/02$ 6�' ��) (d��&� 80.� �':8�E� . b��K45 .���

!�)�2Y< �-5�;�02 d�� ���5 �-.�>*. )1392.( ��; O�W2 :( ��345 �-5�2/�� �/02$:8�E� . b��K45 .�e&C ��(

� 8�2 �60Uj) .1389�� �(0Pe 80.� ��'.d��&� 6�' :8�E� b��K45.���

!Z�MC ��0� Z�MC �8��&�*/�5�E2. )1390 .(��� -KL(�_ -(���/� b�3�3W� :>�02 �� �&� � I�( -�/02$ 6�'

8�E� �E� ��5 b�/ :( :4>( ����&2 �/02$ #��$ +���' 7�4>L5 . �8�1E� �-5�2/�� �/02$ -��.�7-

6 .��2 &.U�

-W4� ���I��F ��0;. )1390 .(:2�5�( 6 �� �/02$ 7�) �2&9 8�.;��; .8�E� : b��K45���.

iB2 �-*04�. )1388 .(��� -KL(�_ h502 -���(8�EUj �U5 ��PK�k�� -�/02$ 6�'8���� . :2�5 �&1�� -��.���;

.8�E� ��PK5�

-<�� �6�( &�* !-BC�6��5 &�W2 -BC! R�'�( ��0� �)��BC. )1387 .( A120C �_a12 �1( 6�13�� �1�U�; �/012$

7�) �2&9 8�.;��; ��PK5� �/$ -2Y1� &1* 8�P1��09 ) 8�EU1j( . +15� +',1� �� D01BC -14�(��-

:2�5�( 6 �� �-��� ����� 19� � 78-61.

�-U]5 -BC !�-Me�G �]* :e. )1391.( -*�G 60Pe +].1� -1KL(�_ ��� 6�1' -1�/02$ �1( &1�;`� �1( ��1345

6��I��� )��4��(. :��K5 ���(&� ����� 239.

Aguinis, H. & Kraiger, K. (2009). Benefits of training and development for individuals and teams, organizations and society. Review Psychology, 60, 451-474.

Broad, M. L. and Newstrom, J. W. (1992). Transfer of Training: Action-packed Strategies to Ensure High Payoff from Training Investments. Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA.

Bossard,C., Kermarrec,G., Buche,C. and Tisseau,J.(2008). Transfer of learning in Virtual Environments: a new challenge? Journal 0f Virtual Reality, 12, 151-161.

Ford, J.K. & Weissbein, D.A. (1997). Transfer of training: An updated review and analysis. Performance Improvement Quarterly, 10(2), 22-41.

Fogarty, R., Perkins, D. and Barrell, J. (1992). The Mindful School: How to Teach for Transfer. Highett, Australia:Hawker Brownlow Education.

Gagne, E. D., Yekovich, C. W. and Yekovich, F. R. (1993). The Cognitive Psychology of School Learning. (2ndedn.) New York, HarperCollins College.

leberman,S., Mcdonald, L. and Doyle, S. (2006). The transfer of learning: participants’ perspectives of adult education and training. Gower Publishing Company.

McDonald, B. L. (2002). Transfer of Training in a Cultural Context. A Cook Islands Study. Unpublished, Victoria University of Wellington, Wellington, New Zealand.

Noe, R.A. (2010). Employee training and development. New York: McGraw-Hill. Perez, A.G. (2006). Measuring the perceived transfer of learning and training for a

customer service training program delivered by line managers to call center

Page 24: فصلنامه آموزش و توسعه منابع انسانیistd.saminatech.ir/WebUsers/istd/UploadFiles/OK/... · 1-24 1393 2 Quarterly Journal of Training & Development of Human

-5�>5 h(�.2 :N�0� �/02$ :2�.BS� ����� �� ��� �2 ���� �1393 24

employees in a fortune 200 financial services company. Ph.D. Thesis, University of North Texas.

Ripple R.E. and Drinkwater, D.J. (1982). In Encyclopedia of Educational Research. Free Press, New York.

Subedi, S. (2004). Emerging trends of research on transfer of learning. International Journal of Education, 5(4).

Schmitz, M. & Maag, C. (2009). Report on transfer-of-training effects. D5. 4. 1. Saks, A.M. & Belcourt, M. (2006). An Investigation of training activities and transfer

of training in organizations. Human Resource Management, 45(4), 629–648. Velada, R. & Caetano, A. (2007). Training transfer: the mediating role of perception

of learning. Journal of European Industrial Training, 31, 96-283. Velada, R., Caetano, A., Michel, J.W., Lyons, B.D. & Kavanagh, M.J. (2007). The

effects of training design, individual characteristics and work environment on transfer of training.

Yahya,S. & Goh,W. (2002). Managing human resources toward axhiviny knowledge management. Journal of knowledge management, 6(5), 457-468.