¨¶§³°¬´¹¯ gf ]o &9 pppppp ppppppppppppp · [ v ] w r k m lÐ x¹ nk 6 Ë û Æ ò ç...
TRANSCRIPT
���¦*��£¼�
������
¨¶§³°¬´¹¯�GF�]o���&9��pppppp����
ppppppppppppp���ppppppppppB2#$3/����W>�
資料3
Śŗ ƢǂƛƿƴĿ�ƲƵƌĪƛƱ³ƿƤƴsäƲJƠƮƌƧƴY\U¶ƴÑ<Dž�ĆìƲĔƘƢưƜÌƺƿǂƸƥœŜŖŝŋŔƍ�
śŗ ƧƴƩƺƴƩƱqËŤƴĎƙ®ƜƌNjǻdžDzǧǘǵȀǣƯƥƍY\-ƴÅƎƱT�ƌ�Âƌ!�DžƬƱƗƯƗƸƥœŞŖŚšŋŔƍ�
Ŝŗ ƤƛƤƌäXƴqËŤƲƵĤŌƜƖǀƸƥœŚŢŖśŜŋŔƍ�ŝŗ ĦcVƴNjǻdžDzǧǘǵȀǣƵƌťũŧŘŦũŧ4�ƜǮȂǙƍƢǂƵƌĒÏƲ]ƭƞY\ĄSĂĊƯƥœśŝŖśŠŋŔƍ�
Şŗ Y\Dž¥ƙǁƐxƣƱ+,ƑưƤƮƌAĩDžĵƸƙƩ��Îrư�ĆìƲÂĻSƥǁƢưƴƯƝǁĂĊȁīÖDžñûƥǁ4�Ɯ�ėƯƵƱƗƯƤƽƘƛœśšŋŔƍ�
� 2
¨¶§³°¬´¹¯�GF�]o���&9��½ ��D¤¾�
ŚŖŚŗŒƢǂƛƿƴĿ�ƴü9ưƵ�
– Zı>ƤƩĿ�ƴő9ƴƱƣ�– Y\Þ�DžƗƛƤƩƸƪƭƞǀƶƴǦȂǚ�
�
�
�
ŚŖśŗŒƤƗY\ĤŌƲu�ƥǁ���
– ƬƞƫƩ�ƴƐĐƮǁƑÊŊƲƵŤƜłėƍ�– 4�Ƽ5�ƴaDžijƙƮƌƤƗCǀĂƹDžiƺǁǾȂǎǼƱ�Ăƹƍ�
Ŀ�ƴÙL�ÛƱƇúņţŒůſųŵŷƈDžƌƧƴY\ƲưƫƮ�LƖǁƇ_ţŒŭŻųŵŷƈƲbƙƮƗƞƢưƜÌƺƿǂǁ²�ƍĒÚƌ�ą¬>ýƴłĚƍ�
Ƈ_ţŒŭŻųŵŷƈƯÑ<ƴÄ�ƤƌƧǂDž|Ņƥǁ�Džë Ƥƌ�ėƱīÖDžĥļƯƝǁDzǧǘǵȀǣƴ�ĂƹƜÌƺƿǂǁ²�ƍ�
tr �¤�¡�g'���`��7¡��%G����������8�C�¦-UL�[����@�¡¤����
3
tqvrpg'�k�£^X�¡ �#g'���Nj�@�¡¤£c�,K�!������£��¥�¢����
ŚŢŢŚ Œ�ƇǒǾȂǨǼȁǗǡLJƈ�� � �ȃǕǙǐdžȁǕǠǛȀȄ�
�
�
�
śřřś ƇǑǻNjLjǡLJǬȁǑǺǙƈ�� � �ȃǻǟǶȂǤȁǫǾǻǞȄ�
śřŚŞƋƈůƂƀŷŷƂŒŨźŸŹƂƈ�� � �ȃǘǶǧǠǣȁǕǢLJǑȍǎȂȀȄ�
śřřřƋƇŭƀźƄųƂŷŻƆŒŬƅŽŷŶŒŭƃŴŻźŵŒůſųŵŷƁƈ�� �Ƌ � � �ȃǘNJǾǼǤȁȑȐȒȔȓȄ�
śřŚş ƋƇŰųŵƂźŵųŻŒűƀŴųŽźƁżƈ��ȃDzLjǑȁǺLjǤȀƌdžȀǜǦȂȁǏǼǗdžȄ�
Ő�ƯdVāƱÂ=Èđƴģ�DžƺƟǁü��Ŀ�«#ƴƐ�_>Ƒ�ȃËņƲƾǁ«#ȁÿåȄ�
èÂDžIJƤƌß�ƥǁ�ºñ DžƺƟǁ,8��Ŀ�«#ȁĻSƴó�>ȃ�Ɨ�ƯƖǁ�ËƜĒƿƌg'¦�����Nj�!����%d¦f�£6�ƶƍȄ�
4
ƌƒY\ƴ�"Džć�ȁJ�ƣƦƌƸƩƩƱY\�"Dž8ĸƥǁƩƺƴƌ�ËȁÂďȁYÆďýƲƾǁƐăƑDžƻưƲĔƘ��ìƱCĂưƧƴĂĊƌqËŤƴ�ĂƹƭƞǀƓ�
śŖŚŗŒNjǻdžDzǧǘǵȀǣưƵ�
ƐăƑƉó�Ň�į·ƴÄĀ�� �ƋȃȃǩǠǣǥǴƐOnƥǁË��čȃŚŢŢŜȄƑȄƌƐmáƱǰljǻȀǒȃśřřřȄƑȄ�! �ËÑ<ƴ°®¯¸»©ƌ�ËƴĒëìƱA9Dž�ƥnº�h+ƴ\QƜƌó�ĻSƴ;ã�Dž¦Rƥǁ�
! ó�Ň�į·DžĪƛƲƥǁ�ƎƴAĥĔ<DžÑëƲƥǁƢưƲƾƫƮƌó�ƴ;ã�Dž¦RƯƝǁư��ƍŒ�
ur�����4���?e1�X�5��¨¶§³°¬´¹¯���Y\-ƴÅƎƱT�ƌ�Âƌ!�DžƬƱƗƯƗƸƥƍ�
x¾ł©'çƴrčDžƻưƲëĖď¦b�
5
¨¶§³°¬´¹¯0fRV��
Y\ƴv¼&ȁǭǺȀƴ,¶Ɖ ÂsĔ�
�(�.ZR���
�Ȏĭ�ƌLjǮȀǣƌp)ȁp��
�
�Âý��
�ȎęÂƌŦůŮƌY\Ĭâ�
�
J ��YA��³¹«µ¹PHR�O�
�
�Ȏõòƌ�Òƌ�ķp)�
|~}B��'?ª·»±O�
�Ȏæ`ƌ¨ĐýƴǡȂDzÑ<�
�
ƧǂƨǂƴNjǻdžƴƐxƣƱ+,ȃƊ,íȄƑDž��ƥǁƩƺƲĽƤƩĂĊDžƬƞǀƌ-ëìƛƬł}ìƲÑ<Dž|ŅƤƮƗƞƍ�
Ĕ§�
¥£ȁA%�
�7/��
¨¶§³°¬´¹¯��S���������:<¦�¢i�4��M�k�b;�
6
NjǻdžDzǧǘǵȀǣƴCǀĂƹƵƌ�Y\ƴv¼ƴƩƺƲĒƿÎƺƌ<ƞƢư�
Njǻdž)�ƴæ`ƲŇƥǁÑ<�
Y\ƴv¼&ȁǭǺȀƴþrȁ,¶>�
ĕ�ƹƴę4ȁģw�
+Ýȁ,¶ÝýƴÿåƲŇƥǁÑ<�
+Ýȃ+WýȄƴć�ÿå�
,¶Ýýƴć�ÿåȃTY-,¶¯ĞýȄ�
z�æ`ƼY\ƴÑ�>ƲŇƥǁÑ<�
Y\ƴʼnà�ƴć�J��
Y\ƴ�Ľ�ƴć�J��
Y\ƴŭŮȁ�^�
Y\ĄÕƴÑ�>�
útȁúYýƴÑé�ĺ�
Y\æ`QŌƶƴŀ��
ǕȂǪǙ¡�ƌǔdzǷǦǡLJ��ýƴǜǫǣƴŅë�
çÑƴǼȂǼƭƞǀ�
Y\ƴ3��ƴć�J�ƌ¥£ǕȂǪǙýƴ¡��
ǔdzǷǦǡLJƴ��� 7
!
!
!SNS
!MYROOM)
!
!
8
ĂĊÞ�ȋ
Y\�ƋƋƋƋ�ƱÂ�!
!!
!!!ĂĊÞ�
!
Y\�ƋƋƋƋƋƋƋƋ�ƱÂ�!!
!!!!
!ĂĊÞ�ȋ
PÂÂ=Y�
ŅëĹ<�°��ĕY�
!!
!!
!
!!
!!
!!!
!!
Y\�ƋƋƋƋƋƋƋƋ�ƱÂ�!!
!!
!!ĂĊÞ�ȋ
!!
!!
!!
uqurp=��¨¶§³°¬´¹¯�
�oY� 9
śŖŜŗŒ¸�Ŏ5ķƸƪƭƞǀÀ��ó�
!
NjǻdžDzǧǘǵȀǣƴ��ȃPÂÂ=YȁŅëĹ<Ȅ�
! 17!
3!
2010 990!
!(2016.7.11)
10
śřŚşŒdžȂǣDzǧǘǵȀǣǙ
ǑȂǼŅħ�
+,úņ«#ưĹ<ƤƩNjǻdžDzǧǘǵȀǣƴw(�
2001! 200
Ņë�
���
Ȃ
�
���
���
śřřśŒĿ�ƸƪƭƞǀĜê�
śřŚřŗŢ�Ƹƪƭƞǀ�ó�Ğû�
���
���
śřŚŞŗŚřȕ�NjǻdžǪǘǹȀþrÁĝ�
śřŚŞŗś�ƣƫƷǃǸǐǡǺǙśřŚŞ�
śřŚŝŗş�ǕǠDZǾǫǺǿȂǎȂǯǠǣ�
śřŚŞŗš�ƣƫƷǃ*µõ�
śřŚŜŗŠŖŚś�ij~Ĝê�
śřŚŜ�ŭŤŮŦȃdžȂǣȄȆǑǺǗNJȃDzǼǗNJȄǙǝȂǣ�
śřŚśŗŢ�?Ŝ»�_F÷sğsŏȃǎǫNJƌljLJȀǝȂǙǑNjdžȄ�
Ĕ§�wƴ�Y\Ņë�
2011 201520132003 20092005
Ëņ�wȁqËŤ[NjǻdžDzǧǘǵȀǣ�
Ƨƴ'ƶ�
11
ĂĊưŤƴÃėư�¿ȁĤŌ�
"
K�E��/?;G<R05
•
UjvcN_cr
cqU
hN%:�!
•
Y
ivZgV<�)w1
7+A!
•
I�2�C�wu\vC�!
•
�.ito
]pv
"
��;GR05!
•
�x,&�<ORUjvcR
#+!
•
Y
ivZgV<�)w17
+A!!
"
WrSke^nvc&�!
"
Ujvc[
bTe
cM!"
�.w !QPR8BN(�!
"
�E"�F�NH30�!
"
LD$=N��R4�>�0�M
<!"
`ld
wgX
qmR�6wF�!
"
9R#+M
<!"
K�E��RJI'- !
"
@�fvgsacR*N���R@
�- M
<
!10
4
�Q#+.�
!!
!! !!
!
!!
!
!!
!!
!!
!
12
śŖŝŗŒ���ƋūŭŬÐ�x¹ŎKĶNjǻdžDzǧǘǵȀǣ�NjǻdžDzǧǘǵȀǣƴ��ȃ�oYȁŅëĹ<Ȅ�
! NPO
007 NPO !! 300 ×12
!! NPO 12 10 30
!! ! 13
NPO
Ťƴ�ĂƹưĂĊƴÃėƌ�¿ȁĤŌ�
NPO !!
NPO
! !!
!!
!!
!
NPO !!
!!
!
!
5000 15,000
14
NjǻdžDzǧǘǵȀǣƴ��ȃPÂÂ=Yȁ°l�ĕYȄ�śŖŞŗŒŲŷŒŪžƄŷŒfôAĩ�ȃö���g@Ȅ�
!
20042005 We!
Love! !
! 10
!
!
BID
!!
WL !
15
!
We!Love
We!Love!
!
!
!
!
!
!
! !
!
Ñ<ƴ�¿�•
!��ƴĤŌ�•
!•
! ĂĊƴÞ��ĂĊƴÃėư�¿ȁ
ĤŌ�
36, 79,!8!!
123( 28.2
16
śŖşȅńÍY@ŒưŒūŭŬÐ�ǫǷȂǘǹȀńÍ�śŗŒNjǻdžDzǧǘǵȀǣƴ��ȃ�oYȁ°l�ĕYȄ�
! !
!
17 NPO HP !
18
NPO
$
$
$
NPO
NPO !!
!
!!
!!
!
!!
!
18
12 15
# !
!!# !
!!qËŤƶƴ�Ĩ�$ !
!!$ !
!!$ !
!
!
ŜŗŒƤƛƤƌäXƴqËŤƲƵĤŌƜƖǀƸƥƍ�
NjǻdžDzǧǘǵȀǣƯî�ƤƩƗqËŤƴ�ưƵȏ� 19
ŜŖŚŒqËŤƴĚØƛƿƹƩNjǻdžDzǧǘǵȀǣ�
PFI,!
! !×
!!
!
!
!
① !
!!
PPP
20
(2014.2.26)
! ︎!
! ︎!
! ︎BID!
!
!
!
224 !
.2.
4.$
5.$
$
ŜŖśŒqËŤDž�ĺƥǁĦ4��
6.$
3.$
➡ ︎#l'��¢R�¦m���aE������£��Nj�CI�[��f����£GF�� 21
3.3 $$
!
!
QOL
!!
︎ !!
︎
22
!
②!
!
23
BID $
!
BID 700I1000 NY 70 (2014) LA 40 (2014)!!!!BID 130 2013) 37
!
!
!
!
BID! BID !
wrp_"��¨¶§³°¬´¹¯��x{zsy{z�)�²»��¤��YA������T�RV����
baseline!service!level) !
BID
24
DMA$(District$Management$Associa?on)$BID
$$$$$
$BID $
$
Board$ $BID $
District$Manager $$
4(2.$BID Y
!
!BID !
!
DMA !!
!!
25
4(3.$BID $
4(3(1$$ BID *!①
!!
BID(Joint!Service!Agreement) !
!
② $!
Area
26
@DUMBO!
@Bryant!Park
(3(2.$ !
Sole$Source$License$Agreement
!
NYPlaza!Program !
Sole!Source!License!Agreement NY 12 ( SecYon!1I16:Commi\ee!Approval!of!Different!Procedures
BID
Times!Square BID!
!!1991I2!740 2010I11! !1,250 !
!!1996!200 2011 2,000 !
!!1993!3,924 2011!786 ! 27 imes!Square!Alliance
$α !
!
$!
!%
!%
!% !!
!!
!
!!
!
!
ŞŗŒY\Dž¥ƙǁƐxƣƱ+,ƑưƤƮƌAĩDžĵƸƙƩ��Îrư�ĆìƲÂĻSƥǁƢưƴƯƝǁĂĊȁīÖDžñûƥǁ4�Ɯ�ėƯƵƱƗƯƤƽƘƛȏ�
QOL
28
śřŚŚ��ƋƐæ`ƸƪƭƞǀǕǾȀƑëĴ�
śřŚś��ƋƐæ`ƸƪƭƞǀǫnjȂǺǴȉȇȈȉƑƴĹĆŅ$�
ƋȌNjǻdžDzǧǘǵȀǣDžĺƺǁƩƺƴ¡ěȎëĖ�
�ȁƾǀ+,�ƴŐƗÑ<ƶƴu�ƴ�ė��
Ƌ �ȁNjǻdžDzǧǘǵȀǣĂĊưīÖƲŇDŽǁ4�ƴ�ė��
�ȁ+Ë�ơƮÁĝDžĺƺǁƢưƴ¡ěƍ�
śřŚŝ���ƋȁŒƒ´NjǻdžDzǧǘǵȀǣƓȃnē.ÜóȄë0�
ƋƋƋƋƋƋ �ȁŒeň�ƲƮƌ±·1ƴťũŧ»��ûƍ�
śřŚŞ��Ƌ)VNjǻdžDzǧǘǵȀǣǧǠǣǿȂǑĞû×#jN��
ƋƋƋƋƋƋƋȃ �ČÇjNń�MȄŒ�
�ȁ¸�ƌ�EƲƮ)VǻǽȂǗȀDZǘljǴƴŅ$ȃ ĿenưƴŤȄ�
�ȁ��ƌNjǻdžDzǧǘǵȀǣhk�ýƌÅƎƱ_Ư�^�¢Ƽ�Ę�ƴ,¶Džĺƺǁƍ�
śřŚş��Ƌ)VNjǻdžDzǧǘǵȀǣǧǠǣǿȂǑĞûȃĄTĹ�ōƯƴĞûĈ�Ȅ�
�ȁID{ƌ½ ƌö�ƌeňƲƮǻǽȂǗȀDZǘljǴŅ$ƍ�
�ȁeĿ�ƲƚƠǁNjǻdžDzǧǘǵȀǣÁĝľ�ëĴƍ�
�ȁ�NdžȀǓȂǣs¯ƍ�
�
�
�
�
BĎȋśřŚş�Ȋµ)VNjǻdžDzǧǘǵȀǣǧǠǣǿȂǑĞû�
29
ĄĉȋènqƴǍȂǭȀƱðù�ƴøƹłƳƛƿçƸǂƸƤƩƍ�
�NªƋÉ�NŠśŕŒİ:�NŚŜŕŒ�Ĕ§ȃǍǬǖȂǨȂȄśŚŒ�GĜŒŚřşŒœśřŚŠŗŚäXȄŒƋ�
�Nª�
ƏƋƔ�DŽǁƕƋNjǻdžDzǧǘǵȀǣĂĊƴǧǠǣǿȂǑȁǔdzǷǦǡLJƴŁ��ƏƋƔÔƺǁƕŒĔ§ưƴuġȁŤƴ_ƴÄĀ�ƏƋƔ�ƺǁƕƋNjǻdžDzǧǘǵȀǣƴ
ó�ìƱĢïJ��
Ñ<®Ń�
��ȋNjǻdžDzǧǘǵȀǣƴĠ�ǗǙǡǴƴñûƌÓcĂĊưƴ�^�¢ƌ�ºĐ�ǭǾǒǺǴƴÁĝƌ!2ƴûƪ�ơ¥£ýDžĺƺƮƗƝƸƥƍ�
�ńţŒx¾ł©ƌ6�ńţŒ �ČÇDž(ǂŚřI�-Ư��DžĞċƍ=yƵe�¶NjǻdžDzǧǘǵȀǣA�Dž��ưƤƩŜT�Ư,HĞċƍŒīÖƵ�Įƍ�
�Nȁ=yȁīÖ�
$
30
BIDNY CA !
●1981 General!Municipal!Act/ArYcle!19IA)!●1984 NY Local!Law 1
●1965!Parking!&!Business!Improvement!Area!Law
PBIA 79,!89!
●1994 Property!&!Business!Improvement!District!Law
PBID !
●2001! Strong!Local!Leadership BID
2003! Local!Government!Act)
BID!
●2004!BID 2005!
2007!2013! !
● BID 2005
●
2004
BID !●2012
BID
●2014
!●2014 4
1
BIDDMA
PBIA !PBID !
!2013
BID NY 70 2015)!NY 115 2011
LA 39 2015)!CA 232 (2011)
179 (2014)!41 2015) (2010)
1 2015
501 3
(Exempted) !NPO
District!Manager
1 31
①! Trafalgar!Square,!Highbury!Field,!Brixton!Central!Square!
②! More!London,!Regent’s!Place,!Old!Spitalfields!Market,!Central!St!Giles,!!Stranord!City!(Wesnield).
!
!!
③! Po\ers!Field!Park,!Westway!Development!Trust,!Bankside!Open!Spaces!Trust,!‘Friends!of!parks’!
④! Heart!of!London!BIDI!Westminster
London!Bridge!BID,!Wimbledon!Town!Centre!Partnership!&!Management!Board
!BID
!
”Public!life!in!private!hands”!May,!2011 32